
Text -- Numbers 5:12 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: Num 5:12 - -- This law was given partly to deter wives from adulterous practices, and partly to secure wives against the rage of their hard - hearted husbands, who ...
This law was given partly to deter wives from adulterous practices, and partly to secure wives against the rage of their hard - hearted husbands, who otherwise might upon mere suspicions destroy them, or at least put them away. There was not like fear of inconveniences to the husband from the jealousy, of the wife, who had not that authority and power, and opportunity for the putting away or killing the husband, as the husband had over the wife.

Wesley: Num 5:12 - -- From the way of religion and justice, and that either in truth, or in her husband's opinion.
From the way of religion and justice, and that either in truth, or in her husband's opinion.
JFB -> Num 5:12-15
JFB: Num 5:12-15 - -- This law was given both as a strong discouragement to conjugal infidelity on the part of a wife, and a sufficient protection of her from the consequen...
This law was given both as a strong discouragement to conjugal infidelity on the part of a wife, and a sufficient protection of her from the consequences of a hasty and groundless suspicion on the part of the husband. His suspicions, however, were sufficient in the absence of witnesses (Lev 20:10) to warrant the trial described; and the course of proceeding to be followed was for the jealous husband to bring his wife unto the priest with an offering of barley meal, because none were allowed to approach the sanctuary empty handed (Exo 23:15). On other occasions, there were mingled with the offering, oil which signified joy, and frankincense which denoted acceptance (Psa 141:2). But on the occasion referred to, both these ingredients were to be excluded, partly because it was a solemn appeal to God in distressing circumstances, and partly because it was a sin offering on the part of the wife, who came before God in the character of a real or suspected offender.
Defender -> Num 5:12
Defender: Num 5:12 - -- This remarkable test for adultery (Numbers 5:12-31) was established by God (Num 5:11) for the purpose of maintaining family purity and integrity in Hi...
This remarkable test for adultery (Numbers 5:12-31) was established by God (Num 5:11) for the purpose of maintaining family purity and integrity in His chosen people. The "holy water" (Num 5:17) is mentioned only here, so its nature and activity are not known. Also unknown is the chemical composition of the "dust" mixed with it, so the capabilities of the resulting solution are also unknown. It may be that some as yet undiscovered chemical reaction would produce the described results in a guilty wife. On the other hand, it may be that her guilt would affect her psychologically and this would generate such a physiological reaction. Most likely God would intervene supernaturally in such cases to make the decision Himself. This was a very special period in world history and miracles were common - the manna itself was a daily miracle. It would not take many such miraculous decisions to effectively restrain future temptations to wifely infidelity."
TSK -> Num 5:12

