collapse all  

Text -- Amos 4:4 (NET)

Strongs On/Off
Context
Israel has an Appointment with God
4:4 “Go to Bethel and rebel! At Gilgal rebel some more! Bring your sacrifices in the morning, your tithes on the third day!
Parallel   Cross Reference (TSK)   ITL  

Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics

Names, People and Places:
 · Bethel a town of Benjamin bordering Ephraim 18 km north of Jerusalem
 · Gilgal a place where Israel encamped between Jericho and the Jordan,a town between Dor and Tirza in the territory of Ephraim (YC),a town just north of Joppa, originally a military base (YC),a place 12 miles south of Shechem now called Jiljiliah (YC)


Dictionary Themes and Topics: Tithes | TITHE | SACRIFICE, IN THE OLD TESTAMENT, 2 | JUDAH, TERRITORY OF | JEROBOAM | Israel | Irony | Idolatry | Gilgal | Calf | CRITICISM | CALF, GOLDEN | Beth-el | BETHEL | AMOS (1) | more
Table of Contents

Word/Phrase Notes
Wesley , JFB , Clarke , Calvin , Defender , TSK

Word/Phrase Notes
Barnes , Poole , Haydock , Gill

Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes , Geneva Bible

Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis , Maclaren , MHCC , Matthew Henry , Keil-Delitzsch , Constable , Guzik

collapse all
Commentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)

Wesley: Amo 4:4 - -- el - A strong irony, giving them over as incorrigible.

el - A strong irony, giving them over as incorrigible.

Wesley: Amo 4:4 - -- Gilgal was a place where much idolatry was acted.

Gilgal was a place where much idolatry was acted.

Wesley: Amo 4:4 - -- In the same irony God reproves their sins tho' they imitated the instituted worship at Jerusalem.

In the same irony God reproves their sins tho' they imitated the instituted worship at Jerusalem.

Wesley: Amo 4:4 - -- God had Deu 14:28, commanded every third year that all the tithe of that year should be brought, and laid up in a publick store - house.

God had Deu 14:28, commanded every third year that all the tithe of that year should be brought, and laid up in a publick store - house.

JFB: Amo 4:4 - -- God gives them up to their self-willed idolatry, that they may see how unable their idols are to save them from their coming calamities. So Eze 20:39.

God gives them up to their self-willed idolatry, that they may see how unable their idols are to save them from their coming calamities. So Eze 20:39.

JFB: Amo 4:4 - -- (Amo 3:14).

JFB: Amo 4:4 - -- (Hos 4:15; Hos 9:15; Hos 12:11).

JFB: Amo 4:4 - -- As commanded in the law (Num 28:3-4). They imitated the letter, while violating by calf-worship the spirit, of the Jerusalem temple-worship.

As commanded in the law (Num 28:3-4). They imitated the letter, while violating by calf-worship the spirit, of the Jerusalem temple-worship.

JFB: Amo 4:4 - -- Every third year; literally, "after three (years of) days" (that is, the fullest complement of days, or a year); "after three full years." Compare Lev...

Every third year; literally, "after three (years of) days" (that is, the fullest complement of days, or a year); "after three full years." Compare Lev 25:20; Jdg 17:10, and "the days" for the years, Joe 1:2. So a month of days is used for a full month, wanting no day to complete it (Gen 29:14, Margin; Num 11:20-21). The Israelites here also kept to the letter of the law in bringing in the tithes of their increase every third year (Deu 14:28; Deu 26:12).

Clarke: Amo 4:4 - -- Come to Beth-el and transgress - Spoken ironically. Go on to worship your calves at Beth-el; and multiply your transgressions at Gilgal; the very pl...

Come to Beth-el and transgress - Spoken ironically. Go on to worship your calves at Beth-el; and multiply your transgressions at Gilgal; the very place where I rolled away the reproach of your fathers, by admitting them there into my covenant by circumcision. A place that should have ever been sacred to me; but you have now desecrated it by enormous idolatries. Let your morning and evening sacrifices be offered still to your senseless gods; and continue to support your present vicious priesthood by the regular triennial tithes which should have been employed in my service; and: -

Calvin: Amo 4:4 - -- The Prophet here again pours contempt on the perverse confidence, in which the Israelites were become hardened. They thought, indeed, that their wors...

