collapse all  

Text -- 1 Chronicles 10:9-14 (NET)

Strongs On/Off
Context
10:9 They stripped his corpse, and then carried off his head and his armor. They sent messengers throughout the land of the Philistines proclaiming the news to their idols and their people. 10:10 They placed his armor in the temple of their gods and hung his head in the temple of Dagon. 10:11 When all the residents of Jabesh Gilead heard about everything the Philistines had done to Saul, 10:12 all the warriors went and recovered the bodies of Saul and his sons and brought them to Jabesh. They buried their remains under the oak tree in Jabesh and fasted for seven days. 10:13 So Saul died because he was unfaithful to the Lord and did not obey the Lord’s instructions; he even tried to conjure up underworld spirits. 10:14 He did not seek the Lord’s guidance, so the Lord killed him and transferred the kingdom to David son of Jesse.
Parallel   Cross Reference (TSK)   ITL  

Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics

Names, People and Places:
 · Dagon a pagan god; the principal god of the Philistines (OS)
 · David a son of Jesse of Judah; king of Israel,son of Jesse of Judah; king of Israel
 · Jabesh a town of Gilead 20 km SE of Beth-Shan,father of king Shallum
 · Jabesh-gilead a town of Gilead 20 km SE of Beth-Shan
 · Jabesh-Gilead a town of Gilead 20 km SE of Beth-Shan
 · Jesse a son of Obed; the father of David the king and ancestor of Jesus,son of Obed of Judah; father of David
 · Philistines a sea people coming from Crete in 1200BC to the coast of Canaan
 · Saul the sixth king of Edom,son of Simeon and a Canaanite woman,son of Uzziah of Kohath son of Levi


Dictionary Themes and Topics: Wicked | Temple | TEREBINTH | Saul | PHILISTINES | OAK | Jabesh-gilead | JESSE | HEAD | GODS | Familiar Spirits | FAMILIAR | Death | Dagon's house | Dagon | DAVID | CORPSE | COMMUNION WITH DEMONS; DEVILS | CHRONICLES, BOOKS OF | BODY | more
Table of Contents

Word/Phrase Notes
Wesley , JFB , Clarke , Defender , TSK

Word/Phrase Notes
Barnes , Poole , Haydock , Gill

Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes , Geneva Bible

Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis , MHCC , Matthew Henry , Keil-Delitzsch , Constable , Guzik

Other
Critics Ask

collapse all
Commentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)

Wesley: 1Ch 10:10 - -- If we give not God the glory of our successes, even Philistines will rise up in judgment with us and condemn us. Shall Dagon have so great a place in ...

If we give not God the glory of our successes, even Philistines will rise up in judgment with us and condemn us. Shall Dagon have so great a place in their triumphs, and the true God be forgotten in ours?

Wesley: 1Ch 10:12 - -- Every day 'till evening, after the manner of the Jewish fasts.

Every day 'till evening, after the manner of the Jewish fasts.

Wesley: 1Ch 10:13 - -- Against God's express command: which is a great aggravation of any sin.

Against God's express command: which is a great aggravation of any sin.

Wesley: 1Ch 10:13 - -- Which also was contrary to a manifest command, Lev 19:31.

Which also was contrary to a manifest command, Lev 19:31.

Wesley: 1Ch 10:14 - -- He did in some sort, but not in a right manner, not humbly and penitently, not diligently and importunately, not patiently and perseveringly. Nor 'til...

He did in some sort, but not in a right manner, not humbly and penitently, not diligently and importunately, not patiently and perseveringly. Nor 'till he was brought to the last extremity. And then it was too late.

JFB: 1Ch 10:10 - -- It was common among the heathen to vow to a national or favorite deity, that, in the event of a victory, the armor of the enemy's king, or of some emi...

It was common among the heathen to vow to a national or favorite deity, that, in the event of a victory, the armor of the enemy's king, or of some eminent leader, should be dedicated to him as an offering of gratitude. Such trophies were usually suspended on the pillars of the temple.

