
Text -- Ezekiel 20:1-4 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: Eze 20:1 - -- Of Zedekiah's reign, two years and five months before Nebuchadnezzar besieged Jerusalem.
Of Zedekiah's reign, two years and five months before Nebuchadnezzar besieged Jerusalem.

Yet resolved before - hand what they would do.

Wesley: Eze 20:4 - -- Wilt thou not convince and reprove them? And denounce my judgments against them? The abominations - What their fathers have done, they approve, and ha...
Wilt thou not convince and reprove them? And denounce my judgments against them? The abominations - What their fathers have done, they approve, and have outdone; by that let them know what to expect.
JFB: Eze 20:1 - -- Namely, from the carrying away of Jeconiah (Eze 1:2; Eze 8:1). This computation was calculated to make them cherish the more ardently the hope of the ...

JFB: Eze 20:1 - -- The object of their inquiry, as in Eze 14:1, is not stated; probably it was to ascertain the cause of the national calamities and the time of their te...
The object of their inquiry, as in Eze 14:1, is not stated; probably it was to ascertain the cause of the national calamities and the time of their termination, as their false prophets assured them of a speedy restoration.

JFB: Eze 20:3 - -- The chapter falls into two great parts: Eze. 20:1-32, the recital of the people's rebellions during five distinct periods: in Egypt, the wilderness, o...
The chapter falls into two great parts: Eze. 20:1-32, the recital of the people's rebellions during five distinct periods: in Egypt, the wilderness, on the borders of Canaan when a new generation arose, in Canaan, and in the time of the prophet.

JFB: Eze 20:3 - -- Because their moral state precluded them from capability of knowing the will of God (Psa 66:18; Pro 28:9; Joh 7:17).

JFB: Eze 20:4 - -- The emphatical repetition expresses, "Wilt thou not judge? yes, judge them. There is a loud call for immediate judgment." The Hebrew interrogative her...
The emphatical repetition expresses, "Wilt thou not judge? yes, judge them. There is a loud call for immediate judgment." The Hebrew interrogative here is a command, not a prohibition [MAURER]. Instead of spending time in teaching them, tell them of the abomination of their fathers, of which their own are the complement and counterpart, and which call for judgment.
Clarke: Eze 20:1 - -- In the seventh year - Of the captivity of Jeconiah, (see Eze 8:1), and the seventh of the reign of Zedekiah
In the seventh year - Of the captivity of Jeconiah, (see Eze 8:1), and the seventh of the reign of Zedekiah

Clarke: Eze 20:1 - -- The fifth month, the tenth day - That is, according to Abp. Usher, Monday, August 27, A.M. 3411
The fifth month, the tenth day - That is, according to Abp. Usher, Monday, August 27, A.M. 3411

Clarke: Eze 20:1 - -- Certain of the elders of Israel - What these came to inquire about is not known. They were doubtless hypocrites and deceivers, from the manner in wh...

Clarke: Eze 20:3 - -- I will not be inquired of by you - I will not hear you. I will have nothing to do with you.
I will not be inquired of by you - I will not hear you. I will have nothing to do with you.

Clarke: Eze 20:4 - -- Wilt thou judge them - If thou wilt enter into any discussion with them, show them the abomination of their fathers. The whole chapter is a consecut...
Wilt thou judge them - If thou wilt enter into any discussion with them, show them the abomination of their fathers. The whole chapter is a consecutive history of the unfaithfulness ingratitude, rebellion, and idolatry of the Jews, from the earliest times to that day; and vindicates the sentence which God had pronounced against them, and which he was about to execute more fully in delivering them and the city into the hands of the Chaldeans.
Calvin: Eze 20:1 - -- Here he does not narrate a vision but an event which really happened. It is a simple historical narrative, that some of the elders of Israel were cho...
Here he does not narrate a vision but an event which really happened. It is a simple historical narrative, that some of the elders of Israel were chosen to interrogate him. We know this to be customary, and when God separates His people from the profane nations, he opposes his prophets to the soothsayers and magi, augurs and astrologers. For he says that the Gentiles inquire what concerns them in various ways, and so interrogate their deities; but that he prescribes to the chosen people but one method: I will raise for them a prophet from the midst of their brethren, says Moses, (Deu 18:18;) that is, they need not wander about, like the wretched gentiles, destitute of counsel, first to their soothsayers, then to magi, and then to astrologers: there is no end to them’ but I will meet them, says he, by my prophets, who shall always exist among the people. In this sense Ezekiel says that the elders of Israel came to consult God. The verb,
Now the Clause which I have noticed contains some useful instruction, — the elders of Israel came to consult God and sat before the Prophet. We see, then, as far as concerns outward forms, that they followed what God had commanded in his law; lest you should say, Who shall ascend above the clouds? who shall descend into the abyss? who shall cross the sea? The word is ever there, in thy heart and in thy mouth. (Deu 30:12; Rom 10:6.) Since therefore God in some way brought himself forward whenever he instructed his servants by the spirit of prophecy, so when the elders of Israel came to the Prophet, they are said to come to God himself, because God was unwilling to utter his own oracles either from heaven or by means of angels, but he appointed his servant by whom he would speak, and suggested what he should say. Hence we gather that our faith is not rightly founded unless when we listen to God alone, who only deserves and claims us as listeners. But at the same time, we must remark that faith was joined with humility and modesty. Hence if any one desires to ascend to the clouds to inquire what God will answer, he departs far from him, although he pretends to approach him. Hence this moderation is to be observed, that our faith may acquiesce in the authority of the one God, and not be carried hither and thither by the will of men; and yet it should not object to here God speak through his servants, but calmly submit itself to the prophets. It now follows —

