
Text -- Isaiah 1:29 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: Isa 1:29 - -- Which, after the manner of the Heathen, you have consecrated to idolatrous uses.
Which, after the manner of the Heathen, you have consecrated to idolatrous uses.

In which, as well is in the groves, they committed idolatry.

JFB: Isa 1:29 - -- Others translate the "terebinth" or "turpentine tree." Groves were dedicated to idols. Our Druids took their name from the Greek for "oaks." A sacred ...
Others translate the "terebinth" or "turpentine tree." Groves were dedicated to idols. Our Druids took their name from the Greek for "oaks." A sacred tree is often found in Assyrian sculpture; symbol of the starry hosts, Saba.

Planted enclosures for idolatry; the counterpart of the garden of Eden.
Clarke -> Isa 1:29
Clarke: Isa 1:29 - -- For they shall be ashamed of the oaks "For ye shall be ashamed of the ilexes"- Sacred groves were a very ancient and favorite appendage of idolatry....
For they shall be ashamed of the oaks "For ye shall be ashamed of the ilexes"- Sacred groves were a very ancient and favorite appendage of idolatry. They were furnished with the temple of the god to whom they were dedicated, with altars, images, and every thing necessary for performing the various rites of worship offered there; and were the scenes of many impure ceremonies, and of much abominable superstition. They made a principal part of the religion of the old inhabitants of Canaan; and the Israelites were commanded to destroy their groves, among other monuments of their false worship. The Israelites themselves became afterwards very much addicted to this species of idolatry
"When I had brought them into the land
Which I swore that I would give unto them
Then they saw every high hill and every thick tree
And there they slew their victims
And there they presented the provocation of their offerings
And there they placed their sweet savor
And there they poured out their libations.
"On the tops of the mountains they sacrifice
And on the hills they burn incense
Under the oak and the poplar
And the ilex, because her shade is pleasant.
Of what particular kinds the trees here mentioned are, cannot be determined with certainty. In regard to
By the ilex the learned prelate means the holly, which, though it generally appears as a sort of shrub, grows, in a good soil, where it is unmolested, to a considerable height. I have one in my own garden, rising three stems from the root, and between twenty and thirty feet in height. It is an evergreen
For they shall be ashamed "For ye shall be ashamed"-
Calvin -> Isa 1:29
Calvin: Isa 1:29 - -- 29.For (or, that is) they shall be ashamed In the Hebrew the particle כי ( ki) is employed, which properly denotes a cause, but frequently also...
29.For (or, that is) they shall be ashamed In the Hebrew the particle
The word
Which you have desired By the word desired he reproves the mad and burning eagerness with which wicked men follow their superstitions. They ought to have been earnestly devoted with their whole heart to the service of one Gods but they rush with blind violence to false worship, as if they were driven by brutish lust. In almost every human mind there naturally exists this disease, that they have forsaken the true God, and run mad in following idols; and hence Scripture frequently compares this madness to the loves of harlots, who shake off shame, as well as reason.
For the gardens that ye have chosen That the Prophet describes not only their excessive zeal, but their presumption, in corrupting the worship of God, is evident from this second clause, in which he says that they chose gardens, for this term is contrasted with the injunction of the law. Whatever may be the plausible appearances under which unbelievers endeavor to cloak their superstitions, still this saying remains true, that obedience is better than all sacrifices. (1Sa 15:22.) Accordingly, under the term willworship (
This single consideration is sufficient to condemn the inventions of men, that they have it not in their power to choose the manner of worshipping God, because to him alone belongs the right to command. God had at that time enjoined that sacrifices should not be offered to him anywhere else than at Jerusalem (Deu 12:13); the Jews thought that they pleased him in other places, and that false imagination deceived also the heathen nations. Would that it had gone no farther! But we see how the papists are involved in the same error, and, in short, experience shows that the disease has prevailed extensively in every age.
If it be objected that there was not so much importance in the place, that God ought to have regarded with such strong abhorrence the worship which was everywhere offered to him, — first, we ought to consider the reason why God chose that at that time there should be only one altar, which was, that it might be a bond of holy unity to an uncivilized nation, and that by means of it their religion might continue unchanged. Besides, granting that this spiritual reason were but of temporary force, we must hold by the principle that commandments were given in the smallest matters, that the Jews might be better trained to obedience; for since superstition conceals itself under the pretense of devotion, it is hardly possible but that men will flatter themselves with their own inventions. But since obedience is the mother of true religion, it follows that when men exercise their own fancy, it becomes the source of all superstitions.
It must also be added, that as Isaiah formerly complained of those crimes which were contrary to brotherly love and to the second table of the law, so he now complains of their having transgressed the first table. For since the whole perfection of righteousness consists in keeping the law, when the Prophets wish to reprove men for their sins, they speak sometimes of the first, and sometimes of the second, table of the law. But we ought always to observe the figurative mode of expression, when under one class they include the whole.
TSK -> Isa 1:29
TSK: Isa 1:29 - -- ashamed : Isa 30:22, Isa 31:7, Isa 45:16; Eze 16:63, Eze 36:31; Hos 14:3, Hos 14:8; Rom 6:21
the oaks : Isa 57:5 *marg. Eze 6:13; Hos 4:13
the gardens...

