
Text -- Psalms 42:9-11 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley -> Psa 42:10
As a sword, which cutteth the very bones, so painful are their reproaches.
JFB: Psa 42:9-10 - -- In view of which [Psa 42:8], he dictates to himself a prayer based on his distress, aggravated as it was by the cruel taunts and infidel suggestions o...
In view of which [Psa 42:8], he dictates to himself a prayer based on his distress, aggravated as it was by the cruel taunts and infidel suggestions of his foes.

This brings on a renewed self-chiding, and excites hopes of relief.

It is He of whose existence and favor my foes would have me doubt.
I will say unto God my rock - God, my Fortress and Support

Clarke: Psa 42:9 - -- Why hast thou forgotten me? - This and the following verse is badly pointed in our Bibles: "Why go I mourning as with a sword in my bones because of...
Why hast thou forgotten me? - This and the following verse is badly pointed in our Bibles: "Why go I mourning as with a sword in my bones because of the oppression of the enemy? Mine enemies reproach me daily, while they say unto me, Where is thy God?"See on Psa 42:3 (note). Their reproaches are to my soul as cutting and severe as a sword thrust into my body, and separating between my bones; because these reproaches are intended to fall on thee, my God, as if thou hadst not power to save us from the hands of our oppressors.

Clarke: Psa 42:11 - -- Why art thou cast down - There is no reason why thou shouldst despair. God will appear and release thee and thy brother captives and soon thy sighin...
Why art thou cast down - There is no reason why thou shouldst despair. God will appear and release thee and thy brother captives and soon thy sighing and sorrowing shall flee away

Clarke: Psa 42:11 - -- Who is the health of my countenance - As a healthy state of the constitution shows itself in the appearance of the face; God will so rejoice thy hea...
Who is the health of my countenance - As a healthy state of the constitution shows itself in the appearance of the face; God will so rejoice thy heart, heal all thy spiritual maladies, that thy face shall testify the happiness that is within thee
There is a curious gloss on the first verse of this Psalm in my old Psalter, which I cannot withhold from the reader. The author translates and paraphrases the verse thus: -
Trans. Als the Hert yernes til the welles of waters; so my saule yernes til the God.
Par - This Psalm es al of perfite men, that er brinnand in the flamme of Goddes luf, and passes in til the contemplatyf lif: and tharfore it es sungen in the office of the dede men: for than haf that, that thai yearned; that es, the syght of God. Far thi, sais he, als the Hert that has eten the nedder, gretely yernes to com til the welles of waters for to drynk and wax yong opayne: so destroyed in me vices and unclennes, my saule desyres with brinnand yernyng, to come til the God
Aelian, Appian, Anstotle, Nicander, and Pliny, all inform us that one cause why the hart thirsts for the waters is, that they eat serpents, and that the poison of them diffused through their entrails produces a burning heat and fever, to ease and cure themselves of which they have recourse to water. Many of the fathers tell the same tale, and from them the paraphrast in the old Psalter has borrowed what is inserted above: "Like as the hart, which has eaten the adder, greatly longs to come to the fountains of water to drink, that he may grow young again."The hart is undoubtedly a cunning animal; but it would be as difficult to believe that he eats serpents as it would be to believe that he seeks for and eats the fresh water crab or cray fish, in order to cure and make him grow young again, as Eusebius, Didymus, Theodoret, Jerome, Epiphanies, Gregory Nyssen, and others of the primitive fathers gravely inform us
Calvin: Psa 42:9 - -- 9.I will say to God my rock If we read the preceding verse in the past tense, the meaning of this verse will be, Since God has, in this way, heretofo...
9.I will say to God my rock If we read the preceding verse in the past tense, the meaning of this verse will be, Since God has, in this way, heretofore shown himself so kind towards me, I will pray to him now with so much the greater confidence: for the experience which I have had of his goodness will inspire me with courage. But if the preceding verse is rendered in the future tense, David, in this verse, combines the prayer which it contains with the reflections which faith led him to make. And, surely, whoever, from a persuasion of the paternal love of God, anticipates for himself the same favor which David has just described, will also be induced from his example to pray for it with greater confidence. The meaning, then, will be this: Since I expect that God will be favorable to me, inasmuch as by day he manifests his favor towards me, and continues to do this, so that even by night I have occasion to praise him, I will bewail the more frankly my miseries before him, saying, O Lord! my rock, why hast thou forgotten me? In making such a complaint, the faithful are not to be understood as meaning that God has utterly rejected them: for if they did not believe that they were under his care and protection, it were in vain for them to call upon him. But they speak in this manner according to the sense of the flesh. This forgetfulness, then, relates both to outward appearance, and to the disquietude by which the faithful are troubled according to the flesh, although, in the meantime, they rest assured by faith that God regards them, and will not be deaf to their request.

