
Text -- Isaiah 57:16-21 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
I will not proceed to the utmost severity with sinful men.

Wesley: Isa 57:17 - -- Of which sin the Jews were eminently guilty. But this comprehends all those sins for which God contended with them.
Of which sin the Jews were eminently guilty. But this comprehends all those sins for which God contended with them.

Yet he was not reformed, but trespassed more and more.

Wesley: Isa 57:18 - -- To those who are humbled under God's hand, that mourn in Zion for their own and others sins.
To those who are humbled under God's hand, that mourn in Zion for their own and others sins.

Wesley: Isa 57:19 - -- That peace which is not wrought by mens hands, but only by God's lips or word. The doubling of the word signifies the certainty and abundance this pea...
That peace which is not wrought by mens hands, but only by God's lips or word. The doubling of the word signifies the certainty and abundance this peace.

Wesley: Isa 57:19 - -- To the Gentiles who are far from God, as well as to the Jews, who are called a people near unto God, Psa 148:14.
To the Gentiles who are far from God, as well as to the Jews, who are called a people near unto God, Psa 148:14.

Wesley: Isa 57:20 - -- Their minds are restless, being perpetually hurried with their own lusts and passions, and with guilt, and the dread of the divine vengeance.
Their minds are restless, being perpetually hurried with their own lusts and passions, and with guilt, and the dread of the divine vengeance.

Wesley: Isa 57:21 - -- Though they may have a great share of prosperity, yet they have no share in this inward, and spiritual, and everlasting peace.
Though they may have a great share of prosperity, yet they have no share in this inward, and spiritual, and everlasting peace.
JFB: Isa 57:16 - -- Referring to the promise in Isa 57:14-15, of restoring Israel when "contrite" (Gen 6:3; Gen 8:21; Psa 78:38-39; Psa 85:5; Psa 103:9, Psa 103:13-14; Mi...
Referring to the promise in Isa 57:14-15, of restoring Israel when "contrite" (Gen 6:3; Gen 8:21; Psa 78:38-39; Psa 85:5; Psa 103:9, Psa 103:13-14; Mic 7:18). God "will not contend for ever" with His people, for their human spirit would thereby be utterly crushed, whereas God's object is to chasten, not to destroy them (Lam 3:33-34; Mic 7:8-9). With the ungodly He is "angry every day" (Psa 7:11; Rev 14:11).

JFB: Isa 57:16 - -- That is, the human spirit which went forth from Me (Num 16:22), answering to "which I have made" in the parallel clause.
That is, the human spirit which went forth from Me (Num 16:22), answering to "which I have made" in the parallel clause.

JFB: Isa 57:17 - -- Akin to idolatry; and, like it, having drawn off Israel's heart from God (Isa 2:7; Isa 56:11; Isa 58:3; Jer 6:13; Col 3:5).


JFB: Isa 57:18 - -- Rather, "I have seen his ways (in sin), yet will I heal him," that is, restore Israel spiritually and temporally (Jer 33:6; Jer 3:22; Hos 14:4-5) [HOR...
Rather, "I have seen his ways (in sin), yet will I heal him," that is, restore Israel spiritually and temporally (Jer 33:6; Jer 3:22; Hos 14:4-5) [HORSLEY].

JFB: Isa 57:18 - -- However, the phrase, "his mourners," favors English Version; "his ways" will thus be his ways of repentance; and God's pardon on "seeing" them answers...
However, the phrase, "his mourners," favors English Version; "his ways" will thus be his ways of repentance; and God's pardon on "seeing" them answers to the like promise (Isa 61:2-3; Jer 31:18, Jer 31:20).

JFB: Isa 57:19 - -- That is, thanksgivings which flow from the lips. I make men to return thanks to Me (Hos 14:2; Heb 13:15).

JFB: Isa 57:19 - -- "perfect peace" (see Isa 26:3, Margin; Joh 14:27). Primarily, the cessation of the trouble s now afflicting the Jews, as formerly, under the Babylonia...
"perfect peace" (see Isa 26:3, Margin; Joh 14:27). Primarily, the cessation of the trouble s now afflicting the Jews, as formerly, under the Babylonian exile. More generally, the peace which the Gospel proclaims both to Israel "that is near," and to the Gentiles who are "far off" (Act 2:39; Eph 2:17).

JFB: Isa 57:20 - -- Rather, "for it can have no rest" (Job 15:20, &c.; Pro 4:16-17). English Version represents the sea as occasionally agitated; but the Hebrew expresses...
Rather, "for it can have no rest" (Job 15:20, &c.; Pro 4:16-17). English Version represents the sea as occasionally agitated; but the Hebrew expresses that it can never be at rest.

JFB: Isa 57:21 - -- The prophet, having God as his God, speaks in the person of Israel, prophetically regarded as having now appropriated God and His "peace" (Isa 11:1-3)...
The prophet, having God as his God, speaks in the person of Israel, prophetically regarded as having now appropriated God and His "peace" (Isa 11:1-3), warning the impenitent that, while they continue so, they can have no peace.
Clarke: Isa 57:16 - -- For I will not contend for ever - The learned have taken a great deal of pains to little purpose on the latter part of this verses which they suppos...
For I will not contend for ever - The learned have taken a great deal of pains to little purpose on the latter part of this verses which they suppose to be very obscure. After all their labors upon it, I think the best and easiest explication of it is given in the two following elegant passages of the Psalms, which I presume are exactly parallel to it, and very clearly express the same sentiment
"But he in his tender mercy will forgive their si
And will not destroy them
Yea, oftentimes will he turn away his wrath
And will not rouse up his indignation
For he remembereth that they are but flesh
A breath that passeth, and returneth not.
"He will not always conten
Neither will he for ever hold his wrath
As a father yearneth towards his children
So is Jehovah tenderly compassionate towards the
that fear him For he knoweth our frame
He remembereth that we are but dust.
Psa 103:9, Psa 103:13, Psa 103:14
In the former of these two passages the second line seems to be defective both in measure and sense. I suppose the word

For the spirit -

Clarke: Isa 57:16 - -- And the souls - נשמות neshamoth , the immortal spirits. The Targum understands this of the resurrection. I will restore the souls of the dead,...
And the souls -

Clarke: Isa 57:17 - -- For the iniquity of his covetousness was I wroth "Because of his iniquity for a short time was I wroth"- For בצעו bitso , I read בצע betsa ...
For the iniquity of his covetousness was I wroth "Because of his iniquity for a short time was I wroth"- For

Clarke: Isa 57:18 - -- I have seen his ways - Probably these verses refer to the restoration of the Jews from captivity.
I have seen his ways - Probably these verses refer to the restoration of the Jews from captivity.