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Isa 1:29
Barnes: Isa 1:29 - -- For they shall be ashamed - That is, when they see the punishment that their idolatry has brought upon them, they shall be ashamed of the folly...
For they shall be ashamed - That is, when they see the punishment that their idolatry has brought upon them, they shall be ashamed of the folly and degradation of their worship. Moreover, the gods in which they trusted shall yield them no protection, and shall leave them to the disgrace and confusion of being forsaken and abandoned.
Of the oaks - Groves, in ancient times, were the favorite places of idolatrous worship. In the city of Rome, there were thirty-two groves consecrated to the gods. Those were commonly selected which were on hills, or high places; and they were usually furnished with temples, altars, and all the implements of idolatrous worship. Different kinds of groves were selected for this purpose, by different people. The Druids of the ancient Celtic nations in Gaul, Britain, and Germany, offered their worship in groves of oak - hence the name Druid, derived from
Their calamities were coming upon them mainly for this idolatry. It is not certainly known what species of tree is intended by the word translated oaks. The Septuagint has rendered it by the word "idols"-
The flowers are small, and are followed by small oval berries, hanging in clusters from two to five inches long, resembling much the clusters of the vine when the grapes are just set. From incisions in the trunk there is said to flow a sort of transparent balsam, constituting a very pure and fine species of turpentine, with an agreeable odor like citron or jessamine, and a mild taste, and hardening gradually into a transparent gum. The tree is found also in Asia Minor, Greece, Italy, the south of France, and in the north of Africa, and is described as not usually rising to the height of more than twenty feet.’ Robinson’ s Bib. Researches, iii. 15, 16. It produces the nuts called the pistachio nuts. They have a pleasant, unctuous taste, resembling that of almonds, and they yield in abundance a sweet and pleasant oil. The best Venice turpentine, which, when it can be obtained pure, is superior to all the rest of its kind, is the produce of this tree. The picture in the book will give you an idea of the appearance of the terebinth. The Hebrew word
Which ye have desired - The Jews, until the captivity at Babylon, as all their history shows, easily relapsed into idolatry. The meaning of the prophet is, that the punishment at Babylon would be so long and so severe as to make them ashamed of this, and turn them from it.
Shall be confounded - Another word meaning to be ashamed.
For the gardens - The places planted with trees, etc., in which idolatrous worship was practiced. ‘ In the language of the Hebrews, every place where plants and trees were cultivated with greater care than in the open field, was called a garden. The idea of such an enclosure was certainly borrowed from the garden of Eden, which the bountiful Creator planted for the reception of his favorite creature. The garden of Hesperides, in Eastern fables, was protected by an enormous serpent; and the gardens of Adonis, among the Greeks, may be traced to the same origin, for the terms horti Adenides, the gardens of Adonis, were used by the ancients to signify gardens of pleasure, which corresponds with the name of Paradise, or the garden of Eden, as horti Adonis answers to the garden of the Lord. Besides, the gardens of primitive nations were commonly, if not in every instance, devoted to religious purposes. In these shady retreats were celebrated, for a long succession of ages, the rites of pagan superstition.’ - Paxton. These groves or gardens were furnished with the temple of the god that was worshipped, and with altars, and with everything necessary for this species of worship. They were usually, also, made as shady and dark as possible, to inspire the worshippers with religious awe and reverence on their entrance; compare the note at Isa 66:17.
