data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/674fe/674fe95c55835d4b12bd7659619a70745375f8e8" alt=""
Text -- Isaiah 8:20 (NET)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/53bcc/53bcc09312609f7dc35434b05e6325fb4f307489" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/af4c0/af4c08bb75e113d55de738af2fccbbe4c5a2ea12" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/af4c0/af4c08bb75e113d55de738af2fccbbe4c5a2ea12" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/af4c0/af4c08bb75e113d55de738af2fccbbe4c5a2ea12" alt=""
Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/53bcc/53bcc09312609f7dc35434b05e6325fb4f307489" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/75ece/75ece45dbe9362d6fddeec6b919b612852027d80" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9a206/9a20678833a2d5f914528c6918ee079b308382c5" alt=""
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: Isa 8:20 - -- Let this dispute between you and them be determined by God's word, which is here and in many other places called the law, to signify their obligation ...
Let this dispute between you and them be determined by God's word, which is here and in many other places called the law, to signify their obligation to believe and obey it; and the testimony, because it is a witness between God and man, of God's will, and of man's duty.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Wesley: Isa 8:20 - -- This proceeds from the darkness of their minds, they are blind, and cannot see.
This proceeds from the darkness of their minds, they are blind, and cannot see.
JFB: Isa 8:20 - -- The revelation of God by His prophet (Isa 8:16), to which he directs them to refer those who would advise necromancy.
The revelation of God by His prophet (Isa 8:16), to which he directs them to refer those who would advise necromancy.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
JFB: Isa 8:20 - -- English Version understands "they" as the necromancers. But the Hebrew rendered "because" is not this but "who"; and "if not," ought rather to be "sha...
English Version understands "they" as the necromancers. But the Hebrew rendered "because" is not this but "who"; and "if not," ought rather to be "shall they not"; or, truly they shall speak according to this word, who have no morning light (so the Hebrew, that is, prosperity after the night of sorrows) dawning on them [MAURER and G. V. SMITH]. They who are in the dark night of trial, without a dawn of hope, shall surely say so, Do not seek, as we did, to necromancy, but to the law," &c. The law perhaps includes here the law of Moses, which was the "Magna Charta" on which prophetism commented [KITTO].
Clarke -> Isa 8:20
Clarke: Isa 8:20 - -- To the law and to the testimony "Unto the command, and unto the testimony"- "Is not תעודה teudah here the attested prophecy, Isa 8:1-4? and ...
To the law and to the testimony "Unto the command, and unto the testimony"- "Is not
Because there is no light in them "In which there is no obscurity"-
"A day of darkness and obscurity
Of cloud, and of thick vapor
As the gloom spread upon the mountains
A people mighty and numerous.
Where the gloom,
Calvin -> Isa 8:20
Calvin: Isa 8:20 - -- 20.To the law and testimony There are indeed various ways of explaining this passage. Some think that it is the form of an oath, as if the Prophet we...
20.To the law and testimony There are indeed various ways of explaining this passage. Some think that it is the form of an oath, as if the Prophet were swearing by the law that they were apostates, and would entice others to a similar apostasy. But I take a different view of it, which is, that he directs our attention to the law and the testimony; for the preposition
It is therefore a very high commendation of the law that it contains the doctrine of salvation, and the rule of a good and happy life. For this reason also he justly forbids us to turn aside from it in the smallest degree; as if he should say, “Forsake all the superstitions on which they are so madly bent; for they are not satisfied with having God alone, and call to their aid innumerable inventions.” In this manner also Christ speaks,
They have Moses and the prophets, let them hear them, (Luk 16:29;)
for though Abraham is there brought forward as the speaker, still it is a permanent oracle which is uttered by the mouth of God. We are therefore enjoined to hear the law and the prophets, that we may not be under the influence of eager curiosity, or seek to learn anything from the dead. If the law and the prophets had not been sufficient, the Lord would not have refused to allow us other assistance.
Hence we learn that everything which is added to the word must be condemned and rejected. It is the will of the Lord that we shall depend wholly on his word, and that our knowledge shall be confined within its limits; and therefore, if we lend our ears to others, we take a liberty which he has forbidden, and offer to him a gross insult. Everything that is introduced by men on their own authority will be nothing else than a corruption of the word; and consequently, if we wish to obey God, we must reject all other instructors. He likewise warns us that, if we abide by the law of the Lord, we shall be protected against superstitions and wicked modes of worship; for, as Paul calls
the word of God is the sword of the Spirit,
(Eph 6:17,)
so by the word, Satan and all his contrivances are put to flight. We ought therefore to flee to him whenever we shall be attacked by enemies, that, being armed with it, we may contend valiantly, and at length put them to flight.
