
Text -- Jeremiah 42:20-22 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
JFB: Jer 42:20 - -- Rather, "ye have used deceit against your (own) souls." It is not God, but yourselves, whom ye deceive, to your own ruin, by your own dissimulation (G...
Rather, "ye have used deceit against your (own) souls." It is not God, but yourselves, whom ye deceive, to your own ruin, by your own dissimulation (Gal 6:7) [CALVIN]. But the words following accord best with English Version, ye have dissembled in your hearts (see on Jer 42:3) towards me, when ye sent me to consult God for you.

JFB: Jer 42:21 - -- Antithesis. I have done my part; but ye do not yours. It is no fault of mine that ye act not rightly.
Antithesis. I have done my part; but ye do not yours. It is no fault of mine that ye act not rightly.

JFB: Jer 42:22 - -- For a time, until they could return to their country. They expected, therefore, to be restored, in spite of God's prediction to the contrary.
For a time, until they could return to their country. They expected, therefore, to be restored, in spite of God's prediction to the contrary.
Clarke: Jer 42:20 - -- For ye dissembled in your hearts - What a most miserable and incorrigible people! Ingratitude, hypocrisy, rebellion, and cruelty seem to have been e...
For ye dissembled in your hearts - What a most miserable and incorrigible people! Ingratitude, hypocrisy, rebellion, and cruelty seem to have been enthroned in their hearts! And what are they still? Just what their fathers were, except in the mere article of idolatry; and that they do not practice because they are indifferent to their own religion and to that of all others. Examine their devotions and their lives, and see whether Charity herself can say they believe in the God of Abraham!

Clarke: Jer 42:21 - -- Ye have not obeyed the voice - Though ye have requested to have this particular revelation of the Divine will, and promised obedience, yet have ye n...
Ye have not obeyed the voice - Though ye have requested to have this particular revelation of the Divine will, and promised obedience, yet have ye not done one thing for which ye sent me to inquire of the Lord.

Clarke: Jer 42:22 - -- Now therefore know certainly - As ye have determined to disobey, God has determined to punish. Ye may now follow the full bent of your wicked device...
Now therefore know certainly - As ye have determined to disobey, God has determined to punish. Ye may now follow the full bent of your wicked devices, and I will follow the requisitions of my justice. Ye shall die by the sword, by the pestilence, and by the famine, in the place whither ye desire to go to sojourn. Thus was their doom sealed
With such dispositions and with such rebellion of heart, it is strange that they should put themselves to any trouble to inquire of the Lord relative to their future operations. They did not intend to obey; but as a matter of curiosity they would inquire to hear what the prophet might say; and if according to their own inclination, they would obey.
Calvin: Jer 42:20 - -- He now adds another circumstance, that they had sent him under the pretense of rare piety, as though they were in every way ready to render obedience...
He now adds another circumstance, that they had sent him under the pretense of rare piety, as though they were in every way ready to render obedience to God. But he first says that they had deceived themselves, or had been deceived. The verb
He reproves them not only for perfidy, but also for sacrilege, because they wickedly profaned the name of God. For it. was not to be endured that they should pretend a regard for religion, and testify that they would be obedient to God, and should at the same time cherish in their hearts that perverse intention which afterwards they discovered. And hence he not only relates that he had been sent, but that he had also been solicited to intercede for them. It was then a twofold sacrilege, for they had asked what would please God, and afterwards disregarded the prophecy, — and then they offered a prayer, and when God gave them an answer by his servant., they counted it as nothing! We now perceive why Jeremiah so expressly mentioned these two things.
Pray for us to our God, and according to all which Jehovah our God shall say, relate thou to us: the people seemed to act with wonderful sincerity; they exhorted the Prophet to dissemble nothing, to add nothing and to diminish nothing’. What better can be wished than that men should lay aside all ambiguity and all evasions, and not wish God’s words to be corrupted? And this the Jews expressed in high terms, Whatever Jehovah our God shall answer, declare thou to us Here they seemed to have more zeal than Jeremiah himself; for they enjoined a law, that he should add nothing and diminish nothing, but that he should be a faithful interpreter of God’s will. They seemed then to be half-angels. They afterwards testified that they would do whatever God should command them.

Calvin: Jer 42:21 - -- He at length adds, And I have this day declared it to you Here he sets forth his own fidelity, not for the sake of boasting, but that their impiety...
He at length adds, And I have this day declared it to you Here he sets forth his own fidelity, not for the sake of boasting, but that their impiety might be reproved, who at length despised the oracle of God, which they had boasted that they would obey. Ye have not hearkened, he says, to the voice of Jehovah your God, and according to all the things on account of which he hath sent me to you. The Prophet again confirms the truth, that it was their own fault that the Jews did not follow what was right, and also what was for their good, for he had faithfully delivered to them what God had commanded. He now adds, —

