![](images/minus.gif)
Text -- 1 Chronicles 5:1-2 (NET)
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/information.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: 1Ch 5:1 - -- This is added emphatically, because they were treated as if they had been the immediate sons of Jacob.
This is added emphatically, because they were treated as if they had been the immediate sons of Jacob.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: 1Ch 5:1 - -- This is the second reason, which sheweth both why Reuben's genealogy was not first mentioned; and if another tribe was to be ranked before it, why tha...
This is the second reason, which sheweth both why Reuben's genealogy was not first mentioned; and if another tribe was to be ranked before it, why that was Judah, and not Joseph, because the order of their genealogy was not to be ruled by the birthright, but by an higher privilege, which was given to Judah.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Not the person, but the tribe of Judah.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Excelled the other tribes, especially in the following privilege.
JFB -> 1Ch 5:1
JFB: 1Ch 5:1 - -- In proceeding to give this genealogy, the sacred historian states, in a parenthesis (1Ch 5:1-2), the reason why it was not placed first, as Reuben was...
In proceeding to give this genealogy, the sacred historian states, in a parenthesis (1Ch 5:1-2), the reason why it was not placed first, as Reuben was the oldest son of Jacob. The birthright, which by a foul crime he had forfeited, implied not only dominion, but a double portion (Deu 21:17); and both of these were transferred to Joseph, whose two sons having been adopted as the children of Jacob (Gen 48:5), received each an allotted portion, as forming two distinct tribes in Israel. Joseph then was entitled to the precedency; and yet, as his posterity was not mentioned first, the sacred historian judged it necessary to explain that "the genealogy was not to be reckoned after the birthright," but with a reference to a superior honor and privilege that had been conferred on Judah--not the man, but the tribe, whereby it was invested with the pre-eminence over all the other tribes, and out of it was to spring David with his royal lineage, and especially the great Messiah (Heb 7:14). These were the two reasons why, in the order of enumeration, the genealogy of Judah is introduced before that of Reuben.
Clarke: 1Ch 5:1 - -- The sons of Reuben the first-born - As Reuben was the eldest son of Jacob, why was not his genealogy reviewed first? This verse answers the question...
The sons of Reuben the first-born - As Reuben was the eldest son of Jacob, why was not his genealogy reviewed first? This verse answers the question; he lost the birth-right because of the transgression mentioned Gen 35:22; Gen 49:4, and the precedency was given to Judah; from him therefore came the chief ruler. This appears to be the meaning of the place.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: 1Ch 5:2 - -- And of him came the chief ruler - This is, by both the Syriac and Arabic, understood of Christ: "From Judah the King Messiah shall proceed."The Chal...
And of him came the chief ruler - This is, by both the Syriac and Arabic, understood of Christ: "From Judah the King Messiah shall proceed."The Chaldee paraphrases the verse thus: "Seeing Judah prevailed over his brethren, so the kingdom was taken from Reuben and given to Judah; and because he was strong, so was his kingdom. Levi also was godly, and did not transgress in the matter of the golden calf; therefore the high priesthood was taken away from the children of Reuben, and on their account from all the first-born, and given to Aaron and his sons. The custody of the sanctuary belonged to the Levites, but the birthright to Joseph."- T.
Defender -> 1Ch 5:2
Defender: 1Ch 5:2 - -- It had been customary (though never commanded by God) for fathers to leave a double portion of their estate to the eldest son, but Jacob chose to give...
It had been customary (though never commanded by God) for fathers to leave a double portion of their estate to the eldest son, but Jacob chose to give this "birthright" to Joseph instead of Reuben because of Reuben's act of incest and because of Joseph's faithfulness. However, God inspired Jacob to predict that the "sceptre" of the family would go to Judah, probably because of his willingness to die for his younger brother (see notes on Gen 49:3, Gen 49:4, Gen 49:10)."
TSK: 1Ch 5:1 - -- am 2294, etc. bc 1710, etc
he was : 1Ch 2:1; Gen 29:32, Gen 46:8, Gen 49:3; Exo 6:14; Num 1:5, Num 16:1, Num 26:5
forasmuch : Gen 35:22, Gen 49:4; Lev...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
TSK: 1Ch 5:2 - -- Judah : Gen 35:23, Gen 49:8-10; Num 2:3, Num 7:12; Jos 14:6; Jdg 1:2; Psa 60:7, Psa 108:8; Mic 5:2; Mat 2:6; Heb 7:14; Rev 5:5
the chief ruler : or, t...
