
Text -- 1 Kings 2:5 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: 1Ki 2:5 - -- That is, against me; in what he did against Abner and Amasa: whose death was a great injury to David, as it was a breach of his laws and peace; a cont...
That is, against me; in what he did against Abner and Amasa: whose death was a great injury to David, as it was a breach of his laws and peace; a contempt of his person and government; a pernicious example to his subjects, and a great scandal to him, as if Joab had been only David's instrument, to affect what he secretly designed.

Wesley: 1Ki 2:5 - -- He slew them as if they had been in the state of war, when there was not only a cessation of arms, but also a treaty of peace.
He slew them as if they had been in the state of war, when there was not only a cessation of arms, but also a treaty of peace.

Wesley: 1Ki 2:5 - -- This is added to note his impenitency, that although by his perfidious manner of killing them when he pretended to embrace them, he stained his own ga...
This is added to note his impenitency, that although by his perfidious manner of killing them when he pretended to embrace them, he stained his own garments with their blood, yet he was not ashamed of it, but gloried in it, and marched boldly along with the army, with the same girdle and shoes which were sprinkled with their blood.
JFB: 1Ki 2:5-6 - -- The insolent and imperious conduct of that general had not only been deeply offensive to the feelings (2Sa 18:5-15; 2Sa 19:5-7), but calculated to bri...
The insolent and imperious conduct of that general had not only been deeply offensive to the feelings (2Sa 18:5-15; 2Sa 19:5-7), but calculated to bring reproach on the character, to injure the prospects, and endanger the throne of David. Passing over the injuries committed directly against himself, David dwelt with strong feelings on the base assassination of Abner and Amasa.

JFB: 1Ki 2:5-6 - -- The obvious meaning is, that in peace he acted towards them as if they had been in a state of warfare; but perhaps these graphic expressions might be ...
The obvious meaning is, that in peace he acted towards them as if they had been in a state of warfare; but perhaps these graphic expressions might be designed to impress Solomon's mind more strongly with a sense of the malice, treachery, and cruelty by which those murders were characterized.
Clarke: 1Ki 2:5 - -- Thou knowest - what Joab - did to me - He did every thing bad and dishonorable in itself, in the murder of Abner and Amasa, and indeed in the death ...
Thou knowest - what Joab - did to me - He did every thing bad and dishonorable in itself, in the murder of Abner and Amasa, and indeed in the death of the profligate Absalom

Clarke: 1Ki 2:5 - -- Shed the blood of war - upon his girdle - and in his shoes - He stabbed them while he pretended to embrace them, so that their blood gushed out on h...
Shed the blood of war - upon his girdle - and in his shoes - He stabbed them while he pretended to embrace them, so that their blood gushed out on his girdle, and fell into his shoes! This was a most abominable aggravation of his crimes.
TSK -> 1Ki 2:5
TSK: 1Ki 2:5 - -- Joab : 1Ki 1:7, 1Ki 1:18, 1Ki 1:19; 2Sa 3:39, 2Sa 18:5, 2Sa 18:12, 2Sa 18:14, 2Sa 19:5-7
Abner : 2Sa 3:27
Amasa : 2Sa 20:10
Jether : 2Sa 17:25, Ithra
...

