
Text -- 1 Kings 3:2 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: 1Ki 3:2 - -- This particle is used here, and 1Ki 3:3, as an exception to Solomon's integrity and as a blemish to his government, That he himself both permitted and...
This particle is used here, and 1Ki 3:3, as an exception to Solomon's integrity and as a blemish to his government, That he himself both permitted and practised this which was expressly forbidden, Lev 17:3-4; Deu 12:13-14.

Wesley: 1Ki 3:2 - -- Which were groves, or other convenient places upon hills, in which the patriarchs used to offer up their sacrifices to God; and from them this custom ...
Which were groves, or other convenient places upon hills, in which the patriarchs used to offer up their sacrifices to God; and from them this custom was derived both to the Gentiles and the Jews: and in them the Gentiles sacrificed to idols, the Hebrews to the true God.

Wesley: 1Ki 3:2 - -- Which reason was not sufficient, for there was a tabernacle, to which they were as much confined as to the temple, Exo 40:34-38, &c.
Which reason was not sufficient, for there was a tabernacle, to which they were as much confined as to the temple, Exo 40:34-38, &c.
Clarke -> 1Ki 3:2
Clarke: 1Ki 3:2 - -- The people sacrificed in high places - Could there be any sin in this, or was it unlawful till after the temple was built? for prophets, judges, the...
The people sacrificed in high places - Could there be any sin in this, or was it unlawful till after the temple was built? for prophets, judges, the kings which preceded Solomon, and Solomon himself, sacrificed on high places, such as Gibeon, Gilgal, Shiloh, Hebron, Kirjath-jearim, etc. But after the temple was erected, it was sinful to offer sacrifices in any other place; yet here it is introduced as being morally wrong, and it is introduced, 1Ki 3:3, as being an exceptionable trait in the character of Solomon. The explanation appears to be this: as the ark and tabernacle were still in being, it was not right to offer sacrifices but where they were; and wherever they were, whether on a high place or a plain, there sacrifices might be lawfully offered, previously to the building of the temple. And the tabernacle was now at Gibeon, 2Ch 1:3. Possibly the high places may be like those among the Hindoos, large raised-up terraces, on which they place their gods when they bathe, anoint, and worship them. Juggernaut and Krishnu have large terraces or high places, on which they are annually exhibited. But there was no idol in the above case.
Defender -> 1Ki 3:2
Defender: 1Ki 3:2 - -- Worship in high places was forbidden in the Mosaic law (Lev 26:30) because of its universal association with the idolatrous polytheistic pantheism of ...
Worship in high places was forbidden in the Mosaic law (Lev 26:30) because of its universal association with the idolatrous polytheistic pantheism of other nations. Such practice probably originated at the Tower of Babel and then was carried worldwide by the subsequent dispersion. However, the people had been commanded to bring their sacrifices to the tabernacle, and the tabernacle at this time had been erected on the high place at Gibeon (1Ch 16:39; 1Ch 21:29) after temporary sojourns at Gilgal, Shiloh and Nob. It is possible that this situation contributed to David's strong desire to build a permanent temple for the worship of God at Jerusalem."
TSK -> 1Ki 3:2
TSK: 1Ki 3:2 - -- the people : It was not right to offer sacrifices in any place but where the tabernacle and ark were; and wherever they were, whether on a high place ...
the people : It was not right to offer sacrifices in any place but where the tabernacle and ark were; and wherever they were, whether on a high place or a plain, sacrifices might be lawfully offered, previously to building of the temple. The tabernacle was now at Gibeon (2Ch 1:3), which was therefore called the great high place; whither we find Solomon, without censure, repaired to sacrifice. 1Ki 22:43; Lev 17:3-6, Lev 26:30; Deu 12:2-5; 2Ch 33:17
was no : 1Ki 5:3; 1Ch 17:4-6, 1Ch 28:3-6; Act 7:47-49

