collapse all  

Text -- Jeremiah 3:5 (NET)

Strongs On/Off
Context
3:5 You will not always be angry with me, will you? You will not be mad at me forever, will you?’ That is what you say, but you continually do all the evil that you can.”
Parallel   Cross Reference (TSK)   ITL  

Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics

Dictionary Themes and Topics: Wicked | Marriage | Kidron | Idolatry | God | Condescension of God | Church | Backsliders | more
Table of Contents

Word/Phrase Notes
Wesley , JFB , Clarke , Calvin , TSK

Word/Phrase Notes
Barnes , Poole , Haydock , Gill

Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes

Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis , MHCC , Matthew Henry , Keil-Delitzsch , Constable

collapse all
Commentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)

Wesley: Jer 3:5 - -- Will he not be reconciled?

Will he not be reconciled?

JFB: Jer 3:5 - -- "thou," the second person, had preceded. The change to the third person implies a putting away of God to a greater distance from them; instead of repe...

"thou," the second person, had preceded. The change to the third person implies a putting away of God to a greater distance from them; instead of repenting and forsaking their idols, they merely deprecate the continuance of their punishment. Jer 3:12 and Psa 103:9, answer their question in the event of their penitence.

JFB: Jer 3:5 - -- Rather (God's reply to them), "Thou hast spoken (thus), and yet (all the while) thou hast done evil," &c.

Rather (God's reply to them), "Thou hast spoken (thus), and yet (all the while) thou hast done evil," &c.

JFB: Jer 3:5 - -- With all thy might; with incorrigible persistency [CALVIN].

With all thy might; with incorrigible persistency [CALVIN].

Clarke: Jer 3:5 - -- Will he reserve his anger for ever? - Why should not wrath be continued against thee, as thou continuest transgression against the Lord?

Will he reserve his anger for ever? - Why should not wrath be continued against thee, as thou continuest transgression against the Lord?

Calvin: Jer 3:5 - -- God shews that it was the fault of the Jews, that he did not receive them into favor. And here he takes the argument from his own nature, and speaks ...

God shews that it was the fault of the Jews, that he did not receive them into favor. And here he takes the argument from his own nature, and speaks of himself in the third person; and it is the same as though the Prophet had interposed this reasoning, “God is not inexorable, for he is as ready to forgive as he is long — suffering: now, then, what prevents you from living happily again under his government? for he will spare you, provided he finds in you genuine repentance.” We now then see, what the Prophet means here: for as God had kindly exhorted the people to repent, the Prophet speaks now generally of God’s own nature, — that he keeps not for ever, nor reserves perpetually

These words, when put alone, mean that he does not cherish vengeance, and in our language we imitate the Hebrews, Il lui garde. This garde, when put without anything added to it, means, as I have said, that vengeance is cherished within. But nothing is more contrary than this to the nature of God. It hence follows, that the Jews had no obstacle in their way, except that they shunned God, and that being addicted to their own vices, they were unwilling to receive the pardon that was freely offered to them.

As to the second clause, it admits of being explained in two ways. We may regard an adversative particle to be understood, “though thou hast spoken and hast done, “etc.; as if God had said, that he would be propitious to the Jews, however atrociously they might have sinned. But another view is more simple, — that God here complains that there was no hope of amendment, as they had become hardened in their vices, “Thou hast spoken,” he says, “thou hast done, and thou hast been able.” And interpreters further vary in their views: for the copulative is explained by some as a particle of comparison, in the sense of כאשר , k e ash e r, “ according to what thou wert able, thou hast done wickedness.” But others take the words more simply and more correctly, as I think, “Thou hast been very strong;” that is, thou hast exerted all thy power, so that thou hast put forth all thy strength in doing evil, as we say in Latin, pro virili, with all thy might; that is, as far as thy capacity extended, thou hast devoted thyself to wickedness. 76

