![](images/minus.gif)
Text -- Deuteronomy 23:2 (NET)
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/information.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley -> Deu 23:2
Taking the word as in the former verse.
JFB -> Deu 23:1-3
JFB: Deu 23:1-3 - -- "To enter into the congregation of the Lord" means either admission to public honors and offices in the Church and State of Israel, or, in the case of...
"To enter into the congregation of the Lord" means either admission to public honors and offices in the Church and State of Israel, or, in the case of foreigners, incorporation with that nation by marriage. The rule was that strangers and foreigners, for fear of friendship or marriage connections with them leading the people into idolatry, were not admissible till their conversion to the Jewish faith. But this passage describes certain limitations of the general rule. The following parties were excluded from the full rights and privileges of citizenship: (1) Eunuchs--It was a very ancient practice for parents in the East by various arts to mutilate their children, with a view to training them for service in the houses of the great. (2) Bastards--Such an indelible stigma in both these instances was designed as a discouragement to practices that were disgraceful, but too common from intercourse with foreigners. (3) Ammonites and Moabites--Without provocation they had combined to engage a soothsayer to curse the Israelites; and had further endeavored, by ensnaring them into the guilt and licentious abominations of idolatry, to seduce them from their allegiance to God.
Clarke -> Deu 23:2
Clarke: Deu 23:2 - -- A bastard shall not enter - ממזר mamzer , which is here rendered bastard, should be understood as implying the offspring of an illegitimate or ...
A bastard shall not enter -
Calvin -> Deu 23:2
Calvin: Deu 23:2 - -- 2.A bastard shall not enter. All agree that by the word ממזר , mamzer, a bastard is signified, who is born of an uncertain father; but they tak...
2.A bastard shall not enter. All agree that by the word
Defender -> Deu 23:2
Defender: Deu 23:2 - -- The Hebrew word here possibly refers only to certain types of illegitimate children, particularly those conceived in especially flagrant sins, such as...
The Hebrew word here possibly refers only to certain types of illegitimate children, particularly those conceived in especially flagrant sins, such as incest or in pagan idolatrous ceremonies. However, note the listing of a ten-generation genealogy from Judah's illegitimate son Phares to King David (Rth 4:18-22)."
TSK -> Deu 23:2
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Deu 23:2
Barnes: Deu 23:2 - -- A bastard - Probably, a child born of incest or adultery. Even to his tenth generation - i. e. (see the next verse and Neh 13:1), forever...
A bastard - Probably, a child born of incest or adultery.
Even to his tenth generation - i. e. (see the next verse and Neh 13:1), forever. Ten is the number of perfection and completeness.
Poole -> Deu 23:2
Poole: Deu 23:2 - -- A bastard so the word is commonly rendered, and so it notes a person base-born, or born in fornication or adultery, or by incestuous or any prohibite...
A bastard so the word is commonly rendered, and so it notes a person base-born, or born in fornication or adultery, or by incestuous or any prohibited mixtures of man and woman.
Object.
1. This law seems harsh, and too severe for the innocent bastard.
Answ 1. It was only an exclusion from government, which was a tolerable burden.
2. It was a necessary caution to prevent and brand the sin of uncleanness, to which the Jews were more than ordinarily prone.
Object. 2. Pharez and Jephthah were both bastards, yet advanced to great honour and authority.
Answ God gives laws to us, and not to himself; and, therefore he might, when he saw fit, confer what favour or power he pleased upon any such person, as he did to these. But some add, that the Hebrew word mamzer signifies not every bastard, but a bastard born of any strange woman, as the word may seem to intimate, and as such persons generally seem to have been, because of that special provision, that there should be no whore of the daughters of Israel , as it is here below, Deu 23:17 .
To his tenth generation or, his tenth generation, as it is in the Hebrew, and so in the following verses.
PBC -> Deu 23:2
PBC: Deu 23:2 - -- "even to his tenth generation"
Many suggest that David {Ps 51:5} accused his mother of conceiving him in a sinful affair with someone other than Jess...
"even to his tenth generation"
Many suggest that David {Ps 51:5} accused his mother of conceiving him in a sinful affair with someone other than Jesse. I offer that such a thought did not remotely enter his mind! In De 23:2 Moses taught that an illegitimate child could not "Enter into the congregation to the tenth generation." Ancient Jewish interpretation applies this verse to positions of leadership, such as king or priest. The Old Testament furnishes a vivid example of this principle in Ge 38:1-30. Judah fathered a son, Pharez, by his dead son’s widow. Remember that God ordained that Israel’s kings would come from the tribe of Judah, just as the priests would come from the tribe of Levi. Although scripture said that the sceptre should not depart from Judah until Shiloh, Christ the king, came, Judah’s first king was long delayed because of this sin. How many generations passed before Judah had her king? Look at the closing verses of Ruth. Ten generations passed from Judah with no king. Is this coincidence? Who appeared in the kingly line of Judah after the tenth generation? Jesse’s son, David, represented the tenth generation, demonstrating that the curse was satisfied. {Ru 4:18-22}
Haydock -> Deu 23:2
Haydock: Deu 23:2 - -- Mamzer, &c. The author of the Vulgate adds the explication of mamzer, which only occurs again, Zacharias ix. 6. It may in both places denote a stra...
