data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/674fe/674fe95c55835d4b12bd7659619a70745375f8e8" alt=""
Text -- Luke 19:40-48 (NET)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/53bcc/53bcc09312609f7dc35434b05e6325fb4f307489" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/af4c0/af4c08bb75e113d55de738af2fccbbe4c5a2ea12" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/af4c0/af4c08bb75e113d55de738af2fccbbe4c5a2ea12" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/af4c0/af4c08bb75e113d55de738af2fccbbe4c5a2ea12" alt=""
Names, People and Places, Dictionary Themes and Topics
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/53bcc/53bcc09312609f7dc35434b05e6325fb4f307489" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/75ece/75ece45dbe9362d6fddeec6b919b612852027d80" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9a206/9a20678833a2d5f914528c6918ee079b308382c5" alt=""
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per phrase)
Robertson: Luk 19:40 - -- If these shall hold their peace ( ean houtoi siōpēsousin ).
A condition of the first class, determined as fulfilled. The use of ean rather than...
If these shall hold their peace (
A condition of the first class, determined as fulfilled. The use of
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Robertson: Luk 19:40 - -- The stones will cry out ( hoi lithoi kraxousin ).
A proverb for the impossible happening.
The stones will cry out (
A proverb for the impossible happening.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Robertson: Luk 19:41 - -- Wept ( eklausen ).
Ingressive aorist active indicative, burst into tears. Probably audible weeping.
Wept (
Ingressive aorist active indicative, burst into tears. Probably audible weeping.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Robertson: Luk 19:42 - -- If thou hadst known ( ei egnōs ).
Second aorist active indicative of ginōskō . Second-class condition, determined as unfulfilled.
If thou hadst known (
Second aorist active indicative of
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Even thou (
Emphatic position of the subject.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Robertson: Luk 19:42 - -- But now ( nun de ).
Aposiopesis. The conclusion is not expressed and the sudden breaking off and change of structure is most impressive.
But now (
Aposiopesis. The conclusion is not expressed and the sudden breaking off and change of structure is most impressive.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Robertson: Luk 19:42 - -- They are hid ( ekrubē ).
Second aorist passive indicative of kruptō , common verb, to hide.
They are hid (
Second aorist passive indicative of
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Robertson: Luk 19:43 - -- Shall cast up a bank ( parembalousin charaka ).
Future active indicative of paremballō , a double compound (para , en , ballō ) of long usage, f...
Shall cast up a bank (
Future active indicative of
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Robertson: Luk 19:43 - -- Compass thee round ( perikuklōsousin se ).
Future active indicative. Another common compound to make a circle (kuklos ) around (peri ), though he...
Compass thee round (
Future active indicative. Another common compound to make a circle (
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Robertson: Luk 19:43 - -- Keep thee in ( sunexousin se ).
Shall hold thee together on every side (pantothen ). See about sunechō on Luk 4:38.
Keep thee in (
Shall hold thee together on every side (
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Robertson: Luk 19:44 - -- Shall dash to the ground ( edaphiousin ).
Attic future of edaphizō , to beat level, to raze to the ground, a rare verb from edaphos , bottom, base,...
Shall dash to the ground (
Attic future of
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Because (
"In return for which things."
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Robertson: Luk 19:44 - -- Thou knewest not ( ouk egnōs ).
Applying the very words of the lament in the condition in Luk 19:42. This vivid prophecy of the destruction of Jeru...
Thou knewest not (
Applying the very words of the lament in the condition in Luk 19:42. This vivid prophecy of the destruction of Jerusalem is used by those who deny predictive prophecy even for Jesus as proof that Luke wrote the Gospel after the destruction of Jerusalem. But it is no proof at all to those who concede to Jesus adequate knowledge of his mission and claims.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Robertson: Luk 19:45 - -- Began to cast out ( ērxato ekballein ).
So Mar 11:15 whereas Mat 21:12 has simply "he cast out."See Mark and Matthew for discussion of this second ...
Began to cast out (
So Mar 11:15 whereas Mat 21:12 has simply "he cast out."See Mark and Matthew for discussion of this second cleansing of the temple at the close of the public ministry in relation to the one at the beginning in Joh 2:14-22. There is nothing gained by accusing John or the Synoptics of a gross chronological blunder. There was abundant time in these three years for all the abuses to be revived.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
He was teaching (
Periphrastic imperfect.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Robertson: Luk 19:47 - -- Daily ( to kath' hēmeran ).
Note the accusative neuter article, "as to the according to the day,"very awkward English surely, but perfectly good Gr...
Daily (
Note the accusative neuter article, "as to the according to the day,"very awkward English surely, but perfectly good Greek. The same idiom occurs in Luk 11:3.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Robertson: Luk 19:47 - -- Sought ( ezētoun ).
Imperfect active, conative imperfect, were seeking, trying to seek.
Sought (
Imperfect active, conative imperfect, were seeking, trying to seek.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Robertson: Luk 19:47 - -- The principal men of the people ( hoi prōtoi tou laou ).
The first men of the people. The position after the verb and apart from the chief priests ...
The principal men of the people (
The first men of the people. The position after the verb and apart from the chief priests and the scribes calls special attention to them. Some of these "first men"were chief priests or scribes, but not all of them. The lights and leaders of Jerusalem were bent on the destruction (
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Robertson: Luk 19:48 - -- They could not find ( ouch hēuriskon ).
Imperfect active. They kept on not finding.
They could not find (
Imperfect active. They kept on not finding.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Robertson: Luk 19:48 - -- What they might do ( to ti poiēsōsin ).
First aorist active deliberative subjunctive in a direct question retained in the indirect. Note the arti...
What they might do (
First aorist active deliberative subjunctive in a direct question retained in the indirect. Note the article
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Robertson: Luk 19:48 - -- Hung upon him ( exekremeto autou ).
Imperfect middle of ekkremamai , an old verb (mi form) to hang from, here only in the N.T. The form is an omega...
Hung upon him (
Imperfect middle of
Vincent: Luk 19:41 - -- He drew nigh
" Again the procession advanced. The road descends a slight declivity, and the glimpse of the city is again withdrawn behind the int...
He drew nigh
" Again the procession advanced. The road descends a slight declivity, and the glimpse of the city is again withdrawn behind the intervening ridge of Olivet. A few moments, and the path mounts again; it climbs a rugged ascent, it reaches a ledge of smooth rock, and in an instant the whole city bursts into view....It is hardly possible to doubt that this rise and turn of the road was the exact point where the multitude paused again, and He, when he beheld the city, wept over it" (Stanley).
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Wept (
With audible weeping.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Vincent: Luk 19:43 - -- A trench ( χάρακα )
Rev., correctly, as Tynd., a bank. Only here in New Testament. The word literally means a pointed stake, used in ...
