
Text -- Acts 2:47 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Having favor (
Cf. Luk 2:52 of the Boy Jesus.

Robertson: Act 2:47 - -- Added ( prosetithei ).
Imperfect active, kept on adding. If the Lord only always "added"those who join our churches. Note Act 2:41where same verb is ...
Added (
Imperfect active, kept on adding. If the Lord only always "added"those who join our churches. Note Act 2:41where same verb is used of the 3,000.

Robertson: Act 2:47 - -- To them ( epi to auto ).
Literally, "together."Why not leave it so? "To the church"(tēi ekklēsiāi ) is not genuine. Codex Bezae has "in the ch...
To them (
Literally, "together."Why not leave it so? "To the church"(

Robertson: Act 2:47 - -- Those that were being saved ( tous sōzomenous ).
Present passive participle. Probably for repetition like the imperfect prosetithei . Better transl...
Those that were being saved (
Present passive participle. Probably for repetition like the imperfect
Added (
Imperfect: kept adding.

Vincent: Act 2:47 - -- Such as should be saved ( τοὺς σωζομένους )
Lit., as Rev., those that were being saved. The rendering of the A. V. would requ...
Such as should be saved (
Lit., as Rev., those that were being saved. The rendering of the A. V. would require the verb to be in the future, whereas it is the present participle. Compare 1Co 1:18. Salvation is a thing of the present, as well as of the past and future. The verb is used in all these senses in the New Testament. Thus, we were saved (not are, as A. V.), Rom 8:24; shall or shalt be saved, Rom 10:9, Rom 10:13; ye are being saved, 1Co 15:2. " Godliness, righteousness, is life, is salvation. And it is hardly necessary to say that the divorce of morality and religion must be fostered and encouraged by failing to note this, and so laying the whole stress either on the past or on the future - on the first call, or on the final change. It is, therefore, important that the idea of salvation as a rescue from sin, through the knowledge of God in Christ, and therefore a progressive condition, a present state, should not be obscured, and we can but regret such a translation as Act 2:47, 'The Lord added to the church daily such as should be saved,' where the Greek implies a different idea" (Lightfoot, " On a Fresh Revision of the New Testament" ).
Wesley -> Act 2:47
From their sins: from the guilt and power of them.
JFB -> Act 2:41-47; Act 2:41-47; Act 2:47; Act 2:47; Act 2:47; Act 2:47; Act 2:47; Act 2:47; Act 2:47
JFB: Act 2:41-47 - -- "It is difficult to say how three thousand could be baptized in one day, according to the old practice of a complete submersion; and the more as in Je...
"It is difficult to say how three thousand could be baptized in one day, according to the old practice of a complete submersion; and the more as in Jerusalem there was no water at hand except Kidron and a few pools. The difficulty can only be removed by supposing that they already employed sprinkling, or baptized in houses in large vessels. Formal submersion in rivers, or larger quantities of water, probably took place only where the locality conveniently allowed it" [OLSHAUSEN].

Fitting inauguration of the new kingdom, as an economy of the Spirit!

JFB: Act 2:47 - -- "Go thy way, eat thy bread with joy, and drink thy wine with a merry heart, for God now accepteth thy works" (Ecc 9:7, also see on Act 8:39).

JFB: Act 2:47 - -- Commending themselves by their lovely demeanor to the admiration of all who observed them.
Commending themselves by their lovely demeanor to the admiration of all who observed them.

That is, JESUS, as the glorified Head and Ruler of the Church.

JFB: Act 2:47 - -- Kept adding; that is, to the visible community of believers, though the words "to the Church" are wanting in the most ancient manuscripts.
Kept adding; that is, to the visible community of believers, though the words "to the Church" are wanting in the most ancient manuscripts.

JFB: Act 2:47 - -- Rather, "the saved," or "those who were being saved." "The young Church had but few peculiarities in its outward form, or even in its doctrine: the si...
Rather, "the saved," or "those who were being saved." "The young Church had but few peculiarities in its outward form, or even in its doctrine: the single discriminating principle of its few members was that they all recognized the crucified Jesus of Nazareth as the Messiah. This confession would have been a thing of no importance, if it had only presented itself as a naked declaration, and would never in such a case have been able to form a community that would spread itself over the whole Roman empire. It acquired its value only through the power of the Holy Ghost, passing from the apostles as they preached to the hearers; for He brought the confession from the very hearts of men (1Co 12:3), and like a burning flame made their souls glow with love. By the power of this Spirit, therefore, we behold the first Christians not only in a state of active fellowship, but also internally changed: the narrow views of the natural man are broken through; they have their possessions in common, and they regard themselves as one family" [OLSHAUSEN].|| 26998||1||11||0||@@PETER HEALS A LAME MAN AT THE TEMPLE GATE--HS ADDRESS TO THE WONDERING MULTITUDE.==== (Acts 3:1-26)