The Prophet here again pours contempt on the perverse confidence, in which the Israelites were become hardened. They thought, indeed, that their worship was fully approved by God, when they offered Sacrifices in Bethel and Gilgal. But the Prophet here shows, that the more sedulously they labored in performing sacred things, the more grievously they offended God, and the heavier judgment they gained for themselves. “What do you obtain by wearying yourselves, when ye so strictly offer sacrifices, and omit nothing that is prescribed in the law of God? Only this — that you provoke God’s wrath more and more.” But he condemns not the Israelites for thinking that they rendered a compensation, as hypocrites were wont to think, and were on this account often reproved by the Prophets; but he denounces their modes of worship as vicious and false, and abominable before God. The Prophets reprobated sacrifices for two reasons; — first, because hypocrites brought them before God as a compensation, that they might escape the punishment they deserved, as though they paid God what they owed. Thus at Jerusalem, in the very temple, they profaned the name of God; they offered sacrifices according to what the law prescribed, but disregarded the true and legitimate end; for they thought that God was pacified by the blood of beasts, by incense, and other external rites: it was therefore a preposterous abuse. Hence the Prophets often reproved them, inasmuch as they obtruded their sacrifices on God as a compensation, as though they were real expiations for cleansing away sins: this, as the Prophets declared, was extremely puerile and foolish. But, secondly, Amos now goes much farther; for he blames not here the Israelites for thinking that they discharged their duty to God by external rites, but denounces all their worship as degenerate and perverted, for they called on God in places where he had not commanded: God designed one altar only for his people, and there he wished sacrifices to be offered to him; but the Israelites at their own will had built altars at Bethel and Gilgal. Hence the Prophet declares that all their profane modes of worship were nothing but abominations, however much the Israelites confided in them as their safety.

This is the reason why he now says Go ye to Bethel. It is the language of indignation; God indeed speaks ironically, and at the same time manifests his high displeasure, as though he had said, that they were wholly intractable, and could not be restrained by any corrections, as we say in French, Fai du pis que to pouvras So also God speaks in Eze 20:39, ‘Go, sacrifice to your idols.’ When he saw the people running headlong with so much pertinacity into idolatry and superstitions, he said, “Go;” as though he intended to inflame their minds. It is indeed certain, that God does not stimulate sinners; but he thus manifests his extreme indignation. After having tried to restrain men, and seeing their ungovernable madness, he then says, “Go;” as though he said, “Ye are wholly irreclaimable; I effect nothing by my good advice; hear, then, the devil, who will lead you where you are inclined to go: Go then to Bethel, and there transgress; go to Gilgal, and transgress there again; heap sins on sins.”

But how did they transgress at Bethel? Even by worshipping God. We here see how little the pretense of good intention avails with God, which hypocrites ever bring forward. They imagine that, provided their purpose is to worship God, what they do cannot be disapproved: thus they wanton in their own inventions, and think that God obtains his due, so that he cannot complain. But the Prophet declares all their worship to be nothing else than abomination and execrable wickedness, though the Israelites, trusting in it, thought themselves safe. “Add, then, to transgress in Gilgal; and offer your sacrifices in the morning; be thus diligent, that nothing may be objected to you, as to the outward form.”

After three years, 26 that is, in the third year, “bring also your tenths”; for thus it was commanded, as we read in Deu 14:28. Though, then, the Israelites worshipped God apparently in the strictest manner, yet Amos declares that the whole was vain and of no worth, yea, abominable before God, and that the more they wearied themselves, the more they kindled the wrath of God against themselves. And to the same purpose is the next verse.

Defender: Amo 4:4 - -- This ironic invitation recognizes the divisiveness of the false altar at Bethel, established by Jeroboam I (1Ki 12:29-33) and condemned by God. Althou...