I therefore give this explanation: God had before put on, as it were, the character of one in grief and sorrow, and kindly exhorted the people to repent, and testified that he would be ready to pardon them, and at the same time shewed in general that he would be propitious, as he is by nature inclined to mercy. After having set forth these things, he now adds, that he despaired of that people, because they gloried in their own wickedness: for to speak and to do means the same as if he had said, that the people were so impudent, that they boasted of their rebellion against God, and dared to call darkness light; for the superstitious, we know, glory against God without any shame. Now, such was the state of the people; for God, by his prophets, condemned this especially in them — that they had corrupted the pure worship of the law; but they with a meretricious front dared to set up against him their own devotions and good intentions, as they are commonly called. As then, they thus presumptuously defended their wicked deeds, God here complains that they were in no way healable, and so he leaves them as past remedy. This I regard as the real meaning of the Prophet: and of similar import is the verb תוכל , tuc a l; “ thou hast put forth all thy might,” he says, that is, thou hast observed no limits in sinning, but, on the contrary, hast given thyself up to unbridled licentiousness. It now follows —

TSK: Jer 3:5 - -- he reserve : Jer 3:12; Psa 77:7-9, Psa 85:5, Psa 103:8, Psa 103:9; Isa 57:16, Isa 64:9 thou hast spoken : Eze 22:6; Mic 2:1, Mic 7:3; Zep 3:1-5

collapse all
Commentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)

Barnes: Jer 3:5 - -- Rather, "Will he, the young husband,"retain, "keep up His anger forever!"These words should be joined to Jer 3:4. Behold ... - Rather, "Behold...

Rather, "Will he, the young husband,"retain, "keep up His anger forever!"These words should be joined to Jer 3:4.

Behold ... - Rather, "Behold, thou hast spoken"thus, but thou hast "done evil things"persistently. The King James Version translates as if Judah’ s words and deeds were both evil. Really her words were fair, but her deeds proved them to be false.

And here ends the prophecy, most interesting as showing what was the general nature of Jeremiah’ s exhortations to his countrymen, during the 14 years of Josiah’ s reign. He sets before them God and Israel united by a covenant of marriage, to the conditions of which Yahweh is ever true, while Israel practices with zest every form of idolatry. Therefore, the divine blessing is withheld. It is an honest and manly warning, and the great lesson it teaches us is, that with God nothing avails but a real and heartfelt repentance followed by a life of holiness and sincere devotion to His service.

Jer. 3:6\endash 4:4 - "The Call to Repentance"

The former prophecy ended with the denunciation of God’ s perpetual anger because of Israel’ s obstinate persistence in sin. Now there is an invitation to repentance, and the assurance of forgiveness. The argument is as follows: Israel had been guilty of apostasy, and therefore God bad put her away. Unwarned by this example her more guilty sister Judah persists in the same sins Jer 3:6-11. Israel therefore is invited to, return to the marriage-covenant by repentance Jer 3:12-14, in which case she and Judah, accepted upon the like condition, shall become joint members of a spiritual theocracy. Jer 3:15-18. The repentance which God requires must be real Jer. 3:19\endash 4:4.

Poole: Jer 3:5 - -- Will he reserve his anger for ever? here being a defect of the noun, the Jews supply it with thy sin , Isa 43:25 , but the most and best, as we do, ...

Will he reserve his anger for ever? here being a defect of the noun, the Jews supply it with thy sin , Isa 43:25 , but the most and best, as we do,

his anger Compare it with Jer 3:12 Psa 103:9 Nah 1:2 , in which texts there is a defect of the same word. This may seem to be the words of the prophet, and so the connexion is easy with the foregoing words: q.d. If thou wouldst do so, try me now, &c.: would he reserve his anger? would he not be reconciled? but thou hast taken quite another course. Or they may be the words of God, as it were, teaching his people how they should accost him: God is more forward and earnest for reconciliation than sinners themselves.

The end the same with the former for ever.

