
Text -- 1 Chronicles 8:1-9 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley -> 1Ch 8:6
Wesley: 1Ch 8:6 - -- These following, 1Ch 8:7, because he here speaks of them who were removed. He describes the sons of Benjamin by the places of their habitation, withou...
These following, 1Ch 8:7, because he here speaks of them who were removed. He describes the sons of Benjamin by the places of their habitation, without an exact account of their parents; because their genealogies were broken by that almost total extirpation of this tribe, Jdg. 20:29-48.
JFB: 1Ch 8:1 - -- This chapter contains some supplementary particulars in addition to what has been already said regarding the tribe of Benjamin (see on 1Ch 7:6). The n...
This chapter contains some supplementary particulars in addition to what has been already said regarding the tribe of Benjamin (see on 1Ch 7:6). The names of many of the persons mentioned are different from those given by Moses--a diversity which may be accounted for in part on grounds formerly stated, namely, either that the persons had more than one name, or that the word "sons" is used in a loose sense for grandsons or descendants. But there are other circumstances to be taken into account in considering the details of this chapter; namely, first, that the genealogies of the Benjamites were disordered or destroyed by the almost total extermination of this tribe (Jdg. 20:11-48); secondly, that a great number of Benjamites, born in Assyria, are mentioned here, who returned from the long captivity in Babylon, and established themselves--some in Jerusalem, others in different parts of Judea. There were more returned from Babylon of the families belonging to this tribe than to any other except Judah; and hence many strange names are here introduced; some of which will be found in the list of the restored exiles (compare Ezra 2:1-70).

JFB: 1Ch 8:6 - -- Most probably the judge of Israel (Jdg 3:15). His descendants, who had at first been established in Geba in Benjamin, emigrated in a body under the di...

JFB: 1Ch 8:8 - -- He had probably been driven to take refuge in that foreign land on the same calamitous occasion that forced Elimelech to emigrate thither (Rth 1:1). B...
He had probably been driven to take refuge in that foreign land on the same calamitous occasion that forced Elimelech to emigrate thither (Rth 1:1). But, destitute of natural affection, he forsook or divorced his two wives, and in the land of his sojourn married a third, by whom he had several sons. But there is another explanation given of the conduct of this Benjamite polygamist. His children by Hushim are mentioned (1Ch 8:11), while his other wife is unnoticed. Hence it has been thought probable that it is Baara who is mentioned under the name of Hodesh, so called because her husband, after long desertion, returned and cohabited with her as before.
Clarke: 1Ch 8:1 - -- Now Benjamin begat, etc. - See what has been said on the preceding chapter, 1Ch 7:6 (note).
Now Benjamin begat, etc. - See what has been said on the preceding chapter, 1Ch 7:6 (note).

Clarke: 1Ch 8:9 - -- He begat of Hodesh his wife - In the preceding verse it is said that Hushim and Baara were his wives; and here it is said he begat of Hodesh his wif...
He begat of Hodesh his wife - In the preceding verse it is said that Hushim and Baara were his wives; and here it is said he begat of Hodesh his wife, etc. And then his children by Hushim are mentioned, but not a word of Baara! It is likely therefore that Hodesh was another name for Baara, and this is asserted by the Targum: And he begot of Baara, that is Chodesh, his wife; so called because he espoused her anew. It is supposed that he had put her away before, and now remarried her.
Bela : 1Ch 7:6-12; Gen 46:21
Aharah : Num 26:38, Ahiram

TSK: 1Ch 8:3 - -- Addar : The variation in this name is occasioned simply by the transposition of a ד , daleth and ר , raish ; being in the parallel passage ...

TSK: 1Ch 8:5 - -- Gera : Jdg 3:15
Shephuphan : שׁפם [Strong’ s H8206], Shuppim , seems to be merely a contracted form of שׁפופם [Strong’ s H8197...
Gera : Jdg 3:15
Shephuphan :
Huram : Huram appears to be an error for Hupham in the parallel passage of Numbers, which, by contraction, is written Huppim.

TSK: 1Ch 8:6 - -- Ehud : 1Ch 7:10; Jdg 3:20-30, Jdg 4:1, Gera, Gen 46:21
Geba : 1Ch 6:60
Manahath : 1Ch 2:25, 1Ch 2:54

TSK: 1Ch 8:9 - -- Hodesh : In the preceding verse it is said that ""Hushim and Baara were his wives;""and here it said, ""he begat of Hodesh his wife,""etc; and then in...
Hodesh : In the preceding verse it is said that ""Hushim and Baara were his wives;""and here it said, ""he begat of Hodesh his wife,""etc; and then in the 1Ch 8:11, his children by Hushim are mentioned, but not a word of Baara. It is probable, therefore, that Hodesh was another name for Baara; and this is asserted by the Targumist: ""And he begat of Baara, that is, of Chodesh, his wife, so called because he espoused her anew.""

