collapse all  

Text -- Amos 6:12 (NET)

Strongs On/Off
Context
6:12 Can horses run on rocky cliffs? Can one plow the sea with oxen? Yet you have turned justice into a poisonous plant, and the fruit of righteous actions into a bitter plant.
Parallel   Cross Reference (TSK)   ITL  

Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics

Dictionary Themes and Topics: WORMWOOD | TEXT OF THE OLD TESTAMENT | Rulers | Poison | PLOW | JUDGE | Israel | Hemlock | GALL | Church | CALF, GOLDEN | AMOS (1) | more
Table of Contents

Word/Phrase Notes
Wesley , JFB , Clarke , Calvin , Defender , TSK

Word/Phrase Notes
Barnes , Poole , Haydock , Gill

Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes , Geneva Bible

Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis , MHCC , Matthew Henry , Keil-Delitzsch , Constable , Guzik

collapse all
Commentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)

Wesley: Amo 6:12 - -- If prophets exhort or advise, it does no more good than if you would run your horses upon the precipices of rocks.

If prophets exhort or advise, it does no more good than if you would run your horses upon the precipices of rocks.

JFB: Amo 6:12 - -- In turning "judgment (justice) into gall (poison), and . . . righteousness into hemlock" (or wormwood, bitter and noxious), ye act as perversely as if...

In turning "judgment (justice) into gall (poison), and . . . righteousness into hemlock" (or wormwood, bitter and noxious), ye act as perversely as if one were to make "horses run upon the rock" or to "plough with oxen there" [MAURER]. As horses and oxen are useless on a rock, so ye are incapable of fulfilling justice [GROTIUS]. Ye impede the course of God's benefits, because ye are as it were a hard rock on which His favor cannot run. "Those that will not be tilled as fields, shall be abandoned as rocks" [CALVIN].

Clarke: Amo 6:12 - -- Shall horses run upon the rock - First, they could not do it, because they were unshod; for the shoeing of horses with iron was not then known. Seco...

Shall horses run upon the rock - First, they could not do it, because they were unshod; for the shoeing of horses with iron was not then known. Secondly, If they did run on the rock, it would be useless to their owner, and hurtful to themselves. Thirdly, And it would be as useless to plough on the rock with oxen; for there it would be impossible to sow with any advantage. Fourthly, Just as useless and injurious would it be to put gall in the place of judgment, and hemlock in the place of righteousness. You have not only been laboring in vain for yourselves, but you have also been oppressive to others; and for both ye shall suffer.

Calvin: Amo 6:12 - -- This verse interpreters misrepresent; for some think that the Prophet, by these figurative expressions, means, that the people were wholly unprofitab...

This verse interpreters misrepresent; for some think that the Prophet, by these figurative expressions, means, that the people were wholly unprofitable as to any thing good; as some one says, “The slothful ox wishes for the saddle, the horse wishes to plough.” They therefore suppose that this is the meaning of the words, “Ye are no more fitted to lead a good life than a horse is to run on a rock, or an ox to plough on a rock.” Others think that the Prophet complains that the order of things was subverted as though he said, “Ye have alike confounded all equity government, and justice. In short, ye have subverted all right; as when one tries to ride swiftly over a high rock, or attempts to plough there, which is contrary to the nature of things: ye are therefore become monsters.” Others, again, understand that the Prophet here complains that he had lost all his labor; for he had been singing, according to the common proverb, to the deaf. “What do I effect as to this iron generation? It is the same as if one tried to ride on the rock, to mount a rock on a swift horse; or as if one attempted to plough there; both which are impossible. So now, when I address stupid men, there is no fruit to my labor, and no advantage is gained.” 44

