collapse all  

Text -- Acts 5:39 (NET)

Strongs On/Off
Context
5:39 but if it is from God, you will not be able to stop them, or you may even be found fighting against God.” He convinced them,
Parallel   Cross Reference (TSK)   ITL  

Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics

Dictionary Themes and Topics: Scribes | Sanhedrim | Prisoners | Priest | Peter | Persecution | PAUL, THE APOSTLE, 4 | Minister | HAP; HAPLY | Government | God | Gamaliel | Court | COURTS, JUDICIAL | ACTS OF THE APOSTLES, 13-OUTLINE | more
Table of Contents

Word/Phrase Notes
Robertson , Vincent , JFB , Clarke , Defender , TSK

Word/Phrase Notes
Barnes , Poole , Haydock , Gill

Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes

Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis , Combined Bible , Maclaren , MHCC , Matthew Henry , Barclay , Constable , College , McGarvey

collapse all
Commentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)

Robertson: Act 5:39 - -- But if it is of God ( ei de ek theou estin ). The second alternative is a condition of the first class, determined as fulfilled, ei with the presen...

But if it is of God ( ei de ek theou estin ).

The second alternative is a condition of the first class, determined as fulfilled, ei with the present indicative. By the use of this idiom Gamaliel does put the case more strongly in favor of the apostles than against them. This condition assumes that the thing is so without affirming it to be true. On the basis of this alternative Gamaliel warns the Sanhedrin that they cannot "overthrow"(katalusai ) these men for they in that case must "overthrow"God, lest haply ye be found (mē potė̇hurethēte , negative purpose with first aorist passive subjunctive) even to be fighting against God (kai theomachoi , late adjective from theos and machomai , in lxx and here only in the N.T.).

Vincent: Act 5:39 - -- To fight against God ( θεομάχοι ) Lit., to be God- fighters.

To fight against God ( θεομάχοι )

Lit., to be God- fighters.

JFB: Act 5:35-39 - -- Not the same with a deceiver of that name whom JOSEPHUS mentions as heading an insurrection some twelve years after this [Antiquities, 20.5.1], but so...

Not the same with a deceiver of that name whom JOSEPHUS mentions as heading an insurrection some twelve years after this [Antiquities, 20.5.1], but some other of whom he makes no mention. Such insurrections were frequent.

Clarke: Act 5:39 - -- But if it be of God, ye cannot overthrow it - Because his counsel cannot fail; and his work cannot be counteracted. If he be determined that this do...

But if it be of God, ye cannot overthrow it - Because his counsel cannot fail; and his work cannot be counteracted. If he be determined that this doctrine shall prevail, it is vain for us to attempt to suppress it

Clarke: Act 5:39 - -- Lest haply ye be found - to fight against God - Μηποτε και θεομαχοι εὑρεθητε . Some have thought that they saw a paralle...

Lest haply ye be found - to fight against God - Μηποτε και θεομαχοι εὑρεθητε . Some have thought that they saw a parallel to these words in the speech of Diomede, when, seeing Mars, associated with Hector, oppose the Grecians, he judged farther opposition vain, and desired his troops to retire from the battle

Τῳ δ αιει παρα εἱς γε θεων, ὁς λοιγον αμυνει·

Και νυν οἱ παρα κεινος Αρης, βροτῳ ανδρι εοικως.

Αλλα προς Τρωας τετραμμενοι αιεν οπισσ

Εικετε, μηδε Θεοις μενεαινεμεν ιφι μαχεσθαι

Iliad, lib. v. 603

Protected always by some power divine

And Mars attends this moment at his side

In form a man. Ye therefore still retire

But facing still your foes: nor battle wage

However fierce, yet fruitless, with the gods

Cowper.

||&&$

Defender: Act 5:39 - -- Gamaliel may well have known Nicodemus, who was also a member of the council, a Pharisee, and a respected teacher (Joh 3:1, Joh 3:10). He must have be...

Gamaliel may well have known Nicodemus, who was also a member of the council, a Pharisee, and a respected teacher (Joh 3:1, Joh 3:10). He must have been profoundly impressed by the conversion and devotion of Nicodemus to Jesus, and then by the empty tomb and the reports of Christ's resurrection. He had good reason to fear that suppression of the Christians might indeed be fighting against God."