Calvin: Psa 42:10 - -- 10.It is as a slaughter in my bones This verse is somewhat involved in point of expression; but as to the meaning of it there is no obscurity. David ...
10.It is as a slaughter in my bones This verse is somewhat involved in point of expression; but as to the meaning of it there is no obscurity. David here affirms that the grief which he experienced from the reproaches of his enemies, wounded him in no degree less than if they had pierced through his bones. The word

Calvin: Psa 42:11 - -- 11.O my soul! why art thou cast down? This repetition shows us that David had not so completely overcome his temptations in one encounter, or by one ...
11.O my soul! why art thou cast down? This repetition shows us that David had not so completely overcome his temptations in one encounter, or by one extraordinary effort, as to render it unnecessary for him to enter anew into the same conflict. By this example, therefore, we are admonished, that although Satan, by his assaults, often subjects us to a renewal of the same trouble, we ought not to lose our courage, or allow ourselves to be cast down. The latter part of this verse differs from the fifth verse in one word, while in every other respect they agree. In the fifth verse, it is the helps of His countenance, but here we have the relative pronoun of the first person, thus, The helps of My countenance Perhaps in this place, the letter w, vau, which in the Hebrew language denotes the third person, is wanting. Still, as all the other versions agree in the reading which I have adopted, 125 David might, without any absurdity, call God by this designation, The helps or salvations of My countenance, inasmuch as he looked with confidence for a deliverance, manifest and certain, as if God should appear in a visible manner as his defender, and the protector of his welfare. There can, however, be no doubt, that in this place the term helps or salvations is to be viewed as an epithet applied to God; for immediately after it follows, and my God

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes: Psa 42:9 - -- I will say unto God my rock - I will appeal to God as my defense, my helper, my Saviour. On the word rock, as applied to God, see the notes at ...
I will say unto God my rock - I will appeal to God as my defense, my helper, my Saviour. On the word rock, as applied to God, see the notes at Psa 18:2.
Why hast thou forgotten me? - See the notes at Psa 22:1. He had seemed to forget and forsake him, for He did not come to interpose and save him. This is a part of the prayer which he says Psa 42:8 that he would use.
Why go I mourning? - On the meaning of the word used here -
Because of the oppression of the enemy - In the oppression of the enemy; that is, during its continuance, or on account of it. The word here rendered "oppression"means distress, affliction, straits, Job 36:15; 1Ki 22:27; Isa 30:20. The "enemy"here referred to may have been Absalom, who had driven him from his throne and kingdom.

Barnes: Psa 42:10 - -- As with a sword in my bones - Margin, killing. The treatment which I receive in their reproaches is like death. The word rendered "sword"- ר...
As with a sword in my bones - Margin, killing. The treatment which I receive in their reproaches is like death. The word rendered "sword"-
Mine enemies reproach me - That is, as one forsaken of God, and as suffering justly under his displeasure. Their argument was, that if he was truly the friend of God, he would not leave him thus; that the fact of his being thus abandoned proved that he was not a friend of God.
While they say daily unto me - They say this constantly. I am compelled to hear it every day.
Where is thy God? - See the notes at Psa 42:3.

Barnes: Psa 42:11 - -- Why art thou cast down, O my soul? - This closes the second strophe of the psalm, and, with one or two slight and immaterial variations, is the...
Why art thou cast down, O my soul? - This closes the second strophe of the psalm, and, with one or two slight and immaterial variations, is the same as that which closes the first Psa 42:5. In this latter, the word "why"is inserted, and the expression "the salvation of my countenance"occurs instead of "salvations of his countenance,"with the addition of the words "and my God"at the close. The sense, however, is the same; and the verse contains, as before, self-reproof for being thus cast down, and self-exhortation to put trust in God. In the former part of the psalm Psa 42:5 he had addressed this language to himself, as designed to impress his own mind with the guilt of thus yielding to discouragement and sorrow; but he had then almost immediately admitted that his mind was distressed, and that he was cast down; here he rallies again, and endeavors to arouse himself to the conviction that he ought not to be thus depressed and dejected. He exhorts himself, therefore; he charges his own soul to hope in God. He expresses again the assurance that he would yet be permitted to praise him. He regards God now as the "salvation of his countenance,"or as his Deliverer and Friend, and expresses the conviction that he would yet make such manifestations of himself as to clear up and illuminate his countenance, at present made dark and saddened by affliction; and he appeals to him now as "his God."He has reached the true source of comfort to the afflicted and the sad - the living God as his God; and his mind is calm. Why should a man be sorrowful when he feels that he has a God? Why should his heart be sad when he can pour out his sorrows before Him? Why should he be cast down and gloomy when he can hope: hope for the favor of God here; hope for immortal life in the world to come!
Poole: Psa 42:9 - -- I will say unto God I will expostulate the case with him.
My rock who hath formerly been a sure refuge to me.
Why hast thou forgotten me? why dos...
I will say unto God I will expostulate the case with him.
My rock who hath formerly been a sure refuge to me.
Why hast thou forgotten me? why dost thou now seem quite to forget and neglect me? Why go I mourning? why dost thou leave me in this mournful state, and not succour me speedily?

Poole: Psa 42:10 - -- In my bones or in my body , the bones being oft put for the body , whereof they are a very considerable part. Or, as a sword, which pierceth and cu...
In my bones or in my body , the bones being oft put for the body , whereof they are a very considerable part. Or, as a sword, which pierceth and cutteth my flesh even to the bones, and cutteth or breaketh the very bones also. So painful and vexatious are their reproaches.
Where is thy God? of which See Poole "Psa 42:3" .

