![](images/minus.gif)
Text -- Jeremiah 29:28-32 (NET)
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/information.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
JFB: Jer 29:24-32 - -- A second communication which Jeremiah sent to Babylon, after the messenger who carried his first letter had brought a letter from the false prophet Sh...
A second communication which Jeremiah sent to Babylon, after the messenger who carried his first letter had brought a letter from the false prophet Shemaiah to Zephaniah, &c., condemning Jeremiah and reproving the authorities for not having apprehended him.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Jer 29:24-32 - -- A name derived either from his father or from a place: alluding at the same time to the Hebrew meaning, "a dreamer" (compare Jer 29:8).
A name derived either from his father or from a place: alluding at the same time to the Hebrew meaning, "a dreamer" (compare Jer 29:8).
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Jer 29:29 - -- He seems to have been less prejudiced against Jeremiah than the others; hence he reads the charge to the prophet, that he should not be condemned with...
He seems to have been less prejudiced against Jeremiah than the others; hence he reads the charge to the prophet, that he should not be condemned without a hearing. This accords with Shemaiah's imputation against Zephaniah for want of zeal against Jeremiah (Jer 29:26-27). Hence the latter was chosen by King Zedekiah as one of the deputation to Jeremiah (Jer 21:1; Jer 37:3).
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Jer 29:30 - -- This resumes the thread of the sentence which began at Jer 29:25, but was left there not completed. Here, in this thirtieth verse, it is completed, no...
This resumes the thread of the sentence which began at Jer 29:25, but was left there not completed. Here, in this thirtieth verse, it is completed, not however in continuity, but by a new period. The same construction occurs in Rom 5:12-15.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Jer 29:32 - -- As he despised the lawful time and wished to return before the time God had expressly announced, in just retribution he should not share in the restor...
As he despised the lawful time and wished to return before the time God had expressly announced, in just retribution he should not share in the restoration from Babylon at all.
Clarke -> Jer 29:32
Clarke: Jer 29:32 - -- I will punish Shemaiah -
1. He shall have no posterity to succeed him
2. His family, i.e., relations, etc., shal...
I will punish Shemaiah -
1. He shall have no posterity to succeed him
2. His family, i.e., relations, etc., shall not be found among those whom I shall bring back from captivity
3. Nor shall he himself see the good that I shall do for my people
And all this shall come upon him and his because he hath taught rebellion against the Lord. He excited the people to reject Jeremiah, and to receive the lying words of the false prophets; and these led them to rebel.
Calvin: Jer 29:28 - -- The crime ascribed to Jeremiah was, — that he rendered the captives indifferent, so that they cast off every hope of deliverance, and disregarded t...
The crime ascribed to Jeremiah was, — that he rendered the captives indifferent, so that they cast off every hope of deliverance, and disregarded their own country. But the design of Jeremiah was far different; it was, that the people might not by too much haste anticipate the promises of God, and that he might also extend their hope to the end, prefixed. As there are two causal particles here found,
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Calvin: Jer 29:29 - -- It follows, And Zephaniah had read, etc The past perfect tense is more suitable here, for the verse ought to be put in a parenthesis. The Prophet o...
It follows, And Zephaniah had read, etc The past perfect tense is more suitable here, for the verse ought to be put in a parenthesis. The Prophet obviates a doubt which might have been entertained. He then shews how the prophecy was made known to him; he was one of the hearers when the letter was read. And it is probable that the priest called Jeremiah on purpose, that he might be proved guilty by his own accuser. However this may have been, he wished to expose the holy man to the hatred of the people, or rather to their fury. The constancy of Jeremiah was worthy of greater praise, while he boldly reproved the arrogance of them all, who had nothing else in view but to suppress God’s truth by force and tyranny.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Calvin: Jer 29:31 - -- Jeremiah distinctly declares that this impostor would not escape unpunished, because he had dared falsely to pretend the name of God, and avowedly op...
