![](images/minus.gif)
Text -- 2 Samuel 23:5 (NET)
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/information.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: 2Sa 23:5 - -- Although God knows, that neither I, nor my children have lived and ruled as we should have done, so justly, and in the fear of the Lord; and therefore...
Although God knows, that neither I, nor my children have lived and ruled as we should have done, so justly, and in the fear of the Lord; and therefore have not enjoyed that uninterrupted prosperity which we might have enjoyed.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: 2Sa 23:5 - -- Notwithstanding all our transgressions whereby we have broken covenant with God, yet God, to whom all my sins were known, was graciously pleased to ma...
Notwithstanding all our transgressions whereby we have broken covenant with God, yet God, to whom all my sins were known, was graciously pleased to make a sure covenant, to continue the kingdom to me, and to my seed for ever, 2Sa 7:16, until the coming of the Messiah who is to be my son and successor, and whose kingdom shall have no end.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: 2Sa 23:5 - -- Ordained in all points by God's eternal counsel; and disposed by his wise and powerful providence which will over - rule all things, even the sins of ...
Ordained in all points by God's eternal counsel; and disposed by his wise and powerful providence which will over - rule all things, even the sins of my house so far, that although he punished them for their sins, yet he will not utterly root them out, nor break his covenant made with me and mine.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: 2Sa 23:5 - -- Or, preserved, by God's power and faithfulness in the midst of all oppositions.
Or, preserved, by God's power and faithfulness in the midst of all oppositions.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Or, in this is, that is, it consists in, and depends upon this covenant.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: 2Sa 23:5 - -- Both mine own eternal salvation, and the preservation of the kingdom to me and mine.
Both mine own eternal salvation, and the preservation of the kingdom to me and mine.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: 2Sa 23:5 - -- Although God as yet hath not made my house or family to grow; that is, to increase, or to flourish with worldly glory as I expected; yet this is my co...
Although God as yet hath not made my house or family to grow; that is, to increase, or to flourish with worldly glory as I expected; yet this is my comfort, that God will inviolably keep this covenant. But this refers also to the covenant of grace made with all believers. This is indeed an everlasting covenant, from everlasting, in the contrivance of it, and to everlasting, in the continuance and the consequence of it. It is ordered, well ordered in all things; admirably well, to advance the glory of God and the honour of the mediator, together with the holiness and happiness of believers. It is sure, and therefore sure, because well - ordered: the promised mercies are sure, on the performance of the conditions. It is all our salvation: nothing but this will save us, and this is sufficient. Therefore it should be all our desire. Let me have an interest in this covenant, and I have enough, I desire no more.
JFB -> 2Sa 23:5
JFB: 2Sa 23:5 - -- "the light of the morning," that is, the beginning of David's kingdom, was unlike the clear brilliant dawn of an Eastern day but was overcast by many ...
"the light of the morning," that is, the beginning of David's kingdom, was unlike the clear brilliant dawn of an Eastern day but was overcast by many black and threatening clouds; neither he nor his family had been like the tender grass springing up from the ground and flourishing by the united influences of the sun and rain; but rather like the grass that withereth and is prematurely cut down. The meaning is: although David's house had not flourished in an uninterrupted course of worldly prosperity and greatness, according to his hopes; although great crimes and calamities had beclouded his family history; some of the most promising branches of the royal tree had been cut down in his lifetime and many of his successors should suffer in like manner for their personal sins; although many reverses and revolutions may overtake his race and his kingdom, yet it was to him a subject of the highest joy and thankfulness that God will inviolably maintain His covenant with his family, until the advent of his greatest Son, the Messiah, who was the special object of his desire, and the author of his salvation.
Clarke -> 2Sa 23:5
Clarke: 2Sa 23:5 - -- Although my house be not so with God - Instead of כן ken , so, read כן kun , established; and let the whole verse be considered as an interrog...
Although my house be not so with God - Instead of
TSK -> 2Sa 23:5
TSK: 2Sa 23:5 - -- Although : 2Sa 7:18, 2Sa 12:10, 2Sa 13:14, 2Sa 13:28, 2Sa 18:14; 1Ki 1:5, 1Ki 2:24, 1Ki 2:25, 1Ki 11:6-8, 1Ki 12:14
he hath made : 2Sa 7:14-16; 1Ch 17...