But let us see whether a fitter and a more suitable meaning can be elicited. We have already observed how secure the Israelites were; for they thought that God was, in a manner, bound to them, for he had pledged his faith to be a father to them. This adoption of God puffed up their hearts. The Prophet now reproves this presumptuous security; and, in a fitting manner, “Can a horse,” he says, “run on a rock? and can an ox plough in a stony place? So there is not among you a free course to God’s blessings. Ye ought indeed to have been the vineyard and the field of the Lord; justice and judgment ought to have reigned among, you but ye have turned judgment into gall ( ראש , rash, which is variously taken, but as to the sense it matters but little,) ye have then turned judgment into gall, and righteousness into hemlock Since then ye are so perverse, a way for God’s blessings is doubtless closed up. It cannot be that the Lord will act towards you in a manner like himself; for he must necessarily be refractory towards the refractory, as he is gentle towards the gentle”. The Prophet seems to me to mean this and if any one impartially considers the whole verse, he will easily find out the truth of what I have stated, namely, that the Prophet here reproves the supreme haughtiness of the Israelitic people, who thought God bound to them though, at the same time, they, as it were, designedly provoked his wrath. “Ye think”, he says, “that God will be always propitious to you; whence is this confidence? Is it because he has adopted you, because he made a covenant with your fathers? True he has done so; but what sort of covenant was it? What was engaged on your part? Was it not that ye would be perfect before him? But ye have turned judgment into gall, and righteousness into hemlock 45 Since then ye are thus covenant-breakers, what can God now do? Do you wish him to proceed in the same course, and to bestow on you his blessings? Ye do not allow them to be bestowed. For ye are become like craggy rocks. How can God proceed in his course? how can he continue his benefits to you? He can certainly no more do so than a horse, however nimble he may be, can run swiftly on a rock or an ox plough on a rock.” We now understand what the Prophet means in this place. A confirmation of this view now follows, and from this connection the truth of what I have stated will become more evident.

Defender: Amo 6:12 - -- The answer to such rhetorical questions is: "Of course not!" But just as absurd was the destructive life style of Israel's people."

The answer to such rhetorical questions is: "Of course not!" But just as absurd was the destructive life style of Israel's people."

TSK: Amo 6:12 - -- horses : Isa 48:4; Jer 5:3, Jer 6:29, Jer 6:30; Zec 7:11, Zec 7:12 for : Amo 5:7, Amo 5:11, Amo 5:12; 1Ki 21:7-13; Psa 94:20,Psa 94:21; Isa 59:13, Isa...

collapse all
Commentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)

Barnes: Amo 6:12 - -- The two images both represent a toil, which people would condemn as absurd, destructive, as well as fruitless. The horse’ s hoofs or his limbs ...

The two images both represent a toil, which people would condemn as absurd, destructive, as well as fruitless. The horse’ s hoofs or his limbs would be broken; the plowing-gear would be destroyed. The prophet gains the attention by the question. What then? they ask. The answer is implied by the for, which follows. Ye are they, who are so doing. As absurd is it to seek gain from injustice and oppression, to which God had annexed loss and woe, temporal and eternal. More easy to change the course of nature or the use of things of nature, than the course of God’ s Providence or the laws of His just retribution. They had changed the sweet laws of "justice"and equity "into"the "gall"of oppression, and the healthful "fruit of righteousness,"whereof they had received the seed from God, into the life-destroying poison of sin. Better to have "plowed"the rock "with oxen"for food! For now, where they looked for prosperity, they found not barrenness, but death.

Others understand the question as the taunt of unbelievers, trusting in the strength of Samaria, that when horses should run on their rocky eminence, or the oxen plow there, then might an enemy look for gain from investing the hill of Samaria. "Shall things which are against nature be done?""Yes,"the prophet then would answer, "for ye have done against nature yourselves. Ye, have "changed justice,"the solace of the oppressed, "into wormwood,"the bitterness of oppression. Well may what ye think above the laws of physical nature be done, when ye have violated the laws of moral nature. Well may the less thing be done, your destruction, secure as by nature ye seem, when ye have done the greater, violating the laws of the God of nature."Amos, however, when he refers to the sayings of the unbelievers, distinguishes them from his own.

