![](images/minus.gif)
Text -- 2 Samuel 18:28-33 (NET)
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
![](images/advanced.gif)
Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics
![](images/arrow_open.gif)
![](images/information.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: 2Sa 18:33 - -- Retiring himself from all men and business, that he might wholly give up himself to lamentation.
Retiring himself from all men and business, that he might wholly give up himself to lamentation.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Wesley: 2Sa 18:33 - -- This he might speak from a deep sense of his eternal state, because he died in his sins, and because David himself had by his own sins been the occasi...
This he might speak from a deep sense of his eternal state, because he died in his sins, and because David himself had by his own sins been the occasion of his death. But it seems rather to be the effect of strong passion, causing him to speak unadvisedly with his lips.
JFB -> 2Sa 18:24-32
JFB: 2Sa 18:24-32 - -- That is, in the tower-house on the wall that overhung the gate of Mahanaim. Near it was a watchtower, on which a sentinel was posted, as in times of w...
That is, in the tower-house on the wall that overhung the gate of Mahanaim. Near it was a watchtower, on which a sentinel was posted, as in times of war, to notify every occurrence. The delicacy of Ahimaaz' communication was made up by the unmistakable plainness of Cushi's. The death of Absalom was a heavy trial, and it is impossible not to sympathize with the outburst of feeling by which David showed that all thoughts of the victory he had won as a king were completely sunk in the painful loss he had sustained as a father. The extraordinary ardor and strength of his affection for this worthless son break out in the redundancy and vehemence of his mournful ejaculations.
Clarke: 2Sa 18:29 - -- I saw a great tumult - It was very probable that Ahimaaz did not know of the death of Absalom; he had seen the rout of his army, but did not know of...
I saw a great tumult - It was very probable that Ahimaaz did not know of the death of Absalom; he had seen the rout of his army, but did not know of his death. Others think he knew all, and told this untruth that he might not be the messenger of bad news to David.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: 2Sa 18:30 - -- Stand here - He intended to confront two messengers, and compare their accounts.
Stand here - He intended to confront two messengers, and compare their accounts.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: 2Sa 18:32 - -- Is the young man Absalom safe? - This was the utmost of his solicitude, and it well merited the reproof which Joab gave him, 2Sa 19:5.
Is the young man Absalom safe? - This was the utmost of his solicitude, and it well merited the reproof which Joab gave him, 2Sa 19:5.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Clarke: 2Sa 18:33 - -- O my son Absalom - It is allowed by the most able critics that this lamentation is exceedingly pathetic. In what order the words were pronounced, fo...
O my son Absalom - It is allowed by the most able critics that this lamentation is exceedingly pathetic. In what order the words were pronounced, for much depends on this, we cannot say. Perhaps it was the following: -
Is there no hope for the soul of this profligate young man? He died in his iniquity: but is it not possible that he implored the mercy of his Maker while he hung in the tree? And is it not possible that the mercy of God was extended to him? And was not that suspension a respite, to the end that he might have time to deprecate the wrath of Divine justice
This is at least a charitable conjecture, and humanity will delight in such a case to lay hold even on possibilities. If there be any room for hope in such a death, who that knows the worth of an immortal soul, would not wish to indulge in it?
TSK: 2Sa 18:28 - -- All is well : or, Peace be to thee, Heb. Peace, he fell down upon his face, This act was not only in reverence to the king, but in humble adoration of...
All is well : or, Peace be to thee, Heb. Peace, he fell down upon his face, This act was not only in reverence to the king, but in humble adoration of God, whose name he praises for this victory. The more our hearts are fixed and enlarged, in thanksgiving to God for our mercies, the better disposed we shall be to bear with patience the afflictions mixed with them. 2Sa 1:2, 2Sa 14:4
Blessed : 2Sa 22:27; Gen 14:20, Gen 24:27; 2Ch 20:26; Psa 115:1, Psa 124:6, Psa 144:1, Psa 144:2; Rev 19:1-3
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
TSK: 2Sa 18:29 - -- Is the young man Absalom safe : Heb. is there peace to, etc. I saw a great. 2Sa 18:19, 2Sa 18:20, 2Sa 18:22
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
TSK: 2Sa 18:31 - -- Tidings : Heb. Tidings is brought
the Lord : 2Sa 18:19, 2Sa 18:28, 2Sa 22:48, 2Sa 22:49; Deu 32:35, Deu 32:36; Psa 58:10, Psa 94:1-4, Psa 124:2, Psa 1...