Calvin: Eze 20:3 - -- Here the Prophet is ordered to blame those elders, although they pretended to rare piety in inquiring of him: God says that they did not come with a ...
Here the Prophet is ordered to blame those elders, although they pretended to rare piety in inquiring of him: God says that they did not come with a right disposition. Many translate otherwise — if I shall be found, or be en-treated by you, or if I shall answer: thus they take the word,

Calvin: Eze 20:4 - -- The context flows very well if we embrace this sense, that God swears that the Israelites did not come to be subject to his Prophet, and to submit th...
The context flows very well if we embrace this sense, that God swears that the Israelites did not come to be subject to his Prophet, and to submit themselves modestly to his instructions. If this sense pleases, it is well added, shall you judge them? that is, shall you spend thy breath in arguing with them? He means that they are rather to be dismissed than instructed; as Christ says, You shall not cast pearls before swine. (Mat 7:6.) And we know what God pronounces: My Spirit shall not always strive with man, because he is flesh. (Gen 6:3.) He now means that there was no need of any dispute, since there was no means of carrying it on; so in this passage, since the Prophet was dealing with men utterly broken down, who never listened to wise counsels, nor obeyed any admonitions, nor were softened by any chastisement, he adds, therefore, shall you judge them? Some indeed coldly and insipidly explain this of taking away the part of a judge, since God rather wishes them to be called to repentance than to be condemned. But here judging embraces within itself all reproaches and threats. On the whole, since they acted deceitfully, and by no means proposed to submit themselves to God, hence he uses this bitterness, What! are they worthy of your judging them? that is, of your contending with them? for the Prophet’s duty is to argue with sinners, to threaten them, and to cite them to God’s tribunal. God, therefore, pronounces them unworthy of such disputing, because they are not only deaf, but, hardened by abandoned obstinacy. Now, therefore, we understand the sense of the words, wilt you judge them? will you judge them? The repetition is emphatic, that God may strongly express the obstinacy of that desperate people. He afterwards adds, If this be done, then show them the abominations of their fathers. God here mitigates the asperity which he had used, and by means of a correction descends to a reason for it, namely, that he may for once try whether or not they are curable. If then they are to be judged, that is, if he chooses to enter into any dispute, and to argue with them, he says that he ought to begin not with themselves, but with their fathers. God wishes them to be judged, not only on account of the wickedness of a few years, but because before they were born their fathers were obstinately attached to their abominations. In fine, God shows that the wound was deep, and could not be cured, unless the hidden poison was carefully examined, which otherwise would cause putrid matter, from which at length inflammation would arise. For many think that they have properly discharged their duty when they have but lightly probed their wounds: but sometimes it is necessary to penetrate to the inmost parts, as the people had not only provoked God lightly, and for a short time, but their impiety had been growing for ages, and their sins had become a kind of inheritance to them. Since, then, this hidden poison existed, which could not be cured either easily or by any slight remedy, hence God orders them to begin with their fathers. Show them, therefore, the abominations of their fathers. It follows —
TSK: Eze 20:1 - -- am 3411, bc 593
in the seventh : The seventh year of the captivity of Jeconiah, and according to Usher, Monday, Aug. 27, 3411. Eze 1:2, Eze 8:1, Eze 2...
am 3411, bc 593
in the seventh : The seventh year of the captivity of Jeconiah, and according to Usher, Monday, Aug. 27, 3411. Eze 1:2, Eze 8:1, Eze 24:1, Eze 26:1, Eze 29:1, Eze 29:17, Eze 30:20, Eze 31:1, Eze 32:1, Eze 40:1
that certain : Eze 14:1-3, Eze 33:30-33; 1Ki 14:2-6, 1Ki 22:15-28; 2Ki 3:13; Isa 29:13, Isa 58:2; Jer 37:17; Mat 22:16

