![](images/minus.gif)
Text -- 2 Samuel 5:6 (NET)
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/information.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley -> 2Sa 5:6
Wesley: 2Sa 5:6 - -- They confided in the strength of their fortifications, which they thought so impregnable, that the blind and the lame were sufficient to defend them, ...
They confided in the strength of their fortifications, which they thought so impregnable, that the blind and the lame were sufficient to defend them, against the most powerful assailant. And probably they set a parcel of blind and lame people, invalids or maimed soldiers, to make their appearance on the wall, in contempt of David and his men.
JFB -> 2Sa 5:6
JFB: 2Sa 5:6 - -- The first expedition of David, as king of the whole country, was directed against this place, which had hitherto remained in the hands of the natives....
The first expedition of David, as king of the whole country, was directed against this place, which had hitherto remained in the hands of the natives. It was strongly fortified and deemed so impregnable that the blind and lame were sent to man the battlements, in derisive mockery of the Hebrew king's attack, and to shout, "David cannot come in hither." To understand the full meaning and force of this insulting taunt, it is necessary to bear in mind the depth and steepness of the valley of Gihon, and the lofty walls of the ancient Canaanitish fortress.
Clarke: 2Sa 5:6 - -- The king and his men went to Jerusalem - This city was now in the hands of the Jebusites; but how they got possession of it is not known, probably t...
The king and his men went to Jerusalem - This city was now in the hands of the Jebusites; but how they got possession of it is not known, probably they took it during the wars between Ish-bosheth and David. After Joshua’ s death, what is called the lower city was taken by the Israelites; and it is evident that the whole city was in their possession in the time of Saul, for David brought the head of Goliath thither, 1Sa 17:54. It appears to have been a very strong fortress, and, from what follows, deemed impregnable by the Jebusites. It was right that the Israelites should repossess it; and David very properly began his reign over the whole country by the siege of this city
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: 2Sa 5:6 - -- Except thou take away the blind and the lame - Scarcely a passage in the sacred oracles has puzzled commentators more than this. For my own part, I ...
Except thou take away the blind and the lame - Scarcely a passage in the sacred oracles has puzzled commentators more than this. For my own part, I do not think that it is worth the labor spent upon it, nor shall I encumber these pages with the discordant opinions of learned men. From the general face of the text it appears that the Jebusites, vainly confiding in the strength of their fortress, placed lame and blind men upon the walls, and thus endeavored to turn into ridicule David’ s attempt to take the place: Thou shalt not come in hither, except thou take away the blind and the lame; nothing could be more cutting to a warrior
Dr. Kennicott has taken great pains to correct this passage, as may be seen in his First Dissertation on the Hebrew Text, pages 27 to 47. I shall insert our present version with his amended text line for line, his translation being distinguished by italics; and for farther information refer to Dr. K.’ s work
Jerusalem unto the Jebusites, the inhabitants of | Jerusalem unto the Jebusites, the inhabitants of |
the land: who spake unto David, saying, | the land; who spake unto David, saying; |
Except thou take away the blind and the | Thou shalt not come in hither; for the blind |
lame, thou shalt not come in hither: thinking, | and the lame shall drive thee away by saying, |
David cannot come in hither. | "David shall not come in hither." |
And David said - Whosoever getteth | And David said - Whosoever smiteth the |
up to the gutter, and smiteth the Jebusites, | Jebusites, and through the subterranean passage |
and the lame and the blind, that are hated | reacheth the lame and the blind who |
of David’ s soul - Wherefore they said, The | hate the life of David (because the blind and |
blind and the lame shall not come into the | the lame said, "He shall not come into the |
house. | house,") shall be chief and captain. So |
Joab the son of Zeruiah went up first, and | |
was chief. |
Defender -> 2Sa 5:6
Defender: 2Sa 5:6 - -- The Jebusites were a tribe descended from Mizraim, the son of Ham (Gen 10:16), and had been in Canaan since at least the time of Abraham (Gen 15:21). ...
The Jebusites were a tribe descended from Mizraim, the son of Ham (Gen 10:16), and had been in Canaan since at least the time of Abraham (Gen 15:21). Joshua had been unable to drive them out of Jerusalem, their capital, and neither had the hosts of the tribes of Judah and Benjamin, who had been given that region of the promised land (Joshua 15:20-62, Jos 15:63; Jdg 1:21). As a result, the Jebusites were quite smug in their fortress, mocking David by saying their blind and lame could repel his forces."
