collapse all  

Text -- Acts 5:3 (NET)

Strongs On/Off
Context
5:3 But Peter said, “Ananias, why has Satan filled your heart to lie to the Holy Spirit and keep back for yourself part of the proceeds from the sale of the land?
Parallel   Cross Reference (TSK)   ITL  

Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics

Names, People and Places:
 · Ananias the husband of Sapphira,a man of Damascus who was told of Saul's conversion by the Lord,a high priest at Jerusalem
 · Peter a man who was a leader among the twelve apostles and wrote the two epistles of Peter
 · Satan a person, male (evil angelic),an angel that has rebelled against God


Dictionary Themes and Topics: TEXT AND MANUSCRIPTS OF THE NEW TESTAMENT | Sapphira | SPIRIT | PETER, THE FIRST EPISTLE OF | PAPYRUS | Lies and Deceits | Land | LIE; LYING | Judgments of God | Hypocrisy | Holy Spirit | Heart | HOLY SPIRIT, 2 | Death | Community | Church | COVETOUSNESS | BURIAL | Ananias | ANANIAS (1) | more
Table of Contents

Word/Phrase Notes
Robertson , Vincent , Wesley , JFB , Clarke , Calvin , TSK

Word/Phrase Notes
Barnes , Poole , Haydock , Gill

Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes , Geneva Bible

Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis , Combined Bible , MHCC , Matthew Henry , Barclay , Constable , College , McGarvey

collapse all
Commentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)

Robertson: Act 5:3 - -- Filled ( eplērōsen ). The very verb used of the filling by the Holy Spirit (Act 4:31). Satan the adversary is the father of lies (Joh 8:44). He h...

Filled ( eplērōsen ).

The very verb used of the filling by the Holy Spirit (Act 4:31). Satan the adversary is the father of lies (Joh 8:44). He had entered into Judas (Luk 22:3; Joh 13:27) and now he has filled the heart of Ananias with a lie.

Robertson: Act 5:3 - -- To lie to the Holy Spirit ( pseusasthai se to pneuma to hagion ). Infinitive (aorist middle) of purpose with accusative of general reference (se ) a...

To lie to the Holy Spirit ( pseusasthai se to pneuma to hagion ).

Infinitive (aorist middle) of purpose with accusative of general reference (se ) and the accusative of the person (object) as often in Greek writers, though here only in the N.T. with this verb. Usual dative of the person in Act 5:4(anthrōpois , men, tōi theōi , God). The Holy Spirit had been given them to guide them into truth (Joh 15:13).

Vincent: Act 5:3 - -- To lie to ( ψεύσασθαι ) Rather, to deceive. The design of Satan was to deceive the Holy Ghost. To lie to would require a differe...

To lie to ( ψεύσασθαι )

Rather, to deceive. The design of Satan was to deceive the Holy Ghost. To lie to would require a different case in the noun, which occults in Act 5:4, where the same verb is properly rendered lie (unto God). Satan fills the heart to deceive. The result of the attempt is merely to lie.

Wesley: Act 5:3 - -- Who is in us.

Who is in us.

Wesley: Act 5:3 - -- Here was the first instance of it. This was the first attempt to bring propriety of goods into the Christian Church.

Here was the first instance of it. This was the first attempt to bring propriety of goods into the Christian Church.

JFB: Act 5:3-6 - -- "why . . . fill--"why hast thou suffered him to fill"

"why . . . fill--"why hast thou suffered him to fill"

JFB: Act 5:3-6 - -- So criminally entertaining his suggestion? Compare Act 5:4, "why hast thou conceived this thing in thine heart?" And see Joh 13:2, Joh 13:27.

So criminally entertaining his suggestion? Compare Act 5:4, "why hast thou conceived this thing in thine heart?" And see Joh 13:2, Joh 13:27.

JFB: Act 5:3-6 - -- To men under His supernatural illumination.

To men under His supernatural illumination.