Calvin: Jer 42:22 - -- The Prophet at length concludes his discourse, after having mentioned the reasons why God would deal so severely with them, even because their perfid...
The Prophet at length concludes his discourse, after having mentioned the reasons why God would deal so severely with them, even because their perfidy, impiety, ingratitude, and obstinate contempt were unsufferable. After having then shewn that they had no reason to expostulate as though God were extremely rigid, he at length declares what end awaited them, even that they should die by the sword, famine, or pestilence, that is, that there would be no hope of safety to them, because if they escaped from the sword, they should be beset with famine, and if they evaded the famine, they should be destroyed by pestilence. It is a common mode of speaking with the Prophets, as it is well known, that when they intimate that the ungodly in vain hope for impunity, they represent God as having at his command all kinds of punishment.
Ye shall then, he says, die in that place which ye seek for your sojourn, he again shews the object of the people, for they did not intend to dwell perpetually in Egypt, but only for a time, until there was liberty to return to their own country. In short, they wished to be restored, as it were, against God’s will; and yet they ceased not falsely to put forward the name of God, as hypocrites, who mock God, always do. Now follows, —
TSK: Jer 42:20 - -- For ye : God made known to the prophet their dissimulation; which he shunned not to declare to them. Jer 3:10, Jer 17:10; Psa 18:44, Psa 65:3; Eze 14:...
For ye : God made known to the prophet their dissimulation; which he shunned not to declare to them. Jer 3:10, Jer 17:10; Psa 18:44, Psa 65:3; Eze 14:3, Eze 14:4, Eze 33:31; Mat 22:15-18, Mat 22:35; Gal 6:7
dissembled in your hearts : Heb. have used deceit against your souls, Num 16:38; Jam 1:22
Pray : Jer 42:2

TSK: Jer 42:21 - -- I have : Deu 11:26, Deu 11:27; Eze 2:7, Eze 3:17; Act 20:20,Act 20:26, Act 20:27
but : Jer 7:24-27; Deu 29:19; Zec 7:11, Zec 7:12

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Jer 42:20
Barnes: Jer 42:20 - -- Ye dissembled in your hearts - Or, "ye have led yourselves astray,"i. e., your sending me to ask counsel of God was an act of self-delusion. Yo...
Ye dissembled in your hearts - Or, "ye have led yourselves astray,"i. e., your sending me to ask counsel of God was an act of self-delusion. You felt so sure that God would direct you to go into Egypt, that now that He has spoken to the contrary, you are unable to reconcile yourselves to it.
Poole: Jer 42:20 - -- Ye dissembled in your hearts or, you have used deceit, either towards God, dealing falsely with him, calling him to be a witness to your sincerity in...
Ye dissembled in your hearts or, you have used deceit, either towards God, dealing falsely with him, calling him to be a witness to your sincerity in what you never intended any sincerity in; or towards me, sending me to inquire of God for you, and promising to do according to what I should reveal to you from God as his will, whenas you never intended it; or towards your own souls, as every sinner doth but deceive his own soul: you made a pretence of what was not in your hearts, when you sent me to pray God’ s direction for you, and made me such a firm promise to do whatsoever I should reveal to you from God as his will in this case.

Poole: Jer 42:21 - -- I have been faithful to you, I went according to your desire to inquire of God for you, I had his will revealed to me in your case, and now I have a...
I have been faithful to you, I went according to your desire to inquire of God for you, I had his will revealed to me in your case, and now I have as faithfully told you what it is;
but ye have not obeyed How did Jeremiah know this, for they had not yet declared their minds to him? He had either learned it from their discourses during the ten days which God had made him to wait for the revelation, or he had learned it from some contemptuous behaviour of them when he delivered it, or (which is most probable) God had aforehand told it to him.

Poole: Jer 42:22 - -- The prophet ascertaineth that doom unto them which, Jer 42:15-17 , he had threatened them with, in case they were resolved to go into Egypt. We must...
The prophet ascertaineth that doom unto them which, Jer 42:15-17 , he had threatened them with, in case they were resolved to go into Egypt. We must expect nothing but utmost disappointments upon actions done in disobedience to the revealed will of God: you think to avoid death by going thither for a little time to sojourn, but you shall die there, and that by those very deaths which by going thither you seek to avoid,
Haydock -> Jer 42:20
Haydock: Jer 42:20 - -- Deceived. Septuagint, "done ill in your souls." Your intention was bad. You thought that I should speak conformably to your wishes. (Calmet) ---
...
Deceived. Septuagint, "done ill in your souls." Your intention was bad. You thought that I should speak conformably to your wishes. (Calmet) ---
He saw by the prophetic light, or by their deportment, that they were bent on going. (Haydock) ---
They were doubly guilty in neither observing their promise nor obeying God's decree. (Worthington)
Gill: Jer 42:20 - -- For ye dissembled in your hearts,.... Did not honestly and faithfully declare their intentions; they said one thing with their mouths, and meant anoth...
For ye dissembled in your hearts,.... Did not honestly and faithfully declare their intentions; they said one thing with their mouths, and meant another in their minds; they pretended they would act according to the will of God, as it should be made known to them by him, when they were determined to take their own way. Some render it, "ye have deceived me in your hearts" z; the prophet, so Kimchi; by that which was in their hearts, not declaring what was their real intention and design: or, "ye have deceived your souls" a; you have deceived yourselves and one another; I have not deceived you, nor the Lord, but you have put a cheat upon your own souls: or, "you have used deceit against your souls" b; to the hurt of them, to your present ruin and everlasting destruction:
when ye sent me unto the Lord your God; the prophet did not go of himself, they desired him to go:
saying, pray for us unto the Lord our God; to be directed in the way they should go; so that the prophet did nothing but what they desired him to do:
and according to all that the Lord our God shall say, so declare unto us, and we will do it; they pressed him to a faithful declaration of the will of God to them, and promised they would act according to it. Now he had done all this; he had been wire God, prayed unto him as they requested, and had brought them his mind and will, and made a faithful relation of it, and yet they did not attend to it; so that the deceit was not in him, but in them, as follows:

