
Text -- Jeremiah 8:1-5 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: Jer 8:1 - -- This denotes the utter desolation of the city, not only rasing the walls, but turning up the very sepulchres which were accounted sacred, and not to b...
This denotes the utter desolation of the city, not only rasing the walls, but turning up the very sepulchres which were accounted sacred, and not to be violated.

Will they never think of rising again? Not return - Will he wander for ever?

Wesley: Jer 8:5 - -- Their false prophets, encouraging themselves in their wickedness, and pleasing themselves, that their miseries should not come upon them.
Their false prophets, encouraging themselves in their wickedness, and pleasing themselves, that their miseries should not come upon them.
JFB: Jer 8:2 - -- Retribution in kind. The very objects which received their idolatries shall unconcernedly witness their dishonor.
Retribution in kind. The very objects which received their idolatries shall unconcernedly witness their dishonor.

JFB: Jer 8:2 - -- Words are accumulated, as if enough could not be said fully to express the mad fervor of their idolatry to the heavenly host (2Ki 23:5).
Words are accumulated, as if enough could not be said fully to express the mad fervor of their idolatry to the heavenly host (2Ki 23:5).

JFB: Jer 8:3 - -- "in all places of them that remain, whither I . . . that is, in all places whither I have driven them that remain [MAURER].
"in all places of them that remain, whither I . . . that is, in all places whither I have driven them that remain [MAURER].

JFB: Jer 8:4 - -- "Is it not a natural instinct, that if one falls, he rises again; if one turns away (that is, wanders from the way), he will return to the point from ...

JFB: Jer 8:5 - -- Rather, as the Hebrew is the same as in Jer 8:4, to which this verse refers, "turned away with a perpetual turning away."
Rather, as the Hebrew is the same as in Jer 8:4, to which this verse refers, "turned away with a perpetual turning away."
Clarke: Jer 8:1 - -- They shall bring out the bones - This and the two following verses are a continuation of the preceding prophecy, and should not have been separated ...
They shall bring out the bones - This and the two following verses are a continuation of the preceding prophecy, and should not have been separated from the foregoing chapter
In order to pour the utmost contempt upon the land, the victorious enemies dragged out of their graves, caves, and sepulchers, the bones of kings, princes, prophets, priests, and the principal inhabitants, and exposed them in the open air; so that they became, in the order of God’ s judgments, a reproach to them in the vain confidence they had in the sun, moon, and the host of heaven - all the planets and stars, whose worship they had set up in opposition to that of Jehovah. This custom of raising the bodies of the dead, and scattering their bones about, seems to have been general. It was the highest expression of hatred and contempt. Horace refers to it: -
Barbarus, heu, cineres insistet victor, et urbe
Eques sonante verberabit ungula
Quaeque carent ventis et solibus ossa Quirin
(Nefas videre) dissipabit insolens
Epod. 16:11
"Barbarians fell shall wanton with success
Scatter the city’ s flaming ruins wide
Or through her streets in vengeful triumph ride
And her great founder’ s hallowed ashes spurn
That slept uninjured in the sacred urn.
Francis
See this judgment referred to, Baruch 2:24, 25.

Clarke: Jer 8:4 - -- Moreover thou shalt say - Dr. Blayney very properly observes, "In that part of the prophecy which follows next, the difference of speakers requires ...
Moreover thou shalt say - Dr. Blayney very properly observes, "In that part of the prophecy which follows next, the difference of speakers requires to be attended to; the transition being quick and sudden, but full of life and energy. The prophet at first, in the name of God, reproves the people’ s incorrigibility; he charges their wise ones with folly, and threatens them with grievous calamities, Jer 8:4-13. In the three next verses he seems to apostrophize his countrymen in his own person, and as one of the people that dwelt in the open towns, advising those that were in the like situation to retire with him into some of the fortified cities, and there wait the event with patience, since there was nothing but terror abroad, and the noise of the enemy, who had already begun to ravage the country, Jer 8:14-16. God speaks, Jer 8:17, and threatens to bring foes against them that should be irresistible. The prophet appears again in his own person, commiserating the daughter of his people, who is heard bewailing her forlorn case in a distant land; while the voice of God, like that of conscience, breaks in upon her complaints, and shows her that all this ruin is brought upon her by her own infidelities, Jer 8:18-20. The prophet once more resumes his discourse; he regrets that no remedy can be found to close up the wounds of his country, and pathetically weeps over the number of her slain, Jer 8:21, Jer 9:1.

