
Text -- 2 Samuel 15:7 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley -> 2Sa 15:7
Wesley: 2Sa 15:7 - -- From the change of the government, into a monarchy, which was about ten years before David began to reign. So this fell out about the thirtieth year o...
From the change of the government, into a monarchy, which was about ten years before David began to reign. So this fell out about the thirtieth year of his reign.
JFB -> 2Sa 15:7-9; 2Sa 15:7-9
JFB: 2Sa 15:7-9 - -- It is generally admitted that an error has here crept into the text, and that instead of "forty," we should read with the Syriac and Arabic versions, ...
It is generally admitted that an error has here crept into the text, and that instead of "forty," we should read with the Syriac and Arabic versions, and JOSEPHUS, "four years"--that is, after Absalom's return to Jerusalem, and his beginning to practice the base arts of gaining popularity.

JFB: 2Sa 15:7-9 - -- During his exile in Geshur. The purport of it was, that whenever God's providence should pave the way for his re-establishment in Jerusalem, he would ...
During his exile in Geshur. The purport of it was, that whenever God's providence should pave the way for his re-establishment in Jerusalem, he would offer a sacrifice of thanksgiving. Hebron was the spot selected for the performance of this vow, ostensibly as being his native place (2Sa 3:3), and a famous high place, where sacrifices were frequently offered before the temple was built; but really as being in many respects the most suitable for the commencement of his rebellious enterprise. David, who always encouraged piety and desired to see religious engagements punctually performed, gave his consent and his blessing.
Clarke -> 2Sa 15:7
Clarke: 2Sa 15:7 - -- After forty years - There is no doubt that this reading is corrupt, though supported by the commonly printed Vulgate, the Septuagint, and the Chalde...
After forty years - There is no doubt that this reading is corrupt, though supported by the commonly printed Vulgate, the Septuagint, and the Chaldee. But the Syriac has
Defender -> 2Sa 15:7
Defender: 2Sa 15:7 - -- The number "forty" here is apparently a copyist error. The Septuagint and Syriac translations, as well as Josephus, all agree that it was "four" years...
The number "forty" here is apparently a copyist error. The Septuagint and Syriac translations, as well as Josephus, all agree that it was "four" years, a period which fits more realistically in the account."
TSK -> 2Sa 15:7
TSK: 2Sa 15:7 - -- am 2983, bc 1021, An, Ex, Is, 470
forty years : As David reigned in the whole only forty years, this reading is evidently corrupt, though supported by...
am 2983, bc 1021, An, Ex, Is, 470
forty years : As David reigned in the whole only forty years, this reading is evidently corrupt, though supported by the commonly printed Vulgate, LXX, and Chaldee. But the Syriac, Arabic, Josephus, Theodoret, the Sixtine edition of the Vulgate, and several manuscripts of the same version, read four years; and it is highly probable that
let me go : 2Sa 13:24-27