If they shall not speak I do not relate all the expositions of this passage, for that would be too tedious; and I consider the true exposition to be so well supported that it will easily refute all others. It is usually explained to mean that wicked men trifle with their inventions, and expose their impostures to sale, because there is no light in them; that is, because they have not ordinary understanding. For my own part, I consider this to be a reason for encouraging believers to perseverance; that if wicked men depart from the true doctrine, they will evince nothing else than their own blindness and darkness. We ought to despise their folly, that it may not be an obstruction to us; as Christ also teaches us that we should boldly set aside such persons, so as not to be in any degree affected by their blindness or obstinacy. “ They are blind, ” says he, “ and leaders of the blind. Do you wish of your own accord to perish with them?” (Mat 15:14.)
The Prophet therefore enjoins us to ascribe to the word such high authority, that we shall venture boldly to despise the whole world, if the word be opposed by them; for if even angels should do this, we might condemn them also by the authority of the word.
If an angel from heaven, says Paul, preach anything else, let him be accursed. (Gal 1:8.)
How much more boldly, therefore, shall we condemn men who set themselves in opposition to God? The mode of expression is emphatic, If they shall not speak according to this word. He brings an accusation of blindness against every man who does not instantly and without dispute adopt this sentiment, that we ought not to be wise beyond the law of God.
Defender -> Isa 8:20
Defender: Isa 8:20 - -- The "law and testimony" - that is, the written Word of God - provide all the counsel and guidance we need. The Holy Scriptures are given "that the man...
The "law and testimony" - that is, the written Word of God - provide all the counsel and guidance we need. The Holy Scriptures are given "that the man of God may be perfect" (2Ti 3:17)."
TSK -> Isa 8:20
TSK: Isa 8:20 - -- the law : Isa 8:16; Luk 10:26, Luk 16:29-31; Joh 5:39, Joh 5:46, Joh 5:47; Act 17:11; Gal. 3:8-29; Gal 4:21, Gal 4:22; 2Ti 3:15-17; 2Pe 1:19
it is : I...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9a206/9a20678833a2d5f914528c6918ee079b308382c5" alt=""
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Isa 8:20
Barnes: Isa 8:20 - -- To the law ... - To the revelation which God has given. This is a solemn call of the prophet to try everything by the revealed will of God; see...
To the law ... - To the revelation which God has given. This is a solemn call of the prophet to try everything by the revealed will of God; see Isa 8:16.
If they speak not - If the necromancers - those that pretended to have contact with the dead.
According to this word - According to what God has revealed. By this standard all their pretended revelations were to be tried. By this standard all doctrines are still to be tried.
It is because - There has been a great variety of criticism upon this verse, but our translation expresses, probably, the true idea. The word rendered here ‘ because,’
No light - Margin, ‘ Morning.’ Hebrew
‘ If they speak not according to this word,
In which there is no obscurity.’
But there is no evidence that the word is ever used in this sense. Others suppose that the Arabic sense of the word is to be retained here, deception, or magic. ‘ If they speak not according to this oracle, in which there is no deception.’ But the word is not used in this sense in the Hebrew. The meaning is, probably, this: ‘ The law of God is the standard by which all professed communications from the invisible world are to be tested. If the necromancers deliver a doctrine which is not sustained by that, and not in accordance with the prophetic communications, it shows that they are in utter ignorance. There is not even the glimmering of the morning twilight; all is total night, and error, and obscurity with them, and they are not to be followed.’
Poole -> Isa 8:20
Poole: Isa 8:20 - -- To the law and to the testimony let this dispute between you and them be determined by God’ s word, which is here and in many other places calle...
To the law and to the testimony let this dispute between you and them be determined by God’ s word, which is here and in many other places called
the law to signify their obligation to believe and obey it; and the testimony, because it is a witness between God and man of God’ s mind and will, and of man’ s duty; and so these two titles contain two arguments against these idolatrous practices.
If they your antagonists, that seek to pervert you, Isa 8:19 .
It is because there is no light in them this proceeds from the darkness of their minds, because they are blind, and will not see, and God hath shut their eyes that they cannot see. But these words are by divers learned interpreters understood not as a declaration of their ignorance, but a commination and prediction of their misery, light being most commonly used in Scripture for comfort and happiness, and darkness for sorrows and calamities. And this sense seems to be much favoured by the following passages. And then the words may be thus rendered, assuredly (for the Hebrew particle asher is frequently used as a note of asseveration, as 1Sa 15:20 Psa 10:6 95:11 , &c., as hath been more than once observed before) no light or morning light shall be (for that may as well be understood as is) to them ; a night of misery shall come upon them, and they shall never have a morning of deliverance from it; they shall be swallowed up in endless calamities.
