![](images/minus.gif)
Text -- Deuteronomy 5:29 (NET)
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/information.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley -> Deu 5:29
Wesley: Deu 5:29 - -- A heart to fear God, and keep his commandments forever! The God of heaven is truly and earnestly desirous of the salvation of poor sinners. He has giv...
A heart to fear God, and keep his commandments forever! The God of heaven is truly and earnestly desirous of the salvation of poor sinners. He has given abundant proof that he is so: he gives us time and space to repent; by his mercies invites us to repentance, and waiteth to be gracious: has sent his son to redeem us, published a general offer of pardon, promised his spirit to those that pray for him; and has said, yea and sworn, that he hath no pleasure in the death of a sinner!
JFB -> Deu 5:29
JFB: Deu 5:29 - -- God can bestow such a heart, and has promised to give it, wherever it is asked (Jer 32:40). But the wish which is here expressed on the part of God fo...
God can bestow such a heart, and has promised to give it, wherever it is asked (Jer 32:40). But the wish which is here expressed on the part of God for the piety and steadfast obedience of the Israelites did not relate to them as individuals, so much as a nation, whose religious character and progress would have a mighty influence on the world at large.
Clarke -> Deu 5:29
Clarke: Deu 5:29 - -- O that there were such a heart in them - Or rather, מי יתן והיה לבבם זה mi yitten vehayah lebabam zeh , Who will give such a heart t...
O that there were such a heart in them - Or rather,
Calvin -> Deu 5:29
Calvin: Deu 5:29 - -- 29.O that there were such an heart in them God signifies that they would not be so firm and faithful in keeping their promises, as they were ready an...
29.O that there were such an heart in them God signifies that they would not be so firm and faithful in keeping their promises, as they were ready and willing to make them; and thus that hypocrisy was not altogether banished, or purged from their minds. Moreover, He figuratively (improprie) assumes a human feeling, because it would be vain and absurd for Him to desire what it was in His power to confer. Certainly He has the power of bending and directing men’s hearts whithersoever He pleases. Why, then, does He wish that it were given to the people from some other quarter, that they should be always kept in the path of duty, except that, speaking in the character of a man, He shows that it was rather to be wished than hoped that the people would constantly persevere in their fidelity? Wherefore this and similar passages have been ignorantly abused by some, to establish man’s free will. 220 They understand this passage, as if man’s will were capable of bending either way, and that he possessed the power of doing right, whilst God without interfering looked on at the event; as if God’s secret counsel, and not rather the end and use of external teaching, were referred to here. But we, taught by innumerable testimonies of Scripture, maintain, that it is the attribute of God alone to give what He here requires. So also immediately afterwards He says, that he wishes it may be well with the Israelites and their children, viz., because it is certain that it depends on men whether they are happy or not, as often as God invites them, when they refuse the grace offered to them; yet does it not therefore follow, that it depends on every man’s free will to attain happiness for himself. But here we must consider God’s will as it is set before us in His word, not as it is hidden in Himself; for, while by His word He invites all promiscuously to (eternal 221) life, He only quickens by His secret inspiration those whom He has elected. In sum, although God approves of the people’s answer, he says that there will be too much difficulty in the performance of it, for the event to accord with it.
TSK -> Deu 5:29
TSK: Deu 5:29 - -- The language of the original is emphatic: Mee yittain wehayah levavom zeh lahem , literally, ""Who will give that there may be such a heart in...
The language of the original is emphatic:
O that there : Deu 32:29, Deu 32:30; Psa 81:13-15; Isa 48:18; Jer 44:4; Eze 33:31, Eze 33:32; Mat 23:37; Luk 19:42; 2Co 5:20, 2Co 6:1; Heb 12:25
keep all : Deu 11:1; Psa 106:3, Psa 119:1-5; Luk 11:28; Joh 15:14; Rev 22:14
that it might : Deu 5:16; Deu 4:40, Deu 6:3, Deu 6:18; Deu 12:25, Deu 12:28; Deu 19:13; Deu 22:7; Rth 3:1; Psa 19:11; Isa 3:10; Jer 22:14, Jer 22:15; Eph 6:3; Jam 1:25
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Deu 5:23-33
Barnes: Deu 5:23-33 - -- These verses contain a much fuller narrative of the events briefly described in Exo 20:18-21. Here it is important to call attention to the fact tha...
These verses contain a much fuller narrative of the events briefly described in Exo 20:18-21. Here it is important to call attention to the fact that it was on the entreaties of the people that Moses had taken on him to be the channel of communication between God and them. God approved Deu 5:28 the request of the people, because it showed a feeling of their own unworthiness to enter into direct communion with God. The terrors of Sinai had done their work; they had awakened the consciousness of sin.
