
Text -- Joshua 2:17-24 (NET)




Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics



collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Wesley: Jos 2:17 - -- Or, had said; namely, before she let them down; it being very improbable, either that she would dismiss them before the condition was agreed on; or th...
Or, had said; namely, before she let them down; it being very improbable, either that she would dismiss them before the condition was agreed on; or that she would discourse with them, or they with her, about such secret and weighty things after they were let down, when others might overhear them.

Wesley: Jos 2:17 - -- That is, free from guilt or reproach if it be violated, namely, if the following condition be not observed.
That is, free from guilt or reproach if it be violated, namely, if the following condition be not observed.

That is, over Jordan, and near the city.

Probably the same with which she was about to let them down.

That it may be easily discerned by our soldiers.

Wesley: Jos 2:19 - -- The blame of his death shall rest wholly upon himself, as being occasioned by his own neglect of the means of safety.
The blame of his death shall rest wholly upon himself, as being occasioned by his own neglect of the means of safety.

We are willing to bear the sin, and shame, and punishment of it.

Wesley: Jos 2:21 - -- Forthwith, partly that the spies might see it hung out before their departure, and so the better know it at some distance; partly lest some accident m...
Forthwith, partly that the spies might see it hung out before their departure, and so the better know it at some distance; partly lest some accident might occasion a neglect about it.

Wesley: Jos 2:22 - -- Supporting themselves there with the provisions, which Rahab had furnished them with.
Supporting themselves there with the provisions, which Rahab had furnished them with.

Wesley: Jos 2:22 - -- That is, in the road to Jordan, and the places near it, but not in the mountains.
That is, in the road to Jordan, and the places near it, but not in the mountains.
JFB: Jos 2:16-21 - -- Rather "she had said," for what follows must have been part of the previous conversation.
Rather "she had said," for what follows must have been part of the previous conversation.

JFB: Jos 2:16-21 - -- A range of white limestone hills extends on the north, called Quarantania (now Jebel Karantu), rising to a height of from twelve hundred to fifteen hu...
A range of white limestone hills extends on the north, called Quarantania (now Jebel Karantu), rising to a height of from twelve hundred to fifteen hundred feet, and the sides of which are perforated with caves. Some one peak adjoining was familiarly known to the inhabitants as "the mountain." The prudence and propriety of the advice to flee in that direction rather than to the ford, were made apparent by the sequel.

JFB: Jos 2:21 - -- Probably soon after the departure of the spies. It was not formed, as some suppose, into network, as a lattice, but simply to hang down the wall. Its ...
Probably soon after the departure of the spies. It was not formed, as some suppose, into network, as a lattice, but simply to hang down the wall. Its red color made it conspicuous, and it was thus a sign and pledge of safety to Rahab's house, as the bloody mark on the lintels of the houses of the Israelites in Egypt to that people.
Clarke: Jos 2:18 - -- This line of scarlet thread - תקות חוט השני tikvath chut hashshani . Probably this may mean, this piece of scarlet cloth, or, this clot...
This line of scarlet thread -

Clarke: Jos 2:20 - -- If thou utter this our business - It was prudent to make her life depend on her secresy; had it been otherwise she might have been tempted to give i...
If thou utter this our business - It was prudent to make her life depend on her secresy; had it been otherwise she might have been tempted to give information, not only concerning the spies, but concerning the designs of the Israelites. But her life being at stake, added to every other motive, she kept the secret for the sake of her own personal safety and that of all her relatives.

Clarke: Jos 2:23 - -- So the two men returned - Having concealed themselves in the mountains that night, all the next day, and the night ensuing, on the third day they re...
So the two men returned - Having concealed themselves in the mountains that night, all the next day, and the night ensuing, on the third day they returned to Joshua.