Clarke: Jer 8:4 - -- Shall they fall, and not arise? shall he turn away, and not return? - That is, It is as possible for sinners to return from their sin to God, for hi...
Shall they fall, and not arise? shall he turn away, and not return? - That is, It is as possible for sinners to return from their sin to God, for his grace is ever at hand to assist, as it is for God, who is pouring out his judgments, to return to them on their return to him. But these held fast deceit, and refused to return; they would not be undeceived.
Calvin: Jer 8:1 - -- I Have said that Jeremiah repeats in the first verse what he had before said, — that the Jews would be deprived of their graves, in order that ther...
I Have said that Jeremiah repeats in the first verse what he had before said, — that the Jews would be deprived of their graves, in order that there might be on the dead a mark of God’s vengeance; as though he had said, that after having been destroyed by the hand of enemies, they would have their punishment extended farther by having their dead bodies exposed to the wild beasts and birds. The faithful, as I have said, suffer no loss, when burial is denied them; but yet they do not disregard burial, inasmuch as it is a badge of the resurrection. Though God suffers them to be involved in this disgrace with the reprobate, yet this does not hinder but that God should execute his vengeance on the wicked by such a temporal punishment as turns to a blessing to the faithful. It is therefore no unmeaning denunciation, when the Prophet says that the time was at hand, when their bones would be taken out of their graves.
He mentions the bones of kings, and of priests, and of prophets, and of the whole people The kings thought that as soon as they were hid in their graves, their dead bodies would be deemed sacred: the same notion prevailed as to rulers, priests, and prophets: but he says that no grave would be untouched or free from the outrage of enemies; and thus he shews, that the city would be rooted up from its foundations. Were the city to remain safe, the graves would be spared. Hence this punishment could not have been inflicted, without the very foundations of the city being dug up by the enemies. In short, he points out here a dreadful and final overthrow; and at the same time he shews the reason why God would manifest such severity towards the Jews.

Calvin: Jer 8:2 - -- It was, because they served the sun, and the moon, and the stars It was God’s just vengeance, that their bones should be taken from their graves,...
It was, because they served the sun, and the moon, and the stars It was God’s just vengeance, that their bones should be taken from their graves, in order that the sun and moon and all the stars might be witnesses of his judgment. By these words Jeremiah indirectly reprobates the senselessness of the people for thinking that they performed an acceptable service to the sun and moon. He therefore says, that all the stars and the planets would become as it were spectators of the vengeance which God would execute; as though he had said, that the whole celestial host would approve of that punishment; for nothing is more detestable to creatures, than when the glory of their Maker is ascribed to them. It is indeed true that the sun, moon, and stars are without sense or reason; but the Prophet here attributes reason to them, in order that he might shake off from the Jews that stupidity in which they hardened themselves, while they thought that they were rendering to the sun an acceptable service. At the same time he alludes, as it appears also from other places, to the punishment inflicted on adulterers: for when a harlot is drawn out and led forth in contempt and disgrace in the presence of her adulterers, it is deemed a most just punishment. And thus as the Jews had as it were committed adultery with the sun and the moon and the stars, so the Prophet says here, that their disgrace and baseness would be made manifest in the sight of the sun, and the moon, and the stars.
He says, which they have loved He no doubt alludes to the blind ardor by which idolaters were possessed, when they zealously pursued their illicit devotions; for it was a species of an unbridled and mad passion, as it appears from other places; for no fornicator burns with a more impetuous lust after a woman, than idolaters do, when Satan dazzles their eyes and fascinates their hearts. Of this impure love then does the Prophet now speak; and at the same time, he indirectly condemns the Jews for having alienated themselves without a cause from God, who was their legitimate husband. There is indeed nothing less tolerable than for men thus perfidiously to forsake God, when he has invited them to himself, and contracted as it were with them a holy and an inviolable marriage.
He afterwards adds, whom they have served This was still more base; they devoted themselves to the work of serving the sun, the moon, and the stars. He mentions in the third place, that they walked after them. God had shewn them the right way, and had commanded them to follow him: but they forsook God, says the Prophet, and followed the stars of heaven. He states in the fourth place, that they sought them. By this he refers to their perverseness. Some render the word “consulted,” of which I do not approve, for it is strained and far-fetched. 215 The Prophet, I doubt not, denotes here the persevering attention of the Jews to the objects of their worship; for they followed their idols not by a sudden and momentary impulse, but they resolutely devoted themselves to them and became as it were fixed in their wicked purpose. And he says in the last place, that they prostrated themselves before them. This was the way in which they served them. It is an evidence of reverence when men prostrate themselves before their idols; and thus they serve them, for it is an act of worship. The Prophet might indeed have sufficiently expressed in one sentence the impiety of the people; but he joins together several sentences for the sake of amplification, in order that he might render more evident the ingratitude of the people in seeking for themselves unknown gods, and in setting up false and fictitious modes of worship, rather than to render obedience to the only true God and to acquiesce in his law, which is a certain rule, and never leads any astray. 216
He afterwards adds, They shall not be gathered, nor be buried; for dung shall they be on the face or surface of the land He confirms what he had said of the punishment before mentioned, — that they had acted disdainfully towards God, and had prostrated themselves before their idols, so after death they would be made base and detestable, so that the mind would revolt at such a hateful sight. This is the meaning. It follows —

