
Text -- Genesis 9:6 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: Gen 9:6 - -- Whether upon a sudden provocation, or premeditated, (for rash anger is heart - murder as well as malice prepense, Mat 5:21-22), by man shall his blood...
Whether upon a sudden provocation, or premeditated, (for rash anger is heart - murder as well as malice prepense, Mat 5:21-22), by man shall his blood be shed - That is, by the magistrate, or whoever is appointed to be the avenger of blood. Before the flood, as it should seem by the story of Cain, God took the punishment of murder into his own hands; but now he committed this judgment to men, to masters of families at first, and afterwards to the heads of countries.

Wesley: Gen 9:6 - -- Man is a creature dear to his Creator, and therefore ought to be so to us; God put honour upon him, let us not then put contempt upon him. Such remain...
Man is a creature dear to his Creator, and therefore ought to be so to us; God put honour upon him, let us not then put contempt upon him. Such remains of God's image are still even upon fallen man, that he who unjustly kills a man, defaceth the image of God, and doth dishonour to him.
JFB -> Gen 9:6
JFB: Gen 9:6 - -- It is true that image has been injured by the fall, but it is not lost. In this view, a high value is attached to the life of every man, even the poor...
It is true that image has been injured by the fall, but it is not lost. In this view, a high value is attached to the life of every man, even the poorest and humblest, and an awful criminality is involved in the destruction of it.
Clarke -> Gen 9:6
Clarke: Gen 9:6 - -- Whoso sheddeth man’ s blood, by man shall his blood - Hence it appears that whoever kills a man, unless unwittingly, as the Scripture expresses...
Whoso sheddeth man’ s blood, by man shall his blood - Hence it appears that whoever kills a man, unless unwittingly, as the Scripture expresses it, shall forfeit his own life
A man is accused of the crime of murder; of this crime he is guilty or he is not: if he be guilty of murder he should die; if not, let him be punished according to the demerit of his crime; but for no offense but murder should he lose his life. Taking away the life of another is the highest offense that can be committed against the individual, and against society; and the highest punishment that a man can suffer for such a crime is the loss of his own life. As punishment should be ever proportioned to crimes, so the highest punishment due to the highest crime should not be inflicted for a minor offense. The law of God and the eternal dictates of reason say, that if a man kill another, the loss of his own life is at once the highest penalty he can pay, and an equivalent for his offense as far as civil society is concerned. If the death of the murderer be the highest penalty he can pay for the murder he has committed, then the infliction of this punishment for any minor offense is injustice and cruelty; and serves only to confound the claims of justice, the different degrees of moral turpitude and vice, and to render the profligate desperate: hence the adage so frequent among almost every order of delinquents, "It is as good to be hanged for a sheep as a lamb;"which at once marks their desperation, and the injustice of those penal laws which inflict the highest punishment for almost every species of crime. When shall a wise and judicious legislature see the absurdity and injustice of inflicting the punishment of death for stealing a sheep or a horse, forging a twenty shillings’ note, and Murdering A Man; when the latter, in its moral turpitude and ruinous consequences, infinitely exceeds the others?* (* On this head the doctor’ s pious wish has been realized since this paragraph was written. - Publishers)
Calvin -> Gen 9:6
Calvin: Gen 9:6 - -- 6.Whoso sheddeth man’s blood 291 The clause in man which is here added, has the force of amplification. Some expound it, ‘Before witnesses.’ Ot...
6.Whoso sheddeth man’s blood 291 The clause in man which is here added, has the force of amplification. Some expound it, ‘Before witnesses.’ Others refer it to what follows, namely, ‘that by man his blood should be shed.’ 292 But all these interpretations are forced. What I have said must be remembered, that this language rather expresses the atrociousness of the crime; because whosoever kills a man, draws down upon himself the blood and life of his brother. On the whole, they are deceived (in my judgment) who think that a political law, for the punishment of homicides, is here simply intended. Truly I do not deny that the punishment which the laws ordain, and which the judges execute, are founded on this divine sentence; but I say the words are more comprehensive. It is written,
‘Men of blood shall not live out half their days,’
(Psa 55:23.)
And we see some die in highways, some in stews, and many in wars. Therefore, however magistrates may connive at the crime, God sends executioners from other quarters, who shall render unto sanguinary men their reward. God so threatens and denounces vengeance against the murderer, that he even arms the magistrate with the sword for the avenging of slaughter, in order that the blood of men may not be shed with impunity.
