
Text -- Isaiah 5:4 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
JFB -> Isa 5:4
JFB: Isa 5:4 - -- God has done all that could be done for the salvation of sinners, consistently with His justice and goodness. The God of nature is, as it were, amazed...
God has done all that could be done for the salvation of sinners, consistently with His justice and goodness. The God of nature is, as it were, amazed at the unnatural fruit of so well-cared a vineyard.
Calvin -> Isa 5:4
Calvin: Isa 5:4 - -- 4.What more ought to have been done to my vineyard? He first inquires what could have been expected from the best husbandman or householder, which h...
4.What more ought to have been done to my vineyard? He first inquires what could have been expected from the best husbandman or householder, which he has not done to his vineyard ? Hence he concludes that they had no excuse for having basely withheld from him the fruit of his toil.
How did I expect that it would yield grapes? In this clause he appears to expostulate with himself for having expected any good or pleasant fruit from so wicked a people; just as, when the result does not answer to our expectation, we complain of ourselves, and are angry at having ill-bestowed our labor on ungrateful persons whose wickedness ought to have restrained us from doing what we did, and acknowledge that we are justly deceived, because we were too simple and easily imposed on. But a more natural interpretation will be this: “Since I discharged every part of my duty, and did more than any one could have expected in dressing my vineyard, how comes it that it yields me so poor a return, and that, instead of the fruit which was expected, it yields what is absolutely bitter?”
If it be objected that God had the remedy in his hands, if he had turned the hearts of the people, this is an idle evasion as applied to those men; for their conscience holds them fast, so that they cannot escape by laying the blame on another. Though God do not pierce the hearts of men by the power of his Spirit, so as to render them obedient to him, yet they will have no right to complain that this was wanting; for every pretense of ignorance is fully and abundantly taken away by the outward call. Besides, God does not speak here of his power, but declares that he was not under any obligation to do more than he did.
TSK -> Isa 5:4
TSK: Isa 5:4 - -- Isa 1:5; 2Ch 36:14-16; Jer 2:30,Jer 2:31, Jer 6:29, Jer 6:30; Eze 24:13; Mat 23:37; Act 7:51-60