Jeremiah distinctly declares that this impostor would not escape unpunished, because he had dared falsely to pretend the name of God, and avowedly opposed Jeremiah. Here, then, the Prophet makes no long discourse, but on the contrary simply declares by the power of the Spirit what would take place. He speaks in God’s name, for he had been sent as a herald to proclaim this judgment. This, then, is the reason why he is so brief; for there was to be no dispute, though the impostor on the other hand was carrying himself very high, and hesitated not to overthrow the revealed truth of God, which had been confirmed by many witnesses.
The sum of what is stated is, that Shemaiah would not see the favor of God, and that none of his seed would remain alive. It was a curse under the Law, as it is well known, that one should have no seed left. (Deu 28:18.) Jeremiah then denounces on Shemaiah this punishment, that no one of his seed would remain alive, but that he would die childless; and then he excludes him from the enjoyment of the benefit which the Lord had determined to bestow on his people. He wished to return after two years to his own country; Jeremiah commanded the people patiently to endure their exile to the end of seventy years, which was the time of their deliverance. As, then, Shemaiah despised the lawful time, he was deprived of the favor of seeing that event.
Added then is the reason; first, because he had abused the name of God; he prophesied and I had not sent him, said the Lord; the second reason was, that he deceived the people with a vain hope; falsehood of itself is worthy of a heavy punishment; but when it was pernicious to God’s people, it became still more heinous, and therefore worthy of a twofold punishment.
Now we see that Jeremiah esteemed as nothing that he was condemned by Shemaiah; for he retained his own dignity; though the impostor attempted to subvert his authority, yet the Prophet speaks as though he was wholly unstained and not hurt nor affected by any calumny. The same magnanimity of mind is what all faithful teachers ought to possess, so as to look down, as from on high, on all deceivers, and their chatterings, and curses, and to go on in their course, however insolently the despisers of God may rise up against them, and tear and overwhelm them with reproaches. Let then all those who seek to serve God and his Church follow this example of the Prophet, so that they may not be discouraged in their minds when they find that they have to contend with dishonest men.
But Jeremiah is bidden to write to all the captives, for Shemaiah was not worthy of being reproved; but God had a regard for the public safety of the exiles, and reminded them of what would take place. It is indeed probable that this prophecy was without any fruit, until it was known by the event itself that Jeremiah had not without reason thus prophesied. Until, then, Shemaiah died, and died without any to succeed him, the people disregarded what had been predicted; but at length they were constrained to acknowledge that Jeremiah had not spoken his own thought, but had been furnished with a message from God; for God really fulfilled what he had predicted by the mouth of his Prophet.
The two reasons follow, why God resolved to punish Shemaiah: the first is, that he had seized on the prophetic office without a call; and hence we conclude, according to what has already appeared, that this office which had been instituted by God, was perverted, when any one intruded into it without a commission. Let us then know that no one ought to be deemed a legitimate teacher, except he can really shew that he has been called from above. I have in several places stated that two things belonged to a call; the inward call was the chief thing when the state of the Church was in disorder, that is, when the priests neglected the duty of teaching, and wholly departed from what their office required. When, therefore, the Church became disordered, God applied an extraordinary remedy by raising up prophets. But when the Church is rightly and regularly formed, no one can boast that he is a pastor or a minister, except he is also called by the suffrages of men. But as I have spoken on this subject more at large on the twenty-third chapter, I only slightly refer to it now.
As to the present passage in which God condemns Shemaiah for having thrust in himself without being called, what is meant is, that he brought forward his own dreams, having been furnished with no commission; for the prophetic office was then special. Then Shemaiah is here rejected as an impostor, because he had only brought forward prophecies suggested by his own brains, which yet he falsely pretended to have been from God; and it was a most atrocious crime, as it was a sacrilege to abuse, as Shemaiah did, the name of God. But the atrocity of his sin the Prophet still further sets forth, by saying that his prophecies were pernicious and fatal to the people. We hence conclude how solicitous God was for the safety of his people, in thus avenging the falsehoods which were calculated to lead them to ruin; and Jeremiah shews that Shemaiah’s teaching was ruinous, because he inebriated the people with false confidence; he made you, he says, to trust in falsehood; for he promised them a quick return, when it was God’s will, that the Jews should patiently bear their exile till the end of the seventy years.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Calvin: Jer 29:32 - -- But we may deduce from this passage a useful doctrine, — that nothing is more pestiferous in a Church than for men to be led away by a false confid...
