
Text -- Joshua 19:49-51 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: Jos 19:49 - -- That is, they are said to give it, because the whole land was given to Joshua, and Eleazar, and the princes, as joint trustees, acting in the name, an...
That is, they are said to give it, because the whole land was given to Joshua, and Eleazar, and the princes, as joint trustees, acting in the name, and for the good of the people: so that even Joshua could take nothing without their gift.

Wesley: Jos 19:50 - -- As God had promised, or commanded; either formerly, or at this time by Eleazar.
As God had promised, or commanded; either formerly, or at this time by Eleazar.
JFB: Jos 19:50 - -- It was most proper that the great leader should receive an inheritance suited to his dignity, and as a reward for his public services. But the gift wa...
It was most proper that the great leader should receive an inheritance suited to his dignity, and as a reward for his public services. But the gift was not left to the spontaneous feelings of a grateful people. It was conferred "according to the word of the Lord"--probably an unrecorded promise, similar to what had been made to Caleb (Jos 14:9).

JFB: Jos 19:50 - -- Or Heres, on Mount Gaash (Jdg 2:9). Joshua founded it, and was afterwards buried there (Jos 24:30).

JFB: Jos 19:51 - -- This verse is the formal close of the section which narrates the history of the land distribution; and to stamp it with due importance, the names of t...
This verse is the formal close of the section which narrates the history of the land distribution; and to stamp it with due importance, the names of the commissioners are repeated, as well as the spot where so memorable a transaction took place.
Clarke: Jos 19:50 - -- Timnath-serah - Called Timnath-heres in Jdg 2:9, where we find that the mountain on which it was built was called Gaash. It is generally allowed to ...
Timnath-serah - Called Timnath-heres in Jdg 2:9, where we find that the mountain on which it was built was called Gaash. It is generally allowed to have been a barren spot in a barren country.

Clarke: Jos 19:51 - -- At the door of the tabernacle - All the inheritances were determined by lot, and this was cast before the Lord - every thing was done in his immedia...
At the door of the tabernacle - All the inheritances were determined by lot, and this was cast before the Lord - every thing was done in his immediate presence, as under his eye; hence there was no murmuring, each having received his inheritance as from the hand of God himself, though some of them thought they must have additional territory, because of the great increase of their families.
Calvin -> Jos 19:49
Calvin: Jos 19:49 - -- 49.When they had made an end of dividing, etc We have here, at length, an account of the gratitude of the people towards Joshua. For although the par...
49.When they had made an end of dividing, etc We have here, at length, an account of the gratitude of the people towards Joshua. For although the partition of the land of Canaan, among the posterity of Abraham, behooved to be equitable, yet Joshua, by his excellent virtues, deserved some honorary reward. Nor could any complain that a single individual was enriched at their expense. For, first, in the delay there was a striking proof of the moderation of this holy servant of God. He does not give any heed to his own interest till the commonweal has been secured. How seldom do we find any who, after they have given one or two specimens of valor, do not forthwith make haste to the prey? Not so Joshua, who thinks not of himself till the land has been divided. In the reward itself also the same temperance and frugality are conspicuous. The city he asks to be given to himself and his family was a mere heap of stones, either because it had been demolished and converted into a heap of ruins, or because no city had yet been built upon it.
It is conjectured with probability, that with the view of making the grant as little invidious as possible, the city he requested was of no great value. If any one thinks it strange that he did not give his labor gratuitously, let him reflect that Joshua liberally obeyed the divine call, and had no mercenary feelings in undergoing so many labors, dangers, and troubles; but having spontaneously performed his duty, he behooved not to repudiate a memorial of the favor of God, unless he wished by perverse contempt to suppress his glory. For the grant voted to him was nothing else than a simple testimonial of the divine power, which had been manifested through his hand. Truly no ambition can be detected here, inasmuch as he desires nothing for himself, and does not rashly act from a feeling of covetousness, but seeks in the popular consent a confirmation of the honor which God had already bestowed upon him. To have been silent in such a case, would have been more indicative of heartlessness than of modesty. The statement in the concluding verse of the chapter, that Joshua and Eleazar made an end of dividing the land, points to the perpetuity of the boundaries, which had been fixed, and warns the children of Israel against moving in any way to unsettle an inviolable decree.
Defender: Jos 19:50 - -- As Caleb was the first to request and be given his inheritance (among the tribes west of the Jordan, that is), so Joshua was the last (Jos 19:49).
As Caleb was the first to request and be given his inheritance (among the tribes west of the Jordan, that is), so Joshua was the last (Jos 19:49).