Tidings : Heb. Tidings is brought
the Lord : 2Sa 18:19, 2Sa 18:28, 2Sa 22:48, 2Sa 22:49; Deu 32:35, Deu 32:36; Psa 58:10, Psa 94:1-4, Psa 124:2, Psa 124:3; Luk 18:7, Luk 18:8; Cushi was the man Joab ordered to carry the tidings to David. He was an Ethiopian, as his name signifies, and some think he was so by birth - a black, who waited on Joab, probably one of the ten who had helped to dispatch Absalom; though it was dangerous for one of those to bring the news to David, lest his fate should be the same with theirs that reported the death of Saul and Ishbosheth to him.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
TSK: 2Sa 18:32 - -- The enemies : Thus Cushi obliquely and slowly informs David of the death of his son Absalom. Jdg 5:31; Psa 68:1, Psa 68:2; Dan 4:19
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
TSK: 2Sa 18:33 - -- O my son : 2Sa 19:4
would God : 2Sa 12:10-23; Psa 103:13; Pro 10:1, Pro 17:25; Jam 5:17
O my son : 2Sa 19:4
would God : 2Sa 12:10-23; Psa 103:13; Pro 10:1, Pro 17:25; Jam 5:17
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes: 2Sa 18:28 - -- Ahimaaz called - This marks the eager haste with which, before he had quite reached the king, he shouted out the pithy decisive word of good ti...
Ahimaaz called - This marks the eager haste with which, before he had quite reached the king, he shouted out the pithy decisive word of good tidings, "Shalom!"Peace!
Hath delivered - See the margin. The figure seems to be that of confining a person within the power of his enemy, in opposition to "giving him his liberty""in a large room,"to work what mischief he pleases.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Tidings ... - Rather, "Let my lord the king receive the good tidings."
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Barnes: 2Sa 18:33 - -- There is not in the whole of the Old Testament a passage of deeper pathos than this. Compare Luk 19:41. In the Hebrew Bible this verse commences the...
There is not in the whole of the Old Testament a passage of deeper pathos than this. Compare Luk 19:41. In the Hebrew Bible this verse commences the nineteenth chapter. The King James Version follows the Greek and Latin versions.
Into thy hand and power; or, to destruction. Compare 1Sa 24:18 26:8 .
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: 2Sa 18:29 - -- The king’ s servant Cushi.
I knew not what it was he seems to tell an untruth, as is evident from 2Sa 18:20 , because he now plainly perceived...
The king’ s servant Cushi.
I knew not what it was he seems to tell an untruth, as is evident from 2Sa 18:20 , because he now plainly perceived what Joab foretold him, that such tidings would be very unwelcome to David. But he made a bad choice, to offend God with a lie, rather than to displease the king with a truth. Yet thus far it might be true, that though he had reason to think Absalom was dead, yet was not able to give account of the particulars which concerned it, wherewith Cushi was intrusted.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
May they perish and be cut off, as he is.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Poole: 2Sa 18:33 - -- Went up to the chamber over the gate retiring himself from all men and business, that he might wholly give up himself to lamentation.
David might sp...
Went up to the chamber over the gate retiring himself from all men and business, that he might wholly give up himself to lamentation.
David might speak thus from a deep sense of his eternal state, because he died in his sins, without the least testimony of repentance, and because David himself had by his own sins been the unhappy instrument and occasion of his son’ s death.
Haydock: 2Sa 18:28 - -- Shut up; frustrated the attempts of the enemy, and consigned many to the grave. (Haydock)
Shut up; frustrated the attempts of the enemy, and consigned many to the grave. (Haydock)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Haydock: 2Sa 18:32 - -- Is. This was as much as to tell plainly that he was dead, (Menochius) or at least, a prisoner. But David understood him right. (Haydock)
Is. This was as much as to tell plainly that he was dead, (Menochius) or at least, a prisoner. But David understood him right. (Haydock)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Haydock: 2Sa 18:33 - -- Wept, in private. (Menochius) ---
Would. David lamented the death of Absalom, because of the wretched state in which he died; and therefore would...
