collapse all  

Text -- Acts 5:4 (NET)

Strongs On/Off
Context
5:4 Before it was sold, did it not belong to you? And when it was sold, was the money not at your disposal? How have you thought up this deed in your heart? You have not lied to people but to God!”
Parallel   Cross Reference (TSK)   ITL  
Table of Contents

Word/Phrase Notes
Robertson , Vincent , Wesley , JFB , Clarke , Calvin , Defender , TSK

Word/Phrase Notes
Barnes , Poole , Haydock , Gill

Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes , Geneva Bible

Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis , Combined Bible , MHCC , Matthew Henry , Barclay , Constable , College , McGarvey

collapse all
Commentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)

Robertson: Act 5:4 - -- Whiles it remained ( menon ). Present active participle of mend, unsold, Peter means.

Whiles it remained ( menon ).

Present active participle of mend, unsold, Peter means.

Robertson: Act 5:4 - -- After it was sold ( prathen ). First aorist passive of pipraskō , to sell.

After it was sold ( prathen ).

First aorist passive of pipraskō , to sell.

Robertson: Act 5:4 - -- How is that thou hast conceived ( Ti hoti ethou ). Quid esto quod . See note on Luk 2:49. See also Act 5:9. Second aorist middle indicative second p...

How is that thou hast conceived ( Ti hoti ethou ).

Quid esto quod . See note on Luk 2:49. See also Act 5:9. Second aorist middle indicative second person singular of tithēmi . The devil filled his heart (Act 5:3), but all the same Ananias did it too and is wholly responsible.

Vincent: Act 5:4 - -- Whiles it remained, was it not thine own ( οὐχὶ μένον ? σοὶ ἔμενε ) A play on the words. Lit., remaining, did it no...

Whiles it remained, was it not thine own ( οὐχὶ μένον ? σοὶ ἔμενε )

A play on the words. Lit., remaining, did it not remain to thee? Rev., very happily, whiles it remained, did it not remain thine own?

Vincent: Act 5:4 - -- Conceived ( ἔθου ) Lit., put or fixed. Wherefore didst thou fix this deed in thy heart ? - i.e., resolve upon it.

Conceived ( ἔθου )

Lit., put or fixed. Wherefore didst thou fix this deed in thy heart ? - i.e., resolve upon it.

Wesley: Act 5:4 - -- It is true, whosoever among the Christians (not one excepted) had houses or lands, sold them, and laid the price at the feet of the apostles. But it w...

It is true, whosoever among the Christians (not one excepted) had houses or lands, sold them, and laid the price at the feet of the apostles. But it was in his own choice to be a Christian or not: and consequently either to sell his land, or keep it. And when it was sold, was it not in thy power? - For it does not appear that he professed himself a Christian when he sold it.

Wesley: Act 5:4 - -- So profanely to dissemble on so solemn an occasion? Thou hast not lied to men only, but to God also. Hence the Godhead of the Holy Ghost evidently app...

So profanely to dissemble on so solemn an occasion? Thou hast not lied to men only, but to God also. Hence the Godhead of the Holy Ghost evidently appears: since lying to him, Act 5:3, is lying to God.

JFB: Act 5:3-6 - -- "why . . . fill--"why hast thou suffered him to fill"

"why . . . fill--"why hast thou suffered him to fill"

JFB: Act 5:3-6 - -- So criminally entertaining his suggestion? Compare Act 5:4, "why hast thou conceived this thing in thine heart?" And see Joh 13:2, Joh 13:27.

So criminally entertaining his suggestion? Compare Act 5:4, "why hast thou conceived this thing in thine heart?" And see Joh 13:2, Joh 13:27.

JFB: Act 5:3-6 - -- To men under His supernatural illumination.

To men under His supernatural illumination.

JFB: Act 5:4 - -- From which we see how purely voluntary were all these sacrifices for the support of the infant community.

From which we see how purely voluntary were all these sacrifices for the support of the infant community.

JFB: Act 5:4 - -- To men so entirely the instruments of the directing Spirit that the lie was rather told to Him: language clearly implying both the distinct personalit...

To men so entirely the instruments of the directing Spirit that the lie was rather told to Him: language clearly implying both the distinct personality and the proper divinity of the Holy Ghost.

Clarke: Act 5:4 - -- Whiles it remained, was it not thine own? - See the note on Act 5:2, and see that also on Act 2:44 (note).

Whiles it remained, was it not thine own? - See the note on Act 5:2, and see that also on Act 2:44 (note).

Calvin: Act 5:4 - -- 4.Did it not remaining This amplifieth the offense because he sinned, being enforced by no necessity. For seeing it is no just or lawful excuse to ha...