Clarke: Act 5:3 - -- Why hath Satan filled thine heart - The verb πληροειν, which we translate to fill, Kypke has showed by many examples to signify, to instiga...

Why hath Satan filled thine heart - The verb πληροειν, which we translate to fill, Kypke has showed by many examples to signify, to instigate, excite, impel, etc., and it was a common belief, as well among the heathens as among the Jews and Christians, that, when a man did evil, he was excited to it by the influence and malice of an evil spirit. It is strange that, by the general consent of mankind, sin against God has been ever considered so perfectly unnatural, and so evil in itself, that no man would commit it unless impelled to it by the agency of the devil. The words of St. Peter here prove that such an agency is not fictitious: if there had been no devil, as some wish and perhaps feel it their interest to believe, or if this devil had no influence on the souls of men, Peter, under the agency of the Holy Spirit, would not have expressed himself in this way; for, if the thing were not so, it would have been the most direct means to lead the disciples to form false opinions, or to confirm them in old and absurd prejudices

Clarke: Act 5:3 - -- To lie to the Holy Ghost - Ψευσασθαι το Πνευμα το Ἁγιον, To deceive the Holy Spirit. Every lie is told with the intention...

To lie to the Holy Ghost - Ψευσασθαι το Πνευμα το Ἁγιον, To deceive the Holy Spirit. Every lie is told with the intention to deceive; and they wished to deceive the apostles, and, in effect, that Holy Spirit under whose influence they professed to act. Lying against the Holy Ghost is in the next verse said to be lying against God; therefore the Holy Ghost is God

Clarke: Act 5:3 - -- To keep back part of the price - Νοσφισασθαι απο της τιμης . The verb νοσφιζειν, νοσφιζεσθαι, is used by...

To keep back part of the price - Νοσφισασθαι απο της τιμης . The verb νοσφιζειν, νοσφιζεσθαι, is used by the Greek writers to signify purloining part of the public money, peculation. The word is used here with great propriety, as the money for which the estate was sold was public property; as it was for this purpose alone that the sale was made.

Calvin: Act 5:3 - -- 3.And Peter said How did Peter know Ananias’ fraud (and purloining?) Undoubtedly by the revelation of the Spirit. Therefore, Luke signifieth unto u...

3.And Peter said How did Peter know Ananias’ fraud (and purloining?) Undoubtedly by the revelation of the Spirit. Therefore, Luke signifieth unto us, that the apostles did after a sort represent God’s person, and supply his room. If the Spirit of God, by the mouth of a mortal man, do so sore urge an hypocrite, being otherwise painted with the beautiful color of virtues, how shall the reprobate abide the voice of God himself, with the sound of the trumpet, when they shall appear before his judgment-seat? Furthermore, Peter pointeth out the cruelness and horribleness of the offense 240 by his question, when he saith, that Satan had filled the heart of Ananias. For there is no man whose heart is not pricked with the pricks of Satan, and all men are also many ways tempted, yea, these temptations pierce into their minds; but where Satan possesseth the heart, he reigneth in the whole man, having, as it were, expelled God. This is a sign of a reprobate, to be so addicted and given over to Satan, that the Spirit of God hath no place. That which followeth afterward concerning lying may have a double sense; either that he did falsely bear a show of the Spirit, or that he lied against the Spirit. And, indeed, it is word for word mentiri Spiritum; but forasmuch as the Greek word [ψευδεσθαι ] is joined with a double accusative case and that doth better agree with the text [context,] I am rather of this mind, that Ananias is reprehended, because he did lie falsely to the Holy Ghost. Which he confirmeth shortly after, when he upbraideth this unto him, that he hath lied unto God, and not unto men. Wherefore we must take great heed, that hypocrisy reign not in us, which hath this wickedness proper to it, to go about to deceive God, and, as it were cornicum oculos configere. To go about to make blind those which are most wise; 241 which cannot be without a disloyal and unseemly mock. Wherefore it is not without cause that Peter saith, that where this cometh to pass the heart is possessed of Satan. For who durst (unless he were void of reason) so blaspheme God? Therefore Peter asketh him as of some wonder, because such blindness is horrible.