Mamzer, &c. The author of the Vulgate adds the explication of mamzer, which only occurs again, Zacharias ix. 6. It may in both places denote a stranger, or one of a different religion from the Jews, as Jephte was the son of a prostitute, (Judges xi. 1,) and yet became a judge of Israel. But strangers, as long as they professed a false religion, could not be entitled to the privilege of Jewish citizens; and even after they had relinquished their false worship, they were bound to wait ten whole generations, or a long time, before they could fill the posts of honour and command. (Calmet) ---
This, however, seems to be contrary to the disposition made in favour of the Idumeans and Egyptians, who were admitted in the third generation. A mamzer may, therefore, be (Haydock) a bastard of a different nation from the Jews, (Menochius) which was not the case of Jephte. (Haydock) ---
The Rabbins specify three sorts of mamzers: 1. those born of parents who, by the law, are forbidden to marry, being to near akin; 2. those who are the fruit of adultery, or some criminal commerce, which is punished with death; and 3. those whose birth subjects the parents to be cut off or retrenched from the people. (Selden, Jur. v. 16.) ---
the Septuagint, &c., exclude the children "of a harlot," which is the sense of mamzer in the canon law. The Christian Church rejects such from holy orders, and the Athenians would not suffer bastards to offer sacrifice in the city, but only in the cynosarge, dedicated to Hercules, whose birth any doubts might be entertained. (Calmet) ---
It is observable, that such often imitate the wicked conduct of their parents; in which case, they are unfit for the magistracy; and though they may lead a very exemplary life, the law is intended to discourage such practices in parents, which may entail dishonour and loss upon their children; that, if they be not sufficiently restrained by their own personal disgrace, they may at least by the love for their innocent offspring. (Haydock) ---
Tenth. In the 11th generation, when the stain was obliterated, the descendant might become a magistrate. (Menochius) ---
Some understand that they were excluded for ever, as when the judges of the Areopagus ordered a man to appear again before them in 100 years' time, they meant that his cause was entirely rejected. (Vatable; Casaub. in Atheneus vi.)
Gill -> Deu 23:2
Gill: Deu 23:2 - -- A bastard shall not enter into the congregation of the Lord,.... That is born of whoredom, as the Targum of Jonathan; and for the sake of avoiding who...
A bastard shall not enter into the congregation of the Lord,.... That is born of whoredom, as the Targum of Jonathan; and for the sake of avoiding whoredom and deterring from it was this law made, according to Maimonides h, that adulterers might see, as he observes, that they affect their whole family with an irreparable stain, should they commit such an infamous action; though the Jews commonly interpret it of one that is born of any of those incestuous copulations forbidden in Lev 18:1 which they gather from this following upon, and being near unto one of those incests mentioned in the last verse of the preceding chapter i; and it is a rule with them k, that persons born of such copulations were reckoned bastards; now such an one, according to Jarchi, might not marry an Israelitish woman, or rather might not be admitted into the assembly of elders, or bear any public office. Jephthah may seem to be an objection to this, who was the son of an harlot, Jdg 11:1 which might be owing to the badness of the times, the laws of God being neglected, or to the providence of God so ordering it, who is not bound by his own laws, though men are; nor was he the son of a common harlot, nor of an incestuous person, but of his father's concubine; besides some think such only are intended who were born of strangers and not Israelites:
even unto his tenth generation shall he not enter into the congregation of the Lord; which seems as if he might at the eleventh; but it is generally interpreted never, as is gathered from the following verse, and from the tenth number being an absolute and perfect one; yet according to the Jewish writers there were ways and means by which their posterity became legitimate; so they say, bastards may be purified (or legitimated), how? if one marries a servant maid, the child is a servant, who if he becomes free, (his) son is a free man l.
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes: Deu 23:2 Heb “enter the assembly of the Lord.” The phrase “do so” has been used in the translation for stylistic reasons to avoid redun...
Geneva Bible -> Deu 23:2
Geneva Bible: Deu 23:2 ( b ) A bastard shall not enter into the congregation of the LORD; even to his tenth generation shall he not enter into the congregation of the LORD. ...
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Deu 23:1-25
TSK Synopsis: Deu 23:1-25 - --1 Who may or may not enter into the congregation.9 Uncleanness is to be avoided in the host.15 Of the fugitive servant.17 Of filthiness.18 Of abominab...
MHCC -> Deu 23:1-8
MHCC: Deu 23:1-8 - --We ought to value the privileges of God's people, both for ourselves and for our children, above all other advantages. No personal blemishes, no crime...
Matthew Henry -> Deu 23:1-8
Matthew Henry: Deu 23:1-8 - -- Interpreters are not agreed what is here meant by entering into the congregation of the Lord, which is here forbidden to eunuchs and to bastards, ...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Deu 23:1-8
Keil-Delitzsch: Deu 23:1-8 - --
The Right of Citizenship in the Congregation of the Lord. - Deu 23:1. Into the congregation of the Lord there was not to come, i.e., not to be recei...
Constable: Deu 5:1--26:19 - --IV. MOSES' SECOND MAJOR ADDRESS: AN EXPOSITION OF THE LAW chs. 5--26
". . . Deuteronomy contains the most compre...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: Deu 12:1--25:19 - --B. An exposition of selected covenant laws 12-25
Moses' homiletical exposition of the law of Israel that...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: Deu 22:9--23:19 - --7. Laws arising from the seventh commandment 22:9-23:18
The seventh commandment is, "You shall n...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)