TSK: Act 5:39 - -- if : Act 6:10; Gen 24:50; 2Sa 5:2; 1Ki 12:24; Job 34:29; Isa 43:13, Isa 46:10; Dan 4:35; Mat 16:18; Luk 21:15; 1Co 1:25; Rev 17:12-14 to fight : Act 7...

collapse all
Commentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)

Barnes: Act 5:39 - -- But if it be of God - If God is the "author"of this religion. From this it seems that Gamaliel supposed that it was at least possible that this...

But if it be of God - If God is the "author"of this religion. From this it seems that Gamaliel supposed that it was at least possible that this religion was divine. He evinced a far more candid mind than did the rest of the Jews; but still it does not appear that he was entirely convinced. The arguments which could not but stagger the Jewish Sanhedrin were those drawn from the resurrection of Jesus, the miracle on the day of Pentecost, the healing of the lame man in the temple, and the release of the apostles from the prison.

Ye cannot overthrow it - Because:

(1)    God has almighty power, and can execute his purposes;

(2)    Because he is unchanging, and will not be diverted from his plans, Job 23:13-14.

The plan which God forms "must"be accomplished. All the devices of man are feebleness when opposed to him, and he can dash them in pieces in an instant. The prediction of Gamaliel has been fulfilled. People have opposed Christianity in every way, but in vain. They have reviled it; have persecuted it; have resorted to argument and to ridicule; to fire, and faggot, and sword; they have called in the aid of science; but all has been in vain. The more it has been crushed, the more it has risen, and it still exists with as much life and power as ever. The "preservation"of this religion amidst so much and so varied opposition proves that it is of God. No severer trial "can"await it than it has already experienced; and as it has survived so many storms and trials, we have every evidence that, according to the predictions, it is destined to live and to fill the world. See the Mat 16:18; Isa 54:17; Isa 55:11 notes; Dan 4:35 note.

Lest - That is, if you continue to oppose it, you may be found to have been opposing God.

Haply - Perhaps. In the Greek this is "lest at any time"; that is, at some future time, when too late to retract your doings, etc.

Ye be found - It shall appear that you have been opposing God.

Even to fight against God - Greek Θεομάχοι Theomachoi , "those who contend with God."The word occurs nowhere else in the New Testament. To fight against God is to oppose him, or to maintain an attitude of hostility against him. It is an attitude that is most fearful in its character, and will most certainly be attended with an overthrow. No condition can be more awful than such an opposition to the Almighty; no overthrow more terrible than what must follow such opposition. Compare Act 9:5; Act 23:9. Opposition to the "gospel"in the Scriptures is uniformly regarded as opposition to God, Mat 12:30; Luk 11:23. People may be said to "fight against"God in the following ways, or on the following subjects:

(1) When they oppose his "gospel,"its preaching, its plans, its influence among people; when they endeavor to prevent its diffusion, or to withdraw their families and friends from its influence.

\caps1 (2) w\caps0 hen they oppose the "doctrines"of the Bible. When they become angry that the real truths of religion are preached, and suffer themselves to be irritated and excited by an "unwillingness"that those doctrines should be true, and should be presented to people. Yet this is no uncommon thing. People by nature do not love those doctrines, and they are often indignant that they are preached. Some of the most angry feelings which people ever have arise from this source; and man can never find peace until he is "willing"that God’ s truth should exert its influence on his own soul, and rejoice that it is believed and loved by others.

\caps1 (3) p\caps0 eople oppose the "Law"of God. It seems to them too "stern"and "harsh."It condemns them; and they are unwilling that it should be applied to them. There is nothing which a sinner likes "less"than he does the pure and holy Law of God.

\caps1 (4) s\caps0 inners fight against the "providence"of God. When he afflicts them they rebel. When he takes away their health, or property, or friends, they complain. They esteem him harsh and cruel; and instead of finding peace by "submission,"they greatly aggravate their sufferings, and infuse a mixture of wormwood and gall into the cup by complaining and repining. There is no peace in affliction but in the feeling that God is "right."And until this belief is cherished, the wicked will be like the troubled sea which cannot rest, whose waters cast up mire and dirt, Isa 57:20. Such opposition to God is as wicked as it is foolish. The Lord gave, and has a right to remove our comforts; and we should be still, and know that he is God.

