![](images/minus.gif)
Text -- Acts 19:34-41 (NET)
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/information.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Robertson: Act 19:34 - -- When they perceived ( epignontes ).
Recognizing, coming to know fully and clearly (epì‡ ), second aorist (ingressive) active participle of epiginò...
When they perceived (
Recognizing, coming to know fully and clearly (
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:34 - -- An with one voice cried out ( pò„hnè„ egeneto mia ek pantò„n krazontò„n ).
Anacoluthon or construction according to sense. Literally, "one voice ...
An with one voice cried out (
Anacoluthon or construction according to sense. Literally, "one voice arose from all crying."
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:35 - -- The town-clerk ( ho grammateus ).
Ephesus was a free city and elected its own officers and the recorder or secretary was the chief magistrate of the ...
The town-clerk (
Ephesus was a free city and elected its own officers and the recorder or secretary was the chief magistrate of the city, though the proconsul of the province of Asia resided there. This officer is not a mere secretary of another officer or like the copyists and students of the law among the Jews, but the most influential person in Ephesus who drafted decrees with the aid of the
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:35 - -- Had quieted the multitude ( katasteilas ton ochlon ).
First aorist active participle of katastellò„ , to send down, arrange dress (Euripides), lower...
Had quieted the multitude (
First aorist active participle of
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Saith (
Historical present for vividness.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:35 - -- How that.
Merely participle ousan and accusative polin in indirect discourse, no conjunction at all (Robertson, Grammar , pp. 1040ff.), common i...
How that.
Merely participle
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:35 - -- Temple-keeper ( neò„koron ).
Old word from neò„s (naos' , temple, and koreò„ , to sweep. Warden, verger, cleaner of the temple, a sacristan. So ...
Temple-keeper (
Old word from
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:35 - -- And of the image which fell down from Jupiter ( kai tou diopetous ).
Supply agalma (image), "the from heaven-fallen image."From Zeus (Dios ) and p...
And of the image which fell down from Jupiter (
Supply
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:36 - -- Cannot be gainsaid ( anantirà„tn oun ontò„n ).
Genitive absolute with oun (therefore). Undeniable (an , anti , rà„tos ), verbal adjective. Oc...
Cannot be gainsaid (
Genitive absolute with
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:36 - -- Ye ought ( deon estin ).
It is necessary. Periphrastic present indicative instead of dei like 1Pe 1:6; 1Ti 5:13.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:36 - -- Be quiet ( katestalmenous ).
Perfect passive participle of katastellò„ (see Act 19:35).
Be quiet (
Perfect passive participle of
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:36 - -- Rash ( propetes ).
Old adjective from pro and petò„ , to fall forward, headlong, precipitate. In the N.T. only here and 2Ti 3:4, though common in ...
Rash (
Old adjective from
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:37 - -- Neither robbers of temples ( oute hierosulous ).
Common word in Greek writers from hieron , temple, and sulaò„ , to rob, be guilty of sacrilege. The...
Neither robbers of temples (
Common word in Greek writers from
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:37 - -- Nor blasphemers of our goddess ( oute blasphà„mountas tà„n theon hè„mò„n ).
Nor those who blasphemed our goddess. That is to say, these men (Gaiu...
Nor blasphemers of our goddess (
Nor those who blasphemed our goddess. That is to say, these men (Gaius and Aristarchus) as Christians had so conducted themselves (Col 4:5) that no charge could be placed against them either in act (temple-robbery) or word (blasphemy). They had done a rash thing since these men are innocent. Paul had used tact in Ephesus as in Athens in avoiding illegalities.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:38 - -- Have a matter against any one ( echousin pros tina logon ).
For this use of echò„ logon with pros See note on Mat 5:32; and note on Col 3:13. Th...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:38 - -- The courts are open ( agoraioi agontai ).
Supply hà„merai (days), court days are kept, or sunodoi , court-meetings are now going on, Vulgate conv...
The courts are open (
Supply
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:38 - -- And there are proconsuls ( kai anthupatoi eisin ).
Asia was a senatorial province and so had proconsuls (general phrase) though only one at a time, "...
And there are proconsuls (
Asia was a senatorial province and so had proconsuls (general phrase) though only one at a time, "a rhetorical plural"(Lightfoot). Page quotes from an inscription of the age of Trajan on an aqueduct at Ephesus in which some of Luke’ s very words occur (
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:38 - -- Let them accuse one another ( egkaleitò„san allè„lois ).
Present active imperative of egkaleò„ (en , kaleò„ ), old verb to call in one’ ...
Let them accuse one another (
Present active imperative of
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:39 - -- Anything about other matters ( tò„i peraiterò„ ).
Most MSS. here have tò„i peri heterò„n , but B b Vulgate read tò„i peraiterò„ as in Plato...
Anything about other matters (
Most MSS. here have
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:40 - -- For indeed we are in danger to be accused concerning this day’ s riot ( kai gar kinduneuomen egkaleisthai staseò„s peri tè„s sà„meron ).
The ...
For indeed we are in danger to be accused concerning this day’ s riot (
The text is uncertain. The text of Westcott and Hort means "to be accused of insurrection concerning today’ s assembly."The peril was real.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:40 - -- There being no cause for it ( mà„denos aitiou huparchontos ).
Genitive absolute with aitios , common adjective (cf. aitia , cause) though in N.T. on...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:40 - -- And as touching it ( peri hou ).
"Concerning which."But what? No clear antecedent, only the general idea.
And as touching it (
"Concerning which."But what? No clear antecedent, only the general idea.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:40 - -- Give an account of this concourse ( apodounai logon peri tè„s sustrophè„s tautè„s ).
Rationem reddere . They will have to explain matters to the ...