TSK: Eze 20:3 - -- Are : Isa 1:12; Mat 3:7; Luk 3:7
As I : Eze 20:31, Eze 14:3, Eze 14:4, Eze 14:7, Eze 14:8; 1Sa 28:6; Psa 50:15-21; Pro 15:8, Pro 21:27, Pro 28:9; Isa ...

TSK: Eze 20:4 - -- judge them : or, plead for them, Eze 14:14, Eze 14:20, Eze 22:2, Eze 23:36, Eze 23:45; Isa 5:3; Jer 7:16, Jer 11:14, Jer 14:11-14, Jer 15:1; 1Co 6:2
c...
judge them : or, plead for them, Eze 14:14, Eze 14:20, Eze 22:2, Eze 23:36, Eze 23:45; Isa 5:3; Jer 7:16, Jer 11:14, Jer 14:11-14, Jer 15:1; 1Co 6:2
cause : Eze 16:2, Eze 16:3; Mat 23:29-37; Luk 11:47-51, Luk 13:33-35; Act 7:51, Act 7:52

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes: Eze 20:1 - -- The elders of Israel - These were as in Eze 14:1, some of Ezekiel’ s fellow-exiles, designated in general terms by the name of Israel, tho...
The elders of Israel - These were as in Eze 14:1, some of Ezekiel’ s fellow-exiles, designated in general terms by the name of Israel, though more properly belonging to the kingdom of Judah.

Enquire - As to the hope of deliverance from the Babylonians.

Barnes: Eze 20:4 - -- Wilt thou judge them? - We should rather say, Wilt thou not judge them? i. e., wilt thou not pronounce sentence upon them? Compare Eze 22:2.
Wilt thou judge them? - We should rather say, Wilt thou not judge them? i. e., wilt thou not pronounce sentence upon them? Compare Eze 22:2.
Poole: Eze 20:1 - -- The seventh year of Jeconiah’ s captivity and Zedekiah’ s reign, two years and five months before Nebuchadnezzar did besiege Jerusalem.
T...
The seventh year of Jeconiah’ s captivity and Zedekiah’ s reign, two years and five months before Nebuchadnezzar did besiege Jerusalem.
The fifth month August.
The tenth day which answers to cur twenty-seventh.
Certain Heb. men . Some of note among the elders and rulers of Israel. Either some of the captives in Babylon, as most likely they were who, Eze 8:1 , came to him, or some of those who were sent from Zedekiah to compliment or carry tribute to Nebuchadnezzar, as most likely they were, Eze 14:1 .
Of the elders not of the priests or Levites, but of the laity, civil magistrates and officers, who might be sent to view the state of Babylon, and to observe what posture things were in, the better to resolve on that Zedekiah and his councils were forming, whether it will be advisable to shake off the yoke of the king of Babylon by a rebellion, or patiently bear it: and I conjecture this might be the main inquiry they made now, which was two years and five months before the siege began, during which two years and five months I suppose the design was resolved on, framed, provision made of all sorts, and at last a rebellion raised.
Came to inquire of the Lord yet resolved beforehand what they would do, as will appear. Prophets neither did pretend to, nor could they, resolve such inquiries, but the Lord whom the prophets did consult.
Sat before me: whether it speak the quality of the persons, that did not stand as mean persons, or their resolution to wait for answer, or be a phrase proper with the Jews to express the common deportment of the country, I leave you to guess.

Poole: Eze 20:2 - -- While these men were with Ezekiel God gives him instruction what to say to them.
While these men were with Ezekiel God gives him instruction what to say to them.

