
Text -- Isaiah 17:5 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: Isa 17:5 - -- Taking care, as far as may be, that all may be gathered in, and nothing left. So shall the whole body of the ten tribes be carried away captive, some ...
Taking care, as far as may be, that all may be gathered in, and nothing left. So shall the whole body of the ten tribes be carried away captive, some few gleanings only being left.
JFB: Isa 17:5 - -- The inhabitants and wealth of Israel shall be swept away, and but few left behind just as the husbandman gathers the corn and the fruit, and leaves on...
The inhabitants and wealth of Israel shall be swept away, and but few left behind just as the husbandman gathers the corn and the fruit, and leaves only a few gleaning ears and grapes (2Ki 18:9-11).

JFB: Isa 17:5 - -- He collects the standing grain with one arm, so that he can cut it with the sickle in the other hand.
He collects the standing grain with one arm, so that he can cut it with the sickle in the other hand.

JFB: Isa 17:5 - -- A fertile plain at the southwest of Jerusalem toward Beth-lehem and the country of the Philistines (2Sa 5:18-22).
A fertile plain at the southwest of Jerusalem toward Beth-lehem and the country of the Philistines (2Sa 5:18-22).
Clarke -> Isa 17:5
Clarke: Isa 17:5 - -- As when the harvestman gathereth "As when one gathereth"- That is, the king of Assyria shall sweep away the whole body of the people, as the reaper ...
As when the harvestman gathereth "As when one gathereth"- That is, the king of Assyria shall sweep away the whole body of the people, as the reaper strippeth off the whole crop of corn; and the remnant shall be no more in proportion than the scattered ears left to the gleaner. The valley of Rephaim near Jerusalem was celebrated for its plentiful harvest; it is here used poetically for any fruitful country. One MS., and one ancient edition, has
Calvin -> Isa 17:5
Calvin: Isa 17:5 - -- 5.And it shall be as when the harvest-man gathereth the corn He shews by a comparison how great will be the desolation. “As the reapers,” he says...
5.And it shall be as when the harvest-man gathereth the corn He shews by a comparison how great will be the desolation. “As the reapers,” he says, “gather the corn in armfuls, so this multitude, though large and extended, will be mowed down by the enemies.” Now that he may not leave a remainder, he adds that at the conclusion of the harvest the ears will be gleaned, as if he had said, that when the multitude shall have been destroyed and the country laid bare like a field which has been reaped, even the shaken and scattered ears will not be left. Besides, he employs the metaphor of a harvest because the people, trusting to their great number, dreaded nothing; but as the reapers are not terrified by the large quantity of the corn, so he declares that their vast number will not prevent God from utterly destroying them. This may also refer to the Assyrians, but the meaning will be the same, for they were God’s servants in executing this vengeance.
We need not spend much time in explaining the word gather, for it means nothing else than that the slaughter will resemble a harvest, the conclusion of which has been followed by the gleaning of the ears. When the ten tribes had been carried away, the Assyrians, having learned that they were meditating a revolution, destroyed them also (2Kg 17:4). He especially mentions the valley of Rephaim, because its fertility was well known to the Israelites.
TSK -> Isa 17:5
TSK: Isa 17:5 - -- as when : Jer 9:22, Jer 51:33; Hos 6:11; Joe 3:13; Mat 13:30,Mat 13:39-42; Rev 14:15-20
the valley : Jos 15:8, Jos 18:16, the valley of the giants, 2S...

