
Text -- Isaiah 58:4 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: Isa 58:4 - -- Your fasting days, wherein you ought in a special manner to implore the mercy of God, and to shew compassion to men, you employ in injuring or quarrel...
Your fasting days, wherein you ought in a special manner to implore the mercy of God, and to shew compassion to men, you employ in injuring or quarrelling with your brethren, your servants or debtors, or in contriving mischief against them.

In strife and debate. By way of ostentation.
JFB -> Isa 58:4
JFB: Isa 58:4 - -- Rather, "ye do not fast at this time, so as to make your voice to be heard on high," that is, in heaven; your aim in fasting is strife, not to gain th...
Rather, "ye do not fast at this time, so as to make your voice to be heard on high," that is, in heaven; your aim in fasting is strife, not to gain the ear of God [MAURER] (1Ki 21:9, 1Ki 21:12-13). In English Version the sense is, If you wish acceptance with God, ye must not fast as ye now do, to make your voice heard high in strife.
Clarke -> Isa 58:4
Clarke: Isa 58:4 - -- Ye fast for strife and debate - How often is this the case! A whole nation are called to fast to implore God’ s blessing on wars carried on for...
Ye fast for strife and debate - How often is this the case! A whole nation are called to fast to implore God’ s blessing on wars carried on for the purposes of wrath and ambition
To smite with the fist of wickedness: ye shall not fast as ye do this day "To smite with the fist the poor. Wherefore fast ye unto me in this manner"- I follow the version of the Septuagint, which gives a much better sense than the present reading of the Hebrew. Instead of
Calvin -> Isa 58:4
Calvin: Isa 58:4 - -- 4.Behold, for strife and contention ye fast This verse ought to be connected with the end of the preceding verse; for, having in the former clause in...
4.Behold, for strife and contention ye fast This verse ought to be connected with the end of the preceding verse; for, having in the former clause introduced hypocrites as complaining of the violence and harshness of the prophets, he assigns, in the latter clause, the reason why the Lord loathes their fasts and their other performances. It is because they do not proceed from pure affection of heart. What the inclination of their heart is, he shows from its fruits; for he sends them back to the duties of the second table, from which it is easily seen what we are. Purity of heart is manifested by our living innocently, and abstaining from all deceit and injustice. These are the marks of pure affection, in the absence of which the Lord rejects, and even abhors, all external worship. Wherever, on the other hand, cheating, and plunder, and extortion prevail, it is very certain that there is no fear of God.
Thus he reproaches hypocrites with making their fasts to give greater encouragement to sin, and with giving a looser rein to their lusts. We have experience of this every day. Not only do many people fast in order to atone for their cheating and robberies, and to plunder more freely, but even that, during the time of the fast, they may have greater leisure for examining their accounts, perusing documents, and calculating usury, and contriving methods by which they may lay hold on the property of their debtors. On that account they frequently throw this labor on Lent and on the stated times of fasts; and, in like manner, other notable hypocrites hear many Masses every day, that they may more freely, and with less interruption, and under the pretense of religion, contrive their cheating and treachery.
Fast not, as ye do this day At length he rejects their fasts, however highly they may value them; because in this manner the wrath of God is still more provoked. Immediately afterwards he rejects also their prayers.
That ye may make your voice to be heard on high 120 Hence it is evident, (as we have explained fully in our exposition of Isa 1:11,) that God approves of no duties which are not accompanied by sincere uprightness of heart. Certainly no sacrifice is more excellent than calling upon God; and yet we see how all prayers are stained and polluted by impurity of heart. Besides, in consequence of fasting being usually joined to prayer, the Prophet takes this for granted; for it is an appendage to prayer, he therefore forbids such men to offer up solemn prayer accompanied by fasting; because they will gain nothing, except that the Lord will punish them more severely. And hence we infer (as has been already said) that the Lord pays no regard to external works, if they be not preceded by sincere fear of God.
Such fasting as was customary among the Jews is not here blamed in itself, as if it were a superstitious ceremony, but abuse of fasting, and false confidence. This ought to be carefully observed; for we would need to deal very differently with the Papists, if we blamed their fasts. They contain nothing but superstition, being tied to this or that day, or to fixed seasons, as if during the rest of the time they were at liberty to gormandize; while they think that the flesh is unclean, and yet allow every kind of indulgence to it; provided only that they do not once gormandize on a fastday, they think that they have discharged their duty admirably well. Since therefore there is nothing in them that can be approved, we may absolutely condemn them.
But the dispute on this occasion was different. That fasting which the Jews observed was laudable in itself, because God had appointed it; but a false opinion respecting it was censurable. Among the Papists, on the other hand, we must condemn both the false opinion and the institution itself; because it is wicked. The Papists have this in common with the Jews, that they think that they serve God by it, and that it is a meritorious work. Yet fasting is not the worship of God, and is not in itself commanded by him, in the same manner as those works which he enjoins in the Law; but it is an external exercise, which is auxiliary to prayer, or is useful for subduing the flesh, or testifying our humiliation, when, as guilty persons, we implore that the wrath of God may be turned away in adversity. But the reader will find the use and design of fasting more fully discussed in our Institutes. (Book 4, chapter 12:1521)
TSK -> Isa 58:4
TSK: Isa 58:4 - -- ye fast : 1Ki 21:9-13; Pro 21:27; Mat 6:16, Mat 23:14; Luk 20:47; Joh 18:28
and to smite : Act 23:1, Act 23:2; Phi 1:14, Phi 1:15
shall not fast as ye...