\caps1 (5) s\caps0 inners fight against God when they resist the influences of his Spirit; when they "oppose"serious thoughts; when they seek evil or frivolous companions and pleasures rather than submit to God; and when they spurn all the entreaties of their friends to become Christians. All these may be the appeals which God is making to people to be prepared to meet him. And yet it is common for sinners thus to stifle conviction, and refuse even to think of their eternal welfare. Nothing can be an act of more direct and deliberate wickedness and folly than this. Without the aid of the Holy Spirit none can be saved; and to resist his influences is to put away the only prospect of eternal life. To do it is to do it over the grave; not knowing that another hour of life may be granted; and not knowing that "if"life is prolonged, the Spirit will ever strive again with the heart. In view of this verse, we may remark:

1.    That the path of wisdom is to submit at once to the requirements of God. Without this, we must expect conflicts with him, and peril and ruin. No man can be "opposed"to God without endangering himself every minute.

2.    Submission to God should be entire. It should extend to every doctrine and demand; every law, and every act of the Almighty. In all his requirements, and in all afflictions, we should submit to him, for thus only shall we find peace.

3.    Infidels and scoffers will gain nothing by opposing God. They have thus far been thwarted, and unsuccessful; and they will be still. None of their plans have succeeded; and the hope of destroying the Christian religion, after the efforts of almost two thousand years, must be vain, and will recoil with tremendous vengeance on those who make them.

Poole: Act 5:39 - -- The other part of the dilemma. The counsel of the Lord, that shall stand, Pro 19:21 Isa 46:10 ; and it must needs be so, for all power is his, in ...

The other part of the dilemma.

The counsel of the Lord, that shall stand, Pro 19:21 Isa 46:10 ; and it must needs be so, for all power is his, in whom we live and move, Act 17:28 .

Fight against God they who afflict and contend with his people unjustly, though they little think so, set themselves against God, who will overcome at the last, and triumph over his and his people’ s enemies.

Haydock: Act 5:39 - -- Time, and the evident success of Christ's Church, prove it to be of God. No violence of the Jews, no persecution of heathen princes, no attempts of d...

Time, and the evident success of Christ's Church, prove it to be of God. No violence of the Jews, no persecution of heathen princes, no attempts of domestic adversaries, heretics, schismatics, or evil livers, have been able to prevail against it. Men of superior abilities have made violent attacks against it; their memory, and that of their disciples, has either been buried and forgotten, or liveth only in malediction and infamy. Let, then no Catholic be dispirited, because modern heresies continue; Arian and other heresies have continued much longer, have been more powerfully supported by temporal power, and yet have come to nothing. The Catholic religion was the first, and it will be the last religion.

Gill: Act 5:39 - -- But if it be of God,.... If it is according to the counsel of his will; if it is a scheme of his forming, and a work to which he has called these men,...

But if it be of God,.... If it is according to the counsel of his will; if it is a scheme of his forming, and a work to which he has called these men, and they proceed in it on good principles, and with a view to the honour and glory of God:

ye cannot overthrow it; it will proceed and get ground, and stand, maugre all the opposition of hell and earth; therefore do nothing to them, or hinder them from going on. Some copies read, "ye cannot overthrow them"; and add, "neither you, nor kings, nor tyrants; wherefore refrain from these men"; so Beza's Cambridge copy.

Lest haply ye be found even to fight against God; which to do is downright madness, and which no man in his senses can expect to succeed in. There are some sayings of the Jewish doctors which seem to agree with these reasonings of Gamaliel p.

"Says R. Jochanan the shoemaker, every congregation, which is for the name of heaven (or God) at length shall be established, but that which is not for the glory of God shall not be established in the end.''

Which one of the commentators q interprets in words still nearer to Gamaliel's language, thus:

"it shall be that that counsel which is for God shall stand and prosper, but that which is not for God shall cease.''

