
Text -- Isaiah 66:3 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: Isa 66:3 - -- _Solomon, Pro 15:8, gives a full commentary on the whole verse; The sacrifice of the wicked is an abomination to the Lord.
_Solomon, Pro 15:8, gives a full commentary on the whole verse; The sacrifice of the wicked is an abomination to the Lord.

Wesley: Isa 66:3 - -- From hence it is plain, that the prophet is not here reflecting upon idolatrous worship, but formal worship: upon those who in a formality worshipped ...
From hence it is plain, that the prophet is not here reflecting upon idolatrous worship, but formal worship: upon those who in a formality worshipped the true God, and by acts which he had appointed. God by the prophet declares, that these mens services were no more acceptable to him than murder, idolatry, or the most horrid profanation of his name.

JFB: Isa 66:3 - -- LOWTH not so well omits these words: "He that killeth an ox (presently after) murders a man" (as in Eze 23:39). But the omission in the Hebrew of "is ...
LOWTH not so well omits these words: "He that killeth an ox (presently after) murders a man" (as in Eze 23:39). But the omission in the Hebrew of "is as if"--increases the force of the comparison. Human victims were often offered by the heathen.

JFB: Isa 66:3 - -- An abomination according to the Jewish law (Deu 23:18); perhaps made so, because dogs were venerated in Egypt. He does not honor this abomination by u...
An abomination according to the Jewish law (Deu 23:18); perhaps made so, because dogs were venerated in Egypt. He does not honor this abomination by using the word "sacrifice," but uses the degrading term, "cut off a dog's neck" (Exo 13:13; Exo 34:20). Dogs as unclean are associated with swine (Mat 7:6; 2Pe 2:22).
Clarke -> Isa 66:3
Clarke: Isa 66:3 - -- He that killeth an ox is as if he slew a man "He that slayeth an ox killeth a man"- These are instances of wickedness joined with hypocrisy; of the ...
He that killeth an ox is as if he slew a man "He that slayeth an ox killeth a man"- These are instances of wickedness joined with hypocrisy; of the most flagitious crimes committed by those who at the same time affected great strictness in the performance of all the external services of religion. God, by the Prophet Ezekiel, upbraids the Jews with the same practices: "When they had slain their children to their idols, then they came the same day into my sanctuary to profane it,"Eze 23:39. Of the same kind was the hypocrisy of the Pharisees in our Savior’ s time:"who devoured widows’ houses, and for a pretense made long prayers,"Mat 23:14
The generality of interpreters, by departing from the literal rendering of the text, have totally lost the true sense of it, and have substituted in its place what makes no good sense at all; for it is not easy to show how, in any circumstances, sacrifice and murder, the presenting of legal offerings and idolatrous worship, can possibly be of the same account in the sight of God
He that offereth an oblation, as if he offered swine’ s blood "That maketh an oblation offereth swine’ s blood"- A word here likewise, necessary to complete the sense, is perhaps irrecoverably lost out of the text. The Vulgate and Chaldee add the word offereth, to make out the sense; not, as I imagine, from any different reading, (for the word wanted seems to have been lost before the time of the oldest of them as the Septuagint had it not in their copy,; but from mere necessity
Le Clerc thinks that
In their abominations -
Calvin -> Isa 66:3
Calvin: Isa 66:3 - -- 3.He that killeth an ox, as if he slew a man There are two clauses in this verse. In the former, Isaiah plainly declares that all the sacrifices of h...
3.He that killeth an ox, as if he slew a man There are two clauses in this verse. In the former, Isaiah plainly declares that all the sacrifices of his nation are of no value in the sight of God, but are held by him in abomination; in the latter, he describes the dreadful corruption by which they mingled the ceremonies of the Gentiles with the sacrifices of the Law, and in this way corrupted and perverted everything. The greater part of commentators think that these words repeal the sacrifices of the Law, but this is a mistake; for Isaiah, in this passage, treats of the same subject of which he had formerly treated in the first and fifty-eighth chapters, and does not absolutely condemn sacrifices, but rather the blemishes and corruptions of them, because the Jews thought that God was satisfied with a deceitful and empty appearance, and at the same time cared not about the true fear of God and a pure conscience. He does not speak, therefore, of the thing itself, but censures men who abused sacrifices; because this was as much as to offer to God the shell of an empty nut. In a word, no sacrifices are acceptable to God but those which proceed from a pure heart and an upright will.