But we may deduce from this passage a useful doctrine, — that nothing is more pestiferous in a Church than for men to be led away by a false confidence or trust. For it is the foundation of all true religion to depend on the mouth or word of God; and it is also the foundation of our salvation. As, then, the salvation of men as well as true religion is founded on faith and the obedience of faith; so also when we are drawn away to some false trust, the whole of true religion falls to the ground, and at the same time every hope of salvation vanishes. This ought to be carefully observed, so that we may learn to embrace that doctrine which teaches us to trust in no other than in the only true God, and reject all those inventions which may lead us away from him, even in the least degree, so that we may not look around us nor be carried here and there.
For this reason, as I have said, the Prophet declares that Shemaiah would die childless, and be precluded from enjoying the favor which God had resolved and even promised to bestow on his people. And all this, as I have reminded you, was said for the sake of the people; for this prophecy did no good to Shemaiah nor to his posterity; but his punishment ought to have benefited the miserable exiles so as to lead them to repentance, however late it may have been. This is the import of the passage.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
TSK: Jer 29:31 - -- Send : Jer 29:20
Because : Jer 29:9, Jer 29:23, Jer 14:14, Jer 14:15, Jer 23:21, Jer 28:15-17; Eze 13:8-16, Eze 13:22, Eze 13:23; 2Pe 2:1
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
TSK: Jer 29:32 - -- punish : Jer 20:6; Exo 20:5; Num 16:27-33; Jos 7:24, Jos 7:25; 2Ki 5:27; Psa 109:8-15; Isa 14:20,Isa 14:22; Amo 7:17
he shall : Jer 22:30, Jer 35:19; ...
punish : Jer 20:6; Exo 20:5; Num 16:27-33; Jos 7:24, Jos 7:25; 2Ki 5:27; Psa 109:8-15; Isa 14:20,Isa 14:22; Amo 7:17
he shall : Jer 22:30, Jer 35:19; 1Sa 2:30-34
behold : Jer 29:10-14, Jer 17:6; 2Ki 7:2, 2Ki 7:19, 2Ki 7:20
rebellion : Heb. revolt, Jer 28:16 *marg.
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Jer 29:24-29
Barnes: Jer 29:24-29 - -- A narrative showing the effects of Jeremiah’ s letter. Shemaiah the leader of the false prophets wrote to Zephaniah, urging him to restrain the...
A narrative showing the effects of Jeremiah’ s letter. Shemaiah the leader of the false prophets wrote to Zephaniah, urging him to restrain the prophet’ s zeal with the prison and the stocks.
To Shemaiah - Rather, concerning.
The Nehelamite - Not as in the margin; but one belonging to the village of Nehlam (unknown).
Officers - Deputy high priests who had the oversight of the temple.
Mad - See 2Ki 9:11 note. Many of the symbolic actions of the prophets, such as that of Jeremiah going about with a yoke on his neck, would be mocked at by the irreverent as passing the line between prophecy and madness.
Prisons - Rather, the stocks Jer 20:2.
The stocks - Rather, collar.
This captivity is long - Rather, It is long. God’ s anger, their punishment, the exile, the time necessary for their repentance - all is long to men who will never live to see their country again.
Poole: Jer 29:28 - -- The matter of fact was true, as appeared Jer 29:5,6, but it was false that this was the effect of phrensy, or that he spake this of his own head wit...
The matter of fact was true, as appeared Jer 29:5,6, but it was false that this was the effect of phrensy, or that he spake this of his own head without commission from God; for he wrote nothing of this nature but by order from God, as appeareth from Jer 29:4 , where he began his letter with, Thus saith the Lord of hosts, the God of Israel .