Calvin: Jer 8:3 - -- He intimates in this verse, that all survivors would be doubly miserable, as it would be better for them to die at once than to pine away in unceasin...
He intimates in this verse, that all survivors would be doubly miserable, as it would be better for them to die at once than to pine away in unceasing evils: for they who give another meaning to the words, seem not to understand the design of the Prophet. The import then of the passage is, — that however dreadful God’s judgment would be, when slaughters everywhere prevailed, and dead bodies were drawn out which had been previously buried, yet all this would be a slight punishment in comparison with what God would inflict on the rest, such as remained alive: and he also intimates that their life would be more miserable than death itself, yea, than ten deaths.
That those then who would escape death might not think that they gained any advantage, the Prophet says, Chosen shall be death before life by all the residue We hence learn how grievous was to be God’s vengeance; for nothing would be better or more desirable than to undergo death at once, as life would be nothing else but a continued languor and torment. Expected then will be death in all places in which there shall be survivors, where I shall drive them He mentions a reason for this twofold misery, — they would not be allowed to live in their own country, but would become aliens, — and they would find in their exile God’s hand against them, and as it were following them everywhere. 217

Calvin: Jer 8:4 - -- Though God had reminded his Prophet of the event, yet he still invites the Jews to repentance; not that there was any hope of restoring them to a rig...
Though God had reminded his Prophet of the event, yet he still invites the Jews to repentance; not that there was any hope of restoring them to a right mind, (for he had said that they were wholly irreclaimable,) but that their perverseness might be less excusable; and it was also his object to afford some relief to the small number of the godly who still remained; for they had not all fallen away into impiety, though the great body of the people had become corrupt. God then, partly to aggravate the sin of the ungodly, and partly to provide for his faithful people, exhorts those to repentance, who were yet wholly intractable. And here we ought to consider that God’s goodness, when abused, brings a much heavier judgment. God does here in a manner contend with the wickedness of his people, by setting before them the hope of pardon, if they repented.
Thou shalt then say to them; that is, “Though I have already testified to thee that thy labor would be in vain, yet thou shalt not give over thy work.” Shall they who have fallen rise again? This sentence is variously explained; the greater part of interpreters confine it to the Jews only, “Shall the Jews who have fallen rise again?” As to the second clause, some give this explanation, “If Israel returns, will not God also return?” that is, from his wrath, or, “Will he not be propitious?” Or, “If Israel turns away, will not God also turn away?” Others understand both parts of the sentence of the people, “If the people have once turned away, will they not yet return to God?” For the verb

