![](images/minus.gif)
Text -- 1 Samuel 21:13-15 (NET)
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/information.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley -> 1Sa 21:15
Wesley: 1Sa 21:15 - -- It is highly probable, Achish was aware, that this madness was counterfeit. But being desirous to preserve David, he speaks as if he thought it real.
It is highly probable, Achish was aware, that this madness was counterfeit. But being desirous to preserve David, he speaks as if he thought it real.
JFB: 1Sa 21:13 - -- It is supposed to have been an attack of epilepsy, real or perhaps only pretended. This disease is relieved by foaming at the mouth.
It is supposed to have been an attack of epilepsy, real or perhaps only pretended. This disease is relieved by foaming at the mouth.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
JFB: 1Sa 21:13 - -- No wonder that Achish supposed him insane, as such an indignity, whether done by another, or one's self, to the beard, is considered in the East an in...
No wonder that Achish supposed him insane, as such an indignity, whether done by another, or one's self, to the beard, is considered in the East an intolerable insult.
Clarke: 1Sa 21:13 - -- And he changed his behavior - Some imagine David was so terrified at the danger to which he was now exposed, that he was thrown into a kind of frenz...
And he changed his behavior - Some imagine David was so terrified at the danger to which he was now exposed, that he was thrown into a kind of frenzy, accompanied with epileptic fits. This opinion is countenanced by the Septuagint, who render the passage thus:
If this translation be allowed, it will set the conduct of David in a clearer point of view than the present translation does. But others think the whole was a feigned conduct, and that he acted the part of a lunatic or madman in order to get out of the hands of Achish and his courtiers. Many vindicate this conduct of David; but if mocking be catching, according to the proverb, he who feigns himself to be mad may, through the just judgment of God, become so. I dare not be the apologist of insincerity or lying. Those who wish to look farther into this subject may consult Dr. Chandler, Mr. Saurin, and Ortlob, in the first volume of Dissertations, at the end of the Dutch edition of the Critici Sacri.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: 1Sa 21:15 - -- Shall this fellow come into my house? - I will not take into my service a man who is liable to so grievous a disease. Chandler, who vindicates David...
Shall this fellow come into my house? - I will not take into my service a man who is liable to so grievous a disease. Chandler, who vindicates David’ s feigning himself, mad, concludes thus: "To deceive the deceiver is in many instances meritorious, in none criminal. And what so likely to deceive as the very reverse of that character which they had so misconstrued? He was undone as a wise man, he had a chance to escape as a madman; he tried, and the experiment succeeded."I confess I can neither feel the force nor the morality of this. Deceit and hypocrisy can never be pleasing in the sight of God.
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> 1Sa 21:13
Barnes: 1Sa 21:13 - -- Scrabbled - literally, made marks (margin), namely, the mark of the "tau"(t), which in the ancient Hebrew and Phoenician was in the shape of a ...
Scrabbled - literally, made marks (margin), namely, the mark of the "tau"(t), which in the ancient Hebrew and Phoenician was in the shape of a cross. (See Eze 9:4.)
On the doors of the gate - The gate of Achish’ s palace-yard or court, in which the attendants waited. The house itself stood in this court. (Compare Est 2:19, Est 2:21.)
Poole: 1Sa 21:13 - -- His behaviour his speech and gesture; and, it may be, his habit also.
Feigned himself mad which they might the more easily believe, partly because ...
His behaviour his speech and gesture; and, it may be, his habit also.
Feigned himself mad which they might the more easily believe, partly because of the disappointment of his great hopes, and his extreme danger and trouble from Saul, which might well make him mad; and partly because he had put himself into their hands, which they supposed none but a fool or a madman would have done. And David counterfeited this madness, that he might procure both their pity and their contempt; that they being freed from jealousies and fears of future mischief from David, and from his wise conduct, of which they had sad experience, might be secure of him, and so spare him.
In their hands i.e. whilst he was in their power, and before them.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: 1Sa 21:14 - -- Ye see the man is mad and so were Achish and his men too, to be so soon cheated. But this must be ascribed to the wise and powerful providence of God...