Clarke: Isa 57:19 - -- I create the fruit of the lips - "The sacrifice of praise,"saith St. Paul, Heb 13:15, "is the fruit of the lips."God creates this fruit of the lips,...
I create the fruit of the lips - "The sacrifice of praise,"saith St. Paul, Heb 13:15, "is the fruit of the lips."God creates this fruit of the lips, by giving new subject and cause of thanksgiving by his mercies conferred on those among his people, who acknowledge and bewail their transgressions, and return to him. The great subject of thanksgiving is peace, reconciliation and pardon, offered to them that are nigh, and to them that are afar off, not only to the Jew, but also to the Gentile, as St. Paul more than once applies those terms, Eph 2:13, Eph 2:17. See also Act 2:39
Peace to him that is far off "That is, to the penitent; and to him that is near, i.e., the righteous."- Kimchi.

Clarke: Isa 57:21 - -- There is no peace, saith my God - For אלהי Elohai , twenty-two MSS. (five ancient) of Kennicott’ s, thirty of De Rossi’ s, and one an...
There is no peace, saith my God - For
Calvin: Isa 57:16 - -- 16.Because not for ever will I strive He continues the same doctrine; for it was difficult to persuade them of this, seeing that during that painful ...
16.Because not for ever will I strive He continues the same doctrine; for it was difficult to persuade them of this, seeing that during that painful captivity they perceived that God was their enemy, and could scarcely obtain any taste of the grace of God, by which their hearts might be encouraged or relieved. The Prophet therefore meets this doubt, and shows that the punishments which they shall endure will be for a short time, and that God will not always be angry with them; that God has indeed very good reason to be angry, but yet that he will relinquish his right, and will make abatement of that which he might have demanded. Thus he connects the wrath of God with that moderation by which he soothes believers, that they may not be discouraged; for, although he draws an argument from the nature of God, yet this promise is especially directed to the Church.
This sentence, therefore, ought always to be remembered by us amidst our sorest afflictions, lest we should think that God is our enemy, or that he will always contend with us. When he says that God is angry, he speaks as if he made an admission, and in accordance with the feelings of our flesh; for we cannot form any other conception of God during our afflictions, than that he is angry with us. It is even profitable to be moved by this feeling, that it may instruct us to repentance; and therefore this form of expression must be viewed as referring exclusively to our capacity, and not to God.
For the spirit shall be clothed, (or, shall be concealed, or, shall fail.) He assigns the reason why he will not always strive. There are various interpretations of this passage. Among others this appears to me to be the more appropriate; that “the spirit is clothed” with the body, as with a garment. Hence also the body is called the tabernacle, and, as it were, the habitation of the spirit. If we adopt this signification of the word, there will be two modes of interpreting this clause. Some explain it as referring to the last resurrection: “the spirit shall be clothed;“ that is, after having gone out of the body, will again return to it as to its habitation. Thus there will be an argument from the greater to the less: “I will raise up dead bodies; why then shall I not restore you, though halfdead, to a better life?” Another meaning, which is also adopted by some, will be simpler and better; for the interpretation of the clause, as referring to the last resurrection, is too remote from the context. “I surrounded the spirit with a body;” as if he had said, “I created men, and therefore will take care of them.”
But for my own part, I think that the Prophet rises higher; for he shows that the Lord deals so gently and kindly with us, because he perceives how weak and feeble we are; as is also pointed out in other passages of Scripture, such as Psa 103:13. “Like as a father pitieth his children, so the Lord pitieth them that fear him. He knoweth our condition, remembering that we are dust. The age of man is like grass, and flourisheth as a flower in the field.” The same thing is said in Psa 78:38. “Yet being inclined to mercy, he was gracious to their iniquity, and did not destroy them, and often recalled his anger, and did not stir up all his indignation, remembering that they were flesh, and a wind that passeth away and returneth not again.” Here the Prophet appears to me to mean the same thing; as if the Lord had said, “I am unwilling to try my strength with breath or wind, which would be as if with grass or a leaf, that shall suddenly vanish away when they have felt the heat of the sun.”

Calvin: Isa 57:17 - -- 17.For the iniquity of his lust Here he complains of the obstinate wickedness of the people, and shows that the Lord had very good reason for punishi...
17.For the iniquity of his lust Here he complains of the obstinate wickedness of the people, and shows that the Lord had very good reason for punishing him in this manner; so that there can be no complaint of his immoderate cruelty.
I struck him, I hid myself He means that his favor was, in some respects, withdrawn and “hidden” for a time. Now, he speaks according to the opinion of men, because, as we have already said, we imagine that God is an enemy, and is angry with us, when he punishes for our transgressions. And it is necessary that we should have those views and conceptions of him, that we may arrive at a true acknowledgment of our sins; for we should never acknowledge them sincerely, or be distressed on account of them, if we did not reflect with ourselves, and know that we had provoked God’s wrath. But, while it is desirable that we should be led to repentance in this manner, we must beware, on the other hand, lest in consequence of imagining that God is hostile and unwilling to be reconciled to us, we should be swallowed up by sorrow. The Prophet therefore restrains these immoderate terrors, and forbids us to judge of God according to our natural disposition; for although he chastises us, he does not cease to cherish a father’s love and affection towards those whom he has once embraced.
But he went away This is the rebelliousness which the Prophet blames and rebukes, that the people were in no degree made better, but persevered in their wickedness. He shows that they were desperate, because the violent remedies which the Lord had tried could not bring them back into the right way.