Clarke: Jos 2:24 - -- Truly the Lord hath delivered into our hands all the land - How different was this report from that brought by the spies on a former occasion! They ...
Truly the Lord hath delivered into our hands all the land - How different was this report from that brought by the spies on a former occasion! They found that all the inhabitants of the land were panic-struck. The people had heard of the great exploits of the Israelites on the other side of Jordan; and as they had destroyed the potent kings of the Amorites, they took it for granted that nothing could stand before them. This information was necessary to Joshua to guide him in forming the plan of his campaign
1. It may be asked, Did not Rahab lie in the account she gave to the officers of the king of Jericho, (Jos 2:4, Jos 2:5), There came men unto me, etc.? I answer, She certainly did; and the inspired writer sets down the fact merely as it stood, without making the Spirit of God responsible for the dissimulation of the woman. But was she not rewarded, etc.? Yes; for her hospitality and faith, not for her lie. But could she have saved the spies without telling a lie? Yes, she certainly might; but what notion could a woman of her occupation, though nothing worse than an inn-keeper, have of the nicer distinctions between truth and falsehood, living among a most profligate and depraved people, where truth could scarcely be known
2. There is a lax morality in the world that recommends a lie rather than the truth, when the purposes of religion and humanity can be served by it. But when can this be? The religion of Christ is one eternal system of truth, and can neither be served by a lie nor admit one. On this vile subject fine words have been spoken. Tasso, in his elegant episode of Sophronia and Olindo, in the Gerusalemme Liberata, b. ii., v. 22, represents the former as telling a lie to Saladdin, relative to the stealing of an image, for which, as he could not discover the culprit, he doomed all the Christians in his power to death. Sophronia, a pious Christian virgin, getting into the presence of the tyrant, in order to save her people, accuses herself, though perfectly innocent, of the theft. Her conduct on this occasion the poet embellishes in the following manner, for which the religion of that time, which dealt in holy frauds, would no doubt applaud him
‘ Ed ella: il reo si trova al tuo cospetto
Opra e il furto, Signor, di questa man
Io l’ immagine tolsi; Io son cole
Che tu ricerchi, e me punir tu dei
Cosi al pubblico fato il capo alter
Offerse, e ‘ l volle in se sol racorre
Magnanima Menzogna! or quando e il Ver
Si Bello, che si possa a te preporre?
Then she: "Before thy sight the guilty stands
The theft, O King, committed by these hands
In me the thief who stole the image view
To me the punishment decreed is due.
Thus, filled with public zeal, the generous dam
A victim for her people’ s ransom came
O great deceit! O lie divinely fair
What truth with such a falsehood can compare
Hoole
Thus a lie is ornamented with splendid decorations both by the Italian and English poet, and the whole formed into an anti-apostolic maxim, Let us do Evil, that Good may come of it. A purer morality was taught by one of the most ancient heathen writers than is here preached by these demi-christians: -
Iliad. l. ix., v. 312
My soul detests him as the gates of hell
Who knows the truth and dares a falsehood tell
The following is the advice of a genuine Christian poet, and one of the holiest men of his time: -
Lie not; but let thy heart be true to God
Thy tongue to it, thy actions to them bot
Cowards tell lies, and those who fear the rod
The stormy working soul spits lies and froth
Dare To Be True! nothing can Need a lie
The fault that needs it most grows Two thereby
Herbert
For other observations on this subject see the notes on Gen 12:20, at the end, and Gen 20:12
3. Though the hand of God was evidently in every thing that concerned the Israelites, and they were taught to consider that by his might alone they were to be put in possession of the promised land; yet they were as fully convinced that if they did not use the counsel, prudence, and strength which they had received from him, they should not succeed. Hence, while they depended on the Divine direction and power, they exercised their own prudence, and put forth their own strength; and thus they were workers together with him, and did not receive the grace of God in vain. The application of this maxim is easy; and we cannot expect any success, either in things spiritual or temporal, unless we walk by the same rule and mind the same thing.
Calvin -> Jos 2:24
Calvin: Jos 2:24 - -- 24.And they said unto Joshua, etc. This passage shows that Joshua was not mistaken in selecting his spies; for their language proves them to have bee...
24.And they said unto Joshua, etc. This passage shows that Joshua was not mistaken in selecting his spies; for their language proves them to have been right-hearted men possessed of rare integrity. Others, perhaps, not recovered from the terror into which they had once been thrown, would have disturbed the whole camp, but these, while they reflect on the wonderful kindness of God, displayed in their escape from danger, and the happy issue of their expedition, exhort Joshua and the people to go boldly forward. And although the mere promise of possessing the land ought to have been sufficient, yet the Lord is so very indulgent to their weakness, that, for the sake of removing all doubt, he confirms what he had promised by experience. That the Lord had not spoken in vain, was proved by the consternation of the nations, when it began already to put them to flight., and to drive them out, as if hornets had been sent in upon them. For they argue in the same way as Rahab had done, that the land was given to them, as the inhabitants had almost fainted away from fear. I have therefore used the illative particle for, though the literal meaning is, and also. But it is sufficiently plain, that in the other way there is a confirmation of what they had said. And, indeed, the courage of all melted away, as if they felt themselves routed by the hand of God.
Defender -> Jos 2:18
Defender: Jos 2:18 - -- It is noteworthy that the word translated "line" (here and in Jos 2:21), which has its first occurrence in the Bible at this point, is never translate...
It is noteworthy that the word translated "line" (here and in Jos 2:21), which has its first occurrence in the Bible at this point, is never translated "line" anywhere else in the Bible. Its usual meaning is hope. "Thou art my hope, O Lord God" (Psa 71:5). This thin scarlet line, the scarlet color perhaps speaking of the blood of sacrifice, was thus Rahab's only hope of deliverance for herself and her loved ones. All others in Jericho perished when the children of Israel took it several days later (Jos 6:25)."
TSK: Jos 2:17 - -- Jos 2:20; Gen 24:3-8; Exo 20:7; Lev 19:11, Lev 19:12; Num 30:2; 2Sa 21:1, 2Sa 21:2, 2Sa 21:7

