
Text -- Isaiah 17:9-14 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
The day of Jacob's trouble, of which he spake Isa 17:4.

Wesley: Isa 17:9 - -- Which he that prunes the tree neglects, because he esteems it useless and inconsiderable.
Which he that prunes the tree neglects, because he esteems it useless and inconsiderable.

Wesley: Isa 17:9 - -- Which they (the Canaanites) left or forsook because of (or for fear of) the children of Israel. And this was a fit example, to awaken the Israelites t...
Which they (the Canaanites) left or forsook because of (or for fear of) the children of Israel. And this was a fit example, to awaken the Israelites to a serious belief of this threatening, because God had inflicted the same judgment upon the Canaanites, for the same sins of which they were guilty.

That God who was thy only sure defence.

Fetched from far countries, and therefore highly esteemed.

Wesley: Isa 17:11 - -- Thou shalt from day to day, beginning early in the morning, use all diligence that what thou hast planted may thrive.
Thou shalt from day to day, beginning early in the morning, use all diligence that what thou hast planted may thrive.

Wesley: Isa 17:11 - -- When this grievous calamity shall come, all your harvest shall be but one heap.
When this grievous calamity shall come, all your harvest shall be but one heap.

This is a new prophecy, added for the comfort of God's people.

Wesley: Isa 17:12 - -- Who invade my land and people with great force, as the sea does when it enters into the land by a breach.
Who invade my land and people with great force, as the sea does when it enters into the land by a breach.

Wesley: Isa 17:14 - -- At even there is great terror among God's people, for fear of their enemies; and before the morning comes, their enemies are cut off.
At even there is great terror among God's people, for fear of their enemies; and before the morning comes, their enemies are cut off.
JFB: Isa 17:9 - -- Rather "the leavings of woods," what the axeman leaves when he cuts down the grove (compare Isa 17:6).
Rather "the leavings of woods," what the axeman leaves when he cuts down the grove (compare Isa 17:6).

JFB: Isa 17:9 - -- Rather, "which (the enemies) shall leave for the children of Israel"; literally, "shall leave (in departing) from before the face of the children of I...
Rather, "which (the enemies) shall leave for the children of Israel"; literally, "shall leave (in departing) from before the face of the children of Israel" [MAURER]. But a few cities out of many shall be left to Israel, by the purpose of God, executed by the Assyrian.

Rather, "nursery grounds," "pleasure-grounds" [MAURER].

Rather, "set them," the pleasure-grounds.

Cuttings of plants from far, and therefore valuable.

Rather, "In the day of thy planting" [HORSLEY].

JFB: Isa 17:11 - -- MAURER translates, "Thou didst fence it," namely, the pleasure-ground. The parallel clause, "Make . . . flourish," favors English Version. As soon as ...
MAURER translates, "Thou didst fence it," namely, the pleasure-ground. The parallel clause, "Make . . . flourish," favors English Version. As soon as thou plantest, it grows.

JFB: Isa 17:11 - -- That is, immediately after; so in Psa 90:14, the Hebrew, "in the morning," is translated "early."
That is, immediately after; so in Psa 90:14, the Hebrew, "in the morning," is translated "early."

Rather, "but (promising as was the prospect) the harvest is gone" [HORSLEY].

JFB: Isa 17:11 - -- Rather, "in the day of (expected) possession" [MAURER]. "In the day of inundation" [HORSLEY].
Rather, "in the day of (expected) possession" [MAURER]. "In the day of inundation" [HORSLEY].

JFB: Isa 17:11 - -- Rather, "And the sorrow shall be desperate or irremediable." In English Version "heap" and "sorrow" may be taken together by hendiadys. "The heap of t...
Rather, "And the sorrow shall be desperate or irremediable." In English Version "heap" and "sorrow" may be taken together by hendiadys. "The heap of the harvest shall be desperate sorrow" [ROSENMULLER].
The connection of this fragment with what precedes is: notwithstanding the calamities coming on Israel, the people of God shall not be utterly destroyed (Isa 6:12-13); the Assyrian spoilers shall perish (Isa 17:13-14).

JFB: Isa 17:12 - -- SUDDEN DESTRUCTION OF A GREAT ARMY IN JUDEA (namely that of the Assyrian Sennacherib), AND ANNOUNCEMENT OF THE EVENT TO THE ETHIOPIAN AMBASSADORS. (Is...
SUDDEN DESTRUCTION OF A GREAT ARMY IN JUDEA (namely that of the Assyrian Sennacherib), AND ANNOUNCEMENT OF THE EVENT TO THE ETHIOPIAN AMBASSADORS. (Isa. 17:12-18:7)

JFB: Isa 17:12 - -- Rather, "Ho (Hark)! a noise of," &c. The prophet in vision perceives the vast and mixed Assyrian hosts (Hebrew, "many peoples," see on Isa 5:26): on t...


JFB: Isa 17:13 - -- Rather, "God rebuketh (Psa 9:5) them, and they flee--are chased"; the event is set before the eyes as actually present, not future.
Rather, "God rebuketh (Psa 9:5) them, and they flee--are chased"; the event is set before the eyes as actually present, not future.

JFB: Isa 17:13 - -- Threshing floors in the East are in the open air on elevated places, so as to catch the wind which separates the chaff from the wheat (Psa 88:13; Hos ...

JFB: Isa 17:14 - -- Fulfilled to the letter in the destruction "before morning" of the vast host that "at eveningtide" was such a terror ("trouble") to Judah; on the phra...