Give an account of this concourse (
Rationem reddere . They will have to explain matters to the proconsul.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Robertson: Act 19:41 - -- Dismissed the assembly ( apelusen tè„n ekklè„sian ).
The town-clerk thus gave a semblance of law and order to the mob by formally dismissing them, ...
Dismissed the assembly (
The town-clerk thus gave a semblance of law and order to the mob by formally dismissing them, this much to protect them against the charge to which they were liable. This vivid, graphic picture given by Luke has all the earmarks of historical accuracy. Paul does not describe the incidents in his letters, was not in the theatre in fact, but Luke evidently obtained the details from one who was there. Aristarchus, we know, was with Luke in Caesarea and in Rome and could have supplied all the data necessary. Certainly both Gaius and Aristarchus were lively witnesses of these events since their own lives were involved.
Vincent: Act 19:34 - -- With one voice cried out
The reverberations of their voices from the steep rock which formed one side of the theatre must have rendered their fre...
With one voice cried out
The reverberations of their voices from the steep rock which formed one side of the theatre must have rendered their frenzied cries still more terrific.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 19:35 - -- The town-clerk
Or recorder, who had charge of the city-archives, and whose duty it was to draw up official decrees and present them to assembli...
The town-clerk
Or recorder, who had charge of the city-archives, and whose duty it was to draw up official decrees and present them to assemblies of the people. Next to the commander, he was the most important personage in the Greek free cities.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 19:35 - -- Worshipper ( νεωκὸÏον )
Lit., a temple-sweeper. See on Act 19:27. This title, originally applied to the lowest menials of the temple,...
Worshipper (
Lit., a temple-sweeper. See on Act 19:27. This title, originally applied to the lowest menials of the temple, became a title of honor, and was eagerly appropriated by the most famous cities. Alexander says, " The city of Ephesus is the sacristan of the great goddess Artemis."
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 19:36 - -- Quiet ( κατεσταλμὲνους )
Compare quieted (Act 19:35). The verb means to let down or lower; and so is applied, metaphoricall...
Quiet (
Compare quieted (Act 19:35). The verb means to let down or lower; and so is applied, metaphorically, to keeping one's self in check; repressing.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Rash (
Lit., headlong.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 19:37 - -- Robbers of churches ( ὶ”εÏοσὺλους )
The A. V. puts a droll anachronism into the mouth of the town-clerk of a Greek city. Render, rat...
Robbers of churches (
The A. V. puts a droll anachronism into the mouth of the town-clerk of a Greek city. Render, rather, as Rev., robbers of temples.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 19:38 - -- The law is open ( ὰ“γοÏαῖοι ᾶγονται )
Lit., the court-days are being kept. Rev., the courts are open . Compare Rev 17:5.
The law is open (
Lit., the court-days are being kept. Rev., the courts are open . Compare Rev 17:5.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 19:38 - -- Deputies ( ὰ“νθὺπατοι )
Proconsuls, by whom Asia, as a senatorial province, was governed. See Introduction to Luke.
Deputies (
Proconsuls, by whom Asia, as a senatorial province, was governed. See Introduction to Luke.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Vincent: Act 19:40 - -- Concourse ( συστÏοφῆς )
Lit., a twisting together: hence of anything which is rolled or twisted into a mass; and so of a mass of peo...
Concourse (
Lit., a twisting together: hence of anything which is rolled or twisted into a mass; and so of a mass of people, with an underlying idea of confusion: a mob. Compare Act 23:12.
Wesley: Act 19:34 - -- And consequently an enemy to their worship of images; they prevented him, by crying, Great is Diana of the Ephesians.
And consequently an enemy to their worship of images; they prevented him, by crying, Great is Diana of the Ephesians.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Probably the chief governor of the public games.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: Act 19:35 - -- They believed that very image of Diana, which stood in her temple, fell down from Jupiter in heaven. Perhaps he designed to insinuate, as if falling d...
They believed that very image of Diana, which stood in her temple, fell down from Jupiter in heaven. Perhaps he designed to insinuate, as if falling down from Jupiter, it was not made with hands, and so was not that sort of idols which Paul had said were no gods.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
They simply declared the one God, and the vanity of idols in general.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
One in every province. There was one at Ephesus.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: Act 19:39 - -- In such a regular assembly as has authority to judge of religious and political affairs.
In such a regular assembly as has authority to judge of religious and political affairs.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
He wisely calls it by an inoffensive name.
With noble forgetfulness of self.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
The demos, that is, the people met in public assembly.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 19:30-34 - -- The tense used implies only that they were using their efforts to restrain him; which might have been unavailing but for what follows.
The tense used implies only that they were using their efforts to restrain him; which might have been unavailing but for what follows.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 19:34 - -- The very appearance of a Jew had the opposite effect to that intended. To prevent him obtaining a hearing, they drowned his voice in one tumultuous sh...
The very appearance of a Jew had the opposite effect to that intended. To prevent him obtaining a hearing, they drowned his voice in one tumultuous shout in honor of their goddess, which rose to such frantic enthusiasm as took two hours to exhaust itself.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Keeper of the public archives, and a magistrate of great authority.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 19:35-41 - -- "the multitude," which the very presence of such an officer would go far to do.
"the multitude," which the very presence of such an officer would go far to do.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 19:35-41 - -- Literally, the neocoros or "warden." The word means "temple-sweeper"; then, "temple-guardian." Thirteen cities of Asia had an interest in the temple, ...
Literally, the neocoros or "warden." The word means "temple-sweeper"; then, "temple-guardian." Thirteen cities of Asia had an interest in the temple, but Ephesus was honored with the charge of it. (Various cities have claimed this title with reference to the Virgin or certain saints) [WEBSTER and WILKINSON].