Poole: Amo 6:12 - -- Shall horses run upon the rock? would it not be dangerous to horse and rider? If prophets and pious men exhort, threaten, or advise, they endanger th...

Shall horses run upon the rock? would it not be dangerous to horse and rider? If prophets and pious men exhort, threaten, or advise, they endanger themselves, it does no more good than if you would run your horse on the slippery precipices of rocks. Or, all is lost labour on these hardened sinners.

Will one plough there with oxen? your hearts are hard as the rocks; my prophets’ preaching, my lesser judgments warning you, all gentler means used, are but as a husbandman’ s ploughing the rocks. These shall therefore be torn up by the roots, your state and kingdom shall be utterly overthrown.

For ye you judges and governors in the ten tribes, and in Judah too,

have turned judgment see Amo 5:7 ,

into gall or poison; by those laws they took away life, and forfeited estate, which, had the laws been rightly executed, had saved both.

The fruit of righteousness all that fruit which equity and justice would have produced by due application of the law, hath been wormwood, grief, and complaints, by your wresting and perverting the law.

Into hemlock a deadly and pernicious weed so the course of your courts have been.

Haydock: Amo 6:12 - -- Clefts. All shall perish, (Calmet) both Israel and Juda. (Chaldean) (Grotius) --- But he speaks only of the former.

Clefts. All shall perish, (Calmet) both Israel and Juda. (Chaldean) (Grotius) ---

But he speaks only of the former.

Gill: Amo 6:12 - -- Shall horses run upon the rocks? or will one plough there with oxen?.... Will any man be so weak and foolish, to propose or attempt a race for horse...

Shall horses run upon the rocks? or will one plough there with oxen?.... Will any man be so weak and foolish, to propose or attempt a race for horses upon rocks, where they and their riders would be in danger of breaking their necks? or would any man act so unwise a part, as to take a yoke of oxen to plough with them upon a rock, where no impression can be made? as vain and fruitless a thing it would be to attempt to bring such persons under a conviction of their sins, and to repentance for them, and reformation from them, who are given up to a judicial hardness of heart, like that of a rock, as are the persons described in the next clause; or as such methods with horses and oxen would be contrary to all the rules of reason and prudence, so as contrary a part do such persons act whose characters are next given, and there is no probability of bringing them to better sense and practice of things;

for ye have turned judgment into gall, and the fruit of righteousness into hemlock; that which would be beneficial to a nation, than which nothing is more so, as the exercise of justice, and judgment, into that which is bitter and pernicious to it, as injustice and oppression; see Amo 5:7.

expand all
Commentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

NET Notes: Amo 6:12 The botanical imagery, when juxtaposed with the preceding rhetorical questions, vividly depicts and emphasizes how the Israelites have perverted justi...

Geneva Bible: Amo 6:12 Shall horses ( n ) run upon the rock? will [one] plow [there] with oxen? for ye have turned judgment into gall, and the fruit of righteousness into ( ...

expand all
Commentary -- Verse Range Notes

TSK Synopsis: Amo 6:1-14 - --1 The wantonness of Israel,7 shall be plagued with desolation;12 and their incorrigibleness shall end in affliction.

MHCC: Amo 6:8-14 - --How dreadful, how miserable, is the case of those whose eternal ruin the Lord himself has sworn; for he can execute his purpose, and none can alter it...

Matthew Henry: Amo 6:8-14 - -- In the former part of the chapter we had these secure Israelites loading themselves with pleasures, as if they could never be made merry enough; her...

Keil-Delitzsch: Amo 6:12-14 - -- This judgment also, they, with their perversion of all right, will be unable to avert by their foolish trust in their own power. Amo 6:12. "Do hors...

Constable: Amo 1:3--7:1 - --II. Prophetic messages that Amos delivered 1:3--6:14 The Book of Amos consists of words (oracles, 1:3-6:14) and ...