Judah : Gen 35:23, Gen 49:8-10; Num 2:3, Num 7:12; Jos 14:6; Jdg 1:2; Psa 60:7, Psa 108:8; Mic 5:2; Mat 2:6; Heb 7:14; Rev 5:5
the chief ruler : or, the prince, By the chief ruler is meant first David, and after him the Messiah, agreeably to the celebrated prophecy of Jacob (Gen 49:10). The Syriac calls him ""Christ the king,""and the Arabic, ""Messiah the king.""1Sa 16:1, 1Sa 16:10, 1Sa 16:12; 2Sa 8:15; Psa 78:68-71; Jer 23:5, Jer 23:6; Mic 5:2; Mat 2:6; Heb 7:14
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> 1Ch 5:1
Barnes: 1Ch 5:1 - -- His birthright was given ... - In particular, the right of the first-born to a double inheritance Deu 21:17 was conferred on Joseph, both by th...
His birthright was given ... - In particular, the right of the first-born to a double inheritance Deu 21:17 was conferred on Joseph, both by the expressed will of Jacob Gen 48:22 and in the actual partition of Canaan Josh. 16\endash 17. But though the birthright, as respecting its material privileges, passed to Joseph, its other rights, those of dignity and pre-eminence, fell to Judah; of whom came the chief ruler, an allusion especially to David, though it may reach further, and include a glance at the Messiah, the true "Ruler"of Israel Mic 5:2.
Poole: 1Ch 5:1 - -- For he was the first-born: these and the following words 1Ch 5:3 , which are enclosed within a parenthesis, seem to be inserted here as an answer to...
For he was the first-born: these and the following words 1Ch 5:3 , which are enclosed within a parenthesis, seem to be inserted here as an answer to a secret objection, or as a reason why Reuben’ s genealogy was not set down first, but Judah’ s was put before it, which is double; the first follows immediately, the other is in the last clause of this verse. His birthright i.e. the right of the first-born, which, although it contain in it something of dominion, Gen 27:1,32 , which Joseph had in his own person, Ge 49 ; yet principally consisted in having a double portion, as appears from Deu 21:17 , which Joseph enjoyed both in his person and in his posterity, which had two parts of twelve in Canaan. And it is Joseph’ s posterity which is here considered.
Unto the sons of Joseph Ephraim and Manasseh, each having a distinct portion.
The sons of Israel: this is added emphatically, because they were reputed and treated as if they had been the immediate sons of Jacob; of which see Gen 48:5 .
The genealogy is not to be reckoned after the birthright: this is the second reason, which showeth both why Reuben’ s genealogy was not first mentioned; and if another tribe was to be ranked before it, why that was Judah, and not Joseph, as it might seem most fit for the former reason; because, saith he, the order of their genealogy was not to be ruled by the birthright but by a higher privilege, which was given to Judah, and which here follows.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: 1Ch 5:2 - -- Judah; not the person, (for so Joseph prevailed,) but the tribe of Judah.
Prevailed above his brethren excelled the other tribes in number and pow...
Judah; not the person, (for so Joseph prevailed,) but the tribe of Judah.
Prevailed above his brethren excelled the other tribes in number and power, and especially in the following privilege.
And of him or for of him , as the Hebrew vau is oft used; this being a reason of the foregoing assertion, or a declaration wherein he did prevail.
Came the chief ruler the government was by God’ s promise and appointment to be seated chiefly and most durably in that tribe, first in David and his successors, and then in the Messiah, who sprang out of Judah , Heb 7:14 , which was a far greater privilege than the birthright. Or, as to the ruler, (i.e. as to the point of dominion,) he was more than he , or preferred before him , i.e. before Joseph, who is named in the very next clause, the pronoun being referred unto the following noun, which is frequent among the Hebrews, as Psa 87:1 105:19 .
But the birthright or,
although as vau is oft used; so this prevents or removes an objection against Judah’ s precedency taken from his birthright.
Haydock: 1Ch 5:1 - -- First-born, Genesis xlix. 4. (Worthington) ---
He gives this reason for not beginning with him. (Calmet) ---
And he. Protestants, "and the gene...
First-born, Genesis xlix. 4. (Worthington) ---
He gives this reason for not beginning with him. (Calmet) ---
And he. Protestants, "and the genealogy is not to be reckoned after the birth-right." (Haydock)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Haydock: 1Ch 5:2 - -- Accounted to Joseph, viz., as to the double portion, which belonged to the first-born: but the princely dignity was given to Juda, and the priesthood...