JFB: Act 2:47 - -- Already associated by their Master, first with James (Mar 1:29; Mar 5:37; Mar 9:2), then by themselves (Luk 22:8; and see Joh 13:23-24). Now we find t...
Already associated by their Master, first with James (Mar 1:29; Mar 5:37; Mar 9:2), then by themselves (Luk 22:8; and see Joh 13:23-24). Now we find them constantly together, but John (yet young) only as a silent actor.
Clarke: Act 2:47 - -- Praising God - As the fountain whence they had derived all their spiritual and temporal blessings; seeing him in all things, and magnifying the work...
Praising God - As the fountain whence they had derived all their spiritual and temporal blessings; seeing him in all things, and magnifying the work of his mercy

Clarke: Act 2:47 - -- Having favor with all the people - Every honest, upright Jew would naturally esteem these for the simplicity, purity, and charity of their lives. Th...
Having favor with all the people - Every honest, upright Jew would naturally esteem these for the simplicity, purity, and charity of their lives. The scandal of the cross had not yet commenced; for, though they had put Jesus Christ to death, they had not get entered into a systematic opposition to the doctrines he taught

Clarke: Act 2:47 - -- And the Lord added to the Church daily such as should be saved - Though many approved of the life and manners of these primitive Christians, yet the...
And the Lord added to the Church daily such as should be saved - Though many approved of the life and manners of these primitive Christians, yet they did not become members of this holy Church; God permitting none to be added to it, but
One MS. and the Armenian version, instead of
On that awful subject, the foreknowledge of God, something has already been spoken: see Act 2:23. Though it is a subject which no finite nature can comprehend, yet it is possible so to understand what relates to us in it as to avoid those rocks of presumption and despondency on which multitudes have been shipwrecked. The foreknowledge of God is never spoken of in reference to himself, but in reference to us: in him properly there is neither foreknowledge nor afterknowledge. Omniscience, or the power to know all things, is an attribute of God, and exists in him as omnipotence, or the power to do all things. He can do whatsoever he will; and he does whatsoever is fit or proper to be done. God cannot have foreknowledge, strictly speaking, because this would suppose that there was something coming, in what we call futurity, which had not yet arrived at the presence of the Deity. Neither can he have any afterknowledge, strictly speaking, for this would suppose that something that had taken place, in what we call pretereity, or past time, had now got beyond the presence of the Deity. As God exists in all that can be called eternity, so he is equally every where: nothing can be future to him, because he lives in all futurity; nothing can be past to him, because he equally exists in all past time; futurity and pretereity are relative terms to us; but they can have no relation to that God who dwells in every point of eternity; with whom all that is past, and all that is present, and all that is future to man, exists in one infinite, indivisible, and eternal Now. As God’ s omnipotence implies his power to do all things, so God’ s omniscience implies his power to know all things; but we must take heed that we meddle not with the infinite free agency of this Eternal Being. Though God can do all thinks, he does not all things. Infinite judgment directs the operations of his power, so that though he can, yet he does not do all things, but only such things as are proper to be done. In what is called illimitable space, he can make millions of millions of systems; but he does not see proper to do this. He can destroy the solar system, but he does not do it: he can fashion and order, in endless variety, all the different beings which now exist, whether material, animal, or intellectual; but he does not do this, because he does not see it proper to be done. Therefore it does not follow that, because God can do all things, therefore he must do all things. God is omniscient, and can know all things; but does it follow from this that he must know all things? Is he not as free in the volitions of his wisdom, as he is in the volitions of his power? The contingent as absolute, or the absolute as contingent? God has ordained some things as absolutely certain; these he knows as absolutely certain. He has ordained other things as contingent; these he knows as contingent. It would be absurd to say that he foreknows a thing as only contingent which he has made absolutely certain. And it would be as absurd to say that he foreknows a thing to be absolutely certain which in his own eternal counsel he has made contingent. By absolutely certain, I mean a thing which must be, in that order, time, place, and form in which Divine wisdom has ordained it to be; and that it can be no otherwise than