TSK -> 2Sa 5:6
TSK: 2Sa 5:6 - -- Jerusalem : Gen 14:18; Jos 10:3; Jdg 1:8; Heb 7:1
the Jebusites : Jos 15:63, Jos 18:28; Jdg 1:8, Jdg 1:21, Jdg 19:10-12
which spake : etc. Dr. Kennico...
Jerusalem : Gen 14:18; Jos 10:3; Jdg 1:8; Heb 7:1
the Jebusites : Jos 15:63, Jos 18:28; Jdg 1:8, Jdg 1:21, Jdg 19:10-12
which spake : etc. Dr. Kennicott’ s amended translation is as follows: ""Who spake unto David, saying, Thou shalt not come in hither; for the blind and the lame shall drive thee away, by saying, David shall not come in hither""2Sa 5:8. ""And David said, Whosoever smiteth the Jebusites, and through the subterraneous passage reacheth the lame and the blind, who hate the life of David (because the blind and the lame said, he shall not come into the house), shall be chief and captain. So Joab, the son of Zeriah, went up first, and was chief."
Except : Jer 37:10
thinking, David cannot : or, saying, David shall not, etc
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> 2Sa 5:6
Barnes: 2Sa 5:6 - -- David immediately after being anointed king of Israel, probably wished to signalize his accession by an exploit which would be popular with all Isra...
David immediately after being anointed king of Israel, probably wished to signalize his accession by an exploit which would be popular with all Israel, and especially with Saul’ s tribe, Benjamin. He discerned the importance of having Jerusalem for his capital both because it belonged as much to Benjamin as to Judah, and on account of its strong position.
Except thou take away the blind ... - Rather, "and (the Jebusite) spake to David, saying, Thou shalt not come hither, but the blind and the lame shall keep thee off,"i. e. so far shalt thou be from taking the stronghold from us, that the lame and blind shall suffice to defend the place.
Poole -> 2Sa 5:6
Poole: 2Sa 5:6 - -- Having the advantage of so great a confluence of his people to make him king, he thought fit to begin his reign with some eminent action, and to lea...
Having the advantage of so great a confluence of his people to make him king, he thought fit to begin his reign with some eminent action, and to lead them forth in this expedition; wherein doubtless he asked advice from God, and the consent of the elders now present.
To Jerusalem as the place which God had designed for his worship; and in the centre and heart of his kingdom, and therefore fittest for his royal city.
The Jebusites continued to dwell there in spite of the Benjamites, to whose lot it fell. See Jos 15:63 Jud 1:21 19:10,11 .
Except thou take away the blind and the lame, thou shalt not come in hither or, Thou shalt not come in hither, but the blind and the lame shall remove or hinder thee . By the blind and the lame they understand, either,
1. Their own people; and so they imply that the place was so impregnable, that a few blind and lame men were able to defend it against all David’ s assaults. And these may be called and were the hated of David’ s soul , 2Sa 5:8 , not because they were blind and lame, but because they were Jebusites, a people hated and accursed by God: and the Jebusites of this place were more hateful to him than the rest of that nation; partly, because they possessed this place, which David knew was designed for the one and only place of God’ s solemn worship; and partly because they did so wickedly and insolently defy the armies of Israel, and consequently, the God of Israel. Or,
2. Their gods or images; which, after the manner of the heathens, they worshipped as their tutelary gods, and placed in their gates or walls. These they call blind and lame sarcastically, and with respect to David’ s opinion; as if they said, These gods of ours, whom you Israelites reproach, as blind and lame, Psa 115:5,6 , and so unable to direct and protect us, they will defend us against you; and you will find they are neither blind nor lame, but have eyes to watch for us, and hands to fight against you; and you must conquer them before you can take our city. And these may well be called the hated of David’ s soul . But I prefer the former sense, as being most easy, and natural, and proper; whereas the latter is metaphorical, and seems doubtful and forced.
David cannot come in hither concluding their fort to be impregnable.
Haydock -> 2Sa 5:6
Haydock: 2Sa 5:6 - -- Land. This was the only canton which the infidels still retained, as they had still possession of the citadel of Jebus, (Calmet) though the Israelit...
Land. This was the only canton which the infidels still retained, as they had still possession of the citadel of Jebus, (Calmet) though the Israelites had been in the country above 400 years. (Kennicott) ---
Nothing could reflect greater glory on the beginning of David's reign, than the seizing of this place, (Calmet) which was deemed so impregnable, that the Jebusites thought the blind and the lame were sufficient to defend it. (Haydock) ---
They placed some upon the walls, (Menochius) "despising him, on account of the strength of their walls."