Accounted to Joseph, viz., as to the double portion, which belonged to the first-born: but the princely dignity was given to Juda, and the priesthood to Levi. (Challoner) ---
Yet it is not certain that the latter dignity formed a part of the birth-right, (Genesis xxv. 31.) and the author takes no notice of it. (Calmet) ---
The double portion seems to have been all the privilege, Deuteronomy xxi. 17. Septuagint, "the blessing or gift was Joseph's." Hebrew also does not specify princes, but "the leader," (Haydock) the Messias, (Syriac, &c.) and kings, from David till the captivity. (Calmet) (Genesis xlix. 4.) (Worthington)
Gill: 1Ch 5:1 - -- Now the sons of Reuben, the firstborn of Israel,.... Are as follow in 1Ch 5:3 where the account begins; for what comes between this and that is in a p...
Now the sons of Reuben, the firstborn of Israel,.... Are as follow in 1Ch 5:3 where the account begins; for what comes between this and that is in a parenthesis:
for he was the firstborn; of Jacob by his wife Leah; that must be owned, and Jacob allows it, Gen 49:3 and yet the genealogy in this book begins not with him, as might on that account be expected; the reason follows:
but forasmuch as he defiled his father's bed: by lying with Bilhah his concubine:
his birthright was given unto the sons of Joseph the son of Israel; his beloved son by his beloved wife Rachel and so had a double portion given him; his two sons being equally ranked with the other sons of Jacob, and became distinct tribes, and each had their lot in the land of Canaan, see Gen 48:5 compared with Deu 21:17.
and the genealogy is not to be reckoned after the birthright; or, "but the genealogy", &c. o; neither after the birthright of Reuben, which he had by nature, being Jacob's firstborn; nor after the birthright of Joseph, which be had by his father's gift, as it might be thought it should; the reason of which follows.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: 1Ch 5:2 - -- For Judah prevailed above his brethren,.... That is, the tribe of Judah prevailed above the rest in number, in valour, and courage, and in dignity; wh...
For Judah prevailed above his brethren,.... That is, the tribe of Judah prevailed above the rest in number, in valour, and courage, and in dignity; wherefore the genealogy is not reckoned according to birthright, but dignity and dominion; hence this genealogical account began with Judah:
because of him came the chief ruler; David and the kings of Judah, his successors; and above all, from him the Prince Messiah was to spring, and did, according to Gen 49:10 so both the Syriac and Arabic versions read,"out of Judah should go forth the King Messiah:"
but the birthright was Joseph's or "though" p it was; yet Judah having the dominion and dignity, that tribe is first genealogized.
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes: 1Ch 5:1 Heb “and not to be listed in the genealogical records as (having) the right of the firstborn.”
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: 1Ch 5:2 Heb “and [one] for a leader [was] from him.” This probably refers to the Davidic king.
Geneva Bible: 1Ch 5:1 Now the sons of Reuben the firstborn of Israel, (for he [was] the firstborn; but, forasmuch as he defiled his father's bed, his birthright was given u...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Geneva Bible: 1Ch 5:2 For Judah prevailed above his brethren, and of him [came] ( b ) the chief ruler; but the birthright [was] Joseph's:)
( b ) That is, he was the chiefe...
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> 1Ch 5:1-26
TSK Synopsis: 1Ch 5:1-26 - --1 Judah and Joseph preferred before Reuben, who forfeited his birthright.3 Ruben's descendants; some of whom vanquish the Hagarites.11 The chief men o...
MHCC -> 1Ch 5:1-26
MHCC: 1Ch 5:1-26 - --This chapter gives some account of the two tribes and a half seated on the east side of Jordan. They were made captives by the king of Assyria, becaus...
Matthew Henry -> 1Ch 5:1-17
Matthew Henry: 1Ch 5:1-17 - -- We have here an extract out of the genealogies, I. Of the tribe of Reuben, where we have, 1. The reason why this tribe is thus postponed. It is conf...
Keil-Delitzsch -> 1Ch 5:1-3
Keil-Delitzsch: 1Ch 5:1-3 - --
The families of the tribe of Reuben. - 1Ch 5:1, 1Ch 5:2. Reuben is called the first-born of Israel, because he was the first-born of Jacob, although...
Constable: 1Ch 1:1--9:44 - --I. ISRAEL'S HISTORICAL ROOTS chs. 1--9
"The fact that the author of 1 and 2 Chronicles devoted nine chapters out...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: 1Ch 4:1--7:40 - --B. The House of Israel chs. 4-7
The writer's next concern was to trace the line of people to whom and th...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)