
Text -- Deuteronomy 10:6 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley -> Deu 10:6
Wesley: Deu 10:6 - -- This following history comes in manifestly by way of parenthesis, as may appear from Deu 10:10, where he returns to his former discourse; and it seems...
This following history comes in manifestly by way of parenthesis, as may appear from Deu 10:10, where he returns to his former discourse; and it seems to be here inserted as an evidence of God's gracious answer to Moses's prayers, and of his reconciliation to the people, notwithstanding their late and great provocation. For, saith he, after this they proceeded by God's guidance in their journeys, and though Aaron died in one of them, yet God made up that breach, and Eleazar came in his place, and ministered as priest, one branch of which office was to intercede for the people.
JFB -> Deu 10:6-9
JFB: Deu 10:6-9 - -- So sudden a change from a spoken discourse to a historical narrative has greatly puzzled the most eminent biblical scholars, some of whom reject the p...
So sudden a change from a spoken discourse to a historical narrative has greatly puzzled the most eminent biblical scholars, some of whom reject the parenthesis as a manifest interpolation. But it is found in the most ancient Hebrew manuscripts, and, believing that all contained in this book was given by inspiration and is entitled to profound respect, we must receive it as it stands, although acknowledging our inability to explain the insertion of these encampment details in this place. There is another difficulty in the narrative itself. The stations which the Israelites are said successively to have occupied are enumerated here in a different order from Num 33:31. That the names of the stations in both passages are the same there can be no doubt; but, in Numbers, they are probably mentioned in reference to the first visit of the Hebrews during the long wandering southwards, before their return to Kadesh the second time; while here they have a reference to the second passage of the Israelites, when they again marched south, in order to compass the land of Edom. It is easy to conceive that Mosera (Hor) and the wells of Jaakan might lie in such a direction that a nomadic horde might, in different years, at one time take the former first in their way, and at another time the latter [ROBINSON].|| 05197||1||13||0||Moses here resumes his address, and having made a passing allusion to the principal events in their history, concludes by exhorting them to fear the Lord and serve Him faithfully.
Clarke -> Deu 10:6
Clarke: Deu 10:6 - -- And the children of Israel took their journey, etc. - On this and the three following verses see Kennicott’ s remarks at the end of this chapte...
And the children of Israel took their journey, etc. - On this and the three following verses see Kennicott’ s remarks at the end of this chapter.
Calvin -> Deu 10:6
Calvin: Deu 10:6 - -- 6.And the children of Israel Since it is not the design of Moses to specify the stations here, as he does in Num 33:0, but only to mark the place in ...
6.And the children of Israel Since it is not the design of Moses to specify the stations here, as he does in Num 33:0, but only to mark the place in which Aaron died, I have therefore thought fit to connect what we read here with the preceding narrative. In the death of Aaron, they might recognize the punishment of their own rebellion. But that Eleazar should be substituted in his place, was a sign of the paternal grace of God, who did not suffer them to be deprived of this blessing. This succession, too, was to be a perpetual rule for the future, so that the sacerdotal dignity, according to God’s prescription, should remain in that family.
He here specifies the names of certain places, which he omits in the passage above cited; for he there states that the Israelites went straight from Kadesh-barnea to Mount Hor; and then makes them pass on to Zalmonah and Punon, perhaps because the places had different names, or because they did not pitch their camp in Gudgodah, or Jotbath; although the advantages of the spot might have invited them to stop in a well-watered valley, for it is called “the land of torrents,” through which an abundance of water flowed.
I do not advert to what every reader will readily observe for himself, that in the discourse of Moses the order of the history is inverted; for he says that the Levites were separated from the rest of the people, after the death of Aaron.
Defender -> Deu 10:6
TSK -> Deu 10:6
TSK: Deu 10:6 - -- took : Num 10:6, Num 10:12, Num 10:13, Num 33:1, Num 33:2
Mosera : Num 33:30-33, Moseroth, Hor-ha-gid-gad, Jotbathah
there Aaron : Num 20:23-28, Num 3...
took : Num 10:6, Num 10:12, Num 10:13, Num 33:1, Num 33:2
Mosera : Num 33:30-33, Moseroth, Hor-ha-gid-gad, Jotbathah
there Aaron : Num 20:23-28, Num 33:38

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Deu 10:1-11
Barnes: Deu 10:1-11 - -- These verses are closely connected with the preceding chapter, and state very briefly the results of the intercession of Moses recorded in Deu 9:25-...