JFB: Isa 17:14 - -- The Jews. A general declaration of the doom that awaits the foes of God's people (Isa 54:17).
Isaiah announces the overthrow of Sennacherib's hosts a...
The Jews. A general declaration of the doom that awaits the foes of God's people (Isa 54:17).
Isaiah announces the overthrow of Sennacherib's hosts and desires the Ethiopian ambassadors, now in Jerusalem, to bring word of it to their own nation; and he calls on the whole world to witness the event (Isa 18:3). As Isa 17:12-14 announced the presence of the foe, so Isa 18:1-7 foretells his overthrow.
Clarke: Isa 17:9 - -- As a forsaken bough, and an uppermost branch "the Hivites and the Amorites"- החרש והאמיר hachoresh vehaamir . No one has ever yet been a...
As a forsaken bough, and an uppermost branch "the Hivites and the Amorites"-

Clarke: Isa 17:10 - -- Strange slips "Shoots from a foreign soil"- The pleasant plants, and shoots from a foreign soil, are allegorical expressions for strange and idolatr...
Strange slips "Shoots from a foreign soil"- The pleasant plants, and shoots from a foreign soil, are allegorical expressions for strange and idolatrous worship; vicious and abominable practices connected with it; reliance on human aid, and on alliances entered into with the neighboring nations, especially Egypt; to all which the Israelites were greatly addicted, and in their expectations from which they should be grievously disappointed.

Clarke: Isa 17:12 - -- Wo to the multitude - The three last verses of this chapter seem to have no relation to the foregoing prophecy, to which they are joined. It is a be...
Wo to the multitude - The three last verses of this chapter seem to have no relation to the foregoing prophecy, to which they are joined. It is a beautiful piece, standing singly and by itself; for neither has it any connection with what follows: whether it stands in its right place, or not, I cannot say. It is a noble description of the formidable invasion and the sudden overthrow of Sennacherib; which is intimated in the strongest terms and the most expressive images, exactly suitable to the event

Clarke: Isa 17:12 - -- Like the rushing of mighty waters! - Five words, three at the end of the twelfth verse, and two at the beginning of the thirteenth, are omitted in e...
Like the rushing of mighty waters! - Five words, three at the end of the twelfth verse, and two at the beginning of the thirteenth, are omitted in eight MSS., with the Syriac; that is, in effect, the repetition contained in the first line of Isa 17:13 in this translation, is not made. After having observed that it is equally easy to account for the omission of these words by a transcriber if they are genuine, or their insertion if they are not genuine, occasioned by his carrying his eye backwards to the word

Clarke: Isa 17:14 - -- He is not "He is no more"- For איננו einennu ten MSS. of Dr. Kennicott’ s, (three ancient), ten of De Rossi’ s, and two editions, ...
He is not "He is no more"- For
"At the season of evening, behold terror
Before the morning, and [behold] he is no more!
That spoil us - For
Calvin: Isa 17:9 - -- 9.In that day shall his strong cities be as a forsaken bough He follows out what he had begun to say about driving out the inhabitants of the country...
9.In that day shall his strong cities be as a forsaken bough He follows out what he had begun to say about driving out the inhabitants of the country; and as the Israelites, trusting to their fortified cities and to their bulwarks, thought that they were in safety, he threatens that they will be of no more use than if enemies were marching through desert places. The view entertained by some, that
As they left 7 Here the particle
This passage will be made more plain by the writings of Moses, whom the prophets follow; for in the promises he employs this mode of expression, “One of you shall chase a thousand,” (Lev 26:8; Jos 23:10), and in the threatenings, on the other hand, he says, “One shall chase a thousand of you.” (Deu 32:30.) Accordingly, as he struck such terror into the Canaanites, that at the sight of the Israelites they immediately fled, so he punished the ingratitude of the people in such a manner that they had no power to resist. Thus the Lord gave a display of his power in two ways, both in driving out the Canaanites and in punishing his people. The Prophet, therefore, by mentioning that ancient kindness, reproaches the people with ingratitude, forgetfulness, and treachery, that they may acknowledge that they are justly punished, and may perceive that it proceeds from the Lord, that they are thus chased by the enemies to whom they were formerly a terror.

Calvin: Isa 17:10 - -- 10.Because thou hast forgotten the God of thy salvation He shews the reason why the Lord exercises such severity against the Ten Tribes, that they ma...
10.Because thou hast forgotten the God of thy salvation He shews the reason why the Lord exercises such severity against the Ten Tribes, that they may not complain of being unjustly afflicted or too harshly treated. The sum of what is stated is, that all those evils come to them because they have wickedly despised God. It was excessively base and altogether inexcusable ingratitude, after having received so many favors, to prostitute their hopes to heathen nations and to idols, as if they had never in any respect experienced the love of God. Indeed, no unbelievers, when they are called to account, will vindicate themselves from the charge of offering an insult to God by wandering after creatures. But the argument was applicable, in a special manner, to the people of Israel, to whom God had revealed himself in such a manner that they ought to have left off all the impostures of the world and relied on his grace alone. They are therefore justly accused of ingratitude, for having buried in forgetfulness the object of true faith; and indeed, when God has once allowed us to taste the delight of his goodness, if it gain a place in our hearts, we shall never be drawn away from it to anything else. Hence it follows that they are convicted of ingratitude who, not being satisfied with the true God, are unsteady and driven about in all directions; for in this manner they despise his invaluable grace.
Accordingly, the Prophet expressly calls him the God of salvation and the God or Rock of strength
Therefore thou shalt plant Next follows the punishment, that they might not think that this ingratitude would remain unpunished. That is, because they forsook the fountain of all good, though they labor to obtain food, yet they will be consumed by famine and hunger; for all that shall be obtained with great labor the enemy will either carry away or destroy. This passage is taken from Moses; for it is a curse pronounced amidst other curses.
“The fruit of thy land, and all thy labors, shall a nation which thou knowest not eat up.” (Deu 28:33).
Hence we see what I have often mentioned before, that the prophets borrow many things from Moses, and are the true interpreters of the law. He speaks of choice vines and branches taken from them; because the greatness of the loss aggravates the sorrow.