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 19:35-41 - -- "from the sky" or "from heaven." See on Act 19:27. "With this we may compare various legends concerning images and pictures in the Romish Church, such...
"from the sky" or "from heaven." See on Act 19:27. "With this we may compare various legends concerning images and pictures in the Romish Church, such as the traditional likenesses of Christ, which were said to be "not made with hands"" [WEBSTER and WILKINSON].
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 19:36 - -- Like a true legal man, he urges that such was notoriously the constitution and fixed character of the city, with which its very existence was all but ...
Like a true legal man, he urges that such was notoriously the constitution and fixed character of the city, with which its very existence was all but bound up. Did they suppose that all this was going to be overturned by a set of itinerant orators? Ridiculous! What did they mean, then, by raising such a stir?
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
"temple-plunderers," or sacrilegious persons.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Act 19:37 - -- This is a remarkable testimony, showing that the apostle had, in preaching against idolatry, studiously avoided (as at Athens) insulting the feelings ...
This is a remarkable testimony, showing that the apostle had, in preaching against idolatry, studiously avoided (as at Athens) insulting the feelings of those whom he addressed--a lesson this to missionaries and ministers in general.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Rather, "the court days are being held."
Clarke: Act 19:35 - -- When the town-clerk - Ὸ”γÏαμματευς, Literally, the scribe. The Syriac has reisha damedinato , the chief or prince of the city. The late...
When the town-clerk -
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 19:35 - -- Ye men of Ephesus - The speech of this man may be thus analyzed
1. He states that there was no need of a public declaration that t...
Ye men of Ephesus - The speech of this man may be thus analyzed
1. He states that there was no need of a public declaration that the Ephesians were worshippers of Diana; this every person knew, and nobody attempted to contest it, Act 19:35, Act 19:36
2. That the persons accused were not guilty of any public offense, nor of any breach of the laws of the city, Act 19:37
3. That, if they were, this was not a legal method of prosecuting them, Act 19:38, Act 19:39
4. That they themselves, by this tumultuous meeting, had exposed themselves to the censure of the law, and were in danger of being called into question for it, Act 19:40. See Dodd
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 19:35 - -- Is a worshipper of the great goddess Diana - The word νεωκοÏος, neocoros , which we translate worshipper, signified at first, among the anc...
Is a worshipper of the great goddess Diana - The word
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 19:35 - -- Of the image which fell down from Jupiter? - The original image of the Ephesian Diana (see on Act 19:27 (note)) was supposed to have descended from ...
Of the image which fell down from Jupiter? - The original image of the Ephesian Diana (see on Act 19:27 (note)) was supposed to have descended from heaven; which intimates that it was so old that no person knew either its maker or the time in which it was formed, and it was the interest of the priests to persuade the people that this image had been sent to them as a present from Jupiter himself. Several images and sacred things were supposed, among the heathens, to be presents immediately from heaven. Euripides states the image of Diana of Tauri to be of this kind; and calls it
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 19:37 - -- These men - are neither robbers of churches - Ὶ”Ïεσυλους ; Spoilers of sacred places. As his design evidently was to appease and concilia...
These men - are neither robbers of churches -
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 19:38 - -- If Demetrius - have a matter against any man - If it be any breach of law, in reference to Demetrius and the artists, the law is open, αγοÏαι...
If Demetrius - have a matter against any man - If it be any breach of law, in reference to Demetrius and the artists, the law is open,
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 19:39 - -- But if ye inquire any thing concerning other matters - In which the safety of the state, or the national worship, is concerned, know that such a mat...
But if ye inquire any thing concerning other matters - In which the safety of the state, or the national worship, is concerned, know that such a matter is not the business of the mob; it must be heard and determined in a lawful assembly,
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 19:40 - -- For we are in danger, etc. - Popular commotions were always dreaded by the Roman government; and so they should by all governments; for, when might ...
For we are in danger, etc. - Popular commotions were always dreaded by the Roman government; and so they should by all governments; for, when might has nothing to direct its operations but passion, how destructive must these operations be! One of the Roman laws made all such commotions of the people capital offenses against those who raised them. Qui caetum et concursus fecerit, capite puniatur : "He who raises a mob shall forfeit his life."If such a law existed at Ephesus - and it probably did, from this reference to it in the words of the town-clerk or recorder - then Demetrius must feel himself in great personal danger; and that his own life lay now at the mercy of those whom he had accused, concerning whom he had raised such an outcry, and against whom nothing disorderly could be proved.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Act 19:41 - -- He dismissed the assembly - Την εκκλησιαν . Another proof that the word εκκλησια, which we generally translate church, signifi...
He dismissed the assembly -
1. How forcible are right words! From the conduct of this prudent, sensible man, we may learn how much influence persons of this character may have, even over the unbridled multitude. But, where the civil power associates itself with the lawless might of the many, There must be confusion and every evil work. What a blessing to the community is the civil law! Were it not for this, the unthinking multitude would destroy others, and at last destroy themselves. Law and justice are from God; and the civil power, by which they are supported and administered, should be respected by all who regard the safety of their persons or property
2. Though the ministry of St. Paul was greatly blessed at Ephesus, and his preaching appears to have been very popular, yet this sunshine was soon darkened: peace with the world cannot last long; the way of the Lord will always be opposed by those who love their own ways
3. How few would make an outward profession of religion, were there no gain connected with it! And yet, as one justly observes, religion is rendered gainful only by some external part of it. For this very reason, the external part of religion is always on the increase, and none can find fault with it without raising storms and tempests; while the internal part wastes and decays, no man laying it to heart. Demetrius and his fellows would have made no stir for their worship, had not the apostle’ s preaching tended to discredit that by which they got their wealth. Most of the outcries that have been made against all revivals of religion - revivals by which the Church has been called back to its primitive principles and purity, have arisen out of self-interest. The cry of, the Church is in danger, has been echoed only by those who found their secular interest at stake; and knew that reformation must unmask them and show that the slothful and wicked servants could no longer be permitted to live on the revenues of that Church which they disgraced by their lives, and corrupted by their false doctrines. He that eats the Church’ s bread should do the Church’ s world: and he that will not work should not be permitted to eat.