For in the image of God made he man. For the greater confirmation of the above doctrines God declares, that he is not thus solicitous respecting human life rashly, and for no purpose. Men are indeed unworthy of God’s care, if respect be had only to themselves. but since they bear the image of God engraven on them, He deems himself violated in their person. Thus, although they have nothing of their own by which they obtain the favor of God, he looks upon his own gifts in them, and is thereby excited to love and to care for them. This doctrine, however is to be carefully observed that no one can be injurious to his brother without wounding God himself. Were this doctrine deeply fixed in our minds, we should be much more reluctant than we are to inflict injuries. Should any one object, that this divine image has been obliterated, the solution is easy; first, there yet exists some remnant of it, so that man is possessed of no small dignity; and, secondly, the Celestial Creator himself, however corrupted man may be, still keeps in view the end of his original creation; and according to his example, we ought to consider for what end he created men, and what excellence he has bestowed upon them above the rest of living beings.
Defender -> Gen 9:6
Defender: Gen 9:6 - -- This establishment of capital punishment, administered judicially by man, has never been changed or withdrawn. It is still God's law today and forms t...
This establishment of capital punishment, administered judicially by man, has never been changed or withdrawn. It is still God's law today and forms the basic authorization of the institution of human government. It implies also the enactment and enforcement of regulations for those human activities (stealing, adultery) which if unrestrained, would lead to murder. It does not stipulate the form, but only the fact of government. It extends the primeval mandate by giving man the responsibility to control not only the animals but his own society also. The original commission had authorized the natural sciences and technologies; this new extension incorporated in God's covenant with Noah authorizes the social sciences and their technologies (psychology, law, sociology, anthropology, political science, government, police, criminology).
Although capital punishment is the proper prerogative of human society ("every man's brother") as far as strict justice is concerned, mitigating circumstances (especially sincere repentance and restitution) may warrant extension of mercy in individual cases. Nevertheless, the basic right of governments to exact capital punishment as penalty for murder cannot legitimately be abrogated as far as God is concerned. This is clear even in the Christian dispensation. The eating of meat (1Ti 4:3, 1Ti 4:4), the abstinence from blood (Act 15:19, Act 15:20) and the authority of the governmental sword (Rom 13:4; Act 25:11) were reaffirmed to the early church, making it clear that the Noahic mandate still applied."
TSK -> Gen 9:6
TSK: Gen 9:6 - -- by : Exo 21:12-14, Exo 22:2, Exo 22:3; Lev 17:4, Lev 24:17; Num 35:25; 1Ki 2:5, 1Ki 2:6, 1Ki 2:28-34; Mat 26:52; Rom 13:4; Rev 13:10
in : Gen 1:26, Ge...

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Gen 9:1-7
Barnes: Gen 9:1-7 - -- - The Blessing of Noah 2. מורא môrā' , "fear, reverence, awful deed." חת chat , "dread, breaking of the courage." Noah is save...
- The Blessing of Noah
2.
Noah is saved from the deluge. His life is twice given to him by God. He had found grace in the sight of the Lord, and now he and his family have been graciously accepted when they approached the Lord with burnt-offerings. In him, therefore, the race of man is to be begun anew. Accordingly, as at the beginning, the Lord proceeds to bless him. First. The grant of increase is the same as at first, but expressed in ampler terms. Second. Dominion over the other animals is renewed. But some reluctance on their part to yield obedience is intimated. "The fear and dread of you."These terms give token of a master whose power is dreaded, rather than of a superior whose friendly protection is sought. "Into your hand are they given."They are placed entirely at the disposal of man.
The grant of sustenance is no longer confined to the vegetable, but extended to the animal kinds, with two solemn restrictions. This explains how fully the animals are handed over to the will of man. They were slain for sacrifice from the earliest times. Whether they were used for food before this time we are not informed. But now "every creeper that is alive"is granted for food. "Every creeper"is everything that moves with the body prone to the earth, and therefore in a creeping posture. This seems to describe the inferior animals in contradistinction to man, who walks erect. The phrase "that is alive"seems to exclude animals that have died a natural death from being used as food.
The first restriction on the grant of animal food is thus expressed: "Flesh with its life, its blood, shall ye not eat."The animal must be slain before any part of it is used for food. And as it lives so long as the blood flows in its veins, the life-blood must be drawn before its flesh may be eaten. The design of this restriction is to prevent the horrid cruelty of mutilating or cooking an animal while yet alive and capable of suffering pain. The draining of the blood from the body is an obvious occasion of death, and therefore the prohibition to eat the flesh with the blood of life is a needful restraint from savage cruelty. It is also intended, perhaps, to teach that the life of the animal, which is in the blood, belongs not to man, but to God himself, who gave it. He makes account of it for atonement in sacrifice; otherwise it is to be poured on the ground and covered with dust Lev 17:11-13.
The second restriction guards human life. The shedding of human blood is sternly prohibited. "Your blood of your lives."The blood which belongs to your lives, which constitutes the very life of your corporeal nature. "Will I require."I, the Lord, will find the murderer out, and exact the penalty of his crime. The very beast that causes the death of man shall be slain. The suicide and the homicide are alike accountable to God for the shedding of man’ s blood. The penalty of murder is here proclaimed - death for death. It is an instance of the law of retaliation. This is an axiom of moral equity. He that deprives another of any property is bound to make it good or to suffer the like loss.