Calvin: Isa 17:11 - -- 11.In the day This denotes the incessant labor which is bestowed on plants and seeds. Yet we might understand by it the fruit which is yielded, as if...
11.In the day This denotes the incessant labor which is bestowed on plants and seeds. Yet we might understand by it the fruit which is yielded, as if a vine newly planted would immediately produce wine. And this agrees with the next clause, in which the morning is put for the day. This appears to denote sudden maturity, unless perhaps this also be supposed to denote carefulness, because from the very earliest dawn they will devote themselves to labor.
The words are somewhat ambiguous; for some render them, “the removing of the branch on the day of affliction.” But as
It might also be rendered a Collector; and yet I do not choose to dispute keenly about those two significations, for the meaning will be the same, provided that
This is a very severe punishment, and undoubtedly proceeds from the curse of God; for if he who has no possession be driven out and banished from a country, he will not be rendered so uneasy as the man who has well cultivated fields, and particularly if he has bestowed his labor on them for a long time. In this manner the Lord determined to punish the Israelites, because they abused the fertility of the country and grew wanton amidst their abundance. A similar punishment is also threatened against the wicked in general terms, that “in vain do they rise early, and vex themselves with unremitted toil;” for they gain nothing by it. (Psa 127:2). On the other hand, it is declared that they who trust in the Lord will undoubtedly receive the reward of their toil, for the blessing of God will accompany their labors. (Psa 128:2).

Calvin: Isa 17:12 - -- 12.Alas 8 for the multitude! Some render Woe, making it to denote execration. Sometimes, as we have seen elsewhere, it is employed in calling to a ...
12.Alas 8 for the multitude! Some render Woe, making it to denote execration. Sometimes, as we have seen elsewhere, it is employed in calling to a person; but on the present occasion I rather think that it betokens sorrow, 9 for he groans on account of the calamity which he foresees will befall Israel, and he does so either out of brotherly affection, or in order that the prophecy may make a more powerful impression on the minds of a sluggish and indolent people. It is certain, that the prophets regarded with greater horror than other men the vengeance of God, of which they were the heralds; and although, in sustaining the character assigned to them, they threatened severely, still they never laid aside human feelings, so as not to have compassion on those who perished. But the chief reason was a consideration of the covenant which God had made with the seed of Abraham; and we see that Paul also had this feeling to such an extent, that he “wished to be accursed for his brethren.” (Rom 9:3). When therefore Isaiah brings the fact before his mind, he cannot but be deeply affected with grief; and yet, as I have hinted, it tends to make the fact more certain, when he places it before his eyes as if he actually saw it.
The word multitude is here employed, because the army had been collected out of many and various nations, of which the Assyrian monarchy was composed. The metaphors which he adds are intended for no other purpose than to exhibit more forcibly what has been already stated; for he compares them to a sea or a deluge, which overflows a whole country.

Calvin: Isa 17:13 - -- 13.The nations shall rush Although he appears to follow out that threatening, which he formerly uttered, yet he begins to comfort believers by repeat...
13.The nations shall rush Although he appears to follow out that threatening, which he formerly uttered, yet he begins to comfort believers by repeating the same statement, as if we should say, “They who were unmindful of God must be punished for their wicked revolt, and must be, as it were, overwhelmed by a deluge; but the Lord will restrain this savage disposition of the enemies, for, when they have exercised their cruelty, he shall find a method of casting them out and driving them away.” This is a remarkable consolation, by which he intended to support the remnant of the godly. Nor does he speak of the Jews only, as is commonly supposed, for hitherto he has addressed his discourse to the ten tribes, and it is certain that there were still left in Israel some who actually feared God, and who would have despaired if they had not been upheld by some promise.
By these metaphors he describes dreadful storms and tempests. When the Holy Spirit intends to bring comfort to the godly, he holds out those objects which are wont to terrify and discourage the minds of men, that we may learn that God will easily allay all tempests, however violent and dreadful. As the winds and seas and storms are at his command, so it is easy for him to restrain enemies and their violence; and therefore immediately afterwards he compares the Assyrians to chaff.
As the chaff of the mountains before the wind Although with regard to the Israelites their attack was terrible, yet he shews that before God they will be like chaff, for without any effort he will scatter all their forces. Hence it follows that we ought not to judge of their resources and strength by our senses. Whenever therefore we see the restraints laid on the wicked withdrawn, 10 that they may rush forward for our destruction, let us indeed consider that, so far as lies in ourselves, we are ruined, but that God can easily frustrate their attacks.

Calvin: Isa 17:14 - -- 14.And, behold, at evening tide trouble The meaning is, “As when a storm has been raised in the evening, and soon afterwards allayed, no trace of...
14.And, behold, at evening tide trouble The meaning is, “As when a storm has been raised in the evening, and soon afterwards allayed, no trace of it is found in the morning, so will cheerful prosperity suddenly arise, contrary to expectation.” The Prophet intended to state two things — first, that the attack of the enemy will be sudden; and secondly, that the ravages which they shall commit will not be of long duration. As the Assyrians rose suddenly against the Israelites, so their fall was sudden.
From this passage all the godly ought to draw wonderful consolation, whenever they see that everything is in disorder, and when dreadful changes are at hand; for what is it but a sudden storm which the Lord will allay? Tyrants rush upon us like storms and whirlwinds, but the Lord will easily dispel their rage. Let us therefore patiently wait for his assistance; for though he permit us to be tossed about, yet through the midst of the tempests he will at length conduct us “to the haven.” (Psa 107:30.) And if the Prophet comforted a small remnant, who appeared to be almost none at all, this promise undoubtedly belongs to us also. True, we are almost none, and a wretched church is concealed in a few corners; but if we look at the condition of the kingdom of Israel, how few were the servants of God in it! And these hardly ventured to mutter, such was the universal hatred of religion and godliness. Although therefore the Lord destroy the multitude of the wicked, yet to the small number of the godly, who may be said to be tossed about in the same ship with them, he will hold out a plank to rescue them from shipwreck, and will guide them safely and comfortably into the harbour.
This is the portion He addresses the believers who were concealed in the kingdom of Israel, and joins them with the Church, although, as is frequently the case with the children of God, the members were scattered in every direction. We see here what will be the end of the wicked who have persecuted us. Though we are exposed to their rage, so that they tear and plunder and trample upon us, and inflict on us every kind of insult, yet they will be like storms which are subdued by their own violence and quickly disappear. We ought to expect that this will be the lot of all the tyrants who at the present day wretchedly harass the Church, and treat cruelly the children of God. Let this consolation be engraved on our minds, that we may know that the same thing will happen to them.
TSK: Isa 17:9 - -- Isa 17:4, Isa 17:5, Isa 6:11-13, Isa 7:16-20, Isa 9:9-12, Isa 24:1-12, Isa 27:10, Isa 28:1-4; Hos 10:14; Hos 13:15, Hos 13:16; Amo 3:11-15, Amo 7:9; M...