Calvin: Jer 8:5 - -- Whoever will impartially consider the discourse of the Prophet must see that this is the real meaning; for, in the second of these verses, he says, ...
Whoever will impartially consider the discourse of the Prophet must see that this is the real meaning; for, in the second of these verses, he says, Why is this people of Jerusalem, etc. ; he now first speaks, as it clearly appears, of the people. It then follows that the former verse ought not to be applied to the people; but it contains only a general statement. In short, Jeremiah condemns here the madness of the people, because they followed not the example of those who have either fallen or deviated from the way by mistake. For it is what is naturally implanted in all, that they do not willingly perish in their misfortunes. He then who falls immediately strives to rise again; and he who leaves the right way, tries if possible to return to it again. This then is what the most foolish will do; why then, says Jeremiah, do not this people imitate such an example? He therefore shews by this comparison, that their conduct was monstrous; for they obstinately adhered to their vices, and never thought that there was a hope of reconciliation if they from the heart returned unto God. And he emphatically mentions Jerusalem; for had such obstinacy prevailed among the Chaldeans or the Egyptians, it would indeed have been inexcusable; but not so strange as among a people to whom the law had been given, and to whom God had plainly revealed the way of salvation. When, therefore, this people so hardened themselves as to reject all warnings, was it not monstrous? 218
Then he says, that they were rebellious with a pertinacious rebellion; that is, that they forsook God not only through levity or want of thought, or some sudden impulse, but so pertinaciously, that the prophets spent their labor in vain in teaching and exhorting them. Hence he calls it a strong rebellion, though the word may be taken here as in other places in the sense of perpetual And he assigns the cause, because they laid hold on deception, that is, they adhered fast to deception. But the Prophet means by deception, not that by which a neighbor is deceived or circumvented, but hypocrisy, by which men so blind themselves, that they are unwilling either to attend to God’s word, or to open their eyes to see the light. When, therefore, men through willful obstinacy bury themselves in darkness, they may be said to lay fast hold on deception 219
David says, in Psa 32:2, that the man is blessed in whose spirit there is no guile: he entertains no guile, as we commonly do. Now, to entertain guile is to possess a deceitful heart. He had before said that they are blessed whose sins are forgiven and to whom iniquity is not imputed: he adds by way of explanation, provided there be no guile in the spirit; and why? Because wicked men seem to themselves to be blessed, for they perceive not their own misery, because they are enveloped in their own coverings: and this is the guile of which David speaks. According to the same meaning, our Prophet says, that those laid fast hold on deception, who were so involved in darkness or so blinded by their lusts, as to seek to deceive God; but they deceive themselves. This then is the cause why those whom God corrects and chastises feel no penitence; for they are willfully blind, they close their eyes and deafen their ears, and seek to be deceived by the devil; they attend not to the holy warnings given them for their salvation. If then, we wish to be healed of our vices, let us ever begin in this way, — let us carefully examine our thoughts and our motives, and not please ourselves nor deceive ourselves by empty flatteries, but strive to shake off whatever is reprehensible and vicious. The very beginning of true repentance is to renounce all deceptions and fallacies and to seek the light, which can alone discover to us our evils. It afterwards follows —
TSK: Jer 8:1 - -- Jer 7:32-34; 1Ki 13:2; 2Ki 23:16, 2Ki 23:20; 2Ch 34:4, 2Ch 34:5; Eze 6:5, Eze 37:1; Amo 2:1

TSK: Jer 8:2 - -- and all : Jer 19:13, Jer 44:17-19; Deu 4:19, Deu 17:3; 2Ki 17:16, 2Ki 21:3, 2Ki 21:5, 2Ki 23:5; 2Ch 33:3-5; Eze 8:16; Zep 1:5; Act 7:42
they shall be ...

TSK: Jer 8:3 - -- death : Jer 20:14-18; 1Ki 19:4; Job 3:20-22, Job 7:15, Job 7:16; Jon 4:3; Rev 6:16, Rev 9:6
in all : Jer 23:3, Jer 23:8, Jer 29:14, Jer 29:28, Jer 32:...

TSK: Jer 8:4 - -- Moreover : Blayney justly observes, that the change of speakers here requires to be carefully attended to. The prophet first, in the name of God, rep...
Moreover : Blayney justly observes, that the change of speakers here requires to be carefully attended to. The prophet first, in the name of God, reproves the people, and threatens them with grievous calamities, Jer 8:4-13. Then, apostrophising his countrymen, he advises them to retire with him to some fortified city, Jer 8:14-16. God then threatens to bring foes against them, that are irresistible, Jer 8:17. The prophet next commiserates the daughter of his people, who is heard bewailing her forlorn case; whilst the voice of God breaks in upon her complaints, and shows that all this ruin is brought upon her by her infidelities, Jer 8:18-20. The prophet regrets that her wounds had not been healed, and laments over her slain, Jer 8:21; Jer 9:1.
Shall they : Pro 24:16; Hos 14:1; Amo 5:2; Mic 7:8
turn : Jer 3:1, Jer 3:22, Jer 4:1, Jer 23:14, Jer 36:3; 1Ki 8:38; Isa 44:22, Isa 55:7; Eze 18:23; Hos 6:1, Hos 7:10

TSK: Jer 8:5 - -- slidden : Jer 2:32, Jer 3:11-14, Jer 7:24-26; Hos 4:16, Hos 11:7
they hold : Jer 9:6; Pro 4:13; Isa 30:10, Isa 44:20; 1Th 5:21; 2Th 2:9-12; Rev 2:25
t...