Yet it is probable that the Prophet alludes to the sacrifices of the Gentiles, which were shocking and monstrous; for they killed men, or buried them alive. Neither the Romans, (who reckoned themselves to be more religious than other nations,) nor even the Jews, abstained from this crime. Nay more, (
And truly they have chosen their own ways There are two interpretations of this passage; for the antecedent to the pronoun may either be the Gentiles or the Jews; that is, either that the Jews mingled and entangled themselves with the wicked ceremonies of the Gentiles, or that they followed their own inventions. The former exposition would not be inappropriate, were it not that it is unnatural, because the word “Gentiles” has not been formerly expressed. It was the most aggravated part of the wickedness of the Jews, that they not only abused the pure worship of God, but likewise, through their contempt of the Law, defiled the temple and every other place by wicked and abominable superstitions. They built altars on high places, planted and reared groves, took delight in games and public entertainments, and copied everything else that was appointed by public authority for the purpose of corrupting the hearts of men. Thus there was produced among them a confused medley of superstitions, such as we now behold in Popery, in which we see various patches sewed together, taken out of every kind of superstitions, not only heathen and Jewish, but likewise such as have been recently contrived by Satan, that he might more easily, and with greater plausibility, impose on the world. These and similar practices the Prophet would justly pronounce to be doubly worthy of condemnation, because, while they boast of the name of God, and make profession of his worship, still they are not ashamed to stain and pollute that worship by the sacrileges of idolatrous nations.
The other interpretation is not obscure, and is equally appropriate, that the Jews were devoted to their own inventions, and followed their own abominations, He affirms that they do not worship God sincerely, who despise him according to their own caprice, not only because they are full of avarice, hatred, ambition, dishonesty, cruelty, and extortion, but because they corrupt the worship of God by their own contrivances. Although the pronoun refers to the Jews, yet the Prophet condemns all superstitions which they had borrowed from the heathen nations. Consequently, there is little difference between the two interpretations; for he merely teaches that, because they have insolently and rebelliously shaken off the yoke of God, because wickedness openly prevails among them, everything that proceeds from them is polluted and detestable. Streams that bring down dirty and offensive matter from a muddy and polluted fountain cannot be clean or pure. Choice and desire reveal their obstinacy more clearly; that is, because, knowingly and willingly, they despised God’s commandments, and devoted their heart to everything that was opposed to them, as if they wished intentionally to disdain everything that proceeded from God, that they might obey their depraved lust.
TSK -> Isa 66:3
TSK: Isa 66:3 - -- killeth : Isa 1:11-15; Pro 15:8, Pro 21:27; Amo 5:21, Amo 5:22
lamb : or, kid
cut : Deu 23:18
as if he offered : Isa 66:17, Isa 65:3, Isa 65:4; Deu 14...

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Isa 66:3
Barnes: Isa 66:3 - -- He that killeth an ox is as if he slew a man - Lowth and Noyes render this, ‘ He that slayeth an ox, killeth a man.’ This is a liter...
He that killeth an ox is as if he slew a man - Lowth and Noyes render this, ‘ He that slayeth an ox, killeth a man.’ This is a literal translation of the Hebrew. Jerome renders it, ‘ He who sacrifices an ox is as if (quasi) he slew a man.’ The Septuagint, in a very free translation - such as is common in their version of Isaiah - render it, ‘ The wicked man who sacrifices a calf, is as he who kills a dog; and he who offers to me fine flour, it is as the blood of swine.’ Lowth supposes the sense to be, that the most flagitious crimes were united with hypocrisy, and that they who were guilty of the most extreme acts of wickedness at the same time affected great strictness in the performance of all the external duties of religion. An instance of this, he says, is referred to by Ezekiel, where he says, ‘ When they had slain their children to their idols, then they came the same day into my sanctuary to profane it’ Eze 23:39.
There can be no doubt that such offences were often committed by those who were very strict and zealous in their religious services (compare Isa 1:11-14, with Isa 66:21-23. But the generality of interpreters have supposed that a different sense was to be affixed to this passage. According to their views, the particles as if are to be supplied; and the sense is, not that the mere killing of an ox is as sinful in the sight of God as deliberate murder, but that he who did it in the circumstances, and with the spirit referred to, evinced a spirit as odious in his sight as though he had slain a man. So the Septuagint, Vulgate, Chaldee, Symmachus, and Theodotion, Junius, and Tremellius, Grotius, and Rosenmuller, understand it. There is probably an allusion to the fact that human victims were offered by the pagan; and the sense is, that the sacrifices here referred to were no more acceptable in the sight of God than they were.
