
Text -- 1 Kings 2:42-46 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: 1Ki 2:44 - -- For which thine own conscience accuseth thee, and there is no need of other witnesses.
For which thine own conscience accuseth thee, and there is no need of other witnesses.

Wesley: 1Ki 2:44 - -- God hath punished thee for thy former wickedness, by suffering thee to expose thyself to thy deserved death.
God hath punished thee for thy former wickedness, by suffering thee to expose thyself to thy deserved death.
JFB -> 1Ki 2:46
JFB: 1Ki 2:46 - -- Now, by the death of Shimei, all the leaders of the rival factions had been cut off.
Now, by the death of Shimei, all the leaders of the rival factions had been cut off.
Clarke: 1Ki 2:45 - -- King Solomon shall be blessed - He seems to think that, while such bad men remained unpunished, the nation could not prosper; that it was an act of ...
King Solomon shall be blessed - He seems to think that, while such bad men remained unpunished, the nation could not prosper; that it was an act of justice which God required him to perform, in order to the establishment and perpetuity of his throne.

Clarke: 1Ki 2:46 - -- And the kingdom was established - He had neither foes within nor without. He was either dreaded or loved universally. His own subjects were affectio...
And the kingdom was established - He had neither foes within nor without. He was either dreaded or loved universally. His own subjects were affectionately bound to him, and the surrounding nations did not think proper to make him their enemy
As there are serious doubts relative to the dying charge of David as it relates to Shimei, most believing that, in opposition to his own oath, David desired that Solomon should put him to death; I shall here insert Dr. Kennicott’ s criticism on this part of the text: -
"David is here represented in our English version as finishing his life with giving a command to Solomon to kill Shimei, and to kill him on account of that very crime for which, as David here says, he had sworn to him by the Lord he would not put him to death. The behavior thus imputed to the king and prophet, and which would be justly censurable if true, should be examined very carefully as to the ground it stands upon; and when the passage is duly considered, I presume it will appear highly probable that an injury has been here done to this illustrious character. The point to which I now beg the reader’ s attention is this: That it is not uncommon in the Hebrew language to omit the negative in a second part of the sentence, and to consider it as repeated, when it has been once expressed, and is followed by the connecting particle. And thus on Isa 13:22 the late learned annotator says: ‘ The negative is repeated or referred to by the conjunction
Did I not : 1Ki 2:36-38; Psa 15:4; Luk 19:22
and thou saidst : Luk 15:22


TSK: 1Ki 2:44 - -- Thou knowest : 2Sa 16:5-13; Joh 8:9; Rom 2:15; 1Jo 3:20
return : 1Ki 2:32, 1Ki 2:33; Psa 7:16; Pro 5:22; Eze 17:19; Hos 4:9 *marg.

TSK: 1Ki 2:45 - -- blessed : Psa 21:6, Psa 72:17
the throne : 1Ki 2:24, 1Ki 2:33, 1Ki 2:34; Pro 25:5; Isa 9:6, Isa 9:7

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> 1Ki 2:42
Barnes: 1Ki 2:42 - -- Did I not make thee to swear - The Septuagint add to 1Ki 2:37 a clause stating that Solomon "made Shimei swear"on the day when he commanded him...
Did I not make thee to swear - The Septuagint add to 1Ki 2:37 a clause stating that Solomon "made Shimei swear"on the day when he commanded him to reside at Jerusalem.
Poole: 1Ki 2:43 - -- He was guilty both of rebellion against the express, and just, and (as himself called it) good command of the king, and of perjury against God; whic...
He was guilty both of rebellion against the express, and just, and (as himself called it) good command of the king, and of perjury against God; which were two high and heinous crimes. His oath he calls
the oath of the Lord because it was taken in God’ s presence, and he was called upon as a witness of it, and as the avenger of all violations of it, and because the law of God obliged him to the performance of it.

Poole: 1Ki 2:44 - -- Thou knowest all the wickedness which thine heart is privy to for which thy own conscience accuseth thee, and there is no need of other witnesses.
S...
Thou knowest all the wickedness which thine heart is privy to for which thy own conscience accuseth thee, and there is no need of other witnesses.
Shall return Heb. hath returned , which seems most proper. God hath punished thee for thy former wickedness, by suffering thee to fall into further crimes, and expose thyself to thy deserved death.

Poole: 1Ki 2:45 - -- The throne of David that royal power and dignity conferred upon David to him and his heirs for ever.
Shall be established by the execution of such ...
The throne of David that royal power and dignity conferred upon David to him and his heirs for ever.
Shall be established by the execution of such righteous judgments as this is.
Before the Lord in the presence of that God who is both an observer and rewarder of all such righteous actions; or under God’ s inspection, and by his blessing.