These verses are closely connected with the preceding chapter, and state very briefly the results of the intercession of Moses recorded in Deu 9:25-29. The people are reminded that all their blessings and privileges, forfeited by apostasy as soon as bestowed, were only now their own by a new and most unmerited act of grace on the part of God, won from Him by the self-sacrificing mediation of Moses himself Deu 10:10.
Deu 10:1-5. The order for making the ark and tabernacle was evidently given before the apostasy of the people (Exo. 25ff); but the tables were not put in the ark until the completion and dedication of the tabernacle Exo. 40. But here as elsewhere (compare the Deu 9:1 note) Moses connects transactions closely related to each other and to his purpose without regard to the order of occurrence.
There Aaron died - i. e., while the people were encamped in Mosera or Moseroth. In Deu 32:50; as well as in Num 20:25 ff Mount Hor is assigned as the place of Aaron’ s death. It is plain then that Moserah was in the neighborhood of Mount Hor. The appointment of Eleazar to minister in place of Aaron, is referred to as a proof of the completeness and fulness of the reconciliation effected between God and the people by Moses. Though Aaron was sentenced to die in the wilderness for his sin at Meribah, yet God provided for the perpetuation of the high priesthood, so that the people would not suffer. Compare Deu 9:20 and note.
At that time - i. e., that of the encampment at Sinai, as the words also import in Deu 10:1. Throughout the passage the time of the important events at Sinai is kept in view; it is reverted to as each incident is brought forward by Moses, alluded to sufficiently for his purpose, and dismissed.
Moses is evidently here speaking of the election by God of the tribe of Levi at large, priests and others also, for His own service.
Poole -> Deu 10:6
Poole: Deu 10:6 - -- This following history comes in manifestly by way of parenthesis, as may appear from Deu 10:10 , where he returns to his former discourse; and it se...
This following history comes in manifestly by way of parenthesis, as may appear from Deu 10:10 , where he returns to his former discourse; and it seems to be here inserted, either,
1. Because the priests and Levites here mentioned were the guardians and keepers of the ark and tables here mentioned. Or rather,
2. As an evidence of God’ s gracious answer to Moses’ s prayers, and of his reconciliation to the people, notwithstanding their late and great provocation. For, saith he, after this they proceeded by God’ s guidance in their journeys, some eminent stages whereof he names for all; and though Aaron died in one of them, yet God made up that breach, and Eleazar came in his place, and ministered as priest, one branch of which office was to intercede for the people. Then, saith he, God brought them from the barren parts of the wilderness to
a land of rivers of waters Deu 10:7 , a pleasant and fruitful soil. Then he adds, God separated the Levites, &c., Deu 10:8 .
Mosera
Object. This place seems directly contrary to that, Num 33:31 , where their journey is quite contrary to this, even
from Moseroth to Bene-jaakan This indeed is a great difficulty, and profane wits take occasion to cavil. And if a satisfactory answer be not yet given to it by interpreters, it ought not therefore to be concluded unanswerable, because many things formerly thought unanswerable have been since fully cleared, and therefore the like may be presumed concerning other doubts yet remaining. And it were much more reasonable to acknowledge here a transposition of the words through the scribe’ s mistake, than upon such a pretence to reject the Divine authority of those sacred books, which hath been confirmed by such irresistible arguments. But there is no need of these general pleas, seeing particular answers are and may be given to this difficulty sufficient to satisfy modest and impartial inquirers.
Answ
1. The places here mentioned are differing from those, Nu 33 , it being very frequent in Scripture for diverse persons and places to be called by the same names, and yet the names are not wholly the same; for there it is
Bene-jaakan and here Beeroth bene-jaakan , or
Beeroth of the children of Jaakan there Moseroth , here Mosera ; there Horhagidgad , here Gudgodah ; there Jotbathah , here Jotbath . If the places were the same, it may justly seem strange why Moses should so industriously make a change in every one of the names. And therefore these may be other stations, which being omitted in Nu 33 , are supplied here, it being usual in sacred Scripture to supply the defects of one place out of another.
