collapse all  

Text -- 1 Chronicles 27:23 (NET)

Strongs On/Off
Context
27:23 David did not count the males twenty years old and under, for the Lord had promised to make Israel as numerous as the stars in the sky.
Parallel   Cross Reference (TSK)   ITL  

Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics

Names, People and Places:
 · David a son of Jesse of Judah; king of Israel,son of Jesse of Judah; king of Israel
 · Israel a citizen of Israel.,a member of the nation of Israel


Dictionary Themes and Topics: Rulers | Joab | Jaresiah | Israel | GENEALOGY, 8 part 2 | DAVID | Chronicles, Books of | Armies | more
Table of Contents

Word/Phrase Notes
Wesley , JFB , TSK

Word/Phrase Notes
Barnes , Poole , Haydock , Gill

Verse Notes / Footnotes


Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis , MHCC , Matthew Henry , Keil-Delitzsch , Constable , Guzik

collapse all
Commentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)

Wesley: 1Ch 27:23 - -- And therefore to number them all both above and under twenty years old, had been both an infinite trouble and a tempting of God, or a questioning the ...

And therefore to number them all both above and under twenty years old, had been both an infinite trouble and a tempting of God, or a questioning the truth of his promises.

JFB: 1Ch 27:23 - -- The census which David ordered did not extend to all the Israelites; for to contemplate such an enumeration would have been to attempt an impossibilit...

The census which David ordered did not extend to all the Israelites; for to contemplate such an enumeration would have been to attempt an impossibility (Gen 28:14), and besides would have been a daring offense to God. The limitation to a certain age was what had probably quieted David's conscience as to the lawfulness of the measure, while its expediency was strongly pressed upon his mind by the army arrangements he had in view.

TSK: 1Ch 27:23 - -- David took not : It seems probable, from this passage, that Joab began, by David’ s order, to number the children, as well as adults, but was pre...

David took not : It seems probable, from this passage, that Joab began, by David’ s order, to number the children, as well as adults, but was prevented from finishing the account, probably because the plague had begun. The numbering of the effective men might have been deemed a political expedient; but pride and ostentation alone could dictate the numbering of minors and infants, especially as God had pronounced the seed of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, innumerable.

from twenty : Num 1:18

he would increase : Gen 15:5; Heb 11:12

collapse all
Commentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)

Barnes: 1Ch 27:23 - -- David’ s numbering of the people was therefore a military arrangement in order to fix the amount of his standing army. To the general Oriental ...

David’ s numbering of the people was therefore a military arrangement in order to fix the amount of his standing army. To the general Oriental prejudice against numbering possessions, etc., there was added in the case of the Jews a special objection - a feeling that it would be irreverent to attempt to count what God had promised should be countless.

Poole: 1Ch 27:23 - -- The meaning is, David, when he desired to number the people, he designed to number only those who were from twenty years old and upward, or (which i...

The meaning is, David, when he desired to number the people, he designed to number only those who were from twenty years old and upward, or (which is the same thing) those that drew sword , 1Ch 21:5 , and not those who were from twenty years old and under .

He would increase Israel like to the stars of the heavens and therefore to number them all both above and under twenty years old, had been both an infinite trouble, and a tempting of God, or a questioning of the truth of his promises. And possibly this circumstance might in part deceive or quiet David’ s conscience, that his desire of knowing the number of his people did not proceed from distrust of God’ s promise or providence, but from a prudent care to know the true state and strength of his kingdom.

Haydock: 1Ch 27:23 - -- Heaven. It would have seemed, therefore, as if David distrusted the divine promise, (Haydock) and attempted what was impossible (Grotius) or useless...

Heaven. It would have seemed, therefore, as if David distrusted the divine promise, (Haydock) and attempted what was impossible (Grotius) or useless. (Calmet) ---

He had before offended, and hence would now only number those who were wanted. (Worthington)

Gill: 1Ch 27:23 - -- But David took not the number of them from twenty years old and under,.... Only those that were twenty years and upwards; but, according to Cornelius ...

But David took not the number of them from twenty years old and under,.... Only those that were twenty years and upwards; but, according to Cornelius Bertram k, he numbered them that were under twenty, though but sixteen, seventeen, eighteen, or nineteen years of age, provided they were of robust bodies, and of a tall stature, and able to bear arms; which he takes to be the sin of David, in numbering the people, being contrary to the law of God; yet though he had ordered them to be numbered, and they were, yet he would not take them and put them into the account of his chronicles, as in the next verse, that his sin might not be known, see 2Sa 24:9.

because the Lord had said, he would increase Israel like to the stars in the heavens; which are not to be numbered, and therefore David sinned in attempting to number the people.

expand all
Commentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

expand all
Commentary -- Verse Range Notes

TSK Synopsis: 1Ch 27:1-34 - --1 The twelve captains for every several month.16 The princes of the twelve tribes.23 The numbering of the people is hindered.25 David's several office...

