collapse all
Text -- 1 Kings 2:8 (NET)

Parallel
Cross Reference (TSK)
ITL
Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley -> 1Ki 2:8
Wesley: 1Ki 2:8 - -- _The words are, The king said unto Shimei, thou shalt not die: and the king sware unto him, 2Sa 19:23. The oath, we see, was absolute. It was not, I w...
_The words are, The king said unto Shimei, thou shalt not die: and the king sware unto him, 2Sa 19:23. The oath, we see, was absolute. It was not, I will not put thee to death now. or, I will not put thee to death with the sword. But who can reconcile his charge to Solomon with this oath? Surely, considering the time of that charge, this next to the matter of Uriah, is the greatest blemish in all David's life.
JFB -> 1Ki 2:8
JFB: 1Ki 2:8 - -- Though David promised him a pardon, which being enforced by the presence of a thousand followers, could not have been well refused, he warned his son ...
Though David promised him a pardon, which being enforced by the presence of a thousand followers, could not have been well refused, he warned his son against Shimei as a turbulent and dangerous character. It must not be supposed that in these dying instructions David was evincing a fierce, vindictive spirit. He is rather to be considered as acting in the character of a king and magistrate, in noticing crimes which he had not been in a condition to punish, and pointing out persons of whom Solomon would be under a necessity to rid himself as dangerous to the state. The grateful mention of Barzillai's kindness [1Ki 2:7] was, however, a personal feeling that does honor to the warmth of his heart; and his silence as to Mephibosheth, the son of his beloved Jonathan, would imply the previous death of that prince.
Clarke -> 1Ki 2:8
Clarke: 1Ki 2:8 - -- Thou hast with thee Shimei - See on 2Sa 16:5 (note), etc., and the notes on 2Sa 19:18-23 (note).
Thou hast with thee Shimei - See on 2Sa 16:5 (note), etc., and the notes on 2Sa 19:18-23 (note).
TSK -> 1Ki 2:8
TSK: 1Ki 2:8 - -- Shimei : 1Ki 2:36-46; 2Sa 16:5-8
grievous : Heb. strong
he came : 2Sa 19:16-23; Jer 4:2

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Poole -> 1Ki 2:8
Poole: 1Ki 2:8 - -- With thee i.e. in thy power, as that phrase is oft used.
Cursed me with a grievous curse or, reproached me with bitter reproaches , 2Sa 16:7,8 ; w...
With thee i.e. in thy power, as that phrase is oft used.
Cursed me with a grievous curse or, reproached me with bitter reproaches , 2Sa 16:7,8 ; which David could not but deeply resent from him, though, as it was an affliction sent from God, he patiently submitted to it.
I will not put thee to death with the sword
Quest. How then could David lawfully engage Solomon to punish him for it? And did David upon his death-bed bear malice against Shimei?
Answ First, David was not a private person, which might remit such offences without any inconvenience; but a public magistrate, who for the honour and maintenance of government was obliged to punish such insolent and opprobrious speeches, if the necessity of his affairs had not then engaged him to pass it by. Otherwise it appears from divers passages of the Psalms, and of this history, how free David was from a rancorous and revengeful spirit, even towards his enemies.
Secondly, The following advice is not contrary to David’ s oath, both because that was only personal, that David would not kill him either at that time, as Abishai desired him, or whilst he lived, and did not oblige his successors; and especially, because it was not David’ s mind that Shimei should be put to death for that fault, (as is evident; for then there was no need of Solomon’ s wisdom to find out an occasion, but only of his justice to punish him for the old crime,) but for some other competent crime, which Solomon’ s wisdom, narrowly prying into all his actions, would easily find out. And if the condition which Solomon imposed upon Shimei, 1Ki 2:36,37 , seem hard, it must be remembered that David only swore that he would pardon him as to life, but not that he would exempt him from all punishment or confinement.
Haydock -> 1Ki 2:8
Haydock: 1Ki 2:8 - -- Curse. Saying, Go out, &c., 2 Kings xvi. 5. ---
Camp. Hebrew Machanayim. (Haydock) ---
Sword. He would revenge his private wrongs, but re...
Curse. Saying, Go out, &c., 2 Kings xvi. 5. ---
Camp. Hebrew Machanayim. (Haydock) ---
Sword. He would revenge his private wrongs, but reserved the punishment of a notorious offender, till a time when passion would have no influence. Solomon was not bound by the personal oath of his father.
Gill -> 1Ki 2:8
Gill: 1Ki 2:8 - -- And behold thou hast with thee Shimei the son of Gera, a Benjamite of Bahurim,.... Of whom, and of his native place; see Gill on 2Sa 16:5; he was now...
And behold thou hast with thee Shimei the son of Gera, a Benjamite of Bahurim,.... Of whom, and of his native place; see Gill on 2Sa 16:5; he was now at Jerusalem, and so with Solomon, or near at hand; and was on his side, and of his party; see 1Ki 1:8; but not to be trusted, or looked upon as a real friend:
which cursed me with a grievous curse, when I went to Mahanaim; a place on the other side Jordan, of which place, and the curses this man cursed David, with, see 2Sa 16:7;
but he came down to me at Jordan; after the defeat of Absalom, and when David was returning, and humbled himself to him, and begged his pardon:
and I sware unto him by the Lord, saying, I will not put thee to death with the sword; but this oath was not binding upon his successor, and especially should he commit a new crime.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> 1Ki 2:1-46
TSK Synopsis: 1Ki 2:1-46 - --1 David, having given a charge to Solomon,3 of religiousness;5 of Joab;7 of Barzillai;8 of Shimei;10 dies.12 Solomon succeeds.13 Adonijah, moving Bath...
MHCC -> 1Ki 2:5-11
MHCC: 1Ki 2:5-11 - --These dying counsels concerning Joab and Shimei, did not come from personal anger, but for the security of Solomon's throne, which was the murders he ...
Matthew Henry -> 1Ki 2:1-11
Matthew Henry: 1Ki 2:1-11 - -- David, that great and good man, is here a dying man (1Ki 2:1), and a dead man, 1Ki 2:10. It is well there is another life after this, for death stai...
Keil-Delitzsch -> 1Ki 2:1-11
Keil-Delitzsch: 1Ki 2:1-11 - --
The anointing of Solomon as king, which was effected by David'scommand (1 Kings 1), is only briefly mentioned in 1Ch 23:1 in the words,"When David w...
Constable: 1Ki 1:1--11:43 - --I. THE REIGN OF SOLOMON chs. 1--11
The Holy Spirit led the writer of Kings to give an interpretation of history,...

Constable: 1Ki 1:1--2:13 - --A. Solomon's Succession to David's Throne 1:1-2:12
The first segment of the writer's story (1:1-2:12) co...