Wept, in private. (Menochius) ---
Would. David lamented the death of Absalom, because of the wretched state in which he died; and therefore would have been glad to have saved his life, even by dying for him. In this he was a figure of Christ weeping, praying, and dying for his rebellious children, and even for them that crucified him. (Challoner; St. Ambrose (de Ob. Valent.); Theodoret, q. 35.) ---
David had presently ceased to weep for the son of Bethsabee, because he had reason to hope that he was saved. (Calmet)
Gill: 2Sa 18:28 - -- And Ahimaaz called and said unto the king,.... As soon as he came so near as to be heard by him, before he came up to him, he said with a loud voice:
...
And Ahimaaz called and said unto the king,.... As soon as he came so near as to be heard by him, before he came up to him, he said with a loud voice:
all is well; the king's army has had success, beat the rebels, and obtained a complete victory: or "peace" e; for it is but one word in the original, which signifies all happiness and prosperity, and this he wished the king; and so it is the same as if he had said, God save the king, may all happiness attend him:
and he fell down to the earth upon his face before the king; when he came nearer to him, not only in reverence of him, but in thankfulness to God:
and said, blessed be the Lord thy God, which hath delivered up the men that lifted up their hand against my lord the king; in which he ascribes the victory, not to Joab and his army, but to the Lord, to whom he gives thanks; and this agreeably to his character as a good man, and a priest of the Lord.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: 2Sa 18:29 - -- And the king said, is the young man Absalom safe?.... Or, is there "peace" f to him? you say there is peace, and that prosperity and success have atte...
And the king said, is the young man Absalom safe?.... Or, is there "peace" f to him? you say there is peace, and that prosperity and success have attended my army; but what peace has Absalom? is he well, and in safety? David seemed more concerned for him than for his army and the success of it; and even suggests as if it was nothing if Absalom was not safe, so great were his affections towards him:
and Ahimaaz answered, when Joab sent the king's servant; which was Cushi, the first messenger, whose office perhaps it was to be one of the king's messengers, and therefore called his servant:
and me thy servant: Ahimaaz himself who was sent after the other:
I saw a great tumult, but I knew not what it was; he perceived that the tidings of the death of Absalom would be disagreeable to the king, and therefore concealed it from him; and though a good man, he cannot be excused from lying, for certainly he knew that Absalom was dead, as appears from 2Sa 18:19; though indeed what he said might be true, that after Joab had sent him and Cushi, as the Targum paraphrases it, he saw a company of people gathered together in a tumultuous manner, the meaning of which he knew not; but then this was no other than an evasion.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: 2Sa 18:30 - -- And the king said unto him, turn aside, and stand here,.... On the side of him, not far from him, until the other messenger came, that he might lear...
And the king said unto him, turn aside, and stand here,.... On the side of him, not far from him, until the other messenger came, that he might learn from them both the true state of the case:
and he turned aside, and stood still; saying nothing more to the king, nor he to him.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: 2Sa 18:31 - -- And, behold, Cushi came,.... A little after:
and Cushi said, tidings, my lord the king; news is sent and brought by me, and good news it is:
for...
And, behold, Cushi came,.... A little after:
and Cushi said, tidings, my lord the king; news is sent and brought by me, and good news it is:
for the Lord hath avenged thee this day of all them that rose up against thee; they are either killed or dispersed; there is an entire victory over them, and deliverance from them.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: 2Sa 18:32 - -- And the king said unto Cushi, is the young man Absalom safe?.... The same question that was put to Ahimaaz, 2Sa 18:29; which shows what lay nearest hi...
And the king said unto Cushi, is the young man Absalom safe?.... The same question that was put to Ahimaaz, 2Sa 18:29; which shows what lay nearest his heart, and was uppermost in his mind:
and Cushi answered, the enemies of my lord the king, and all that rise against thee to do thee hurt, be as that young man is, which was tacitly saying he was dead, and so David understood it; and he expressed it in such a manner, that David could not be displeased with the messenger; though the message was grievous to him.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Gill: 2Sa 18:33 - -- And the king was much moved,.... His affections were moved, his passions were stirred up; he was greatly troubled, distressed, and grieved:
and wen...
