data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/674fe/674fe95c55835d4b12bd7659619a70745375f8e8" alt=""
Text -- Daniel 1:17 (NET)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/53bcc/53bcc09312609f7dc35434b05e6325fb4f307489" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/af4c0/af4c08bb75e113d55de738af2fccbbe4c5a2ea12" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/af4c0/af4c08bb75e113d55de738af2fccbbe4c5a2ea12" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/af4c0/af4c08bb75e113d55de738af2fccbbe4c5a2ea12" alt=""
Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/53bcc/53bcc09312609f7dc35434b05e6325fb4f307489" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/75ece/75ece45dbe9362d6fddeec6b919b612852027d80" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9a206/9a20678833a2d5f914528c6918ee079b308382c5" alt=""
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
(Exo 31:2-3; 1Ki 3:12; Job 32:8; Jam 1:5, Jam 1:17).
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
JFB: Dan 1:17 - -- God thus made one of the despised covenant-people eclipse the Chaldean sages in the very science on which they most prided themselves. So Joseph in th...
God thus made one of the despised covenant-people eclipse the Chaldean sages in the very science on which they most prided themselves. So Joseph in the court of Pharaoh (Gen 40:5; Gen 41:1-8). Daniel, in these praises of his own "understanding," speaks not through vanity, but by the direction of God, as one transported out of himself. See my Introduction, "CONTENTS OF THE BOOK."
Clarke: Dan 1:17 - -- As for these four children - Young men or youths. Our translation gives a false idea
As for these four children - Young men or youths. Our translation gives a false idea
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Clarke: Dan 1:17 - -- In all visions and dreams - That is, such as are Divine; for as to dreams in general, they have as much signification as they have connection, being...
In all visions and dreams - That is, such as are Divine; for as to dreams in general, they have as much signification as they have connection, being the effects of the state of the body, of the mind, or of the circumstances of the dreamer. A dream may be considered supernatural, if it have nothing preposterous, nothing monstrous, and nothing irregular. If the whole order and consequences of the things be preserved in them, from beginning to end, then we may presume they are supernatural. In such dreams Daniel had understanding.
Calvin -> Dan 1:17
Calvin: Dan 1:17 - -- The Prophet here shows what we have already touched upon, how his authority was acquired for exercising the prophetic office with greater advantage. ...
The Prophet here shows what we have already touched upon, how his authority was acquired for exercising the prophetic office with greater advantage. He ought to be distinguished by fixed marks, that the Jews first, and foreigners afterwards, might acknowledge him to be endued with the prophetic spirit. But a portion of this favor was shared with his three companions; yet he excelled them all, because God fitted him specially for his office. Here the end is to be noticed, because it would be incorrect to say that their reward was bestowed by God, because they lived both frugally and heavenly, and spontaneously abstained from the delicacies of the palace; for God had quite a different intention. For he wished, as I have already said, to extol Daniel, to enable him to shew with advantage that Israel’s God is the only God; and as he wished his companions to excel hereafter in political government, he presented them also with some portion of his Spirit. But it is worthwhile to set Daniel before our eyes; because, as I have said, before God appointed him his Prophet, he wished to adorn him with his own insignia, to procure confidence in his teaching. He says, therefore, to those four boys, or youths, knowledge and science were given in all literature and wisdom Daniel was endued with a very singular gift — he was to be an interpreter of dreams, and an explainer of visions. Since Daniel here speaks of literature, without doubt he simply means the liberal arts, and does not comprehend the magical arts which flourished then and afterwards in Chaldea. We know that nothing was sincere among unbelievers; and, on the other hand, I have previously admonished you, that Daniel was not imbued with the superstitions in those days highly esteemed in that nation. Through discontent with genuine science, they corrupted the study of the stars; but Daniel and his associates were so brought up among the Chaldeans, that they were not tinctured with those mixtures and corruptions which ought always to be separated from true science. It would be absurd, then, to attribute to God the approval of magical arts, which it is well known were severely prohibited and condemned by the law itself. (Deu 18:10.) Although God abominates those magical superstitions as the works of the devil, this does not prevent Daniel and his companions from being divinely adorned with this gift, and being very well versed in all the literature of the Chaldees. Hence this ought to be restricted to true and natural science. As it respects Daniel, he says, he understood even, visions and dreams and we know how by these two methods the Prophets were instructed in the will of God. (Num 12:6.) For while God there blames Aaron and Miriam, he affirms this to be his usual method; as often as he wishes to manifest his designs to the Prophets, he addresses them by visions and dreams. But Moses is treated out of the common order of men, because he is addressed face to face, and mouth to mouth. God, therefore, whenever he wished to make use of his Prophets, by either visions or dreams, made known to them what he wished to be proclaimed to the people. When, therefore, it is here said, — Daniel understood dreams and visions, it has the sense of being endued with the prophetic spirit. While his companions were superior masters and teachers in all kinds of literature, he alone was a Prophet of God.