TSK: Jos 2:18 - -- scarlet thread : Jos 2:21; Lev 14:4; Num 4:8, Num 19:6; Heb 9:19
bring : Heb. gather
thy father : Jos 2:13, Jos 6:23; Gen 7:1, Gen 12:2, Gen 19:12-17;...

TSK: Jos 2:19 - -- whosoever : Exo 12:13, Exo 12:23; Num 35:26-28; 1Ki 2:36-42; Mat 24:17; Act 27:31; Phi 3:9; Heb 10:29; 1Jo 2:27, 1Jo 2:28
his blood : Lev 20:9, Lev 20...



TSK: Jos 2:24 - -- Truly the Lord : Jos 1:8, Jos 21:44, Jos 21:45; Exo 23:31; Num 13:32, Num 13:33; Pro 25:13
all the inhabitants : Jos 2:9-11; Psa 48:5, Psa 48:6; Rev 6...

collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes: Jos 2:18 - -- The "line"or cord was spun of threads dyed with cochineal: i. e., of a deep and bright scarlet color. The color would catch the eye at once, and sup...
The "line"or cord was spun of threads dyed with cochineal: i. e., of a deep and bright scarlet color. The color would catch the eye at once, and supplied an obvious token by which the house of Rahab might be distinguished. The use of scarlet in the Levitical rites, especially in those more closely connected with the idea of putting away of sin and its consequences (compare e. g., Lev 14:4, Lev 14:6,Lev 14:51; Num 19:6), naturally led the fathers, from Clement of Rome onward, to see in this scarlet thread, no less than in the blood of the Passover (Exo 12:7, Exo 12:13, etc.), an emblem of salvation by the Blood of Christ; a salvation common alike to Christ’ s messengers and to those whom they visit.