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Isa 17:5
Barnes: Isa 17:5 - -- And it shall be ... - This is the other figure by which the prophet sets forth the calamities that were coming upon Ephraim - an image designed...
And it shall be ... - This is the other figure by which the prophet sets forth the calamities that were coming upon Ephraim - an image designed to denote the fact that the inhabitants and wealth of the land would be collected and removed, as the farmer gathers his harvest, and leaves only that which is inaccessible in the upper boughs of the tree, or the gleanings in the field.
As when the harvest-man gathereth the corn - The wheat, the barley, etc.; for so the word "corn"- now applied by us almost exclusively to maizes means in the Scriptures. The sense in this passage is plain. As the farmer cuts down and collects his grain and removes it from the harvest field, so the enemies of Ephraim would come and remove the people and their wealth to a distant land. This received a complete fulfillment when the ten tribes were removed by the Assyrians to a distant land. This was done by Tiglath-pileser 2Ki 15:29, and by Shalmaneser 2Ki 17:6.
And reapeth the ears with his arm - As he collects the standing grain with one arm so that he can cut it with the sickle in the other hand. The word rendered ‘ reapeth’ (
In the valley of Rephaim - The valley of Rephaim is mentioned in 2Sa 5:18, 2Sa 5:22; 2Sa 23:13; 1Ch 11:15; 1Ch 14:9. The name means ‘ the Giants;’ but why it was given to it is now unknown. In passing from Bethlehem to Jerusalem, it lies on the left, and descends gradually to the southwest, until it contracts in that direction into a deeper and narrower valley, called wady el-Werd, which unites further on with wady Ahmed, and finds its way to the Mediterranean. The plain extends nearly to Jerusalem, and is terminated by a slight rocky ridge forming the brow of the valley of Hinnom (see Josephus, "Ant."vii. 4. 1; viii. 12. 4; also Robinson’ s "Bib. Researches,"vol. i. pp. 323, 324). It seem to have been distinguished for its fertility, and is used here to denote a fertile region in general.
Poole -> Isa 17:5
Poole: Isa 17:5 - -- Reapeth the ears with his arm taking care, as far as may be, that all may be gathered in, and nothing left. So shall the whole body of the ten tribes...
Reapeth the ears with his arm taking care, as far as may be, that all may be gathered in, and nothing left. So shall the whole body of the ten tribes be carried away captive, some few gleanings only being left of them, as it is in the harvest.
The valley of Rephaim a very fruitful place near Jerusalem, Jos 15:8 18:16 .
Haydock -> Isa 17:5
Haydock: Isa 17:5 - -- Raphaim. Near Jerusalem, 3 Kings xxiii. 13. Septuagint, "of stones." (Calmet) ---
It will be equally difficult to find any men left in the kingdo...
Raphaim. Near Jerusalem, 3 Kings xxiii. 13. Septuagint, "of stones." (Calmet) ---
It will be equally difficult to find any men left in the kingdom of Israel. (Haydock)
Gill -> Isa 17:5
Gill: Isa 17:5 - -- And it shall be as when the harvestman gathereth the corn,.... The "standing" corn, as in the Hebrew text: "and reapeth the ears with his arm"; or "hi...
And it shall be as when the harvestman gathereth the corn,.... The "standing" corn, as in the Hebrew text: "and reapeth the ears with his arm"; or "his arm reaps the ears" o; that is, with one hand he gathers the standing corn into his fist, and then reaps it with his other arm; and just so it should be with the people of Israel: they were like a field of standing corn, for number, beauty, and glory; the Assyrian was like a harvestman, who laid hold upon them, and cut them down, as thick and as numerous as they were, just as a harvestman cuts down the corn, and with as much ease and quick dispatch; they being no more able to stand before him than a field of corn before the reaper! this was done both by Tilgathpilneser, 2Ki 15:29 and by Shalmaneser, 2Ki 17:6 kings of Assyria:
and it shall be as he that gathereth ears in the valley of Rephaim; the Targum renders it,
"the valley of giants.''
and so it is translated, Jos 15:8 mention is made of it in 2Sa 5:18 it was a valley not far from Jerusalem, as Josephus p says; who also calls it the valley of the giants: it is thought to have been a very fruitful place, where the ears of corn were very large and heavy, and so great care was taken in gathering and gleaning that none be lost: wherefore, as the former simile signifies the carrying off the people of Israel in great numbers by the above kings, this may signify, as some have thought, either the picking up of those that fled without, or the gleaning of them in after times by Esarhaddon, Ezr 4:2.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Isa 17:1-14
TSK Synopsis: Isa 17:1-14 - --1 Syria and Israel are threatened.6 A remnant shall forsake idolatry.9 The rest shall be plagued for their impiety.12 The woe of Israel's enemies.
MHCC -> Isa 17:1-11
MHCC: Isa 17:1-11 - --Sin desolates cities. It is strange that great conquerors should take pride in being enemies to mankind; but it is better that flocks should lie down ...
Matthew Henry -> Isa 17:1-5
Matthew Henry: Isa 17:1-5 - -- We have here the burden of Damascus; the Chaldee paraphrase reads it, The burden of the cup of the curse to drink to Damascus in; and, the ten tri...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Isa 17:4-8
Keil-Delitzsch: Isa 17:4-8 - --
Second turn: "And it comes to pass in that day, the glory of Jacob wastes away, and the fat of his flesh grows thin. And it will be as when a reape...
Constable: Isa 7:1--39:8 - --III. Israel's crisis of faith chs. 7--39
This long section of the book deals with Israel's major decision in Isa...

Constable: Isa 13:1--35:10 - --B. God's sovereignty over the nations chs. 13-35
This major section of the book emphasizes the folly of ...

Constable: Isa 13:1--23:18 - --1. Divine judgments on the nations chs. 13-23
The recurrence of the Hebrew word massa', translat...

Constable: Isa 13:1--20:6 - --The first series of five oracles chs. 13-20
The first series shows that God has placed I...