Defender: Jos 19:50 - -- Timnath-serah, the city assigned to Joshua, has been suggested by some as the source of the name Nazareth. The names of both are of uncertain meaning ...
Timnath-serah, the city assigned to Joshua, has been suggested by some as the source of the name Nazareth. The names of both are of uncertain meaning and derivation. However, the locations of the two were quite far apart, so it is unlikely there could be any connection."


TSK: Jos 19:51 - -- These are : Jos 14:1; Num 34:17-29; Psa 47:3, Psa 47:4; Mat 20:23, Mat 25:34; Joh 14:2, Joh 14:3, Joh 17:2; Heb 4:8, Heb 4:9
in Shiloh : Jos 18:1, Jos...

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Jos 19:50
Barnes: Jos 19:50 - -- Nothing is said of any express command of God respecting the inheritance of Joshua. But as such special portion appears to have been promised to Cal...
Nothing is said of any express command of God respecting the inheritance of Joshua. But as such special portion appears to have been promised to Caleb at the time when he and Joshua alone out of the twelve spies remained faithful Jos 14:6-9, it is probable that a like promise was made to Joshua. The name of the place is also written Timnath-heres Jdg 2:9, by a transposition of the letters. The rabbinical explanation that the name Timnath-heres (i. e. "portion of the sun") was given because a representation of the sun was affixed to the tomb in memory of Joshua’ s command to the sun to stand still, appears to be an afterthought. The name Timnath-serah ("portion that remains") was perhaps conferred on the spot in consequence of its being allotted to Joshua, the last allotment made in the whole distribution of his conquests. The site has been conjectured to be "Tibneh,"a village about five miles north-west of Lydda (or, by Conder, Kerr Hares, nine miles south of Nablous).
Poole: Jos 19:49 - -- i.e. They are said to give it , because the whole land was given to Joshua, and Eleazar, and the princes, as joint trustees, acting in the name and...
i.e. They are said to give it , because the whole land was given to Joshua, and Eleazar, and the princes, as joint trustees, acting in the name and for the good of the people; so that even Joshua could take nothing without their gift.

Poole: Jos 19:50 - -- According to the word of the Lord as God promised or commanded; either, first, formerly, as may be gathered from Jos 16:6 ; where we read that the L...
According to the word of the Lord as God promised or commanded; either, first, formerly, as may be gathered from Jos 16:6 ; where we read that the Lord said something unto Moses concerning me , Caleb, and thee, Joshua; though only what is said to Caleb be there expressed, the other not being to his purpose there; for Joshua having showed the same courage and faithfulness which Caleb did, did doubtless receive equal encouragement and comfort from God at that time. Or, secondly, now at this time by Eleazar.
Timnath-serah called Timnath-heres , Jud 2:9 . He built , i.e. repaired and enlarged it, in which sense Nebuchadnezzar is said to have built Babylon, Dan 4:30 .
Haydock -> Jos 19:50
Haydock: Jos 19:50 - -- Lord, by the mouth of Eleazar. Josue was content with one of the most barren parts of the country. He waits till all are provided for, shewing thro...
Lord, by the mouth of Eleazar. Josue was content with one of the most barren parts of the country. He waits till all are provided for, shewing throughout his life a pattern of moderation and disinterestedness, which render him worthy to be considered as a figure of Jesus Christ, who reduced himself to the lowest state of abjection for our sakes. (Calmet) See chap. xiv. 6. (Menochius) ---
Ephraim. It was before called Gaas; and the city, which Josue enlarged, lay on the north side of it, chap. xxiv. 30., and Judges ii. 9.
Gill: Jos 19:49 - -- And when they made an end of dividing the land for inheritance by their coasts,.... That is, Eleazar, Joshua, and the ten men appointed for this, purp...
And when they made an end of dividing the land for inheritance by their coasts,.... That is, Eleazar, Joshua, and the ten men appointed for this, purpose; when all the lots were drawn, and the several inheritances which came up to them were divided among the families of the respective tribes, this work being finished:
the children of Israel gave an inheritance to Joshua the son of Nun among them; most interpreters observe the modesty of Joshua, that though the oldest and the greatest man in the nation, the chief governor, yet had his inheritance last of all; nor did he take any part to himself, it was given to him by the people, who had the whole land divided among them; in which he was a type of Christ; see 2Co 8:9 Phi 2:6.