Barnes: Jos 2:22 - -- Unto the mountain - Probably the mountains to the west and north of Jericho, called afterward, from the belief that the 40 days of our LordR...
Unto the mountain - Probably the mountains to the west and north of Jericho, called afterward, from the belief that the 40 days of our Lord’ s temptation were passed among them, the Quarantania. The spies avoided at the first the neighhourhood of the Jordan, where the pursuers sought them: and amidst the grottoes of the limestone rocks, which in later ages were the abode of numerous hermits, they could readily shelter themselves for three days.
Poole: Jos 2:17 - -- The men said or, had said ; namely, before she let them down; it being very improbable, either that she would dismiss them before the condition was ...
The men said or, had said ; namely, before she let them down; it being very improbable, either that she would dismiss them before the condition was expressed and agreed; or that she would discourse with them, or they with her, about such secret and weighty things after they were let down, when others might overhear them; or that she should begin her discourse in her chamber, and not finish it till they were gone out of her house.
Object. They spoke this after they were let down; for it follows, Jos 2:18 , this-thread which thou didst let us down by .
Answ Those words may be thus rendered, which thou dost let us down by , i.e. art about to do it; it being frequent for the pretertense to be used of a thing about to be done, by an enallage of tenses, as Jos 10:15 .
Blameless of this thine oath i.e. free from guilt or reproach if it be violated, namely, if the following condition be not observed.

Poole: Jos 2:18 - -- Into the land i.e. over Jordan, and near the city.
Bind this line of scarlet thread in the window that it may be easily discerned by our soldiers.
Into the land i.e. over Jordan, and near the city.
Bind this line of scarlet thread in the window that it may be easily discerned by our soldiers.

Poole: Jos 2:19 - -- His blood shall be upon his head the blame of his death shall rest wholly upon himself, as being occasioned by his own neglect or contempt of the mea...
His blood shall be upon his head the blame of his death shall rest wholly upon himself, as being occasioned by his own neglect or contempt of the means of safety.
His blood shall be on our head we are willing to bear the sin, and shame, and punishment of it.
If any hand be upon him to wit, so as to kill him, as this phrase is used, Est 6:2 Job 1:12 .

Poole: Jos 2:21 - -- Forthwith, partly, that the spies might see it hung out before their departure, and so the better know it at some distance; partly, lest some accide...
Forthwith, partly, that the spies might see it hung out before their departure, and so the better know it at some distance; partly, lest some accident might occasion a mistake or neglect about it; and partly, for her own comfort, it being pleasant and encouraging to her to have in her eye the pledge of her deliverance.

Poole: Jos 2:22 - -- Abode there three days supporting themselves there with the provisions, which after the manner of those times and places they carried with them, whic...
Abode there three days supporting themselves there with the provisions, which after the manner of those times and places they carried with them, which Rahab furnished them with.
Throughout all the way i.e. in the road to Jordan, and the places near it, but not in the mountains.
Haydock -> Jos 2:24
Haydock: Jos 2:24 - -- Fear, as Rahab had testified. They might also have been witnesses of the people's consternation, which gave them the most assured hopes of victory, ...
Fear, as Rahab had testified. They might also have been witnesses of the people's consternation, which gave them the most assured hopes of victory, as the Lord had given this sign, among others, that he would be with them, Deuteronomy xxviii. 10. (Haydock)
Gill: Jos 2:17 - -- And the men said unto her,.... Some think that this discourse, which passed between the spies and her, was while in the house before she let them down...
And the men said unto her,.... Some think that this discourse, which passed between the spies and her, was while in the house before she let them down, or otherwise they would have been in danger of being overheard, and so the whole affair discovered; but as it was on the other side of the house, and under the wall of the city, and without it, they might with the greater safety converse together:
we will be blameless of this thine oath which thou hast made us swear; that is, they would most faithfully and punctually keep it, it should be sacred to them, and she should have no occasion to lay any blame upon them in the least.