A trench (
Rev., correctly, as Tynd., a bank. Only here in New Testament. The word literally means a pointed stake, used in fortifying the intrenchments of a camp, and thence the palisade itself. In fortifying a camp or besieging a city, a ditch was dug round the entire circuit, and the earth from it thrown up into a wall, upon which sharp stakes were fixed. Every Roman soldier carried three or four of these stakes on the march. Wyc., with pale.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Vincent: Luk 19:44 - -- Lay thee even with the ground ( ἐδαφιοῦσιν )
Only here in New Testament. Primarily, to beat level, like a threshing-floor or pave...
Lay thee even with the ground (
Only here in New Testament. Primarily, to beat level, like a threshing-floor or pavement. The Septuagint uses it in the sense of dashing down to the ground (Psalms 137:9, and elsewhere). So Rev., from the succeeding reference to the children, and in allusion to the Psalms.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Vincent: Luk 19:48 - -- Were very attentive ( ἐξεκρέματο )
Only here in New Testament. Lit., as Rev., hung upon him. Tynd., stuck by h im.
Were very attentive (
Only here in New Testament. Lit., as Rev., hung upon him. Tynd., stuck by h im.
Wesley: Luk 19:40 - -- That is, God would raise up some still more unlikely instruments to declare his praise. For the power of God will not return empty.
That is, God would raise up some still more unlikely instruments to declare his praise. For the power of God will not return empty.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
The day wherein God still offers thee his blessings.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
All this was exactly performed by Titus, the Roman general.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Wesley: Luk 19:44 - -- All the Jews were at that time gathered together, it being the time of the passover.
All the Jews were at that time gathered together, it being the time of the passover.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Wesley: Luk 19:44 - -- Only three towers were left standing for a time, to show the former strength and magnificence of the place. But these likewise were afterward levelled...
Only three towers were left standing for a time, to show the former strength and magnificence of the place. But these likewise were afterward levelled with the ground.
JFB -> Luk 19:40; Luk 19:41-44; Luk 19:42; Luk 19:42; Luk 19:42; Luk 19:43; Luk 19:45-46; Luk 19:47; Luk 19:48
JFB: Luk 19:40 - -- Hitherto the Lord had discouraged all demonstrations in His favor; latterly He had begun an opposite course; on this one occasion He seems to yield Hi...
Hitherto the Lord had discouraged all demonstrations in His favor; latterly He had begun an opposite course; on this one occasion He seems to yield His whole soul to the wide and deep acclaim with a mysterious satisfaction, regarding it as so necessary a part of the regal dignity in which as Messiah He for this last time entered the city, that if not offered by the vast multitude, it would have been wrung out of the stones rather than be withheld (Hab 2:11).
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
JFB: Luk 19:41-44 - -- Compare Lam 3:51, "Mine eye affecteth mine heart"; the heart again affecting the eye. Under this sympathetic law of the relation of mind and body, Jes...
Compare Lam 3:51, "Mine eye affecteth mine heart"; the heart again affecting the eye. Under this sympathetic law of the relation of mind and body, Jesus, in His beautiful, tender humanity, was constituted even as we. What a contrast to the immediately preceding profound joy! He yielded Himself alike freely to both. (See on Mat 23:37.)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
JFB: Luk 19:42 - -- Thinking perhaps of the name of the city. (Heb 7:2) [WEBSTER and WILKINSON]. How much is included in this word!
Thinking perhaps of the name of the city. (Heb 7:2) [WEBSTER and WILKINSON]. How much is included in this word!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
JFB: Luk 19:42 - -- It was His among His last open efforts to "gather them," but their eyes were judicially closed.
It was His among His last open efforts to "gather them," but their eyes were judicially closed.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
JFB: Luk 19:43 - -- A rampart; first of wood, and when this was burnt, a built wall, four miles in circuit, built in three days--so determined were they. This "cut off al...
A rampart; first of wood, and when this was burnt, a built wall, four miles in circuit, built in three days--so determined were they. This "cut off all hope of escape," and consigned the city to unparalleled horrors. (See JOSEPHUS, Wars of the Jews, 6.2; 12.3,4.) All here predicted was with dreadful literally fulfilled.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
JFB: Luk 19:45-46 - -- Banded together for plunder, reckless of principle. The mild term "house of merchandise," used on the former occasion, was now unsuitable.
Banded together for plunder, reckless of principle. The mild term "house of merchandise," used on the former occasion, was now unsuitable.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Continued seeking, that is, daily, as He taught.
Clarke: Luk 19:40 - -- If these should hold their peace, the stones would - cry out - Of such importance is my present conduct to you and to others, being expressly predic...
If these should hold their peace, the stones would - cry out - Of such importance is my present conduct to you and to others, being expressly predicted by one of your own prophets, Zec 9:9, as pointing out the triumph of humility over pride, and of meekness over rage and malice, as signifying the salvation which I bring to the lost souls of men, that, if this multitude were silent, God would give even to the stones a voice, that the advent of the Messiah might be duly celebrated.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Clarke: Luk 19:42 - -- The things which belong unto thy peace! - It is very likely that our Lord here alludes to the meaning of the word Jerusalem, ירושלים from ...
The things which belong unto thy peace! - It is very likely that our Lord here alludes to the meaning of the word Jerusalem,
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Clarke: Luk 19:43 - -- Cast a trench about thee - This was literally fulfilled when this city was besieged by Titus. Josephus gives a very particular account of the buildi...
Cast a trench about thee - This was literally fulfilled when this city was besieged by Titus. Josephus gives a very particular account of the building of this wall, which he says was effected in three days, though it was not less than thirty-nine furlongs in circumference; and that, when this wall and trench were completed, the Jews were so enclosed on every side that no person could escape out of the city, and no provision could be brought in, so that they were reduced to the most terrible distress by the famine which ensued. The whole account is well worth the reader’ s attention. See Josephus, War, book v. chap. xxii. sec. 1, 2, 3.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Clarke: Luk 19:44 - -- The time of thy visitation - That is, the time of God’ s gracious offers of mercy to thee. This took in all the time which elapsed from the pre...
The time of thy visitation - That is, the time of God’ s gracious offers of mercy to thee. This took in all the time which elapsed from the preaching of John the Baptist to the coming of the Roman armies, which included a period of above forty years.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Clarke: Luk 19:45 - -- Went into the temple - See all this transaction explained, Mat 21:12-16 (note).
Went into the temple - See all this transaction explained, Mat 21:12-16 (note).
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Clarke: Luk 19:47 - -- And he taught daily in the temple - This he did for five or six days before his crucifixion. Some suppose that it was on Monday in the passion week ...
And he taught daily in the temple - This he did for five or six days before his crucifixion. Some suppose that it was on Monday in the passion week that he thus entered into Jerusalem, and purified the temple; and on Thursday he was seized late at night: during these four days he taught in the temple, and lodged each night at Bethany. See the note on Mat 21:17.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Clarke: Luk 19:48 - -- Were very attentive to hear him - Or, They heard him with the utmost attention, εξεκρεματο αυτου ακουων, literally, They hung ...