JFB: 1Ch 10:10 - -- While the trunk or headless corpse was affixed to the wall of Beth-shan (1Sa 31:10).

While the trunk or headless corpse was affixed to the wall of Beth-shan (1Sa 31:10).

JFB: 1Ch 10:13 - -- In having spared the king of the Amalekites and taken the flocks of the people as spoils [1Sa 15:9], as well as in having consulted a pythoness [1Sa 2...

In having spared the king of the Amalekites and taken the flocks of the people as spoils [1Sa 15:9], as well as in having consulted a pythoness [1Sa 28:7]. Both of these acts were great sins--the first as a violation of God's express and positive command [1Sa 15:3], and the second as contrary to a well-known statute of the kingdom (Lev 19:31).

JFB: 1Ch 10:14 - -- He had done so in form (1Sa 28:6), but not in the spirit of a humble penitent, nor with the believing confidence of a sincere worshipper. His enquiry ...

He had done so in form (1Sa 28:6), but not in the spirit of a humble penitent, nor with the believing confidence of a sincere worshipper. His enquiry was, in fact, a mere mockery, and his total want of all right religious impressions was manifested by his rushing from God to a wretched impostor in the service of the devil [1Sa 28:7].

Clarke: 1Ch 10:11 - -- When all Jabesh-gilead heard - For a general account of the principles of heroism and gratitude from which this action of the men of Jabesh-gilead p...

When all Jabesh-gilead heard - For a general account of the principles of heroism and gratitude from which this action of the men of Jabesh-gilead proceeded, see the note on 1Sa 31:11, 1Sa 31:12

By the kindness of a literary friend, I am enabled to lay a farther illustration of this noble act before the reader, which he will find at the conclusion of the chapter.

Clarke: 1Ch 10:13 - -- Saul died for his transgression - See the concluding observations on the first book of Samuel (1Sa 31:13 (note)).

Saul died for his transgression - See the concluding observations on the first book of Samuel (1Sa 31:13 (note)).

Clarke: 1Ch 10:14 - -- Inquired not of the Lord - On these two last verses the Targum speaks thus: "And Saul died for the transgression by which he transgressed against th...

Inquired not of the Lord - On these two last verses the Targum speaks thus: "And Saul died for the transgression by which he transgressed against the Word of the Lord, and because he did not keep the commandment of the Lord when he warred against the house of Amalek; and because he consulted Pythons, and sought oracular answers from them. Neither did he ask counsel from before the Lord by Urim and Thummim, for he had slain the priests that were in Nob; therefore the Lord slew him, and transferred the kingdom to David the son of Jesse.

A Literary friend furnishes the following remarks: -

"The sacred writer, in the first book of Samuel, 1Sa 31:11-13, and 1Ch 10:11, 1Ch 10:12, after relating the defeat and death of Saul, and the ignominious treatment of his remains, thus concludes: -

"‘ And when the inhabitants of Jabesh-gilead heard of that which the Philistines had done to Saul, all the valiant men arose, and went all night, and took the body of Saul, and the bodies of his sons, from the wall of Beth-shan, and came to Jabesh, and burnt them there; and they took the bones, and buried them under a tree at Jabesh, and fasted seven days.’

"Often has this account been read with admiration of the bravery and devotedness of the men of Jabesh-gilead, but without considering that these men had any greater cause than others for honoring the remains of their sovereign; but, on reflection, it will be perceived that the strong impulse of gratitude prompted them to this honorable exertion. They remembered their preservation from destruction, and, which to brave men is more galling, from bearing marks of having been defeated, and being deprived of the honorable hope of wiping off disgrace, or defending their country at future seasons

"Reading these verses in conjunction with the attack of Nahash, we perceive the natural feelings of humanity, of honorable respect, prompting the men of Jabesh to act as they did in rescuing the bones of Saul and his family