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: Jer 29:29 - -- It is uncertain whether Zephaniah did this out of kindness to Jeremiah, for we read he was sent to Jeremiah upon messages, Jer 21:1 37:3 , from the ...
It is uncertain whether Zephaniah did this out of kindness to Jeremiah, for we read he was sent to Jeremiah upon messages, Jer 21:1 37:3 , from the king, or because he would not apprehend him before he heard him, and let him know that he did nothing against him but upon information, &c.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: Jer 29:31 - -- This is the great mischief of false teachers, they are the causes of people’ s trusting in lies; and from hence the sins of false prophets are ...
This is the great mischief of false teachers, they are the causes of people’ s trusting in lies; and from hence the sins of false prophets are ordinarily aggravated.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: Jer 29:32 - -- I will punish Shemaiah the Nehelamite, and his seed: punishments of this life ordinarily are extended to the children of sinful parents, for the pare...
I will punish Shemaiah the Nehelamite, and his seed: punishments of this life ordinarily are extended to the children of sinful parents, for the parents’ sake, who are punished in their children, being res parentum , a considerable part of their parents’ goods and portion. He shall not have a man to dwell among this people ; he and his whole posterity shall be rooted out;
neither shall he behold the good that I will do for my people and neither he nor they shall live to the time of my people’ s return from the captivity of Babylon.
Because he hath taught rebellion against the Lord because by the falsehoods which he hath taught he hath been an instrument to make people disobey the commands of God. We had the same clause Jer 28:16 , and such a kind of threatening we find Amo 7:17 , denounced by that prophet against Amaziah the priest of Beth-el, forbidding him to prophesy at Beth-el, because it was the king’ s court and chapel . To obstruct the revelation of God’ s will to people, or to publish what is contrary to it, to seduce people from believing it, or yielding obedience, are both crimes that have been and will be of fatal consequence to them and their families who are so hardy as to incur the guilt of them.
Haydock: Jer 29:28 - -- Time, before you will return. (Haydock) ---
Sophonias read the letter, approving of its contents, (St. Jerome) though this is not certain. He took...
Time, before you will return. (Haydock) ---
Sophonias read the letter, approving of its contents, (St. Jerome) though this is not certain. He took no violent steps against Jeremias, as Phassur had done. (Haydock)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Sit, in an honourable station, or they shall all die. (Calmet)
Gill: Jer 29:28 - -- For therefore he sent unto us in Babylon, saying,.... That is, Jeremiah the prophet; and this was the reason, because his mouth was not stopped, and ...
For therefore he sent unto us in Babylon, saying,.... That is, Jeremiah the prophet; and this was the reason, because his mouth was not stopped, and he restrained from prophesying; so that Shemaiah lays all the blame on Zephaniah, and his brethren the priests; who, had they done their duty, would have prevented Jeremiah's letter to the captives, as he suggests; the purport of which was,
this captivity is long; so Kimchi, Abarbinel, and Ben Melech, supply it; or, "it is long" m; it will be a long time before the captives shall return to their own land; and therefore they should not think of it, or provide for it; but, on the contrary, for their continuance in Babylon; giving the following advice:
build ye houses, and dwell in them; and plant gardens, and eat the fruit of them; referring to Jeremiah's letter; See Gill on Jer 29:5.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Jer 29:29 - -- And Zephaniah the priest read this letter,.... Of Shemaiah's to him, and the other priests:
in the ears of Jeremiah the prophet: whether out of goo...
And Zephaniah the priest read this letter,.... Of Shemaiah's to him, and the other priests:
in the ears of Jeremiah the prophet: whether out of good will, to let him know who were his enemies abroad; or out of ill will, to stir up the people against him; or in pretence of proceeding equitably with him; not taking him up, and punishing him before he brought the accusation and charge against him; and acquainted him who were his accusers, and what evidence there was, and heard what he had to say in his own defence whether one or the other is uncertain; however, by this means Jeremiah came to the knowledge of Shemaiah's letter.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Jer 29:30 - -- When came the word of the Lord unto Jeremiah,.... After he had heard the letter read:
saying; as follows:
When came the word of the Lord unto Jeremiah,.... After he had heard the letter read:
saying; as follows:
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Jer 29:31 - -- Send to all them of the captivity,.... Another letter; not to Shemaiah, but to the people, that they might all know that he was a false prophet; and h...