Gill: Jer 42:21 - -- And now I have this day declared it unto you,.... The whole will of God, and had not kept back anything from them:
but ye have not obeyed the voi...
And now I have this day declared it unto you,.... The whole will of God, and had not kept back anything from them:
but ye have not obeyed the voice of the Lord your God; or, "ye will not obey" c; the prophet knew they would not obey the command of the Lord not to go into Egypt, either by his conversation with them during the ten days the answer of the Lord was deferred, by which he plainly saw they were determined to go into Egypt; or by their countenances and behaviour, while he was delivering the Lord's message to them; by what he observed in them, he knew what was said was not agreeable to them, and that their mind was to go into Egypt: or he had this, as others think, by divine revelation; though without that he knew the cast of this people, and what a rebellious and disobedient people they were, and had been, never obeying the voice of the Lord:
nor any thing for which he hath sent me unto you: not anyone particular thing respecting this present affair; nor indeed any of his prophecies had they regarded, with which he had been sent to them before.

Gill: Jer 42:22 - -- Now therefore know certainly,.... Or, "in knowing know" d; they might assure themselves of this, that it would certainly come to pass, and most justly...
Now therefore know certainly,.... Or, "in knowing know" d; they might assure themselves of this, that it would certainly come to pass, and most justly and deservedly; since it was at their own request the prophet sought the mind of the Lord for them, and had faithfully related it to them, and they had promised to observe it; wherefore, should they go into Egypt, as their inclination scented to be entirely that way, they must expect what follows:
that ye shall die by the sword, by the famine, and by the pestilence; by one or other of these, or all of them; some by one, and some by another, as before threatened; evils they thought to escape by going thither, but which should surely follow them, and overtake them:
in the place whither ye desire to go and to sojourn; that is, in Egypt, to which they had a strong inclination, where they greatly desired to be, pleased themselves with the thoughts of, and which they chose of their own will and pleasure for their habitation.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes: Jer 42:20 Heb “According to all which the Lord our God says so tell us and we will do.” The restructuring of the sentence is intended to better refl...

NET Notes: Jer 42:21 Heb “But you have not hearkened to the voice of [idiomatic for “obeyed” see BDB 1034 s.v. שָׁמַע...
Geneva Bible: Jer 42:20 For ye were ( h ) hypocrites in your hearts, when ye sent me to the LORD your God, saying, Pray for us to the LORD our God; and according to all that ...

Geneva Bible: Jer 42:22 Now therefore know certainly that ye shall die by the sword, by the famine, and by the pestilence, ( i ) in the place where ye desire to go [and] to s...

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Jer 42:1-22
TSK Synopsis: Jer 42:1-22 - --1 Johanan desires Jeremiah to enquire of God, promising obedience to his will.7 Jeremiah assures him of safety in Judea;13 and destruction in Egypt.19...
MHCC -> Jer 42:7-22
MHCC: Jer 42:7-22 - --If we would know the mind of the Lord in doubtful cases, we must wait as well as pray. God is ever ready to return in mercy to those he has afflicted;...
Matthew Henry -> Jer 42:7-22
Matthew Henry: Jer 42:7-22 - -- We have here the answer which Jeremiah was sent to deliver to those who employed him to ask counsel of God. I. It did not come immediately, not till...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Jer 42:17-22
Keil-Delitzsch: Jer 42:17-22 - --
ויהיוּ , used instead of the impersonal והיה , is referred to the following subject by a rather unusual kind of attraction; cf. Ewald, §...
Constable: Jer 2:1--45:5 - --II. Prophecies about Judah chs. 2--45
The first series of prophetic announcements, reflections, and incidents th...

Constable: Jer 34:1--45:5 - --D. Incidents surrounding the fall of Jerusalem chs. 34-45
The Book of Consolation contained messages of ...

Constable: Jer 40:1--45:5 - --3. Incidents after the fall of Jerusalem chs. 40-45
One of the important theological lessons of ...