Calvin: Act 19:34 - -- 34.Great is Diana of the Ephesians This was a clamorous confession, but without any soundness; neither did it proceed from the faith of the heart. Fo...
34.Great is Diana of the Ephesians This was a clamorous confession, but without any soundness; neither did it proceed from the faith of the heart. For whence came that great divinity of Diana whereof they spake, save only because like mad men they furiously defend that error which they had once received? It fareth otherwise with true godliness, that we believe with the heart unto righteousness, and then doth the confession of the mouth follow to salvation. Therein doth the distemperature and mad stubbornness of all mad men and brain-sick fools differ from the constancy and zeal of the martyrs. And yet, notwithstanding, our sluggishness is shameful if we be not as ready and stout in the confession of a sure faith as are they in their filthy error. For we see what the Spirit of God prescribeth unto us by the mouth of David, −
“ I believed, and therefore will I speak,†( Psa 116:10).
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Calvin: Act 19:35 - -- 35. Luke showeth in this place that the tumult was so appeased, that yet, notwithstanding, superstition prevailed with the mad people, and the truth...
35. Luke showeth in this place that the tumult was so appeased, that yet, notwithstanding, superstition prevailed with the mad people, and the truth of God was not heard. For the town-clerk, as politic men use to do, counteth it sufficient for him if he can by any means appease the outrageous multitude. Nevertheless, the cause itself is oppressed. He saw undoubtedly Demetrius’ malice, and how he had troubled the city, abusing the pretense of religion for his own private gain; but he toucheth not that wound which he knew to be unknown to the unskillful. Nevertheless, to the end he may stay the uproar and contention, he extolleth the reigned power of Diana, and maintaineth her superstitious worship. If Paul had been in the common place − 398 at that time, he would rather have suffered death an hundred times than have suffered himself to be delivered from danger paying so dear for it. For though the town-clerk had not been by him commanded to speak thus, yet it should have been treacherous dissimulation in a public witness and preacher of heavenly doctrine. The scribe affirmeth that the image which the Ephesians did worship came down from heaven, and that Paul and his companions spake no blasphemy against their goddess. Could he have holden his peace, but he must needs by his silence have allowed his false excuse? And this had been to shake hands with idolatry. Therefore, it was not without cause that Luke said before that Paul was kept back by the brethren, and not suffered to enter into the common place [theater]. −
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Calvin: Act 19:37 - -- 37.Men which are neither church-robbers He doth both truly and well deny that they be church-robbers; but he doth shortly after falsely define the ki...
37.Men which are neither church-robbers He doth both truly and well deny that they be church-robbers; but he doth shortly after falsely define the kind of church-robbery to speak blasphemously against Diana. For seeing that all superstition is profane and polluted, it followeth that those be sacrilegious persons who translate the honor which is due to God alone unto idols. But the wisdom of the town-clerk, and that carnal, is here commended, and not his godliness. For he had respect unto this alone to extinguish the heat of the uproar; and therefore doth he at length conclude, if Demetrius have any private matter, there be judgment-seats and magistrates. And that public affairs must be handled in a lawful, and not in a disordered assembly — in an assembly gathered by the commandment of the magistrates, and not in a concourse which is without consideration, run together through the motion of one man, and to satisfy his appetite. − 399 He calleth them deputies, − 400 in the plural number, not that Asia had more than one, but because legates did sometimes keep courts in the place of the deputies. Also, he appeaseth them by putting them in fear, because the deputy had occasion offered to punish and fine the city sore. − 401
Defender -> Act 19:35
Defender: Act 19:35 - -- This tradition was derived from the fact that a large meteorite had fallen from the sky into Ephesus. It apparently had a shape which the pagan leader...
This tradition was derived from the fact that a large meteorite had fallen from the sky into Ephesus. It apparently had a shape which the pagan leaders of Ephesus interpreted as a many-breasted female which they identified as an image of the goddess. Copies of this image thereafter became both commercially and religiously profitable to the Ephesians. Renaissance scholars denied that such an event could ever have happened until other meteorite falls began to be documented in modern times."
TSK: Act 19:34 - -- they knew : Act 19:26, Act 16:20; Rom 2:22
all : 1Ki 18:26; Mat 6:7
Great : Act 19:28; Rev 13:4
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
TSK: Act 19:35 - -- Ye men : Eph 2:12
a worshipper : Gr. the temple-keeper
and of : Act 19:26; 2Th 2:10,2Th 2:11; 1Ti 4:2
Jupiter : Act 14:12, Act 14:13
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
TSK: Act 19:38 - -- Demetrius : Act 19:24
have : Act 18:14; Deu 17:8; 1Co 6:1
the law is open : or, the court-days are kept
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes: Act 19:34 - -- But when they knew - When they perceived or ascertained. That he was a Jew - There was a general prejudice against the Jews. They were di...
But when they knew - When they perceived or ascertained.
That he was a Jew - There was a general prejudice against the Jews. They were disposed to charge the whole difficulty on Jews - esteeming Christians to be but a sect of the Jews. They were, therefore, indiscriminate in their wrath, and unwilling to listen to any defense.
With one voice - Unitedly, in one continued shout and clamor.