this infinite counsel has ordained. By contingent, I mean such things as the infinite wisdom of God has thought proper to poise on the possibility of being or not being, leaving it to the will of intelligent beings to turn the scale. Or, contingencies are such possibilities, amid the succession of events, as the infinite wisdom of God has left to the will of intelligent beings to determine whether any such event shall take place or not. To deny this would involve the most palpable contradictions, and the most monstrous absurdities. If there be no such things as contingencies in the world, then every thing is fixed and determined by an unalterable decree and purpose of God; and not only all free agency is destroyed, but all agency of every kind, except that of the Creator himself; for on this ground God is the only operator, either in time or eternity: all created beings are only instruments, and do nothing but as impelled and acted upon by this almighty and sole Agent. Consequently, every act is his own; for if he have purposed them all as absolutely certain, having nothing contingent in them, then he has ordained them to be so; and if no contingency, then no free agency, and God alone is the sole actor. Hence the blasphemous, though, from the premises, fair conclusion, that God is the author of all the evil and sin that are in the world; and hence follows that absurdity, that, as God can do nothing that is wrong, Whatever Is, is Right. Sin is no more sin; a vicious human action is no crime, if God have decreed it, and by his foreknowledge and will impelled the creature to act it. On this ground there can be no punishment for delinquencies; for if every thing be done as God has predetermined, and his determinations must necessarily be all right, then neither the instrument nor the agent has done wrong. Thus all vice and virtue, praise and blame, merit and demerit, guilt and innocence, are at once confounded, and all distinctions of this kind confounded with them. Now, allowing the doctrine of the contingency of human actions, (and it must be allowed in order to shun the above absurdities and blasphemies), then we see every intelligent creature accountable for its own works, and for the use it makes of the power with which God has endued it; and, to grant all this consistently, we must also grant that God foresees nothing as absolutely and inevitably certain which he has made contingent; and, because he has designed it to be contingent, therefore he cannot know it as absolutely and inevitably certain. I conclude that God, although omniscient, is not obliged, in consequence of this, to know all that he can know; no more than he is obliged, because he is omnipotent, to do all that he can do
How many, by confounding the self and free agency of God with a sort of continual impulsive necessity, have raised that necessity into an all-commanding and overruling energy, to which God himself is made subject! Very properly did Milton set his damned spirits about such work as this, and has made it a part of their endless punishment: -
Others apart sat on a hill retired
In thoughts more elevate; and reasoned hig
Of providence, foreknowledge, will, and fate
Fixed fate, free-will, foreknowledge absolute
And found no end, in wand’ ring mazes lost
Parad. Lost, b. ii. l. 557
Among some exceptionable expressions, the following are also good thoughts on the flee agency and fall of man: -
- I made him just and right
Sufficient to have stood, though free to fall
Not free, what proof could they have given sincer
Of true allegiance, constant faith or love
When only what they needs must do appeared
Not what they would? What praise could they receive?
Useless and vain, of freedom both despoiled
Made passive, both had served Necessity
Not Me. -
So without least impulse or shadow of fate
Or aught by me immutably foreseen
They trespass, authors to themselves in al
Both what they judge, and what they choose, for s
I formed them free, and free they must remai
Till they enthrall themselves: I else must chang
Their nature, and revoke the high decre
Unchangeable, eternal, which ordaine
Their freedom; they themselves ordained their fall
Ibid, b. iii. l. 98, 103, 120
I shall conclude these observations with a short extract from Mr. Bird’ s Conferences, where, in answer to the objection, "If many things fall out contingently, or as it were by accident, God’ s foreknowledge of them can be but contingent, dependent on man’ s free will,"he observes: "It is one thing to know that a thing will be done necessarily; and another, to know necessarily that a thing will be done. God doth necessarily foreknow all that will be done; but he doth not know that those things which shall be done voluntarily will be done necessarily: he knoweth that they will be done; but he knoweth withal that they might have fallen out otherwise, for aught he had ordered to the contrary. So likewise God knew that Adam would fall; and get he knew that he would not fall necessarily, for