4.Did it not remaining This amplifieth the offense because he sinned, being enforced by no necessity. For seeing it is no just or lawful excuse to have been provoked by some other means, how much worse is it to run headlong unto wickedness willingly, and, as it were of set purpose to pull down God’s vengeance? We gather out of this, that no man was enforced to sell his goods or lands. For Peter saith, that Ananias had free liberty to keep both his land and his money; because in the second member, the field which was sold is taken for the price itself. Therefore he should nevertheless have been counted faithful, though he had kept that which was his own. Whereby it appeareth that they are men destitute of their right wits, who say that it is not lawful for the faithful to have anything of their own.

Thou hast not lied to men, but to God Although the words be diversely construed, yet do I not doubt but that this confirmeth the former sentence. For hypocrites do so enwrap themselves in so many shifts, that they think they have nothing to do with God. And Peter speaketh thus expressly, because Ananias had deceived the Church. But he ought to have considered, that

“where two or three be gathered together in the name of Christ, he is present there as the chief governor,”
(Mat 18:20;)

yea, he ought to have behaved himself no otherwise in that assembly, than if he should have seen God with his eyes. For seeing that God will reign in the Church, if we give him any reverence, we must reverence that rule and government religiously which he exerciseth by his Word. The apostles were indeed men, but not private men, because God had put them in his stead. Furthermore, we must note, that he saith that he lieth to God who doth lie to the Holy Ghost. For the divinity of the Holy Ghost is manifestly proved by this form of speech. In like sort Paul saith, “Ye are the temples of God, because his Spirit dwelleth in you,” (1Co 3:16.)

Defender: Act 5:4 - -- In Act 5:3, Peter said that Ananias had lied to the Holy Ghost: in Act 5:4, he said that Ananias had lied to God. Thus, God and the Holy Ghost are use...

In Act 5:3, Peter said that Ananias had lied to the Holy Ghost: in Act 5:4, he said that Ananias had lied to God. Thus, God and the Holy Ghost are used synonymously, showing clearly that the Holy Spirit is God."

TSK: Act 5:4 - -- was it not thine : Exo 35:21, Exo 35:22, Exo 35:29; 1Ch 29:3, 1Ch 29:5, 1Ch 29:9, 1Ch 29:17; 1Co 8:8, 1Co 9:5-17; Phm 1:14 why : Act 8:21, Act 8:22; J...

collapse all
Commentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)

Barnes: Act 5:4 - -- Whiles it remained - As long as it remained unsold. This place proves that there was no "obligation"imposed on the disciples to sell their prop...

Whiles it remained - As long as it remained unsold. This place proves that there was no "obligation"imposed on the disciples to sell their property. They who did it, did it voluntarily; and it does not appear that it was done by all, or expected to be done by all.

And after it was sold ... - Even after the property was sold, and Ananias had the money, still there was no obligation on him to devote it in this way. He had the disposal of it still. The apostle mentions this to show him that his offence was especially aggravated. He was not "compelled"to sell his property - he had not even the poor pretence that he was "obliged"to dispose of it, and was "tempted"to withhold it for his own use. It was "all"his, and might have been retained if he had chosen.

Thou hast not lied unto men - Unto people "only,"or, it is not your "main"and "chief"offence that you have attempted to deceive people. It is true that Ananias "had"attempted to deceive the apostles, and it is true, also, that this was a crime; but still, the principal magnitude of the offence was that he had attempted to deceive "God."So small was his crime as committed against "men"that it was lost sight of by the apostles, and the great, crowning sin of attempting to deceive "God"was brought fully into view. Thus, David also saw his sin as committed against "God"to be so enormous that he lost sight of it as an offence to man, and said, "Against thee, thee only, have I sinned, and done this evil in thy sight,"Psa 51:4.

But unto God - It has been "particularly"and "eminently"against God. This is true, because:

(1)    He had professedly "devoted"it to God. The act, therefore, had express and direct reference to him.

(2)\caps1     i\caps0 t was an attempt to deceive him. It implied the belief of Ananias that God would not detect the crime, or see the motives of the heart.

(3)\caps1     i\caps0 t is the prerogative of God to judge of sincerity and hypocrisy; and this was a case, therefore, which came under his special notice. Compare Psa 139:1-4. The word "God"here is evidently used in its plain and obvious sense as denoting the "supreme divinity,"and the use of the word here shows that the Holy Spirit is "divine."The whole passage demonstrates, therefore, one of the important doctrines of the Christian religion, that the Holy Spirit is distinct from the Father and the Son, and yet is divine.

Poole: Act 5:4 - -- Whiles it remained, was it not thine own? A sufficient argument that there was no command (even then) to necessitate them to part with their estates,...