Calvin: Isa 57:18 - -- 18.I have seen his ways 115 Here the Lord, on the contrary, magnifies his mercy, because he is gracious to that people, though obstinate and rebellio...
18.I have seen his ways 115 Here the Lord, on the contrary, magnifies his mercy, because he is gracious to that people, though obstinate and rebellious, and anticipates them by his grace and mercy. As if he had said, “I labored to bring back this people to repentance by my chastisements, because they violently pursued their lusts; but they were obstinate and untameable; all that I did was of no avail. I might justly, indeed, have ruined him, but I choose rather to heal and preserve. This cannot be done but by distinguished and incomparable mercy. I will therefore cease to punish them.” For these reasons Isaiah gradually magnifies the mercy of God, whom he represents as a physician considering what remedies are best adapted for healing this people. Now, our diseases are incurable, if the Lord do not anticipate us by his mercy.
And will guide him No chastisements, however severe, will drive us to repentance, if the Lord do not quicken us by his Spirit; for the consequence will be, to render us more rebellious and hardhearted. And so we may behold, in the example of this people, an image of mankind; that we may clearly see what is our rebellion and obstinacy against God, and what remedies are necessary for curing our diseases; and that, when we are diseased and almost beyond hope, we are healed, are brought back to the right path, and afterwards continue in it. Hence follows consolation:
Restoring comforts to him If piety be wanting, there can be no faith and no consolation; for they who are not dissatisfied with themselves on account of their vices can look for nothing but the wrath of God, terrors and despair. It is proper, therefore, to observe the context, in which the Prophet, after mentioning “healing,” next mentions “consolation;“ for they whose diseases have been cured obtain, at the same time, that joy of heart and that consolation of which they had been deprived.
When he adds, To his mourners, he appears especially to denote good men, 116 who were few in number; as appears clearly from the complaints of the prophets, who exclaim loudly against the stupidity which had seized the people on every side. Thus he describes those who, amidst the universal guilt, were constrained by sincere grief to mourn, and who not only bewailed the miseries of the people, but deeply groaned under the burden of God’s wrath, while others indulged freely in their pleasures.

Calvin: Isa 57:19 - -- 19.I create the fruit of the lips This is an explanation of the former statement, or of the manner in which the Lord will give consolation to this pe...
19.I create the fruit of the lips This is an explanation of the former statement, or of the manner in which the Lord will give consolation to this people. It is, because he will promise and offer peace to them; for by “the fruit of the lips” he means that he will cause them to hear the glad tidings of peace, by which they shall be filled with joy.
Peace, peace I think that he speaks of the publication of “peace,” the ministry of which was committed to the prophets, and was afterwards enjoined on the apostles and the other ministers of the Gospel; as Paul teaches that they “are ambassadors for Christ, to reconcile men to God.” (2Co 5:20) The repetition of the word “Peace” is intended to express not only certainty, but also uninterrupted continuance. As if he had said, “You now hear nothing but dreadful threatenings. The doctrine of grace and salvation is silent, because you are incapable of it. Such is your obstinacy that I must deal with you by threatenings and terrors. But I will one day restore the doctrine of ‘peace,’ and open the lips of the prophets, that they may proclaim it to you.”
To them that are far off This is added, because the people who had been carried into captivity did not think that these things belonged to them, (because they were “far off,”) but perhaps to those who were at home; for captivity was a sort of casting off. But the Prophet foretells that, though they are at a great distance, yet they shall be partakers of this grace.
And I heal him At length he adds the end or effect, that the Lord determines to heal the people; that is, to make them safe and sound. Hence we infer what I remarked a little before, that all that relates to the full and perfect happiness of the Church is absolutely the gift of God.
Paul appears to have glanced at this passage, when he says that Christ
“brought peace to them that are near, and to them that are far off.” (Eph 2:17)
He speaks of Gentiles and Jews; for the Jews were “near,” because God had entered into a covenant with them; but the Gentiles were “far off,” because they were strangers to that covenant. But the Prophet appears to speak of Jews only.
I reply, Paul adheres to the true meaning of the Prophet, if the whole be but carefully examined; for the Jews are said, in this passage, to be “far off,” because the Lord appeared to have driven them out of his house; and in that respect they resembled the Gentiles. Since, therefore, at the time of that casting off, there was no difference between them and the Gentiles, Paul, by putting both, as it were, in the same rank, justly placed them on a level with the Jews, and thus applied to them what the Prophet had spoken about the Jews; as, in a manner not unlike, he elsewhere applies to the Gentiles a passage in Hosea. (Rom 9:25; Hos 1:10)

Calvin: Isa 57:20 - -- 20.But the wicked Having formerly spoken of the “peace” which good men shall enjoy, he threatens that the wicked, on the contrary, shall have con...
20.But the wicked Having formerly spoken of the “peace” which good men shall enjoy, he threatens that the wicked, on the contrary, shall have continual war and incessant uneasiness and distress of heart; in order that good men may value more highly the excellent blessing of “peace,” and next, that the reprobate may know that their condition shall in no degree be improved in consequence of that peace which is promised to the children of God. But because the reprobate make false pretensions to the name of God, and vainly glory in it, the Prophet shows that there is no reason why they should flatter themselves, or advance any claim, on the ground of this promise, since they can have no share in this peace. Nor will it avail them anything, that God, having compassion upon his people, receives them into favor, and commands peace to be proclaimed to them.
As the troubled sea That metaphor of “the sea” is elegant and very well fitted to describe the uneasiness of the wicked; for of itself “the sea is troubled.” Though it be not beaten by the wind or agitated by frightful tempests, its billows carry on mutual war, and dash against each other with terrible violence. In the same manner wicked men are “troubled” by inward distress, which is deeply seated in their hearts. They are terrified and alarmed by conscience, which is the most agonizing of all torments and the most cruel of all executioners. The furies agitate and pursue the wicked, not with burning torches, (as the fables run,)but with anguish of conscience and the torment of wickedness; for every one is distressed by his own wickedness and his own alarm; 117 every one is agonized and driven to madness by his own guilt; they are terrified by their own evil thoughts and by the pangs of conscience. Most appropriately, therefore, has the Prophet compared them to a stormy and troubled sea. Whoever then wishes to avoid these alarms and this frightful agony of heart, let him not reject that peace which the Lord offers to him. There can be no middle course between them; for, if you do not lay aside sinful desires and accept of this peace, you must unavoidably be miserably distressed and tormented.