Were very attentive to hear him - Or, They heard him with the utmost attention,
Ex vultu dicentis, pendet omnium vultus
The face of every man hung on the face of the speaker
- Pendetque iterum narrantis ab ore
Virg. Aen. iv. 7
And she hung again on the lips of the narrator
The words of the evangelist mark, not only the deepest attention because of the importance of the subject, but also the very high gratification which the hearers had from the discourse. Those who read or hear the words of Christ, in this way, must inevitably become wise to salvation
The reader is requested to refer to Matthew 24 (note), and to Mat 25:14 (note), for more extensive information on the different subjects in this chapter, and to the other parallel places. The prophecy relative to the destruction of Jerusalem is one of the most circumstantial, and the most literally fulfilled, of any prediction ever delivered. See this particularly remarked at the conclusion of Matthew 24 (note), where the whole subject is amply reviewed.
Calvin: Luk 19:41 - -- 41.And wept over it As there was nothing which Christ more ardently desired than to execute the office which the Father had committed to him, and as ...
41.And wept over it As there was nothing which Christ more ardently desired than to execute the office which the Father had committed to him, and as he knew that the end of his calling was to gather the lost sheep of the house of Israel, (Mat 15:24,) he wished that his coming might bring salvation to all. This was the reason why he was moved with compassion, and wept over the approaching destruction of the city of Jerusalem. For while he reflected that this was the sacred abode which God had chosen, in which the covenant of eternal salvation should dwell — the sanctuary from which salvation would go forth to the whole world, it was impossible that he should not deeply deplore its ruin. And when he saw the people, who had been adopted to the hope of eternal life, perish miserably through their ingratitude and wickedness, we need not wonder if he could not refrain from tears.
As to those who think it strange that Christ should bewail an evil which he had it in his power to remedy, this difficulty is quickly removed. For as he came down from heaven, that, clothed in human flesh, he might be the witness and minister of the salvation which comes from God, so he actually took upon him human feelings, as far as the office which he had undertaken allowed. And it is necessary that we should always give due consideration to the character which he sustains, when he speaks, or when he is employed in accomplishing the salvation of men; as in this passage, in order that he may execute faithfully his Father’s commission, he must necessarily desire that the fruit of the redemption should come to the whole body of the elect people. Since, therefore, he was given to this people as a minister for salvation, it is in accordance with the nature of his office that he should deplore its destruction. He was God, I acknowledge; but on all occasions when it was necessary that he should perform the office of teacher, his divinity rested, and was in a manner concealed, that it might not hinder what belonged to him as Mediator. By this weeping he proved not only that he loved, like a brother, those for whose sake he became man, but also that God made to flow into human nature the Spirit of fatherly love.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Calvin: Luk 19:42 - -- 42.O if even thou hadst known! The discourse is pathetic, and therefore abrupt; for we know that by those who are under the influence of vehement pas...
42.O if even thou hadst known! The discourse is pathetic, and therefore abrupt; for we know that by those who are under the influence of vehement passion their feelings are not more than half-expressed. Besides, two feelings are here mingled; for not only does Christ bewail the destruction of the city, but he likewise reproaches the ungrateful people with the deepest guilt, in rejecting the salvation which was offered to them, and drawing down on themselves a dreadful judgment of God. The word even, which is interwoven with it, is emphatic; for Christ silently contrasts Jerusalem with the other cities of Judea, or rather, of the whole world, and the meaning is: “If Even thou, who art distinguished by a remarkable privilege above the whole world, — if thou at least, (I say,) who art a heavenly sanctuary in the earth, hadst known ” This is immediately followed by another amplification taken from the time: “Though hitherto thou hast wickedly and outrageously rebelled against God, now at least there is time for repentance.” For he means that the day is now at hand, which had been appointed by the eternal purpose of God for the salvation of Jerusalem, and had been foretold by the prophets. Thus (says Isaiah) is the accepted time, this is the day of salvation, (Isa 49:8; 2Co 6:2.)
Seek the Lord while he may be found; call upon him while he is near,
(Isa 55:6.)
The things which belong to thy peace Under the word peace he includes, according to the meaning of the Hebrew phrase, all that is essential to happiness. Nor does he simply say, that Jerusalem did not know her peace, but the things which belonged to her peace; for it frequently happens that men are far from being unacquainted with their happiness, but they are ignorant of the way and means, (as we say,) because they are blinded by their wickedness. Now since the compassion is mingled with reproach, let us observe, that men deserve the heavier punishment in proportion to the excellence of the gifts which they have received, because to other sins there is added an impious profanation of heavenly grace. Secondly, let us observe, that the nearer God approaches to us, and holds out the light of sound doctrine, the less excusable are we, if we neglect this opportunity. The gate of salvation, indeed, is always open; but as God is sometimes silent, it is no ordinary privilege, when He invites us to himself with a loud voice, and in a familiar manner, and therefore the contempt will be visited by severer punishment.
But now they are hid from thy eyes This is not said for the purpose of extenuating the guilt of Jerusalem; for, on the contrary, it marks with disgrace the monstrous stupidity of that city, that, when God is present, it does not perceive him. I do acknowledge that it belongs to God alone to open the eyes of the blind, and that no man is qualified for understanding the mysteries of the heavenly kingdom, unless God enlighten him inwardly by his Spirit; but it does not follow from this that they who perish through their own brutal blindness are excusable. Christ intended also to remove an offense, which might otherwise have perplexed the ignorant and weak; for when the eyes of all were directed to that city, his example might have very great influence in both respects, either for evil or for good. That no man then may be perplexed by its unbelief and proud contempt of the Gospel, Jerusalem is condemned for disgraceful blindness.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Calvin: Luk 19:43 - -- 43.For the days shall come upon thee He now assumes, as it were, the character of a judge, and addresses Jerusalem with greater severity. In like man...
43.For the days shall come upon thee He now assumes, as it were, the character of a judge, and addresses Jerusalem with greater severity. In like manner the prophets also, though they shed tears over the destruction of those about whom they ought to feel anxiety, yet they summon up courage to pronounce severe threatenings, because they know that not only are they commanded to watch over the salvation of men, but that they have also been appointed to be the heralds of the judgment of God. Under these terms Jesus declares that Jerusalem will suffer dreadful punishment, because she did not know the time of her visitation; that is, because she despised the Redeemer who had been exhibited to her, and did not embrace his grace. Let the fearful nature of the punishments which she endured now alarm us, that we may not, by our carelessness, extinguish the light of salvation, but may be careful to receive the grace of God, and may even run with rigor to meet it.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Calvin: Luk 19:47 - -- Luk 19:47.And he taught daily in the temple Mark and Luke point out, first, what was the class of men of which the Church consisted, namely, of the ...