We now understand the object of this distinction, when an acquaintance with visions and dreams was ascribed peculiarly to Daniel. And here our previous assertion is fully confirmed, namely, that Daniel was adorned with the fullest proofs of his mission, to enable him afterwards to undertake the prophetic office with greater confidence, and acquire greater attention to his teaching. God could, indeed, prepare the in a single moment, and by striking terror and reverence into the minds of all, induce them to embrace his teaching; but he wished to raise his servant by degrees, and to bring him forth at the fitting time, and not too suddenly so that all might know by marks impressed for many years how to distinguish him from the common order of men. It afterwards follows:
Defender -> Dan 1:17
Defender: Dan 1:17 - -- In Christ "are hid all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge" (Col 2:3). To those who sincerely study, believe and obey God's Word and who are determi...
In Christ "are hid all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge" (Col 2:3). To those who sincerely study, believe and obey God's Word and who are determined to stand for His truth in an ungodly society, God will provide the necessary wisdom and knowledge to accomplish the work He calls them to do."
TSK -> Dan 1:17
TSK: Dan 1:17 - -- God : Dan 2:21, Dan 2:23; 1Ki 3:12, 1Ki 3:28, 1Ki 4:29-31; 2Ch 1:10,2Ch 1:12; Job 32:8; Psa 119:98-100; Pro 2:6; Ecc 2:26; Isa 28:26; Luk 21:15; Act 6...
God : Dan 2:21, Dan 2:23; 1Ki 3:12, 1Ki 3:28, 1Ki 4:29-31; 2Ch 1:10,2Ch 1:12; Job 32:8; Psa 119:98-100; Pro 2:6; Ecc 2:26; Isa 28:26; Luk 21:15; Act 6:10, Act 7:10; Col 1:9; Jam 1:5, Jam 1:17
knowledge : Act 7:22
Daniel had understanding : or, he made Daniel understand, Dan 4:9, Dan 4:10, Dan 5:11, Dan 5:12, Dan 5:14, Dan 10:1; Gen 41:8-15; Num 12:6; 2Ch 26:5; Eze 28:3; 1Co 12:7-11
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9a206/9a20678833a2d5f914528c6918ee079b308382c5" alt=""
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Dan 1:17
Barnes: Dan 1:17 - -- As for these four children - On the word "children,"see the notes at Dan 1:4. Compare Dan 1:6. God gave them knowledge and skill - See th...
As for these four children - On the word "children,"see the notes at Dan 1:4. Compare Dan 1:6.
God gave them knowledge and skill - See the notes at Dan 1:9. There is no reason to suppose that in the "knowledge and skill"here referred to, it is meant to be implied that there was anything miraculous, or that there was any direct inspiration. Inspiration was evidently confined to Daniel, and pertained to what is spoken of under the head of "visions and dreams."The fact that "all"this was to be attributed to God as his gift, is in accordance with the common method of speaking in the Scriptures; and it is also in accordance with "fact,"that "all"knowledge is to be traced to God. See Exo 31:2-3. God formed the intellect; he preserves the exercise of reason; he furnishes us instructors; he gives us clearness of perception; he enables us to take advantage of bright thoughts and happy suggestions which occur in our own minds, as much as he sends rain, and dew, and sunshine on the fields of the farmer, and endows him with skill. Compare Isa 28:26, "For his God doth instruct him."The knowledge and skill which we may acquire, therefore, should be as much attributed to God as the success of the farmer should. Compare Job 32:8, "For there is a spirit in man, and the inspiration of the Almighty giveth them understanding."In the case before us, there is no reason to doubt that the natural powers of these young men had been diligently applied during the three years of their trial Dan 1:5, and under the advantages of a strict course of temperance; and that the knowledge here spoken of was the result of such an application to their studies. On the meaning of the words "knowledge"and "skill"here, see the notes at Dan 1:4.
In all learning and wisdom - See also the notes at Dan 1:4.
And Daniel had understanding - Showing that in that respect there was a special endowment in his case; a kind of knowledge imparted which could be communicated only by special inspiration. The margin is, "he made Daniel understand."The margin is in accordance with the Hebrew, but the sense is the same.
In all visions - On the word rendered "visions"-
And dreams - One of the ways by which the will of God was anciently communicated to men. See Introduction to Isaiah, Section 7. (2), and the notes at Job 33:14-18. Daniel, like Joseph before him, was supernaturally endowed to explain these messages which God sent to men, or to unfold these preintimations of coming events. This was a kind of knowledge which the Chaldeans particularly sought, and on which they especially prided themselves; and it was important, in order to "stain the pride of all human glory,"and to make "the wisdom of the wise"in Babylon to be seen to be comparative "folly,"to endow one man from the land of the prophets in the most ample manner with this knowledge, as it was important to do the same thing at the court of Pharaoh by the superior endowments of Joseph Gen 41:8.
