![](images/minus.gif)
Text -- Joshua 16:7-10 (NET)
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/information.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: Jos 16:7 - -- Not to the city of Jericho, which belonged to Benjamin's lot, Jos 18:21, but to its territory.
Not to the city of Jericho, which belonged to Benjamin's lot, Jos 18:21, but to its territory.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: Jos 16:9 - -- That is, besides those cities which were within Ephraim's bounds, he had some other cities, to which all of all their territories were annexed out Man...
That is, besides those cities which were within Ephraim's bounds, he had some other cities, to which all of all their territories were annexed out Manasseh's portion, because his tribe was all here, and was larger than Manasseh's.
JFB: Jos 16:5-9 - -- Ataroth-addar (now Atara), four miles south of Jetta [ROBINSON], is fixed on as a center, through which a line is drawn from Upper Beth-horon to Michm...
Ataroth-addar (now Atara), four miles south of Jetta [ROBINSON], is fixed on as a center, through which a line is drawn from Upper Beth-horon to Michmethah, showing the western limit of their actual possessions. The tract beyond that to the sea was still unconquered.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
The northern boundary is traced from this point eastward to the Jordan.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: Jos 16:8 - -- It is retraced from east to west, to describe the prospective and intended boundary, which was to reach to the sea. Kanah ("reedy") flows into the Med...
It is retraced from east to west, to describe the prospective and intended boundary, which was to reach to the sea. Kanah ("reedy") flows into the Mediterranean.
Clarke: Jos 16:8 - -- Tappuah - This was a city in the tribe of Manasseh, and gave name to a certain district called the land of Tappuah. See Jos 17:8
Tappuah - This was a city in the tribe of Manasseh, and gave name to a certain district called the land of Tappuah. See Jos 17:8
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
The sea - The Mediterranean, as before.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Jos 16:9 - -- And the separate cities - That is, the cities that were separated from the tribe of Manasseh to be given to Ephraim; see Jos 17:9.
And the separate cities - That is, the cities that were separated from the tribe of Manasseh to be given to Ephraim; see Jos 17:9.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: Jos 16:10 - -- The Canaanites that dwelt in Gezer - It appears that the Canaanites were not expelled from this city till the days of Solomon, when it was taken by ...
The Canaanites that dwelt in Gezer - It appears that the Canaanites were not expelled from this city till the days of Solomon, when it was taken by the king of Egypt his father-in-law, who made it a present to his daughter, Solomon’ s queen. See 1Ki 9:16. And see the note on Jos 10:33. The Ephraimites, however, had so far succeeded in subjecting these people as to oblige them to pay tribute, though they could not, or at least did not, totally expel them
Of the names and places in this chapter, we may say the same as of others already mentioned. See the note on Jos 15:1. Many of those towns were small, and, we may rationally conclude, slightly built, and consequently have perished perhaps more than a thousand years ago. It would be therefore useless to look for such places now. Several of the towns in England, a land not exposed to such revolutions as that of Palestine has ever been, mentioned by Caesar and other ancient writers, are no longer discernible. Several have changed their names, and not a few their situation. Tradition states that the city of Norwich anciently stood some miles from its present situation; and we have the fullest proof that this was the case with the city of Salisbury. Such changes do not affect the truth of the ancient geography of our own country; nor can they impeach that of the sacred historian before us.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
TSK: Jos 16:8 - -- Tappuah : Jos 12:17, Jos 17:8
river Kanah : Jos 17:9, Jos 19:28
the sea : Jos 16:3-6; Num 34:6
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Jos 16:5-8; Jos 16:9
Barnes: Jos 16:5-8 - -- From the abrupt manner in which the statements are introduced, as well as from their imperfect character, there is probability in the conjecture tha...
From the abrupt manner in which the statements are introduced, as well as from their imperfect character, there is probability in the conjecture that some words have, in these verses, fallen out of the text. Few of the places are known for certain.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Barnes: Jos 16:9 - -- The verb "were,"introduced by the King James Version in this verse should be omitted; and the full stop after Jos 16:8 replaced by a colon. The purp...