Luk 19:47.And he taught daily in the temple Mark and Luke point out, first, what was the class of men of which the Church consisted, namely, of the despised multitude; and again, what enemies Christ had, namely, the priests and scribes, and all the rulers. Now this is a part of the folly of the cross, that God, passing by the excellence of the world, chooses what is foolish, weak, and despised. Secondly, they relate that those worthy guardians of the Church of God sought an occasion of putting Christ to death, by which their wicked impiety was discovered; for though there had been good grounds for pursuing Christ, yet they had no right to proceed to murder after the manner of robbers, or secretly to hire assassins. Thirdly, they show that the wicked conspiracy of those men was frustrated, because, by the secret purpose of God, Christ was appointed to the death of the cross.
Defender: Luk 19:40 - -- Even the inanimate creation is under God's control for He made it, and the opposition of mere men to the fulfillment of prophecy is no impediment to t...
Even the inanimate creation is under God's control for He made it, and the opposition of mere men to the fulfillment of prophecy is no impediment to the Creator and Sustainer of all things. When God created Adam, He breathed life into the dust of the ground; He could do the same for stones if need be."
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Defender: Luk 19:42 - -- "This thy day" was the day when the Scriptures had said that Messiah would present Himself to Judah and Jerusalem as their promised King. The time of ...
"This thy day" was the day when the Scriptures had said that Messiah would present Himself to Judah and Jerusalem as their promised King. The time of His coming had been foretold in Dan 9:25, and the manner of His coming in Zec 9:9. A believing remnant had recognized Him, but the leaders and most of the people did not. On the very day when they should have crowned Him King, they set about to destroy Him (Luk 19:47)."
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Defender: Luk 19:44 - -- This terrible prophecy was fulfilled in a.d. 70 when the Roman army under Titus destroyed the temple completely. The destruction of the city and dispe...
This terrible prophecy was fulfilled in a.d. 70 when the Roman army under Titus destroyed the temple completely. The destruction of the city and dispersion of its people was completed in a.d. 135.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Defender: Luk 19:44 - -- If the Jewish scribes had really searched and studied the Scriptures (especially Dan 9:24, Dan 9:25), they could have known "the time of thy visitatio...
TSK: Luk 19:40 - -- Psa 96:11, Psa 98:7-9, Psa 114:1-8; Isa 55:12; Hab 2:11; Mat 3:9, Mat 21:15, Mat 21:16; Mat 27:45, Mat 27:51-54; 2Pe 2:6
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
TSK: Luk 19:41 - -- and wept : Psa 119:53, Psa 119:136, Psa 119:158; Jer 9:1, Jer 13:17, Jer 17:16; Hos 11:8; Joh 11:35; Rom 9:2, Rom 9:3
and wept : Psa 119:53, Psa 119:136, Psa 119:158; Jer 9:1, Jer 13:17, Jer 17:16; Hos 11:8; Joh 11:35; Rom 9:2, Rom 9:3
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
TSK: Luk 19:42 - -- If : Deu 5:29, Deu 32:29; Psa 81:13; Isa 48:18; Eze 18:31, Eze 18:32, Eze 33:11
in this : Luk 19:44; Psa 32:6, Psa 95:7, Psa 95:8; Isa 55:6; Joh 12:35...
If : Deu 5:29, Deu 32:29; Psa 81:13; Isa 48:18; Eze 18:31, Eze 18:32, Eze 33:11
in this : Luk 19:44; Psa 32:6, Psa 95:7, Psa 95:8; Isa 55:6; Joh 12:35, Joh 12:36; 2Co 6:1, 2Co 6:2
the things : Luk 1:77-79, Luk 2:10-14, Luk 10:5, Luk 10:6; Act 10:36, Act 13:46; Heb 3:7, Heb 3:13, Heb 3:15, Heb 10:26-29; Heb 12:24-26
but : Isa 6:9, Isa 6:10, Isa 29:10-14, Isa 44:18; Mat 13:14, Mat 13:15; Joh 12:38-41; Act 28:25-27; Rom 11:7-10; 2Co 3:14-16, 2Co 4:3, 2Co 4:4; 2Th 2:9-12
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
TSK: Luk 19:43 - -- the days : Luk 21:20-24; Deu 28:49-58; Psa 37:12, Psa 37:13; Dan 9:26, Dan 9:27; Mat 22:7, Mat 23:37-39; Mar 13:14-20; 1Th 2:15, 1Th 2:16
cast : Or, "...
the days : Luk 21:20-24; Deu 28:49-58; Psa 37:12, Psa 37:13; Dan 9:26, Dan 9:27; Mat 22:7, Mat 23:37-39; Mar 13:14-20; 1Th 2:15, 1Th 2:16
cast : Or, ""cast a bank""or rampart
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
TSK: Luk 19:44 - -- lay : 1Ki 9:7, 1Ki 9:8; Mic 3:12
thy children : Luk 13:34, Luk 13:35; Mat 23:37, Mat 23:38
leave : Luk 21:6; Mat 24:2; Mar 13:2
because : Luk 19:42, L...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
TSK: Luk 19:45 - -- went : Mat 21:12, Mat 21:13; Mar 11:15-17; Joh 2:13-17
sold : Deu 14:25, Deu 14:26
went : Mat 21:12, Mat 21:13; Mar 11:15-17; Joh 2:13-17
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
TSK: Luk 19:47 - -- taught : Luk 21:37, Luk 21:38; Mat 21:23; Mar 11:27-33; Joh 18:20
the chief priests : Mat 26:3, Mat 26:4; Mar 11:18, Mar 12:12, Mar 14:1; Joh 7:19, Jo...
taught : Luk 21:37, Luk 21:38; Mat 21:23; Mar 11:27-33; Joh 18:20
the chief priests : Mat 26:3, Mat 26:4; Mar 11:18, Mar 12:12, Mar 14:1; Joh 7:19, Joh 7:44, Joh 8:37-40, Joh 10:39; Joh 11:53-57
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
TSK: Luk 19:48 - -- could : Luk 20:19, Luk 20:20, Luk 22:2-4; Mat 22:15, Mat 22:16
were very attentive to hear him : or, hanged on him, Εξεκρεματο [Strong...
could : Luk 20:19, Luk 20:20, Luk 22:2-4; Mat 22:15, Mat 22:16
were very attentive to hear him : or, hanged on him,
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9a206/9a20678833a2d5f914528c6918ee079b308382c5" alt=""
collapse allCommentary -- Word/Phrase Notes (per Verse)
Barnes: Luk 19:40 - -- The stones would ...cry out - It is "proper"that they should celebrate my coming. Their acclamations "ought"not to be suppressed. So joyful is ...