"The father of Grecian poetry relates in how great a degree the warriors of ancient days honored the remains of their leaders; how severe were the contests for the body of the fallen chief, more determined oftentimes than the struggle for victory: this point of military honor was possibly excited or heightened by the religious idea so prevalent in his age, and after times, respecting the fate of the spirits of those who were unburied

"Homer wrote of events passing at no distant period from those recorded in the first volume of Samuel; and these accounts mutually corroborate each other, being in unison, not only with the feelings of humanity, but with the customs of ancient nations. These may be farther illustrated by comparing the conduct of the Philistines with regard to Saul and his sons, with that of the hero of the Iliad towards Hector, the most finished character of the poem. Saul had been a severe scourge to the Philistines throughout a long series of years; the illustrious chief of Troy had long warded off the ruin of his country, and destroyed the flower of her foes, independently of his last victory over Patroclus, which drew on his remains that dishonor which, however, fell only on his destroyer

"Should the siege of Troy be considered a fable, it may then be concluded that Homer introduced into his poems the customs and manners known to those for whose perusal he wrote, if these customs were not prevalent among his readers; but anxiety for the body of the illustrious dead, or regret for his death, has often caused success when all exertions prior to this powerful stimulus have not availed; and this even in our days

"The Philistines had long been confined to the southwest angle of the promised land, and in the earlier part of Saul’ s reign had suffered many and severe losses; yet it appears by this chapter that, alone or in conjunction with allies, they had been able to penetrate nearly to the banks of the Jordan, to fight the battle on Mount Gilboa. This could only have been effected by a march through great part of the kingdom of Israel

"Doubtless the attention of Saul in its defense might have been greatly distracted by his pursuit and fear of David, which appeared to have absorbed his whole mind; and it may account for the defenceless or weakened state of his forces

"These circumstances appear to corroborate the authenticity of these books, independently of the many private transactions therein recorded; particularly the interesting and singular friendship of Jonathan and David, a transaction not likely to occur to a forger of a narrative. J.W."

Defender: 1Ch 10:13 - -- The Lord can exact severe penalties upon those who reject His word in favor of guidance from the occult. The increasing reliance on "spirit-guides" an...

The Lord can exact severe penalties upon those who reject His word in favor of guidance from the occult. The increasing reliance on "spirit-guides" and similar so-called "New Age" concepts will eventually reap terrible judgments (Rev 9:20, Rev 9:21)."

Defender: 1Ch 10:14 - -- This statement seems at first to contradict that of 1Sa 28:6, which notes that "when Saul inquired of the Lord, the Lord answered him not." However, t...

This statement seems at first to contradict that of 1Sa 28:6, which notes that "when Saul inquired of the Lord, the Lord answered him not." However, the problem is that two different Hebrew words are involved. In 1Ch 10:14, the word translated "inquired" is darash, conveying the idea of "earnestly seeking." This Saul did not do. What he did was to "inquire" (Hebrew shaal) which suggests only that he asked in fear, without repentance or real faith. This kind of prayer the Lord does not honor."

TSK: 1Ch 10:9 - -- took : 1Ch 10:4; 1Sa 31:9, 1Sa 31:10; 2Sa 1:20; Mat 14:11 tidings : Jdg 16:23, Jdg 16:24; Dan 5:2-4, Dan 5:23

TSK: 1Ch 10:10 - -- their gods : 1Sa 31:10, Ashtaroth in the temple : 1Sa 5:2-7

their gods : 1Sa 31:10, Ashtaroth

in the temple : 1Sa 5:2-7

TSK: 1Ch 10:11 - -- when : 1Sa 11:1-11, 1Sa 31:11-13; 2Sa 2:4-7

TSK: 1Ch 10:12 - -- the oak : Gen 35:8; 2Sa 21:12-14 fasted : Gen 50:10; 2Sa 3:35

the oak : Gen 35:8; 2Sa 21:12-14

fasted : Gen 50:10; 2Sa 3:35

TSK: 1Ch 10:13 - -- committed : Heb. transgressed even against : 1Sa 13:13, 1Sa 15:2, 1Sa 15:23 for asking : 1Sa 28:7-20 a familiar : Exo 22:18; Lev 19:31, Lev 20:6; Deu ...