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes: 1Ch 8:1 - -- The reason of this return to the genealogy of the Benjamites seems to be the desire to connect the genealogical introduction with the historical bod...
The reason of this return to the genealogy of the Benjamites seems to be the desire to connect the genealogical introduction with the historical body of the work. As the history is to begin with Saul, the genealogical portion is made to end with an account of the family of this Benjamite monarch.

Barnes: 1Ch 8:6 - -- And they removed them to Manahath - " They"has no antecedent; and it is difficult to supply one. Almost all commentators suppose that there has ...
And they removed them to Manahath - " They"has no antecedent; and it is difficult to supply one. Almost all commentators suppose that there has been some corruption here, from which, however, we may gather that the "sons of Ehud"(or, perhaps, of Ahoah, 1Ch 8:4) were originally settled at Geba (Jos 18:24 note), but afterward removed to a place called Manahath, probably a town in the vicinity. Gera 1Ch 8:7 directed the movement.

Barnes: 1Ch 8:8 - -- After he had sent them away - Translate it: "after he had divorced his wives, Hushim and Baara."
After he had sent them away - Translate it: "after he had divorced his wives, Hushim and Baara."
Poole: 1Ch 8:1 - -- Bela so called by Moses: but the names of the rest vary from those in Moses; either because the same person had two several names, as hath been often...
Bela so called by Moses: but the names of the rest vary from those in Moses; either because the same person had two several names, as hath been often noted; or because these were not the immediate sons of Benjamin, but his grandchildren, here mentioned in their parents’ stead, possibly because they were more eminent than their parents.

Poole: 1Ch 8:6 - -- These are the sons either those three last mentioned; or rather these following, 1Ch 8:7 , because he here speaks of them who were removed, and they ...
These are the sons either those three last mentioned; or rather these following, 1Ch 8:7 , because he here speaks of them who were removed, and they are said to be removed, 1Ch 8:7
He describes the sons of Benjamin by the places of their habitation, without an exact account of their parents, because their genealogies were broken by that almost total extirpation of this tribe, Jud 20 .
They removed them either their fathers, or their heads and superiors, removed them; or they removed themselves; either because they were too numerous for that place, or because they desired to change their habitation, and hoped it would be for the better, and judged Manahath a more convenient place.

Poole: 1Ch 8:7 - -- He removed them either,
1. Their father; or,
2. Gera last mentioned, who, it seems, was the chief counsellor or promoter of this work.
Begat Uzza ...
He removed them either,
1. Their father; or,
2. Gera last mentioned, who, it seems, was the chief counsellor or promoter of this work.
Begat Uzza and Ahihud when he was seated in Manahath.

Poole: 1Ch 8:8 - -- In the country of Moab whither he had removed himself, either at the same time when Elimelech did, Rth 1:1 , &c., or upon the same or like occasion. ...
In the country of Moab whither he had removed himself, either at the same time when Elimelech did, Rth 1:1 , &c., or upon the same or like occasion.
After he had sent them away Ehud or Gera last mentioned.
Hushim and Baara were his wives: others join these words with the former, and render the place thus, after he had sent them (to wit, his sons) away , with Hushim and Baara his wives , i.e. as he also sent his wives away from him; which may be here mentioned as a brand upon him, to show that he was without natural affection to his wives and children. And it seems the more probable that he divorced them, because we find him married to another wife, 1Ch 8:9 .
Haydock: 1Ch 8:1 - -- Archers, particularly the natives of Gabaa, Judges xx. 16. Jonathan is praised for his skill, 2 Kings i. 22. (Menochius) ---
Benjamin. We might ...
Archers, particularly the natives of Gabaa, Judges xx. 16. Jonathan is praised for his skill, 2 Kings i. 22. (Menochius) ---
Benjamin. We might hence conclude that here ended the genealogy of that family. Yet we find it partly repeated in the following chapter, ver. 35. (Haydock)

Haydock: 1Ch 8:1 - -- Benjamin. Some farther particulars of his genealogy are given, for the honour of Saul; (Calmet) and many of these, who returned from captivity, are ...
Benjamin. Some farther particulars of his genealogy are given, for the honour of Saul; (Calmet) and many of these, who returned from captivity, are mentioned, 1 Esdras x. 11. (Sanctius) ---
Bale, &c., are called Bela, (Menochius; chap. vii. 6.) Jadiel, and Ahiram, or Echi, Numbers xxvi. 36., and Genesis xlvi.

Nohaa is probably styled Bechor; and Rapha, Ros, in Genesis.