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes: Jer 8:1 - -- Not the living only but the dead shall be exposed to the ruthless violence of the enemy, who will ransack the graves of the wealthier classes.
Not the living only but the dead shall be exposed to the ruthless violence of the enemy, who will ransack the graves of the wealthier classes.

Barnes: Jer 8:2 - -- Loved ... served ... walked ... sought ... worshipped - There is great force in the piled-up verbs by which their worship of the heavenly bodie...
Loved ... served ... walked ... sought ... worshipped - There is great force in the piled-up verbs by which their worship of the heavenly bodies is described. The prophet beginning with the heart’ s "love"describes that worship) in the various stages of its development, and then contrasts its fulness with the miserable reward which ensues.

Barnes: Jer 8:3 - -- This evil family - The whole Jewish race. Which remain - The words are omitted by the Septuagint and Syriac versions.
This evil family - The whole Jewish race.
Which remain - The words are omitted by the Septuagint and Syriac versions.

Barnes: Jer 8:4 - -- The prophet here resumes from Jer 7:28 the main subject of his prophecy. He again invites the Jews to repentance. Shall they fall? - The argum...
The prophet here resumes from Jer 7:28 the main subject of his prophecy. He again invites the Jews to repentance.
Shall they fall? - The argument is that when men fall, they do not lie upon the ground, but endeavor to get up again: and when a man loses his way, he does not persist in going on, but turns round, and retraces his steps. Israel then will be only following the dictates of comnon sense in desisting from that which she now knows to be her ruin.

Barnes: Jer 8:5 - -- When men act as in Jer 8:4, why is God’ s own people alone an exception? Slidden back ... backsliding - The same words as "turn"and "retu...
When men act as in Jer 8:4, why is God’ s own people alone an exception?
Slidden back ... backsliding - The same words as "turn"and "return"in Jer 8:4. They should be rendered, "Why doth this people of Jerusalem turn away with a perpetual turning?"
Deceit - i. e., idolatry; because men worship in it that which is false, and it is false to the worshippers.
Refuse - From a feeling of dislike.
Poole: Jer 8:1 - -- They shall bring out the bones of the nobles and princes as Manasseh and others, possibly led to it out of greediness, supposing to find great treasu...
They shall bring out the bones of the nobles and princes as Manasseh and others, possibly led to it out of greediness, supposing to find great treasure in their sepulchres; of the
priests and prophets principally the false ones, as a just judgment of God against them for deceiving the people; of the
inhabitants of Jerusalem out of their spite and fury kindled against them, as soldiers, or in contempt and ignominy: and this notes the utter desolation of the city, not only razing the walls, but turning up the very sepulchres, which were accounted sacred, and not to be violated.

Poole: Jer 8:2 - -- They shall spread them before the sun not gather them together into charnel-houses, as we usually do out of humanity, but scatter them about as it we...
They shall spread them before the sun not gather them together into charnel-houses, as we usually do out of humanity, but scatter them about as it were to be turned into dust and dung.
And the moon, and all the host of heaven viz. all the rest of the stars, to show that they should not lie out in the day time only, but night also, before the moon and stars, Jer 36:30 . Their carcasses shall be cast to their idols, Lev 26:30 2Ki 23:14,20 ; a kind of lex talionis , that as they had served and worshipped these creatures, God doth, as it were, appoint them as spectators and witnesses of his vengeance, and what contempt he pours upon them, their carcasses being brought before their idols, which will be so shameful, as if one should draw forth the adulteress with the adulterer into open view, and expose them together; and it also insinuates the inability that is in these dumb idols to help them in their misery.
Whom they have loved: this and the following term serve to express the greatness and variety of their affection and zeal in their worshipping of them, Deu 4:19 2Ki 23:5 Jer 7:18 : he multiplies words, as it were implying that there can hardly be words enough to express their folly and madness, the Gentiles worshipping these creatures, not only for their beauty and lustre, but, according to their ancient philosophy, apprehending them to have been living creatures, and that all events were ordered by them.
They shall be for dung upon the face of the earth on the superficies of it; there shall be no care taken of them, but they shall lie in the open country in the air, till they rot into dung, or dry into dust, as in the beginning of the verse; see Psa 83:10 Jer 9:22 ; they shall be ignominious even after death.