TSK: Act 5:3 - -- why : Gen 3:13-17; 1Ki 22:21, 1Ki 22:22; 1Ch 21:1-3; Mat 4:3-11, Mat 13:19; Luk 22:3; Joh 13:2, Joh 13:27; Eph 6:11-16; Jam 4:7; 1Pe 5:8; Rev 12:9-11 ...

collapse all
Commentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)

Barnes: Act 5:3 - -- But Peter said ... - Peter could have known this only by "revelation."It was the manifest design of Ananias to deceive; nor was there any way o...

But Peter said ... - Peter could have known this only by "revelation."It was the manifest design of Ananias to deceive; nor was there any way of detecting him but by its being revealed to him by the Spirit of God. As it was an instance of enormous wickedness, and as it was very important to detect and punish the crime, it was made known to Peter directly by God.

Why hath Satan - Great deeds of wickedness in the Scripture are traced to the influence of Satan. Compare Luk 23:3; Joh 13:27. Especially is Satan called the "father of lies,"Joh 8:44-45. Compare Gen 3:1-5. As this was an act of "falsehood,"or an attempt to deceive, it is with great propriety traced to the influence of Satan. The sin of Ananias consisted in his "yielding"to the temptation. Nowhere in the Bible are people supposed to be free from guilt from the mere fact that they have been "tempted"to commit it. God requires them to "resist"temptation; and if they "yield"to it, they must be punished.

Filled thine heart - A man’ s "heart"or "mind"is "full"of a thing when he is "intent on it"; when he is strongly "impelled to it"; or when he is fully occupied with it. The expression here means that he was "strongly impelled"or "excited"by Satan to this crime.

To lie to - To attempt to deceive. The deception which he meant to practice was to keep back a "part"of the price, while he "pretended"to bring the whole of it; thus "tempting"God, and supposing that he could not detect the fraud.

The Holy Ghost - τὸ πνεῦμα τὸ ἅγιον to pneuma to hagion . The main inquiry here is, whether the apostle Peter intended to designate in this place the "third person"of the Trinity; or whether he meant to speak of God "as God,"without any reference to the distinction of persons; or whether he referred to the "divine influence"which inspired the apostles, without reference to the special offices which are commonly ascribed to the Holy Spirit. Or, in other words, is there a "distinction"here recognized between the Father and the Holy Spirit? That there "is,"will be apparent from the following considerations:

(1) If no such distinction is "intended,"it is remarkable that Peter did not use the usual and customary "name"of God. It does not appear why he guarded it so carefully as to denote that this offence was committed against the "Holy Spirit,"and "the Spirit of the Lord,"Act 5:9.

\caps1 (2) t\caps0 he name used here is the one employed in the Scriptures to designate the third person of the Trinity, as implying a distinction from the Father. See Mat 3:16; Mat 1:18, Mat 1:20; Mat 3:11; Mat 12:32; Mat 28:19; Mar 1:8; Mar 3:29; Mar 12:36; Luk 12:10; Joh 14:26; Joh 7:39; Joh 20:22; Act 4:8; Act 5:32, etc.

(3) Peter intended, doubtless, to designate an offence as committed particularly against the person, or influence, by which he and the other apostles were inspired. Ananias supposed that he could escape detection, and the offence was one, therefore, against the Inspirer of the apostles. Yet that was the Holy Spirit as "distinct from the Father."See Joh 14:16-17, Joh 14:26; Joh 15:26; Joh 16:7-11; Joh 20:22. Compare Act 5:32. The offence, therefore, being against him who was "sent"by the Father, and who was appointed to a particular work, clearly supposes that the Holy Spirit is distinct from the Father.