The stones would ...cry out - It is "proper"that they should celebrate my coming. Their acclamations "ought"not to be suppressed. So joyful is the event which they celebrate - the coming of the Messiah - that it is not fit that I should attempt to impose silence on them. The expression here seems to be "proverbial,"and is not to be taken literally. Proverbs are designed to express the truth "strongly,"but are not to be taken to signify as much as if they were to be interpreted literally. The sense is, that his coming was an event of so much importance that it "ought"to be celebrated in some way, and "would"be celebrated. It would be impossible to restrain the people, and improper to attempt it. The language here is strong proverbial language to denote that fact. We are not to suppose, therefore, that our Saviour meant to say that the stones were "conscious"of his coming, or that God would "make"them speak, but only that there was "great joy"among the people; that it was "proper"that they should express it in this manner, and that it was not fit that he should attempt to repress it.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Barnes: Luk 19:41-44 - -- He wept over it - Showing his compassion for the guilty city, and his strong sense of the evils that were about to come upon it. See the notes ...
He wept over it - Showing his compassion for the guilty city, and his strong sense of the evils that were about to come upon it. See the notes at Mat 23:37-39. As he entered the city he passed over the Mount of Olives. From that mountain there was a full and magnificent view of the city. See the notes at Mat 21:1. The view of the splendid capital - the knowledge of its crimes - the remembrance of the mercies of God toward it - the certainty that it might have been spared if it had received the prophets and himself - the knowledge that it was about to put "him,"their long-expected Messiah, to death, and "for"that to be given up to utter desolation - affected his heart, and the triumphant King and Lord of Zion wept! Amid all "his"prosperity, and all the acclamations of the multitude, the heart of the Redeemer of the world was turned from the tokens of rejoicing to the miseries about to come on a guilty people. Yet they "might"have been saved. If thou hadst known, says he, even thou, with all thy guilt, the things that make for thy peace; if thou hadst repented, had been righteous, and had received the Messiah; if thou hadst not stained thy hands with the blood of the prophets, and shouldst not with that of the Son of God, then these terrible calamities would not come upon thee. But it is too late. The national wickedness is too great; the cup is full: mercy is exhausted; and Jerusalem, with all her pride and splendor, the glory of her temple, and the pomp of her service, "must perish!"
For the days shall come ... - This took place under Titus, the Roman general, 70 a.d., about thirty years after this was spoken.
Cast a trench about thee - The word "trench"now means commonly a "pit or ditch."When the Bible was translated, it meant also "earth thrown up to defend a camp"(Johnson’ s "Dictionary"). This is the meaning of the original here. It is not a pit or large "ditch,"but a pile of earth, stones, or wood thrown up to guard a camp, and to defend it from the approach of an enemy. This was done at the siege of Jerusalem. Josephus informs us that Titus, in order that he might compel the city to surrender by "famine,"built a wall around the whole circumference of the city. This wall was nearly 5 miles in length, and was furnished with thirteen castles or towers. This work was completed with incredible labor in ten days. The professed design of this wall was "to keep"the city "in on every side."Never was a prophecy more strikingly accomplished.
Shall lay thee even with the ground ... - This was literally done. Titus caused a plow to pass over the place where the temple stood. See the notes at Matt. 24. All this was done, says Christ, because Jerusalem knew not the time of its visitation - that is, did not know, and "would not"know, that the Messiah had come. "His coming"was the time of their merciful visitation. That time had been predicted, and invaluable blessings promised as the result of his advent; but they would not know it. They rejected him, they put him to death, and it was just that they should be destroyed.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Daily in the temple - That is, for five or six days before his crucifixion.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Barnes: Luk 19:48 - -- Could not find ... - Were not able to accomplish their purpose; they did not know "how"to bring it about. Very attentive - literally, "hu...
Could not find ... - Were not able to accomplish their purpose; they did not know "how"to bring it about.
Very attentive - literally, "hung upon him"to hear him. The word denotes an anxious desire, a fixed attention, a cleaving to him, and an unwillingness to "leave"him, so that they might hear his words. This is always the case when people become anxious about their salvation. They manifest it by hanging on the preaching of the gospel; by fixed attention; and by an unwillingness to leave the place where the word of God is preached. In view of the fact that the Lord Jesus wept over Jerusalem, we may remark:
(1) It was on account of the sins and danger of the inhabitants, and of the fact that they had rejected offered mercy.
(2)\caps1 t\caps0 here was "occasion"for weeping. Jesus would not have wept had there been no cause for it. If they were in no danger, if there was no punishment in the future world, why should he have wept? When the Lord Jesus weeps over sinners, it is the fullest proof that they are in danger.
(3)\caps1 s\caps0 inners are in the same danger now. They reject Christ as sinners did then. They despise the gospel as they did then. They refuse now to come to him as the inhabitants of Jerusalem did. Why are they not then in the same danger?
(4)\caps1 d\caps0 eep feeling, gushing emotions, lively affections, are proper in religion. If the Saviour wept, it is not improper for us to weep - it is right. Nay, can it be right "not"to weep over the condition of lost man.
(5) Religion is tenderness and love. It led the Saviour to weep, and it teaches us to sympathize and to feel deeply. Sin hardens the heart, and makes it insensible to every pure and noble emotion; but religion teaches us to feel "for others’ woes,"and to sympathize in the danger of others.
(6) Christians and Christian ministers should weep over lost sinners. They have souls just as precious as they had then; they are in the same danger; they are going to the judgment-bar; they are wholly insensible to their danger and their duty.
"Did Christ o’ er sinners weep?
And shall our cheeks be dry?
Let floods of penitential grief.
Burst forth from every eye.
"The Son of God in tears.
Angels with wonder see!
Be thou astonished, O my soul;
He shed those tears for thee.
"He wept that we might weep;
Each sin demands a tear:
In heaven alone no sin is found.
And there’ s no weeping there."
Poole: Luk 19:39-40 - -- Ver. 39,40. How peevish were these wretched Pharisees, to envy our Saviour this little triumph, of coming into the city upon an ass’ s colt, wit...
Ver. 39,40. How peevish were these wretched Pharisees, to envy our Saviour this little triumph, of coming into the city upon an ass’ s colt, with garments under him instead of a saddle, or any stately furniture and trappings, and attended by a company of poor people throwing their garments and boughs of trees in the way! Yet these they would have silenced. Our Saviour’ s reply,
If these should hold their peace, the stones would immediately cry out seemeth to have been a proverbial speech used amongst them, to signify a thing which could not be. This day was accomplished God’ s decree in that particular passage of providence, concerning our Saviour, which could not be defeated.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Poole: Luk 19:41 - -- Those who of old blotted out this sentence, as thinking that weeping was not becoming Christ’ s perfection, seem to have forgotten that he was ...
