![](images/minus.gif)
Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/information.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
JFB: Ezr 1:11 - -- The vessels here specified amount only to the number of 2499. Hence it is probable that the larger vases only are mentioned, while the inventory of th...
The vessels here specified amount only to the number of 2499. Hence it is probable that the larger vases only are mentioned, while the inventory of the whole, including great and small, came to the gross sum stated in the text.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Ezr 1:11 - -- All the Jewish exiles did not embrace the privilege which the Persian king granted them. The great proportion, born in Babylon, preferred continuing i...
All the Jewish exiles did not embrace the privilege which the Persian king granted them. The great proportion, born in Babylon, preferred continuing in their comfortable homes to undertaking a distant, expensive, and hazardous journey to a desolate land. Nor did the returning exiles all go at once. The first band went with Zerubbabel, others afterwards with Ezra, and a large number with Nehemiah at a still later period.
Clarke -> Ezr 1:11
Clarke: Ezr 1:11 - -- All the vessels - were five thousand and four hundred - This place is without doubt corrupted; here it is said the sum of all the vessels, of every ...
All the vessels - were five thousand and four hundred - This place is without doubt corrupted; here it is said the sum of all the vessels, of every quality and kind, was five thousand four hundred; but the enumeration of the articles, as given in Ezr 1:9, Ezr 1:10, gives the sum of two thousand four hundred and ninety-nine only. But we can correct this account from 1 Esdras 2:13, 14
I shall set both accounts down, that they may be compared together
Ezr 1:9, Ezr 1:11 | 1 Esdras 2:13, 14 | ||
Golden chargers | 30 | Golden cups | 1000 |
Silver chargers | 1000 | Silver cups | 1000 |
Knives | 29 | Silver censers | 29 |
Golden basons | 30 | Golden vials | 30 |
Silver basons, second sort | 410 | Silver vials | 2410 |
Other vessels | 1000 | Other vessels | 1000 |
Said to be 5400 - only 2499 | Total | 5469 | |
Difference of the first account from itself: 2901 | Difference of the second account from the first: 69 |
According, therefore, to the sum total in Ezra, the sum total in Esdras is only 69 different. See the next chapter, Ezra 2 (note)
It may be said that the vessels did actually amount to 5400, and that the chief of them only were intended to be specified; and these happen to amount to 2499; but that it was not the design of Ezra to insert the whole; and that the ninth verse should be considered as stating, And of the chief of them, that is, the gold and silver articles, this is the number. But the expression in Ezr 1:10, other vessels, sets this conjecture aside: the place is most manifestly corrupted.
TSK -> Ezr 1:11
TSK: Ezr 1:11 - -- the vessels : Rom 9:23; 2Ti 2:19-21
five thousand : Instead of 5,400, the enumeration of the articles in 2Ti 2:9, 2Ti 2:10, only amounts to 2,499; but...
the vessels : Rom 9:23; 2Ti 2:19-21
five thousand : Instead of 5,400, the enumeration of the articles in 2Ti 2:9, 2Ti 2:10, only amounts to 2,499; but in the account, Esdras 2Ti 2:13, 2Ti 2:14, the amount is 5,469, as will be evident from the following statements:
Temple Vessels | |||
In Ezra | In Esdras | ||
Gold chargers | 30 | Gold cups | 1,000 |
Silver chargers | 1,000 | Silver cups | 1,000 |
Knives | 29 | Silver censers | 29 |
Gold basons | 30 | Gold vials | 30 |
Silver basons | 410 | Silver vials | 2,410 |
Other vessels | 1,000 | Other vessels | 1,000 |
Said to be | 5,400 | Total | 5,469 |
But only | 2,499 | ||
Deficiency | 2,901 | Surplus | 69 |
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Ezr 1:11
Barnes: Ezr 1:11 - -- The sum of the numbers as they stand in the present Hebrew text is 2,499, instead of 5,400. In the Apocryphal Book of Esdras the sum given is 5,469,...
The sum of the numbers as they stand in the present Hebrew text is 2,499, instead of 5,400. In the Apocryphal Book of Esdras the sum given is 5,469, and with this sum the items in that place exactly agree (1 Esdras 2:13, 14). Most commentators propose to correct Ezra by the passage of Esdras; but the items of Esdras are improbable. Probably the sum total in the present passage has suffered corruption.
Poole -> Ezr 1:10
Poole: Ezr 1:10 - -- Basons of a second sort the first or chief were of gold, and these of silver are called the second, or next to them of worth and use.
Other vessels ...
Basons of a second sort the first or chief were of gold, and these of silver are called the second, or next to them of worth and use.
Other vessels a thousand: he speaks of vessels of a middle size; for great and small were five thousand four hundred, as it follows here. Or, as some render it,
other vessels by
thousands: they were not distinctly numbered according to their various forms and uses, but were promiscuously put together by thousands.
Haydock: Ezr 1:10 - -- Sort. Septuagint and Syriac, "double;" yet of less value. (Calmet) ---
As no first sort had been mentioned, and some Latin manuscripts read 2410, ...
