![](images/minus.gif)
Text -- Leviticus 5:4 (NET)
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/information.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: Lev 5:4 - -- Rashly, without consideration either of God's law, or his own power or right, as David did, 1Sa 25:22.
Rashly, without consideration either of God's law, or his own power or right, as David did, 1Sa 25:22.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: Lev 5:4 - -- To himself, to punish himself either in his body, or estate, or something else which is dear to him. Or rather to his neighbour.
To himself, to punish himself either in his body, or estate, or something else which is dear to him. Or rather to his neighbour.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: Lev 5:4 - -- That is, he did not know, or not consider, that what he swore to do, was or would be impossible, or unlawful: When he discovers it to be so, either by...
That is, he did not know, or not consider, that what he swore to do, was or would be impossible, or unlawful: When he discovers it to be so, either by his own consideration, or by information from others, whether it was good or evil which he swore to do.
JFB -> Lev 5:4
JFB: Lev 5:4 - -- A rash oath, without duly considering the nature and consequences of the oath, perhaps inconsiderately binding himself to do anything wrong, or neglec...
A rash oath, without duly considering the nature and consequences of the oath, perhaps inconsiderately binding himself to do anything wrong, or neglecting to perform a vow to do something good. In all such cases a person might have transgressed one of the divine commandments unwittingly, and have been afterwards brought to a sense of his delinquency.
Clarke -> Lev 5:4
Clarke: Lev 5:4 - -- To do evil, or to do good - It is very likely that rash promises are here intended; for if a man vow to do an act that is evil, though it would be c...
To do evil, or to do good - It is very likely that rash promises are here intended; for if a man vow to do an act that is evil, though it would be criminal to keep such an oath or vow, yet he is guilty because he made it, and therefore must offer the trespass-offering. If he neglect to do the good he has vowed, he is guilty, and must in both cases confess his iniquity, and bring his trespass-offering.
Calvin -> Lev 5:4
Calvin: Lev 5:4 - -- 4.Or if a soul shall swear The Gulf is also ascribed to error and ignorance, when a person does inconsiderately what he has promised not to do; for t...
4.Or if a soul shall swear The Gulf is also ascribed to error and ignorance, when a person does inconsiderately what he has promised not to do; for the oath is not in that case violated, which would be criminal; 267 but in this very carelessness there is enough of wrong, because sound religion would renew the recollection of the vow. Consequently, where no anxiety (to fulfill it) is shewn, there is no serious desire to do so. But this commandment was necessary, because it might often happen that men who had pledged their faith in a vow, and had broken it in thoughtlessness, would deem themselves released from every, and would in future give themselves up to indulgence, whereas they who arrive at such a pitch of licentiousness, harden themselves more and more, until at length they throw off all reverence for God. God would therefore have vows kept faithfully, lest those who despised them should thus rush into impiety. If then any one had thoughtlessly broken faith, he is commanded to make atonement to God; not on account of his levity, as some think, as if he had rashly promised what he might not, but on account of his neglect, because he had not given diligence to remember the vow at the proper time. Now if the Papists stupidly wrest this text after their custom, in order to establish the obligation of all kinds of vows, their confutation is easy; viz., that God requires this stedfastness only with respect to lawful vows duly made. We have already understood from the teaching of Moses, what is the rule of pious vow-making; whence we gather, that those which profane God’s name are by no means to be kept; for if we set out with doing wrong, obstinacy in it is doubly wicked. In this passage, therefore, “to do evil” is not to perform any improper action, but to undertake something which would otherwise be disagreeable and burdensome to the flesh; such as to diminish domestic expenditure, or to deprive one’s self of luxuries, or to determine upon abstinence from something which would gratify or profit us.