This ironic invitation recognizes the divisiveness of the false altar at Bethel, established by Jeroboam I (1Ki 12:29-33) and condemned by God. Although God had blessed the altars at Bethel established by Abraham and Jacob (Gen 12:8; Gen 28:17-19), He had by this time ordained the temple at Jerusalem as the sole place of sacrificial worship (Deu 12:1-14)."

TSK: Amo 4:4 - -- Come : A bitter irony and sarcasm, addressed to the idolatrous Israelites. Amo 3:14; Ecc 11:9; Eze 20:39; Joe 3:9-12; Mat 23:32, Mat 26:45; Mar 14:41 ...

Come : A bitter irony and sarcasm, addressed to the idolatrous Israelites. Amo 3:14; Ecc 11:9; Eze 20:39; Joe 3:9-12; Mat 23:32, Mat 26:45; Mar 14:41

at Gilgal : Amo 5:5; Hos 4:15, Hos 9:15, Hos 12:11

and bring : Num 28:3, Num 28:4

and your : Deu 14:28, Deu 14:29, Deu 26:12

three years : Heb. three years of days

collapse all
Commentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)

Barnes: Amo 4:4 - -- Come to Beth-el and transgress - Having foretold their captivity, the prophet tries irony. But his irony is in bidding them go on to do, what t...

Come to Beth-el and transgress - Having foretold their captivity, the prophet tries irony. But his irony is in bidding them go on to do, what they were doing earnestly, what they were set upon doing, and would not be withdrawn from. As Micaiah in irony, until adjured in the name of God, joined Ahab’ s court-priests, bidding, him "go to Ramoth-Gilead"1Ki 22:15, where he was to perish; or Elijah said to the priests of Baal, "Cry aloud, for he is a god"1Ki 18:27; or our Lord, "Fill ye up then the measure of your fathers"Mat 23:32; so Amos bids them do all they did, in their divided service of God, but tells them that to multiply all such service was to multiply transgression. Yet they were diligent in their way. Their offerings were daily, as at Jerusalem; the tithes of the third year for the poor was paid, as God had ordained Deu 14:28; Deu 26:12. They were punctual in these parts of the ritual, and thought much of their punctuality.

So well did they count themselves to stand with God, that there is no mention of sin offering or trespass offering. Their sacrifices were "sacrifics of thanksgiving"and "free will offerings,"as if out of exuberance of devotion, such as David said that Zion would "offer,"when God had been "favorable and gracious unto"her Psa 51:18-19. These things they did; they "proclaimed"and "published"them, like the hypocrites whom our Lord reproves, "sounding a trumpet before them"Mat 6:2 when they did alms; proclaiming these private offerings, as God bade proclaim the solemn assemblies. "For so ye love."They did it, because they liked it, and it cost them nothing, for which they cared. It was more than most Christians will sacrifice, two fifteenths of their yearly income, if they gave the yearly tithes, which were to be shared with the poor also. But they would not sacrifice what God, above all, required, the fundamental breach of God’ s law, on which their kingdom rested, "the sin which Jeroboam made Israel to sin."They did what they liked; they were pleased with it, and they had that pleasure for their only reward, as it is of all which is not done for God.

Poole: Amo 4:4 - -- Come to Beth-el the known place of the moscholatria, calf-worship: see Amo 3:14 . And transgress: this clears it to be an irony, either throwing th...

Come to Beth-el the known place of the moscholatria, calf-worship: see Amo 3:14 .

And transgress: this clears it to be an irony, either throwing them up to their obstinate way of sinning, giving them over as hopeless and incorrigible sinners, or deriding their trust and dependence on idols, to which they sacrificed at Beth-el: See what will be the issue hereof, how you shall succeed herein.

At Gilgal multiply transgression Gilgal was a place also where much idolatry was acted: see Hos 4:15 9:15 12:11 . Since you will not be warned, go on, try whether God likes your sacrifices there as well as you like them, and whether they will be a means to preserve from judgments, or sins hastening judgments’ on you.