\caps1 (4) a\caps0 further incidental proof of this may be found in the fact that the sin here committed was one of special magnitude - so great as to be deemed worthy of the immediate and signal vengeance of God. Yet the sin against the Holy Spirit is uniformly represented to be of this description. Compare Mat 12:31-32; Mar 3:28-29. As these sins evidently coincide in enormity, it is clear that the same class of sins is referred to in both places; or, in other words, the sin of Ananias was against the third person of the Trinity. Two remarks may be made here:

(1) The Holy Spirit is a distinct Person from the Father and the Son; or, in other words, there is a distinction of some kind in the divine nature that may be designated by the word "person."This is clear from the fact that sin is said to have been committed against him - a sin which it was supposed could not be detected. "Sin"cannot be committed against an "attribute"of God, or an "influence"from God. We cannot "lie unto"an attribute, or against wisdom, or power, or goodness; nor can we "lie unto"an "influence,"merely, of the Most High. Sin is committed against a "Being,"not against an "attribute"; and as a sin is here charged on Ananias against "the Holy Spirit,"it follows that the Holy Spirit has a "personal"existence, or that there is such a distinction in the divine essence that it may be proper to "specify"a sin as committed especially against him. In the same way sin may be represented as committed especially against the "Father"when his "name"is blasphemed; when his "dominion"is denied; when his mercy in sending his Son is called in question. Sin may be represented as committed against "the Son"when his atonement is denied; his divinity assailed; his character derided, or his invitations slighted. And thus sin may be represented as committed against "the Holy Spirit"when his office of renewing the heart, or sanctifying the soul, is called in question, or when "his"work is ascribed to some malign or other influence. See Mar 3:22-30. And as sin against the Son proves that he is in some sense distinct from the Father, so does sin against the Holy Spirit prove that in some sense he is distinct from the Father and the Son.

\caps1 (2) t\caps0 he Holy Spirit is divine. This is proved, because he is represented here as being able to search the heart, and to detect insincerity and hypocrisy. Compare Jer 17:10; 1Ch 28:9; 1Co 2:10, "The Spirit searcheth all things, yea, the deep things of God"; Rev 2:23. And he is expressly "called"God. See the notes on Act 5:4.

Poole: Act 5:3 - -- But Peter said Peter knew this deceit by the inspiration of the Holy Ghost; it being most probably not otherwise likely ever to be discovered. Satan...

But Peter said Peter knew this deceit by the inspiration of the Holy Ghost; it being most probably not otherwise likely ever to be discovered.

Satan filled thine heart: as when the heart is filled with hot spirits it is daring and bold, so when Satan filled their heart these wretches venture upon desperate courses and provoking sins.

To lie to the Holy Ghost this sin is said to be lying to the Holy Ghost:

1. Because against their own consciences, and the Spirit of God too witnessing with their spirits, Rom 9:1 . As also:

2. Because they pretended to holiness, and the service of God, when they intended only to serve their own turns; now the Spirit is in a peculiar manner the Spirit of holiness, and the author of it in us, whom they pretended to have been moved by, but falsely.

3. And, lastly: Defrauding the poor members of Christ of their right, (for so by their vow it became), they lied to the Holy Ghost, who constitutes and establishes the church, and accepteth these gifts as given to God, and not to men.

Haydock: Act 5:3 - -- Why hath Satan tempted thy heart? [2] The present Greek copies, filled thy heart. (Witham) =============================== [BIBLIOGRAPHY] ...

Why hath Satan tempted thy heart? [2] The present Greek copies, filled thy heart. (Witham)

===============================

[BIBLIOGRAPHY]

Tentavit. In all Greek copies at present, Greek: eplerosen. But St. Epiphanius, Hær. lix. p. 500. reads Greek: epeirasen.

Gill: Act 5:3 - -- But Peter said, Ananias,.... Peter, by divine revelation, or by a spirit of discerning, such as Elisha had, who knew what his servant Gehazi had done,...