Haydock -> Isa 8:20
Haydock: Isa 8:20 - -- Law. Sealed, (ver. 16.) or to the law of Moses, Ecclesiasticus xxxiv. 28. (Calmet) ---
Septuagint, "why do they consult the dead concerning the li...
Law. Sealed, (ver. 16.) or to the law of Moses, Ecclesiasticus xxxiv. 28. (Calmet) ---
Septuagint, "why do they consult the dead concerning the living? For he gave the law to assist us." (Haydock) ---
Light. They shall die or be miserable. (Calmet)
Gill -> Isa 8:20
Gill: Isa 8:20 - -- To the law, and to the testimony,.... Kimchi takes this to be an oath, "by the law, and by the testimony", it is so and so; but Aben Ezra observes the...
To the law, and to the testimony,.... Kimchi takes this to be an oath, "by the law, and by the testimony", it is so and so; but Aben Ezra observes there is no instance of this kind in Scripture; it is a direction of Christ's to his disciples, to attend to the writings of Moses and the prophets, to search the Scriptures, as in Joh 5:39 and particularly what is before said in this prophecy concerning himself, the same is meant as on Isa 8:16.
if they speak not according to this word; this sure word of prophecy, to which men do well to take heed, as to a light shining in a dark place, it being the rule of faith and practice, a lamp to the feet, and a light to the path:
it is because there is no light in them; that is, in them that speak not according to it, meaning the Scribes and Pharisees; who, rejecting the written word, set up the traditions of the elders above it, and taught the people to walk according to them; and so were, as our Lord says, "blind leaders of the blind", Mat 15:14 or the words may be read, "if not"; if they will not regard the Scriptures, and the evangelical doctrine in them, and the testimony they give concerning Christ; "let them speak according to this word"; or instruction, and counsel, they have from the Scribes and Pharisees: "in which there is no light" b; but the darkness of ignorance, infidelity, superstition, and will worship; or "no morning"; but a night of Jewish darkness, even though the sun of righteousness was risen, and the dayspring from on high had visited the earth; yet they had received no light and knowledge from him, which was their condemnation, Joh 1:4, Joh 3:19 or thus, "to the law, and to the testimony, though they may say after this manner, there is no light in it" c; in the law and testimony, preferring the traditions, decisions, and determinations of their doctors above it. Noldhius d renders the words thus, "seeing they speak not according to this word, certainly they shall have no morning"; that is, seeing the seducers and false teachers, in the preceding verse Isa 8:19, speak not according to the word of God, and testimony of Jesus, they shall have no morning of light and joy, of grace and comfort, or any spiritual felicity; Christ will be no morning to them, but they will continue in their dark, benighted, and miserable condition, described in the following verse.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9a206/9a20678833a2d5f914528c6918ee079b308382c5" alt=""
expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes: Isa 8:20 Heb “If they do not speak according to this word, [it is] because it has no light of dawn.” The literal translation suggests that “t...
Geneva Bible -> Isa 8:20
Geneva Bible: Isa 8:20 To the ( y ) law and to the testimony: if they speak not according to this word, [it is] because [there is] no ( z ) light in them.
( y ) Seek remedy...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9a206/9a20678833a2d5f914528c6918ee079b308382c5" alt=""
expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Isa 8:1-22
TSK Synopsis: Isa 8:1-22 - --1 In Maher-shalal-hash-baz, he prophesies that Syria and Israel shall be subdued by Assyria.5 Judah likewise for their infidelity.9 God's judgments sh...
MHCC -> Isa 8:17-22
MHCC: Isa 8:17-22 - --The prophet foresaw that the Lord would hide his face; but he would look for his return in favour to them again. Though not miraculous signs, the chil...
Matthew Henry -> Isa 8:16-22
Matthew Henry: Isa 8:16-22 - -- In these verses we have, I. The unspeakable privilege which the people of God enjoy in having the oracles of God consigned over to them, and being e...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Isa 8:20
Keil-Delitzsch: Isa 8:20 - --
In opposition to such a falling away to wretched superstition, the watchword of the prophet and his supporters is this. "To the teaching of God ( th...
Constable: Isa 7:1--39:8 - --III. Israel's crisis of faith chs. 7--39
This long section of the book deals with Israel's major decision in Isa...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Constable: Isa 7:1--12:6 - --A. The choice between trusting God or Assyria chs. 7-12
This section of Isaiah provides a historical int...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Constable: Isa 7:1--9:8 - --1. Signs of God's presence 7:1-9:7
A unifying theme in this subsection is children. The children...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Constable: Isa 8:11--9:8 - --Clarification of the issue 8:11-9:7
Having received two signs of God's dealing with them...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""