committed : Heb. transgressed

even against : 1Sa 13:13, 1Sa 15:2, 1Sa 15:23

for asking : 1Sa 28:7-20

a familiar : Exo 22:18; Lev 19:31, Lev 20:6; Deu 18:10-14; 2Ki 21:6; Isa 8:19; Act 8:9-11, Act 16:16-18

TSK: 1Ch 10:14 - -- inquired : Jdg 10:11-16; 1Sa 28:6; Eze 14:3-6 he slew : Pro 17:13; Isa 10:7, Isa 10:15 turned : 1Sa 13:14, 1Sa 15:28, 1Sa 16:1, 1Sa 16:11-13, 1Sa 28:1...

collapse all
Commentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)

Barnes: 1Ch 10:13 - -- For his transgression - Compare 1Ch 9:1. The "transgression"intended is probably the disobedience with respect to Amalek, recorded in 1Sa 15:1-...

For his transgression - Compare 1Ch 9:1. The "transgression"intended is probably the disobedience with respect to Amalek, recorded in 1Sa 15:1-9 (compare 1Sa 28:17-18).

Poole: 1Ch 10:10 - -- And his body severed from his head to the wall of Beth-shan, 1Sa 31:10 .

And his body severed from his head to the wall of Beth-shan, 1Sa 31:10 .

Poole: 1Ch 10:12 - -- To wit, every day till evening, after the manner of the Jewish fasts.

To wit, every day till evening, after the manner of the Jewish fasts.

Poole: 1Ch 10:13 - -- Saul died for his transgression: the sense is, Wonder not that Saul fell by the hands of the Philistines, who were armed against him by his own sin a...

Saul died for his transgression: the sense is, Wonder not that Saul fell by the hands of the Philistines, who were armed against him by his own sin and by God’ s vengeance for it.

Against the word of the Lord against God’ s express, and plain, and positive command; which is a great aggravation of any sin.

For asking counsel of one that had a familiar spirit which also was contrary to a manifest command, Lev 19:31 , and moreover, contrary to his own conscience, which was so fully convinced hereof, that he had endeavoured the utter extirpation of all such persons, in pursuance of God’ s law. See 1Sa 28:9 .

To inquire of it concerning the event of the approaching battle.

Poole: 1Ch 10:14 - -- Inquired not of the Lord Object. Saul inquired of the Lord, 1Sa 28:6 . Answ He did so, but not in a right manner, not humbly and penitently, not...

Inquired not of the Lord

Object. Saul inquired of the Lord, 1Sa 28:6 .

Answ He did so, but not in a right manner, not humbly and penitently, not diligently and importunately, not patiently and perseveringly; but when God would not answer him speedily, he gives it over, and goes from God to the devil. Compare 1Sa 14:18,19 . Such an inconsiderable and trifling inquiry as Saul made, is justly accounted to be no inquiry at all; as they are said not to eat the Lord’ s supper , 1Co 11:20 , who did eat it in a sinful and irregular manner.

Haydock: 1Ch 10:9 - -- To be. Hebrew, "to carry tidings to their idols, (sorrows) and to the people." They exposed the spoils in the temples, and gave thanks to their ido...

To be. Hebrew, "to carry tidings to their idols, (sorrows) and to the people." They exposed the spoils in the temples, and gave thanks to their idols for the victory.

Haydock: 1Ch 10:10 - -- Head, while his body was hung on the walls of Bethsan, 1 Kings xxxi. 10. (Calmet) --- The temple of Dagon was contiguous to the wall. (Du Hamel)

Head, while his body was hung on the walls of Bethsan, 1 Kings xxxi. 10. (Calmet) ---

The temple of Dagon was contiguous to the wall. (Du Hamel)

Haydock: 1Ch 10:12 - -- Oak, well known at Jabes. Elsewhere the word is translated, the grove. (Calmet)

Oak, well known at Jabes. Elsewhere the word is translated, the grove. (Calmet)

Haydock: 1Ch 10:13 - -- For. Septuagint, "in his iniquities." (Haydock) --- See 1 Kings xiii. 9., and xv. 23. Saul offered sacrifice unlawfully, and spared some of the A...