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Isa 58:4
Barnes: Isa 58:4 - -- Behold, ye fast for strife and debate - This is a third characteristic of their manner of fasting, and a third reason why God did not regard an...
Behold, ye fast for strife and debate - This is a third characteristic of their manner of fasting, and a third reason why God did not regard and accept it. They were divided into parties and factions, and probably made their fastings an occasion of augmented contention and strife. How often has this been seen! Contending denominations of Christians fast, not laying aside their strifes; contending factions in the church fast in order to strengthen their party with the solemn sanctions of religion. One of the most certain ways for bigots to excite persecution against those who are opposed to them is to ‘ proclaim a fast;’ and when together, their passions are easily inflamed, their flagging zeal excited by inflammatory harangues, and their purpose formed to regard and treat their dissentient brethren as incorrigible heretics and irreconcilable foes. It may be added, also, that it is possible thus to prostitute all the sacred institutions of religion for party and inflammatory purposes. Even the ordinance of the Lord’ s Supper may be thus abused, and violent partisans may come around the sacred memorials of a Saviour’ s body and blood, to bind themselves more closely together in some deed of persecution or violence, and to animate their drooping courage with the belief that what has been in fact commenced with a view to power, is carried on from a regard to the honor of God.
And to smite with the fist of wickedness - Lowth renders this, in accordance with the Septuagint. ‘ To smite with the fist the poor;’ but this translation can be obtained only by a most violent and wholly unauthorized change in the Hebrew text. The idea is plain, that ‘ even when fasting’ they were guilty of strife and personal combats. Their passions were unsubdued, and they gave vent to them in disgraceful personal encounters. This manifests a most extraordinary state of society, and is a most melancholy instance to show how much people may keep up the forms of religion, and even be punctual and exact in them, when the most violent and ungovernable passions are raging in their bosoms, and when they seem to be unconscious of any discrepancy between the religious service and the unsubdued passions of the soul.
Ye shall not fast ... - It is not acceptable to God. It must be offensive in his sight.
To make your voice to be heard on high - That is, in strife and contention. So to contend and strive, says Grotius, that your voice can be heard on the mountain top. Rosenmuller, however, supposes that it means, that their fast was so conducted that they could not expect that their prayers would ascend to heaven and be heard by God. But it seems to me that the former is the correct interpretation. Their fastings were accompanied with the loud and hoarse voice of contention and strife, and on that account could not be acceptable to God.
Poole -> Isa 58:4
Poole: Isa 58:4 - -- Ye fast for strife and debate your fasting days, wherein you ought in a special manner to implore the mercy of God, and to show compassion to men, yo...
Ye fast for strife and debate your fasting days, wherein you ought in a special manner to implore the mercy of God, and to show compassion to men, you employ in a great measure in injuring or quarrelling with your brethren, your servants, or debtors, or in contriving mischief against them, as if the design of your fasting and praying to God were only to obtain a licence to oppress men. Compare Mat 23:14 .
With the fist of wickedness or, with a wicked fist ; a genitive of the adjunct. To deal rigorously and injuriously with your servants or debtors; which servants, it may be, had sold themselves to the year of redemption, Exo 21:2 Lev 25:39,40,50 . You handle them with a hard hand; the word is used for fist , Exo 21:18 ; the LXX. add the humble, poor, or inferior person ; and that not only their debtors, with a summum jus , exact rigour, which seems elsewhere to be expressed by grinding the face; Isa 3:15 , and in that parable by taking by the throat, Mat 18:28 ; but also their servants out of mere will and pleasure, and in contempt of them, treating them opprobriously, as Christ was handled in contempt and scorn, Mat 26:67,68 Joh 18:22 .
Your voice either,
1. In strife and debate, in which men’ s passions show themselves by loud clamours. Or,