Calvin: Isa 57:21 - -- 21.There is no peace to the wicked He confirms the preceding statement, namely, that in vain shall the reprobate endeavor to seek peace, for everywhe...
21.There is no peace to the wicked He confirms the preceding statement, namely, that in vain shall the reprobate endeavor to seek peace, for everywhere they will meet with war. It is God who threatens war, and therefore there can be no hope of “peace.” Wicked men would indeed wish to enjoy peace, and ardently long for it; for there is nothing which they more eagerly desire than to be at ease, and to lull their consciences, that they may freely take their pleasures and indulge in their vices. They drive away all thoughts about the judgment of God, and endeavor to stupify themselves and to repose in indolence, and think that these are the best ways and methods of obtaining peace. But they never shall enjoy it; for, until men have been reconciled to God, conscience will never cease to annoy and carry on war with them.
Saith my God Thus he represents God as the only author of peace, that he may, by this dreadful threatening, tear from the Jews their dearest pleasures; and calls him “his God,” in opposition to the vain boasting of those who falsely boasted of his name; for they cannot acknowledge God, so long as they reject his Prophet and his doctrine. For this reason the Prophet boldly declares that he has received a command from God to declare perpetual war against them.
TSK: Isa 57:16 - -- I will not : Psa 78:38, Psa 78:39, Psa 85:5, Psa 103:9-16; Jer 10:24; Mic 7:18
the souls : Isa 42:5; Num 16:22; Job 34:14, Job 34:15; Ecc 12:7; Jer 38...

TSK: Isa 57:17 - -- the iniquity : Isa 5:8, Isa 5:9, Isa 56:11; Jer 6:13, Jer 8:10, Jer 22:17; Eze 33:31; Mic 2:2, Mic 2:3; Luk 12:15; Eph 5:3-5; Col 3:5; 1Ti 6:9; 2Pe 2:...

TSK: Isa 57:18 - -- have : Isa 1:18, Isa 43:24, Isa 43:25, Isa 48:8-11; Jer 31:18-20; Eze 16:60-63, 36:22-38; Luk 15:20; Rom 5:20
will heal : Jer 3:22, Jer 31:3, Jer 33:6...
have : Isa 1:18, Isa 43:24, Isa 43:25, Isa 48:8-11; Jer 31:18-20; Eze 16:60-63, 36:22-38; Luk 15:20; Rom 5:20
will heal : Jer 3:22, Jer 31:3, Jer 33:6; Hos 14:4-8
will lead : Isa 49:10; Psa 23:2; Rev 7:17
restore : Isa 57:15, Isa 12:1, Isa 61:2, Isa 61:3, Isa 66:10-13; Psa 51:12

TSK: Isa 57:19 - -- I create : ""The sacrifice of praise,""says St. Paul, ""is the fruit of the lips.""God creates this fruit of the lips, by giving new subject and cause...
I create : ""The sacrifice of praise,""says St. Paul, ""is the fruit of the lips.""God creates this fruit of the lips, by giving new subject and cause of thanksgiving by His mercies conferred on His people. The great subject of thanksgiving is peace, reconciliation and pardon offered to them that are nigh, and to them that are afar off; not only to the Jew, but also to the Gentile.
the fruit : Exo 4:11, Exo 4:12; Hos 14:2; Luk 21:15; Eph 6:19; Col 4:3, Col 4:4; Heb 13:15
Peace : Mat 10:13; Mar 16:15; Luk 2:14, Luk 10:5, Luk 10:6; Act 2:39, Act 10:36; 2Co 5:20,2Co 5:21; Eph 2:14-17

TSK: Isa 57:20 - -- like : Isa 3:11; Job 15:20-24, Job 18:5-14, 20:11-29; Psa 73:18-20; Pro 4:16, Pro 4:17; Jud 1:12
like : Isa 3:11; Job 15:20-24, Job 18:5-14, 20:11-29; Psa 73:18-20; Pro 4:16, Pro 4:17; Jud 1:12

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes: Isa 57:16 - -- For I will not contend for ever - I will not be angry with my people forever, nor always refuse to pardon and comfort them (see Psa 103:9). Thi...
For I will not contend for ever - I will not be angry with my people forever, nor always refuse to pardon and comfort them (see Psa 103:9). This is to be regarded as having been primarily addressed to the Jews in their long and painful exile in Babylon. It is, however, couched in general language; and the idea is, that although God would punish his people for their sins, yet his wrath would not be perpetual. If they were his children, he would visit them again in mercy, and would restore to them his favor.
For the spirit should fail before me - Critics have taken a great deal of pains on this part of the verse, which they suppose to be very obscure. The simple meaning seems to be, that if God should continue in anger against people they would be consumed. The human soul could not endure a long-continued controversy with God. Its powers would fail; its strength decay; it must sink to destruction. As God did not intend this in regard to his own people; as he meant that his chastisements should not be for their destruction, but for their salvation; and as he knew how much they could bear, and how much they needed, he would lighten the burden, and restore them to his favor. And the truth taught here is, that if we are his children, we are safe. We may suffer much and long. We may suffer so much that it seems scarcely possible that we should endure more. But he knows how much we can bear; and he will remove the lead, so that we shall not be utterly crushed. A similar sentiment is found in the two following elegant passages of the Psalms, which are evidently parallel to this, and express the same idea:
But he being full of compassion,
Forgave their iniquity, and destroyed them not;
Yea many a time burned he his anger away,
And did not stir up all his wrath.
For he remembered that they were but flesh;
A wind that passeth away and returneth not again.
He will not always chide;
Neither will he keep his anger forever.
Like as a father pitieth his children,
So the Lord pitieth them that fear him.
For he knoweth our frame;
He remembereth that we are dust.
The Hebrew word which is rendered here ‘ should fail’ (

Barnes: Isa 57:17 - -- For the iniquity of his covetousness - The guilt of his avarice; that is, of the Jewish people. The word rendered here ‘ covetousness̵...
For the iniquity of his covetousness - The guilt of his avarice; that is, of the Jewish people. The word rendered here ‘ covetousness’ (
And smote him - That is, I brought heavy judgments on the Jewish people.
I hid me - I withdrew the evidences of my presence and the tokens of my favor, and left them to themselves.
And he went on frowardly - Margin, ‘ Turning away.’ That is, abandoned by me, the Jewish people declined from my service and sunk deeper into sin. The idea here is, that if God withdraws from his people, such is their tendency to depravity, that they will wander away from him, and sink deeper in guilt a truth which is manifest in the experience of individuals, as well as of communities and churches.