TSK: Isa 17:10 - -- thou hast : Isa 51:13; Deu 6:12, Deu 8:11, Deu 8:14, Deu 8:19; Psa 9:17, Psa 106:13, Psa 106:21; Jer 2:32, Jer 17:13; Hos 2:13, Hos 2:14, Hos 4:6, Hos...
thou hast : Isa 51:13; Deu 6:12, Deu 8:11, Deu 8:14, Deu 8:19; Psa 9:17, Psa 106:13, Psa 106:21; Jer 2:32, Jer 17:13; Hos 2:13, Hos 2:14, Hos 4:6, Hos 8:14, Hos 13:6, Hos 13:7
the God : Isa 12:2; 1Ch 16:35; Psa 65:5, Psa 68:19, Psa 68:20, Psa 79:9, Psa 85:4; Hab 3:18
the rock : Isa 26:4; Deu 32:4, Deu 32:15; Psa 18:2, Psa 31:2
shalt thou : Isa 65:21, Isa 65:22; Lev 26:16, Lev 26:20; Deu 28:30,Deu 28:38-42; Jer 12:13; Amo 5:11; Zep 1:13

TSK: Isa 17:11 - -- the harvest : Isa 18:5, Isa 18:6; Job 4:8; Jer 5:31; Hos 8:7, Hos 9:1-4, Hos 9:16, Hos 10:12-15; Joe 1:5-12; Gal 6:7, Gal 6:8
a heap in the day of gri...
the harvest : Isa 18:5, Isa 18:6; Job 4:8; Jer 5:31; Hos 8:7, Hos 9:1-4, Hos 9:16, Hos 10:12-15; Joe 1:5-12; Gal 6:7, Gal 6:8
a heap in the day of grief and of desperate sorrow : or, removed in the day of inheritance, and there shall be deadly sorrow. Isa 65:13, Isa 65:14; Mat 8:11, Mat 8:12; Rom 2:5, Rom 2:8, Rom 2:9

TSK: Isa 17:12 - -- multitude : or, noise, Isa 9:5
make a noise : Isa 5:26-30, Isa 8:7, Isa 8:8, Isa 28:17; Psa 18:4, Psa 46:1-3, Psa 65:6, Psa 65:7, Psa 93:3, Psa 93:4; ...

TSK: Isa 17:13 - -- but : Isa 10:15, Isa 10:16, Isa 10:33, Isa 10:34, Isa 14:25, Isa 25:4, Isa 25:5, Isa 27:1, Isa 30:30-33, Isa 31:8, Isa 31:9, Isa 33:1-3, Isa 33:9-12; ...
but : Isa 10:15, Isa 10:16, Isa 10:33, Isa 10:34, Isa 14:25, Isa 25:4, Isa 25:5, Isa 27:1, Isa 30:30-33, Isa 31:8, Isa 31:9, Isa 33:1-3, Isa 33:9-12; Isa 37:29-38; Psa 9:5, Psa 46:5-11
rebuke : Job 38:11; Mar 4:39-41
shall be : Isa 29:5, Isa 41:15, Isa 41:16; Job 21:18; Psa 1:4, Psa 35:5, Psa 83:13-15; Dan 2:35; Hos 13:3
a rolling thing : or, thistle-down

TSK: Isa 17:14 - -- at eveningtide : Isa 10:28-32; 2Ki 19:3, 2Ki 19:35; Psa 37:36
the portion : Isa 33:1; Jdg 5:31; Job 20:29; Pro 22:23; Jer 2:3, Jer 13:25; Eze 39:10; H...

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes: Isa 17:9 - -- His strong cities - The cities of the united kingdoms of Damascus and Samaria. Be as a forsaken bough - There has been much difficulty in...
His strong cities - The cities of the united kingdoms of Damascus and Samaria.
Be as a forsaken bough - There has been much difficulty in the interpretation of this passage. Lowth says, ‘ No one has ever been able to make any tolerable sense of these words;’ and proposes himself the translation,
In that day shall his strongly fenced cities become
Like the desertion of the Hivites and the Amorites;
Following in this the translation of the Septuagint, but doing violence to the Hebrew text. Rosenmuller translates it, ‘ As the remnant of a grove when the thicket is cut down, and when few trees are left.’ The word rendered ‘ bough’ (
And an uppermost branch - Isa 17:6. As a few berries are left in the topmost branch of the olive, or the vine, so shall I a few cities or people be left in the general desolation.
Which they left - Which "are"left, or which the invaders would leave.
Because of the children of Israel - literally, ‘ from the face,’ that is, before the children of Israel. Lowth supposes that it refers to the Amorites, who left their land before the Israelites, or gave up their land for them. Vitringa renders it, ‘ On account of the children of Israel;’ and supposes that it means that a few cities were spared by the purpose of God in the invasion by Tiglath-pileser, to be a residence of the Israelites that should remain; or that, for some reason which is not known, the Assyrians chose to spare a few towns, and not wholly to destroy the country. The "general"idea is plain, that a few towns would be left, and that it would be "before"the children of Israel, or in their presence, or in order that they might continue to dwell in them. Jerome interprets the whole as referring to the time when the land of Judea was forsaken on the invasion of the Romans.
And there shall be desolation - The land shall be desolated, except the few cities and towns that shall be left, like the gleaning of the olive tree.