Whiles it remained, was it not thine own? A sufficient argument that there was no command (even then) to necessitate them to part with their estates, but only what the present and eminent necessity of the church did persuade them voluntarily unto. The doubling of this expostulation makes the conviction the more forcible.

In thine own power as a steward under God, to do what thou wouldst with it according to his will; and none are, or can be, otherwise disposers of what they possess.

Why hast thou conceived this thing in thine heart? It seems hence, that it was a deliberate and propensed iniquity.

Thou hast not lied unto men, but unto God: in that lying unto God is so often charged, and no express mention is made of Ananias’ s vow, some excuse him of sacrilege, and charge him the more deeply with ambition, covetousness, lying, and hypocrisy, to the apostles, whom he intended to deceive.

Haydock: Act 5:4 - -- Did it not remain to thee? That is, no one forced thee to make such a promise. --- And being sold, was it not in thy power, and at thy free dispos...

Did it not remain to thee? That is, no one forced thee to make such a promise. ---

And being sold, was it not in thy power, and at thy free disposal, before such a promise? but promises and vows must be kept. Thou hast not lied to men, but to God, by lying to the Holy Ghost. (Witham) ---

Thou hast not lied to men, only and principally, but to God also; for he had also lied to Peter, and the other apostles. (Menochius) ---

"If it displeased God," says St. Augustine, "to withdraw part of the money they had vowed to God, how is he angry, when chastity is vowed and not performed! ... let not such persons think to be condemned to corporal death, but to everlasting fire." (Serm. x. de diversis.) ---

St. Gregory, on t his same subject, says: "Ananias had vowed money to God, which afterwards, overcome by diabolical persuasion, he withdrew; but with what death he was punished, thou knowest. See, then, what judgment thou art to expect, for withdrawing, not money, but thyself, from Almighty God." (lib. i. ep. 33.)

Gill: Act 5:4 - -- Whiles it remained, was it not thine own,.... Before it was sold, it was his own proper estate; he had the sole propriety in it, and could have kept i...

Whiles it remained, was it not thine own,.... Before it was sold, it was his own proper estate; he had the sole propriety in it, and could have kept it, or disposed of it as he pleased: he was not obliged to sell it, he might have kept it as his own property; for selling of possessions at this time was a voluntary thing; it was what no man was forced to; it was a pure act of liberality, and what was not enjoined by the apostles; every man was left to his liberty.

And after it was sold, was it not in thine own power? that is, the price for which it was sold: before he had declared that he sold it, in order to give the whole of it to the church, had brought it to the apostles as the whole; it was in his own power to dispose of, as he pleased, whether to give the whole, or a part of it, or it. He might have kept it all if he had thought fit, or have given what portion he pleased.

Why hast thou conceived this thing in thine heart? for though Satan had an hand in it, and greatly solicited him to it, and spirited him up to do it, yet in conjunction with his own heart; and perhaps it began there, which Satan helped forward. It was not so of Satan as to excuse the wickedness of his heart. It was owing partly to the sin of covetousness, which reigned in him, and partly to a desire of vain glory, and being thought a very religious man, that he acted such a part, and was so notoriously guilty of lying and hypocrisy.

Thou hast not lied unto men, but unto God; that is, not to men only, for he had lied to the apostles; but to God also, to the Holy Ghost, who is truly and properly God, of which this passage is a full proof; and it was owing to his omniscience, which is a peculiar attribute of deity, that this wicked man, and this fraud of his, were discovered.

expand all
Commentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

NET Notes: Act 5:4 Grk “to men.” If Peter’s remark refers only to the apostles, the translation “to men” would be appropriate. But if (as i...

Geneva Bible: Act 5:4 Whiles it remained, was it not thine own? and after it was sold, was it not in thine own power? why hast thou ( d ) conceived this thing in thine hear...

expand all
Commentary -- Verse Range Notes

TSK Synopsis: Act 5:1-42 - --1 After that Ananias and Sapphira his wife for their hypocrisy, at Peter's rebuke had fallen down dead;12 and that the rest of the apostles had wrough...

Combined Bible: Act 5:4 - --notes on verse 3     

MHCC: Act 5:1-11 - --The sin of Ananias and Sapphira was, that they were ambitious of being thought eminent disciples, when they were not true disciples. Hypocrites may de...

Matthew Henry: Act 5:1-11 - -- The chapter begins with a melancholy but, which puts a stop to the pleasant and agreeable prospect of things which we had in the foregoing chapter...

Barclay: Act 5:1-11 - --There is no more vivid story in the book of Acts. There is no need to make a miracle of it. But it does show us something of the atmosphere which pr...

Constable: Act 3:1--6:8 - --B. The expansion of the church in Jerusalem 3:1-6:7 Luke recorded the events of this section (3:1-6:7) t...