For. Septuagint, "in his iniquities." (Haydock) ---

See 1 Kings xiii. 9., and xv. 23. Saul offered sacrifice unlawfully, and spared some of the Amalecites. (Worthington)

Gill: 1Ch 10:1-12 - -- See Gill on 1Sa 31:1.

See Gill on 1Sa 31:1.

Gill: 1Ch 10:13 - -- So Saul died for his transgression,.... See Gill on 1Sa 31:13 A violent and dishonourable death, which was suffered on account of the sins he was guil...

So Saul died for his transgression,.... See Gill on 1Sa 31:13 A violent and dishonourable death, which was suffered on account of the sins he was guilty of:

one was, which he committed against the Lord, even against the word of the Lord, which he kept not; both in not staying for Samuel the time appointed, and by sparing the Amalekites whom he was bid to destroy, 1Sa 13:13.

and also for asking counsel of one that had a familiar spirit, to inquire of it; what he should do with respect to engaging in battle with the Philistines, 1Sa 28:8 which to do was contrary to an express command of God, Lev 19:31.

Gill: 1Ch 10:14 - -- And inquired not of the Lord,.... For though he did inquire in some sense in an external, careless, and hypocritical manner, yet not done seriously, s...

And inquired not of the Lord,.... For though he did inquire in some sense in an external, careless, and hypocritical manner, yet not done seriously, sincerely, and heartily, nor with constancy; it was accounted as if he inquired not at all, 1Sa 28:6 the Targum adds another reason of his death, because he killed the priests of Nob; but that is not in the text:

therefore he slew him; or suffered him to be slain:

and turned the kingdom unto David the son of Jesse; translated the kingdom of Israel out of Saul's family, upon his death, into Jesse's, even unto David; for the sake of which observation this short account is given of the last end of Saul.

expand all
Commentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

NET Notes: 1Ch 10:10 Or “god.” The Hebrew term may be translated as singular or plural depending on the context.

NET Notes: 1Ch 10:12 Heb “their bones.”

NET Notes: 1Ch 10:13 Heb “and Saul died because of his unfaithfulness by which he acted unfaithfully against the Lord, concerning the word of the Lord which he did n...

NET Notes: 1Ch 10:14 Heb “he”; the referent (the Lord) has been specified in the translation for clarity.

Geneva Bible: 1Ch 10:10 And they put his armour in the house of their gods, and fastened his head in the temple of ( a ) Dagon. ( a ) Which was the idol of the Philistines, ...

expand all
Commentary -- Verse Range Notes

TSK Synopsis: 1Ch 10:1-14 - --1 Saul's overthrow and death.8 The Philistines triumph over Saul.11 The kindness of Jabesh-gilead towards Saul and his sons.13 Saul's sin, for which t...

MHCC: 1Ch 10:1-14 - --The design chiefly in view in these books of the Chronicles, appears to be to preserve the records of the house of David. Therefore the writer repeats...

Matthew Henry: 1Ch 10:8-14 - -- Here, I. From the triumph of the Philistines over the body of Saul we may learn, 1. That the greater dignity men are advanced to the greater disgrac...

Keil-Delitzsch: 1Ch 10:8-13 - -- On the following day the Philistines, in their search among the fallen, found and plundered the bodies of Saul and of his sons, and sent the head an...

Keil-Delitzsch: 1Ch 10:14 - -- And because he inquired not of the Lord, therefore He slew him. According to 1Sa 28:6, Saul did indeed inquire of Jahve, but received no answer, bec...

Constable: 1Ch 10:1--29:30 - --II. THE REIGN OF DAVID chs. 10--29 In all of Chronicles the writer assumed his readers' acquaintance with the ot...