Poole: 1Ki 2:46 - -- Which went out carrying Shimei along with him to the place of execution, which was not fit to be in the king’ s presence.
The kingdom was estab...
Which went out carrying Shimei along with him to the place of execution, which was not fit to be in the king’ s presence.
The kingdom was established in the hand of Solomon his secret and worst enemies being taken out of the way.
Gill: 1Ki 2:42 - -- And the king sent and called for Shimei,.... He sent messengers to him, and by them ordered him to come to him, who accordingly came:
and he said u...
And the king sent and called for Shimei,.... He sent messengers to him, and by them ordered him to come to him, who accordingly came:
and he said unto him, did not I make thee swear by the Lord; which, though not before mentioned, was no doubt done, nor did Shimei deny it:
and protested unto thee; that is, declared before witnesses:
saying, know for certain, that on the day thou goest out; namely, out of the city of Jerusalem:
and walkest abroad any whither; further at most than the brook Kidron, or any other place equally distant from Jerusalem, on any side of it; for when he went to Gath, he did not go over Kidron, but went the road the other way around. Kidron lay to the east, and Gath to the west of Jerusalem: now the protestation made to him was, that if he went out of Jerusalem any way,
that thou shalt surely die; it would be sure and certain death to him:
and thou saidst unto me, the word that I have heard is good; not only he promised to obey it, and that with an oath, but declared it was agreeable and acceptable to him, and therefore the offence was a very aggravated one.

Gill: 1Ki 2:43 - -- Why then hast thou not kept the oath of the Lord,.... Which was made by him, and in his presence, and in which he was appealed to, and so by not keepi...
Why then hast thou not kept the oath of the Lord,.... Which was made by him, and in his presence, and in which he was appealed to, and so by not keeping it was guilty of perjury:
and the commandment that I have charged thee with? and so guilty of disobedience to him as his sovereign; for which two reasons he ought to die.

Gill: 1Ki 2:44 - -- The king said moreover to Shimei,.... Not as another reason for his putting him to death, but to remind him of his former sins, and to observe to him ...
The king said moreover to Shimei,.... Not as another reason for his putting him to death, but to remind him of his former sins, and to observe to him the providence of God in suffering him to fall into others, that justice might take place upon him for them also:
thou knowest all the wickedness which thine heart is privy to, that thou didst to David my father; which conscience must bear witness to, and accuse him of, not only of the words and actions themselves uttered and done by him, but of the malice and wickedness from whence they sprung:
therefore the Lord shall return thy wickedness upon thine own head; the punishment of it; which though not directly inflicted for that, yet in providence was brought about as a just retaliation for it.

Gill: 1Ki 2:45 - -- And King Solomon shall be blessed,.... With a long and peaceable reign, and large dominions, notwithstanding all the attempts to make him unhappy:
...
And King Solomon shall be blessed,.... With a long and peaceable reign, and large dominions, notwithstanding all the attempts to make him unhappy:
and the throne of David shall be established before the Lord for ever; the kingdom of David over Judah for a long time, in his natural line; and the kingdom of Israel, spiritual Israel, for ever in his son the Messiah; and that in the presence of the Lord, he observing, ordering, and succeeding all things to that purpose.

Gill: 1Ki 2:46 - -- So the king commanded Benaiah the son of Jehoiada, which went out,.... From the presence of the king, and took Shimei with him to the proper place of ...
So the king commanded Benaiah the son of Jehoiada, which went out,.... From the presence of the king, and took Shimei with him to the proper place of execution, it not being fitting to execute him before the king:
and fell upon him, that he died; put him to death by the sword:
and the kingdom was established in the hand of Solomon; Adonijah the usurper, and Joab the general of the army, who took on his side, being both put to death; and Abiathar the high priest deposed, who was in the same conspiracy; and Shimei, a dangerous and troublesome man, dispatched, there remained none to give any disturbance; so that he now sat easy and quiet on his throne, and things with respect to the civil government were on a firm and settled foundation.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

NET Notes: 1Ki 2:43 Heb “Why have you not kept the oath [to] the Lord and the commandment I commanded you?”



Geneva Bible: 1Ki 2:44 The king said moreover to Shimei, ( u ) Thou knowest all the wickedness which thine heart is privy to, that thou didst to David my father: therefore t...

Geneva Bible: 1Ki 2:46 So the king commanded Benaiah the son of Jehoiada; which went out, and fell upon him, that he died. And the kingdom was ( x ) established in the hand ...

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> 1Ki 2:1-46
TSK Synopsis: 1Ki 2:1-46 - --1 David, having given a charge to Solomon,3 of religiousness;5 of Joab;7 of Barzillai;8 of Shimei;10 dies.12 Solomon succeeds.13 Adonijah, moving Bath...
MHCC -> 1Ki 2:35-46
MHCC: 1Ki 2:35-46 - --The old malignity remains in the unconverted heart, and a watchful eye should be kept on those who, like Shimei, have manifested their enmity, but hav...
Matthew Henry -> 1Ki 2:35-46
Matthew Henry: 1Ki 2:35-46 - -- Here is, I. The preferment of Benaiah and Zadok, two faithful friends to Solomon and his government, 1Ki 2:35. Joab being put to death, Benaiah was ...
Keil-Delitzsch -> 1Ki 2:12-46
Keil-Delitzsch: 1Ki 2:12-46 - --
Accession of Solomon and Establishment of his Government. - 1Ki 2:12 is aheading embracing the substance of what follows, and is more fullyexpanded ...
Constable: 1Ki 1:1--11:43 - --I. THE REIGN OF SOLOMON chs. 1--11
The Holy Spirit led the writer of Kings to give an interpretation of history,...

Constable: 1Ki 2:13-46 - --1. Solomon's purges 2:13-46
Solomon wrote that the fear of Yahweh is the beginning of knowledge ...