Poole: Jer 8:3 - -- And death shall be chosen rather than life a description of the unexpressibleness of their misery, that notwithstanding all the barbarism of the Baby...
And death shall be chosen rather than life a description of the unexpressibleness of their misery, that notwithstanding all the barbarism of the Babylonians exercised both upon the bring and the dead, yet a small matter in comparison of what the living would feel, of the greatness of which misery there was a double cause; not only their being led into captivity, but God’ s displeasure following them, even in their banishment, being sorely oppressed; one of those threatenings Lev 26:36,39 : see Job 3:20,21 Re 9:6 . Which remain in all the places whither I have driven them; some dispersed among the mountains and hiding-places of Judea, others in the desert of Moab and Idumea, whither they fled for fear of the Chaldeans, and all other places where God would scatter them; an hypallage.
The Lord of hosts he that hath all the creatures as an army at his command, can do this against those with whom he is displeased.

Poole: Jer 8:4 - -- Moreover thou shalt say unto them though possibly it be all in vain, yet thou shalt keep in thy work.
Shall they fall, and not arise? an interrogat...
Moreover thou shalt say unto them though possibly it be all in vain, yet thou shalt keep in thy work.
Shall they fall, and not arise? an interrogation that hath the force of a negative, i.e. surely none. Or, Will men, is there no hope? And are they upon this ground desperate? Or rather, Will men fall, and not arise? Are they such fools, that having fallen by their sins, and been foretold all that is coming, that they will not accept of a remedy? Jer 7:27 Hos 14:1 .
Shall he turn away, and not return? a metaphor taken from one that is out of his way; can any imagine that if one tell him of it, and direct him aright, that he will not hearken to him, and turn back? It is even against nature itself for a man not to seek his own good.

Poole: Jer 8:5 - -- By a perpetual backsliding: either a universal backsliding; or rather, obstinately resolved to hold on, though they see they are out of the way; not ...
By a perpetual backsliding: either a universal backsliding; or rather, obstinately resolved to hold on, though they see they are out of the way; not out of levity or inconsiderateness. The Hebrew word signifies strength , the same used Psa 13:1 , and translated for ever , implying a strong, stiff, stout refusal. See Isa 57:17 Jer 5:3 . Deceit : either their injustice and cozenages in circumventing one another, which was so frequent among them, Jer 9:4-6 Mic 7:3,4 ; or their hypocrisy, whereby they thought to deceive God, but they did indeed deceive themselves; the great impediment of their repentance, Isa 44:20 ; or rather, their sticking close to their false prophets, who did deceive them, thence encouraging themselves in their wickedness, and pleasing themselves that their miseries should not come upon them. See Poole "Isa 30:10" ; See Poole "Jer v. 31" ; See Poole "Jer 14:13" , &c.
Haydock: Jer 8:1 - -- Graves. They might suppose that they would find treasures in them, as the tombs of Semiramis, Cyrus, &c., were thus enriched. This inhumanity seems...
Graves. They might suppose that they would find treasures in them, as the tombs of Semiramis, Cyrus, &c., were thus enriched. This inhumanity seems to have taken place before the last siege, Baruch ii. 24. (Calmet) Quזque carent ventis et solibus ossa Quirini
Nefas videre dissipabit insoleas. ----- (Horace, epod. 16.)
--- Cruelty and avarice cause persecutors to act thus. (Worthington)

Again. Why then do not the people strive to repent?
Gill: Jer 8:1 - -- At that time, saith the Lord, they shall bring out the bones of the kings of Judah,.... That is, either the Chaldeans or the Romans would do this; for...
At that time, saith the Lord, they shall bring out the bones of the kings of Judah,.... That is, either the Chaldeans or the Romans would do this; for this refers to the destruction of Jerusalem, either by the former or the latter; and it is certain that Jerusalem was ploughed up by the Romans, whereby the prophecy in Mic 3:12 was accomplished; when it is highly probable the graves were dug up, and the bones of the dead brought out, and scattered abroad by way of revenge; or it may be that graves were opened, especially the graves of kings and great men, for the sake of finding treasure in them: it follows,
and the bones of his princes; of the princes of Judah:
and the bones of the priests; that sacrificed to idols:
and the bones of the prophets: the false prophets; though this might be the case of the priests and prophets of the Lord; whose bones, in this general devastation, might be exposed as well as others; which of all might be thought to be the most sacred: and the bones of the inhabitants of Jerusalem out of their graves; high and low, rich and poor, male and female; their graves, in common, were without the city.