Barnes: Isa 57:18 - -- I have seen his ways - That is, either his ways of sin, or of repentance most probably it means the former; and the idea is, that God had seen ...
I have seen his ways - That is, either his ways of sin, or of repentance most probably it means the former; and the idea is, that God had seen how prone his people were to sin, and that he would now interpose and correct their proneness to sin against him, and remove from them the judgments which had been brought upon them in consequence of their crimes.
And will heal him - That is, I will pardon and restore him. Sin, in the Scriptures, is often represented as a disease, and pardon and salvation as a healing of the disease (2Ch 7:14; Psa 41:4; Jer 3:22; Jer 17:4; Jer 32:6; Hos 14:4; see the notes at Isa 6:10).
And to his mourners - To the pious portion that mourned over their sin; or to the nation which would sigh in their long and painful captivity in Babylon.

Barnes: Isa 57:19 - -- I create the fruit of the lips - The Chaldee and Syriac render this, ‘ The words of the lips.’ The ‘ fruit’ of the lips i...
I create the fruit of the lips - The Chaldee and Syriac render this, ‘ The words of the lips.’ The ‘ fruit’ of the lips is that which the lips produce, that is, words; and the reference here is doubtless to offerings of praise and thanksgiving. See Heb 13:15; where the phrase, ‘ fruit of the lips’ (
Peace, peace - The great subject of the thanksgiving would be peace. The peace here referred to probably had a primary reference to the cessation of the calamities which would soon overwhelm the Jewish nation, and their restoration again to their own land. But the whole strain of the passage also shows that the prophet had a more general truth in his view, and that he refers to that peace which would diffuse joy among all who were far off, and those who were near. Paul evidently alludes to this passage in Eph 2:14-17. Thus understood, the more general reference is to the peace. which the Messiah would introduce, and which would lay the foundation for universal rejoicing and praise (compare the notes at Isa 2:4; Isa 9:5).
To him that is far off - Applied by the apostle Paul to the Gentiles, who are represented as having been far off from God, or as aliens or strangers to him Eph 2:17.
And to him that is near - That is, to the Jewish people Eph 2:17, represented as having been comparatively near to God in the enjoyment of religious privileges.

Barnes: Isa 57:20 - -- But the wicked - All who are transgressors of the law and who remain unpardoned. The design of this is to contrast their condition with that of...
But the wicked - All who are transgressors of the law and who remain unpardoned. The design of this is to contrast their condition with that of those who should enjoy peace. The proposition is, therefore, of the most general character. All the wicked are like the troubled sea. Whether prosperous or otherwise; rich or poor; bond or free; old or young; whether in Christian, in civilized, or in barbarous lands; whether living in palaces, in caves, or in tents; whether in the splendor of cities, or in the solitude of deserts; All are like the troubled sea.
Are like the troubled sea - The agitated (
When it cannot rest - Lowth renders this, ‘ For it never can be at rest.’ The Hebrew is stronger than our translation. It means that there is no possibility of its being at rest; it is unable to be still (
Whose waters - They who have stood on the shores of the ocean and seen the waves - especially in a storm - foam, and roll, and dash on the beach, will be able to appreciate the force of this beautiful figure, and cannot but have a vivid image before them of the unsettled and agitated bosoms of the guilty. The figure which is used here to denote the want of peace in the bosom of a wicked man, is likewise beautifully employed by Ovid:
Cumque sit hibernis agitatum fluctibus aequor,
Pectora sunt ipso turbidiora mari .
Trist. i. x. 33
The agitation and commotion of the sinner here referred to, relates to such things as the following:
1. There is no permanent happiness or enjoyment. There is no calmness of soul in the contemplation of the divine perfections, and of the glories of the future world. There is no substantial and permanent peace furnished by wealth, business, pleasure; by the pride, pomp, and flattery of the world. All leave the soul unsatisfied, or dissatisfied; all leave is unprotected against the rebukes of conscience, and the fear of hell.
2. Raging passions. The sinner is under their influence. and they may be compared to the wild and tumultuous waves of the ocean. Thus the bosoms of the wicked are agitated with the conflicting passions of pride, envy, malice, lust, ambition, and revenge. These leave no peace in the soul; they make peace impossible. People may learn in some degree to control them by the influence of philosophy; or a pride of character and respect to their reputation may enable them in some degree to restrain them; but they are like the smothered fires of the volcano, or like the momentary calm of the ocean that a gust of wind may soon lash into foam. To restrain them is not to subdue them, for no man can tell how soon he may be excited by anger, or how soon the smothered fires of lus may burn.
3. Conscience. Nothing more resembles an agitated ocean casting up mire and dirt, than a soul agitated by the recollections of past guilt. A deep dark cloud in a tempest overhangs the deep; the lightnings play and the thunder rolls along the sky, and the waves heave with wild commotion. So it is with the bosom of the sinner. Though there may be a temporary suspension of the rebukes of conscience, yet there is no permanent peace. The soul cannot rest; and in some way or other the recollections of guilt will be excited, and the bosom thrown into turbid and wild agitation.
4. The fear of judgment and of hell. Many a sinner has no rest, day or night, from the fear of future wrath. His troubled mind looks onward, and he sees nothing to anticipate but the wrath of God, and the horrors of an eternal hell. How invaluable then is religion! All these commotions are stilled by the voice of pardoning mercy, as the billows of the deep were hushed by the voice of Jesus. How much do we owe to religion! Had it not been for this, there had been no peace in this world. Every bosom would have been agitated with tumultuous passion; every heart would have quailed with the fear of hell. How diligently should we seek the influence of religion! We all have raging passions to be subdued. We all have consciences that may be troubled with the recollections of past guilt. We are all traveling to the bar of God, and have reason to apprehend the storms of vengeance. We all must soon lie down on beds of death, and in all these scenes there is nothing that can give permanent and solid peace but the religion of the Redeemer. Oh! that stills all the agitation of a troubled soul; lays every billow of tumultuous passion to rest; calms the conflicts of a guilty bosom; reveals God reconciled through a Redeemer to our souls, and removes all the anticipated terrors of a bed of death and of the approach to the judgment bar. Peacefully the Christian can die - not as the troubled sinner, who leaves the world with a bosom agitated like the stormy ocean but as peacefully as the gentle ripple dies away on the beach.
How blest the righteous when they die,
When holy souls retire to rest I
How mildly beams the closing eye,
How gently heaves the expiring breast!
So fades a summer cloud away;
So sinks the gale when storms are o’ er;
So gently shuts the eve of day;
So dies a wave along the shore.
- Barbauld
Poole: Isa 57:16 - -- I will not contend for ever I will not constantly proceed to the utmost severity with sinful men in this life, and therefore I will put an end to the...
I will not contend for ever I will not constantly proceed to the utmost severity with sinful men in this life, and therefore I will put an end to the miseries of the Jews, and turn their captivity.
For the spirit should fail before me, and the souls which I have made for then their spirits would sink and die under my stroke, and I should do nothing else but destroy the works of mine own hands. Therefore I consider their infirmity, and spare them. Compare Psa 78:38,39 103:13,14 .