But Peter said, Ananias,.... Peter, by divine revelation, or by a spirit of discerning, such as Elisha had, who knew what his servant Gehazi had done, knowing what a reserve Ananias had made, calls him by his name, and says to him,

why hath Satan filled thine heart? or emboldened thee, given thee so much spirit and courage to act in such an impudent and audacious manner; so the phrase is used in Est 7:5 see the Septuagint there, and often in Talmudic writings.

"Says R. Joshua, I never מלאני לבי, "filled my heart"; or my heart never filled me to say to a man, go and take the change of these three things, &c. d.''

And says another Rabbi e,

"though I say so, לא מלאני לבי, "I never filled my heart", or my heart never filled me to transgress the words of the companions;''

that is, I never durst do so. And again f, it being observed, that Isaiah should say, "hear, O heavens!" it is said,

"who, or what is this, who מלאו לבו, "hath filled his heart", or whose heart has filled him to call to the heavens to hear.''

But this instance of Ananias was such, that none but Satan could have put him upon, or emboldened him to have done; who from hence appeared to have the power over him, and to have possessed him, to have great access to him, even to his heart, and great influence upon it, so as to prompt him

to lie to the Holy Ghost; who was in the apostles, and by whom they were acted, and to whom he had given a discerning of spirits; so that it was a daring action, and downright madness, to go about to deceive them: or he pretended he had an impulse from the Spirit of God to sell his estate, and give the whole price of it to the apostles, and yet kept back part of it; which was acting contrary to that Spirit he pretended to be influenced by.

And to keep back part of the price of the land: that is, he lied against the Holy Ghost, by keeping back part of the price the land was sold for; when he had declared he sold it with this view, to give the whole for charitable uses, and affirmed that what he brought was the whole.

expand all
Commentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

NET Notes: Act 5:3 The words “from the sale of” are not in the Greek text, but are supplied to clarify the meaning, since the phrase “proceeds from the...

Geneva Bible: Act 5:3 But Peter said, Ananias, why hath Satan ( b ) filled thine heart ( c ) to lie to the Holy Ghost, and to keep back [part] of the price of the land? ( ...

expand all
Commentary -- Verse Range Notes

TSK Synopsis: Act 5:1-42 - --1 After that Ananias and Sapphira his wife for their hypocrisy, at Peter's rebuke had fallen down dead;12 and that the rest of the apostles had wrough...

Combined Bible: Act 5:3 - --4. " But Peter said, Ananias, why has Satan filled thy heart, to lie to the Holy Spirit, and to keep back part of the price of the land? (4) While i...

MHCC: Act 5:1-11 - --The sin of Ananias and Sapphira was, that they were ambitious of being thought eminent disciples, when they were not true disciples. Hypocrites may de...

Matthew Henry: Act 5:1-11 - -- The chapter begins with a melancholy but, which puts a stop to the pleasant and agreeable prospect of things which we had in the foregoing chapter...

Barclay: Act 5:1-11 - --There is no more vivid story in the book of Acts. There is no need to make a miracle of it. But it does show us something of the atmosphere which pr...

Constable: Act 3:1--6:8 - --B. The expansion of the church in Jerusalem 3:1-6:7 Luke recorded the events of this section (3:1-6:7) t...

Constable: Act 4:32--5:12 - --2. Internal compromise 4:32-5:11 As was true of Israel when she entered Canaan under Joshua's le...

Constable: Act 5:1-11 - --The hypocrisy of Ananias and Sapphira 5:1-11 We might conclude from what precedes that t...

Constable: Act 5:1-6 - --The death of Ananias 5:1-6 5:1-2 "But" introduces another sacrificial act that looked just as generous as Barnabas' (4:37). However in this case the m...

College: Act 5:1-42 - --ACTS 5 3. The Deceit of Ananias and Sapphira (5:1-11) 1 Now a man named Ananias, together with his wife Sapphira, also sold a piece of property. 2 W...