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> 2Sa 15:7
Barnes: 2Sa 15:7 - -- Forty years - An obvious clerical error, though a very ancient one for four years, which may date from Absalom’ s return from Geshur, or f...
Forty years - An obvious clerical error, though a very ancient one for four years, which may date from Absalom’ s return from Geshur, or from his reconciliation with David, or from the commencement of the criminal schemes to which 2Sa 15:1 refers.
Hebron - This, as having been the old capital of David’ s kingdom and Absalom’ s birthplace, was well chosen. It was a natural center, had probably many inhabitants discontented at the transfer of the government to Jerusalem, and contained many of the friends of Absalom’ s youth. As the place of his birth (compare 1Sa 20:6), it afforded a plausible pretext for holding there the great sacrificial feast ("the serving the Lord,"2Sa 15:8), which Absalom pretended to have vowed to hold to the glory of God.
Poole -> 2Sa 15:7
Poole: 2Sa 15:7 - -- After forty years
Quest. Whence are these to be computed?
Answ . Not from Absalom’ s birth; for he was born in Hebron some considerable tim...
After forty years
Quest. Whence are these to be computed?
Answ . Not from Absalom’ s birth; for he was born in Hebron some considerable time after David had begun his reign, 2Sa 3:3 , much less from the time of his vow made, or of his return from banishment; but either, first, From the time of David’ s election or designation to the kingdom. 1Sa 16:13 . Or, secondly, From the beginning of Saul’ s reign; which being a solemn time, and observable for the change of the government in Israel, might very fitly be made an epochs, from which the computation or account of times begin; as the Greeks and Romans began their accounts in the same manner, and upon the same ground. Or rather, thirdly, From the beginning of David’ s reign, who reigned forty years; and so the words may be rendered, about or towards the end of forty years , i. e. in the beginning of the fortieth year. And so this very phrase is used Deu 15:1 , At the end of every seven years , i.e. in the seventh year, even from the beginning of it, as is manifested and confessed. So in a like expression, After three days will I rise again , Mar 8:31 , i.e. on the beginning of the third day, when Christ did rise; the number of three days being then completed when the third day is begun. And the forty years are here expressed as one motive or inducement to Absalom to rebel, because now his father’ s end grew near; and one of the Hebrew doctors affirms, that there was a tradition, or rumour, or prediction, that David should reign but forty years. And Absalom might easily understand that David intended to decline him, and to make Solomon his successor, as well by the conscience of his own wickedness and unfitness for so great a trust, as by that eminent wisdom and piety which appeared in Solomon in his tender years, and that great respect and affection which his father must needs have and manifest to him upon this account, and by that promise and oath given to Bathsheba concerning his succession mentioned 1Ki 1:30 , but made before that time, which also might come to Absalom’ s ear. Against this opinion two things are objected: first, That David was in the time of this rebellion a strong man, for he marched on foot, 2Sa 15:30 , whereas in his last year he was very infirm and bedrid. Secondly, That after this rebellion was ended divers other things happened, as the three years’ famine, 2Sa 21:1 , and other things following in the history. But it may be answered to the first, that David might in the beginning of his last year have so much strength and vigour left as to march on foot, especially when he did so humble and afflict himself, as it is apparent he did, 2Sa 15:30 ; and yet through his tedious marches, and the tormenting cares, fears, and griefs of his soul for Absalom, might be so strangely and suddenly impaired, as in the end of the same year to be very feeble and bedrid, it being a very common accident, especially in old men, and upon extraordinary occasions, to languish and decline exceedingly, and to fall from some competent degree of health and rigour, to be very infirm and bedrid, and that in the space of a few months. And to the second objection, That those histories related 2Sa 21 , &c., though they be placed after this rebellion, yet indeed were done before it; the proof of which see on 2Sa 21:1 . For it is so confessed and evident, that things are not always placed in the same order in which they were done, that it is a rule of the Hebrews, and approved by other learned men, Non datur pri us et posterius in Saetia literis; that is, There is no first and last in the order of Scripture relations . And here is a plain reason for this transplacing of this history, which is allowed in other like cases, that when once the history of Tamar’ s rape had been mentioned, it was very fit to subjoin the relation of all the mischiefs which followed upon that occasion. If any infidel will yet cavil with this text and number of years, let him know, that instead of forty , the Syriac, and Arabic, and Josephus the Jew read four years ; and that it is much more rational to acknowledge an error of the scribe, who copied out the sacred text, than upon so frivolous a ground to question the Divine authority of the Holy Scriptures. And that some men choose the latter way rather than the former, is an evidence that they are infidels by the choice of their wills, more than by the strength of their reasons.
Let me go and pay my vow : he pretends piety, which he knew would please his father, and easily procure his consent.
Hebron is mentioned as the place, not where the vow was made, for that was at Geshur, 2Sa 15:8 , but where he intended to perform it. The pretence for which was, that he was born in this place, 2Sa 3:3 , and that here was a famous high place; and, till the temple was built, it was permitted to sacrifice upon the high places.
Haydock -> 2Sa 15:7
Haydock: 2Sa 15:7 - -- Forty, which Vatable dates from the time when the people petitioned for a king; Salien, from the first anointing of David. (Menochius) ---
It is pr...
Forty, which Vatable dates from the time when the people petitioned for a king; Salien, from the first anointing of David. (Menochius) ---
It is probable enough that this number has been substituted instead of four, which Josephus, Theodoret, Syriac, Arabic, and many Latin manuscripts read; and Absalom would employ this term in securing the interest of Israel, before he declared himself openly their king. (Calmet) ---
He had been so long at Jerusalem, since his return. (Salien) ---
The canon of Hebrew verity, supposed to be made about the ninth century, is said (by Martinnay; Haydock) to be altered by some correcting hand, from four to forty. (Kennicott) ---
This is the famous Memmian canon, which Theodulph, bishop of Orleans, is believed to have ordered, as the standard of truth, according to the Hebrew copies of that day: (Haydock) and this seems to have guided the Ben. editor of St. Jerome's works, and of his translation; so that it is no wonder if "the printed copies agree in so many places with the corrupted Hebrew." Canon Memmianus pure leget juxta Hebræum, quod nos edidimus. (Note on 2 Paralipomenon xiii. 3, 17.) The Vulgate of Sixtus V, in that passage, as well as in the present, reads the smaller numbers, as he was guided by the best Latin copies, whereas Clement VIII has also consulted "the Hebrew fountains." The former, says Kennicott, (Diss. ii. p. 205) "seems to have been printed on a juster plan....and the old Latin version is likely to be found more pure in the edition of Sixtus than in that of Clement, since the latter seems to have corrected his Latin by the modern (i.e., the corrupted) Hebrew copies." Dr. James observes, that "almost all the Latin editions received in the Church, for many years, (preceding 1590) agree with Sixtus," who here reads quatuor, with many others; so that Grotius is well supported in having pronounced so decisively, "without doubt there is a mistake, two letters having been added at the end of arba. The thing itself declares that four years had elapsed." (Kennicott) ---
It appears to be indubitable, that some mistakes have taken place with regard to numbers. But that this place is incorrect may not be so certain, as the chronology of Salien, Usher, &c., explains it well enough. The Hebrew text was esteemed more correct when the last editions of St. Jerome, and of the Vulgate, were given, than it is at present. (Haydock)
Gill -> 2Sa 15:7
Gill: 2Sa 15:7 - -- And it came to pass after forty years,.... Or four years; so long it was from the reconciliation of Absalom to David, as Josephus f says; and so read ...
And it came to pass after forty years,.... Or four years; so long it was from the reconciliation of Absalom to David, as Josephus f says; and so read Theodoret on the place, the Syriac and Arabic versions: but some say it was either forty years from the time Israel first had a king; and which might be an era of reckoning with the Jews, as the era of Seleucidae was with the Greeks, on the like account; or from the time Saul slew the priests at Nob, as Jerom g; or from the time of David's being anointed by Samuel; or this was the year of Absalom's age, or of David's reign: but these, and other attempts made to account for this passage, are not entirely satisfactory; and therefore one may be tempted to conclude there must be a mistake in the copy, of "arbaim" for "arba", forty for four; which makes it quite easy, and confirms the first sense:
that Absalom said unto the king, I pray thee, let me go and pay my vow,
which I have vowed unto the Lord, in Hebron; not what he vowed in Hebron; for according to his own account he had vowed it in Geshur, as in 2Sa 15:8; but his request is, that he might pay it in Hebron; which place he fixed upon, being his native place, and where David was anointed king; and which, being about twenty miles from Jerusalem, was at a proper distance to lay the scene of his conspiracy in, and bring it to perfection.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes -> 2Sa 15:7
NET Notes: 2Sa 15:7 The MT has here “forty,” but this is presumably a scribal error for “four.” The context will not tolerate a period of forty ye...
Geneva Bible -> 2Sa 15:7
Geneva Bible: 2Sa 15:7 And it came to pass after ( e ) forty years, that Absalom said unto the king, I pray thee, let me go and pay my vow, which I have vowed unto the LORD,...