Barnes: Isa 17:10 - -- Because thou ... - Because the kingdom of Israel or Samaria had done it. The God of thy salvation - The God in whom alone was salvation; ...
Because thou ... - Because the kingdom of Israel or Samaria had done it.
The God of thy salvation - The God in whom alone was salvation; or who alone could protect thee (compare Mic 7:7; Hos 2:15).
The rock of thy strength - God. A rock of strength is a strongly fortified place; or a rock which an enemy could not successfully assail. High rocks were selected as a place of refuge from an invading foe (see the notes at Isa 1:10, Isa 1:21). In allusion to this, God is often called "a Rock,"and a strong tower Deu 32:4, Deu 32:15, Deu 32:18, Deu 32:30-31, Deu 32:37; 1Sa 2:2; 2Sa 22:2-3, 2Sa 22:32; Psa 18:31, Psa 18:46; Psa 19:14; Psa 28:1; Psa 30:1-2.
Shalt thou plant pleasant plants - Plants that are suited to produce pleasure or delight; that is, you shall cultivate your fields, and set them out with choice vines and plants in hope of a future harvest, but you shall be disappointed.
And shall set it with strange slips - The word ‘ slips’ means the "cuttings"of the vine that are set in the ground to grow; or the shoot or sucker that is taken off and "set out,"or put in the earth to take root and grow, as is often done by farmers and gardeners. The word ‘ strange’ here means "foreign,"those which are procured from a distance, and which are, therefore, esteemed valuable; plants selected with care. This does not mean, as Lowth supposes, strange and idolatrous worship, and the vicious practices connected with it; but it means that, though they should be at great pains and expense in cultivating their land, yet the enemy would come in and make it desolate.

Barnes: Isa 17:11 - -- In the day ... - Thou shalt cultivate it assiduously and constantly. Thou shalt be at special pains that it may be watered and pruned, in order...
In the day ... - Thou shalt cultivate it assiduously and constantly. Thou shalt be at special pains that it may be watered and pruned, in order that it may produce abundantly.
And in the morning - With early care and attention - denoting the pains that would be bestowed on the young plant.
The harvest shall be a heap - The margin reads this, ‘ the harvest shall be removed in the day of inheritance, rendering it as if the word
In the day of grief - The word rendered ‘ grief’ here (
And desperate sorrow - The word rendered ‘ desperate’ (
The twelfth verse commences a new prophecy, which has no connection with that which precedes it; and which in itself gives no certain indication of the time when it was uttered, or of the people to which it relates. It is a broken and detached piece, and is evidently the description of some army rushing to conquest, and confident of success, but which was to be overtaken with sudden calamity. The entire description is so applicable to the invasion of the land of Judah by the army of Sennacherib, and his overthrow by the angel of Yahweh, that by the common consent of interpreters it has been regarded as referring to it (see the notes at Isa. 10). But when it was spoken, or why it was placed here, is unknown. It may be added that many commentators, and, among the rest, Gesenius, have supposed that the following chapter is a part of this prophecy. The general sense of the prophecy is, that numerous hostile nations would overrun Palestine, but that Yahweh would destroy them all.

Barnes: Isa 17:12 - -- Wo to the multitude ... - The word ‘ woe’ ( הוי hôy ) may be either an interjection simply directing the attention to them...
Wo to the multitude ... - The word ‘ woe’ (
The multitude of many people - Or, the tumult of many nations - a description of the noise attending an invading army made up of many nations mingled together, such as was that of Sennacherib.
Which make a noise ... - This is a beautiful description of a vast army, and of the shouting, the tumult, the din, which attends its march. The same comparison occurs in Jer 6:23; Psa 65:7 (see Eze 43:2; Rev 1:15; Rev 14:2; Rev 19:6).
And to the rushing of nations - The rushing of mighty armies to conquest.

Barnes: Isa 17:13 - -- God shall rebuke them - The word ‘ God’ is not here in the original, but is evidently to be supplied. The word ‘ rebuke’ ...
God shall rebuke them - The word ‘ God’ is not here in the original, but is evidently to be supplied. The word ‘ rebuke’ means that he would disarrange their plans, prevent their success, and defeat their purposes. It shows the great power of God, that he can thus by a "rebuke"- a word - arrest mighty nations, and discomfit thom when they are tumultuously hastening onward in the confidence of victory. This discomfiture refers, doubtless, to the overthrow of Sennacherib and his army by the pestilence (2Ki 19:35; see the notes at Isa 37:36).
And they shall flee far off - The whole army of Sennacherib was not destroyed, but a part with himself returned to Assyria 2Ki 19:36.
And shall be chased as the chaff ... - Denoting the case with which God would do it, and the certain and entire discomfiture of the army. The figure is one that is very striking in describing an army that is routed, and that flees in disorder (compare Job 21:18; Psa 1:4; Psa 35:5; Isa 29:5; Hos 13:3).
And like a rolling thing - Margin, ‘ Thistle-down.’ It means, literally, anything that "rolls"(

Barnes: Isa 17:14 - -- At evening-tide trouble - In the time of evening - that is, in the night. Before the morning he is not - That is, he is destroyed. This i...
At evening-tide trouble - In the time of evening - that is, in the night.
Before the morning he is not - That is, he is destroyed. This is strikingly descriptive of the destruction of the army of Sennacherib on that fatal night when the angel of the Lord killed 185,000 men (see the note at Isa 37:36).
This is the portion of them that spoil us - Of those who would plunder us. This is a "general"declaration in regard to the enemies of the Jewish people. This is the lot, the end, the destiny of all who attempt to destroy them. That is, the people of God shall be safe whoever rises up against them; and whatever may be the number, or the power of their foes, they shall be overthrown.
Poole: Isa 17:9 - -- In that day; in the day of Jacob’ s trouble, of which he spake Isa 17:4 , and continueth his speech unto these words, and afterwards.
An upper...
In that day; in the day of Jacob’ s trouble, of which he spake Isa 17:4 , and continueth his speech unto these words, and afterwards.
An uppermost branch which he that pruneth the tree neglecteth, either because he esteems it useless and inconsiderable, or because he cannot reach it.
Which they left because of the children of Israel: the sense is either,
1. Which they to wit, the enemies, left or, which shall be left, (the active verb being put impersonally, as it frequently is in the Hebrew text,)
because of or for the children of Israel which God inclined their hearts to leave or spare, out of his love to his Israel. Thus this is mentioned as a mercy, or mitigation of the calamity. But this seems not to agree either with the foregoing or following words, both which manifestly speak of the greatness of the judgment. And that their strong cities were not left for them, but taken from them, seems evident from Isa 17:3,4 . Or,
2. As the cities (which words are easily understood out of the former part of the verse, where they are expressed) which they (to wit, the Canaanites, as the seventy interpreters express it; and it was needless to name them, because the history was so well known to them to whom the prophet writes) left or forsook (which they did either by departing from them, or being destroyed out of them) bemuse of (or before , or for fear of ) the children of Israel . And this was a very fit example, to awaken the Israelites to a serious belief of this threatening, because God had inflicted the same judgment upon the Canaanites, and that for the same sins of which they were guilty.