it was possible for him not to have fallen. And as touching God’ s preordination going before his prescience as the cause of all events this would be to make God the author of all the sin in the world; his knowledge comprehending that as well as other things. God indeed foreknoweth all things, because they will be done; but things are not (therefore) done, because he foreknoweth them. It is impossible that any man, by his voluntary manner of working, should elude God’ s foresight; but then this foresight doth not necessitate the will, for this were to take it wholly away. For as the knowledge of things present imports no necessity on that which is done, so the foreknowledge of things future lays no necessity on that which shall be; because whosoever knows and sees things, he knows and sees them as they are, and not as they are not; so that God’ s knowledge doth not confound things, but reaches to all events, not only which come to pass, but as they come to pass, whether contingency or necessarily. As, for example, when you see a man walking upon the earth, and at the very same instant the sun shining in the heavens, do you not see the first as voluntary, and the second as natural? And though at the instant you see both done, there is a necessity that they be done, (or else you could not see them at all), yet there was a necessity of one only before they were done, (namely, the sun’ s shining in the heavens), but none at all of the other, (viz. the man’ s walking upon the earth.) The sun could not but shine, as being a natural agent; the man might not have walked, as being a voluntary one."This is a good argument; but I prefer that which states the knowledge of God to be absolutely free, without the contradictions which are mentioned above. "But you deny the omniscience of God."- No, no more than I deny his omnipotence, and you know I do not, though you have asserted the contrary. But take heed how you speak about this infinitely free agent: if you will contradict, take heed that you do not blaspheme. I ask some simple questions on the subject of God’ s knowledge and power: if you know these things better than your neighbor, be thankful, be humble, and pray to God to give you amiable tempers; for the wrath of man worketh not the righteousness of God. May he be merciful to thee and me!
Calvin -> Act 2:47
Calvin: Act 2:47 - -- 47.Having favor This is the fruit of an innocent life, to find favor even amongst strangers. And yet we need not to doubt of this, but that they were...
47.Having favor This is the fruit of an innocent life, to find favor even amongst strangers. And yet we need not to doubt of this, but that they were hated of many. But although he speak generally of the people, yet he meaneth that part alone which was sound, neither yet infected with any poison of hatred; he signifieth briefly, that the faithful did so behave themselves, that the people did full well like of them for their innocency of life. 160
The Lord added daily He showeth in these words that their diligence was not without profit; they studied so much as in them lay to gather into the Lord’s sheepfold those which wandered and went astray. He saith that their labor bestowed herein was not lost; because the Lord did increase his Church daily. And surely, whereas the Church is rather diminished than increased, that is to be imputed to our slothfulness, or rather forwardness. 161 And although they did all of them stoutly labor to increase the kingdom of Christ, yet Luke ascribeth 162 this honor to God alone, that he brought strangers into the Church. And surely this is his own proper work. For the ministers do no good by planting or watering, unless he make their labor effectual by the power of his Spirit, (1Co 3:0.) Furthermore, we must note that he saith, that those were gathered unto the Church which should be saved. For he teacheth that this is the means to attain salvation, if we be incorporate into the Church. For like as there is no remission of sins, so neither is there any hope of salvation. 163 Furthermore, this is an excellent comfort for all the godly, that they were received into the Church that they might be saved; as the Gospel is called the power of God unto salvation to all that believe, (Rom 1:16.) Now, forasmuch as God doth gather only a part, or a certain number, this grace is restrained unto election, that it may be the first cause of our salvation.
Defender -> Act 2:47
Defender: Act 2:47 - -- This is the first mention of the "church" in Acts; the context indicates that the reference is to the visible body of believers in Jerusalem, function...
This is the first mention of the "church" in Acts; the context indicates that the reference is to the visible body of believers in Jerusalem, functioning as described in Act 2:44-47."
TSK -> Act 2:47
TSK: Act 2:47 - -- having : Act 4:21, Act 4:33; Luk 2:52, Luk 19:48; Rom 14:18
the Lord : Act 2:39, Act 5:14, Act 11:24, Act 13:48; Rom 8:30, Rom 9:27, Rom 11:5-7; Tit 3...