Answ 2. Admitting these two places to be the same with those Num 33:31 , yet the journeys are diverse. They went from
Beeroth of the children of Jaakan to Mosera which is omitted in Numbers, and therefore here supplied; and then back again from Mosera or Moseroth to Bene-jaakan , as is there said; for which return there might then be some sufficient reason, though now unknown to us, as the reasons of many such like things are: or God might order it so for his own pleasure, and it is not impossible he might do it for this reason, that by this seeming contradiction, as well as some others, he might in just judgment do what he threatened to the Jews, Jer 6:21 , even lay stumbling-blocks before profane and proud wits, and give them that occasion of deceiving and ruining themselves, which they so greedily seek and gladly embrace; which is the reason given by some of the ancients why God hath left so many difficulties in Scripture.
Answ 3. The words may be otherwise rendered,
from Beeroth of the children of Jaakan and from Mosera ; where the order of the places is not observed, as was noted before of the order of time, Deu 10:1 , because it was nothing to the purpose here, and because that might be easily fetched from Nu 33 , where those journeys are more particularly and exactly described. For the conjunction and , that may be here wanting, and to be supplied, as it is Exo 6:23 1Sa 4:7 Psa 133:3 Isa 63:11 Hab 3:11 . And the preposition from is easily supplied from the foregoing words, as is most usual. Nor seems there to be any more reason to render it to Mosera , than from Mosera , seeing the Hebrew letter he in the end is made a part of the proper name, and therefore is not local. There Aaron died . Quest . How is this true? when Aaron died not in Mosera, but in Mount Hor, Num 33:38 .
Answ 1. Mosera may be a different place from Moseroth, and that may be the name of a town or region in which Mount Hor was, or to which it belonged. Or, the same mountain, in respect of diverse parts and opposite sides of it, might be called by diverse names, here Mosera, and there Hor. And it is possible they might go several journeys, and pass to divers stations, and by fetching a compass (which they oft did in their wilderness travels) come to the other side of the same mountain.
Answ 2. The Hebrew particle scham may here note the time, and not the place of Aaron’ s death, and may be rendered then, as it is taken, Gen 49:24 Psa 14:5 Ecc 3:17 Zep 1:14 . And then is not to be taken precisely, but with some latitude, as it is oft used in Scripture; that is, about that time, after a few removes more; as the words, at that time , Deu 10:8 , must necessarily be understood.
Haydock -> Deu 10:6
Haydock: Deu 10:6 - -- Mosera, by Mount Hor, for there Aaron died, Numbers xx. This and the following verses seem to be inserted by way of parenthesis, (Challoner) as far ...
Mosera, by Mount Hor, for there Aaron died, Numbers xx. This and the following verses seem to be inserted by way of parenthesis, (Challoner) as far as the 10th. The reason of their insertion here cannot easily be explained; but we must adore, in silence, the designs of the Holy Spirit. (Calmet) ---
Moses had just mentioned the ark, designed to contain the tables of the law; and as the priests and Levites were to be the guardians of those sacred things, he takes occasion to specify something with respect to their institution, &c. Mosera was perhaps twice visited by the Hebrews. The first time, they came thither from Beroth -Benejaacan, or from "the well of the children of Jacan, " and thence measured back their steps; though, the second time, Mosera, or Moseroth, is not noticed, because it had been specified already, and they did not stop long there, but proceeded to Gadgad, Numbers xxxiii. 30. (Bonfrere) (Menochius) ---
Others think that Mosera and Benejaacan are not the same places as Moseroth and Beroth Bensacan, though the names be similar. (Cornelius a Lapide) ---
Perhaps it will be more satisfactory to acknowledge, that Mosera has been transposed by the copyists, as it ought to come before Beroth, particularly as Moses places it in that order, where he gives an account of the 42 stations; and the Samaritan copy agrees with him in this place. (Calmet) ---
It also retains many words which have been omitted in Hebrew, and in all the versions taken from it; whence the omission seems to have taken place before the appearance of the version of the Septuagint. The Samaritan version, which is acknowledged to have preceded the Septuagint, agrees with its text, and reads, "And the children of Israel journeyed from Moseroth, and pitched in Benejaakan: from thence they journeyed, and pitched in Hagidgad: from thence they journeyed, and pitched in Jotbathah, a land of rivers of waters: from thence they journeyed, and pitched in Ebronah: from thence they journeyed, and pitched in Eziongaber: from thence they journeyed, and pitched in the wilderness of Zin, which is Kadesh: from thence they journeyed, and pitched in Mount Hor. And there Aaron died," &c. (Kennicott, 2. Dis.) ---
Thus Mosera will be the 27th, and Mount Hor the 34th station; (Pococke) whence the Israelites departed, after the death of Aaron, to Salmona, directing their course to the countries east of the Jordan, which had been promised to them. The appointment of Eleazar to succeed Aaron, and the separation of the Levites unto the Lord, should be all placed together, after the different encampments. (Haydock)
Gill -> Deu 10:6
Gill: Deu 10:6 - -- And the children of Israel took their journey from Beeroth of the children of Jaakan,.... Not when or soon after they removed from Sinai; for if this ...