Gill: Jos 2:18 - -- Behold, when we come into the land,.... The land of Canaan, and into this city, into that part of it, as the Septuagint, where her house was, meaning...
Behold, when we come into the land,.... The land of Canaan, and into this city, into that part of it, as the Septuagint, where her house was, meaning not themselves only, but the people of Israel they belonged to:
thou shall bind this line of scarlet thread in the window which thou didst let us down by; the word by refers either to the scarlet thread they were let down by, said to be a cord, Jos 2:15; and therefore must be a line twisted with various scarlet threads, as Kimchi; who observes, that according to the Targum, it was the border of a red garment; or to the window through which they were let down, as the Septuagint version; it may refer to both, and the sense be, that the same twisted cord of scarlet thread they were let down by should be bound to the same window they were let down through; only this objection there is to the same window, that it was not towards the city, and so not to be seen when they came into it, but looked over the wall without the city: now as Rahab was an instance of the salvation of sinners by the grace of God, for she was a sinner by birth, by practice, and a notorious one; she was an instance of distinguishing grace, of free and efficacious grace, a singular instance of it; and became a true penitent, a real believer, was a justified person, and saved: so the scarlet thread was an emblem of the blood of Christ, by which salvation is; redemption and all the blessings of grace are through it; justification, remission of sin, reconciliation, and atonement, and safety, and protection from avenging justice, and wrath to come, are only by it: likewise the spies, who are also called "messengers", Jam 2:25; may represent the ministers of the Gospel, who are the messengers of Christ, and the churches, are sent out by him the antitypical Joshua, men of wisdom, courage, and valour, and are sent as spies to bring to light men and things, who direct to the way of salvation and give the same token of it, Mar 16:16,
and thou shall bring thy father, and thy mother, and thy brethren, and all thy father's household home unto thee; into her house, where the scarlet thread was bound, and where only they would be safe, as the Israelites were in the houses where the blood of the paschal lamb was sprinkled, Exo 12:23; and so they are safe, and they only, who are under the blood of sprinkling, and partake of the virtue of it.

Gill: Jos 2:19 - -- And it shall be, that whosoever shall go out of the door of thy house into the street,.... After they have been taken in, and when the Israelites wer...
And it shall be, that whosoever shall go out of the door of thy house into the street,.... After they have been taken in, and when the Israelites were come into the city:
his blood shall be upon his head, and we will be guiltless; if he is killed by any person, his death will be owing to himself, and no blame to be laid on us; nor shall we reckon ourselves guilty of the breach of the oath taken:
and whosoever shall be with thee in the house, his blood shall be on our head, if any hand be upon him: if anyone within doors is killed by an Israelite entering in, the guilt of the blood shall lie upon us, and we will be answerable, according to the tenor of the oath, "our life for yours", Jos 2:14.

Gill: Jos 2:20 - -- And if thou utter this our business,.... So that others would either hang out scarlet threads or get into her house for shelter; see Gill on Jos 2:14,...
And if thou utter this our business,.... So that others would either hang out scarlet threads or get into her house for shelter; see Gill on Jos 2:14,
then we will be quit of thine oath which thou hast made us to swear; be under no obligation to make it good, by saving her and her father's house.

Gill: Jos 2:21 - -- And she said, according to your words, so be it,.... She agreed, that if the conditions required were not performed, they would be quit of their oath...
And she said, according to your words, so be it,.... She agreed, that if the conditions required were not performed, they would be quit of their oath, but if they were, she expected it would be fulfilled:
and she sent them away, and they departed; took their leave of each other:
and she bound the scarlet line in the window; immediately, as Abarbinel thinks, and in the sight of the spies, that they might see that she conformed to their direction, and that they might take notice where she fastened it; and that she herself might, at the sight of it, be put in mind of the design of it, and be an encouragement to her faith as to the safety of her and her father's house; and it being a thing so trifling and insignificant in itself, would not be taken notice of by the inhabitants, or be thought to be done with any design; though, according to the instruction of the spies, it seems as if it was to be done when they came into the land, and into the city, and which seems most likely that it was then done.

Gill: Jos 2:22 - -- And they went, and came unto the mountain,.... Rahab had directed them to, the mountain Quarantania; see Gill on Jos 2:16,
and abode there three da...
And they went, and came unto the mountain,.... Rahab had directed them to, the mountain Quarantania; see Gill on Jos 2:16,
and abode there three days; being, no doubt, supplied with food by Rahab; and it might not be three wholly, but one whole day and part of the other two:
until the pursuers were returned; to the city of Jericho, as might reasonably be supposed:
and the pursuers sought them throughout all the way; from Jericho to the fords of Jordan, searching every hedge, field, and village as they went and returned:
but found them not; Rahab having hid them in her house, and then sent them to the mountain, there to remain till the return of the pursuers.