About the space of two hours - The day, from sunrise to sunset, among the Greeks and Romans, was divided into twelve equal parts, Joh 11:9. An hour, therefore, did not differ materially from an hour with us. It is not at all improbable that the tumult would continue for so long a time, before it would be possible to allay the excitement.
Cried out ... - This they at first did to silence Alexander. The shouting, however, was continued in order to evince their attachment to Diana, as would be natural in an excited and tumultuous mob of pagan worshippers.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Barnes: Act 19:35 - -- And when the town-clerk - ὸ” γÏαμματὲÏ…Ï‚ ho grammateus . The scribe; the secretary. This word is often used in the Bible, and...
And when the town-clerk -
Had appeased the people -
What man is there - Who is there that can deny this? It is universally known and admitted. This is the language of strong confidence, of reproof, and of indignation. It implied that the worship of Diana was so well established that there was no danger that it could be destroyed by a few Jews, and he therefore reproved them for what he deemed their unreasonable fears. But he little knew the power of that religion which had been the innocent cause of all this tumult; nor that, at no very distant period, this despised religion would overturn not only the worship of Diana at Ephesus, but the splendid idolatry of the mighty Roman empire.
Is a worshipper -
And of the image - A special guardian of the image, or statue of Diana.
Which fell down ... - Which was reigned or believed to have been sent down from heaven. See the notes on Act 19:27. It is probable that the image was so ancient that the maker of it was unknown, and it was therefore reigned to have fallen from heaven. It was for the interest of the priest to keep up this impression. Many cities pretended to have been favored in a similar manner with images or statues of the gods, sent directly from heaven. The safety of Troy was supposed to depend on the Palladium, or image of Pallas Minerva, which was believed to have fallen from heaven. Numa pretended that the ancilia, or sacred shields, had descended from heaven. Herodian expressly affirms that "the Phoenicians had no statue of the sun polished by the hand, but only a certain large stone, circular below, and terminated acutely above in the figure of a cone, of a black color, and that they believed it to have fallen from heaven."The same thing was affirmed of the ancient Minerva of the Athenian Acropolis (Paus., Att. 26); of the Paphian Venus, and the Ceres of Sicily (Cic. in Verr., v. 187). It has been supposed by some that this image at Ephesus was merely a conical or pyramidal stone which fell from the clouds - a meteorite - and that it was regarded with superstitious reverence, as having been sent from heaven. See the Edinburgh Encyclopedia’ s article, "Meteorites."
From Jupiter - See the notes on Act 14:12.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Barnes: Act 19:36 - -- Seeing then ... - Since no one can call in question the zeal of the Ephesians on this subject, or doubt the sincerity of their belief, and sinc...
Seeing then ... - Since no one can call in question the zeal of the Ephesians on this subject, or doubt the sincerity of their belief, and since there can be no danger that this well-established worship is to be destroyed by the efforts of a few evil-disposed Jews, there is no occasion for this tumult.
Be quiet - Be appeased. The same Greek word which is used in Acts . Act 19:35, "had appeased the people."
To do nothing rashly - To do nothing in a heated, inconsiderate manner. There is no occasion for tumult and riot. The whole difficulty can be settled in perfect consistency with the maintenance of order.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Barnes: Act 19:37 - -- For ye ... - Demetrius and his friends. The blame was to be traced to them. Which are neither robbers of churches - The word "churches"we...
For ye ... - Demetrius and his friends. The blame was to be traced to them.
Which are neither robbers of churches - The word "churches"we now apply to edifices reared for purposes of Christian worship. Since no such churches had then been built, this translation is unhappy, and is not at all demanded by the original. The Greek word
Nor yet blasphemers of your goddess - They had not used harsh or reproachful language of Diana. This had not been charged on them, nor is there the least evidence that they had done it. They had opposed idolatry; had reasoned against it; and had endeavored to turn the people from it. But there is not the least evidence that they had ever done it in harsh or reproachful language. This shows that people should employ reason, and not harsh or reproachful language against a pervading evil; and that the way to remove it is to enlighten the minds of people, and to convince them of the error of their ways. People gain nothing by bitter and reviling words; and it is much to obtain the testimony of even the enemies of religion as Paul did of the chancellor of Ephesus - that no such words had been used in describing their crimes and follies.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Barnes: Act 19:38 - -- Have a matter against any man - Have a complaint of injury; if injustice has been done them by anyone. The law is open - See the margin. ...
Have a matter against any man - Have a complaint of injury; if injustice has been done them by anyone.
The law is open - See the margin.
And there are deputies - Roman proconsuls. See the notes on Act 13:7. The cause might be brought before them with the certainty that it would be heard and decided. The Syriac reads this in the singular number "Lo, the proconsul is in the city."
Let them implead one another - Let them accuse each other in the court. The laws are equal, and impartial justice will be done.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Barnes: Act 19:39 - -- But if we inquire - If you seek to determine any other matters than that pertaining to the alleged wrong which Demetrius has suffered in his bu...
But if we inquire - If you seek to determine any other matters than that pertaining to the alleged wrong which Demetrius has suffered in his business.
Other matters - Anything respecting public affairs; anything pertaining to the government and the worship of Diana.
In a lawful assembly - In an assembly convened, not by tumult and riot, but in conformity to law. This was a tumultuous assemblage, and it was proper in the public officer to demand that they should disperse; and that, if there were any public grievances to be remedied, it should be done in an assembly properly convened. It may be remarked here that the original word rendered assembly is what is usually in the New Testament rendered church -
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Barnes: Act 19:40 - -- To be called in question - By the government; by the Roman authority. Such a tumult, continued for so long. a time, would be likely to attract ...