Constable: 1Ch 10:1-14 - --A. The Death of Saul ch. 10 "Having established the remnant's genealogical link with the Davidic and pri...

Guzik: 1Ch 10:1-14 - --1 Chronicles 10 - The Death of Saul "Having established Israel's historical setting and ethnic bounds in the preceding genealogies, the Chronicle...

expand all
Commentary -- Other

Critics Ask: 1Ch 10:14 1 CHRONICLES 10:14—Did Saul inquire of the Lord or not? PROBLEM: First Samuel 28:6 says “when Saul inquired of the Lord, the Lord did not ans...

expand all
Introduction / Outline

JFB: 1 Chronicles (Book Introduction) THE FIRST AND SECOND BOOKS OF CHRONICLES were also considered as one by the ancient Jews, who called them "words of days," that is, diaries or journal...

JFB: 1 Chronicles (Outline) ADAM'S LINE TO NOAH. (1Ch. 1:1-23) SHEM'S LINE TO ABRAHAM. (1Ch 1:24-28) SONS OF ISHMAEL. (1Ch 1:29-31) SONS OF KETURAH. (1Ch 1:32-33) POSTERITY OF A...

TSK: 1 Chronicles 10 (Chapter Introduction) Overview 1Ch 10:1, Saul’s overthrow and death; 1Ch 10:8, The Philistines triumph over Saul; 1Ch 10:11, The kindness of Jabesh-gilead towards Sau...

Poole: 1 Chronicles (Book Introduction) FIRST BOOK OF THE CHRONICLES THE ARGUMENT THESE Books of the CHRONICLES are not the same which are so called, 1Ki 14:19 , and elsewhere, (because...

Poole: 1 Chronicles 10 (Chapter Introduction) CHRONICLES CHAPTER 10 Saul’ s overthrow and death, 1Ch 10:1-7 . The Philistines triumph over Saul, 1Ch 10:8-10 . The kindness of Jabesh-gilead...

MHCC: 1 Chronicles (Book Introduction) The books of Chronicles are, in a great measure, repetitions of what is in the books of Samuel and of the Kings, yet there are some excellent useful t...

MHCC: 1 Chronicles 10 (Chapter Introduction) The death of Saul.

Matthew Henry: 1 Chronicles (Book Introduction) An Exposition, with Practical Observations, of The First Book of Chronicles In common things repetition is thought needless and nauseous; but, in sacr...

Matthew Henry: 1 Chronicles 10 (Chapter Introduction) The design of Ezra, in these books of the Chronicles, was to preserve the records of the house of David, which, though much sunk and lessened in a ...

Constable: 1 Chronicles (Book Introduction) Introduction Title The earliest Hebrew title for the Books of Chronicles translates as...

Constable: 1 Chronicles (Outline) Outline I. Israel's historical roots chs. 1-9 A. The lineage of David chs. 1-3 ...

Constable: 1 Chronicles 1 Chronicles Bibliography Ackroyd, Peter R. I and II Chronicles, Ezra, Nehemiah. London: SCM Press, 1973. ...

Haydock: 1 Chronicles (Book Introduction) THE FIRST BOOK OF PARALIPOMENON. INTRODUCTION. These Books are called by the Greek Interpreters, Paralipomenon; ( Greek: Paraleipomenon, ) tha...

Gill: 1 Chronicles (Book Introduction) INTRODUCTION TO 1 CHRONICLES This and the following book were reckoned by the Jews as one book, as appears by the Masoretic note at the end of the ...

Gill: 1 Chronicles 10 (Chapter Introduction) INTRODUCTION TO 1 CHRONICLES 10 This part, 1Ch 10:1 which gives an account of the last battle of Saul with the Philistines, and of his death and bu...

Advanced Commentary (Dictionaries, Hymns, Arts, Sermon Illustration, Question and Answers, etc)


created in 0.20 seconds
powered by
bible.org - YLSA