Poole: Eze 20:3 - -- Son of man: see Eze 2:3 .
Speak unto the elders of Israel speak plainly, boldly, and to their faces, fear not their frowns; if they are deputies fr...
Son of man: see Eze 2:3 .
Speak unto the elders of Israel speak plainly, boldly, and to their faces, fear not their frowns; if they are deputies from Zedekiah, yet let not that character make thee mealymouthed.
Thus saith the Lord God: this expression carries enough to encourage him.
Are ye come to inquire of me? are ye in good earnest? Nay, but you act a deep hypocrisy, being already resolved on your own course, and yet now pretend you would know my counsel. It is a sharp reproof of their wickedness, and God utterly refuseth to be inquired of by such.
As I live: see Eze 14:16 .
I will not be inquired of by you profane hypocrites, that abuse my prophet, and tempt his God. They are, as all politicians who have less of religion than worldly wisdom, willing to hear whether the prophet will flatter, and fawn, and encourage them; if so, then he is a wise, able, honest man; else a sot to be slighted.

Poole: Eze 20:4 - -- Wilt thou judge them? either, Wilt thou judge charitably, and, supposing they are upright and teachable, wilt thou plead with me for them? as Eze 14:...
Wilt thou judge them? either, Wilt thou judge charitably, and, supposing they are upright and teachable, wilt thou plead with me for them? as Eze 14:3 , or as Jer 14:9 . Or else thus, Wilt thou argue with them, convince them, and reprove them? This is fittest to be done, and do this, handle them severely as they deserve. It is repeated, to whet the prophet, and quicken him to this work, and to intimate to us the great contumacy of the people.
Cause them to know the abominations of their fathers: tell them somewhat that they may go away wiser than they came. They expect to know what will be their fate, tell them what hath been their fathers’ carriage towards me, which they imitate, nay exceed. Their curiosity and perplexity would be informed what is to come, but their consciences need more to be informed: what their fathers have done they approved, and have outdone; by that let them know what to do, what to expect.
Haydock: Eze 20:1 - -- But. Literally, "And I did for," &c. This motive caused me to spare them. (Haydock) ---
I punished only the most guilty adorers of the calf, and ...
But. Literally, "And I did for," &c. This motive caused me to spare them. (Haydock) ---
I punished only the most guilty adorers of the calf, and murmurers, &c., Numbers xiv. 28. (Calmet) ---
Some were always preserved for a succession, ver. 9, 22. (Worthington)

Haydock: Eze 20:1 - -- Month: the year of the world 3411, August 27. (Usher) ---
Ezechiel had prophesied in the fourth year; they was silent a year and two months, or 430...
Month: the year of the world 3411, August 27. (Usher) ---
Ezechiel had prophesied in the fourth year; they was silent a year and two months, or 430 days. He opened his mouth again in the sixth year, (chap. viii. 1.) and now in the seventh year he is ordered not to answer. (Worthington) ---
We know not what the ancients wanted to know; but their design was evil. (Calmet)

Haydock: Eze 20:4 - -- Judgest them; or, if thou wilt enter into the cause, and plead against them. (Challoner) ---
Lay before them the iniquities of their fathers, and t...
Judgest them; or, if thou wilt enter into the cause, and plead against them. (Challoner) ---
Lay before them the iniquities of their fathers, and their own, which bring on the reprobation of the greatest part. God will form his Church out of a few of them and of the Gentiles. The return of a small number from captivity is also insinuated.
Gill: Eze 20:1 - -- And it came to pass in the seventh year,.... Of Zedekiah's reign, and of the captivity of Jeconiah; from whence the dates of Ezekiel's visions and pro...
And it came to pass in the seventh year,.... Of Zedekiah's reign, and of the captivity of Jeconiah; from whence the dates of Ezekiel's visions and prophecies are taken, Eze 1:2; two years, one month, and five days, after Ezekiel began to prophesy, and eleven months and five days after the preceding prophecy:
in the fifth month, the tenth day of the month; the month Ab, which answers to our July and August; on this day afterwards Jerusalem was twice destroyed, first by the Chaldeans, and then by the Romans:
that certain of the elders of Israel came to inquire of the Lord; by the prophet; these were either some of the elders that were carried captive, who came to inquire how long they should continue in this state; or what methods they should use to free themselves from it; or what they should do while they were in it; whether it would be advisable that they should conform to the customs of the Heathens among whom they were; or what would be the case of those that were left in Judea: or else these were sent by Zedekiah to pay the king of Babylon his tax, or to negotiate some affair with him relating to the captives; and who took this opportunity of consulting the Lord by the prophet what methods should be taken to throw off the yoke, and to know what was the mind of God in it; but these things are uncertain, as are also the persons the inquirers; though the Jews say e they were Ananias, Azarias, and Misael; which is not probable, since they were good men, whereas these seem to be hypocritical persons:
and sat before me; with great seriousness and devotion seemingly, waiting for an answer.