Gill: Jer 8:2 - -- And they shall spread them before the sun and the moon, and all the host of heaven,.... The stars. This shows, not only that they should be publicly e...
And they shall spread them before the sun and the moon, and all the host of heaven,.... The stars. This shows, not only that they should be publicly exposed; but, as it refers to their idolatrous worship of the sun, moon, and stars, that these deities will not be able to help them; as they could not prevent their dead bodies being dug up, so neither could they order or cause them to be gathered together, and buried again:
whom they have loved; whereas they ought to have loved the Lord their God, and him only: it means an idolatrous love of and affection for them; and not the love of them, as creatures for use and delight; otherwise the light of the sun, moon, and stars, is sweet, and their influence great; and a pleasant thing it is to behold them, and especially the former of them, the fountain of light and heat: and whom they have served; more and besides the Creator of them, whom they should have served, the Lord of hosts, and him only:
and after whom they have walked; not in a natural and literal sense, but in a religious one, as is after explained:
and whom they have sought; for advice and counsel, and by making their prayers and supplications to them:
and whom they have worshipped; by bowing the knee, or kissing the hand; by offering sacrifices, and burning incense, and putting up petitions to them; by trusting in them, and expecting good things from them; see 2Ki 21:3,
they shall not be gathered, nor be buried: meaning not the men that should die in those times, but the bones that should be brought out of the graves; these, having been scattered about, should not be collected together again, and replaced in their sepulchres:
they shall be for dung upon the face of the earth; that is, they should lie and rot upon the face of the earth, and crumble into dust, and become dung for it; see Psa 83:10.

Gill: Jer 8:3 - -- And death shall be chosen rather than life,.... By them that should be alive in those times, who would be carried captive into other lands, and be use...
And death shall be chosen rather than life,.... By them that should be alive in those times, who would be carried captive into other lands, and be used very hardly, and suffer greatly, by the nations among whom they should dwell; see Rev 9:6. The Septuagint version, and those that follow it, make this to be a reason of the former, reading the words thus, "because they have chosen death rather than life"; see Deu 30:19, but the other sense is best, which is confirmed by what follows:
by all the residue of them that remain of this evil family; the nation of the Jews, become very corrupt and degenerate; so the people of Israel are called the whole family of Israel, Amo 3:1, now it is foretold, that those which remained of that people, who died not by famine, or were not slain by the sword, yet should be in such a miserable condition, as that death would be more eligible to them than life:
even which remain in all the places whither I have driven them, saith the Lord of hosts: for, though they were carried captive by men, yet the thing was of the Lord, and a just punishment upon them for their sins.

Gill: Jer 8:4 - -- Moreover, thou shalt say unto them,.... The Jews, in Jeremiah's time, in order to leave them inexcusable, though the Lord had before assured that they...
Moreover, thou shalt say unto them,.... The Jews, in Jeremiah's time, in order to leave them inexcusable, though the Lord had before assured that they would not hearken to him, Jer 7:27,
thus saith the Lord, shall they fall, and not rise? men, when they fall, endeavour to get up again, and generally they do:
shall he turn away, and not return? when a man turns out of the right way into a wrong one, as soon as he is sensible of his mistake, he returns back; this is usually done among men. This is generally the case in a natural sense, and might be expected in a moral sense; that whereas these people had fallen into sin, they would rise again by repentance; and, having turned from the good ways of God, would soon return again to them.