The first law promulgated in Scripture was that between Creator and creature. If the creature refuse to the Creator the obedience due, he forfeits all the Creator has given him, and, therefore, his life. Hence, when Cain murdered his brother, he only displayed a new development of that sin which was in him, and, being already condemned to the extreme penalty under the first transgression, had only a minor punishment annexed to his personal crime. And so it continued to be in the antediluvian world. No civil law is on record for the restriction of crime. Cain, indeed, feared the natural vengeance which his conscience told him his sin deserved. But it was not competent in equity for the private individual to undertake the enforcement of the penalties of natural law. So long as the law was between Creator and creature, God himself was not only the sole legislator, but the sole administrator of law.
The second law is that between creature and creature, which is here introduced on the occasion of giving permission to partake of animal food, as the first was published on that of granting the use of vegetable diet. In the former case, God is the administrator of the law, as he is the immediate and sovereign party in the legal compact. In the latter case, man is, by the express appointment of the Lord of all, constituted the executive agent. "By man shall his blood be shed."Here, then, is the formal institution of civil government. Here the civil sword is committed to the charge of man. The judgment of death by the executioner is solemnly delegated to man in vindication of human life. This trust is conveyed in the most general terms. "By man."The divine legislator does not name the sovereign, define his powers, or determine the law of succession. All these practical conditions of a stable government are left open questions.
The emphasis is laid solely on "man."On man is impressively laid the obligation of instituting a civil constitution suited to his present fallen condition. On the nation as a body it is an incumbent duty to select the sovereign, to form the civil compact between prince and people, to settle the prerogative of the sovereign and the rights of the subjects, to fix the order of succession, to constitute the legislative, judicial, and administrative bodies, and to render due submission to the constituted authorities. And all these arrangements are to be made according to the principles of Scripture and the light of nature.
The reason why retribution is exacted in the case of man is here also given. "For in the image of God has he made man."This points on the one hand to the function of the magistrate, and on the other to the claims of the violated law; and in both respects illustrates the meaning of being created in the image of God. Man resembles God in this, that he is a moral being, judging of right and wrong, endowed with reason and will, and capable of holding and exercising rights. Hence, he is in the first place competent to rule, and on his creation authorized to exercise a mild and moral sway over the inferior creatures. His capacity to govern even among his fellow-men is now recognized. The function of self-government in civil things is now conferred upon man. When duly called to the office, he is declared to be at liberty to discharge the part of a ruler among his fellow-men, and is entitled on the ground of this divine arrangement to claim the obedience of those who are under his sway. He must rule in the Lord, and they must obey in the Lord.
However, in the next place, man is capable of, and has been actually endowed with, rights of property in himself, his children, his industrial products, his purchases, his receipts in the way of gift, and his claims by covenant or promise. He can also recognize such rights in another. When, therefore, he is deprived of anything belonging to him, he is sensible of being wronged, and feels that the wrongdoer is bound to make reparation by giving back what he has taken away, or an equivalent in its place. This is the law of requital, which is the universal principle of justice between the wrongdoer and the wrong-sufferer. Hence, the blood of him who sheds blood is to be shed. And, in setting up a system of human government, the most natural and obvious case is given, according to the manner of Scripture, as a sample of the law by which punishment is to be inflicted on the transgressor in proportion to his crime. The case in point accordingly arises necessarily out of the permission to use animal food, which requires to be guarded on the one hand by a provision against cruelty to animals, and, on the other, by an enactment forbidding the taking away of human life, on the pain of death, by order of the civil magistrate. This case, then, turns out to be the most heinous crime which man can commit against his fellow-man, and strikingly exemplifies the great common principle of retributive justice.
The brute is not a moral being, and has, therefore, no proper rights in itself. Its blood may therefore be shed with impunity. Nevertheless, man, because he is a moral being, owes a certain negative duty to the brute animal, because it is capable of pain. He is not to inflict gratuitous or unnecessary suffering on a being susceptible of such torture. Hence, the propriety of the blood being shed before the flesh is used for food. Life, and therefore the sense of pain, is extinguished when the blood is withdrawn from the veins.
Poole -> Gen 9:6
Poole: Gen 9:6 - -- Whoso sheddeth man’ s blood wilfully and unwarrantably. For there is a double exception to this law:
1. Of casual murder, expressed Num 35:31 D...
Whoso sheddeth man’ s blood wilfully and unwarrantably. For there is a double exception to this law:
1. Of casual murder, expressed Num 35:31 Deu 19:4 .
2. Of death inflicted by the hand of the magistrate for crimes deserving it, mentioned in the following words, and elsewhere.