Gill: Eze 20:2 - -- Then came the word of the Lord unto me,.... While the elders were sitting before him, by an impulse upon his mind, dictating things unto him:
sayin...
Then came the word of the Lord unto me,.... While the elders were sitting before him, by an impulse upon his mind, dictating things unto him:
saying: as follows:

Gill: Eze 20:3 - -- Son of man, speak unto the elders of Israel, and say unto them,.... Give them this for an answer from me:
thus saith the Lord God, are ye come to i...
Son of man, speak unto the elders of Israel, and say unto them,.... Give them this for an answer from me:
thus saith the Lord God, are ye come to inquire of me? no; not seriously, heartily, and in good earnest, determining to abide by the advice and counsel that might be given; or how can you have the face to inquire of me, when guilty of such abominations?
as I live, saith the Lord God, I will not be inquired of by you; knowing their wickedness and hypocrisy, which were detestable to him, and therefore would not hear what they had to say, nor give them any answer, or direct them what they should do. Sad is the case of persons when the Lord will not be inquired of by them! it is plain he has no favours to bestow upon them; for, when he has, he will put them upon inquiring of him for them, to do them unto them, Eze 36:37; this was the case of Saul, whom God, when he inquired of him, would not answer in any of his usual ways, 1Sa 28:6.

Gill: Eze 20:4 - -- Wilt thou judge them, son of man?.... Excuse them, patronise them, defend their cause, and plead for them? surely thou wilt not; or rather, wilt thou ...
Wilt thou judge them, son of man?.... Excuse them, patronise them, defend their cause, and plead for them? surely thou wilt not; or rather, wilt thou not reprove and correct them, judge and condemn them, for their sins and wickedness? this thou oughtest to do:
wilt thou judge them? this is repeated, to show the vehemency of the speaker, and the duty of the prophet:
cause them to know the abominations of their fathers: the sins they committed, which were abominable in themselves, and rendered them abominable unto God, and what came upon them for them; by which they would be led to see the abominable evils which they also had been guilty of, in which they had imitated their fathers, and what they had reason to expect in consequence of them.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes


NET Notes: Eze 20:4 Heb “will you judge.” Here the imperfect form of the verb is probably used with a desiderative nuance. Addressed to the prophet, “ju...
Geneva Bible: Eze 20:1 And it came to pass in the ( a ) seventh year, in the fifth [month], the tenth [day] of the month, [that] certain of the elders of Israel came to enqu...

Geneva Bible: Eze 20:4 Wilt thou judge them, son of man, wilt thou judge [them]? cause ( b ) them to know the abominations of their fathers:
( b ) This declares the great l...

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Eze 20:1-49
TSK Synopsis: Eze 20:1-49 - --1 God refuses to be consulted by the elders of Israel.4 He shews the story of their rebellions in Egypt,10 in the wilderness,27 and in the land.33 He ...
MHCC -> Eze 20:1-9
MHCC: Eze 20:1-9 - --Those hearts are wretchedly hardened which ask God leave to go on in sin, and that even when suffering for it; see Eze 20:32. God is justly angry with...
Matthew Henry -> Eze 20:1-4
Matthew Henry: Eze 20:1-4 - -- Here is, 1. The occasion of the message which we have in this chapter. That sermon which we had ch. 18 was occasioned by their presumptuous reflecti...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Eze 20:1-4
Keil-Delitzsch: Eze 20:1-4 - --
The date given in Eze 20:1 applies not only to Ezekiel 20, but also to Ezekiel 20-23 (compare Eze 24:1); the prophetic utterances in these four chap...
Constable: Eze 4:1--24:27 - --II. Oracles of judgment on Judah and Jerusalem for sin chs. 4-24
This section of the book contains prophecies th...

Constable: Eze 20:1--23:49 - --D. Israel's defective leadership chs. 20-23
This section of the book is the final collection of propheci...

Constable: Eze 20:1-44 - --1. The history of Israel's rebellion and Yahweh's grace 20:1-44
The structure of this passage is...