Send to all them of the captivity,.... Another letter; not to Shemaiah, but to the people, that they might all know that he was a false prophet; and how his lies were resented by the Lord; and what punishment should be inflicted on him and his, on account of them:
saying, thus saith the Lord concerning Shemaiah the Nehelamite; the letter, though written by the prophet, must be sent in the name of the Lord, declaring what he would do with the person mentioned, and the reason of it; which follows:
because that Shemaiah hath prophesied unto you, and I sent him not,
and he caused you to trust in a lie; that they should in a very little time return from their captivity to Jerusalem.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Jer 29:32 - -- Therefore thus saith the Lord,.... Because he prophesied without being sent of God, and prophesied lies, by which the people were deceived:
behold,...
Therefore thus saith the Lord,.... Because he prophesied without being sent of God, and prophesied lies, by which the people were deceived:
behold, I will punish Shemaiah the Nehelamite, and his seed; not him only, but his posterity also: thus God sometimes visits the sins of parents on their children, they being, as it were, a part of themselves, and oftentimes partners with them in their iniquities:
he shall not have a man to dwell among this people; either at Babylon, or at Jerusalem, whither he had promised a speedy return:
neither shall he behold the good that I will do for my people, saith the Lord; by returning them, after seventy years captivity, to their own land, and to the enjoyment of all their privileges, civil and religious:
because he hath taught rebellion against the Lord; or, "a departure n from him"; taught men to revolt from him, and not give heed to his prophets; to disbelieve what he said by them, concerning their continuance in Babylon; which is called a rebellion against him; and being so heinous a crime, deserved the punishment denounced on him and his; rebels and their offspring are punished among men.
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: Jer 29:32 Compare the same charge against Hananiah in Jer 28:16 and see the note there. In this case, the false prophesy of Shemaiah is not given but it likely ...
Geneva Bible -> Jer 29:32
Geneva Bible: Jer 29:32 Therefore thus saith the LORD; Behold, I will punish Shemaiah the Nehelamite, and his seed: he shall not have a man ( p ) to dwell among this people; ...
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Jer 29:1-32
TSK Synopsis: Jer 29:1-32 - --1 Jeremiah sends a letter to the captives in Babylon to be quiet there,8 and not to believe the dreams of their prophets;10 and that they shall return...
MHCC -> Jer 29:20-32
MHCC: Jer 29:20-32 - --Jeremiah foretells judgments upon the false prophets, who deceived the Jews in Babylon. Lying was bad; lying to the people of the Lord, to delude them...
Matthew Henry -> Jer 29:24-32
Matthew Henry: Jer 29:24-32 - -- We have perused the contents of Jeremiah's letter to the captives in Babylon, who had reason, with a great deal of thanks to God and him, to acknowl...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Jer 29:24-32
Keil-Delitzsch: Jer 29:24-32 - --
Threatening against the false prophet Shemaiah . - Jeremiah's letter to the exiles (vv. 1-23) had excited great indignation among the false prophet...
Constable: Jer 2:1--45:5 - --II. Prophecies about Judah chs. 2--45
The first series of prophetic announcements, reflections, and incidents th...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: Jer 26:1--29:32 - --B. Controversies concerning false prophets chs. 26-29
These chapters contrast the true prophet of Yahweh...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: Jer 29:1-32 - --3. Conflict with the false prophets in exile ch. 29
This chapter continues the theme of the prev...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: Jer 29:24-28 - --Jeremiah's letter to Shemaiah in Babylon 29:24-28
Jeremiah wrote another letter, this time in response to a letter that the false prophet Shemaiah in ...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)