Poole: Isa 57:17 - -- Covetousness of which sin the Jews were eminently guilty, as is expressly affirmed, Jer 6:13 8:10 . But this is not mentioned exclusively as to other...
Covetousness of which sin the Jews were eminently guilty, as is expressly affirmed, Jer 6:13 8:10 . But this is not mentioned exclusively as to other sins, but synecdochically, so as to comprehend all those sins for which God contended with them.
I hid me I withdrew my favour and help from him, and left him in great calamities.
And he went on frowardly in the way of his heart yet he was not reformed by corrections, but in his distresses trespassed more and more, as was said of Ahaz, and obstinately persisted in those sinful courses which were chosen by and were most pleasing to the lusts of his own corrupt heart.

Poole: Isa 57:18 - -- I have seen his ways I have taken notice of these evil ways in which he seems resolved to walk, and that he is neither bettered by mercies nor judgme...
I have seen his ways I have taken notice of these evil ways in which he seems resolved to walk, and that he is neither bettered by mercies nor judgments.
And will heal him or, yet I will heal him . Although I might justly destroy him, and leave him to perish in his own ways, yet of my mere mercy, and for my own name’ s sake, I will pity him, and turn him from his sins, and bring him out of his troubles. And , or, to wit , the copulative conjunction being put expositively, as it is frequently,
to his mourners to those who are humbled under God’ s hand, that mourn in Zion, Isa 61:2,3 , for their own and others’ sins, Eze 9:4 , and for the calamities of God’ s church and people, Isa 66:10 .

Poole: Isa 57:19 - -- I create I will by my almighty power and in a wonderful manner produce,
the fruit of the lips; Peace: either,
1. Praise or thanksgiving, which is ...
I create I will by my almighty power and in a wonderful manner produce,
the fruit of the lips; Peace: either,
1. Praise or thanksgiving, which is called the fruit of our lips , Hos 14:2 Heb 13:15 , and peace: or rather,
2. That peace which is not wrought by men’ s hands, but only by God’ s lips or word; peace with God, and in a man’ s own conscience, which God hath promised to his people, and which he hath published and offered to all sorts of men by the preaching of the prophets, and especially of the apostles; as may be gathered both from the object of this peace in the following words, and by the exclusion of all wicked men from this peace, Isa 57:20 21 .
Peace: the doubling of the word signifies the certainty and abundance of this peace.
To him that is far off, and to him that is near to the Gentiles, who are far from God and from salvation, Act 2:38,39 Eph 2:12 , &c., as well as to the Jews, who are called a people near unto God , Psa 148:14 .

Poole: Isa 57:20 - -- Their minds are restless, being perpetually hurried and tormented with their own lusts and passions, and with the horror of their guilt, and the dre...
Their minds are restless, being perpetually hurried and tormented with their own lusts and passions, and with the horror of their guilt, and the dread of the Divine vengeance due unto them, and ready to come upon them.

Poole: Isa 57:21 - -- Though they may have as great a share of prosperity as the best of men have, as appears from Psa 37:35 73:3 , &c.; Ecc 8:14 9:2 ; yet they have no s...
Though they may have as great a share of prosperity as the best of men have, as appears from Psa 37:35 73:3 , &c.; Ecc 8:14 9:2 ; yet they have no share in this inward, and spiritual, and everlasting peace.
Haydock: Isa 57:16 - -- End. I will not always threaten or be angry, Genesis vi. 3. (Calmet) ---
Spirit. Holy Ghost. (St. Irenזus v. 12.) (St. Augustine) ---
God sp...
End. I will not always threaten or be angry, Genesis vi. 3. (Calmet) ---
Spirit. Holy Ghost. (St. Irenזus v. 12.) (St. Augustine) ---
God spares the humble penitent, and grants what they desire with as much eagerness as a sailor does a fair wind. (Worthington) ---
He does not regard the indifferent. (Haydock)

Haydock: Isa 57:17 - -- Heart. Dreadful state of the abandoned sinner! (Deuteronomy xxxii.21., and Psalm xii. 2., and xliii. 24.)
Heart. Dreadful state of the abandoned sinner! (Deuteronomy xxxii.21., and Psalm xii. 2., and xliii. 24.)