Haydock: 1Ch 8:6 - -- Ahod, the judge, Judges iii. 15. ---
Manahath; the Menuchat, in the tribe of Juda, (chap. ii. 54.) after the captivity. (Calmet) ---
Abulensis th...
Ahod, the judge, Judges iii. 15. ---
Manahath; the Menuchat, in the tribe of Juda, (chap. ii. 54.) after the captivity. (Calmet) ---
Abulensis thinks Manahath was in Moab, ver. 8. (Menochius)

Haydock: 1Ch 8:7 - -- And. Literally, "but," autem. (Haydock) ---
The sentence is clearer without this particle. (Menochius) ---
Naaman was the first-born of Ahod;...
And. Literally, "but," autem. (Haydock) ---
The sentence is clearer without this particle. (Menochius) ---
Naaman was the first-born of Ahod; and Gera prevailed on his brethren to leave Gabaa, (Tirinus) and was probably the father of Oza. (Calmet)

Haydock: 1Ch 8:8 - -- Saharim. His father is not specified: but his was a Benjamite. (Menochius) ---
Some force the Hebrew text to say that Ahod had three sons, whom he...
Saharim. His father is not specified: but his was a Benjamite. (Menochius) ---
Some force the Hebrew text to say that Ahod had three sons, whom he sent to form a colony at Manahath, and afterwards he had three others by his two wives, and at last, by Rodes, he had Jobab, &c. (Calmet) ---
Begot. Protestants, " children in the country of Moab, after he had sent them away: Hushim and Baara were his wives." But the Septuagint intimate, that "Saharim begot....after he had sent away Osim, and his wife Baara, and he begot of Ada," &c. (Haydock) ---
He had perhaps retired into Moab, at the same time as Elimelech, Ruth i. (Tirinus) ---
Those who were sent away were men, ( eos ) according to the Hebrew, unless (Haydock) the word should be eas . (Du Hamel)
Gill: 1Ch 8:1 - -- Now Benjamin begat Bela his firstborn,.... See 1Ch 7:6. The genealogy of the tribe of Benjamin is reviewed, because it joined and kept close with Juda...
Now Benjamin begat Bela his firstborn,.... See 1Ch 7:6. The genealogy of the tribe of Benjamin is reviewed, because it joined and kept close with Judah in the worship of God, went into captivity, and returned out of it with it; and this review is made chiefly for the sake of Saul, and his posterity, the first king of Israel, who was of it, and in whose posterity this genealogy ends:
Ashbel the second; supposed to be the same with Jediael, 1Ch 7:6, see Gen 46:21.
and Aharah the third; the same with Aher, 1Ch 7:13, and with Ahiram, Num 26:38.

Gill: 1Ch 8:2 - -- Nohah the fourth, and Rapha the fifth. Nohah is supposed by some to be the same with Becher, 1Ch 7:6 and by others with Naaman, Gen 46:21, as Rapha, t...

Gill: 1Ch 8:3 - -- The sons of Bela were Addar, and Gera, and Abihud. The first of these is thought to be the same with Ard, mentioned among the sons of Benjamin, Gen 46...

Gill: 1Ch 8:4-5 - -- And Abishua, and Naaman, and Ahoah, and Gera, and Shephuphan, and Huram. These were all the sons of Bela; one of the name of Naaman is reckoned among ...
And Abishua, and Naaman, and Ahoah, and Gera, and Shephuphan, and Huram. These were all the sons of Bela; one of the name of Naaman is reckoned among the sons of Benjamin, Gen 46:21 and from this grandson the family of the Naamanites are named, Num 26:40, and Ahoah is by some thought to be the same with Ehi, mentioned in Gen 46:21 as one of Benjamin's sons. Some take the three last to be the sons of Ehud, spoken of in the next verse; but Shephuphan and Huram seem to be the same with Shupham and Hupham, Num 26:39.

Gill: 1Ch 8:6 - -- And these are the sons of Ehud,.... Not he that was a judge in Israel, Jdg 3:15 but perhaps a son of Huram the last mentioned; for not the three last ...
And these are the sons of Ehud,.... Not he that was a judge in Israel, Jdg 3:15 but perhaps a son of Huram the last mentioned; for not the three last are his sons, as some think, but the three following in the next verse; what follows being to be read in a parenthesis:
(these are the heads of the fathers of the inhabitants of Geba;) a city in the tribe of Benjamin, Jos 18:24 namely, those sons of Ehud, after mentioned, were principal men in that tribe, and chief of the inhabitants of the city of Geba:
and they removed them to Manahath; the name of a country referred to in 1Ch 2:52 according to Jarchi, which was in the tribe of Judah; Geba being too small, either the inhabitants of Geba removed them, or they removed themselves, or their fathers removed them, 1Ch 8:7, or it may be read impersonally, they were removed thither for the sake of a better habitation; the Targum adds,"to the land of the house of Esau,''to Edom; which is not likely.