Poole: Isa 17:10 - -- Thou O Israel. The Rock of thy strength; that God Who was thy only sure defence.
Pleasant plants excellent flowers and fruit trees.
Strange slips ...
Thou O Israel. The Rock of thy strength; that God Who was thy only sure defence.
Pleasant plants excellent flowers and fruit trees.
Strange slips fetched from far countries. and therefore highly esteemed. The sense is, Thou shalt use much industry and cost, but to no purpose, as it follows.

Poole: Isa 17:11 - -- In the day shalt thou make thy plant to grow, and in the morning shalt thou make thy seed to flourish thou shalt from day to day, beginning early in ...
In the day shalt thou make thy plant to grow, and in the morning shalt thou make thy seed to flourish thou shalt from day to day, beginning early in the morning, use all care and diligence that what thou hast planted and sown may thrive; and thou shalt see some effect of thy labours, and some hopes of success.
But the harvest shall be a heap in the day of grief and of desperate sorrow: the sense of the words thus rendered is this, But in the time of your grief, &c., or when this grievous calamity shall come, all your harvest shall be but one heap, which in itself is very inconsiderable, and is easily carried away by your enemies. But the place is and may be otherwise rendered, and that very agreeably both to the words and order of the Hebrew text; But the heap (or, heaps , the singular number being most commonly put for the plural) of the harvest (i.e. instead of those heaps of corn which thou didst expect, and which men usually reap in harvest)
in the day or time (to wit, of the harvest; or, in the day of calamity, of which I have spoken, Isa 17:4,9 ; or, in a day, i.e. speedily or suddenly) shall be (or, thou shalt have)
grief and desperate sorrow This shall be all thy harvest, and the event of thy labours.

Poole: Isa 17:12 - -- This is a new prophecy, added for the present support and comfort of God’ s people.
The multitude of many people combined together against Ju...
This is a new prophecy, added for the present support and comfort of God’ s people.
The multitude of many people combined together against Judah. It matters not whether you understand this of the Syrians and Israelites who were united against Judah, or of the Assyrians, whose army consisted of vast numbers, and of men of several nations. The following words agree to either of them.
Which make a noise like the noise of the seas which invade my land and people with great force and fury, as the sea doth, either in its own channel, or when it enters into the land by a breach.

Poole: Isa 17:13 - -- Shall rebuke them not in words, but deeds; shall discomfit and overthrow them.
Like a rolling thing which is easily moved by every slight touch, an...
Shall rebuke them not in words, but deeds; shall discomfit and overthrow them.
Like a rolling thing which is easily moved by every slight touch, and much more by a violent wind. Or, like a wisp , to wit, of straw, which is sometimes rolled together.

Poole: Isa 17:14 - -- Behold at evening-tide trouble; and before the morning he is not: at even there is a great terror and consternation among God’ s people, for fea...
Behold at evening-tide trouble; and before the morning he is not: at even there is a great terror and consternation among God’ s people, for fear of their enemies; and ere the morning cometh, their enemies are cut off by the hand of God. This was literally and eminently fulfilled in the destruction of Sennacherib’ s army before Jerusalem. Although the words may be more generally understood of any great and sudden change, and unexpected deliverance, granted to God’ s people, when their enemies were ready to devour them. And this place may be compared with that in Psa 30:5 , Weeping may endure for a night, but joy cometh in the morning. This is the portion of them that spoil us, and the lot of them that rob us : this is a triumphant conclusion, uttered by the prophet in the name of God’ s people.
Haydock: Isa 17:9 - -- Left. By the Chanaanites, when the children of Israel came into their land. (Challoner) ---
Their consternation was become proverbial, Josue ii. 9...
Left. By the Chanaanites, when the children of Israel came into their land. (Challoner) ---
Their consternation was become proverbial, Josue ii. 9., and v. 11.

Haydock: Isa 17:10 - -- Good. Septuagint, "fruitless." Israel had abandoned the Lord; and could expect nothing but the fruits of death. (Calmet)
Good. Septuagint, "fruitless." Israel had abandoned the Lord; and could expect nothing but the fruits of death. (Calmet)

Much. Thou hast laboured earnestly, but reaped no benefit. (Haydock)