Haydock: Isa 57:19 - -- Lips. Whatever they could ask, so that they might sing canticles. All should be content. He alludes to the liberation of the captives, which was ...
Lips. Whatever they could ask, so that they might sing canticles. All should be content. He alludes to the liberation of the captives, which was near, and to the redemption of mankind far off. (Calmet)

Haydock: Isa 57:20 - -- Dirt. Literally, "treading," conculcationem. (Haydock) ---
The works of the wicked are fruitless. They have no content. (Calmet) Non enim gaz...
Dirt. Literally, "treading," conculcationem. (Haydock) ---
The works of the wicked are fruitless. They have no content. (Calmet) Non enim gazז neque consularis
Summovet lictor miseros tumultus,
Mentis et curas laqueata circum,
Tecta volantes. ----- (Horace, ii. ode 16.)
--- The obstinate sinner can receive no pardon. (Worthington)
Gill: Isa 57:16 - -- For I will not contend for ever,.... By afflictive providences; with the humble and contrite, the end being in a great measure answered by their humil...
For I will not contend for ever,.... By afflictive providences; with the humble and contrite, the end being in a great measure answered by their humiliation and contrition; when God afflicts his people, it shows that he has a controversy with them, for their good, and his own glory; and when these ends are obtained, he will carry it on no longer:
neither will I be always wroth; as he seems to be in the apprehensions of his people, when he either hides his face from them, or chastises them with a rod of affliction:
for the spirit should fail before me; the spirit of the afflicted, which not being able to bear up any longer under the affliction, would sink and faint, or be "overwhelmed", as the word c signifies:
and the souls which I have made; which are of God's immediate creation, and which are also renewed by his grace, and made new creatures. The proselytes Abraham made are called the souls he made in Haran, Gen 12:5, much more may this be said of the Father of spirits, the author both of the old and new creation. The Lord knowing the weakness of the human frame, therefore restrains his hand, or moderates or removes the affliction; see a like reason in Psa 78:38, the last days of trouble to God's people, which will be the time of the slaying of the witnesses, will be such that if they are not shortened, no flesh can be saved, but for the elect's sake they will be shortened, Mat 24:22.

Gill: Isa 57:17 - -- For the iniquity of his covetousness was I wroth, and smote him, .... Not the greedy watchmen of the church of Rome, Isa 56:10, but teachers and preac...
For the iniquity of his covetousness was I wroth, and smote him, .... Not the greedy watchmen of the church of Rome, Isa 56:10, but teachers and preachers in the reformed churches, who mind their own things, and not the things of Christ; seek after good benefices and livings, temporalities and pluralities, and to be lord bishops; taking the oversight of the flock for filthy lucre sake; which may easily be observed to be the predominant sin of the preachers and professors of the reformed churches; for which God has a controversy with them, and, resenting it, has smote and rebuked them in a providential way; and has threatened them, as he did the church at Sardis, the emblem of the reformed churches, that he will come upon them as a thief, Rev 3:4.
I hid me, and was wroth: showed his displeasure by departing from them; and how much God has withdrawn his presence, and caused his spirit to depart from the churches of the Reformation, is too notorious:
and he went on frowardly in the way of his heart; took no notice of the reproofs and corrections of God; was unconcerned at his absence; not at all affected with his departure, and the withdrawings of his Spirit; these had no effect to cause a reformation, as is now too visibly the case; the same evil is pursued with equal eagerness; this is a way the heart of man is set upon, and they do not care to be turned out of it; and are like froward peevish children under the rod, receive no correction by it.

Gill: Isa 57:18 - -- I have seen his ways, and will heal him,.... Either the ways of such who trust in the Lord, the ways of the humble and contrite, who are brought by re...
I have seen his ways, and will heal him,.... Either the ways of such who trust in the Lord, the ways of the humble and contrite, who are brought by repentance and reformation, by the dealings of God with them; these he sees, knows, and approves of, and heals their former backslidings; for though not all, yet some may be reformed hereby; or rather the ways of the froward, their evil ways, which are their own ways in opposition to God's ways, peculiar to themselves, of their own devising and choosing; these the Lord sees, resents, and corrects for, and yet graciously pardons them, which is meant by healing:
I will lead him also; out of those evil ways of his into the good and right way in which he should go; into the way of truth and paths of righteousness; for it is for want of evangelical light and knowledge that so many err from the truths of the Gospel, and from the simplicity of Gospel worship; but in the latter day the Spirit of truth shall be poured down from on high, and shall lead professors of real religion into all truth, and they shall speak a pure language, and worship the Lord with one consent:
and restore comforts to him, and to his mourners; that mourn over their own sins, and the sins of others; that mourn in Zion, and for Zion; for the corruptions in doctrine and worship crept into the reformed churches; for the want of church discipline and Gospel conversation; for the declensions of professors of religion, and the divisions among them; and for that worldly, earthly, and carnal spirit that prevails; for these, as bad as our times are, there are some that mourn publicly and privately; and to these, and to the church for their sakes, comfort shall be restored, by sending forth Gospel light, truth, and knowledge, which shall cover the earth as the waters the sea; by reviving primitive doctrines and ordinances; by blessing the word to the conversion of a multitude of sinners, and to the edification of saints; by causing brotherly love, peace, and spirituality, to abound among professors, and by blessing all the means of grace to the consolation of their souls; and by making particular applications of the blood, righteousness, and sacrifice of Christ, for pardon, justification, and atonement, the solid foundation of all true comfort.