And in another place it is said r,

"all contention (or dispute) which is for God, at length shall be established, but that which is not for God shall not in the end be established: what is contention that is for God? the contention of Hillell and Shammai, (two famous doctors among the Jews,) but that which is not for God is the contention of Korah, and his whole company.''

Some have thought from this advice of Gamaliel, that he was a Christian, or greatly inclined to Christianity; but when it is considered what respect was shown him at his death by the Jews, before observed on Act 5:34 it will appear that he died a Pharisee; and especially it cannot be thought he had any favourable sentiments of the Christians, since a little before his death he ordered a prayer to be made against them. Maimonides says s, that

"in the days of Rabban Gamaliel, the Epicureans (so the Amsterdam edition reads, but former editions read מינים, "heretics", by whom are meant Christians) increased in Israel; and they distressed the Israelites, and seduced them to turn aside from God; and when he saw that this was greater than all the necessities of the children of men, he stood up, and his council or sanhedrim, and composed another prayer, in which there was a request to God to destroy the Epicureans,''

or heretics, meaning the Christians: and though this prayer is sometimes ascribed to Samuel the little, yet it was composed by him at the hint and instigation of Gamaliel; for so it is said t, R. Gamaliel said to the wise men,

"is there no man that knows how to compose a prayer for the Sadducees? (R. Asher reads "heretics";) Samuel the little stood up and composed one.''

And it is also said u, that

"Samuel the little composed, ברכת מינין, "the prayer for the heretics", before, or in the presence of Gamaliel the elder.''

He made it when he was present, assisting, dictating, directing, and approving. The prayer was this w,

"let there be no hope for apostates, and may all heretics perish in a moment, and all the enemies of thy people be quickly cut off: root out the kingdom of pride, and break, destroy, and subdue them in haste in our days.''

In some forms it is added,

"blessed art thou, O Lord, that breakest the wicked in pieces, and humblest the proud.''

Upon the whole, Gamaliel does not seem to have been a Christian, or to have favoured the Christian religion; but he was, as he is said, Act 5:34 to be, a Pharisee: and this council, or sanhedrim, were, for the greater part of them, Sadducees, as seems from Act 5:17 who, as the Jews say, were wicked and base men, men of very ill manners, whereas the Pharisees were רחמנים, "merciful men" x; and such an one was Gamaliel: he was a religious man in his way; a man of humanity, a mild and moderate man, that had compassion and pity for his fellow creatures; and could not give in to any schemes of cruelty and persecution, which the Sadducees were forward to; and upon these principles he acted, and upon these he gave this advice.

expand all
Commentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

NET Notes: Act 5:39 Grk “They were convinced by him.” This passive construction was converted to an active one (“He convinced them”) in keeping wi...

expand all
Commentary -- Verse Range Notes

TSK Synopsis: Act 5:1-42 - --1 After that Ananias and Sapphira his wife for their hypocrisy, at Peter's rebuke had fallen down dead;12 and that the rest of the apostles had wrough...

Combined Bible: Act 5:39 - --notes on verse 34     

Maclaren: Act 5:38-39 - --Gamaliel's Counsel Refrain from these men, and let them alone; for if this counsel or this work be of men, it will come to nought: 39. But if it be o...

MHCC: Act 5:34-42 - --The Lord still has all hearts in his hands, and sometimes directs the prudence of the worldly wise, so as to restrain the persecutors. Common sense te...

Matthew Henry: Act 5:26-42 - -- We are not told what it was that the apostles preached to the people; no doubt it was according to the direction of the angel - the words of this l...

Barclay: Act 5:33-42 - --On their second appearance before the Sanhedrin the apostles found an unexpected helper. Gamaliel was a Pharisee. The Sadducees were the wealthy col...

Constable: Act 3:1--6:8 - --B. The expansion of the church in Jerusalem 3:1-6:7 Luke recorded the events of this section (3:1-6:7) t...

Constable: Act 5:12-42 - --3. Intensified external opposition 5:12-42 God's power manifest through the apostles in blessing...

Constable: Act 5:34-40 - --Gamaliel's wise counsel 5:34-40 Gamaliel's advocacy of moderation is the main point and reason for Luke's record of the apostles' second appearance be...