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> 1Ki 2:5
Barnes: 1Ki 2:5 - -- In his directions with respect to certain important persons, David, anxious for the security of his young successor’ s kingdom, allows old anim...
In his directions with respect to certain important persons, David, anxious for the security of his young successor’ s kingdom, allows old animosities to revive, and is willing to avenge himself indirectly and by deputy, though he had been withheld by certain scruples from taking vengeance in his own person. We must not expect Gospel morality from the saints of the Old Testament. They were only the best men of their several ages and nations. The maxim of "them of old time,"whether Jews or Gentiles, was "Love your friends and hate your enemies"(see Mat 5:43); and David perhaps was not in this respect in advance of his age. Joab’ s chief offence against David, besides his two murders, was no doubt his killing Absalom 2Sa 18:14. Another serious crime was his support of the treasonable attempt of Adonijah 1Ki 1:7. But besides these flagrant misdemeanours, he seems to have offended David by a number of little acts. He was a constant thorn in his side. He treated him with scant respect, taking important steps without his orders 2Sa 3:26, remonstrating with him roughly and rudely 2Sa 2:24-25, almost betraying his secrets 2Sa 11:19-21, and, where he disliked the orders given him, disobeying them 1Ch 21:6. David allowed his ascendancy, but he chafed against it, finding this "son of Zeruiah,"in particular "too hard"for him (margin reference).
Put the blood of war upon his girdle ... - Meaning "The blood of Amasa spirited all over the girdle to which the sword of Joab was attached; and the sandals on his feet were reddened with the stains left by the falling corpse."
Poole -> 1Ki 2:5
Poole: 1Ki 2:5 - -- Did to me i.e. against me; either, first, Directly and immediately; how insolently and imperiously he hath carried himself towards me from time to ti...
Did to me i.e. against me; either, first, Directly and immediately; how insolently and imperiously he hath carried himself towards me from time to time, trampling upon my authority and commands when they thwarted his humour or interest, provoking my spirit by his words and actions. See 2Sa 3:39 19:7 . Or, secondly, Indirectly, in what he did against Abner and Amasa; whose death was a great injury to David, as it was a breach of his laws and peace; a contempt of his person and government; a pernicious example to others of his subjects upon the like occasions; a great scandal and dishonour to him, as if Joab had been only David’ s instrument, to effect what he secretly desired and designed; whereby the hearts of his people either were or might have been alienated from him, and inflamed against him, and the wounds which were well nigh healed might have been widened again, and made to bleed afresh.
And what he did or, even ; the following branches being added as an explication of the foregoing, to show what and how he acted towards or against David. Or, and particularly ; as his other miscarriages, so these especially.
Shed the blood of war in peace he slew them as if they had been in the state and act of war, when there was not only a cessation of arms, but also a treaty and agreement of peace, of which also they were the great procurers and promoters.
Upon his girdle that was about his loins, and in his shoes that were on his feet: this is added to note his impudence and impenitency, that although by his perfidious manner of killing them, when he pretended to embrace them, he stained his own garments with their blood, yet he was not ashamed of it, but gloried in it, and marched boldly along with the army with the same girdle and shoes which were sprinkled with their blood. See 2Sa 20:10 .
Haydock -> 1Ki 2:5
Haydock: 1Ki 2:5 - -- Joab. These instructions given by David to his son, with relation to Joab and Semei, proceeded not from any rancour of heart, or private pique; but ...
Joab. These instructions given by David to his son, with relation to Joab and Semei, proceeded not from any rancour of heart, or private pique; but from a zeal for justice: that crimes so public and heinous might not pass unpunished. (Challoner) ---
David and Solomon esteemed themselves, in a manner, defiled, as long as these continued unpunished, ver. 31. Joab had behaved to David with great insolence, after the death of Absalom. (Haydock) ---
He had lately sided with Adonias. (Menochius) ---
But what touched the good old king more particularly, were the treacherous murders of two great generals, who had put themselves under his protection, and were endeavouring to promote his welfare. Only the fear of greater commotions had hitherto prevented David from bringing his nephew to public execution, as the people expected. He deemed it requisite to remind his successor of this obligation, when his power should be sufficiently strong, that the impunity of such daring offenders might not destroy the commonwealth. (Haydock) ---
Peace. Pretending affection. Joab had treated Abner and Amasa as the worst of enemies, and their blood had stained his garments. (Menochius)
Gill -> 1Ki 2:5
Gill: 1Ki 2:5 - -- Moreover thou knowest also what Joab the son of Zeruiah did unto me,.... In slaying Absalom, contrary to his orders, and in behaving insolently toward...
Moreover thou knowest also what Joab the son of Zeruiah did unto me,.... In slaying Absalom, contrary to his orders, and in behaving insolently towards him on account of his mourning for him, and at other times; but as these things might not be personally known to Solomon, only by hearsay, this may respect his disloyalty towards him, in joining with Adonijah, who set himself up for king in his lifetime, and without his knowledge and consent; or it may respect the instances next mentioned, in which he did injury to the interest, honour, and character of David:
and, or "even",
what he did to the two captains of the host of Israel, unto Abner the son of Ner, and unto Amasa the son of Jether, whom he slew; to Abner who was under Ishbosheth, and Amasa under David, who had not only the promise of the post, but was actually in it when Joab slew him; and indeed out of envy to him for it:
and shed the blood of war in peace; when they were at peace with him, as if they had been in open war; and even under a pretence of friendship to them, asking of their peace and welfare, as if he meant nothing less than to behave peaceably towards them; hence the Targum is,
"whom he slew in craftiness:''
and put the blood of war upon the girdle that was about his loins,
and in his shoes that were in his feet; which particularly respects the affair of Amasa, whose blood he shed with his sword, that dropped out of its scabbard, girded upon his loins, and into which he put it again, all over bloody, and wore it girded upon his loins; and which he also stooped for when it fell, as if he was going to unloose or buckle his shoes, and into which the blood ran down when he stabbed him; and after this barbarous action marched on without any shame or remorse, with his bloody sword on his loins, and the blood of the murdered in his shoes.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes: 1Ki 2:5 Heb “and he shed the blood of battle when he killed which is on his waist and on his sandal[s] which are on his feet.” That is, he covered...
Geneva Bible -> 1Ki 2:5
Geneva Bible: 1Ki 2:5 Moreover thou knowest also what Joab the son of Zeruiah did to me, [and] what he did to the two captains of the hosts of Israel, unto Abner the son of...

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> 1Ki 2:1-46
TSK Synopsis: 1Ki 2:1-46 - --1 David, having given a charge to Solomon,3 of religiousness;5 of Joab;7 of Barzillai;8 of Shimei;10 dies.12 Solomon succeeds.13 Adonijah, moving Bath...
MHCC -> 1Ki 2:5-11
MHCC: 1Ki 2:5-11 - --These dying counsels concerning Joab and Shimei, did not come from personal anger, but for the security of Solomon's throne, which was the murders he ...
Matthew Henry -> 1Ki 2:1-11
Matthew Henry: 1Ki 2:1-11 - -- David, that great and good man, is here a dying man (1Ki 2:1), and a dead man, 1Ki 2:10. It is well there is another life after this, for death stai...
Keil-Delitzsch -> 1Ki 2:1-11
Keil-Delitzsch: 1Ki 2:1-11 - --
The anointing of Solomon as king, which was effected by David'scommand (1 Kings 1), is only briefly mentioned in 1Ch 23:1 in the words,"When David w...
Constable: 1Ki 1:1--11:43 - --I. THE REIGN OF SOLOMON chs. 1--11
The Holy Spirit led the writer of Kings to give an interpretation of history,...

Constable: 1Ki 1:1--2:13 - --A. Solomon's Succession to David's Throne 1:1-2:12
The first segment of the writer's story (1:1-2:12) co...