Although : 2Sa 7:18, 2Sa 12:10, 2Sa 13:14, 2Sa 13:28, 2Sa 18:14; 1Ki 1:5, 1Ki 2:24, 1Ki 2:25, 1Ki 11:6-8, 1Ki 12:14
he hath made : 2Sa 7:14-16; 1Ch 17:11-14; Psa 89:3, Psa 89:28; Isa 9:6, Isa 9:7, Isa 55:3, Isa 61:8; Jer 32:40; Jer 33:25, Jer 33:26; Eze 37:26; Heb 13:20
and sure : 1Sa 2:35, 1Sa 25:28; 1Ki 11:38; Act 13:34; Heb 6:19
all my salvation : Psa 62:2, Psa 119:81
desire : Psa 27:4, Psa 63:1-3, Psa 73:25, Psa 73:26
to grow : Isa 4:2, Isa 7:14, Isa 9:6, Isa 9:7, Isa 11:1, Isa 27:6; Amo 9:11; 1Co 3:6, 1Co 3:7
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> 2Sa 23:5
Barnes: 2Sa 23:5 - -- Although my house ... - The sense of this clause (according to the the King James Version) will be that David comparing the actual state of his...
Although my house ... - The sense of this clause (according to the the King James Version) will be that David comparing the actual state of his family and kingdom during the later years of trouble and disaster with the prophetic description of the prosperity of the righteous king, and seeing how far it falls short, comforts himself by the terms of God’ s covenant 2Sa 7:12-16 and looks forward to Messiah’ s kingdom. The latter clause, "although he make it not to grow,"must then mean that, although at the present time the glory of his house was not made to grow, yet all his salvation and all his desire was made sure in the covenant which would be fulfilled in due time. But most modern commentators understand both clauses as follows: "Is not my house so with God that He has made with me an everlasting covenant,"etc.? "For all my salvation and all my desire, will He not cause it to spring up?"namely, in the kingdom of Solomon, and still more fully in the kingdom of Christ.
Poole -> 2Sa 23:5
Poole: 2Sa 23:5 - -- Although my house be not so with God although God knows that neither I nor my children have lived and ruled as we should have done, so justly, and in...
Although my house be not so with God although God knows that neither I nor my children have lived and ruled as we should have done, so justly, and in the fear of the Lord; and therefore have not enjoyed that uninterrupted prosperity which we might have enjoyed; but our morning light, or the beginning of that kingdom promised to me and mine for ever, hath been overcast with many black and dismal clouds, and my children have not hitherto been like the tender grass springing out of the earth, and thriving by the influences of the sun and rain; but rather like the grass that withereth away, or is cut off before its due time.
Yet he hath made with me an everlasting covenant: not-withstanding all our transgressions whereby we have broken covenant with God, and the confusions and civil wars. which have threatened our dissipation and utter destruction; yet I comfort myself with this, that God, to whom all my sins were foreknown before I committed them, was graciously pleased to make a sure covenant, to give and continue the kingdom to me and to my seed for ever, 2Sa 7:16 , until the coming of the Messias, who is to be my Son and successor, and whose kingdom shall have no end.
Ordered in all things ordained in all points by God’ s eternal and unchangeable counsel; and disposed by his wise and powerful providence, which doth and will overrule all things, even the sins and sufferings of my house, so far, that although he would punish them for their sins, yet he will not utterly root them out, nor break his covenant made with me and mine; as is said, Psa 89:31-34 . Sure, or preserved or observed, or kept , to wit, on God’ s part, or by God’ s power and faithfulness, in the midst of all the oppositions and uncertainties to which it seems to be exposed on our part. Compare Rom 3:3 2Ti 2:13 . For , or therefore , as the Hebrew particle chi oft signifies; therefore, i.e. because God hath made such a covenant. This is , or, he is , he who hath made this covenant; or, in this is , i.e. it consists in and depends upon this covenant.
All my salvation both my own eternal salvation, and the temporal salvation, or the preservation of the kingdom to me and mine.