To be called in question - By the government; by the Roman authority. Such a tumult, continued for so long. a time, would be likely to attract the attention of the magistrates, and expose them to their displeasure. Popular commotions were justly dreaded by the Roman government; and such an assembly as this, convened without any good cause, would not escape their notice. There was a Roman law which made it capital for anyone to be engaged in promoting a riot. Sui coetum , et concursum fecerit , capite puniatur : "He who raises a mob, let him be punished with death."
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Barnes: Act 19:41 - -- Dismissed the assembly - τὴ€Î½ ὲ“κκλησὶαν tè„n ekklè„sian . The word usually translated "church."Here it is applied to th...
Dismissed the assembly -
Poole: Act 19:34 - -- A Jew and by consequence an enemy to their idolatry; and, as they might imagine at least, a friend to St. Paul.
All with one voice unanimity makes ...
A Jew and by consequence an enemy to their idolatry; and, as they might imagine at least, a friend to St. Paul.
All with one voice unanimity makes not the cause to be good, if it were bad at first.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: Act 19:35 - -- Town clerk or secretary, who registered their acts, and intervened in all their meetings.
Is a worshipper each country and city had their peculiar ...
Town clerk or secretary, who registered their acts, and intervened in all their meetings.
Is a worshipper each country and city had their peculiar gods, which they worshipped, and took for their patrons, as Ephesus did this goddess Diana. But the word here signifies a sacrist, or one that looks to the temple to keep it clean; especially that hath the charge of more solemn shows or sports in honour of any supposed deity: and these Ephesians took it to be their no small glory, that they were employed in such as belonged to Diana.
The image which fell down from Jupiter though the maker’ s name (Canetias) is upon record, yet it having lasted whilst the temple was six or seven times repaired, at least, if not renewed, and none ever remembering when it first was brought in amongst them, the crafty priests persuaded the credulous people that it was fallen from heaven, thereby getting more honour unto it, and profit to themselves.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: Act 19:36 - -- He did there cunningly than honestly endeavour to evade their clamour, and still their rage, by telling them (how fallaciously soever), that neither...
He did there cunningly than honestly endeavour to evade their clamour, and still their rage, by telling them (how fallaciously soever), that neither Paul, nor any other Christian or Jew, had any quarrel with their goddess or worship. For they indeed were against all images that were made with hands; but theirs was not such a one, it being fallen down from heaven. We must consider he was but a pagan; and his design was only to still the people; and populus vult decipi.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: Act 19:37 - -- Neither robbers of churches for they had not entered into their temple.
Nor yet blasphemers of your goddess Paul had barely preached this truth amo...
Neither robbers of churches for they had not entered into their temple.
Nor yet blasphemers of your goddess Paul had barely preached this truth amongst them, not upbraiding them for their idolatry; as Michael, the archangel, brought no railing accusation against the devil, when he contended with him, Jud 1:9 .
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: Act 19:38 - -- The law is open which is fittest to determine all questions and controversies; for men would be partial to their own cause, and every one challenge t...
The law is open which is fittest to determine all questions and controversies; for men would be partial to their own cause, and every one challenge to be in the right.
Deputies who, under the Roman emperors or consuls, had power to hear and determine of all matters.
Let them implead one another that so both parties may be heard.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: Act 19:39 - -- Other matters relating to the good government of the city, or maintaining the established religion, which ought not in such a confused manner to be t...
Other matters relating to the good government of the city, or maintaining the established religion, which ought not in such a confused manner to be treated of, but in an assembly called by lawful authority, which the Romans did usually call, at least, three times every month.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: Act 19:40 - -- He wisely minds them of their danger; for being under the power of the Romans, it was no less than the loss of their liberties to abet any faction o...
He wisely minds them of their danger; for being under the power of the Romans, it was no less than the loss of their liberties to abet any faction or sedition; and to make a concourse or meeting tumultuously together, was capital, unless it were upon the sudden invasion of an enemy, or to but out some raging fire.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: Act 19:41 - -- The people were persuaded quietly to depart to their homes. Thus God one way or other, sometimes by friends, and sometimes by foes, kept his church ...
The people were persuaded quietly to depart to their homes. Thus God one way or other, sometimes by friends, and sometimes by foes, kept his church and people from being ruined; and his hand is not shortened.
Haydock: Act 19:35 - -- The town-clerk, &c. Literally, the scribe, or the recorder of the city. ---
Jupiter's offspring. [2] His daughter, according to the poets. The Gr...
The town-clerk, &c. Literally, the scribe, or the recorder of the city. ---
Jupiter's offspring. [2] His daughter, according to the poets. The Greek text seems to signify a statue, or figure of Diana, which was pretended to have fallen from heaven, and from Jupiter. (Witham) ---
Is a worshipper. Greek: Neokoron ousan; the word Greek: Neokoros is found in this sense in the Arundelian marbles, and more frequently on ancient coins and inscriptions. Its derivation is from Greek: neos, a temple, and Greek: kore, a virgin, or rather Greek: korein, to cleanse and decorate; as if this city were especially destined to ornament the Diana of Ephesus, which the people supposed came to them not by the work of man, but a present from heaven.
===============================
[BIBLIOGRAPHY]
Jovisque prolis, Greek: kai tou diopetous. Simulachri a cælo dilapsi. See Suidas.
====================
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Haydock: Act 19:37 - -- Nor of blasphemy against your goddess. St. John Chrysostom takes notice, that to calm the people, he says more than was true. (Witham)
Nor of blasphemy against your goddess. St. John Chrysostom takes notice, that to calm the people, he says more than was true. (Witham)
Gill: Act 19:34 - -- But when they knew that he was a Jew,.... And so equally an enemy to their idolatry, as Paul and his companions were, whether he was a Christian or no...