Sort. Septuagint and Syriac, "double;" yet of less value. (Calmet) ---
As no first sort had been mentioned, and some Latin manuscripts read 2410, agreeably to 3 Esdras ii. 12., and the truth, (Hallet) it may be inferred that "thousands were expressed anciently by single letters, with a dot....over them." Afterwards, when numbers were expressed by words at length, the b being thus reduced to signify "two," was, of course, written shnim; but this word making nonsense with the following, has been changed into mishnim, a word not very agreeable to the sense here, and which leaves the sum total, now specified in the Hebrew text, very deficient for want of the 2000, thus omitted. (Kennicott, Dis. ii.) ---
Josephus has, "30 golden cups, 2400 of silver." (Haydock)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Haydock: Ezr 1:11 - -- Hundred. Only 2499 are specified. 3 Esdras reads, 5469. Josephus ([Antiquities?] xi. 1.) differs from all, reading 5210; which shews that the copi...
Hundred. Only 2499 are specified. 3 Esdras reads, 5469. Josephus ([Antiquities?] xi. 1.) differs from all, reading 5210; which shews that the copies have varied, and that the Hebrew is incorrect. (Calmet) ---
The use of number letters might cause this confusion. (Haydock) (Capel. iii. 20, 13.)
Gill: Ezr 1:10 - -- Thirty basins of gold,.... Cups or dishes with covers, as the word seems to signify; but, according to Jarchi and Aben Ezra, they were vessels in whic...
Thirty basins of gold,.... Cups or dishes with covers, as the word seems to signify; but, according to Jarchi and Aben Ezra, they were vessels in which the blood of sacrifices was received, and out of which it was sprinkled on the altar:
silver basins of a second sort four hundred and ten; perhaps lesser than the other, however not so valuable, being of silver; in the Apocrypha:"And this was the number of them; A thousand golden cups, and a thousand of silver, censers of silver twenty nine, vials of gold thirty, and of silver two thousand four hundred and ten, and a thousand other vessels.'' (1 Esdras 2:13)the number is 2410; and in the letter of Cyrus, before referred to, it is 2400:
and other vessels a thousand; which are not particularly mentioned; Junius and Tremellius render the words:
other vessels by thousands, there being near 3000 that are not described.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Ezr 1:11 - -- All the vessels of gold, and of silver, were five thousand and four hundred,.... Those that are mentioned make no more than 2499, which Aben Ezra thin...
All the vessels of gold, and of silver, were five thousand and four hundred,.... Those that are mentioned make no more than 2499, which Aben Ezra thinks were the larger vessels; but this general sum takes in great and small, as in 2Ch 36:18 in the letter of Cyrus, before mentioned, these vessels are more particularly described, and their several numbers given, which together amount to the exact number in the text, 5400; the apocryphal Ezra makes them 5469:
all these did Sheshbazzar bring up with them of the captivity, that were brought up from Babylon unto Jerusalem: of whom there is a large and particular account in the following chapter.
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes: Ezr 1:10 The meaning of the Hebrew term מִשְׁנִים (mishnim) is uncertain. The noun מִש&...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: Ezr 1:11 The total number as given in the MT does not match the numbers given for the various items in v. 9. It is not clear whether the difference is due to e...
Geneva Bible -> Ezr 1:11
Geneva Bible: Ezr 1:11 All the vessels of gold and of silver [were] five thousand and four hundred. All [these] did Sheshbazzar bring up ( k ) with [them of] the captivity t...
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Ezr 1:1-11
TSK Synopsis: Ezr 1:1-11 - --1 The proclamation of Cyrus for the building of the temple.5 The people provide for their return.7 Cyrus restores the vessels of the temple to Sheshba...
Maclaren -> Ezr 1:1-11
Maclaren: Ezr 1:1-11 - --The Eve Of The Restoration
Now in the first year of Cyrus king of Persia, that the word of the Lord by the mouth of Jeremiah might be fulfilled, the ...
MHCC -> Ezr 1:5-11
MHCC: Ezr 1:5-11 - --The same God that raised up the spirit of Cyrus to proclaim liberty to the Jews, raised up their spirits to take the benefit. The temptation was to so...
Matthew Henry -> Ezr 1:5-11
Matthew Henry: Ezr 1:5-11 - -- We are here told, I. How Cyrus's proclamation succeeded with others. 1. He having given leave to the Jews to go up to Jerusalem, many of them went u...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Ezr 1:7-10; Ezr 1:11
Keil-Delitzsch: Ezr 1:7-10 - --
King Cyrus, moreover, caused those sacred vessels of the temple whichhad been carried away by Nebuchadnezzar to be brought forth, anddelivered them ...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Keil-Delitzsch: Ezr 1:11 - --
"All the vessels of gold and of silver were five thousand and fourhundred."But only 30 + 1000 אנרטלים , 29 מחלפים , 30 + 410 coveredg...
Constable: Ezr 1:1--6:22 - --I. THE FIRST RETURN UNDER SHESHBAZZAR chs. 1--6
"This whole section (Ezra 1-6) emphasizes God's sovereignty and ...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: Ezr 1:1-11 - --1. The edict of Cyrus and its consequences ch. 1
God had warned his people Israel that disobedie...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)