By man i.e. by the hand of man, namely, the magistrate, Rom 13:4 ; who is hereby empowered and required, upon pain of my highest displeasure, to inflict this punishment. See Exo 21:12 Lev 24:17 Mat 26:57 . Or, for that man, i.e. for that man’ s sake, whose blood he hath shed, which cries for vengeance.
In the image of God made he man so that murder is not only an offence against man, but also an injury to God, and a contempt of that image of God which all men are obliged to reverence and maintain, and especially magistrates, who being my vicegerents and servants, are therefore under a particular obligation to punish those who deface and destroy it.
Haydock -> Gen 9:6
Haydock: Gen 9:6 - -- Shed. God had not subjected Cain to this law of retaliation, as he was the first murderer, and the earth was unpeopled. (Haydock) ---
Here he decl...
Shed. God had not subjected Cain to this law of retaliation, as he was the first murderer, and the earth was unpeopled. (Haydock) ---
Here he declares, that it is just to inflict such a punishment on the offender. (Menochius) ---
Judges are hence authorized to punish murderers with death. (Calmet) ---
The general law, thou shalt not kill, admits of exceptions, and forbids killing by private authority, or out of revenge. (Haydock) ---
The blood of your lives, may signify the blood on which your life depends; or, according to the Rabbin, it is a prohibition of suicide, which one would think is so contrary to the first law of nature, self-preservation, as to require no prohibition; and yet, to the scandal of philosophers, some have written in its defence! (Haydock)
Gill -> Gen 9:6
Gill: Gen 9:6 - -- Whoso sheddeth man's blood, by man shall his blood be shed,.... That is, he that is guilty of wilful murder shall surely be put to death by the order ...
Whoso sheddeth man's blood, by man shall his blood be shed,.... That is, he that is guilty of wilful murder shall surely be put to death by the order of the civil magistrate; so the Targum of Jonathan,"by witnesses the judges shall condemn him to death,''that is, the fact being clearly proved by witnesses, the judges shall condemn"him to death,''that is, the fact being clearly proved by witnesses, the judges shall pass the sentence of death upon him, and execute it; for this is but the law of retaliation, a just and equitable one, blood for blood, or life for life; though it seems to be the first law of this kind that empowered the civil magistrate to take away life; God, as it is thought, reserving the right and power to himself before, and which, for some reasons, he thought fit not to make use of in the case of Cain, whom he only banished, and suffered not others to take away his life, but now enacts a law, requiring judges to punish murder with death: and which, according to this law, ought never to go unpunished, or have a lesser punishment inflicted for it: the reason follows:
for in the image of God made he man; which, though sadly defaced and obliterated by sin, yet there are such remains of it, as render him more especially the object of the care and providence of God, and give him a superiority to other creatures; and particularly this image, among others, consists in immortality, which the taking away of his life may seem to contradict; however, it is what no man has a right to do.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Gen 9:1-29
TSK Synopsis: Gen 9:1-29 - --1 God blesses Noah and his sons, and grants them flesh for food.4 Blood and murder are forbidden.8 God's covenant, of which the rainbow was constitute...
MHCC -> Gen 9:4-7
MHCC: Gen 9:4-7 - --The main reason of forbidding the eating of blood, doubtless was because the shedding of blood in sacrifices was to keep the worshippers in mind of th...
Matthew Henry -> Gen 9:1-7
Matthew Henry: Gen 9:1-7 - -- We read, in the close of the foregoing chapter, the very kind things which God said in his heart, concerning the remnant of mankind which was now le...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Gen 9:3-7
Keil-Delitzsch: Gen 9:3-7 - --
" Every moving thing that liveth shall be food for you; even as the green of the herb have I given you all ( את־כּל = חכּל )."These words d...
Constable: Gen 1:1--11:27 - --I. PRIMEVAL EVENTS 1:1--11:26
Chapters 1-11 provide an introduction to the Book of Genesis, the Pentateuch, and ...

Constable: Gen 6:9--10:1 - --D. What became of Noah 6:9-9:29
The Lord destroyed the corrupt, violent human race and deluged its world...

Constable: Gen 9:1-17 - --2. The Noahic Covenant 9:1-17
Following the Flood God established human life anew on the earth showing His high regard for it. He promised to bless hu...
Guzik -> Gen 9:1-29
Guzik: Gen 9:1-29 - --Genesis 9 - God's Covenant with Noah and Creation
A. God's covenant and instructions to Noah.
1. (1-4) Instructions for living in a new world.
So ...

expand allCommentary -- Other
Bible Query: Gen 9:6 Q: Does Gen 9:6 forbid executing criminals today?
A: Not at all. Genesis 9:6 both prohibits only murder, and commanded execution punishment for murd...