All my desire or, every desirable thing ; the word desire being oft put for desired , or a desirable thing ; as Psa 21:2 78:29,30 Eze 24:16 . David being deeply sensible, and having had large experience, of the vanity and uncertainty of all earthly things, here declares that the covenant made by God with him and his in the Messias, is the only happiness which he prizeth and desireth, in which he doth fully acquiesce.
Although he make it not to grow i.e. my house, mentioned before. So the sense is, Although God as yet hath not made my house or family to grow, i.e. to increase, or to flourish with worldly glory and prosperity, as I expected; but hath for my sins cut off divers of my most eminent branches, and sorely afflicted my person and family; and although he may for the future deal in like manner with my sons and successors for the like miscarriages, which it is probable they may commit: yet this is my great support and comfort, that God will constantly and inviolably keep this covenant; and therefore, in the midst of all the shakings, and confusions, and interruptions which may happen in my house and kingdom, will preserve my line and family until the coming of the Messiah out of my loins, whose kingdom is an everlasting kingdom; who, as he is the desire of all nations, Hag 2:7 , so in a special manner is my desire, and the author of all my salvation.
Haydock -> 2Sa 23:5
Haydock: 2Sa 23:5 - -- Neither is my house, &c. As if he should say: This everlasting covenant was not due to my house: but purely owing to his bounty, who is all my salva...
Neither is my house, &c. As if he should say: This everlasting covenant was not due to my house: but purely owing to his bounty, who is all my salvation, and my will; that is, who hath always saved me, and granted me what I desired of him; so that I and my house, through his blessing, have sprung up, and succeeded in all things. (Challoner) ---
He clearly distinguishes between the covenant made with him as to his earthy kingdom, and that which regards Christ. (Worthington) ---
Even the former should be of long duration, Psalm cxxxi. 11. (Haydock) ---
Up. Hebrew seems to contradict all that had gone before; "for it shall not flourish." (Calmet) ---
Protestants, "although he make it not to grow;" (Haydock) unless we read with an interrogation, "And shall not my family flourish?" which was a natural reverence to ver. 4. (Calmet) ---
God had blessed David with the dew of heaven, and with the fatness of the earth. (Menochius) ---
His glory and happiness should not be of short duration, like the brightest summer-day, or a transient flower. (Haydock)
Gill -> 2Sa 23:5
Gill: 2Sa 23:5 - -- Although my house be not so with God,.... So bright, and flourishing, and prosperous as the government of the just ruler before described; or is not ...
Although my house be not so with God,.... So bright, and flourishing, and prosperous as the government of the just ruler before described; or is not "right" m with God, meaning his family, in which great sins were committed, and great disorders and confusions brought into it, as the cases of Amnon, Absalom, and Adonijah showed; or "not firm" or "stable" n, through the rebellion of one, the insurrection of another, and the usurpation of a third; yet he believed it would be firm and stable in the Messiah that should spring from him, promised in the everlasting covenant; though the Jewish writers understand this of the firmness and stability of his kingdom and government: "but my house is not so", &c. like the morning light, which increases by little and little, and like the morning, which sometimes is not cloudy, and sometimes is; sometimes the sun shines clearly, and sometimes not; or like the tender grass, which is sometimes flourishing, and after withers; but so is not my kingdom, it is a perpetual one, given and secured by an everlasting covenant; and such certainly is or will be the kingdom of the Messiah:
yet he hath made with me an everlasting covenant, ordered in all things, and sure; or, "for o he hath made", &c. the covenant by which the kingdom was settled on David and his seed was a covenant that would continue for ever, and would be kept, "observed", and "preserved" p in all the articles of it, and so be sure to his seed, particularly to the Messiah that should spring from him, in whom it was fulfilled, Luk 1:32; and the covenant of grace made with David's antitype, with Christ the head of the church, and the representative of it, and so with all his people in him, is an everlasting one: it was made with Christ from everlasting, as appears from the everlasting love of God, the source and spring of it; the earliness of the divine counsels on which it is formed, and blessings and promises of it, with which it is filled, which were before the world was; and from Christ being set up as