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> 1Ki 3:2
Barnes: 1Ki 3:2 - -- The word "only"introduces a contrast. The writer means to say that there was one exception to the flourishing condition of things which he has been ...
The word "only"introduces a contrast. The writer means to say that there was one exception to the flourishing condition of things which he has been describing, namely, that "the people sacrificed in high-places."(Compare the next verse.) The Law did not forbid "high-places"directly, but only by implication. It required the utter destruction of all the high-places which had been polluted by idolatrous rites Deu 12:2; and the injunction to offer sacrifices nowhere except at the door of the tabernacle Lev 17:3-5 was an indirect prohibition of them, or, at least, of the use which the Israelites made of them; but there was some real reason to question whether this was a command intended to come into force until the "place"was chosen "where the Lord would cause His name to dwell."(See Deu 12:11, Deu 12:14.) The result was that high-places were used for the worship of Yahweh, from the time of the Judges downward Jdg 6:25; Jdg 13:16; 1Sa 7:10; 1Sa 13:9; 1Sa 14:35; 1Sa 16:5; 1Ch 21:26, with an entire unconsciousness of guilt on the part of those who used them. And God so far overlooked this ignorance that He accepted the worship thus offered Him, as appears from the vision vouchsafed to Solomon on this occasion. There were two reasons for the prohibition of high-places; first, the danger of the old idolatry creeping back if the old localities were retained for worship; and, secondly, the danger to the unity of the nation if there should be more than one legitimate religious center. The existence of the worship at high places did, in fact, facilitate the division of the kingdom.
Poole -> 1Ki 3:2
Poole: 1Ki 3:2 - -- Only: this particle is used here and 1Ki 3:3 , as an exception to Solomon’ s integrity and glory, and as his infirmity, and a blemish to his gov...
Only: this particle is used here and 1Ki 3:3 , as an exception to Solomon’ s integrity and glory, and as his infirmity, and a blemish to his government, that he himself both permitted and practised this which was expressly forbidden, Lev 17:3,4 De 12:13,14 , except in some extraordinary cases. Possibly he permitted it because he thought it better to allow an error in a circumstance, than to occasion a neglect of the substance of God’ s worship, which he apprehended would follow upon a severe prohibition of that practice, because the people’ s hearts were generally and constantly set upon these high places, as appears from all the following history; and they were not willing to submit to so much trouble and charge as the bringing of all their sacrifices to one place would cause; nor would yield to it until the temple was built, which he knew would easily incline and oblige them to it; and that being speedily to be done, he might think it more advisable rather to delay the execution of that law of God for an approaching season, wherein he doubted not they would be sweetly and freely drawn to it, than at present to drive them to it by force; although these and all other prudential considerations should have given place to the will and wisdom of God.
In high places which were groves, or other convenient places upon hills, in which the patriarchs used to offer up their worship and sacrifices to God; and from them this custom was derived both to the Gentiles and the Jews; and in them the Gentiles sacrificed to idols, Jer 7:31 Eze 6:3,4 Ho 10:8 , the Hebrews to the true God.
Because there was no house which reason was not sufficient, for there was a tabernacle, to which they were as much confined as to the temple, De 12 , &c.
Unto the name of the Lord either,
1. To the Lord; the name of the Lord being oft put for the Lord himself, as Deu 28:58 Job 1:21 Psa 7:17 116:13 135:1 . Or,
2. To the honour, and praise, and service of God; to the glory of his name, i.e. of his majesty, and all his perfections, which shall be adored and manifested there.
Haydock -> 1Ki 3:2
Haydock: 1Ki 3:2 - -- But yet. It is not clear to what this refers. Hebrew, "for the rest, (Calmet) or only;" (as also ver. 3,) which may signify that the people, and ...
But yet. It is not clear to what this refers. Hebrew, "for the rest, (Calmet) or only;" (as also ver. 3,) which may signify that the people, and their king, were blamable; or else, that they zealously offered sacrifices to God, even before the temple was erected. (Haydock) ---
Those who afterwards left that sacred place, to imitate the conduct of idolaters, or of the ancient patriarchs, which was no longer tolerated, are justly condemned. (Calmet) ---
High places. That is, altars where they worshipped the Lord, indeed, but not according to the ordinance of the law; which allowed of no other places for sacrifice but the temple of God. Among these high places, that of Gabaon was the chief, because there was the tabernacle of the testimony wich had been removed from Silo to Nobe, and from Nobe to Gabaon. (Challoner) ---
Hither David would have gone, as Solomon did, ver. 4. (Calmet) ---
Hence this was not, at least, once of those high places, where it was unlawful to offer sacrifice; as the tabernacle was there, and the altar of holocausts, which Moses had erected. The obligation of sacrificing in no place, except in that which the Lord had appointed, regarded the times while the ark was in the desert, (Haydock) and when it was placed in the temple. While it continued in an unsettled state, people enjoyed more liberty in this respect; (Calmet) particularly when there was a prophet present, to sanction what they did. (Haydock)
Gill -> 1Ki 3:2
Gill: 1Ki 3:2 - -- Only the people sacrificed in high places,.... On the tops of their houses, on hills and mountains, and particularly at the high place in Gibeon, wher...
Only the people sacrificed in high places,.... On the tops of their houses, on hills and mountains, and particularly at the high place in Gibeon, where the tabernacle was:
because there was no house built unto the name of the Lord until those days; to which they were obliged to repair as afterwards, and there offer their sacrifices, as the Lord had commanded, Deu 12:5.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes: 1Ki 3:2 Heb “for the name of the Lord.” The word “name” sometimes refers to one’s reputation or honor (thus the translation here...
Geneva Bible -> 1Ki 3:2
Geneva Bible: 1Ki 3:2 Only the people sacrificed in ( b ) high places, because there was no house built unto the name of the LORD, until those days.
( b ) Where altars wer...

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> 1Ki 3:1-28
TSK Synopsis: 1Ki 3:1-28 - --1 Solomon marries Pharaoh's daughter.2 High places being in use, Solomon sacrifices at Gibeon.5 Solomon at Gibeon, in the choice which God gave him, p...
MHCC -> 1Ki 3:1-4
MHCC: 1Ki 3:1-4 - --He that loved the Lord, should, for his sake, have fixed his love upon one of the Lord's people. Solomon was a wise man, a rich man, a great man; yet ...
Matthew Henry -> 1Ki 3:1-4
Matthew Henry: 1Ki 3:1-4 - -- We are here told concerning Solomon, I. Something that was unquestionably good, for which he is to be praised and in which he is to be imitated. 1. ...
Keil-Delitzsch -> 1Ki 3:1-3
Keil-Delitzsch: 1Ki 3:1-3 - --
Solomon's marriage and the religious state of the kingdom . - 1Ki 3:1. When Solomon had well secured his possession of the throne (1Ki 2:46), he en...
Constable: 1Ki 1:1--11:43 - --I. THE REIGN OF SOLOMON chs. 1--11
The Holy Spirit led the writer of Kings to give an interpretation of history,...

Constable: 1Ki 3:1-28 - --2. Solomon's wisdom from God ch. 3
The flowing narrative of chapters 1-2 now gives way to report...