The verb "were,"introduced by the King James Version in this verse should be omitted; and the full stop after Jos 16:8 replaced by a colon. The purport of Jos 16:9 is simply to add to the inheritance of Ephraim, defined by the preceding context, "the separate cities"or more properly "single cities"which were allotted to them in addition within the borders of Manasseh. The reasons for granting these additional cities to the Ephraimites can only be conjectured. Perhaps the territory assigned to this numerous tribe proved on experiment to be too small; and therefore some towns, which are named in 1Ch 7:29, were given to them from the kindred Manassites, the latter being recompensed (Jos 17:11 note) at the expense of Issachar and Asher.
Poole: Jos 16:7 - -- Not to the city of Jericho, which belonged to Benjamin’ s lot, Jos 18:21 , but to its territory.
Not to the city of Jericho, which belonged to Benjamin’ s lot, Jos 18:21 , but to its territory.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: Jos 16:9 - -- The separate cities i.e. besides those cities which were within Ephraim’ s bounds, he had some other cities, to which all their territories were...
The separate cities i.e. besides those cities which were within Ephraim’ s bounds, he had some other cities, to which all their territories were annexed out of Manasseh’ s portion, because his tribe was all here, and was larger than Manasseh’ s.
Haydock: Jos 16:8 - -- Reeds. Septuagint, "of Cana." The vale belonged to Manasses, but the cities were ceded to Ephraim, ver. 9., chap. xvii. 19. The limits of these tw...
Reeds. Septuagint, "of Cana." The vale belonged to Manasses, but the cities were ceded to Ephraim, ver. 9., chap. xvii. 19. The limits of these two tribes are very confused. (Calmet) ---
Most salt. This is the title generally applied to the lake of Sodom. But here the Mediterranean is meant, which, compared with many of the seas of Palestine, is certainly most salt. (Menochius) ---
The epithet is not, however, found in Hebrew or Septuagint (Calmet) and Serarius thinks it has crept in here by mistake. (Menochius)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Haydock: Jos 16:10 - -- Gazer. It is not certain when the Ephraimites rendered this city tributary, or when it threw off the yoke. The king of Egypt afterwards conquered i...
Gazer. It is not certain when the Ephraimites rendered this city tributary, or when it threw off the yoke. The king of Egypt afterwards conquered it, and gave it with his daughter to Solomon, chap. x. 33. (Calmet) See Judges i. 29. ---
The negligence of Ephraim was contrary to God's order, Exodus xx. (Menochius) ---
The Alexandrian Septuagint here inserts after day, "till Pharao, king of Egypt, went up and took the city, and burnt it with fire, and the Chanaanites and Pherezites, and the inhabitants of Gazer, he slew; and Pharao gave it as a dowry to his daughter." Grabe adds what seems deficient, "and they became tributary slaves." (Haydock)
Gill: Jos 16:7 - -- And it went down from Johanan to Ataroth,.... This is different from Ataroth before mentioned, Jos 16:2; there were several places of this name, as be...
And it went down from Johanan to Ataroth,.... This is different from Ataroth before mentioned, Jos 16:2; there were several places of this name, as before observed; this seems to be that which Jerom places four miles from Sebaste or Samaria; see Gill on Jos 16:2,
and to Naarath; Jerom g says, that Naarath was in his time called Naorath, a village of the Jews, five miles from Jericho; and is the village Josephus h calls Neara, where was a water, half of which Archelaus turned, and led to the field planted with palm trees, near Jericho; and, according to the Jewish writers i: there was a place called Noaran near to Jericho, which seems to be this:
and came to Jericho, and went out at Jordan; where it ended this way, which was eastward.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Jos 16:8 - -- The border went out from Tappuah westward,.... Which was different from the Tappuah in the tribe of Judah, Jos 15:34; this was in the tribe of Ephraim...
The border went out from Tappuah westward,.... Which was different from the Tappuah in the tribe of Judah, Jos 15:34; this was in the tribe of Ephraim on the border of Manasseh, Jos 17:8,
unto the river Kanah; supposed by some to be the brook Cherith, by which Elijah hid himself, 1Ki 17:3; though objected to by others; it seems to have had its name from the reeds which grew in it, or on the banks of it:
and the goings out thereof were at the sea; if the river Kanah was the brook Cherith, this must be the dead or salt sea: but that is never called "the sea", rather the Mediterranean sea is meant, and consequently Kanah could not be Cherith, which was at too great a distance from this sea:
this is the inheritance of the tribe of the children of Ephraim by their families; that is, this is the description of the border of it; for the cities within are not mentioned, and the descriptions in general are very obscure.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Jos 16:9 - -- And the separate cities for the children of Ephraim,.... The tribe of Ephraim, being much larger than the half tribe of Manasseh, besides the lot that...