the Mediator of it from everlasting: and it will continue to everlasting; it is a covenant that cannot be broken, will never be removed, nor give way to or be succeeded by another: it is "ordered in all things": to promote and advance the glory of all the three Persons in the Godhead, Father, Son, and Spirit; to secure the persons of the saints, and to provide everything needful for them for time and eternity: and it is "sure"; it stands upon a sure basis, the unchangeable will and favour of God, and is in the hands of Christ, the same today, yesterday, and for ever; its mercies are the sure mercies of David, and its promises are yea and amen in Christ, and are sure to all the seed. Though things may not be with them God-ward, as they desire, and could be wished for; though they may be attended with many sins and infirmities, the temptations of Satan, divine desertions, and various afflictions, and be guilty of many backslidings, yet covenant interest always continues; and so, though in the kingdom and interest of Christ in the world, there are, and may be, many things disagreeable; it may be attended with persecutions, heresies, scandals, &c. yet it shall continue and increase, and spread, and be an everlasting kingdom:
for this is all my salvation: all depends upon this covenant; the safety of David's family, and the security of the kingdom in it, and to his seed, till the Messiah came, depended on the covenant made with him respecting that; and the spiritual and eternal salvation of the Lord's people depends upon the covenant of grace; which was contrived, formed, and settled in it, in which the Saviour is provided, and the persons to share in his salvation are taken into it and secured, with all blessings both of grace and glory:
and all my desire; to see it fulfilled; as it is the desire of good men to be led more and more into it, to see their interest in it, to have the blessings and promises of it applied unto them, and to be saved by it, and not by the covenant of works; and there is all that in it that a believer can desire to make him comfortable here, or happy hereafter; and it is what gives him delight and pleasure in all his troubles: it may be supplied he is, as well as "this is", and be applied to Christ, the ruler over men, described, 2Sa 23:3; with whom the covenant of grace is made, in whom is the salvation of men; he is the author and the only author of it; in whom it is complete and perfect; "all" salvation is in him, and which they can claim as theirs; to whom is "all their desire"; and in whom is "all their delight", as it may be rendered; on account of the glory of his person, the fulness of his grace, and his suitableness as a Saviour; whom they desire to know more of, and have more communion with:
although he made it not to grow; though there may not be at present any growth of outward prosperity, or of inward grace, or even of the produce of the earth, Hab 3:17; though the horn of David is not yet made to bud, or his family in growing and flourishing circumstances, or the Messiah, the man, the branch, does not yet shoot forth, though he certainly would; or, "for shall he not bud forth" he shall, Jer 23:5.
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes: 2Sa 23:5 Heb “for all my deliverance and every desire, surely does he not make [it] grow?”
Geneva Bible -> 2Sa 23:5
Geneva Bible: 2Sa 23:5 Although my house [be] not so with God; yet he hath made with me an everlasting covenant, ordered in all [things], and sure: for [this is] all my salv...
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> 2Sa 23:1-39
TSK Synopsis: 2Sa 23:1-39 - --1 David, in his last words, professes his faith in God's promises to be beyond sense or experience.6 The different state of the wicked.8 A catalogue o...
Maclaren -> 2Sa 23:1-7
Maclaren: 2Sa 23:1-7 - --2 Samuel 23:1-7
It was fitting that the last words of David' should be a prophecy of the true King, whom his own failures and sins, no less than his c...
MHCC -> 2Sa 23:1-7
MHCC: 2Sa 23:1-7 - --These words of David are very worthy of regard. Let those who have had long experience of God's goodness, and the pleasantness of heavenly wisdom, whe...
Matthew Henry -> 2Sa 23:1-7
Matthew Henry: 2Sa 23:1-7 - -- We have here the last will and testament of king David, or a codicil annexed to it, after he had settled the crown upon Solomon and his treasures up...
Keil-Delitzsch -> 2Sa 23:1-7
Keil-Delitzsch: 2Sa 23:1-7 - --
The psalm of thanksgiving, in which David praised the Lord for all the deliverances and benefits that he had experienced throughout the whole of his...
Constable -> 2Sa 21:1--24:25; 2Sa 23:1-7
Constable: 2Sa 21:1--24:25 - --VII. SUMMARY ILLUSTRATIONS chs. 21--24
The last major section of the Book of Samuel (2 Sam. 21-24) consists of s...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)