And the king was much moved,.... His affections were moved, his passions were stirred up; he was greatly troubled, distressed, and grieved:
and went up to the chamber over the gate, and wept; got out of sight and company as soon as he could; as his own dwelling was at some distance, he made haste to the chamber in the watchtower, over the gate of the city, where the watchman was, to vent his grief; and could not suppress it till he got thither:
and as he went; up the stairs to the chamber:
thus he said, O my son Absalom! my son, my son Absalom! which repetition expresses the vehemence of his affections, and how inconsolable he was on account of his son's death:
would God I had died for thee, O Absalom, my son, my son! some think he said this on account of his eternal state, being satisfied of his own; but it may be it was only the effect of natural affection, indulged to too great a degree, and unbecoming so good a man in such a case; the Targum is,"I wish I had died for thee, and thou hadst remained this day.''
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: 2Sa 18:31 Heb “for the Lord has vindicated you today from the hand of all those rising against you.”
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
NET Notes: 2Sa 18:33 The Lucianic Greek recension and Syriac Peshitta lack this repeated occurrence of “my son” due to haplography.
Geneva Bible: 2Sa 18:29 And the king said, Is the young man Absalom safe? And Ahimaaz answered, When Joab sent the king's ( k ) servant, and [me] thy servant, I saw a great t...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Geneva Bible: 2Sa 18:33 And the king was much ( l ) moved, and went up to the chamber over the gate, and wept: and as he went, thus he said, O my son Absalom, my son, my son ...
![](images/cmt_minus_head.gif)
expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> 2Sa 18:1-33
TSK Synopsis: 2Sa 18:1-33 - --1 David viewing the armies in their march gives them charge of Absalom.6 The Israelites are sorely smitten in the wood of Ephraim.9 Absalom, hanging i...
Maclaren -> 2Sa 18:18-33
Maclaren: 2Sa 18:18-33 - --2 Samuel 18:18-33
The first verse of this passage and the one preceding it give a striking contrast between the actual and the designed burial-place o...
MHCC -> 2Sa 18:19-33
MHCC: 2Sa 18:19-33 - --By directing David to give God thanks for his victory, Ahimaaz prepared him for the news of his son's death. The more our hearts are fixed and enlarge...
Matthew Henry -> 2Sa 18:19-33
Matthew Henry: 2Sa 18:19-33 - -- Absalom's business is done; and we are now told, I. How David was informed of it. He staid behind at the city of Mahanaim, some miles from the wood ...
Keil-Delitzsch: 2Sa 18:28 - --
Ahimaaz then called out to the king, "Shalom," i.e., Hail! and fell down before him to greet him reverentially, and said, "Blessed be Jehovah thy ...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Keil-Delitzsch: 2Sa 18:29 - --
In answer to the king's inquiry, "Is it well with the young man Absalom?" Ahimaaz replied, "I saw the great tumult (that arose) when Joab sent off t...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Keil-Delitzsch: 2Sa 18:30 - --
And the king said, "Turn, and stand here,"that he might hear the further news from the Cushite, who had just arrived.
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Keil-Delitzsch: 2Sa 18:31 - --
The Cushite said, "Let my lord the king receive good tidings, for Jehovah hath procured thee justice to-day out of the hand of all who have risen up...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Keil-Delitzsch: 2Sa 18:32 - --
When asked about the welfare of Absalom, the Cushite replied, "May it happen to the enemies of my lord the king, and all who have risen up against t...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Keil-Delitzsch: 2Sa 18:33 - --
The king understood the meaning of the words. He was agitated, and went up to the balcony of the gate (the room above the entrance) and wept, and sa...
Constable: 2Sa 9:1--20:26 - --VI. DAVID'S TROUBLES chs. 9--20
Chapters 9-20 contrast with chapters 2-8 in that this later section is negative ...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: 2Sa 13:1--20:26 - --C. David's Rejection and Return chs. 13-20
This is the longest literary section in the Court History of ...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)
Constable: 2Sa 15:1--20:26 - --2. Absalom's attempt to usurp David's throne chs. 15-20
Absalom was never Yahweh's choice to suc...
![](images/cmt_minus.gif)