Haydock: Isa 17:12 - -- Multitude, &c. This and all that follows to the end of the chapter, relates to the Assyrian army under Sennacherib, (Challoner) or rather to that of...
Multitude, &c. This and all that follows to the end of the chapter, relates to the Assyrian army under Sennacherib, (Challoner) or rather to that of Israel and its allies. (Calmet) ---
After the Assyrians had afflicted Israel, they were also punished. (Worthington)
Gill: Isa 17:9 - -- In that day shall his strong cities be as a forsaken bough, and an uppermost branch,.... Meaning the strong cities of Ephraim or Jacob, the ten tribes...
In that day shall his strong cities be as a forsaken bough, and an uppermost branch,.... Meaning the strong cities of Ephraim or Jacob, the ten tribes, which should be forsaken of their inhabitants; having fled from before the enemy, or being slain or carried captive; like a bough of a tree, that is forsaken stripped of its leaves, and an uppermost branch of a tree that is dead and dry, and has nothing on it:
which they left; or "as they left", or "were left":
because of the children of Israel; "from the face of" them; or for fear of them; that is, the same cities which the Canaanites left; and as they left them, or were left by them, for fear of the Israelites; the same, and in the same manner, shall they be left by the Israelites, for fear of the Assyrians; and so the Septuagint version reads the words,
"in that day thy cities shall be forsaken, in like manner as the Amorites and Hivites left them, from the face of the children of Israel;''
and this sense is given by Aben Ezra and Kimchi: though some interpret it of some places being spared and left for the remnant to dwell in; but what follows in this verse, and in the next Isa 17:10, shows the contrary sense:
and there shall be desolation; over all those cities, and in all the land; though Aben Ezra particularly applies it to Samaria, the royal city. Jerom interprets the whole of the cities of Judea being forsaken of their inhabitants, when the Romans besieged Jerusalem, and made the land desolate; which calamity came upon them, for their neglect and forgetfulness of Jesus the Saviour.

Gill: Isa 17:10 - -- Because thou hast forgotten the God of thy salvation,.... Who had been the author of salvation to them many a time, in Egypt, at the Red Sea, and in v...
Because thou hast forgotten the God of thy salvation,.... Who had been the author of salvation to them many a time, in Egypt, at the Red Sea, and in various instances since; and yet they had forgot his works of mercy and goodness, and had left his worship, and gone after idols; and this was the cause of their cities being forsaken, and becoming a desolation:
and hast not been mindful of the rock of thy strength; or strong Rock, who had supplied and supported them, protected and defended them:
therefore shalt thou plant pleasant plants; or "plants of pleasant fruit" s, or "plants of Naamanim"; and so Aben Ezra takes it to be the proper name of a plant in the Arabic language, and which he says is a plant that grows very quick; perhaps he means "Anemone", which is so called in that language t, and is near to it in sound; though rather, not any particular plant is meant, but all sorts of pleasant plants, flowers, and fruit trees, with which the land of Israel abounded:
and shall set it with strange slips; with foreign ones, such as are brought from other countries, and are scarce and dear, and highly valued; and by "plants" and "slips" may be meant false and foreign doctrines, inculcating idolatry and superstition, which are pleasing to the flesh u.

Gill: Isa 17:11 - -- In the day shall thou make thy plant to grow,.... Not that it is in the power of man to make it grow; but the sense is, that all means and methods sho...
In the day shall thou make thy plant to grow,.... Not that it is in the power of man to make it grow; but the sense is, that all means and methods should be used to make it grow, no cost nor pains should be spared:
and in the morning shall thou make thy seed to flourish; which may denote both diligence in the early care of it, and seeming promising success; and yet all should be in vain, and to no purpose:
but the harvest shall be a heap in the day of grief; or "of inheritance"; when it was about to be possessed and enjoyed, according to expectation, it shall be all thrown together in a heap, and be spoiled by the enemy: or, "the harvest" shall be "removed in the day of inheritance" w; just when the fruit is ripe, and going to be gathered in, the enemy shall come and take it all away; and so, instead of being a time of joy, as harvest usually is, it will be a time of grief and trouble,
and of desperate sorrow too, or "deadly"; which will leave them in despair, without hope of subsistence for the present year, or of having another harvest hereafter, the land coming into the hands of their enemies.

Gill: Isa 17:12 - -- Woe to the multitude of many people,..... Not as lamenting the people of the Jews with Hezekiah, as if they were the words of the prophet bemoaning th...
Woe to the multitude of many people,..... Not as lamenting the people of the Jews with Hezekiah, as if they were the words of the prophet bemoaning their condition, saying, "O the multitude", &c. nor intending the Syrians and Israelites joined together against Judah; but the Assyrian army under Sennacherib, which consisted of people of many nations, and was very numerous, who are either threatened or called unto. A new subject is here begun, though a short one.
which make a noise like the noise of the seas; in a storm, when they foam and rage, and overflow the banks; this may refer both to the noise made by the march of such a vast army, the rattling of their armour and chariot wheels, and prancing of their horses; and to the hectoring, blustering, and blasphemous speeches of Sennacherib and Rabshakeh:
and to the rushing of nations, or "rushing nations",
that make a rushing like the rushing of mighty, waters; which denotes the fury and force with which they come, threatening to bear down all before them, as an inundation of water does.

Gill: Isa 17:13 - -- The nations shall rush like the rushing of many waters,.... With great force and noise, and run over the whole land, as the Assyrian army did, until i...
The nations shall rush like the rushing of many waters,.... With great force and noise, and run over the whole land, as the Assyrian army did, until it came to Jerusalem, and there it stopped; see Isa 8:7,
but God shall rebuke them; as he did the waters of the Red Sea, Psa 106:9 and as Christ rebuked the winds and sea, and made a calm, Mat 8:26. The word "God" is not in the text, but rightly supplied; for as none but he can rebuke the mighty waters of the sea, so none but he could have destroyed such an army in the manner it was, and wrought such a salvation for his people. The phrase, is expressive both of his wrath and power.
And they shall flee afar off; from Jerusalem to Nineveh, reckoned to be six hundred and eighty four miles from thence: or, "he shall flee afar off" x; that is, Sennacherib, and the few that escaped with him, for, his army was destroyed; see 2Ki 19:36,
and shall be chased as the chaff of the mountains before the wind; chaff upon the floor is easily chased away with the fan, and much more easily chaff upon the mountains with the wind; it was usual with the Jews to thresh their corn, and winnow it on hills and mountains, to which the allusion is; see 2Ch 3:1 or "the dust of the mountains", as some y render it, which is more exposed to the wind than that in the valleys. Kings and great men of the earth are but as dust with God; and the higher they are, or they exalt themselves, the more they are exposed to the power of his wrath, and as easily cast down as the dust is scattered by the wind:
and like a rolling thing before the whirlwind; or "like a wheel" z, as the word is sometimes rendered; or any round thing, as a round wisp of straw or stubble, which is easily and swiftly moved and rolled along, especially by a strong wind. Jarchi interprets it of the flower of thorns; that is, the down of the thistle, which, when blown off, rolls up, and, being exceeding light, is carried away at once; see Psa 83:13 all which shows what poor light things the greatest of men are in the hands of God, and with what ease he can chase them from place to place, and out of the world, when it is his pleasure.

