
Text -- Deuteronomy 24:16 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley -> Deu 24:16
Wesley: Deu 24:16 - -- If the one be free from the guilt of the others sin, except in those cases where the sovereign Lord of life and death, before whom none is innocent, h...
If the one be free from the guilt of the others sin, except in those cases where the sovereign Lord of life and death, before whom none is innocent, hath commanded it, as Deu. 13:1-18; Jos 7:24. For though God do visit the father's sins upon the children, Exo 20:5, yet he will not suffer men to do so.
JFB -> Deu 24:16-18
JFB: Deu 24:16-18 - -- The rule was addressed for the guidance of magistrates, and it established the equitable principle that none should be responsible for the crimes of o...
The rule was addressed for the guidance of magistrates, and it established the equitable principle that none should be responsible for the crimes of others.
Clarke -> Deu 24:16
Clarke: Deu 24:16 - -- The fathers shall not be put to death for the children, etc. - This law is explained and illustrated in sufficient detail, Ezekiel 18.
The fathers shall not be put to death for the children, etc. - This law is explained and illustrated in sufficient detail, Ezekiel 18.
Calvin -> Deu 24:16
Calvin: Deu 24:16 - -- Here also God manifests how great is His regard for human life, so that blood should not be shed indiscriminately, when he forbids that children shou...
Here also God manifests how great is His regard for human life, so that blood should not be shed indiscriminately, when he forbids that children should be involved in the punishment of their parents. Nor was this Law by any means supererogatory, because on account of one man’s crime his whole race was often severely dealt with. It is not without cause, therefore, that God interposes for the protection of the innocent, and does not allow the punishment to travel further than where the crime exists. And surely our natural common sense dictates that it is an act of barbarous madness to put children to death out of hatred to their father. If any should object, what we have already seen, that God avenges “unto the third and fourth generation,” the reply is easy, that He is a law unto Himself, and that He does not rush by a blind impulse to the exercise of vengeance, so as to confound the innocent with the reprobate, but that He so visits the iniquity of the fathers upon their children, as to temper extreme severity with the greatest equity. Moreover, He has not so bound Himself by an inflexible rule as not to be free, if it so pleases Him, to depart from the Law; as, for example, He commanded the whole race of Canaan to be rooted out, because the land would not be purged except by the extermination of their defilements; and, since they were all reprobate, the children, no less than their fathers, were doomed to just destruction. Nay, we read that, after Saul’s death, his guilt was expiated by the death of his children, (2Sa 21:0;) still, by this special exception, the Supreme Lawgiver did not abrogate what He had commanded; but would have His own admirable wisdom acquiesced in, which is the fountain from whence all laws proceed.
TSK -> Deu 24:16

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Deu 24:16
Barnes: Deu 24:16 - -- A caution addressed to earthly judges. Among other Oriental nations the family of a criminal was commonly involved in his punishment (compare Est 9:...
A caution addressed to earthly judges. Among other Oriental nations the family of a criminal was commonly involved in his punishment (compare Est 9:13-14). In Israel it was not to be so; compare marginal references.
Poole -> Deu 24:16
Poole: Deu 24:16 - -- Understand it thus, if the one be free from the guilt of the other’ s sin, and except in those cases where the sovereign Lord of life and death...
Understand it thus, if the one be free from the guilt of the other’ s sin, and except in those cases where the sovereign Lord of life and death, before whom none is innocent, hath commanded it, as De 13 Jos 7:24 . For this law is given to men, not to God; and though God do visit the father’ s sins upon the children, Ex 20 , yet he will not suffer men to do so.
For his own sin understand only , and not for any other man’ s sin.
Haydock -> Deu 24:16
Haydock: Deu 24:16 - -- Sin. Judges have no right to punish any but those who have transgressed. (Calmet) ---
God may for reasons known to himself, which cannot be unjust...
Sin. Judges have no right to punish any but those who have transgressed. (Calmet) ---
God may for reasons known to himself, which cannot be unjust, visit the sins of the fathers upon their children; (Exodus xx. 5) and hence, (Josue vii.) he ordered the family of Achan to be involved in his punishment. Temporal sufferings, or death itself, are not however always a misfortune. They frequently prove a source of inconceivable blessings, Romans v. 3. (Haydock) ---
The Rabbins understand, that fathers and children are not to be received as witnesses against each other, (Onkelos) which seems foreign to the sense of the present law. (Calmet)
Gill -> Deu 24:16
Gill: Deu 24:16 - -- The fathers shall not be put to death for the children,.... By the civil magistrates, for sins committed by them of a capital nature, and which are wo...
The fathers shall not be put to death for the children,.... By the civil magistrates, for sins committed by them of a capital nature, and which are worthy of death:
neither shall the children be put to death for the fathers; for sins committed by them that deserve it:
every man shall be put to death for his own sin: which is but just and reasonable; see Eze 18:4; which is no contradiction to Exo 20:5; that respects what God himself would do, this what Israel, or the civil magistrates in it, should do; this is a command on Israel, as Aben Ezra observes; that the declaration of the sovereign Being, who is not bound by any law. Jarchi interprets these words differently, as that the one should not be put to death by the testimony of the other; and it is a rule with the Jews,"that an oath of witness is taken of men, and not of women; of those that are not akin, and not of those that are nearly related p:''on which one of the commentators observes q that such that are near akin are not fit to bear testimony, because it is written, "the father shall not be put to death for the children"; that is, for the testimony of the children. Jarchi indeed mentions the other sense, for the sins of the children, which has been given, and is undoubtedly the true sense of the text. The Targum of Jonathan gives both;"fathers should not be put to death, neither by the testimony, nor for the sins of the children; and children shall not be put to death, neither by the testimony, nor for the sins of fathers; but every man shall be put to death for his own sin by proper witnesses.''

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Deu 24:1-22
TSK Synopsis: Deu 24:1-22 - --1 Of divorce.5 A new married man goes not to war.6 Of pledges.7 Of man-stealers.8 Of leprosy.10 Of pledges.14 The hire is to be given.16 Of justice.19...
MHCC -> Deu 24:14-22
MHCC: Deu 24:14-22 - --It is not hard to prove that purity, piety, justice, mercy, fair conduct, kindness to the poor and destitute, consideration for them, and generosity o...
Matthew Henry -> Deu 24:14-22
Matthew Henry: Deu 24:14-22 - -- Here, I. Masters are commanded to be just to their poor servants, Deu 24:14, Deu 24:15. 1. They must not oppress them, by overloading them with work...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Deu 24:16-18
Keil-Delitzsch: Deu 24:16-18 - --
Warning against Injustice . - Deu 24:16. Fathers were not to be put to death upon (along with) their sons, nor sons upon (along with) their fathers...
Constable: Deu 5:1--26:19 - --IV. MOSES' SECOND MAJOR ADDRESS: AN EXPOSITION OF THE LAW chs. 5--26
". . . Deuteronomy contains the most compre...

Constable: Deu 12:1--25:19 - --B. An exposition of selected covenant laws 12-25
Moses' homiletical exposition of the law of Israel that...

Constable: Deu 24:8--26:1 - --9. Laws arising from the ninth commandment 24:8-25:19
The ninth commandment is, "You shall not b...