But when they knew that he was a Jew,.... And so equally an enemy to their idolatry, as Paul and his companions were, whether he was a Christian or not.
All with one voice about the space of two hours cried out; all that were in the theatre lift up their voices at once to prevent Alexander's apology, or at least its being heard; and which they continued about two hours, which was a long time to keep hallooing out,
great is Diana of the Ephesians; See Gill on Act 19:28.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Act 19:35 - -- And when the town clerk had appeased the people,.... Caused them to cease their loud outcry, so as that he could be heard. This person seems to have b...
And when the town clerk had appeased the people,.... Caused them to cease their loud outcry, so as that he could be heard. This person seems to have been more than a "town clerk", as we render it; or a common "scribe", as the Vulgate Latin, Arabic, and Ethiopic versions render it; rather as the Syriac version, "a chief man of the city"; the Septuagint interpreters in Exo 5:6 use the word for the Egyptian officers that were over the Israelites; and the Babylonians used to call the priest of a Isis by this name; and according to some learned men, this man's office was to register the conquerors' names, and their rewards in the theatre; and who was chosen into this office by the people, and was a man of some considerable authority, as it is very apparent by what follows that this man was:
he said, ye men of Ephesus, what man is there that knoweth not how that the city of the Ephesians is a worshipper of the great goddess Diana? the word "Neocorus", translated "worshipper", signifies an officer in the temple, one that looked after it, beautified and adorned it; for "Neocorus" is from
and of the image which fell down from Jupiter; or "of Diopetes"; so the Palladium, or image of Pallas, was called, because it was supposed to fall down from heaven, which Diomedes and Ulysses are said to take away from Troy; and here it seems to be something distinct from the goddess Diana, and her image, and may design another deity worshipped along with her, and by them, since they make mention of more gods, Act 19:26. The Vulgate Latin version takes it to be the same with Diana, reading the words in connection with the preceding, "and the offspring of Jupiter"; she being said to be his daughter by Latona, as before observed; and the Ethiopic version understands it of her image, rendering them thus, "and of that molten image which was sent from Jupiter the great god"; and more expressly the Syriac version, which reads, "and of her image which fell from heaven"; and so was not made with the hands of men, and could not be objected to on that account, or denied to be a deity; and this the people might be the rather induced to believe, since it had been in the temple before the memory of any man. The Arabic version, reading these words in connection with the beginning of the next verse, gives a very different sense, "but neither indeed they that fell from heaven contradict the faith of this thing"; as if it was to be understood of the fallen angels, of which it can hardly be thought Demetrius had any knowledge. This image, Pliny says c, it was doubted of what it was made; some said of the vine tree, others of ebony; but Athenagoras says, the old image of Diana of the Ephesians was made of olive d.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Act 19:36 - -- Seeing then that these things cannot be spoken against,.... This officer intimates, in order to quiet the mob, and make them easy, that these things w...
Seeing then that these things cannot be spoken against,.... This officer intimates, in order to quiet the mob, and make them easy, that these things were so certain, and well known, that nobody would pretend to contradict them, and therefore they must be mistaken in the men, whom they had hurried into the theatre; it was impossible that they, or any men, should be capable of saying any thing against the truth of these things: therefore
ye ought to be quiet and do nothing rashly; to these men, to their hurt, but sit down, and compose yourselves, and think again, and consider of this matter, and not go into any hasty measures, which may, in the issue, be prejudicial to yourselves.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Act 19:37 - -- For ye have brought hither these men,.... The Arabic version reads, "these two men"; that is, Gaius and Aristarchus, whom they had brought by force in...
For ye have brought hither these men,.... The Arabic version reads, "these two men"; that is, Gaius and Aristarchus, whom they had brought by force into the theatre to fight with wild beasts:
which are neither robbers of churches; or "temples"; or, as the Arabic version renders it, "robbers of the vessels of the temple", sacrilegious persons; they have not stolen anything out of the temple of Diana, nor any other:
nor yet blasphemers of your goddess; they have not made mention of her name, much less said anything against her, at least this officer did not know that they had; and if he had, he did not stick to tell an officious lie to screen them, as did the Egyptian midwives in favour of the Hebrew women.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Act 19:38 - -- Wherefore if Demetrius, and the craftsmen which are with him,.... Who were the ringleaders and encouragers of this tumult:
have a matter against an...
Wherefore if Demetrius, and the craftsmen which are with him,.... Who were the ringleaders and encouragers of this tumult:
have a matter against any man; any accusation, or charge, any crime to accuse him of, and charge him with:
the law is open; or court days are kept; there are certain times fixed for the hearing and trying of causes, where and when such an affair should be regularly brought; and not use such disorderly methods, and throw a city into confusion, and break the peace as these men had done: the Syriac version renders it, "they are artificers"; that is, Demetrius and the craftsmen with him; they are tradesmen, and it does not belong to them, nor should they take upon themselves to judge and determine what is right or wrong:
and there are deputies; or "proconsuls"; the proconsul and his deputy, to whom such matters appertain, and who are judges in such cases, and to whom application should be made, and before whom such cases should be brought, and heard, and tried: the Syriac version reads in the singular number, "and there is a proconsul in the city"; a Roman governor and judge, whose province it is to determine such matters:
let them implead one another; let the plaintiff bring his accusation, and charge, and let the others defend themselves, and let things proceed in a due course of law, and so issue.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Act 19:39 - -- But if ye inquire anything concerning other matters,.... Than what belongs to the craft and business of Demetrius, and the artificers:
it shall be ...
But if ye inquire anything concerning other matters,.... Than what belongs to the craft and business of Demetrius, and the artificers:
it shall be determined in a lawful assembly; that is, called together according to law, and who have a right to hear, try, and judge causes, which such a confused lawless assembly as this in the theatre had not.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Act 19:40 - -- For we are in danger of being called in question,.... Or are liable to be called to an account, reproved, and punished by the Roman proconsul, appoint...