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> 2Sa 15:1-37
TSK Synopsis: 2Sa 15:1-37 - --1 Absalom, by fair speeches and courtesies, steals the hearts of Israel.7 Under pretence of a vow, he obtains leave to go to Hebron.10 He makes there ...
Maclaren -> 2Sa 15:1-12
Maclaren: 2Sa 15:1-12 - --2 Samuel 15:1-12
There was little brightness in David's life after his great sin. Nathan had told him, even while announcing his forgiveness, that the...
MHCC -> 2Sa 15:7-12
MHCC: 2Sa 15:7-12 - --See how willing tender parents are to believe the best concerning their children. But how easy and how wicked is it, for children to take advantage of...
Matthew Henry -> 2Sa 15:7-12
Matthew Henry: 2Sa 15:7-12 - -- We have here the breaking out of Absalom's rebellion, which he had long been contriving. It is said to be after forty years, 2Sa 15:7. But whence ...
Keil-Delitzsch -> 2Sa 15:7-8
Keil-Delitzsch: 2Sa 15:7-8 - --
Absalom's rebellion. - 2Sa 15:7, 2Sa 15:8. After the lapse of forty (?) years Absalom said to the king, "Pray I will go (i.e., pray allow me to go...
Constable: 2Sa 9:1--20:26 - --VI. DAVID'S TROUBLES chs. 9--20
Chapters 9-20 contrast with chapters 2-8 in that this later section is negative ...

Constable: 2Sa 13:1--20:26 - --C. David's Rejection and Return chs. 13-20
This is the longest literary section in the Court History of ...

Constable: 2Sa 15:1--20:26 - --2. Absalom's attempt to usurp David's throne chs. 15-20
Absalom was never Yahweh's choice to suc...