The prophet here refers, probably, first, to the spirit with which this was done. Their sacrifices were offered with a temper of mind as offensive to God as if a man had been slain, and they had been guilty of murder. They were proud, vain, and hypocritical. ‘ They had forgotten the true nature and design of sacrifice, and such worship could not but be an abhorrence in the sight of God. Secondly, It may also be implied here, that the period was coming when all sacrifices would be unacceptable to God. When the Messiah should have come; when he should have made by one offering a sufficent atonement for the sins of the whole world; then all bloody sacrifices would be needless, and would be offensive in the sight of God. The sacrifice of an ox would be no more acceptable than the sacrifice of a man; and all offerings with a view to propitiate the divine favor, or that implied that there was a deficiency in the merit of the one great atoning sacrifice, would be odious to God.
He that sacrificeth a lamb - Margin, ‘ Kid’ The Hebrew word (
As if he cut off a dog’ s neck - That is, as if he had cut off a dog’ s neck for sacrifice. To offer a dog in sacrifice would have been abominable in the view of a Jew. Even the price for which he was sold was not permitted to be brought into the house of God for a vow (Deu 23:18; compare 1Sa 17:43; 1Sa 24:14). The dog was held in veneration by many of the pagan, and was even offered in sacrifice; and it was, doubtless, partly in view of this fact, and especially of the fact that such veneration was shown for it in Egypt, that it was an object of such detestation among the Jews. Thus Juvenal, Sat. xiv. says:
Oppida tota canem venerantur, nemo Dianam .
‘ Every city worships the dog; none worship Diana.’ Diodorus (B. i.) says, ‘ Certain animals the Egyptians greatly venerate (
He that offereth an oblation - On the word rendered here ‘ oblation’ (
As if he offered swine’ s blood - The sacrifice of a hog was an abomination in the sight of the Hebrews (see the notes at Isa 65:4). Yet here it is said that the offering of the
He that burneth incense - See the word ‘ incense’ explained in the notes at Isa 1:13. The margin here is, ‘ Maketh a memorial of.’ Such is the usual meaning of the word used here (
As if he blessed an idol - The spirit with which incense would be offered would be as offensive as idolatry. The sentiment in all this is, that the most regular and formal acts of worship where the heart is lacking, may be as offensive to God as the worst forms of crime, or the most gross and debasing idolatry. Such a spirit often characterized the Jewish people, and eminently prevailed at the time when the temple of Herod was nearly completed, and when the Saviour was about to appear.
Poole -> Isa 66:3
Poole: Isa 66:3 - -- Solomon, Pro 15:8 , gives us a short but full commentary on the whole verse, The sacrifice of the wicked is an abomination to the Lord . He that k...
Solomon, Pro 15:8 , gives us a short but full commentary on the whole verse, The sacrifice of the wicked is an abomination to the Lord . He that killeth an ox , that is, for sacrifice, as it is expounded by the next words, he that sacrificeth a lamb . The comparisons show God’ s detestation of ceremonial performances from men of wicked hearts and lives. He that burneth incense , as if he blessed an idol: from hence it is plain that the prophet is not here reflecting upon idolatrous worship, but formal worship ; for to say, he that burneth incense to an idol is as he that blesseth an idol , is but to say, he that blesseth an idol blesseth an idol; but upon those who in a formality worshipped the true God, and by acts which he had appointed, such were offering sacrifices, oblation, incense. God by the prophet declares that these men’ s services were no more acceptable to him than murder, idolatry , or the most horrid profanation of his name . Such would cutting off a dog’ s neck for sacrifice have been, or offering swine’ s blood ; so little do ritual performances, though instituted by God himself, please God, when they are but mere formalities , as they always are when those that perform them live as they list, lewd and loose lives, and think to save themselves by their prayers, like the whore, Pro 7:14,15 ; not only sinning by human frailty, but taking pleasure in their sins, Pro 15:26 . To offer a sacrifice with a heart resolved (when it is offered) to go on in sinful courses, is to offer it with an evil mind . This is a dreadful text to those persons who will murder , and steal , and swear , and curse , and lie , and commit adultery , and then come and stand before God in his house, which is called by his name, that is, come to serve him in acts of worship, Lev 10:3 ; see Psa 50:16-18 Isa 1:11-14 Jer 7:9,10 Mt 7:21-23 Joh 4:24 1Ti 4:8 .
Haydock -> Isa 66:3
Haydock: Isa 66:3 - -- He. Septuagint, "the wicked who." (Haydock) ---
Ox. This is a prophecy, that the sacrifices which were offered in the old law, should be abolish...