For we are in danger of being called in question,.... Or are liable to be called to an account, reproved, and punished by the Roman proconsul, appointed over this city, or by the Roman emperor, or the Roman senate: for this day's uproar; it being capable of being interpreted as a riot, tumult, and sedition:
there being no cause whereby we may give an account of this concourse: or no reason can be assigned, why such a number of people should gather together; none can be given that will justify it, or that can be alleged in favour of it.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Act 19:41 - -- And when he had thus spoken,.... Or delivered this oration, made use of the above arguments, reasonings, and expostulations:
he dismissed the assem...
And when he had thus spoken,.... Or delivered this oration, made use of the above arguments, reasonings, and expostulations:
he dismissed the assembly; he ordered them to break up, and every one to return home in peace, and go about his own business; and thus Paul, and his companions, were delivered from an imminent danger they were exposed to.
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes -> Act 19:34; Act 19:34; Act 19:34; Act 19:34; Act 19:35; Act 19:35; Act 19:35; Act 19:35; Act 19:35; Act 19:35; Act 19:36; Act 19:36; Act 19:36; Act 19:36; Act 19:37; Act 19:37; Act 19:38; Act 19:38; Act 19:38; Act 19:39; Act 19:39; Act 19:39; Act 19:40; Act 19:40; Act 19:40; Act 19:40; Act 19:41; Act 19:41; Act 19:41; Act 19:41
NET Notes: Act 19:34 They all shouted…for about two hours. The extent of the tumult shows the racial and social tensions of a cosmopolitan city like Ephesus, indicat...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: Act 19:35 The expression fell from heaven adds a note of apologetic about the heavenly origin of the goddess. The city’s identity and well-being was wrapp...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: Act 19:36 L&N 88.98 has “pertaining to impetuous and reckless behavior – ‘reckless, impetuous.’…‘so then, you must calm ...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: Act 19:37 Nor blasphemers of our goddess. There was no formal crime with which Paul could be charged. He had the right to his religion as long as he did not act...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: Act 19:38 The word “there” is not in the Greek text but is implied. The official’s request is that the legal system be respected.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: Act 19:40 Or “commotion.” BDAG 979 s.v. συστροφή 1 gives the meaning “a tumultuous gathering of peopl...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: Act 19:41 Verse 41 in the English text is included as part of verse 40 in the standard critical editions of the Greek NT.
Geneva Bible: Act 19:34 ( 9 ) But when they knew that he was a Jew, all with one voice about the space of two hours cried out, Great [is] Diana of the Ephesians.
( 9 ) Inste...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Geneva Bible: Act 19:35 ( 10 ) And when the townclerk had appeased the people, he said, [Ye] men of Ephesus, what man is there that knoweth not how that the city of the Ephes...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Geneva Bible: Act 19:38 Wherefore if Demetrius, and the craftsmen which are with him, have a ( o ) matter against any man, the ( p ) law is open, and there are ( q ) deputies...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Geneva Bible: Act 19:39 But if ye enquire any thing concerning other matters, it shall be determined in a ( r ) lawful assembly.
( r ) He speaks of a lawful assembly not onl...
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Act 19:1-41
TSK Synopsis: Act 19:1-41 - --1 The Holy Ghost is given by Paul's hands.8 The Jews blaspheme his doctrine, which is confirmed by miracles.13 The Jewish exorcists,16 are beaten by t...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Combined Bible: Act 19:35 - --The rage of an excited multitude, unless it find some new fuel to keep up the flame, will naturally subside in a few hours. While it is at its height,...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Maclaren -> Act 19:21-34
Maclaren: Act 19:21-34 - --The Fight With Wild Beasts At Ephesus
After these things were ended, Paul purposed in the spirit, when he had passed through Macedonia and Achaia, to...
MHCC -> Act 19:32-41
MHCC: Act 19:32-41 - --The Jews came forward in this tumult. Those who are thus careful to distinguish themselves from the servants of Christ now, and are afraid of being ta...
Matthew Henry -> Act 19:21-41
Matthew Henry: Act 19:21-41 - -- I. Paul is here brought into some trouble at Ephesus, just when he is forecasting to go thence, and to cut out work for himself elsewhere. See here,...
Barclay -> Act 19:23-41
Barclay: Act 19:23-41 - --This thrilling story sheds a great deal of light on the characters in it. First, there are Demetrius and the silversmiths. Their trouble was that t...
Constable: Act 9:32--Rom 1:1 - --III. THE WITNESS TO THE UTTERMOST PART OF THE EARTH 9:32--28:31
Luke next recorded the church's expansion beyond...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: Act 19:21--Rom 1:1 - --D. The extension of the church to Rome 19:21-28:31
"The panel is introduced by the programmatic statemen...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: Act 19:21--21:17 - --1. Ministry on the way to Jerusalem 19:21-21:16
At this point in his ministry Paul began to focu...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: Act 19:23-41 - --The riot in Ephesus 19:23-41
This incident reveals more about the effects of the gospel on Ephesian society and religion (cf. vv. 13-20).
"Luke's purp...
College -> Act 19:1-41
College: Act 19:1-41 - --ACTS 19
3. The Twelve Disciples at Ephesus (19:1-7)
1 While Apollos was at Corinth, Paul took the road through the interior and arrived at Ephesus. ...
McGarvey -> Act 19:32-34; Act 19:35-41
McGarvey: Act 19:32-34 - --32-34. Leaving the apostle, for a time, in the cloud of sorrow which we will find still enveloping him when we meet him again, we turn to witness the ...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)