Poole: Psa 42:11 - -- The health of my countenance Heb. the salvations of my face i.e. either,
1. Which are present and manifest, being before my face. Or,
2. Which wi...
The health of my countenance Heb. the salvations of my face i.e. either,
1. Which are present and manifest, being before my face. Or,
2. Which will make my face to shine, and my countenance cheerful, which supposeth the gladness of the heart, and the bettering of his condition. Or,
3. Of his person; as the face sometimes signifies, as 2Sa 17:11 Isa 3:15 . As also the Greek word signifying face , is very frequently put for the person, whereof the face is an eminent part. My God : as he formerly was, so he still is, and ever will be, and will suddenly show himself to be, my God, although for a season he may hide his face, or withdraw his help from me.
PBC -> Psa 42:11
Gill: Psa 42:9 - -- I will say unto God my rock,.... A name frequently given to the eternal God, Father, Son, and Spirit, Deu 32:4; See Gill on Psa 18:2;
why hast thou...
I will say unto God my rock,.... A name frequently given to the eternal God, Father, Son, and Spirit, Deu 32:4; See Gill on Psa 18:2;
why hast thou forgotten me? See Gill on Psa 13:1;
why go I mourning because of the oppression of the enemy? meaning perhaps Saul; though it may be applied to any spiritual enemy, sin, Satan, and the world; who are very oppressive and afflicting, and occasion continual mourning to the children of God.

Gill: Psa 42:10 - -- As with a sword in my bones, mine enemies reproach me,.... The reproaches of his enemies were grievous and cutting to him, as if a sword pierced thro...
As with a sword in my bones, mine enemies reproach me,.... The reproaches of his enemies were grievous and cutting to him, as if a sword pierced through the marrow in his bones, which, being very sensitive, gives exquisite pain. There is a various reading here: some copies, as Vatablus observes, read
while they say daily unto me, where is thy God? See Gill on Psa 42:3.

Gill: Psa 42:11 - -- Why art thou cast down, O my soul?.... The same expostulation as in Psa 42:5; and so is what follows,
and why art thou disquieted within me? and th...
Why art thou cast down, O my soul?.... The same expostulation as in Psa 42:5; and so is what follows,
and why art thou disquieted within me? and the same argument and means are made use of to remove dejection and disquietude;
hope thou in God; for I shall yet praise him; See Gill on Psa 42:5; to which is added a new argument, taken from the grace and goodness of God, and covenant interest in him;
who is the health of my countenance, and my God; as the bodily health of man is seen in the countenance, and for the most part to be judged of by it; so is the spiritual health of the saints, and which they have from the Lord; when he, as the sun of righteousness, arises upon them with healing in his wings, he, by his gracious presence, makes their countenances cheerful, fills them with joy unspeakable and full of glory, and causes them to lift up their heads with an holy boldness and confidence, and without shame and fear: or as it may be rendered, who "is the salvations of my countenance" o; that is, who is or will be the author of full and complete salvation to me; which will be so public and open, so clear and manifest, as to be beheld by myself and others; and this the psalmist mentions, in order to remove his present dejections; and besides, this God of salvation he believed was his covenant God, and would be so even unto death; and therefore he had no just reason to be dejected and disquieted.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes


NET Notes: Psa 42:11 Heb “for again I will give him thanks, the saving acts of my face and my God.” The last line should be emended to read יְ...
Geneva Bible: Psa 42:10 [As] with a sword in my ( i ) bones, mine enemies reproach me; while they say daily unto me, Where [is] thy God?
( i ) That is, I am most grievously ...

Geneva Bible: Psa 42:11 ( k ) Why art thou cast down, O my soul? and why art thou disquieted within me? hope thou in God: for I shall yet praise him, [who is] the health of m...

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Psa 42:1-11
TSK Synopsis: Psa 42:1-11 - --1 David's zeal to serve God in the temple.5 He encourages his soul to trust in God.
MHCC -> Psa 42:6-11
MHCC: Psa 42:6-11 - --The way to forget our miseries, is to remember the God of our mercies. David saw troubles coming from God's wrath, and that discouraged him. But if on...
Matthew Henry -> Psa 42:6-11
Matthew Henry: Psa 42:6-11 - -- Complaints and comforts here, as before, take their turn, like day and night in the course of nature. I. He complains of the dejections of his spiri...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Psa 42:6-11
Keil-Delitzsch: Psa 42:6-11 - --
(Heb.: 42:7-12) The poet here continues to console himself with God's help. God Himself is indeed dishonoured in him; He will not suffer the trust ...
Constable: Psa 42:1--72:20 - --II. Book 2: chs. 42--72
In Book 1 we saw that all the psalms except 1, 2, 10, and 33 claimed David as their writ...

Constable: Psa 42:1-11 - --Psalm 42
Some ancient Hebrew manuscripts united Psalms 42 and 43 as one. This is understandable since th...