He. Septuagint, "the wicked who." (Haydock) ---
Ox. This is a prophecy, that the sacrifices which were offered in the old law, should be abolished in the new; and that he offering of them should be a crime. (Challoner) ---
Without the proper dispositions, sacrifice only displeases God. (Calmet) ---
Brain, or slay. (Haydock) ---
Incense. To offer it in the way of a sacrifice; (Challoner) or to remind God of his people. The expression is popular, but energetic, Leviticus ii. 2, 9., and vi. 15. ---
Ways, to please themselves, and to bind me. But I will not have a divided heart, chap. i. 11., and lviii. 3. (Calmet)
Gill -> Isa 66:3
Gill: Isa 66:3 - -- He that killeth an ox, is as if he slew a man,.... Not that killed the ox of his neighbour, which, according to law, he was to pay for; or that killed...
He that killeth an ox, is as if he slew a man,.... Not that killed the ox of his neighbour, which, according to law, he was to pay for; or that killed one for food, which was lawful to be done; but that slew one, and offered it as a sacrifice; not blamed because blind or lame, or had any blemish in it, and so unfit for sacrifice; or because not rightly offered, under a due sense of sin, and with repentance for it, and faith in Christ; but because all sacrifices of this kind are now abolished in Gospel times, to which this prophecy belongs; Christ the great sacrifice being offered up; and therefore to offer sacrifice, which, notwithstanding the unbelieving Jews continued daily, till it was made to cease by the destruction of their temple, was a great offence to God; it was as grievous to him as offering their children to Moloch; or as the murder of a man; and was indeed a trampling under foot the Son of God, and accounting his blood and sacrifice as nothing, which was highly displeasing to God:
he that sacrificeth a lamb, as if he cut off a dog's neck; the lamb for the daily sacrifice, morning and evening, or the passover lamb, or any other: this now is no more acceptable to God, than if a dog, a very impure creature, was slain, his head cut off, and offered on the altar; which was so abominable to the Lord, that the price of one might not be brought into his house, Deu 23:18,
he that offereth an oblation, as if he offered swine's blood; the meat offering, made of fine flour, on which oil was poured, and frankincense put, Lev 2:1, however rightly composed it might be, and offered according to law, yet now of no more esteem with God than blood, which was forbidden by the same law; nay, than the blood of swine, which creature itself, according to the ceremonial law, was unclean, and might not be eaten, and much less be offered up, and still less its blood, Lev 11:7,
and he that burneth incense, as if he blessed an idol; or that "remembers incense" p; that offers it as a memorial of mercies, and by way of thankfulness for them, as if he gave thanks to an idol, which is nothing, and vanity and vexation in the world; sacrifices of such kind, be they what they will, are reckoned no other than as idolatry and will worship:
yea, they have chosen their own ways: which were evil, and opposite to the ways of God, especially to the way of salvation by Christ; they gave heed to the traditions of the elders; continued the service of the ceremonial law; and set up their own righteousness, in opposition to the doctrines, ordinances, sacrifice, and righteousness of Christ:
and their soul delighteth in their abominations: things which were abominable unto God; as were their traditions, which were preferred to the word of God, and by which they made it void; and their sacrifices being offered up contrary to his will, and with a wicked mind; and their righteousness being imperfect, and trusted in, to the neglect and contempt of the righteousness of his Son.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Isa 66:1-24
TSK Synopsis: Isa 66:1-24 - --1 The glorious God will be served in humble sincerity.5 He comforts the humble by shewing the confusion of their enemies;7 with the marvellous growth,...
MHCC -> Isa 66:1-4
MHCC: Isa 66:1-4 - --The Jews gloried much in their temple. But what satisfaction can the Eternal Mind take in a house made with men's hands? God has a heaven and an earth...
Matthew Henry -> Isa 66:1-4
Matthew Henry: Isa 66:1-4 - -- Here, I. The temple is slighted in comparison with a gracious soul, Isa 66:1, Isa 66:2. The Jews in the prophet's time, and afterwards in Christ's t...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Isa 66:1-4
Keil-Delitzsch: Isa 66:1-4 - --
Although the note on which this prophecy opens is a different one from any that has yet been struck, there are many points in which it coincides wit...
Constable: Isa 56:1--66:24 - --V. Israel's future transformation chs. 56--66
The last major section of Isaiah deals with the necessity of livin...

Constable: Isa 63:1--66:24 - --C. Recognition of divine ability chs. 63-66
The third and final subdivision of this last part of the boo...

Constable: Isa 65:17--Jer 1:1 - --2. The culmination of Israel's future 65:17-66:24
As the book opened with an emphasis on judgmen...