TSK -> Lev 5:4
TSK: Lev 5:4 - -- if a soul : This relates to rash oaths or vows, which a man was afterwards unable, or which it would have been sinful, to perform.
to do evil : Lev. 2...
if a soul : This relates to rash oaths or vows, which a man was afterwards unable, or which it would have been sinful, to perform.
to do evil : Lev. 27:2-34; Jos 2:14, Jos 9:15; Jdg 9:19, Jdg 11:31, Jdg 21:7, Jdg 21:18; 1Sa 1:11; 1Sa 14:24-28, 1Sa 24:21, 1Sa 24:22, 1Sa 25:22; 2Sa 21:7; 2Ki 6:31; Psa 132:2-5; Ecc 5:2-6; Eze 17:18, Eze 17:19; Mat 14:7, Mat 14:9; Mar 6:23; Act 23:12
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Lev 5:1-13
Barnes: Lev 5:1-13 - -- Special occasions are mentioned on which sin-offerings are to be made with a particular confession of the offence for which atonement is sought Lev ...
Special occasions are mentioned on which sin-offerings are to be made with a particular confession of the offence for which atonement is sought Lev 5:5.
Swearing - Adjuration. The case appears to be that of one who has been put upon his oath as a witness by a magistrate, and fails to utter all he has seen and heard (compare the marginal references. and Pro 29:24; Num 5:21).
Hid from him - Either through forgetfulness or indifference, so that purification had been neglected. In such a case there had been a guilty negligence, and a sin-offering was required. On the essential connection between impurity and the sin-offering, see Lev 12:1.
Pronouncing - Idly speaking Psa 106:33. The reference is to an oath to do something uttered in recklessness or passion and forgotten as soon as uttered.
His trespass offering - Rather, as his forfeit, that is, whatever is due for his offence. The term "trespass-offering"is out of place here, since it has become the current designation for a distinct kind of sin-offering mentioned in the next section (see Lev 5:14 note).
A lamb or a kid of the goats - A sheep Lev 4:32 or a shaggy she-goat Lev 4:23.
See Lev 1:14-16; Lev 12:8. In the larger offerings of the ox and the sheep, the fat which was burned upon the altar represented, like the burnt-offering, the dedication of the worshipper; in this case, the same meaning was conveyed by one of the birds being treated as a distinct burnt-offering.
A lamb - One of the flock, either a sheep or a goat.
For his trespass, which he hath committed - As his forfeit for the sin he hath committed.
tenth part of an ephah i. e. - " the tenth deal;"probably less than half a gallon. See Lev 19:36 note. This sin-offering of meal was distinguished from the ordinary
Poole -> Lev 5:4
Poole: Lev 5:4 - -- If a soul swear to wit, rashly, without consideration, either of God’ s law, or his own power or right, as David did, 1Sa 25:22 .
To do evil e...
If a soul swear to wit, rashly, without consideration, either of God’ s law, or his own power or right, as David did, 1Sa 25:22 .
To do evil either,
1. To himself, to wit, to punish himself, either in his body, or estate, or something else which is dear to him. Or rather,
2. To his neighbour, as 1Sa 25:22 Act 23:12 .
Or to do good to wit, to his neighbour, as Mar 6:23 , when a man either may not or cannot do it, which may frequently happen.
And it be hid from him i.e. he did not know, or not consider, that what he swore to do, was or would be impossible or unlawful.
When he knoweth of it when he discovers it to be so, either by his own consideration, or by information from others.
In one of these either in the good or evil which he swore to do.
Haydock -> Lev 5:4
Haydock: Lev 5:4 - -- Lips. This is necessary before he can be punished by men; but every secret promise binds before God. (Tostat) ---
Evil or good: any thing whatsoe...