Constable: Amo 3:1--6:14 - --B. Messages of Judgment against Israel chs. 3-6 After announcing that God would judge Israel, Amos deliv...

Constable: Amo 6:1-14 - --5. The fifth message on complacency and pride ch. 6 In this lament Amos announced again that Isr...

Constable: Amo 6:8-14 - --The complete devastation of Samaria 6:8-14 6:8 The prophet announced further that the sovereign Yahweh of hosts, even He, had sworn by Himself (cf. 4:...

Guzik: Amo 6:1-14 - --Amos 6 - Woe to the Pride of Jacob A. Woe to those who are at ease in Zion. 1. (1-2) Comparing Israel to her pagan neighbors. Woe to you who are a...

expand all
Introduction / Outline

JFB: Amos (Book Introduction) AMOS (meaning in Hebrew "a burden") was (Amo 1:1) a shepherd of Tekoa, a small town of Judah, six miles southeast from Beth-lehem, and twelve from Jer...

JFB: Amos (Outline) GOD'S JUDGMENTS ON SYRIA, PHILISTIA, TYRE, EDOM, AND AMMON. (Amo 1:1-15) CHARGES AGAINST MOAB, JUDAH, AND LASTLY ISRAEL, THE CHIEF SUBJECT OF AMOS' P...

TSK: Amos 6 (Chapter Introduction) Overview Amo 6:1, The wantonness of Israel, Amo 6:7, shall be plagued with desolation; Amo 6:12, and their incorrigibleness shall end in afflictio...

Poole: Amos (Book Introduction) THE ARGUMENT IF we might be allowed to make a conjecture at the quality of our prophet’ s sermons by the signification of his name, we must co...

Poole: Amos 6 (Chapter Introduction) CHAPTER 6 The voluptuousness of Israel, Amo 6:1-6 , shall be punished with desolation, Amo 6:7-11 . Their perversion of justice and vain confidence...

MHCC: Amos (Book Introduction) Amos was a herdsman, and engaged in agriculture. But the same Divine Spirit influenced Isaiah and Daniel in the court, and Amos in the sheep-folds, gi...

MHCC: Amos 6 (Chapter Introduction) (Amo 6:1-7) The danger of luxury and false security. (Amo 6:8-14) Punishments of sins.

Matthew Henry: Amos (Book Introduction) An Exposition, with Practical Observations, of The Prophecy of Amos Though this prophet appeared a little before Isaiah, yet he was not, as some have ...

Matthew Henry: Amos 6 (Chapter Introduction) In this chapter we have, I. A sinful people studying to put a slight upon God's threatenings and to make them appear trivial, confiding in their p...

Constable: Amos (Book Introduction) Introduction Title and Writer The title of the book comes from its writer. The prophet...

Constable: Amos (Outline) Outline I. Prologue 1:1-2 A. Introduction 1:1 B. Theme 1:2 ...

Constable: Amos Amos Bibliography Alter, Robert. The Art of Biblical Poetry. New York: Basic, 1985. Andersen, F...

Haydock: Amos (Book Introduction) THE PROPHECY OF AMOS. INTRODUCTION. Amos prophesied in Israel about the same time as Osee, and was called from following the cattle to denoun...

Gill: Amos (Book Introduction) INTRODUCTION TO AMOS This book in the Hebrew Bibles is called "Sepher Amos", the Book of Amos; and, in the Vulgate Latin and Syriac versions, the P...

Gill: Amos 6 (Chapter Introduction) INTRODUCTION TO AMOS 6 This chapter seems to be directed both to the two tribes of Judah and Benjamin, and the ten tribes of Israel, under the name...

Advanced Commentary (Dictionaries, Hymns, Arts, Sermon Illustration, Question and Answers, etc)


TIP #22: To open links on Discovery Box in a new window, use the right click. [ALL]
created in 0.06 seconds
powered by
bible.org - YLSA