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes -> Act 2:47
Barnes: Act 2:47 - -- Praising God - See Luk 24:53. And having favour - See Luk 2:52. With all the people - That is, with the great mass of the people; w...
Praising God - See Luk 24:53.
And having favour - See Luk 2:52.
With all the people - That is, with the great mass of the people; with the people generally. It does not mean that all the people had become reconciled to Christianity; but their humble, serious, and devoted lives won the favor of the great mass of the community, and silenced opposition and cavil. This was a remarkable effect, but God has power to silence opposition; and there it nothing so well suited to do this as the humble and consistent lives of his friends.
And the Lord added - See Act 5:14; Act 11:24, etc. It was the Lord who did this. There was no power in man to do it; and the Christian loves to trace all increase of the church to the grace of God.
Added - Caused, or inclined them to be joined to the church.
The church - To the assembly of the followers of Christ -
Such as should be saved - This whole phrase is a translation of a participle -
We have now contemplated the foundation of the Christian church and the first glorious revival of religion. This chapter deserves to be profoundly studied by all ministers of the gospel, as well as by all who pray for the prosperity of the kingdom of God. It should excite our fervent gratitude that God has left this record of the first great work of grace, and our earnest prayers that He would multiply and extend such scenes until the earth shall be filled with His glory.
Poole -> Act 2:47
Poole: Act 2:47 - -- Praising God acknowledging him who teacheth one to want, and another to abound.
Having favour with all the people that is, generally to be understo...
Praising God acknowledging him who teacheth one to want, and another to abound.
Having favour with all the people that is, generally to be understood, amongst them that continued yet without the pale of the church; the goodness, meekness, and patience of the apostles, and the rest of the believers, did wonderfully prevail to beget a good opinion of them.
The Lord added to the church salvation is (to be sure) only from the Lord; not Peter’ s sermons, no, nor the miracles of fiery cloven tongues, and the rushing mighty wind, could have converted any, but
Haydock -> Act 2:47
Haydock: Act 2:47 - -- More and more he added daily to the Church, as it is clearly expressed in the Greek, prosetithei te ekklesia, that we may see the visible propagatio...
More and more he added daily to the Church, as it is clearly expressed in the Greek, prosetithei te ekklesia, that we may see the visible propagation and increase of the same. We may here, and throughout the whole book, observe a visible society of men joined in Christ, which visible society may be traced through ecclesiastical history, down to our days, and which will continue, in virtue of Christ's promise, to the end of time, as the point of union, by which the true disciples of Jesus Christ are to be connected together in one body, and one spirit; "one Lord, one faith, one baptism." (Ephesians iv. 5.) This book can shew the true Church ever visible, and ever speaking with authority to all that do not willingly shut their eyes, as plainly as the gospel doth shew the true Christ. "Every where the Church proclaims the truth; she is the candlestick, with the seven lamps (Exodus xxv.); bearing the light of Christ, Greek: eptamukos, " says St. Irenæus; which light nothing can obscure. Hence St. John Chrysostom says, "sooner shall the sun be extinguished, than the Church be obscured;" Greek: eukolioteron ton elion sbesthenai, e ten ekklesian aphanisthenai.
Gill -> Act 2:47
Gill: Act 2:47 - -- Praising God,.... Not only for their temporal mercies and enjoyments of life, which they partook of in so delightful and comfortable a manner; but for...
Praising God,.... Not only for their temporal mercies and enjoyments of life, which they partook of in so delightful and comfortable a manner; but for their spiritual mercies, that the Lord had been pleased to call them by his grace, and reveal Christ to them, and pardon them who had been such vile sinners, give them a name, and a place in his house, and favour them with the ordinances of it, and such agreeable and delightful company as the saints were, they had fellowship with:
having favour with all the people; they not only behaved with such true and sincere love towards one another in their church state, but with so much wisdom, courteousness, and affability towards them that were without, and walked so becoming the profession they made, that they gained the good will of the generality of the people:
and the Lord added to the church daily such as should be saved: partly by the conversation of these young converts, and chiefly by the ministry of the word, many souls were won and gained to Christ, were wrought upon, and converted, whose hearts the Lord inclined to give up themselves to the church, and walk with them in all the ordinances and commandments of the Lord; and these were such whom God had chosen to salvation by Jesus Christ, and whom he had redeemed by his precious blood, and who were now regenerated and sanctified by the Spirit of God, and so should certainly be saved; which is not always the case of persons added to churches, many of whom have not the root of the matter in them, and so fall away; but is of those who are added by the Lord, for there is a difference between being added by the Lord, and being added by men.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Act 2:1-47
TSK Synopsis: Act 2:1-47 - --1 The apostles, filled with the Holy Ghost, and speaking divers languages, are admired by some, and derided by others;14 whom Peter disproves;37 he ba...
Combined Bible -> Act 2:47
Maclaren -> Act 2:32-47; Act 2:47
Maclaren: Act 2:32-47 - --Peter's First Sermon
This Jesus hath God raised up, whereof we all are witnesses. 33. Therefore being by the right hand of God exalted, and having re...