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Isa 5:4
Barnes: Isa 5:4 - -- What could I... - As a man who had done what is described in Isa 5:2, would have done all that "could"be done for a vineyard, so God says that ...
What could I... - As a man who had done what is described in Isa 5:2, would have done all that "could"be done for a vineyard, so God says that he has done all that he could, in the circumstances of the Jews, to make them holy and happy. He had chosen them; had given them his law; had sent them prophets and teachers; had defended them; had come forth in judgment and mercy, and he now appeals "to them"to say what "could"have been done more. This important verse implies that God had done all that he could have done; that is, all that he could consistently do, or all that justice and goodness required him to do, to secure the welfare of his people. It cannot, of course, be meant that he had no physical ability to do anything else, but the expression must be interpreted by a reference to the point in hand; and that is, an appeal to others to determine that he had done all that could be done in the circumstances of the case. In this respect, we may, without impropriety, say, that there is a limit to the power of God. It is impossible to conceive that he "could"have given a law more holy; or that he could append to it more solemn sanctions than the threatening of eternal death; or that he could have offered higher hopes than the prospect of eternal life; or that he could have given a more exalted Redeemer. It has been maintained (see the "Princeton Bib. Repert.,"April 1841) that the reference here is to the future, and that the question means, ‘ what remains now to be done to my vineyard as an expression of displeasure?’ or that it is asked with a view to introduce the expression of his purpose to punish his people, stated in Isa 5:5. But that the above is the meaning or the passage, or that it refers to what God had actually done, is evident from the following considerations:
(1) He had specified at length Isa 5:2 what he had done. He had performed "all"that was usually done to a vineyard; in fencing it, and clearing it of stones, and planting in it the choicest vines, and building a wine-press in it. Without impropriety, it might be said of a man that, whatever wealth he had, or whatever power he had to do "other"things, he "could do nothing more to perfect a vineyard."
(2) It is the meaning which is most naturally suggested by the original. Literally, the Hebrew is, ‘ What to do more?’
(3) That this is the fair interpretation is apparent further, because, when, in Isa 5:5, he says what he "would do,"it is entirely different from what he said he "had done."He "had"done all that could be done to make it proper to expect fruit; he now "would"do what would be a proper expression of his displeasure that no fruit had been produced. He would take away its hedge; break down its walls, and lay it waste. But in the interpretation of the passage proposed by the "Princeton Repert.,"there is an entire omission of this part of the verse - ‘ that I have not done in it.’ It is not improper, therefore, to use this passage to show that God had done all that could be consistently done for the salvation of man, and the same appeal may now be made to sinners everywhere; and it may be asked, what God "could"have done for their salvation more than has been done? "Could"he have given them a purer law? "Could"he present higher considerations than have been drawn from the hope of an "eternal"heaven, and the fear of an "eternal"hell? Could he have furnished a more full atonement than has been made by the blood of his own Son? The conclusion to which we should come would be in accordance with what is said in the prophet, that God has done "all"for the salvation of sinners that in the circumstances of the case could be done, and that if they are lost, they only will bear the blame.
Poole -> Isa 5:4
Poole: Isa 5:4 - -- What work is there belonging to the office of a master or keeper of the vineyard which I have neglected? How unworthy and inexcusable a crime is it,...
What work is there belonging to the office of a master or keeper of the vineyard which I have neglected? How unworthy and inexcusable a crime is it, that you have not only been unfruitful in good works, but also filled with all the fruits of wickedness!
Haydock -> Isa 5:4
Was it. "Why has it produced wild grapes, while I looked?" &c.
Gill -> Isa 5:4
Gill: Isa 5:4 - -- What could have been done more to my vineyard, that I have not done in it?.... Or "ought", as the Vulgate Latin: this is generally understood of good ...
What could have been done more to my vineyard, that I have not done in it?.... Or "ought", as the Vulgate Latin: this is generally understood of good things done to it in time past; as what better culture could it have had? what greater privileges, blessings, and advantages, natural, civil, and religious, could have been bestowed on this people? what greater favour could have been shown them, or honour done them? or what of this kind remains to be done for them? they have had everything that could be desired, expected, or enjoyed: though it may be rendered, "what is further or hereafter to be done to my vineyard" u, and "I have not done in it?" that is, by way of punishment; I have reproved and chastised them, but all in vain; what remains further for me, and which I will do, because of their ingratitude and unfruitfulness? I will utterly destroy them as a nation and church; I will cause their civil and ecclesiastical state to cease. The sense may be gathered from the answer to the question in the following verse Isa 5:5,
wherefore, when I looked that it should bring forth grapes, brought it forth wild grapes? that is, why have these people acted so ill a part, when such and so many good things have been bestowed upon them; on account of which it might have been reasonably expected they would have behaved in another manner? or rather the words may be rendered, "why have I looked or expected w that it should bring forth grapes, seeing it brought forth wild grapes?" why have I been looking for good fruit, when nothing but bad fruit for so long a time has been produced? why have I endured with so much patience and longsuffering? I will bear with them no longer, as follows. The Targum is for the former sense,
"what good have I said to do more to my people, which I have not done to them? and what is this I have said, that they should do good works, and they have done evil works?''

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Isa 5:1-30
TSK Synopsis: Isa 5:1-30 - --1 Under the parable of a vineyard, God excuses his severe judgment.8 His judgments upon covetousness;11 upon lasciviousness;13 upon impiety;20 and upo...
MHCC -> Isa 5:1-7
MHCC: Isa 5:1-7 - --Christ is God's beloved Son, and our beloved Saviour. The care of the Lord over the church of Israel, is described by the management of a vineyard. Th...
Matthew Henry -> Isa 5:1-7
Matthew Henry: Isa 5:1-7 - -- See what variety of methods the great God takes to awaken sinners to repentance by convincing them of sin, and showing them their misery and danger ...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Isa 5:3-4
Keil-Delitzsch: Isa 5:3-4 - --
The song of the beloved who was so sorely deceived terminates here. The prophet recited it, not his beloved himself; but as they were both of one he...
Constable: Isa 1:1--5:30 - --I. introduction chs. 1--5
The relationship of chapters 1-5 to Isaiah's call in chapter 6 is problematic. Do the ...

Constable: Isa 5:1-30 - --C. The analogy of wild grapes ch. 5
This is the third and last of Isaiah's introductory oracles. The fir...