And the separate cities for the children of Ephraim,.... The tribe of Ephraim, being much larger than the half tribe of Manasseh, besides the lot that fell to it, described before by its boundaries, had several particular and distinct cities given to it: which
were among the inheritance of the children of Manasseh; some that were upon the borders of Ephraim, and within the territory of Manasseh, and it may be where it jetted out in a nook or corner, see Jos 17:8,
all the cities with their villages; not the separate cities only, but the little towns adjacent to them.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: Jos 16:10 - -- And they drove not out the Canaanites which dwelt in Gezer,.... Which was the border of their tribe length ways, and was near the sea, Jos 16:3; in th...
And they drove not out the Canaanites which dwelt in Gezer,.... Which was the border of their tribe length ways, and was near the sea, Jos 16:3; in this they did not obey the command of God, and either they did not drive them out, because they could not, God not delivering them up into their hands, because of their sins; or through their slothfulness, or it may be through covetousness, being willing to make some advantage to themselves by them, being a trading people, which seems to be intended in the next clause:
but the Canaanites dwelt among the Ephraimites unto this day; which Joshua, the writer of this book, might truly say, and be no objection to it, since the same is observed after his death, Jdg 1:29; and indeed they continued to dwell there until the times of Solomon, when it was taken by Pharaoh king of Egypt, and given as a present to his daughter, the wife of Solomon, 1Ki 9:15; and though this clause does not furnish out an argument against the writing of this book by Joshua, yet, from the instance given, it appears it must have been written before the times of Solomon, and so not by Ezra, as some:
and serve under tribute; so that they were under their power, and therefore could have driven them out, or slain them, as by the command of God they should; but they spared them for the sake of the tribute they received from them, which seems to agree with the character of the Ephraimites, Hos 12:8.
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes: Jos 16:7 The word “River” is not in the Hebrew text, but has been supplied in the translation for clarity.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: Jos 16:9 Heb “and the cities set apart for the sons of Ephraim in the midst of the inheritance of the sons of Manasseh, all the cities and their towns....
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: Jos 16:10 Heb “they”; the referent (the Ephraimites) has been specified in the translation for clarity.
Geneva Bible: Jos 16:7 And it went down from Janohah to Ataroth, and to Naarath, and came to Jericho, ( d ) and went out at Jordan.
( d ) For so far the coasts reach.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Geneva Bible: Jos 16:9 And the ( e ) separate cities for the children of Ephraim [were] among the inheritance of the children of Manasseh, all the cities with their villages...
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Jos 16:1-10
TSK Synopsis: Jos 16:1-10 - --1 The general borders of the sons of Joseph.5 The border of the inheritance of Ephraim.10 The Canaanites of Gezer not conquered.
MHCC -> Jos 16:1-10
MHCC: Jos 16:1-10 - --This and the following chapter should not be separated. They give the lots of Ephraim and Manasseh, the children of Joseph, who, next to Judah, were t...
Matthew Henry -> Jos 16:5-10
Matthew Henry: Jos 16:5-10 - -- Here, 1. The border of the lot of Ephraim is set down, by which it was divided on the south from Benjamin and Dan, who lay between it and Judah, and...
Keil-Delitzsch: Jos 16:7 - --
From Janoah the boundary went down "to Ataroth and Naarath," Ataroth , a different place from the Ataroth or Atroth-addar mentioned in Jos 16:3 and...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Keil-Delitzsch: Jos 16:8 - --
The western half of the northern boundary went from Tappuah westwards to the Cane-brook, and terminated at the sea. Tappuah, called En-tappuah in Jo...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Keil-Delitzsch: Jos 16:9 - --
The tribe of Ephraim also received some scattered towns in the territory of the tribe of Manasseh, in fact all those towns to which Tappuah belonged...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Keil-Delitzsch: Jos 16:10 - --
From Gezer, however (see Jos 16:3), they could not drive out the Canaanites, so that they still dwelt among the Ephraimites, but were reduced to a s...
Constable -> Jos 13:1--21:45; Jos 16:1--17:18
Constable: Jos 13:1--21:45 - --II. THE DIVISION OF THE LAND chs. 13--21
Chapters 13-24 describe how Joshua divided the land and the results of ...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)