
Text -- Job 31:38 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley -> Job 31:38
Because I have gotten it by fraud or violence.
JFB: Job 31:38 - -- Personification. The complaints of the unjustly ousted proprietors are transferred to the lands themselves (Job 31:20; Gen 4:10; Hab 2:11). If I have ...

JFB: Job 31:38 - -- The specification of these makes it likely, he implies in this, "If I paid not the laborer for tillage"; as Job 31:39, "If I paid him not for gatherin...
The specification of these makes it likely, he implies in this, "If I paid not the laborer for tillage"; as Job 31:39, "If I paid him not for gathering in the fruits." Thus of the four clauses in Job 31:38-39, the first refers to the same subject as the fourth, the second is connected with the third by introverted parallelism. Compare Jam 5:4, which plainly alludes to this passage: compare "Lord of Sabaoth" with Job 31:26 here.
Clarke -> Job 31:38
Clarke: Job 31:38 - -- If my land cry - The most careless reader may see that the introduction of this and the two following verses here, disturbs the connection, and that...
If my land cry - The most careless reader may see that the introduction of this and the two following verses here, disturbs the connection, and that they are most evidently out of their place. Job seems here to refer to that law, Lev 25:1-7, by which the Israelites were obliged to give the land rest every seventh year, that the soil might not be too much exhausted by perpetual cultivation, especially in a country which afforded so few advantages to improve the arable ground by manure. He, conscious that he had acted according to this law, states that his land could not cry out against him, nor its furrows complain. He had not broken the law, nor exhausted the soil.
TSK -> Job 31:38

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Job 31:38
Barnes: Job 31:38 - -- If my land cry against me - This is a new specification of an offence, and an imprecation of an appropriate punishment if he had been guilty of...
If my land cry against me - This is a new specification of an offence, and an imprecation of an appropriate punishment if he had been guilty of it. Many have supposed that these closing verses have been transferred from their appropriate place by an error of transcribers, and that they should have been inserted between Job 31:23-24 - or in some previous part of the chapter. It is certain that Job 31:35-37 would make an appropriate and impressive close of the chapter, being a solemn appeal to God in reference to all the specifications, or to the general tenor of his life; but there is no authority from the MSS. to make any change in the present arrangement. All the ancient versions insert the verses in the place which they now occupy, and in this all versions agree, except, according to Kennicott, the Teutonic version, where they are inserted after Job 31:25. All the MSS. also concur in the present arrangement.
Schultens supposes that there is manifest pertinency and propriety in the present arrangement. The former specification, says he, related mainly to his private life, this to his more public conduct; and the design is to vindicate himself from the charge of injustice and crime in both respects, closing appropriately with the latter. Rosenmuller remarks that in a composition composed in an age and country so remote as this, we are not to look for or demand the observance of the same regularity which is required by the modern canons of criticism. At all events, there is no authority for changing the present arrangement of the text. The meaning of the phrase "if my land cry out against me"is, that in the cultivation of his land he had not been guilty of injustice. He had not employed those to till it who had been compelled to do it, nor had he imposed on them unreasonable burdens, nor had he defrauded them of their wages. The land had not had occasion to cry out against him to God, because fraud or injustice had been done to any in its cultivation; compare Gen 4:10; Hab. ii. 11.
Or that the furrows likewise thereof complain - Margin, weep. The Hebrew is, "If the furrows weep together,"or "in like manner weep."This is a beautiful image. The very furrows in the field are personified as weeping on account of injustice which would be done them, and of the burdens which would be laid on them, if they were compelled to contribute to oppression and fraud.
Poole -> Job 31:38
Poole: Job 31:38 - -- To wit, to God for revenge, as the like phrase is used, Gen 4:10 Hab 2:11 , because I have gotten it from the right owners by fraud or violence, as ...
Haydock -> Job 31:38
Mourn, as if I possessed the land unjustly, or had committed some crime.
Gill -> Job 31:38
Gill: Job 31:38 - -- If my land cry against me,.... Some think that this verse and Job 31:39 stand out of their place, and should rather follow after Job 31:34; and some p...
If my land cry against me,.... Some think that this verse and Job 31:39 stand out of their place, and should rather follow after Job 31:34; and some place them after Job 31:25; and others after Job 31:8; but this is the order of them in all copies and versions, as they stand in our Bibles; and here, after Job had expressed his desire to have a hearer and judge of his cause, and his charge exhibited in writing, and his confidence of the issue of it, should it be granted, returns to his former subject, to clear himself from any notorious vice he was suspected of or charged with; and as he had gone through what might respect him in private life, here he gives another instance in public life, with which he concludes; namely, purging himself from tyranny and oppression, with which his friends had charged him without any proof; and he denies that the land he lived on was possessed of, and of which he was the proprietor, cried against him as being unjustly gotten, either by fraud or by force, from others; or as being ill used by him either as being too much cultivated, having never any rest, or lying fallow; and so much weakened and drained of its strength, or neglected and overrun with weeds, thorns, and thistles; or on account of the dressers and tillers of it being badly dealt with, either overworked, or not having sufficiency of food, or their wages, detained from them; all which are crying sins, and by reason of which the land by a figure may be said to cry out as the stone out of the wall, and the beam out of the timber, because of the sins of spoil, violence, oppression, and covetousness, Hab 2:11;
or that the furrows likewise thereof complain; or "weep" a, on account of the like ill usage. Jarchi, and so the Midrash, interpret this of not allowing the forgotten sheaf and corner of the field to the poor, and detaining the tithes; and of ploughing and making furrows with an ox and an ass together; but the laws respecting these things were not yet in being; and if they had been, were only binding on Israelites, and not on Job, and the men of his country.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes: Job 31:38 Some commentators have suggested that the meaning behind this is that Job might not have kept the year of release (Deut 15:1), and the law against mix...
Geneva Bible -> Job 31:38
Geneva Bible: Job 31:38 If my land ( d ) cry against me, or that the furrows likewise thereof complain;
( d ) As though I had withheld their wages that laboured in it.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Job 31:1-40
MHCC -> Job 31:33-40
MHCC: Job 31:33-40 - --Job clears himself from the charge of hypocrisy. We are loth to confess our faults, willing to excuse them, and to lay the blame upon others. But he t...
Matthew Henry -> Job 31:33-40
Matthew Henry: Job 31:33-40 - -- We have here Job's protestation against three more sins, together with his general appeal to God's bar and his petition for a hearing there, which, ...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Job 31:38-40
Keil-Delitzsch: Job 31:38-40 - --
38 If my field cry out against me,
And all together its furrows weep;
39 If I have devoured its strength without payment,
And caused the soul of ...
Constable -> Job 29:1--31:40; Job 31:1-40
Constable: Job 29:1--31:40 - --2. Job's defense of his innocence ch. 29-31
Job gave a soliloquy before his dialogue with his th...