Gill: Jer 8:5 - -- Why then is this people of Jerusalem slidden back by a perpetual backsliding?.... These people fill into sin, and rise not again by repentance; they t...
Why then is this people of Jerusalem slidden back by a perpetual backsliding?.... These people fill into sin, and rise not again by repentance; they turn out of the good ways of God and religion, and return not again; they backslide and revolt from the Lord, and they continue in their revolt and rebellion; their backsliding is an everlasting one; there is no hope of their repentance and recovery: it is a vehement and passionate expostulation about the people of the Jews, founded upon the former general observation, showing them to be the worst of all people: it is a common saying, "it is a long lane that has no turning"; but these people, having departed from the Lord, return no more. A very learned man renders the words, "why does Jerusalem turn away this people with an obstinate aversion?" b that is, the rulers and governors of Jerusalem, as in Mat 23:37 or rather thus, "why does a stubborn aversion turn away this people, O Jerusalem?" and so they are an address to the magistrates and inhabitants of Jerusalem.
They hold fast deceit; practise it, and continue in the practice of it, both with God and man:
they refuse to return: to the Lord, to his worship, and to the right ways of holiness and truth, from whence they had erred; see Jer 5:3.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes



NET Notes: Jer 8:4 There is a play on two different nuances of the same Hebrew word that means “turn” and “return,” “turn away” and &...

NET Notes: Jer 8:5 There is a continuing play on the same root word used in the preceding verse. Here the words “turn away from me,” “apostasy,” ...
Geneva Bible: Jer 8:1 At that time, saith the LORD, they shall bring the bones of the kings of Judah, and the bones of his princes, and the bones of the priests, and the bo...

Geneva Bible: Jer 8:3 And death shall be chosen ( b ) rather than life by all the remnant of them that remain of this evil family, who remain in all the places where I have...

Geneva Bible: Jer 8:4 Moreover thou shalt say to them, Thus saith the LORD; Shall they ( c ) fall, and not rise? shall he turn away, and not return?
( c ) Is there no hope...

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Jer 8:1-22
TSK Synopsis: Jer 8:1-22 - --1 The calamity of the Jews, both dead and alive.4 He upbraids their foolish and shameless impenitency.13 He shews their grievous judgment;18 and bewai...
MHCC -> Jer 8:1-3; Jer 8:4-13
MHCC: Jer 8:1-3 - --Though no real hurt can be done to a dead body, yet disgrace to the remains of wicked persons may alarm those yet alive; and this reminds us that the ...

MHCC: Jer 8:4-13 - --What brought this ruin? 1. The people would not attend to reason; they would not act in the affairs of their souls with common prudence. Sin is backsl...
Matthew Henry -> Jer 8:1-3; Jer 8:4-12
Matthew Henry: Jer 8:1-3 - -- These verses might fitly have been joined to the close of the foregoing chapter, as giving a further description of the dreadful desolation which th...

Matthew Henry: Jer 8:4-12 - -- The prophet here is instructed to set before this people the folly of their impenitence, which was it that brought this ruin upon them. They are her...
Keil-Delitzsch: Jer 8:1-2 - --
But even then the judgment has not come to a height. Even sinners long dead must yet bear the shame of their sins. "At that time" points back to "da...

Keil-Delitzsch: Jer 8:3 - --
Not less dreadful will be the fate of those who remain in life; so appalling that they will prefer death to life, since every kind of hardship in ex...

Keil-Delitzsch: Jer 8:4-7 - --
The People's Obstinacy in Wickedness, and the Dreadfulness of the Judgment. - Since the people cleaves stedfastly to its sin (Jer 8:4-13), the Lord ...
Constable -> Jer 2:1--45:5; Jer 2:1--25:38; Jer 7:1--10:25; Jer 7:1--8:4; Jer 8:1-3; Jer 8:4--11:1; Jer 8:4-12
Constable: Jer 2:1--45:5 - --II. Prophecies about Judah chs. 2--45
The first series of prophetic announcements, reflections, and incidents th...

Constable: Jer 2:1--25:38 - --A. Warnings of judgment on Judah and Jerusalem chs. 2-25
Chapters 2-25 contain warnings and appeals to t...

Constable: Jer 7:1--10:25 - --2. Warnings about apostasy and its consequences chs. 7-10
This is another collection of Jeremiah...

Constable: Jer 7:1--8:4 - --Aspects of false religion 7:1-8:3
All the messages in this section deal with departure f...

Constable: Jer 8:1-3 - --Astral worship 8:1-3
"The sermon ends (if these verses, still in prose, should be taken with ch. 7) on a note which takes away the last shreds of comf...

Constable: Jer 8:4--11:1 - --Incorrigible Judah 8:4-10:25
The twin themes of Judah's stubborn rebellion and her inevi...