Gill: 1Ch 8:7 - -- And Naaman, and Ahiah, and Gera,.... Or, to wit, Naaman, &c. so the words are to be connected with
these are the sons or Ehud, in the preceding ver...
And Naaman, and Ahiah, and Gera,.... Or, to wit, Naaman, &c. so the words are to be connected with
these are the sons or Ehud, in the preceding verse:
he removed them; to the above place, that is, either Gera, or rather Ehud, he advised them, directed and enjoined them to go thither, as being most convenient for them:
and he begat Uzza and Ahihud; after he had removed his other sons.

Gill: 1Ch 8:8 - -- And Shaharaim,.... Who was either a son of Ahihud, or rather a brother of his, another son of Ehud:
begat children in the country of Moab; whither ...
And Shaharaim,.... Who was either a son of Ahihud, or rather a brother of his, another son of Ehud:
begat children in the country of Moab; whither he might go on account of the famine, as Elimelech did, Rth 1:1, after he had sent them away; which some understand of those that were removed from Geba to Manahath, 1Ch 8:6, but a different word is here used; and besides Shaharaim seems to be one of those that were removed. Kimchi takes Shilhootham, we render "had sent them away", to be the name of his first wife, of whom he begat children in Moab; but it seems best to render and interpret the words in connection with what follows: he begat children in Moab:
after he had sent them away; even Hushim and Baara his wives; after he had divorced them, for some reasons he had, he begat children of another wife, later mentioned.

Gill: 1Ch 8:9 - -- And he begat of Hodesh his wife,.... That is, he, I say, begat, namely, Shaharaim; the Targum makes this Hodesh to be the same with Baara, called so b...
And he begat of Hodesh his wife,.... That is, he, I say, begat, namely, Shaharaim; the Targum makes this Hodesh to be the same with Baara, called so because she was newly espoused; but wrongly: the sons begotten of her were the seven following;
Jobab, Zibia, Mesha, Malcham, Jeuz, Shachia, and Mirma. These were his sons; the sons of Shaharaim by his wife Hodesh:
heads of the fathers; of the houses or families of their father.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

Geneva Bible: 1Ch 8:1 Now Benjamin ( a ) begat Bela his firstborn, Ashbel the second, and Aharah the third,
( a ) He continues in the description of the tribe of Benjamin,...

Geneva Bible: 1Ch 8:6 And these [are] the sons of Ehud: these are the heads of the fathers of the inhabitants of Geba, and ( b ) they removed them to Manahath:
( b ) Meani...

Geneva Bible: 1Ch 8:7 And Naaman, and Ahiah, and Gera, he removed them, and ( c ) begat Uzza, and Ahihud.
( c ) That is, Ehud.

Geneva Bible: 1Ch 8:8 And Shaharaim begat [children] in the country of Moab, after he had sent them ( d ) away; Hushim and Baara [were] his wives.
( d ) After he had put a...

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> 1Ch 8:1-40
TSK Synopsis: 1Ch 8:1-40 - --1 The sons and chief men of Benjamin.33 The stock of Saul and Jonathan.
MHCC -> 1Ch 8:1-40
MHCC: 1Ch 8:1-40 - --Here is a larger list of Benjamin's tribe. We may suppose that many things in these genealogies, which to us seem difficult, abrupt, and perplexed, we...
Matthew Henry -> 1Ch 8:1-32
Matthew Henry: 1Ch 8:1-32 - -- There is little or nothing of history in all these verses; we have not therefore much to observe. 1. As to the difficulties that occur in this and t...
Keil-Delitzsch: 1Ch 8:1-5 - --
The families of Benjamin enumerated in this chapter were probably separated from those in 1Ch 7:6-11, merely on the ground that all the registers wh...

Keil-Delitzsch: 1Ch 8:6-7 - --
Sons of Ehud. - The descent of Ehud from the sons, grandsons, and descendants of Benjamin, enumerated in 1Ch 8:1-5, is not given. The names of Ehud...

Keil-Delitzsch: 1Ch 8:8-12 - --
The descendants of Shaharaim. - The descent of Shaharaim from the sons and grandsons named in 1Ch 8:1-3 is obscure, and the conjecture which connec...
Constable -> 1Ch 1:1--9:44; 1Ch 8:1--9:44
Constable: 1Ch 1:1--9:44 - --I. ISRAEL'S HISTORICAL ROOTS chs. 1--9
"The fact that the author of 1 and 2 Chronicles devoted nine chapters out...