Constable: Act 4:32--5:12 - --2. Internal compromise 4:32-5:11 As was true of Israel when she entered Canaan under Joshua's le...

Constable: Act 5:1-11 - --The hypocrisy of Ananias and Sapphira 5:1-11 We might conclude from what precedes that t...

Constable: Act 5:1-6 - --The death of Ananias 5:1-6 5:1-2 "But" introduces another sacrificial act that looked just as generous as Barnabas' (4:37). However in this case the m...

College: Act 5:1-42 - --ACTS 5 3. The Deceit of Ananias and Sapphira (5:1-11) 1 Now a man named Ananias, together with his wife Sapphira, also sold a piece of property. 2 W...

McGarvey: Act 5:3-4 - --3, 4. " But Peter said, Ananias, why has Satan filled thy heart, to lie to the Holy Spirit, and to keep back part of the price of the land? (4) While ...

expand all
Introduction / Outline

Robertson: Acts (Book Introduction) THE ACTS OF THE APOSTLES By Way of Introduction But for the Acts we should know nothing of the early apostolic period save what is told in the Epi...

JFB: Acts (Book Introduction) THIS book is to the Gospels what the fruit is to the tree that bears it. In the Gospels we see the corn of wheat falling into the ground and dying: in...

JFB: Acts (Outline) INTRODUCTION--LAST DAYS OF OUR LORD UPON EARTH--HIS ASCENSION. (Act 1:1-11) RETURN OF THE ELEVEN TO JERUSALEM--PROCEEDINGS IN THE UPPER ROOM TILL PEN...

TSK: Acts (Book Introduction) The Acts of the Apostles is a most valuable portion of Divine revelation; and, independently of its universal reception in the Christian church, as an...

TSK: Acts 5 (Chapter Introduction) Overview Act 5:1, After that Ananias and Sapphira his wife for their hypocrisy, at Peter’s rebuke had fallen down dead; Act 5:12, and that the r...

Poole: Acts 5 (Chapter Introduction) CHAPTER 5

MHCC: Acts (Book Introduction) This book unites the Gospels to the Epistles. It contains many particulars concerning the apostles Peter and Paul, and of the Christian church from th...

MHCC: Acts 5 (Chapter Introduction) (Act 5:1-11) The death of Ananias and Sapphira. (Act 5:12-16) The power which accompanied the preaching of the gospel. (Act 5:17-25) The apostles im...

Matthew Henry: Acts (Book Introduction) An Exposition, with Practical Observations, of The Acts of the Apostles We have with an abundant satisfaction seen the foundation of our holy religion...

Matthew Henry: Acts 5 (Chapter Introduction) In this chapter we have, I. The sin and punishment of Ananias and Sapphira, who, for lying to the Holy Ghost, were struck dead at the word of Pete...

Barclay: Acts (Book Introduction) INTRODUCTION TO THE ACTS OF THE APOSTLES A Precious Book In one sense Acts is the most important book in the New Testament. It is the simple truth t...

Barclay: Acts 5 (Chapter Introduction) Trouble In The Church (Act_5:1-11) The Attraction Of Christianity (Act_5:12-16) Arrest And Trial Once Again (Act_5:17-32) An Unexpected Ally (Act...

Constable: Acts (Book Introduction) Introduction Title The title "Acts of the Apostles" is very ancient. The Anti-Marcioni...

Constable: Acts (Outline) Outline I. The witness in Jerusalem 1:1-6:7 A. The founding of the church 1:1-2:46 ...

Constable: Acts Acts Bibliography Albright, William Foxwell. The Archaeology of Palestine. 1949. Revised ed. Pelican Archaeolog...

Haydock: Acts (Book Introduction) THE ACTS OF THE APOSTLES. INTRODUCTION. St. Luke, who had published his gospel, wrote also a second volume, which, from the first ages, hath bee...

Gill: Acts (Book Introduction) INTRODUCTION TO ACTS This book, in some copies, is called, "The Acts of the holy Apostles". It contains an history of the ministry and miracles of ...

College: Acts (Book Introduction) INTRODUCTION As early as the second century the title "The Acts of the Apostles" was given to this document. Before that time the work probably circu...

College: Acts (Outline) OUTLINE I. THE CHURCH IN JERUSALEM - 1:1-8:1a A. INTRODUCTION OF THE BOOK - 1:1-3 B. THE COMMISSIONING OF THE APOSTLES - 1:4-8 C. THE ASCENSI...

Advanced Commentary (Dictionaries, Hymns, Arts, Sermon Illustration, Question and Answers, etc)


created in 0.16 seconds
powered by
bible.org - YLSA