Gill: Jos 2:23 - -- So the two men returned, and descended from the mountain,.... Or came down from it again, by which, it seems, they went to the top of it, and hid them...
So the two men returned, and descended from the mountain,.... Or came down from it again, by which, it seems, they went to the top of it, and hid themselves in some cave there: this descent, Kimchi says, was,"on the third day of their being sent, which was the second day of the three days Joshua made mention of when he said, "within three days";''See Gill on Jos 1:11,
and passed over; that is, the river Jordan, at the fords of it:
and came to Joshua the son of Nun; at Shittim, where he still continued, and from whence he sent them, Jos 2:1,
and told him all things that befell them; what house they went into when come to Jericho, what reception they met with, the report of them to the king of Jericho, how messengers were sent by him to demand them, and by what means they were preserved and made their escape.

Gill: Jos 2:24 - -- And they said unto Joshua,.... Made a report of what they had got knowledge of, which answered the end of their mission:
truly the Lord hath delive...
And they said unto Joshua,.... Made a report of what they had got knowledge of, which answered the end of their mission:
truly the Lord hath delivered into our hands all the land: which they concluded by the terror the inhabitants of it were in, and so in no condition to make resistance and defend themselves; and they not only judged of the whole land by the case of the inhabitants of Jericho, but were assured by Rahab that all the inhabitants of the land were in the same plight and condition, Jos 2:9,
for even the inhabitants of the country do faint because of us; this was the temper and disposition they appeared in, and seems to be what Joshua was chiefly desirous of knowing; since nothing else is told by the spies nor inquired of by him, but immediately upon this report began his march towards Canaan, as in the next chapter is related.

expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes: Jos 2:17 Heb “We are free from this oath of yours which you made us swear.” The words “unless the following conditions are met” are not...

NET Notes: Jos 2:18 Heb “and your father and your mother and your brothers and all the house of your father gather to yourself to the house.”

NET Notes: Jos 2:19 Heb “But anyone who is with you in the house, his blood is on our head if a hand should be on him.”




NET Notes: Jos 2:23 The words “the river,” though not in the Hebrew text, are added for clarification.

Geneva Bible: Jos 2:17 And the men said unto her, ( h ) We [will be] blameless of this thine oath which thou hast made us swear.
( h ) We will be released from our oath if ...

Geneva Bible: Jos 2:19 And it shall be, [that] whosoever shall go out of the doors of thy house into the street, ( i ) his blood [shall be] upon his head, and we [will be] g...

Geneva Bible: Jos 2:20 And if thou utter this our ( k ) business, then we will be quit of thine oath which thou hast made us to swear.
( k ) So that others should think to ...

expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Jos 2:1-24
TSK Synopsis: Jos 2:1-24 - --1 Rahab receives and conceals the two spies sent from Shittim.8 The covenant between her and them.23 Their return and relation.
MHCC -> Jos 2:8-21; Jos 2:22-24
MHCC: Jos 2:8-21 - --Rahab had heard of the miracles the Lord wrought for Israel. She believed that his promises would certainly be fulfilled, and his threatenings take ef...

MHCC: Jos 2:22-24 - --The report the spies brought was encouraging. All the people of the country faint because of Israel; they have neither wisdom to yield, nor courage to...
Matthew Henry -> Jos 2:8-21; Jos 2:22-24
Matthew Henry: Jos 2:8-21 - -- The matter is here settled between Rahab and the spies respecting the service she was now to do for them, and the favour they were afterwards to sho...

Matthew Henry: Jos 2:22-24 - -- We have here the safe return of the spies Joshua had sent, and the great encouragement they brought with them to Israel to proceed in their descent ...
Keil-Delitzsch: Jos 2:17-20 - --
In conclusion, the spies guarded against any arbitrary interpretation and application of their oath, by imposing three conditions, on the non-fulfil...

Keil-Delitzsch: Jos 2:21 - --
When Rahab had accepted all these conditions, she let the men go, and bound the red cord in the window. It is not to be supposed that she did this a...

Keil-Delitzsch: Jos 2:22 - --
The spies remained three days in the mountains, till the officers returned to the town, after searching for them the whole way in vain. The mountain...
