
Text -- 1 Chronicles 11:33-47 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: 1Ch 11:41 - -- The last of that catalogue in 2Sa 23:39. But here some others are added to the number, because though they were not of the thirty, yet they were men o...
The last of that catalogue in 2Sa 23:39. But here some others are added to the number, because though they were not of the thirty, yet they were men of great valour and renown amongst David's commanders.

Thirty captains who were under him as their colonel.
JFB: 1Ch 11:39 - -- Armorbearer to Joab (2Sa 23:37). The non-occurrence of Joab's name in any of the three catalogues is most probably to be accounted for by the circumst...
Armorbearer to Joab (2Sa 23:37). The non-occurrence of Joab's name in any of the three catalogues is most probably to be accounted for by the circumstance that his office as commander-in-chief raised him to a position superior to all these orders of military knighthood.

JFB: 1Ch 11:41 - -- The enrolment of this name in such a list, attesting, as it does, his distinguished merits as a brave and devoted officer, aggravates the criminality ...
The enrolment of this name in such a list, attesting, as it does, his distinguished merits as a brave and devoted officer, aggravates the criminality of David's outrage on his life and honor. The number of the names at 1Ch. 11:26-41 (exclusive of Asahel and Uriah, who were dead) is thirty, and at 1Ch 11:41-47 is sixteen--making together forty-eight (see on 1Ch. 27:1-34). Of those mentioned (1Ch. 11:26-41), the greater part belonged to the tribes of Judah and Benjamin; the sixteen names (1Ch 11:41-47) are all associated with places unknown, or with cities and districts on the east of the Jordan. The northern tribes do not appear to have furnished any leaders [BERTHEAU].

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> 1Ch 11:34
Barnes: 1Ch 11:34 - -- The sons of Hashem - It is impossible that this can be the true reading, since an individual warrior must be spoken of. Comparing 2Sa 23:32, pe...
The sons of Hashem - It is impossible that this can be the true reading, since an individual warrior must be spoken of. Comparing 2Sa 23:32, perhaps the most probable conjecture is that the "Beni-Hashem"of Chronicles and the "Beni Jashen"of Samuel alike conceal some single name of a man which cannot now be recovered.
Poole: 1Ch 11:34 - -- Hashem or Jashem , to wit,
Jonathan here following, and Shammah here omitted, but expressed 2Sa 23:32,33 .
Hashem or Jashem , to wit,
Jonathan here following, and Shammah here omitted, but expressed 2Sa 23:32,33 .

Poole: 1Ch 11:38 - -- Joel the brother of Nathan either,
1. The same who is called Jaal the son of Nathan of Zobah , being possibly his brother by birth and nature, and ...
Joel the brother of Nathan either,
1. The same who is called Jaal the son of Nathan of Zobah , being possibly his brother by birth and nature, and called his son by adoption, or right of succession to his estate, or called his brother at large for his near kinsman, and his son for his nephew. Or,
2. Another, who, upon the death of the former, was put in his stead.

Poole: 1Ch 11:41 - -- Uriah the Hittite the last of that catalogue in 2Sa 23:39 . But here some others are added to the number, because though they were not of the thirty,...
Uriah the Hittite the last of that catalogue in 2Sa 23:39 . But here some others are added to the number, because though they were not of the thirty, yet they were men of great valour and renown amongst David’ s commanders.

Thirty captains, who were under him at their colonel

Poole: 1Ch 11:44 - -- The Aroerite so called possibly because his station and quarters were upon the river Aroer beyond Jordan, being placed there for the defence of those...
The Aroerite so called possibly because his station and quarters were upon the river Aroer beyond Jordan, being placed there for the defence of those parts.

Poole: 1Ch 11:46 - -- So called, either because he was by birth a Moabite, though now proselyted to the true religion, or from some eminent service done by him against th...
So called, either because he was by birth a Moabite, though now proselyted to the true religion, or from some eminent service done by him against the Moabites, as among the Romans Scipio was called Asiatic and African, because of his great achievements and victories over those parts and people.
Haydock: 1Ch 11:33 - -- Gezonite. We know not the meaning of this epithet. (Calmet) ---
In 2 Kings, we read of the sons of Jassen, Jonathan, and Semma; (K.) but both s...
Gezonite. We know not the meaning of this epithet. (Calmet) ---
In 2 Kings, we read of the sons of Jassen, Jonathan, and Semma; (K.) but both seem to be incorrect; instead of Septuagint, "the son," or supposing m to be lost, at the beginning, "of the sons of Assem, Gouni," as Septuagint read, instead of Genonite, which would leave this hero without any name. See chap. v. 15. E is prefixed to this name, as it is to that of Manasses, Josue i. 12. ---
Sage, should be Shamha, (Kennicott) or Jonathan, the son of Samaa, the brother of David. He slew the monstrous giant, (chap. xx. 7.) as Sabachai did another. Jonathan is mentioned also along with Asahel (2 Kings xxi.) so that he deserves a place here among David's heroes.