Gill -> 2Sa 5:6
Gill: 2Sa 5:6 - -- And the king and his men went to Jerusalem,.... Which, at least part of it, belonged to the tribe of Benjamin; and therefore until all Israel, and tha...
And the king and his men went to Jerusalem,.... Which, at least part of it, belonged to the tribe of Benjamin; and therefore until all Israel, and that tribe, with the rest, made him king, he did not attempt the reduction of it, but now he immediately set out on an expedition against it:
unto the Jebusites, the inhabitants of the land: who inhabited the country about it, and even dwelt in that itself; for the tribe of Judah could not drive them out at first from that part of it which belonged to them, nor the tribe of Benjamin from that part which was theirs; in short, they became so much masters of it, that it was called, even in later times, Jebus, and the city of the Jebusites; see Jos 15:63 Jdg 1:21,
which spake unto David; when he came up against them, and besieged them:
except thou take away the blind and lame, thou shalt not come in hither; which many understand of their idols and images, which had eyes, but saw not, and feet, but walked not, which therefore David and his men in derision called the blind and lame; these the Jebusites placed for the defence of their city, and put great confidence in them for the security of it, and therefore said to David, unless you can remove these, which you scornfully call the blind and the lame, you will never be able to take the place. And certain it is the Heathens had their tutelar gods for their cities as well as their houses, in which they greatly trusted for their safety; and therefore with the Romans, when they besieged a city, the first thing they attempted to do was by any means, as by songs particularly, to get the tutelar gods out of it b; believing otherwise it would never be taken by them; or if it could, it was not lawful to make the gods captives c: and to this sense most of the Jewish commentators agree, as Kimchi, Jarchi, Ben Gersom, and R. Isaiah, who take them to be images; some say, made of brass, which were placed either in the streets of the city, or on the towers: it was usual with all nations to place on their walls both their household and country gods, to defend them from the enemy d. A learned countryman of ours e is of opinion that these were statues or images talismanically made, under a certain constellation, by some skilful in astrology, placed in the recess of the fort, and intrusted with the keeping of it, and in which the utmost confidence was put: but it seems better with Aben Ezra and Abarbinel, and so Josephus f, to understand this of blind and lame men; and that the sense is, that the Jebusites had such an opinion of the strength of their city, that a few blind and lame men were sufficient to defend it against David and his army; and perhaps in contempt of him placed some invalids, blind and lame men, on the walls of it, and jeeringly told him, that unless he could remove them, he would never take the city:
thinking: or "saying" g; this was the substance of what they said, or what they meant by it:
David cannot come in hither; it is impossible for him to enter it, he cannot and shall not do it, and very probably these words were put into the mouths of the blind and lame, and they said them frequently.
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes: 2Sa 5:6 The Hebrew text has “he” rather than “the Jebusites.” The referent has been specified in the translation for clarity. In the S...
Geneva Bible -> 2Sa 5:6
Geneva Bible: 2Sa 5:6 And the king and his men went to Jerusalem unto the Jebusites, the inhabitants of the land: which spake unto David, saying, Except thou take away the ...
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> 2Sa 5:1-25
TSK Synopsis: 2Sa 5:1-25 - --1 The tribes come to Hebron and anoint David over Israel.4 David's age.6 He taking Zion from the Jebusites, dwells in it.11 Hiram sends to David.13 El...
Maclaren -> 2Sa 5:1-12
Maclaren: 2Sa 5:1-12 - --2 Samuel 5:1-12
The dark day on Gilboa put the Philistines in possession of most of Saul's kingdom. Only in the south David held his ground, and Abner...
MHCC -> 2Sa 5:6-10
MHCC: 2Sa 5:6-10 - --The enemies of God's people are often very confident of their own strength, and most secure when their day to fall draws nigh. But the pride and insol...
Matthew Henry -> 2Sa 5:6-10
Matthew Henry: 2Sa 5:6-10 - -- If Salem, the place of which Melchizedec was king, was Jerusalem (as seems probable from Psa 76:2), it was famous in Abraham's time. Joshua, in his ...
Keil-Delitzsch -> 2Sa 5:6-10
Keil-Delitzsch: 2Sa 5:6-10 - --
Conquest of the Stronghold of Zion, and Choice of Jerusalem as the Capital of the Kingdom (cf. 1Ch 11:4, 1Ch 11:9). - These parallel accounts agree ...
Constable: 2Sa 1:1--8:18 - --V. DAVID'S TRIUMPHS chs. 1--8
The first 20 chapters of 2 Samuel are divisible into four uni...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: 2Sa 3:6--5:17 - --B. The Unification of the Kingdom 3:6-5:16
The writer also documented God's blessing on David in this re...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)