Bring your sacrifices every morning: in the same irony God doth by Amos express his own displeasure, reprove their sin, and threaten it, though they imitate the instituted worship at Jerusalem, Exo 29:38,39 Nu 28:3,4 .

And your tithes after three years God had, Deu 14:28 , commanded every third year that all the tithe of that year should be brought, and laid up in a public storehouse; to this law, with the same irony, doth the prophet allude here.

Haydock: Amo 4:4 - -- Galgal. Thither the people went of their own accord, as to a place of devotion, Osee iv. 15. Amos ironically tells them to proceed, as Christ addre...

Galgal. Thither the people went of their own accord, as to a place of devotion, Osee iv. 15. Amos ironically tells them to proceed, as Christ addressed the Jews, Matthew xxiii. 32. (Calmet) ---

After many admonitions have proved fruitless, God suffers infidels to act as they please. (Worthington) ---

This is the most dreadful of his judgments. (Haydock) ---

Morning, with haste. ---

Three days. This also may denote the false exactitude of the Israelites to perform what God did not require, while they neglected the most essential duties, like the Pharisees. It may also imply the giving tithes every third year, (Deuteronomy xiv. 28.) or presenting themselves at the three great festivals, Exodus xxiii. 14. The schismatics observed parts of the law, and had a devotion of their own choice. (Calmet)

Gill: Amo 4:4 - -- Come to Bethel and transgress,.... and what follows, are ironic and sarcastic speeches, not giving liberty to sin, but in this way reproving for it: B...

Come to Bethel and transgress,.... and what follows, are ironic and sarcastic speeches, not giving liberty to sin, but in this way reproving for it: Bethel was one of the places where the calves were placed and worshipped: and here they are bid to go thither, and go on with and continue in their idolatrous worship, by which they transgressed the law of God, and mark what would be the issue of it. The sense is the same with Ecc 11:9; see Eze 20:29;

at Gilgal multiply transgression; that is, multiply acts of idolatry: Gilgal was a place where high places and altars were erected, and idols worshipped; as it had formerly been a place of religious worship of the true God, the ten tribes made use of it in the times of their apostasy for idolatrous worship; see Hos 4:15;

and bring your sacrifices every morning; and offer them to your idols, as you were wont formerly to offer them unto the true God, according to the law of Moses, Exo 29:38;

and your tithes after three years; the third year after the sabbatical year was the year of tithing; and after the tithe of the increase of the fruits of the earth, there was "maaser sheni", the second tithe, the same with "maaser ani", the poor's tithe, which was given to the Levite, the stranger, the fatherless; and the widow, to eat with them, Deu 14:22; and this they are sarcastically bid to observe in their idolatrous way. It is, in the Hebrew text, "after three days"; and so the Targum,

"your tithes in three days;''

days being put for years, as Kimchi and Ben Melech observe. It may be rendered, "after three years of days" s; three complete years.

expand all
Commentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

NET Notes: Amo 4:4 Or “for.”

Geneva Bible: Amo 4:4 Come to ( d ) Bethel, and transgress; at Gilgal multiply transgression; and bring your sacrifices every morning, [and] your tithes after three ( e ) y...

expand all
Commentary -- Verse Range Notes

TSK Synopsis: Amo 4:1-13 - --1 He reproves Israel for oppression,4 for idolatry,6 and for their incorrigibleness.

Maclaren: Amo 4:4-13 - --Smitten In Vain Come to Beth-el, and transgress; at Gilgal multiply transgression; and bring your sacrifices every morning, and your tithes after thr...

MHCC: Amo 4:1-5 - --What is got by extortion is commonly used to provide for the flesh, and to fulfil the lusts thereof. What is got by oppression cannot be enjoyed with ...

Matthew Henry: Amo 4:1-5 - -- It is here foretold, in the name of God, that oppressors shall be humbled and idolaters shall be hardened. I. That proud oppressors shall be humbled...

Keil-Delitzsch: Amo 4:4-5 - -- After this threat directed against the voluptuous women of the capital, the prophecy turns again to all the people. In bitter irony, Amos tells them...