Haydock: 1Ch 11:35 - -- Eliphal should be Eliphelet, the son of Aasgai, the son of Machati, (Haydock) or of the country of Maacha, 4 Kings xxv. 23. (Kennicott) ---
Eliph...
Eliphal should be Eliphelet, the son of Aasgai, the son of Machati, (Haydock) or of the country of Maacha, 4 Kings xxv. 23. (Kennicott) ---
Eliphal and Hepher cannot constitute two heroes, as that would derange the number 37, 2 Kings xxiii. 39. The copies of the Septuagint vary much. (Haydock)

Haydock: 1Ch 11:36 - -- Ahia, or rather "Eliam, the son of Achitophel, the Gilonite," 2 Kings. The name of the hero is lost here; and the latter part of his father's name (...
Ahia, or rather "Eliam, the son of Achitophel, the Gilonite," 2 Kings. The name of the hero is lost here; and the latter part of his father's name ( p ) has also been mistaken for g, which it resembles.

Haydock: 1Ch 11:37 - -- Hesro ends with u in the Hebrew. Yet some read more properly with i, "Hetzrai," as all the ancient versions have it, except the Vulgate, (Kennic...
Hesro ends with u in the Hebrew. Yet some read more properly with i, "Hetzrai," as all the ancient versions have it, except the Vulgate, (Kennicott) some copies of which read Asra. (Blanchini, Vind. 1740.) ---
Carmelite. Septuagint Greek: Karmedi. The Greek D might easily be mistaken for Greek L, as the Greek bibles (Kennicott) for some ages after Origen were written in capital letters, without accents. (Montfaucon, Pref. to Hexap. p. 44.) ---
Azbai seems preferable to Arbi, as the proper name seems also more correct than Pharai, 2 Kings. (Haydock) ---
The Vatican Septuagint confounds both words in one "Ouraiverchi." We may apply to many of the proper names that severe censure which St. Jerome has passed upon the transcribers of the book of Chronicles. Ita in Græcis & Latinis cod: hic nominum liber vitiosus est, ut non tam Hebræa quam Barbara quædam & Sarmatica nomina conjecta arbitrandum eit, &c. (ep. ad Domn.) If this epistle be not genuine, the same doctor complains at least of the incorrect state of the Septuagint. (Pref. in Paral.)

Haydock: 1Ch 11:38 - -- Joel seems better than Igaal, (2 Kings; Haydock) as we know there were some of this name under David, (chap. xxvi. 22., and xxvii. 20.) and all the v...
Joel seems better than Igaal, (2 Kings; Haydock) as we know there were some of this name under David, (chap. xxvi. 22., and xxvii. 20.) and all the versions agree here, but vary much [in] 2 Kings. It is, therefore, more natural for us to adhere to that copy which has the greatest authority from the ancient versions. (Kennicott) ---
Brother, relation, adopted child, (Du Hamel) or son, (2 Kings) which seems more correct, as this is an usual expression. (Calmet) ---
This reason may rather lead us to conclude that the mistake being more natural, has been made by the transcriber of that book; particularly as we no where else read of Joel being the son of Nathan, but rather of Pedaiah, &c. ---
Mibahar, or rather "Nathan of Tzoba." ---
The son, ought to be the proper name, "Bonni, (of Gadi, 2 Kings) or the Gadite." (Kennicott)

Haydock: 1Ch 11:41 - -- Zabad. This name, with the following, is not found [in] 2 Kings, where Elica occurs, though not mentioned here. (Calmet) ---
We have observed that...
Zabad. This name, with the following, is not found [in] 2 Kings, where Elica occurs, though not mentioned here. (Calmet) ---
We have observed that Zabad took his place, and completed the number 37, ver. 27.