Behold, thou hast spoken and done evil things as thou couldest: God’ s challenge of the people, charging them, either with their resolved wickedness, that they had made good all their evil words by their evil actions, they had even done as they said; or rather, with their hypocrisy: q.d. Notwithstanding all thy former promises, yet thou persistest still in thy lewdness and obstinacy, Isa 58:2 Hos 7:14 .

Haydock: Jer 3:5 - -- Wilt. Hebrew, "will he," &c. The faithless people will not use this language, but do all the evil possible.

Wilt. Hebrew, "will he," &c. The faithless people will not use this language, but do all the evil possible.

Gill: Jer 3:5 - -- Will he reserve his anger for ever?.... These words may be considered as a continuation of the speech put into their mouths to make to the Lord and pl...

Will he reserve his anger for ever?.... These words may be considered as a continuation of the speech put into their mouths to make to the Lord and plead with him, as well as what follows:

will he keep it to the end? that is, his anger: no; he will not: this is not according to the nature of God; he retains not his anger for ever, Mic 7:18, though, according to some versions, this is to be understood of the sins of these people being reserved and kept forever, as their impudence and obstinacy; so the Syriac and Arabic versions; and to which agrees the Targum,

"is it possible that thy sins should be kept for thee for ever, or the stroke (of punishment) be strengthened upon thee to the end?''

so Kimchi,

"says the prophet, if thou dost this (call him my father, &c.) will God reserve thine iniquity for thee for ever, or keep thy sin unto the end? he will not do so; but when thou returnest unto him, he will return unto thee, and do thee good; but thou hast not done so.''

The sense is much the same:

behold, thou hast spoken, and done evil things as thou couldest; which were enough to cause the Lord to reserve and keep his anger for ever. There is a double reading here; the Cetib, or writing, is דברתי, "I have spoken"; the prophet had spoken to them to return; or the Lord by the prophet had spoken to them, and put the above words into their mouths, and told them what they should say when they returned to the Lord; "but thou hast done evil things" y; notwithstanding such declarations of grace, and dost continue to do them:

and thou hast prevailed z; as the last clause may be rendered; that I cannot turn away mine anger from thee, but must reserve it, and keep it for ever. The Keri, or reading, is דברת, "thou hast spoken"; thou hast said thou wilt do evil things, and thou hast done them as thou hast said, and hast prevailed; thou hast sinned with all thy might and main, and hast spoken and done as evil things as possibly could be done. Some choose to render the words thus, "if thou hadst spoken"; the words that were put into their mouths before mentioned; "though thou hast done evil things, yet thou wouldest have prevailed" a; that is, with God, to have turned away his anger from thee.

expand all
Commentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

NET Notes: Jer 3:5 Heb “You do the evil and you are able.” This is an example of hendiadys, meaning “You do all the evil that you are able to do.”...

expand all
Commentary -- Verse Range Notes

TSK Synopsis: Jer 3:1-25 - --1 God's great mercy in Judah's vile whoredom.6 Judah is worse than Israel.12 The promises of the gospel to the penitent.20 Israel reproved, and called...

MHCC: Jer 3:1-5 - --In repentance, it is good to think upon the sins of which we have been guilty, and the places and companies where they have been committed. How gently...

Matthew Henry: Jer 3:1-5 - -- These verses some make to belong to the sermon in the foregoing chapter, and they open a door of hope to those who receive the conviction of the rep...

Keil-Delitzsch: Jer 3:4-5 - -- Henceforward, forsooth, it calls upon its God, and expects that His wrath will abate; but this calling on Him is but lip-service, for it goes on in ...

Constable: Jer 2:1--45:5 - --II. Prophecies about Judah chs. 2--45 The first series of prophetic announcements, reflections, and incidents th...

Constable: Jer 2:1--25:38 - --A. Warnings of judgment on Judah and Jerusalem chs. 2-25 Chapters 2-25 contain warnings and appeals to t...