And the children of Israel took their journey from Beeroth of the children of Jaakan,.... Not when or soon after they removed from Sinai; for if this place is the same with Benejaakan, as is generally supposed, they had a great many journeys, mansions, and stations before they came to it; see Num 33:31 and besides, since Aaron, according to this account, died at their next station from hence, that was thirty eight years after their departure from Mount Sinai; and it is hard to say what should be the reason of making mention of these two or three journeys here; and whereas they are here said to journey front the place here mentioned
to Mosera; on the contrary in Num 33:31 they are said to depart from Mosera, and pitch in Benejaakan; which is accounted for by their going backwards and forwards, and so both may be true. Aben Ezra is of opinion, that Beeroth Benejaakan, or the wells of the children of Jaakan, is not the same with Bene Jaakan, nor Mosera the same with Moseroth; but Beeroth is Kadesh, and Mosera is the name of the desert of Mount Hor; and it is certain that Moseroth was the twenty seventh station, and Mosera, or the desert of Mount Hor, where Aaron died, was the thirty fourth, and therefore must be distant; see Num 33:30, which seems to agree with what follows:
there Aaron died, and there he was buried; it is certain that Aaron died on Mount Hor, Num 20:23, or there died and was buried when in the desert of Mosera:
and Eleazar his son ministered in the priest's office in his stead; so that though the high priest died, the office continued, and the law of it remained in force, and the tribe of Levi was separated for the service of the sanctuary, as afterwards expressed.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes: Deu 10:6 Moserah. Since Aaron in other texts (Num 20:28; 33:38) is said to have died on Mount Hor, this must be the Arabah region in which Hor was located.
Geneva Bible -> Deu 10:6
Geneva Bible: Deu 10:6 And the children of Israel took their journey from Beeroth of the children of Jaakan to ( c ) Mosera: there Aaron died, and there he was buried; and E...

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Deu 10:1-22
TSK Synopsis: Deu 10:1-22 - --1 God's mercy in restoring the two tables;6 in continuing the priesthood;8 in separating the tribe of Levi;10 in hearkening unto Moses' suit for his p...
MHCC -> Deu 10:1-11
MHCC: Deu 10:1-11 - --Moses reminded the Israelites of God's great mercy to them, notwithstanding their provocations. There were four things in and by which the Lord showed...
Matthew Henry -> Deu 10:1-11
Matthew Henry: Deu 10:1-11 - -- There were four things in and by which God showed himself reconciled to Israel and made them truly great and happy, and in which God's goodness took...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Deu 10:6-7
Keil-Delitzsch: Deu 10:6-7 - --
And the Israelites owed to the grace of their God, which was turned towards them once more, through the intercession of Moses, not only the restorat...
Constable: Deu 5:1--26:19 - --IV. MOSES' SECOND MAJOR ADDRESS: AN EXPOSITION OF THE LAW chs. 5--26
". . . Deuteronomy contains the most compre...

Constable: Deu 5:1--11:32 - --A. The essence of the law and its fulfillment chs. 5-11
"In seven chapters the nature of Yahweh's demand...

Constable: Deu 7:1--11:32 - --3. Examples of the application of the principles chs. 7-11
"These clearly are not laws or comman...