Haydock: 1Ch 11:42 - -- With him. Hebrew, "above him," (Septuagint, Junius, Montanus) which must be applied to the rest of these 15 less valiant men. (Kennicott) ---
Prot...
With him. Hebrew, "above him," (Septuagint, Junius, Montanus) which must be applied to the rest of these 15 less valiant men. (Kennicott) ---
Protestants agree with the Vulgate (Haydock) and Delany looks upon these 30 as a forth order of commanders in chief. But 30 with him would take 31, and why are only 15 mentioned? We have a regular gradation of officers, descending from Joab, the captain general. (Kennicott) ---
These heroes are supplementary to those in the Book of Kings, and were stationed (Calmet) on the east of the Jordan, (Du Hamel) in their native country; (Calmet) which is true, at least (Haydock) with respect to several of them. Maacha, Aashtaroth, and Aroer were in these parts, (Josue xiii. 9, 13.; Kennicott) as well as Mathana, Numbers xxi. 18. (Calmet)

Haydock: 1Ch 11:44 - -- Jehiel. The Masorets read so in the margin; but in the text they substitute u for i, improperly. See Septuagint and chap. v. 7, 8.
Jehiel. The Masorets read so in the margin; but in the text they substitute u for i, improperly. See Septuagint and chap. v. 7, 8.

Haydock: 1Ch 11:45 - -- Samri. Protestants, "Shimri," or margin, "the Shimrite," as they deem the expression to be equivalent. But Shimri was rather the father of Jedihel ...
Samri. Protestants, "Shimri," or margin, "the Shimrite," as they deem the expression to be equivalent. But Shimri was rather the father of Jedihel or Jediael, and Joha.

Haydock: 1Ch 11:46 - -- Mahumite. Protestants, "Mahavite." Kennicott would translate these last verses according to his corrections. 42 ..."Zabad, the son of Ahlai; ( 4...
Mahumite. Protestants, "Mahavite." Kennicott would translate these last verses according to his corrections. 42 ..."Zabad, the son of Ahlai; ( 43 ) Adina, the son of Shiza, the Reubenite, and head of the Reubenites: But the thirty were his superiors. 44 Hanan, the son of Maacha; and Josaphat, the Mithnite. 45 Urzia, the Ashtarothite; Shema and Jehiel, the sons of Hotham, the Aroerite. 46 Jediel, the son of Shimri; and Joha, his brother, the Titzite. 47 Jeliel and Mahavite, and Jeribai and Joshaviah, the sons of Elnaam; and Ithmah, the Moabite; ( 48 ) Eliel, and Obed and Jashiel, the Metzobaites." It will be easily perceived that this author frequently recedes from the Protestant version, as well as from the printed Hebrew, both of which are frequently erroneous. Perhaps the critical examination of these proper names, may appear to some unimportant. But the question respecting the perfect integrity of the Hebrew text deserves to be seriously considered; and every part of sacred history requires our attention. If the Protestant rule of faith be incorrect, what security can they have? We are not exposed to the same inconvenience, even though the Vulgate be susceptible of farther improvement. (Haydock)

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> 1Ch 11:1-47
TSK Synopsis: 1Ch 11:1-47 - --1 David by general consent is made king at Hebron.4 He wins the castle of Zion from the Jebusites by Joab's valour.10 A catalogue of David's mighty me...
MHCC -> 1Ch 11:10-47
MHCC: 1Ch 11:10-47 - --An account is given of David's worthies, the great men who served him. Yet David reckoned his success, not as from the mighty men that were with him, ...
Matthew Henry -> 1Ch 11:10-47
Matthew Henry: 1Ch 11:10-47 - -- We have here an account of David's worthies, the great men of his time that served him and were preferred by him. The first edition of this catalogu...
Keil-Delitzsch: 1Ch 11:21-42 - --
1Ch 11:21 should be translated: honoured before the three as two; i.e., doubly honoured-he became to them prince, leader. With regard to בשּׁנ...


Keil-Delitzsch: 1Ch 11:44-45 - --
העשׁתּרתי , he of the city Ashtaroth (1Ch 6:56), in the trans-Jordanic domain of Manasseh. הערערי , he of Aroer, or Reuben or Gad (Jo...

Keil-Delitzsch: 1Ch 11:46 - --
Bertheau conjectures that the somewhat strange המּחוים (lxx ὁ Μαωί , Vulg. Mahumites) denotes המּחנימי , he of Mahanaim, i...

Keil-Delitzsch: 1Ch 11:47 - --
המּצביה , which, so far as the form is concerned, is not a nomen gentil., Reland ( Palaest. ill. p. 899) holds for a contraction of צבעו...
Constable -> 1Ch 10:1--29:30; 1Ch 11:10--13:1
Constable: 1Ch 10:1--29:30 - --II. THE REIGN OF DAVID chs. 10--29
In all of Chronicles the writer assumed his readers' acquaintance with the ot...