MHCC: 1Ch 27:16-34 - --The officers of the court, or the rulers of the king's substance, had the oversight and charge of the king's tillage, his vineyards, his herds, his fl...

Matthew Henry: 1Ch 27:16-34 - -- We have here an account, I. Of the princes of the tribes. Something of the ancient order instituted by Moses in the wilderness was still kept up, th...

Keil-Delitzsch: 1Ch 27:23-24 - -- 1Ch 27:23 and 1Ch 27:24 contain a concluding remark on the catalogue of the twelve detachments into which the men capable of bearing arms in Israel ...

Constable: 1Ch 10:1--29:30 - --II. THE REIGN OF DAVID chs. 10--29 In all of Chronicles the writer assumed his readers' acquaintance with the ot...

Constable: 1Ch 17:1--29:30 - --E. God's Covenant Promises to David chs. 17-29 The dominating theme in 1 Chronicles is the Davidic Coven...

Constable: 1Ch 22:1--27:34 - --2. The second account of God's promises to David chs. 22-27 In this section of chapters we have ...

Constable: 1Ch 27:1-34 - --Preparations for governmental order ch. 27 David also organized his army (vv. 1-15), Isr...

Guzik: 1Ch 27:1-34 - --1 Chronicles 27 - Tribal Leaders and Officials of State A. Captains over the army of Israel. 1. (1) The military divisions of Israel. And the chil...

expand all
Introduction / Outline

JFB: 1 Chronicles (Book Introduction) THE FIRST AND SECOND BOOKS OF CHRONICLES were also considered as one by the ancient Jews, who called them "words of days," that is, diaries or journal...

JFB: 1 Chronicles (Outline) ADAM'S LINE TO NOAH. (1Ch. 1:1-23) SHEM'S LINE TO ABRAHAM. (1Ch 1:24-28) SONS OF ISHMAEL. (1Ch 1:29-31) SONS OF KETURAH. (1Ch 1:32-33) POSTERITY OF A...

TSK: 1 Chronicles 27 (Chapter Introduction) Overview 1Ch 27:1, The twelve captains for every several month; 1Ch 27:16, The princes of the twelve tribes; 1Ch 27:23, The numbering of the peopl...

Poole: 1 Chronicles (Book Introduction) FIRST BOOK OF THE CHRONICLES THE ARGUMENT THESE Books of the CHRONICLES are not the same which are so called, 1Ki 14:19 , and elsewhere, (because...

Poole: 1 Chronicles 27 (Chapter Introduction) CHRONICLES CHAPTER 27 The twelve captains for every several month, 1Ch 27:1-15 . The princes of the twelve tribes, 1Ch 27:16-22 . The numbering of ...

MHCC: 1 Chronicles (Book Introduction) The books of Chronicles are, in a great measure, repetitions of what is in the books of Samuel and of the Kings, yet there are some excellent useful t...

MHCC: 1 Chronicles 27 (Chapter Introduction) (1Ch 27:1-15) David's military force. (v. 16-34) Princes and officers.

Matthew Henry: 1 Chronicles (Book Introduction) An Exposition, with Practical Observations, of The First Book of Chronicles In common things repetition is thought needless and nauseous; but, in sacr...

Matthew Henry: 1 Chronicles 27 (Chapter Introduction) In this chapter we have the civil list, including the military, I. The twelve captains for every separate month of the year (1Ch 27:1-15). II. Th...

Constable: 1 Chronicles (Book Introduction) Introduction Title The earliest Hebrew title for the Books of Chronicles translates as...

Constable: 1 Chronicles (Outline) Outline I. Israel's historical roots chs. 1-9 A. The lineage of David chs. 1-3 ...

Constable: 1 Chronicles 1 Chronicles Bibliography Ackroyd, Peter R. I and II Chronicles, Ezra, Nehemiah. London: SCM Press, 1973. ...

Haydock: 1 Chronicles (Book Introduction) THE FIRST BOOK OF PARALIPOMENON. INTRODUCTION. These Books are called by the Greek Interpreters, Paralipomenon; ( Greek: Paraleipomenon, ) tha...

Gill: 1 Chronicles (Book Introduction) INTRODUCTION TO 1 CHRONICLES This and the following book were reckoned by the Jews as one book, as appears by the Masoretic note at the end of the ...

Gill: 1 Chronicles 27 (Chapter Introduction) INTRODUCTION TO 1 CHRONICLES 27 In this chapter we have an account of twelve military courses, or twelve legions of soldiers, with the captains of ...

Advanced Commentary (Dictionaries, Hymns, Arts, Sermon Illustration, Question and Answers, etc)


TIP #34: What tip would you like to see included here? Click "To report a problem/suggestion" on the bottom of page and tell us. [ALL]
created in 0.07 seconds
powered by
bible.org - YLSA