Poole -> Isa 1:29
Poole: Isa 1:29 - -- They shall be ashamed not with an ingenuous and penitential shame for the sin, but with an involuntary and penal shame for the disappointment of thei...
They shall be ashamed not with an ingenuous and penitential shame for the sin, but with an involuntary and penal shame for the disappointment of their hopes which they had in their idols.
Which ye have desired which, after the manner of the heathen, you have consecrated to idolatrous uses, that under them you might worship your idols, as they did, Eze 6:13 Hos 4:13 : see also Isa 57:5 Jer 2:20 3:6 .
The gardens in which, as well as in the groves, they committed idolatry; of which we read Isa 65:3 66:17 .
That ye have chosen to wit, for the place of your worship, which is opposed to the place which God had chosen and appointed for his worship.
Haydock -> Isa 1:29
Haydock: Isa 1:29 - -- Idols. Protestants, "oaks, which ye have desired, and ye shall be confounded for the gardens," &c. (Haydock) ---
the groves were sacred to Venus, ...
Idols. Protestants, "oaks, which ye have desired, and ye shall be confounded for the gardens," &c. (Haydock) ---
the groves were sacred to Venus, and the gardens to Adonis, and were scenes of the greatest immorality and profanation, chap. lxv. 3.
Gill -> Isa 1:29
Gill: Isa 1:29 - -- For they shall be ashamed of the oaks which ye have desired,.... Though there is a change of persons in the words, the same are intended; and design s...
For they shall be ashamed of the oaks which ye have desired,.... Though there is a change of persons in the words, the same are intended; and design such, who being convinced of the idolatries of the church of Rome they have been fond of, and delighted in, will be ashamed of them, and relinquish them, and come out of Babylon a little before the destruction of it; for under oaks, and such like green trees, idolatry used to be committed, to which the allusion is; see Jer 2:20 and so the Targum interprets it of "trees of idols"; that is, under which idolatry was practised:
and ye shall be confounded for the gardens ye have chosen; where also idolatrous practices were used, see Isa 65:3 and so the Targum paraphrases it,
"and ye shall be ashamed of the gardens of idols, from whom ye have sought help.''
The sense is the same as before; unless both clauses should rather be understood of the destruction of sinners, before spoken of, who at that time will be filled with shame and confusion, they in vain praying to their idols for help; which sense the following words incline to.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Isa 1:1-31
TSK Synopsis: Isa 1:1-31 - --1 Isaiah complains of Judah for her rebellion.5 He laments her judgments.10 He upbraids their whole service.16 He exhorts to repentance, with promises...
MHCC -> Isa 1:21-31
MHCC: Isa 1:21-31 - --Neither holy cities nor royal ones are faithful to their trust, if religion does not dwell in them. Dross may shine like silver, and the wine that is ...
Matthew Henry -> Isa 1:21-31
Matthew Henry: Isa 1:21-31 - -- Here, I. The woeful degeneracy of Judah and Jerusalem is sadly lamented. See, 1. What the royal city had been, a faithful city, faithful to God and ...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Isa 1:29
Keil-Delitzsch: Isa 1:29 - --
Isa 1:29 declares how God's judgment of destruction would fall upon all of these. The v. is introduced with an explanatory "for"( Chi ): "For they...
Constable: Isa 1:1--5:30 - --I. introduction chs. 1--5
The relationship of chapters 1-5 to Isaiah's call in chapter 6 is problematic. Do the ...

Constable: Isa 1:1-31 - --A. Israel's condition and God's solution ch. 1
As chapters 1-5 introduce the whole book, so chapter 1 in...

Constable: Isa 1:21-31 - --4. Israel's response 1:21-31
While God's invitation to repent was genuine (vv. 16-20), the natio...