Constable: Amo 1:3--7:1 - --II. Prophetic messages that Amos delivered 1:3--6:14 The Book of Amos consists of words (oracles, 1:3-6:14) and ...

Constable: Amo 3:1--6:14 - --B. Messages of Judgment against Israel chs. 3-6 After announcing that God would judge Israel, Amos deliv...

Constable: Amo 4:1-13 - --2. The second message on women, worship, and stubbornness ch. 4 This message consists of seven p...

Constable: Amo 4:4-5 - --Religious hypocrisy 4:4-5 4:4 Ironically the Lord told these sinful Israelites to go to Bethel but to transgress, not to worship. Such a call parodied...

Guzik: Amo 4:1-13 - --Amos 4 - "Yet You Have Not Returned to Me" A. The sinful women of Israel. 1. (1) Amos describes the indulgent women of Israel. Hear this...

expand all
Introduction / Outline

JFB: Amos (Book Introduction) AMOS (meaning in Hebrew "a burden") was (Amo 1:1) a shepherd of Tekoa, a small town of Judah, six miles southeast from Beth-lehem, and twelve from Jer...

JFB: Amos (Outline) GOD'S JUDGMENTS ON SYRIA, PHILISTIA, TYRE, EDOM, AND AMMON. (Amo 1:1-15) CHARGES AGAINST MOAB, JUDAH, AND LASTLY ISRAEL, THE CHIEF SUBJECT OF AMOS' P...

TSK: Amos 4 (Chapter Introduction) Overview Amo 4:1, He reproves Israel for oppression, Amo 4:4, for idolatry, Amo 4:6, and for their incorrigibleness.

Poole: Amos (Book Introduction) THE ARGUMENT IF we might be allowed to make a conjecture at the quality of our prophet’ s sermons by the signification of his name, we must co...

Poole: Amos 4 (Chapter Introduction) CHAPTER 4 Israel reproved for oppression, Amo 4:1-3 ; for idolatry, Amo 4:4,5 ; and for their incorrigibleness, Amo 4:6-13 . This verse is an int...

MHCC: Amos (Book Introduction) Amos was a herdsman, and engaged in agriculture. But the same Divine Spirit influenced Isaiah and Daniel in the court, and Amos in the sheep-folds, gi...

MHCC: Amos 4 (Chapter Introduction) (Amo 4:1-5) Israel is reproved. (Amo 4:6-13) Their impenitence shown.

Matthew Henry: Amos (Book Introduction) An Exposition, with Practical Observations, of The Prophecy of Amos Though this prophet appeared a little before Isaiah, yet he was not, as some have ...

Matthew Henry: Amos 4 (Chapter Introduction) In this chapter, I. The oppressors in Israel are threatened for their oppression of the poor (Amo 4:1-3). II. The idolaters in Israel, being join...

Constable: Amos (Book Introduction) Introduction Title and Writer The title of the book comes from its writer. The prophet...

Constable: Amos (Outline) Outline I. Prologue 1:1-2 A. Introduction 1:1 B. Theme 1:2 ...

Constable: Amos Amos Bibliography Alter, Robert. The Art of Biblical Poetry. New York: Basic, 1985. Andersen, F...

Haydock: Amos (Book Introduction) THE PROPHECY OF AMOS. INTRODUCTION. Amos prophesied in Israel about the same time as Osee, and was called from following the cattle to denoun...

Gill: Amos (Book Introduction) INTRODUCTION TO AMOS This book in the Hebrew Bibles is called "Sepher Amos", the Book of Amos; and, in the Vulgate Latin and Syriac versions, the P...

Gill: Amos 4 (Chapter Introduction) INTRODUCTION TO AMOS 4 In this chapter, the great ones, or the people of Israel, are threatened with calamities for their oppression of the poor, A...

Advanced Commentary (Dictionaries, Hymns, Arts, Sermon Illustration, Question and Answers, etc)


TIP #20: 'To dig deeper, please read related articles at BIBLE.org (via Articles Tab).' [ALL]
created in 0.44 seconds
powered by
bible.org - YLSA