Constable: Jer 2:1--6:30 - --1. Warnings of coming punishment because of Judah's guilt chs. 2-6 Most of the material in this ...

Constable: Jer 3:1--4:5 - --Yahweh's call for His people's repentance 3:1-4:4 A passionate plea for repentance follo...

Constable: Jer 3:1-5 - --The spiritual unfaithfulness of Judah 3:1-5 3:1 God posed the question to His people of what happens in a divorce. The answer to His rhetorical questi...

expand all
Introduction / Outline

JFB: Jeremiah (Book Introduction) JEREMIAH, son of Hilkiah, one of the ordinary priests, dwelling in Anathoth of Benjamin (Jer 1:1), not the Hilkiah the high priest who discovered the ...

JFB: Jeremiah (Outline) EXPOSTULATION WITH THE JEWS, REMINDING THEM OF THEIR FORMER DEVOTEDNESS, AND GOD'S CONSEQUENT FAVOR, AND A DENUNCIATION OF GOD'S COMING JUDGMENTS FOR...

TSK: Jeremiah 3 (Chapter Introduction) Overview Jer 3:1, God’s great mercy in Judah’s vile whoredom; Jer 3:6, Judah is worse than Israel; Jer 3:12, The promises of the gospel to the...

Poole: Jeremiah (Book Introduction) BOOK OF THE PROPHET JEREMIAH THE ARGUMENT IT was the great unhappiness of this prophet to be a physician to, but that could not save, a dying sta...

Poole: Jeremiah 3 (Chapter Introduction) CHAPTER 3 God’ s forbearance with the idolatry of Judah, who is worse than Israel, Jer 3:1-11 . Both called to repent, with gospel promises, J...

MHCC: Jeremiah (Book Introduction) Jeremiah was a priest, a native of Anathoth, in the tribe of Benjamin. He was called to the prophetic office when very young, about seventy years afte...

MHCC: Jeremiah 3 (Chapter Introduction) (Jer 3:1-5) Exhortations to repentance. (Jer 3:6-11) Judah more guilty than Israel. (Jer 3:12-20) But pardon is promised. (Jer 3:21-25) The childre...

Matthew Henry: Jeremiah (Book Introduction) An Exposition, with Practical Observations, of The Book of the Prophet Jeremiah The Prophecies of the Old Testament, as the Epistles of the New, are p...

Matthew Henry: Jeremiah 3 (Chapter Introduction) The foregoing chapter was wholly taken up with reproofs and threatenings against the people of God, for their apostasies from him; but in this chap...

Constable: Jeremiah (Book Introduction) Introduction Title The title of this book derives from its writer, the late seventh an...

Constable: Jeremiah (Outline) Outline I. Introduction ch. 1 A. The introduction of Jeremiah 1:1-3 B. T...

Constable: Jeremiah Jeremiah Bibliography Aharoni, Yohanan, and Michael Avi-Yonah. The Macmillan Bible Atlas. Revised ed. London: C...

Haydock: Jeremiah (Book Introduction) THE PROPHECY OF JEREMIAS. INTRODUCTION. Jeremias was a priest, a native of Anathoth, a priestly city, in the tribe of Benjamin, and was sanct...

Gill: Jeremiah (Book Introduction) INTRODUCTION TO JEREMIAH The title of the book in the Vulgate Latin version is, "the Prophecy of Jeremiah"; in the Syriac and Arabic versions, "the...

Gill: Jeremiah 3 (Chapter Introduction) INTRODUCTION TO JEREMIAH 3 In this chapter the sins of the people of Israel and Judah are exposed; particularly their idolatry, signified by playin...

Advanced Commentary (Dictionaries, Hymns, Arts, Sermon Illustration, Question and Answers, etc)


TIP #24: Use the Study Dictionary to learn and to research all aspects of 20,000+ terms/words. [ALL]
created in 0.09 seconds
powered by
bible.org - YLSA