collapse all
Text -- Deuteronomy 21:15 (NET)

Parallel
Cross Reference (TSK)
ITL
Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: Deu 21:15 - -- This practice, though tolerated, is not hereby made lawful; but only provision is made for the children in this case.
This practice, though tolerated, is not hereby made lawful; but only provision is made for the children in this case.
JFB -> Deu 21:15-17
JFB: Deu 21:15-17 - -- In the original and all other translations, the words are rendered "have had," referring to events that have already taken place; and that the "had" h...
In the original and all other translations, the words are rendered "have had," referring to events that have already taken place; and that the "had" has, by some mistake, been omitted in our version, seems highly probable from the other verbs being in the past tense--"hers that was hated," not "hers that is hated"; evidently intimating that she (the first wife) was dead at the time referred to. Moses, therefore, does not here legislate upon the case of a man who has two wives at the same time, but on that of a man who has married twice in succession, the second wife after the decease of the first; and there was an obvious necessity for legislation in these circumstances; for the first wife, who was hated, was dead, and the second wife, the favorite, was alive; and with the feelings of a stepmother, she would urge her husband to make her own son the heir. This case has no bearing upon polygamy, which there is no evidence that the Mosaic code legalized.
Clarke -> Deu 21:15
Clarke: Deu 21:15 - -- One beloved, and another hated - That is, one loved less than the other. This is the true notion of the word hate in Scripture. So Jacob Hated Leah,...
One beloved, and another hated - That is, one loved less than the other. This is the true notion of the word hate in Scripture. So Jacob Hated Leah, that is, he loved her less than he did Rachel; and Jacob have I loved, but Esau have I Hated, that is, I have shown a more particular affection to the posterity of Jacob than I have to the posterity of Esau. See the note on Gen 29:31. From this verse we see that polygamy did exist under the Mosaic laws, and that it was put under certain regulations; but it was not enjoined, Moses merely suffered it, because of the hardness of their hearts, as our Lord justly remarks Mat 19:8.
Calvin -> Deu 21:15
Calvin: Deu 21:15 - -- 15.If a man have two wives. Inasmuch as it is here provided that a father should not unjustly transfer what belongs to one son to another, it is a pa...
15.If a man have two wives. Inasmuch as it is here provided that a father should not unjustly transfer what belongs to one son to another, it is a part and supplement of the Eighth Commandment, the substance of which is, that every one’s rights should be preserved to him. For, if the father substituted another son in the place of his first-born, it was unquestionably a kind of theft. But, since it rarely happens that a father unnaturally degrades his first-born from his precedence, if all are born of the same mother, God reminds us that He did not enact this law without cause; for, where polygamy was allowed, the mind of the husband was generally most inclined to the second wife; because, if he had loved the first with true affection, he would have been contented with her as the companion of his life and bed, and would not have thought of a second. When, therefore, the husband grew tired of his first wife, and desired a second, he might be coaxed by her blandishments to leave away from the children of his first marriage what naturally belonged to them. Hence, therefore, the necessity of the remedy whereby the father’s power of altering the right of primogeniture is barred; for, although they might allege that they only gave what was their own, yet it was an act of ungodly arrogance to reject him whom God had deigned to honor. For he who arrogates such power to himself, or who assigns the birth-right to whom he will, almost arrogates to himself the ability to create. This right, as is stated in verse 17, was a double portion of the paternal inheritance. The reason which is added, is equivalent to saying, that the first-born is the principal honor and ornament of the father. Still, if there was a just cause for disinheriting the first-born, another successor might be substituted in his stead, as Jacob shewed in his case when he disinherited Reuben. (Gen 49:4.) When it is said, “ before the son of the hated,” some expound it to mean “during his lifetime;” others retain the Hebrew phrase, “before his face.” Their opinion, however, is probable, who take this particle comparatively, for “instead of her son.” The wife is called hated, not that her husband is positively her enemy, but because he loves her least; for contempt is considered as hatred, and he is called an enemy who does not render conjugal benevolence.
TSK -> Deu 21:15

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Deu 21:15-17
Barnes: Deu 21:15-17 - -- Moses did not originate the rights of primogeniture (compare Gen 25:31), but recognized them, since he found them pre-existing in the general social...
Poole -> Deu 21:15
Poole: Deu 21:15 - -- Two wives either,
1. Both together; which practice, though tolerated, is not hereby made lawful, but only provision is made for the children in that...
Haydock -> Deu 21:15
Haydock: Deu 21:15 - -- Two wives. Moses never expressly (Haydock) sanctions polygamy; but he tolerates it frequently, as excused by custom, the example of the Patriarchs, ...
Two wives. Moses never expressly (Haydock) sanctions polygamy; but he tolerates it frequently, as excused by custom, the example of the Patriarchs, &c.; a toleration which Christ has revoked, as contrary to the primary design of God, and the institution of matrimony. (Calmet) (Matthew xix.)
Gill -> Deu 21:15
Gill: Deu 21:15 - -- If a man have two wives,.... Which is supposed, but not approved of, though permitted because of the hardness of men's hearts; for it was not so from ...
If a man have two wives,.... Which is supposed, but not approved of, though permitted because of the hardness of men's hearts; for it was not so from the beginning, when only one man and one woman were created, and joined together in marriage; but as it was connived at, and become customary, a law is made to prevent confusion, and preserve order in families:
one beloved and another hated; or less loved, yet continued his wife, and not divorced. Aben Ezra observes, this follows upon the former, because it is there said, that though first he had a desire to her (the captive beautiful woman), yet afterwards had no delight in her:
and they have borne him children both, the beloved and the hated; as Rachel and Leah did to Jacob, who were, the one very much beloved by him, and the other less:
and if the firstborn son be hers that was hated; or not so much beloved as the other, as was the case in the above instance.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes: Deu 21:15 Heb “both the one whom he loves and the one whom he hates.” On the meaning of the phrase “one whom he loves and one whom he hates...
Geneva Bible -> Deu 21:15
Geneva Bible: Deu 21:15 If a man have two wives, one beloved, and another ( g ) hated, and they have born him children, [both] the beloved and the hated; and [if] the firstbo...

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Deu 21:1-23
TSK Synopsis: Deu 21:1-23 - --1 The expiation of an uncertain murder.10 The usage of a captive taken to wife.15 The first-born is not to be disinherited upon private affection.18 A...
MHCC -> Deu 21:15-17
MHCC: Deu 21:15-17 - --This law restrains men from disinheriting their eldest sons without just cause. The principle in this case as to children, is still binding to parents...
Matthew Henry -> Deu 21:15-17
Matthew Henry: Deu 21:15-17 - -- This law restrains men from disinheriting their eldest sons out of mere caprice, and without just provocation. I. The case here put (Deu 21:15) is v...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Deu 21:15-17
Keil-Delitzsch: Deu 21:15-17 - --
The Right of the first-born. - Whilst the previous law was intended to protect the slave taken in war against the caprice of her Israelitish master,...
Constable: Deu 5:1--26:19 - --IV. MOSES' SECOND MAJOR ADDRESS: AN EXPOSITION OF THE LAW chs. 5--26
". . . Deuteronomy contains the most compre...

Constable: Deu 12:1--25:19 - --B. An exposition of selected covenant laws 12-25
Moses' homiletical exposition of the law of Israel that...

Constable: Deu 19:1--22:9 - --6. Laws arising from the sixth commandment 19:1-22:8
The sixth commandment is, "You shall not mu...

Constable: Deu 21:10-21 - --Wives and children 21:10-21
Everything in this section has some connection with the sixt...