McGarvey: Act 5:3-4 - --3, 4. " But Peter said, Ananias, why has Satan filled thy heart, to lie to the Holy Spirit, and to keep back part of the price of the land? (4) While ...

expand all
Introduction / Outline

Robertson: Acts (Book Introduction) THE ACTS OF THE APOSTLES By Way of Introduction But for the Acts we should know nothing of the early apostolic period save what is told in the Epi...

JFB: Acts (Book Introduction) THIS book is to the Gospels what the fruit is to the tree that bears it. In the Gospels we see the corn of wheat falling into the ground and dying: in...

JFB: Acts (Outline) INTRODUCTION--LAST DAYS OF OUR LORD UPON EARTH--HIS ASCENSION. (Act 1:1-11) RETURN OF THE ELEVEN TO JERUSALEM--PROCEEDINGS IN THE UPPER ROOM TILL PEN...

TSK: Acts (Book Introduction) The Acts of the Apostles is a most valuable portion of Divine revelation; and, independently of its universal reception in the Christian church, as an...

TSK: Acts 5 (Chapter Introduction) Overview Act 5:1, After that Ananias and Sapphira his wife for their hypocrisy, at Peter’s rebuke had fallen down dead; Act 5:12, and that the r...

Poole: Acts 5 (Chapter Introduction) CHAPTER 5

MHCC: Acts (Book Introduction) This book unites the Gospels to the Epistles. It contains many particulars concerning the apostles Peter and Paul, and of the Christian church from th...

MHCC: Acts 5 (Chapter Introduction) (Act 5:1-11) The death of Ananias and Sapphira. (Act 5:12-16) The power which accompanied the preaching of the gospel. (Act 5:17-25) The apostles im...

Matthew Henry: Acts (Book Introduction) An Exposition, with Practical Observations, of The Acts of the Apostles We have with an abundant satisfaction seen the foundation of our holy religion...

Matthew Henry: Acts 5 (Chapter Introduction) In this chapter we have, I. The sin and punishment of Ananias and Sapphira, who, for lying to the Holy Ghost, were struck dead at the word of Pete...

Barclay: Acts (Book Introduction) INTRODUCTION TO THE ACTS OF THE APOSTLES A Precious Book In one sense Acts is the most important book in the New Testament. It is the simple truth t...

Barclay: Acts 5 (Chapter Introduction) Trouble In The Church (Act_5:1-11) The Attraction Of Christianity (Act_5:12-16) Arrest And Trial Once Again (Act_5:17-32) An Unexpected Ally (Act...

Constable: Acts (Book Introduction) Introduction Title The title "Acts of the Apostles" is very ancient. The Anti-Marcioni...

Constable: Acts (Outline) Outline I. The witness in Jerusalem 1:1-6:7 A. The founding of the church 1:1-2:46 ...

Constable: Acts Acts Bibliography Albright, William Foxwell. The Archaeology of Palestine. 1949. Revised ed. Pelican Archaeolog...

Haydock: Acts (Book Introduction) THE ACTS OF THE APOSTLES. INTRODUCTION. St. Luke, who had published his gospel, wrote also a second volume, which, from the first ages, hath bee...

Gill: Acts (Book Introduction) INTRODUCTION TO ACTS This book, in some copies, is called, "The Acts of the holy Apostles". It contains an history of the ministry and miracles of ...

College: Acts (Book Introduction) INTRODUCTION As early as the second century the title "The Acts of the Apostles" was given to this document. Before that time the work probably circu...

College: Acts (Outline) OUTLINE I. THE CHURCH IN JERUSALEM - 1:1-8:1a A. INTRODUCTION OF THE BOOK - 1:1-3 B. THE COMMISSIONING OF THE APOSTLES - 1:4-8 C. THE ASCENSI...

Advanced Commentary (Dictionaries, Hymns, Arts, Sermon Illustration, Question and Answers, etc)


TIP #07: 'Click the Audio icon (NT only) to listen to the NET Bible Audio New Testament.' [ALL]
created in 0.31 seconds
powered by
bible.org - YLSA