Lips. This is necessary before he can be punished by men; but every secret promise binds before God. (Tostat) ---
Evil or good: any thing whatsoever, whether favour or punishment, whether the completion of it be difficult or easy. (Calmet) ---
Thus parents sometimes foolishly swear that they will chastise their children unmercifully; libertines that they will live in luxuries as long as they have any money; ill-natured people that they will never speak to such a one, that they will murder, &c. To execute such promises, even confirmed by an oath, would be a double crime. Let them ask pardon of God for their rash oath. (Philo) ---
Herod made his oath a pretext for killing John the Baptist, deluding himself, perhaps, with a false interpretation of this law. (Haydock) ---
As such hasty oaths are easily forgotten, when the guilty person recollected himself, he was bound to confess his fault to the priest in the following manner, according to the Rabbins: Placing his hands between the horns of his victim, he shall say, "I beseech you, Lord, I have sinned; I have committed iniquity and prevarication; I have committed such a fault. I repent, I am filled with sorrow and confusion for having done so; I will relapse no more." These doctors teach, that without confession and sorrow no sacrifice will remit sin. (Calmet) ---
To preserve the secret of confession, the priests were ordered to eat the victims alone. (Philo, &c.) (Tirinus)
Gill -> Lev 5:4
Gill: Lev 5:4 - -- Or if a soul swear,.... A rash or vain oath:
pronouncing with his lips; not in his heart, as Jarchi notes; not saying within himself that he would ...
Or if a soul swear,.... A rash or vain oath:
pronouncing with his lips; not in his heart, as Jarchi notes; not saying within himself that he would do this, or that, or the other thing, but expressing his oath plainly and distinctly, with an audible voice:
to do good, or to do evil; which was either impossible or unlawful for him to do; whether the good or evil he swears to do is to himself or to another; whether he swears to do good to himself, and evil to another, or, good to another, and evil to himself, see Psa 15:4. The Targum of Jonathan paraphrases it,"whatsoever a man expresses, whether of anything present or future;''as if he swears he has done such and such a thing, whether good or evil; or that he will do it, be it what it will, and it is not in the power of his hands to do it, or, if he did it, it would be doing a wrong thing:
whatsoever it be that a man shall pronounce with an oath, and it be hid from him; he has forgot that he ever swore such an oath:
and when he knoweth of it, then he shall be guilty in one of these; when he is told of it, and it is made clearly to appear to him, that he did at such a time, and in such a place, deliver out a rash oath concerning this, or the other thing, then he shall be chargeable with guilt in one of these; either in rashly swearing to do good when it was not in his power, or to do evil, which would have been unlawful. The Targum of Jonathan is,"if he knows that he has falsified, and repents not, he is guilty.''
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes: Lev 5:4 Heb “and is guilty to one from these,” probably referring here to any of “these” things about which one might swear a thoughtl...
Geneva Bible -> Lev 5:4
Geneva Bible: Lev 5:4 Or if a soul ( b ) swear, pronouncing with [his] lips to do evil, or to do good, whatsoever [it be] that a man shall pronounce with an oath, and it be...
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Lev 5:1-19
TSK Synopsis: Lev 5:1-19 - --1 He that sins in concealing his knowledge;2 in touching an unclean thing;4 or in making an oath.6 His trespass offering, of the flock;7 of fowls;11 o...
MHCC -> Lev 5:1-13
MHCC: Lev 5:1-13 - --The offences here noticed are, 1. A man's concealing the truth, when he was sworn as a witness to speak the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but th...
Matthew Henry -> Lev 5:1-6
Matthew Henry: Lev 5:1-6 - -- I. The offences here supposed are, 1. A man's concealing the truth when he was sworn as a witness to speak the truth, the whole truth, and nothing b...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Lev 5:1-13
Keil-Delitzsch: Lev 5:1-13 - --
There follow here three special examples of sin on the part of the common Israelite, all sins of omission and rashness of a lighter kind than the ca...
Constable: Lev 1:1--16:34 - --I. The public worship of the Israelites chs. 1--16
Leviticus continues revelation concerning the second of three...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: Lev 1:1--7:38 - --A. The laws of sacrifice chs. 1-7
God designed the offerings to teach the Israelites as well as to enabl...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)