Those who of old blotted out this sentence, as thinking that weeping was not becoming Christ’ s perfection, seem to have forgotten that he was perfect man, and a sharer in all the natural infirmities of human nature (if weeping upon the prospect of human miseries deserveth no better name than an infirmity, being an indication of love and compassion). Those who think that it was idle for him to weep for that which he might easily have helped, seem to oblige God to give out of his grace, whether men do what he hath commanded them, and is in their power to do, yea or no. Christ wept over Jerusalem as a man, having compassion for these poor Jews, with respect to the miseries he saw coming upon them; as a minister of the gospel, pitying the people to whom he was primarily sent.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Poole: Luk 19:42 - -- Speeches which are the products of great passion, are usually abrupt and imperfect:
If thou hadst known that is, Oh that thou hadst known, or, I w...
Speeches which are the products of great passion, are usually abrupt and imperfect:
If thou hadst known that is, Oh that thou hadst known, or, I wish that thou hadst known. We are said in Scripture not to know more than we believe, are affected with, and live up to the knowledge of. They had heard enough of the things which concerned their peace, Christ had told them to them, but they attended not to them, they believed them not, and so cared not to direct their lives according to any such notions.
At least in this thy day the time in which I have been preaching the gospel to thee (for so I had rather interpret it, than of this last journey of our Saviour’ s to Jerusalem). This was properly the Jews day, for the first preachers of the gospel spent all their time and pains amongst them.
The things which belong unto thy peace that is, to thy happiness, for so the term often signifies, and it refers as well to the happiness of the outward as of their inward man.
But now they are hid from thine eyes: God will not suffer his Spirit always to strive with man, because he is but flesh, not fit to be always waited on by the great Majesty of heaven. First men shut their eyes against the things that do concern their peace, then God hideth them from them. No man hath more than his day, his time of grace: how long that is none can tell: if he sleepeth out that, his case is desperate, past remedy.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Poole: Luk 19:43-44 - -- Ver. 43,44. It is a plain prophecy of the final destruction of Jerusalem by the Roman armies, which came to pass within less than forty years after. ...
Ver. 43,44. It is a plain prophecy of the final destruction of Jerusalem by the Roman armies, which came to pass within less than forty years after. The cause of that dreadful judgment is assigned,
because thou knewest not the time of thy visitation God’ s visitations are either of wrath or mercy; of wrath, Exo 32:34 Lev 26:16 Jer 15:3 ; of mercy, Jer 29:10 . It is plain that our Saviour useth the term here in the latter, not the former sense; and that by God’ s visitation of this people here, is meant his visiting them with his prophets, by John the Baptist, and by himself. Their not knowing of it (here intended) was their not making use of it, not receiving and embracing the gospel. The contempt of the gospel is the great, cause of all those miseries which come upon people in this life, or shall come upon them in that life which is to come.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Poole: Luk 19:45-46 - -- Ver. 45,46. We have met with this before more fully: See Poole on "Mat 21:12" . See Poole on "Mat 21:13" . See Poole on "Mar 11:15" , and followin...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Poole: Luk 19:47-48 - -- Ver. 47,48. This our Saviour’ s preaching daily must be understood of a very few days, for it appeareth from Joh 12:1 , that he came to Bethan...
Ver. 47,48. This our Saviour’ s preaching daily must be understood of a very few days, for it appeareth from Joh 12:1 , that he came to Bethany but six days before the passover; now upon the passover day he died; but for the intermediate time, it is plain from the other evangelists that he was wont to spend the day time at Jerusalem in the temple, and at night to return to Bethany.
The chief priests and the scribes and the chief of the people sought to destroy him only they stood in a little awe of the people, who were
very attentive to hear him
Lightfoot -> Luk 19:44
Lightfoot: Luk 19:44 - -- And shall lay thee even with the ground, and thy children within thee; and they shall not leave in thee one stone upon another; because thou knewe...
And shall lay thee even with the ground, and thy children within thee; and they shall not leave in thee one stone upon another; because thou knewest not the time of thy visitation.  
[Because thou knewest not the time of thy visitation.] The Masters dispute the reason of the laying-waste of Jerusalem.  
"Abai saith, Jerusalem was not destroyed for any thing but the profanation of the sabbath. R. Abba saith, It was not destroyed for any thing but their neglect in reciting their phylacteries morning and evening. Rabh Menona saith, It was not destroyed for any thing but their not minding the bringing up of their children in the school. Ulla saith, Jerusalem had not been destroyed but for their immodesty one towards another. R. Isaac saith, It had not been destroyed, but that they equalled the inferior with the superior. R. Chainah saith, It had not been destroyed, but that they did not rebuke one another. R. Judah saith, It had not been destroyed, but that they condemned the disciples of the wise men," etc. But Wisdom saith, Jerusalem was destroyed, because she knew not the time of her visitation.  
All those great good things that were promised to mankind were promised as what should happen in the last days; i.e. in the last days of Jerusalem. Then was the Messiah to be revealed: then was the Holy Ghost to be poured out: then was the mountain of the Lord to be exalted, and the nations should flow in to it: in a word, then were to be fulfilled all those great things which the prophets had foretold about the coming of the Messiah and the bringing in of the gospel. These were the times of Jerusalem's visitation; if she could have known it. But so far was she from that knowledge, that nothing was more odious, nothing more contemptible, than when indeed all these ineffable benefits were dispensed in the midst of her. Nor indeed were those times described beforehand with more remarkable characters as to what God would do, than they were with black and dreadful indications as to the perverseness and obstinacy of that people. They were the best of times, and the worst generation lived in them. In those last days of that city were 'perilous times,' 2Ti 3:1; 'departing from the faith,' 1Ti 4:1; 'Scoffers' of religion, 2Pe 3:3; in a word, 'many antichrists,' 1Jo 2:18. So far was Jerusalem and the nation of the Jews from knowing and acknowledging the things that belonged unto their peace.
Haydock: Luk 19:40 - -- The stones. This is a proverb, as if he had said: God has resolved to glorify me this day, in order to fulfil the prophecies. Nothing can hinder th...
The stones. This is a proverb, as if he had said: God has resolved to glorify me this day, in order to fulfil the prophecies. Nothing can hinder the execution of his decrees; if men were silent, he would make even the stones to speak. (Calmet) ---
At the crucifixion of our Redeemer, when his friends were silent through fear, the very stones and rocks spoke in his defence. Immediately after he expired, the earth was moved, the rocks split, and the monuments of the dead opened. (Ven. Bede) ---
Nor is it any wonder if, contrary to nature, the rocks bespeak the praises of the Lord, since he was even praised by a multitude, much more insensible than the rocks themselves, in crucifying him only a few days after, whom they now salute with Hosannahs of joy. (St. Ambrose)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Haydock: Luk 19:41 - -- He wept. St. Epiphanius tells us, that some of the orthodox of his time, offended at these words, omitted them in their copies, as if to shed tears,...