Gill: Isa 57:19 - -- I create the fruit of the lips,.... Which is praise and thanksgiving, Heb 13:16 that is, give occasion of it, afford matter for it, by restoring comfo...
I create the fruit of the lips,.... Which is praise and thanksgiving, Heb 13:16 that is, give occasion of it, afford matter for it, by restoring comforts to the church and its mourners, as in the preceding verse; and by giving peace, as in all the following words. The Targum renders it,
"the speech of the lips in the mouth of all men;''
as if it respected that blessing of nature, speech, common to all mankind: whereas this is a blessing of grace, peculiar to some that share in the above blessings; and it may be restrained to Gospel ministers, the fruit of whose lips is the Gospel of peace; or the word preaching peace by Christ; the word of reconciliation committed to them; the subject of their ministry, as follows:
peace, peace to him that is far off, and to him that is near, saith the Lord; peace with God, made by Christ, is the fruit of Jehovah the Father's lips, who promised it in covenant, on condition of Christ's shedding his blood to make it; whence the covenant is called the covenant of peace; and spoke of it in prophecy, as what should be obtained by Christ the peacemaker; and peace of conscience flowing from it is the fruit of Christ's lips, who promised to give it to, and leave it with, his disciples; and that they should have it in him, when they had tribulation in the world; and who also by his apostles went and
preached peace to them that were afar off, and to them that were nigh; having first made it by the blood of his cross, Eph 2:17 in which place there seems a manifest reference to this passage, when the Gospel was preached to the Jews that were near; to them in Judea first, from whence it first came; and then to the Gentiles that were afar off, as well as the dispersed Jews in distant countries; and in the latter day, to which this prophecy refers, it will be preached far and near, even all the world over; when the earth will be filled with the knowledge of the Gospel of peace, through the ministry of a set of men raised up by the Lord, created for that purpose, and eminently furnished for such service; the effect of which will be great spiritual peace in the hearts of God's people, and much concord, unity, and love among them, as well as there will be an abundance of external peace and prosperity; and when nations shall learn war no more. This Kimchi and Ben Melech take to be yet future, and what will be after the war of Gog and Magog: "and I will heal them"; of all their soul sicknesses and maladies; of all their divisions and declensions; of their carnality and earthly mindedness, before complained of; and even of all their sins and backslidings; and restore them to perfect health in their souls, and in their church state.

Gill: Isa 57:20 - -- But the wicked are like the troubled sea, when it cannot rest,.... Disturbed by winds, storms, and hurricanes, when its waves rise, rage, and tumble a...
But the wicked are like the troubled sea, when it cannot rest,.... Disturbed by winds, storms, and hurricanes, when its waves rise, rage, and tumble about, and beat against the shore and sand, threatening to pass the bounds fixed for it. In such like agitations will the minds of wicked men be, through the terrors of conscience for their sins; or through the malice and envy in them at the happiness and prosperity of the righteous, now enjoyed, upon the downfall of antichrist; and through the judgments of God upon them, gnawing their tongues for pain, and blaspheming the God of heaven, because of their plagues and pains, Rev 16:9,
whose waters cast up mire and dirt; from the bottom of the sea upon the shore; so the hearts of wicked men, having nothing but the mire and dirt of sin in them, cast out nothing else but the froth and foam of their own shame, blasphemy against God, and malice against his people.

Gill: Isa 57:21 - -- There is no peace, saith my God, to the wicked. They have no share in the peace made by the blood of Christ; they have no true, solid, inward peace of...
There is no peace, saith my God, to the wicked. They have no share in the peace made by the blood of Christ; they have no true, solid, inward peace of conscience; nor will they have any part in the happiness and prosperity of the church and people of God in the latter day, which will but add to their uneasiness; and will have no lot and portion in the eternal peace which saints enjoy in the world to come; and of this there is the strongest assurance, since God, the covenant God of his people, has said it.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes



Geneva Bible: Isa 57:16 For I will not contend for ever, neither will I be always angry: ( s ) for the spirit should fail before me, and the souls [which] I have made.
( s )...

Geneva Bible: Isa 57:17 For the ( t ) iniquity of his covetousness I was angry, and smote him: I hid myself, and was angry, and he went on backsliding in the way of his heart...

Geneva Bible: Isa 57:18 I have seen his ways, and will ( u ) heal him: I will lead him also, and restore comforts to him and to his mourners.
( u ) Though they were obstinat...

Geneva Bible: Isa 57:19 I create the ( x ) fruit of the lips; Peace, peace to [him that is] ( y ) far off, and to [him that is] near, saith the LORD; and I will heal him.
( ...

Geneva Bible: Isa 57:20 But the wicked [are] like the troubled sea, when it ( z ) cannot rest, whose waters cast up mire and dirt.
( z ) Their evil conscience always torment...

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Isa 57:1-21
TSK Synopsis: Isa 57:1-21 - --1 The blessed death of the righteous.3 God reproves the Jews for their whorish idolatry.13 He gives promises of mercy to the penitent.
MHCC -> Isa 57:13-21
MHCC: Isa 57:13-21 - --The idols and their worshippers shall come to nothing; but those who trust in God's grace, shall be brought to the joys of heaven. With the Lord there...
Matthew Henry -> Isa 57:13-16; Isa 57:17-21
Matthew Henry: Isa 57:13-16 - -- Here, I. God shows how insufficient idols and creatures were to relieve and succour those that worshipped them and confided in them (Isa 57:13): " W...

Matthew Henry: Isa 57:17-21 - -- The body of the people of Israel, in this account of God's dealings with them, is spoken of as a particular person (Isa 57:17, Isa 57:18), but divid...
Keil-Delitzsch: Isa 57:16 - --
The compassion, by virtue of which God has His abode and His work of grace in the spirit and heart of the penitent, is founded in that free anticipa...

Keil-Delitzsch: Isa 57:17-18 - --
This general law of His action is most especially the law of His conduct towards Israel, in which such grievous effects of its well-deserved punishm...

Keil-Delitzsch: Isa 57:19-21 - --
But when the redemption comes, it will divide Israel into two halves, with very different prospects. "Creating fruit of the lips; Jehovah saith, 'P...
Constable: Isa 56:1--66:24 - --V. Israel's future transformation chs. 56--66
The last major section of Isaiah deals with the necessity of livin...

Constable: Isa 56:1--59:21 - --A. Recognition of human inability chs. 56-59
It is important that God's people demonstrate righteousness...

Constable: Isa 56:1--57:21 - --1. The need for humility and holiness chs. 56-57
These chapters introduce the main subject of th...