Gill: Jos 19:50 - -- According to the word of the Lord,.... Or mouth of the Lord; either according to the oracle of Urim and Thummim, which Eleazar consulted on this occas...
According to the word of the Lord,.... Or mouth of the Lord; either according to the oracle of Urim and Thummim, which Eleazar consulted on this occasion; or according to what the Lord had said to Moses, at the same time that Hebron was ordered to Caleb, Jos 14:6; and
they gave him the city which he asked, even Timnathserah in Mount Ephraim; he chose a place in his own tribe, for he was of the tribe of Ephraim; and it seems that what he chose was none of the best of places; for Paula, as Jerom i relates, when she travelled into those parts, wondered that the distributor of the possessions of the children of Israel should choose such a rough and mountainous place for himself; of its situation, see Jos 24:30,
and he built the city, and dwelt therein; he rebuilt it, and fitted it for his own habitation, and for those that belonged to him. (Timnathserah means "an abundant portion" or "a place in the sun". Joshua great reward was in seeing the promises of God fulfilled before his very eyes Jos 21:45 and the children of Israel serving the Lord's during his lifetime Jos 24:31. Joshua may have received but a small inheritance in the promised land but this was just an earnest of his future glorious inheritance in eternity. The saints of God have the best portion saved for the last Joh 2:10 whereas the worldling has his best portion now; his worst is yet to come. Editor.)

Gill: Jos 19:51 - -- These are the inheritances which Eleazar the priest, and Joshua the son of Nun,.... The one the high priest, and the other the chief governor of the ...
These are the inheritances which Eleazar the priest, and Joshua the son of Nun,.... The one the high priest, and the other the chief governor of the nation:
and the heads of the fathers of the tribes of the children of Israel; the princes appointed for this service, whose names are given Num 34:18; the inheritances before described in the preceding chapters by their boundaries and cities, these the said persons
divided for an inheritance by lot in Shiloh; and so has particular reference to the seven lots drawn there for seven of the tribes, by which their inheritances were assigned to them: and this was done
before the Lord, at the door of the tabernacle of the congregation; see Jos 18:1,
so they made an end of dividing the country; though it was not as yet wholly subdued.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Jos 19:1-51
TSK Synopsis: Jos 19:1-51 - --1 The lot of Simeon;10 of Zebulun;17 of Issachar;24 of Asher;32 of Naphtali;40 of Dan.49 The children of Israel give an inheritance to Joshua.
MHCC -> Jos 19:17-51
MHCC: Jos 19:17-51 - --Joshua waited till all the tribes were settled, before he asked any provision for himself. He was content to be unfixed, till he saw them all placed, ...
Matthew Henry -> Jos 19:49-51
Matthew Henry: Jos 19:49-51 - -- Before this account of the dividing of the land is solemnly closed up, in the last verse, which intimates that the thing was done to the satisfactio...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Jos 19:49-50; Jos 19:51
Keil-Delitzsch: Jos 19:49-50 - --
Conclusion of the Distribution of the Land . - Jos 19:49, Jos 19:50. When the land was distributed among the tribes according to its territories, t...

Keil-Delitzsch: Jos 19:51 - --
Closing formula to the account of the distribution of the land, which refers primarily to Jos 18:1., as the expression " in Shiloh "shows, but which...
Constable: Jos 13:1--21:45 - --II. THE DIVISION OF THE LAND chs. 13--21
Chapters 13-24 describe how Joshua divided the land and the results of ...

Constable: Jos 18:11--20:1 - --6. The inheritance of the remaining tribes 18:11-19:51
First the two and one-half tribes east of...

Constable: Jos 19:49-50 - --The inheritance of Joshua 19:49-50
As Caleb, Joshua received a city, Timnath-serah (call...