He wept. St. Epiphanius tells us, that some of the orthodox of his time, offended at these words, omitted them in their copies, as if to shed tears, were a weakness unworthy of Christ: but this true reading of the evangelist is found in all copies, and received by all the faithful; and the liberty which those who changed them took, was too dangerous ever to be approved of by the Church. Neither do these tears argue in Jesus Christ any thing unworthy of his supreme majesty or wisdom. Our Saviour possessed all the human passions, but not the defects of them. The Stoics, who condemned the passions in their sages, laboured to make statues or automata of man, not philosophers. The true philosopher moderates and governs his passions; the Stoic labours to destroy them, but cannot effect his purpose. And when he labours to overcome one passion, he is forced to have recourse to another for help. (Calmet) ---
Our Saviour is said to have wept six times, during his life on earth: 1st, At his birth, according to may holy doctors; 2ndly, at his circumcision, according to St. Bernard and others; 3rdly, when he raised Lazarus to life, as is related in St. John, chap. xi.; 4thly, in his entry into Jerusalem, described in this place; 5thly, during his agony in the garden, just before his apprehension, when, as St. Luke remarks, (Chap. xxii.) his sweat was as drops of blood trickling down upon the ground; and 6thly, during his passion, when he often wept, on account of his great distress of mind, occasioned principally by the knowledge he had of the grievousness of men's sins, and the bad use they would make of the redemption he was, through so many sufferings, procuring for them. (Dionysius)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Haydock: Luk 19:42 - -- If thou also hadst known. It is a broken sentence, as it were in a transport of grief; and we many understand, thou wouldst also weep. Didst thou...
If thou also hadst known. It is a broken sentence, as it were in a transport of grief; and we many understand, thou wouldst also weep. Didst thou know, even at this day, that peace and reconciliation which God still offers to thee. (Witham) ---
What can be more tender than the apostrophe here made use of by our Saviour! Hadst thou but known, &c. that is, didst thou but know how severe a punishment is about to be inflicted upon thee, for the numberless transgressions of thy people, thou likewise wouldst weep; but, alas! hardness in iniquity, thou still rejoicest, ignorant of the punishment hanging over thy head. Just men have daily occasion to bewail, like our blessed Redeemer, the blindness of the wicked, unable to see, through their own perversity, the miserable state of their souls, and the imminent danger they are every moment exposed to, of losing themselves for ever. Of these, Solomon cries out; (Proverbs ii. 13.) They leave the right way, and walk through dark ways. We ought to imitate this compassion of our blessed Redeemer; and, as he wept over the calamities of the unfortunate Jerusalem, though determined on his destruction; so we ought to bewail the sins not only of our friends, but likewise of our enemies, and daily offer up our prayers for their conversion. (Dionysius)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Haydock: Luk 19:43 - -- And compass thee, &c. Christ's prophecy is a literal description of what happened to Jerusalem, under Titus. (Witham)
And compass thee, &c. Christ's prophecy is a literal description of what happened to Jerusalem, under Titus. (Witham)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Haydock: Luk 19:48 - -- All the people, as they heard him with so great attention. So Virgil said: -----pendetque iterum narrantis ab ore. (Witham)
--- The original Gre...
All the people, as they heard him with so great attention. So Virgil said: -----pendetque iterum narrantis ab ore. (Witham)
--- The original Greek, exekremato autou akouon, shews how eagerly they catched the words that dropped from his sacred lips, all enraptured with the wisdom of his answers, and the commanding superiority of his doctrines. Seneca (Controv ix. 1.) uses a similar turn of expression: Ex vultu discentis pendent omnium vultus. The chief priests and rulers were all apprehension lest the people, who followed Jesus with such avidity, and who had conceived such high sentiments of his character, might prevent the execution of their murderous designs.
====================
Gill: Luk 19:40 - -- And he answered and said unto them, I tell you,.... As a truth, which may be depended on, and you may be assured of; this he spake with great earnestn...
And he answered and said unto them, I tell you,.... As a truth, which may be depended on, and you may be assured of; this he spake with great earnestness, fervour, and courage:
that if these should hold their peace; be silent, and not sing the praises of God, and ascribe glory to him, and profess the Messiah, and make this public acknowledgment of him:
the stones would immediately cry out; either against them, or in a declaration of the Messiah: by which expression our Lord means, that it was impossible it should be otherwise; it would be intolerable if it was not; and rather than it should not be, God, who is able out of stones to raise up children to Abraham, would make the stones speak, or turn stones into men, who should rise up and praise the Lord, and confess the Messiah; hereby commending his disciples, and tacitly reflecting upon the Pharisees, for their stupidity; and also giving a hint of the conversion of the Gentiles, who might be compared to stones, especially in the opinion of the Jews.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Gill: Luk 19:41 - -- And when he was come near, he beheld city,.... Of Jerusalem; being now nearer, and in a situation to take a full view of it, he lift up his eyes, and ...
And when he was come near, he beheld city,.... Of Jerusalem; being now nearer, and in a situation to take a full view of it, he lift up his eyes, and looking wistfully on it, and beholding the grandeur and magnificence of it, the number of the houses, and the stately structures in it, and knowing what calamities, in a few years, would come upon it; with which being affected, as man, he looked upon it,
and wept over it; touched with a tender concern for it, his natural passions moved, and tears fell plentifully from his eyes. This must be understood of Christ merely as man, and is a proof of the truth of his human nature, which had all the natural properties, and even the infirmities of it; and as affected with the temporal ruin of Jerusalem, and as concerned for its temporal welfare; and is not to be improved either against his proper deity, or the doctrines of distinguishing grace, relating to the spiritual and eternal salvation of God's elect; things that are foreign from the sense of this passage: some ancient Christians, and orthodox too, thinking that this was not so agreeable to Christ, but reflected some weakness and dishonour upon him, expunged this clause concerning his weeping; but we have another instance besides this; see Joh 11:35 and even the Jews themselves cannot think this to be unsuitable to the Messiah, when they represent the Shekinah, and God himself weeping over the destruction of the temple p; and it is particularly q said by them of the Messiah, that he shall weep over the wicked among the Jews, according to Isa 53:5 and they encourage persons to mourn over Jerusalem: they say r whoever does any business on the ninth of Ab, (the day that city was destroyed,) and does not mourn over Jerusalem, shall not see its joy; but whoever does mourn over it, shall see its joy, according to Isa 66:10 s.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Gill: Luk 19:42 - -- Saying, if thou hadst, known, even thou,.... As well as other cities; or who hast been so long a flourishing city, the metropolis of the nation, the s...