Ye see the man is mad and so were Achish and his men too, to be so soon cheated. But this must be ascribed to the wise and powerful providence of God, who, in answer to David’ s prayer now made, which is recorded Ps 34 Ps 61 , did infatuate them, as he hath done many others in like cases.
Wherefore then have ye brought him to me? what service can I expect from him? or what cause have I to fear him?
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: 1Sa 21:15 - -- I need wise men, not such fools or madmen as this is. I will not have my court disgraced with entertaining such fellows.
I need wise men, not such fools or madmen as this is. I will not have my court disgraced with entertaining such fellows.
Haydock: 1Sa 21:13 - -- Countenance. Hebrew, "sentiment, (Calmet) or, behaviour." (Haydock) ---
Chaldean, "reason." He no longer acted as a prudent man, but like a foo...
Countenance. Hebrew, "sentiment, (Calmet) or, behaviour." (Haydock) ---
Chaldean, "reason." He no longer acted as a prudent man, but like a fool. ---
Down; not fainting, (Calmet) but like one in an epileptic fit. (Haydock) ---
Hebrew, "he feigned himself mad." Chaldean, "stupid." ---
Stumbled. Hebrew, "wrote, or made figures upon." Septuagint, "beat the drum upon the gates of the city, and he was carried about, or acted the fool, in his hands, ( Greek: parephereto en tais chersin, autou: Amama would have, Greek: auton, their ) and he fell against the doors of the gate," &c. They seem to give a double translation. St. Augustine says, "we cannot understand how David could be carried in his own hands. But we understand how it was verified in Christ. For Christ was carried in his own hands at his last supper, when he gave, or commending, his own body, he said, This, &c., for he then carried his own body in his own hands." (In Psalm xxxiii. conc. i.) Ferebat enim illud corpus in manibus suis. Amama may laugh at St. Augustine's ignorance of Hebrew, but the holy doctor was at least a sincere Catholic. (Haydock) ---
Beard. We find some wretched objects doing the same, Mark ix. 17. The spittle was deemed infectious. Et illic isti qui sputatur, morbus interdum venit. (Plautus in Captivis.)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Haydock: 1Sa 21:15 - -- House. David had not rushed into the palace of his own accord, but wished to remain concealed. Some of the people however knew him, and would have ...
House. David had not rushed into the palace of his own accord, but wished to remain concealed. Some of the people however knew him, and would have him to enlist as one of the soldiers of Achis; (Menochius) or even designed to get him put to death, which made him have recourse to this expedient. Some of the saints have imitated him, to avoid worldly honours and dignities of the Church. (Haydock) ---
Thus the conduct of Jesus Christ himself, was accounted foolishness by worldlings, Mark iii. 21., Luke xxiii. 11., and 1 Corinthians i. 23. (Ven. Bede) (Worthington)
Gill: 1Sa 21:13 - -- And he changed his behaviour before them,.... Behaved like a fool, or a madman: or changed his "taste" s; which some understand of his reason, acted a...
And he changed his behaviour before them,.... Behaved like a fool, or a madman: or changed his "taste" s; which some understand of his reason, acted as if he was deprived of it; and others of his speech, his words and the accent of them, drawled them out, as such persons do:
and feigned himself mad in their hands; for in their hands he was, being taken by them, as the title of the fifty sixth psalm shows, Psa 56:1; and this stratagem he used to get himself out of their hands, acting the part of a madman, delirious, and out of his senses:
and scrabbled on the doors of the gate; as if he was writing something there, and making marks upon them:
and let his spittle fall down upon his beard; slavered, as idiots and madmen do; and however mean this may seem in David to act such a part, it cannot be condemned as wicked, since it was only a stratagem to deliver himself, out of an enemy's hand, and stratagems are always allowed to be used against an enemy; and such a method as this has been taken by men of the greatest sense and wit, as by Brutus t and Solon u; and yet, according to the Vulgate Latin and Septuagint versions, this case of his was real and not feigned; that through the surprise of being known in the court of Achish, he was seized with an epilepsy; that his countenance was changed, and his mouth distorted, as persons in such fits are; that he fell among them as one convulsed, and fell at, and dashed against the doors of the gates, and foamed at the mouth, as such persons do; see Luk 9:39; and so in the following words the Greek version is, ye see the man is an epileptic; I do not want epileptics; but the thirty fourth and fifty sixth psalms, composed by him at this time, show that as he was of a sound mind, so in good health of body, and not subject to such fits as here represented, see Psa 34:1; which would have rendered him unfit for such composures.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: 1Sa 21:14 - -- Then said Achish to his servants, lo, you see the man is mad,.... Which he said, as willing his servants should think so, and therefore rather the obj...