Poole -> Deu 5:29
Poole: Deu 5:29 - -- Heb. Who will give them such an heart ? This is spoken of God after the manner of men, to show that such a heart is desirable to him, and required ...
Heb. Who will give them such an heart ? This is spoken of God after the manner of men, to show that such a heart is desirable to him, and required by him; otherwise it is certain that God can give such a heart, and hath promised to give it, Jer 32:40 Eze 36:27 . And if God will work, who can hinder him? Job 11:10 .
Haydock -> Deu 5:29
Haydock: Deu 5:29 - -- A mind. God speaks like men, and insinuates how agreeable to him is a disposition influenced by a salutary fear. He does not mean that He cannot co...
A mind. God speaks like men, and insinuates how agreeable to him is a disposition influenced by a salutary fear. He does not mean that He cannot convert the heart of man. (Estius) ---
God exerts his power over our will by persuasive invitations. (Maimonides)
Gill -> Deu 5:29
Gill: Deu 5:29 - -- O that there were such an heart in them,.... Not that there is properly speaking such volitions and wishes in God; but, as Aben Ezra observes, the Scr...
O that there were such an heart in them,.... Not that there is properly speaking such volitions and wishes in God; but, as Aben Ezra observes, the Scripture speaks after the language of the children of men; and may be considered as upbraiding them with want of such an heart, and with weakness to do what they had promised; and, at most, as approving of those things they spoke of as grateful to him, and profitable to them: the words may be rendered, "who will give l that they had such an heart"; not to me, but to them, as Aben Ezra notes; they cannot give it to themselves, nor can any creature give it to them; none but God can, and therefore they ought to have prayed to him to give them an heart to hearken and do; agreeably to which is the Arabic version,"it is to be wished by them, that such an heart would continue with them;''which they by their language signified was in them: that they would fear me; which is not naturally in the heart of man, is a gift of God, a part of the covenant of grace, is implanted in regeneration, and is no inconsiderable branch of it; it is opposed to pride, and is consistent with faith and joy, and is increased by views of the grace and goodness of God, and is a distinguishing character of a good man:
and keep all my commandments always; not only one, but all, and not only at some certain times, but continually; and which are to be kept in faith from a principle of love, with a view to the glory of God, and in the strength of Christ; and to this the fear of God is necessary, for where there is no fear of God, there is no regard to his commandments; but where there is a reverential fear of God, there are faith, hope, love, and every other grace; yea, the Spirit, the author of all, who is in the saints, to enable them to walk in the statutes of the Lord, and to keep his judgments and do them; and such keep the commandments of God, not from a slavish fear, but from a sense of divine goodness:
that it might be well with them, and with their children for ever; for the fear of God, and the keeping of his commandments, issue in the good of men, in their own good, their inward peace, and spiritual welfare; in the good of others, their neighbours, servants, and children, by way of example and instruction; and even in the public peace and prosperity of a nation in which they dwell: not that these things are meritorious of eternal life, but are what are approved of by the Lord, and are grateful to him; which is the chief view in the expression of the text.
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Deu 5:1-33
TSK Synopsis: Deu 5:1-33 - --1 The covenant in Horeb.6 The ten commandments.23 At the people's request Moses receives the law from God.
MHCC -> Deu 5:23-33
MHCC: Deu 5:23-33 - --Moses refers to the consternation caused by the terror with which the law was given. God's appearances have always been terrible to man, ever since th...
Matthew Henry -> Deu 5:23-33
Matthew Henry: Deu 5:23-33 - -- Here, I. Moses reminds them of the agreement of both the parties that were now treating, in the mediation of Moses. 1. Here is the consternation tha...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Deu 5:24-33
Keil-Delitzsch: Deu 5:24-33 - --
Deu 5:24-27 contain a rhetorical, and at the same time really a more exact, account of the events described in Exo 20:18-20 (15-17). ואתּ (Deu 5...
Constable: Deu 5:1--26:19 - --IV. MOSES' SECOND MAJOR ADDRESS: AN EXPOSITION OF THE LAW chs. 5--26
". . . Deuteronomy contains the most compre...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: Deu 5:1--11:32 - --A. The essence of the law and its fulfillment chs. 5-11
"In seven chapters the nature of Yahweh's demand...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: Deu 5:1-33 - --1. Exposition of the Decalogue and its promulgation ch. 5
"The exposition of the law commences w...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)