2. So as to cause the cry of the oppressed, by reason of your injuries, of what kind soever, to enter into the ears of God; which is a crying sin, whether it proceed from unmercifulness, Exo 22:25-27 , which sometimes increaseth to rage , 2Ch 28:9 ; or from injustice , Isa 5:7 ; or from fraud and deceit , Jam 5:4 . The Scripture doth frequently express whatever sin is against charity in special, as also general complex sins, by crying , Gen 18:20,21Jo 1:2 . Or,
3. By way of ostentation, to note their hypocrisy ; they love to be taken notice of by others, Mt 6 2,5,16 ; or their folly , supposing that they shall be heard for their much speaking, upon which account Baal’ s priests are mocked by Elijah, 1Ki 18:27,28 4 . Voice here relates principally to their prayer ; it is a synecdoche of the kind: so the sense is, This is not the way to have your prayers heard; if you desire that, you must first in another manner, and abstain from all kind of oppression. And this seems best to suit the context, which is to show what kind of fast the Lord reproves, and what he approves in the following verses.
Haydock -> Isa 58:4
Haydock: Isa 58:4 - -- Strife. The usual works were interrupted. The Church formerly forbade law-suits on fast-days. ---
Fist. Matthew xviii. 28. ---
Wickedly. Sept...
Strife. The usual works were interrupted. The Church formerly forbade law-suits on fast-days. ---
Fist. Matthew xviii. 28. ---
Wickedly. Septuagint, "the humble."
Gill -> Isa 58:4
Gill: Isa 58:4 - -- Behold, ye fast for strife and debate,.... Brawling with their servants for not doing work enough; or quarrelling with their debtors for not paying th...
Behold, ye fast for strife and debate,.... Brawling with their servants for not doing work enough; or quarrelling with their debtors for not paying their debts; or the main of their religion lay in contentions and strifes about words, vain hot disputations about rites and ceremonies in worship, as is well known to have been the case of the reformed churches:
and to smite with the fist of wickedness; their servants or their debtors; or rather it may design the persecution of such whose consciences would not suffer them to receive the doctrines professed; or submit to ordinances as administered; or comply with rites and ceremonies enjoined by the said churches; for which they have smitten their brethren that dissented from them with the fist, or have persecuted them in a violent manner by imprisonment, confiscation of goods, &c.; all which is no other than a fist of wickedness, and highly displeasing to God, and renders all their services unacceptable in his sight; see Mat 24:49,
ye shall not fast as ye do this day; or, "as this day"; after this manner; this is not right:
to make your voice to be heard on high; referring either to their noisy threatening of their servants for not doing their work; or their clamorous demands upon their debtors; or to their loud prayers, joined with their fasting, which they expected to be heard in the highest heaven, but would be mistaken; for such services, attended with the above evils, are not wellpleasing to God.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Isa 58:1-14
TSK Synopsis: Isa 58:1-14 - --1 The prophet, being sent to reprove hypocrisy, shews the difference between a counterfeit fast and a true.8 He declares what promises are due unto go...
MHCC -> Isa 58:3-12
MHCC: Isa 58:3-12 - --A fast is a day to afflict the soul; if it does not express true sorrow for sin, and does not promote the putting away of sin, it is not a fast. These...
Matthew Henry -> Isa 58:3-7
Matthew Henry: Isa 58:3-7 - -- Here we have, I. The displeasure which these hypocrites conceived against God for not accepting the services which they themselves had a mighty opin...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Isa 58:3-4
Keil-Delitzsch: Isa 58:3-4 - --
There follow now the words of the work-righteous themselves, who hold up their fasting before the eyes of God, and complain that He takes no notice ...
Constable: Isa 56:1--66:24 - --V. Israel's future transformation chs. 56--66
The last major section of Isaiah deals with the necessity of livin...

Constable: Isa 56:1--59:21 - --A. Recognition of human inability chs. 56-59
It is important that God's people demonstrate righteousness...

Constable: Isa 58:1--59:21 - --2. The relationship of righteousness and ritual chs. 58-59
The structure of this section is simi...

Constable: Isa 58:1-14 - --What God wants ch. 58
Again Isaiah presented the folly of simply going through a system ...