Poole -> Dan 1:17
Poole: Dan 1:17 - -- We must own
knowledge, and skill, and wisdom to come from God, Jam 1:5 . These are beams of light shining in us from the Father of lights, and a m...
We must own
knowledge, and skill, and wisdom to come from God, Jam 1:5 . These are beams of light shining in us from the Father of lights, and a man can receive nothing of this unless it be given him from above, Joh 3:27 .
Object. But was not this magic, and was not this learning forbidden as abomination to the Lord, Deu 18:9-14 ?
Answ The Chaldeans used lawful arts and sciences, and unlawful; these four young men, Daniel and his companions, used only those that were lawful; rejecting all that wisdom which is sensual, carnal, and devilish, Jam 3:15 . In all visions and dreams; not in idle, vain, and lying, but in such as were sent of God, and predictions of things to come, as Num 12:6 , such as the prophets had. Such was that of Nebuchadnezzar.
Haydock -> Dan 1:17
Haydock: Dan 1:17 - -- Dreams. He was learned in all the sciences of the country, like Moses. (Acts vii. 22.) (Calmet) ---
They studies these things, in order to refute w...
Dreams. He was learned in all the sciences of the country, like Moses. (Acts vii. 22.) (Calmet) ---
They studies these things, in order to refute what was erroneous: discunt....ut judicent. (St. Jerome) ---
The Chaldeans paid great attention to dreams. Daniel acquired the knowledge of such as were sent from heaven by the gift of God, as Joseph had done. To pay any regard to common dreams would be childish (Calmet) and sinful, if the person depend on them for the knowledge of futurity. (Haydock)
Gill -> Dan 1:17
Gill: Dan 1:17 - -- As for these four children, God gave them knowledge and skill in all learning and wisdom,.... As they prospered in their bodies, they succeeded in the...
As for these four children, God gave them knowledge and skill in all learning and wisdom,.... As they prospered in their bodies, they succeeded in their studies, and improved in their minds, and became great proficients in all kind of lawful and useful knowledge; not owing so much to their own sagacity and diligence, and the goodness and ability of their teachers, as to the blessing of God on their instructions and studies; for, as all natural, so all acquired parts are to be ascribed to God; and which these were favoured with by him in a very great manner, to answer some purposes of his. This is to be understood, not of magic art, vain philosophy, judicial astrology, to which the Chaldeans were addicted; but of learning and wisdom, laudable and useful, both in things natural and political; for these men, who scrupled eating and drinking what came from the king's table, would never indulge themselves in the study of vain, curious, and unlawful knowledge; much less would God have blessed the study of such things, and still less be said to give them knowledge and skill therein:
and Daniel had understanding in all visions and dreams; besides knowledge and skill in all learning and wisdom, in languages and sciences, in common with the other young men; he had the honour of seeing very remarkable visions of future things, and of interpreting dreams; and this not by rules of art, such as the Oneirocritics use, but by the gift of God; of which many singular instances follow in this book.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9a206/9a20678833a2d5f914528c6918ee079b308382c5" alt=""
expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9a206/9a20678833a2d5f914528c6918ee079b308382c5" alt=""
expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Dan 1:1-21
TSK Synopsis: Dan 1:1-21 - --1 Jehoiakim's captivity.3 Ashpenaz takes Daniel, Hananiah, Mishael, and Azariah.8 They refusing the king's portion do prosper with pulse and water.17 ...
Maclaren -> Dan 1:8-21
Maclaren: Dan 1:8-21 - --Youthful Confessors
But Daniel purposed in his heart that he would not defile himself with the portion of the king's meat, nor with the wine which he...
MHCC -> Dan 1:17-21
MHCC: Dan 1:17-21 - --Daniel and his fellows kept to their religion; and God rewarded them with eminence in learning. Pious young persons should endeavour to do better than...
Matthew Henry -> Dan 1:17-21
Matthew Henry: Dan 1:17-21 - -- Concerning Daniel and his fellows we have here, I. Their great attainments in learning, Dan 1:17. They were very sober and diligent, and studied har...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Dan 1:17-21
Keil-Delitzsch: Dan 1:17-21 - --
The progress of the young men in the wisdom of the Chaldeans, and their appointment to the service of the king.
As God blessed the resolution of ...
Constable -> Dan 1:1-21; Dan 1:17-21
Constable: Dan 1:1-21 - --I. The character of Daniel Ch. 1
Chapter 1 provides an introduction to the whole book. It relates early events i...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""