College: Act 5:1-42 - --ACTS 5 3. The Deceit of Ananias and Sapphira (5:1-11) 1 Now a man named Ananias, together with his wife Sapphira, also sold a piece of property. 2 W...

McGarvey: Act 5:34-39 - --34-39. At this crisis the madness of the Sadducees was suddenly checked by the prudent counsel of one of the opposite party. The Pharisees were less e...

expand all
Introduction / Outline

Robertson: Acts (Book Introduction) THE ACTS OF THE APOSTLES By Way of Introduction But for the Acts we should know nothing of the early apostolic period save what is told in the Epi...

JFB: Acts (Book Introduction) THIS book is to the Gospels what the fruit is to the tree that bears it. In the Gospels we see the corn of wheat falling into the ground and dying: in...

JFB: Acts (Outline) INTRODUCTION--LAST DAYS OF OUR LORD UPON EARTH--HIS ASCENSION. (Act 1:1-11) RETURN OF THE ELEVEN TO JERUSALEM--PROCEEDINGS IN THE UPPER ROOM TILL PEN...

TSK: Acts (Book Introduction) The Acts of the Apostles is a most valuable portion of Divine revelation; and, independently of its universal reception in the Christian church, as an...

TSK: Acts 5 (Chapter Introduction) Overview Act 5:1, After that Ananias and Sapphira his wife for their hypocrisy, at Peter’s rebuke had fallen down dead; Act 5:12, and that the r...

Poole: Acts 5 (Chapter Introduction) CHAPTER 5

MHCC: Acts (Book Introduction) This book unites the Gospels to the Epistles. It contains many particulars concerning the apostles Peter and Paul, and of the Christian church from th...

MHCC: Acts 5 (Chapter Introduction) (Act 5:1-11) The death of Ananias and Sapphira. (Act 5:12-16) The power which accompanied the preaching of the gospel. (Act 5:17-25) The apostles im...

Matthew Henry: Acts (Book Introduction) An Exposition, with Practical Observations, of The Acts of the Apostles We have with an abundant satisfaction seen the foundation of our holy religion...

Matthew Henry: Acts 5 (Chapter Introduction) In this chapter we have, I. The sin and punishment of Ananias and Sapphira, who, for lying to the Holy Ghost, were struck dead at the word of Pete...

Barclay: Acts (Book Introduction) INTRODUCTION TO THE ACTS OF THE APOSTLES A Precious Book In one sense Acts is the most important book in the New Testament. It is the simple truth t...

Barclay: Acts 5 (Chapter Introduction) Trouble In The Church (Act_5:1-11) The Attraction Of Christianity (Act_5:12-16) Arrest And Trial Once Again (Act_5:17-32) An Unexpected Ally (Act...

Constable: Acts (Book Introduction) Introduction Title The title "Acts of the Apostles" is very ancient. The Anti-Marcioni...

Constable: Acts (Outline) Outline I. The witness in Jerusalem 1:1-6:7 A. The founding of the church 1:1-2:46 ...

Constable: Acts Acts Bibliography Albright, William Foxwell. The Archaeology of Palestine. 1949. Revised ed. Pelican Archaeolog...

Haydock: Acts (Book Introduction) THE ACTS OF THE APOSTLES. INTRODUCTION. St. Luke, who had published his gospel, wrote also a second volume, which, from the first ages, hath bee...

Gill: Acts (Book Introduction) INTRODUCTION TO ACTS This book, in some copies, is called, "The Acts of the holy Apostles". It contains an history of the ministry and miracles of ...

College: Acts (Book Introduction) INTRODUCTION As early as the second century the title "The Acts of the Apostles" was given to this document. Before that time the work probably circu...

College: Acts (Outline) OUTLINE I. THE CHURCH IN JERUSALEM - 1:1-8:1a A. INTRODUCTION OF THE BOOK - 1:1-3 B. THE COMMISSIONING OF THE APOSTLES - 1:4-8 C. THE ASCENSI...

Advanced Commentary (Dictionaries, Hymns, Arts, Sermon Illustration, Question and Answers, etc)


created in 0.32 seconds
powered by
bible.org - YLSA