Gill: Isa 17:14 - -- And behold at eveningtide trouble,.... Or terror a and consternation; which some understand of that which was in the Assyrian army, when the Angel of ...
And behold at eveningtide trouble,.... Or terror a and consternation; which some understand of that which was in the Assyrian army, when the Angel of the Lord destroyed it, taking "evening for night", for it was in the night that that was done; so Jarchi interprets it of Shedim, a sort of spirits or demons, that came against the enemy, and troubled and frightened them: but it is best to take it in the more common sense, of the trouble that Hezekiah and the inhabitants of Jerusalem were in, on the evening or night before their deliverance; the whole land of Judea round about them being laid waste, their city besieged by a powerful army, and the enemy blaspheming, blustering, and triumphing:
and before the morning he is not; Sennacherib, the king of Assyria, he was not before Jerusalem, he was fled: or "it was not" b; the Assyrian army was not, it was destroyed by an angel in the night, and in the morning were all dead corpses, 2Ki 19:35 or trouble was not, that was all over, joy came in the morning; see Psa 30:5,
this is the portion of them that spoil us, and the lot of them that rob us; these are the words of the prophet, and of the people of God, he represents, making observation upon, and use of the above dispensation, though not confining it to that; and their meaning is, that this is not the case of these Assyrians only, but of all the enemies of God's people, who, sooner or later, come to destruction; and which is not by chance, but by the appointment and disposition of God, who allots and portions out ruin unto them, as the just reward of their works; see Job 20:29.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes: Isa 17:9 The Hebrew text reads literally, “like the abandonment of the wooded height and the top one.” The following relative clause appears to all...

NET Notes: Isa 17:10 Heb “a vine, a strange one.” The substantival adjective זָר (zar) functions here as an appositional genitive. It could r...

NET Notes: Isa 17:11 The Hebrew text has, “a heap of harvest.” However, better sense is achieved if נֵד (ned, “heap”) is emended ...



NET Notes: Isa 17:14 Heb “this is the portion of those who plunder us, and the lot of those who loot us.”
Geneva Bible: Isa 17:9 In that day shall his strong cities be as a forsaken bough, and an uppermost branch, which ( l ) they left because of the children of Israel: and ther...

Geneva Bible: Isa 17:10 Because thou hast forgotten the God of thy salvation, and hast not been mindful of the rock of thy strength, therefore shalt thou plant pleasant plant...

Geneva Bible: Isa 17:11 In the day shalt thou make thy plant to grow, and in the morning shalt thou make thy seed to flourish: [but] the harvest [shall be] a heap in the day ...

Geneva Bible: Isa 17:12 ( o ) Woe to the multitude of many people, [who] make a noise like the noise of the seas; and to the rushing of nations, [that] make a rushing like th...

Geneva Bible: Isa 17:13 The nations shall rush like the rushing of many waters: but [God] shall ( p ) rebuke them, and they shall flee far off, and shall be chased as the cha...

Geneva Bible: Isa 17:14 And behold at the time of evening ( q ) trouble; [and] before the morning he [is] not. This [is] the portion of them that plunder us, and the lot of t...

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Isa 17:1-14
TSK Synopsis: Isa 17:1-14 - --1 Syria and Israel are threatened.6 A remnant shall forsake idolatry.9 The rest shall be plagued for their impiety.12 The woe of Israel's enemies.
Maclaren -> Isa 17:10-11
Maclaren: Isa 17:10-11 - --The Harvest Of A Godless Life
Because thou hast forgotten the God of thy salvation, and hast not been mindful of the Rock of thy strength, therefore ...
MHCC -> Isa 17:1-11; Isa 17:12-14
MHCC: Isa 17:1-11 - --Sin desolates cities. It is strange that great conquerors should take pride in being enemies to mankind; but it is better that flocks should lie down ...

MHCC: Isa 17:12-14 - --The rage and force of the Assyrians resembled the mighty waters of the sea; but when the God of Israel should rebuke them, they would flee like chaff,...
Matthew Henry -> Isa 17:9-11; Isa 17:12-14
Matthew Henry: Isa 17:9-11 - -- Here the prophet returns to foretel the woeful desolations that should be made in the land of Israel by the army of the Assyrians. 1. That the citie...

Matthew Henry: Isa 17:12-14 - -- These verses read the doom of those that spoil and rob the people of God. If the Assyrians and Israelites invade and plunder Judah, if the Assyrian ...
Keil-Delitzsch -> Isa 17:9-11; Isa 17:12-14
Keil-Delitzsch: Isa 17:9-11 - --
Third turn: "In that day will his fortified cities be like the ruins of the forest and of the mountain top, which they cleared before the sons of I...

Keil-Delitzsch: Isa 17:12-14 - --
Fourth turn: "Woe to the raoring of many nations: like the roaring of seas they roar; and to the rumbling of nations, like the rumbling of mighty w...
Constable: Isa 7:1--39:8 - --III. Israel's crisis of faith chs. 7--39
This long section of the book deals with Israel's major decision in Isa...

Constable: Isa 13:1--35:10 - --B. God's sovereignty over the nations chs. 13-35
This major section of the book emphasizes the folly of ...

Constable: Isa 13:1--23:18 - --1. Divine judgments on the nations chs. 13-23
The recurrence of the Hebrew word massa', translat...

Constable: Isa 13:1--20:6 - --The first series of five oracles chs. 13-20
The first series shows that God has placed I...