Then said Achish to his servants, lo, you see the man is mad,.... Which he said, as willing his servants should think so, and therefore rather the object of their pity than of their rage and malice; or as really believing he was so, which he and they might conclude not merely from these his actions, before described, which they might judge real and not feigned; but they might suppose this was truly his case, brought upon him by the ill usage of Saul, who pursuing him from place to place, and sending after him to take away his life, had really brought him to distraction; and this they might rather conclude from his coming to Gath, an enemy's country, and whose champion he had slain, and many others of them; which it might be thought no man in his senses would have done:
wherefore then have ye brought him to me? for if he was brought to be employed in his service, he seemed very unfit for it, whether in the camp, or in the court; and if to be tried and condemned as an enemy, since he was a madman, he was rather to be pitied.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: 1Sa 21:15 - -- Have I need of madmen?.... Or fools, do I want them? have not I enough of them already at my court? I want wise men, and not fools and madmen. The Jew...
Have I need of madmen?.... Or fools, do I want them? have not I enough of them already at my court? I want wise men, and not fools and madmen. The Jews say w that the wife and daughter of Achish were mad; that while David was playing the fool and madman without, they were acting the same part within; so that Achish had enough of that sort of diversion, if it was to be reckoned such; as it was according to the taste of some persons, who used, as in later so in earlier times, to keep fools in their houses to make them sport; but Achish had enough of that, and too much, at least needed no more:
that ye have brought this fellow to play the madman in my presence? or act the part of a fool before me:
shall this fellow come into mine house? court or palace, and have a post there; you need be in no pain about it; he is neither agreeable to me, nor fit for any; and therefore Achish drove him away as a fool or madman, instead of imprisoning him as an enemy, or taking away his life; see the title of the thirty fourth psalm, Psa 34:1.
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
Geneva Bible: 1Sa 21:13 And he changed his behaviour before them, and feigned himself mad in their hands, and ( i ) scrabbled on the doors of the gate, and let his spittle fa...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Geneva Bible: 1Sa 21:15 Have I need of mad men, that ye have brought this [fellow] to play the mad man in my presence? ( k ) shall this [fellow] come into my house?
( k ) Is...
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> 1Sa 21:1-15
TSK Synopsis: 1Sa 21:1-15 - --1 David at Nob obtains of Ahimelech hallowed bread.7 Doeg is present.8 David takes Goliath's sword.10 David at Gath feigns himself mad.
MHCC -> 1Sa 21:10-15
MHCC: 1Sa 21:10-15 - --God's persecuted people have often found better usage from Philistines than from Israelites. David had reason to put confidence in Achish, yet he bega...
Matthew Henry -> 1Sa 21:10-15
Matthew Henry: 1Sa 21:10-15 - -- David, though king elect, is here an exile - designed to be master of vast treasures, yet just now begging his bread - anointed to the crown, and ye...
Keil-Delitzsch -> 1Sa 21:12-13; 1Sa 21:14-15
Keil-Delitzsch: 1Sa 21:12-13 - --
But David took these words to heart, and was in great fear of Achish, lesthe should treat him as an enemy, and kill him. In order to escape thisdang...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Keil-Delitzsch: 1Sa 21:14-15 - --
By this dissimulation David escaped the danger which threatened him; forAchish thought him mad, and would have nothing to do with him. " Wherefore d...
Constable: 1Sa 16:1--31:13 - --IV. SAUL AND DAVID 1 Sam. 16--31
The basic theme in Samuel, that blessing, and in particular fertility of all ki...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: 1Sa 21:1--30:31 - --C. David in Exile chs. 21-30
In chapters 21-30 we see David's forces growing stronger and stronger while...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: 1Sa 21:1--22:23 - --1. David's initial movements chs. 21-22
"The two chapters comprise a literary unit of three sect...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)