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Num 5:11-31
Barnes: Num 5:11-31 - -- The trial of jealousy. Since the crime of adultery is especially defiling and destructive of the very foundations of social order, the whole subject...
The trial of jealousy. Since the crime of adultery is especially defiling and destructive of the very foundations of social order, the whole subject is dealt with at a length proportionate to its importance. The process prescribed has lately been strikingly illustrated from an Egyptian "romance,"which refers to the time of Rameses the Great, and may therefore well serve to illustrate the manners and customs of the Mosaic times. This mode of trial, like several other ordinances, was adopted by Moses from existing and probably very ancient and widely spread institutions.
The offering was to be of the cheapest and coarsest kind, barley (compare 2Ki 7:1, 2Ki 7:16, 2Ki 7:18), representing the abused condition of the suspected woman. It was, like the sin-offering Lev 5:11, to be made without oil and frankincense, the symbols of grace and acceptableness. The woman herself stood with head uncovered Num 5:18, in token of her shame.
The dust that is in the floor of the tabernacle - To set forth the fact that the water was endued with extraordinary power by Him who dwelt in the tabernacle. Dust is an emblem of a state of condemnation Gen 3:14; Mic 7:17.
Gone aside ... - literally, "gone astray from"thy husband by uncleanness; compare Hos 4:12.
Blot them out with the bitter water - In order to transfer the curses to the water. The action was symbolic. Travelers speak of the natives of Africa as still habitually seeking to obtain the full force of a written charm by drinking the water into which they have washed it.
Shall cause the woman to drink - Thus was symbolised both her full acceptance of the hypothetical curse (compare Eze 3:1-3; Jer 15:16; Rev 10:9), and its actual operation upon her if she should be guilty (compare Psa 109:18).
The memorial thereof - See the marginal reference. "Memorial"here is not the same as "memorial"in Num 5:15.
Of itself, the drink was not noxious; and could only produce the effects here described by a special interposition of God. We do not read of any instance in which this ordeal was resorted to: a fact which may be explained either (with the Jews) as a proof of its efficacy, since the guilty could not be brought to face its terrors at all, and avoided them by confession; or more probably by the license of divorce tolerated by the law of Moses. Since a husband could put away his wife at pleasure, a jealous man would naturally prefer to take this course with a suspected wife rather than to call public attention to his own shame by having recourse to the trial of jealousy. The trial by red water, which bears a general resemblance to that here prescribed by Moses, is still in use among the tribes of Western Africa.
Poole -> Num 5:12
Poole: Num 5:12 - -- This law was given partly to deter wives from adulterous practices, and partly to secure wives against the rage of their hard-hearted husbands, who ...
This law was given partly to deter wives from adulterous practices, and partly to secure wives against the rage of their hard-hearted husbands, who otherwise might upon mere suspicions destroy them, or at least put them away.
Quest. Why was there not the same law for the trial of the husband, when the wife was jealous of him?
Answ This might be either,
1. Because the woman’ s sin is greater, because there is not only filthiness and falseness in it, which is also in the man’ s sin, but also peculiar unrighteousness in dishonouring his name and family, and transferring his estate to strangers and other men’ s children. Or,
2. Because there was not like fear of inconveniences to the husband from the jealousy of the wife, who had not that authority, and power, and opportunity for the putting away or killing of the husband as the husband had over the wive. Or,
3. Because being the inferior and the weaker sex, and more subject to jealousies and groundless suspicions, it was not thought expedient to trust them with such a power or privilege.
Go aside from the way of religion and justice, or from her faith given to her husband, or to the by-paths of falsehood and filthiness, and that either in truth, or in appearance, and in her husband’ s opinion.
Gill -> Num 5:12
Gill: Num 5:12 - -- Speak unto the children of Israel, and say unto them,.... It being an affair which concerned them:
if any man's wife go aside, and commit a trespas...
Speak unto the children of Israel, and say unto them,.... It being an affair which concerned them:
if any man's wife go aside, and commit a trespass against him; the sin of adultery, which is a going aside out of the way of virtue and chastity, and a trespass against an husband, a breach of the marriage covenant with him, a defiling his bed, doing an injury and dishonour to him, bringing confusion into his family, and a spurious offspring to possess his substance: though this is to be understood, not of certain adultery, of which there is plain and full proof, for then there would be no occasion of such a trial, as is afterwards directed to; besides, her husband, in such a case, might put her away, and even, according to the law, she was to be put to death, Lev 20:10; but of her having committed it in the opinion of her husband, he having some ground of suspicion, though he could not be certain of it; and therefore, by this law, was allowed to make trial, that he might find it out, it at present only a suspected case, and a doubtful one; and the Jews k say,"they never gave the waters drink but in a doubtful case:''and so this may interpreted of her declining and departing from her husband's house, not keeping at home to mind the affairs of her family, but gadding abroad, and keeping company with another man, or other men; and that after she had been warned and charged by her husband to the contrary, and so had disobeyed him, and acted contrary to his will; and in that sense had committed a trespass, and so had given him suspicion of her unchastity, for which he might have some reason; if, as it is said in the Misnah l, he gave her an admonition before two witnesses, saying, have no talk with such a man, and yet she talks with him; or, as the commentators add m, be not secretly or in private with such an one, and yet goes into a private place with him, and stays so long with him that she may be defiled; this with them rendered her suspected.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Num 5:1-31
TSK Synopsis: Num 5:1-31 - --1 The unclean are removed out of camp.5 Restitution is to be made in trespass.11 The trial of jealousy.
MHCC -> Num 5:11-31
MHCC: Num 5:11-31 - --This law would make the women of Israel watch against giving cause for suspicion. On the other hand, it would hinder the cruel treatment such suspicio...
Matthew Henry -> Num 5:11-31
Matthew Henry: Num 5:11-31 - -- We have here the law concerning the solemn trial of a wife whose husband was jealous of her. Observe, I. What was the case supposed: That a man had ...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Num 5:11-31
Keil-Delitzsch: Num 5:11-31 - --
Sentence of God upon Wives Suspected of Adultery. - As any suspicion cherished by a man against his wife, that she either is or has been guilty of a...
Constable: Num 1:1--10:36 - --A. Preparations for entering the Promised Land from the south chs. 1-10
The first 10 chapters in Numbers...

Constable: Num 5:1--9:23 - --2. Commands and rituals to observe in preparation for entering the land chs. 5-9
God gave the fo...