Saying, if thou hadst, known, even thou,.... As well as other cities; or who hast been so long a flourishing city, the metropolis of the nation, the seat of the ancient kings of Judah; yea, the city of the great God, the place of divine worship, whither the tribes came up, time after time, to serve the Lord; a city so highly honoured of God and man: or, who hast despised the messages of the servants of God, mocked and misused the prophets in time past, beat one, killed another, and stoned another: if such a city, after all this, had but known its true interest,
at least in this thy day; the day of thy visitation, the last day thou art to have, though it is so late:
the things which belong unto thy peace; meaning, not peace with God, and the things belonging, or conducing to that, which are not men's works of righteousness, nor tears of repentance, nor even faith itself, but the obedience and righteousness, the blood, sacrifice and death of Christ; nor spiritual peace, or internal peace of conscience, which comes in a Gospel way, through believing, in a course of obedience, and all from Christ, the peacemaker, and peace giver; nor eternal peace hereafter, which the grace of God gives a meetness for, and the righteousness of Christ a right unto; the knowledge of all which is not natural to men, or to be obtained of themselves, but is the gift of God's grace, and the operation of his Spirit: but supposing such a peace, and such things relating to it, were intended, nothing more can be inferred from hence, than that if the Jews had known these things, they had been happy; and since they had the means of knowing them, they were, of all men, inexcusable; and that Christ, as man, and one of their nation, and as a minister of the circumcision, had a passionate concern for their welfare: but not that these Jews, or any men, can of themselves, and without the unfrustrable grace of God working upon their hearts, and enlightening their understanding, know these things; or that Christ acted any insincere part in wishing for these things for them, as man, and a minister of the word, when he knew, as God, it was not consistent with the will of God that they should have them; since Christ, as man, sometimes earnestly prayed for that, which he, as God, knew could not be, as in the case of his own sufferings and death; nor is this irreconcilable to his dying intentionally only for those who are actually saved: but after all, these words are, only spoken of Jerusalem, and the inhabitants of that city, and not of all mankind, and regard only their temporal peace and welfare, whose destruction Christ knew was near at hand; and of which he afterwards speaks in the following verses:
but now they are hid from thine eyes; their eyes were blinded; they were given up to a judicial blindness, and hardness of heart; a spirit of slumber and stupidity had seized them; they could not discern the signs of the times and so disbelieved Jesus as the Messiah, and rejected him as such; whom, had they received only in a notional way, though they had not believed in him spiritually, to the saving of their souls, they would have been secured from outward calamities, and would have enjoyed peace and prosperity, and the things belonging to it our Lord speaks of. Christ alludes to the name of Jerusalem, which signifies the vision of peace; or they shall see peace; but her name and case now did not agree. His wish is the same the Psalmist encourages in Psa 122:6 which, in the Septuagint version, is rendered, "pray for the things" that belong "to the peace Jerusalem".
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Gill: Luk 19:43 - -- For the days shall come upon thee,.... Suddenly, and very quickly, as they did within forty years after this:
that thine enemies; the Romans, and s...
For the days shall come upon thee,.... Suddenly, and very quickly, as they did within forty years after this:
that thine enemies; the Romans, and such the Jews took them to be, and might easily understand who our Lord meant:
shall cast a trench about thee, and compass thee round, and keep thee in on every side: which was not only verified in the Roman armies closely besieging them; but particularly in this, as Josephus relates t that Titus built a wall about the city, of thirty nine furlongs long, and thirteen forts in it which reached ten furlongs, and all done in three days time; by which means they were pent up, starved, and famished, and reduced to inexpressible distress.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Gill: Luk 19:44 - -- And shall lay thee even with the ground,.... Beat down all the houses in it, the stately edifices, and even the temple itself; See Gill on Mat 24:2.
...
And shall lay thee even with the ground,.... Beat down all the houses in it, the stately edifices, and even the temple itself; See Gill on Mat 24:2.
and thy children within thee; that is, the inhabitants of the place should be slain with the sword of the enemy, and so fall to the ground, and lie upon it;
and they shall not leave in thee one stone upon anther; such a consummate, and entire desolation shall be made, as was foretold by Daniel, Dan 9:27
because thou knowest not the time of thy visitation; in which the dayspring from on high had visited them with his personal presence, preaching among them, and working miracles; and yet they knew him not, but despised and rejected him; yea, after that they had put him to death, and he was risen again, he ordered his disciples to begin their ministry, and preach the Gospel, at Jerusalem; and they continued for some time only preaching to them, or at least rarely elsewhere, till they put away the Gospel from them. The time of the ministry of John the Baptist, of Christ, and his apostles in Judea, was the time of Jerusalem's visitation in a way of mercy; which not being taken notice of, and observed, brought another kind of visitation upon them, even in a way of wrath and vengeance. The Jews pretend to assign other causes of Jerusalem's destruction; but the true cause was their rejection of Jesus, as the Messiah.
"Says Abai, Jerusalem was not destroyed, but because they profaned the sabbath, as it is said, Eze 22:26 "and have hid their eyes from my sabbaths", &c. Says R. Abhu, Jerusalem was not destroyed, but because they ceased reading the "Shema (hear, O Israel", &c.) morning and evening, as it is said, Isa 5:11 woe to them that rise up early", &c. Says Rab. Hamenuna, Jerusalem was not destroyed, but because there ceased in it the children of the school of Rabban, (children were not put to school,) as it is said Jer 6:11 "I will pour it out upon the children", &c. Says Ula, Jerusalem was not destroyed, but because there was no shame among them, as it is said, Jer 6:15 "were they ashamed", &c. Says R. Isaac, Jerusalem was not destroyed, but because small and great were put upon a level, as it is said, Isa 24:2 "as with the people, so with the priest", &c. Says R. Amram, the son of R. Simeon bar Aba, R. Chanina said, Jerusalem was not destroyed, but because they did not reprove one another, as it is said, Lam 1:6 "her princes are become like harts", &c. Says R. Judah, Jerusalem was not destroyed, but because they despised the disciples of the wise men, as it is said; 2Ch 36:16 but they mocked the messengers of God", &c. u.''
Thus they shifted off the true cause of their ruin, and ascribed it to other things.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Gill: Luk 19:45 - -- And he went into the temple,.... Being come into the city, he alighted from the colt he rode on, and having committed it to the care of a proper perso...
And he went into the temple,.... Being come into the city, he alighted from the colt he rode on, and having committed it to the care of a proper person to return it to the owner, he went up directly to the temple, of which he was the Lord and proprietor, and where he had some work to do the few days he had to live.
And began to cast out them that sold therein, and them that bought; that traded in sheep, and oxen, and doves; see Joh 2:15. The Ethiopic version adds here, as there, "and overthrew, the tables of the money changers, and the seats of them that sold doves".
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Gill: Luk 19:46 - -- Saying unto them, it is written,.... In Isa 56:7
my house is the house of prayer; built and devoted for that service:
but ye have made it a den ...
Saying unto them, it is written,.... In Isa 56:7
my house is the house of prayer; built and devoted for that service:
but ye have made it a den of thieves; which clause is not written in the above prophecy, but are the words of Christ referring to Jer 7:11. The Ethiopic version adds, "and robbers"; and the Persic version adds, "and a place of cut-purses"; See Gill on Mat 21:13.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Gill: Luk 19:47 - -- And he taught daily in the temple,.... Every day till the passover came, and only in the day; for at night he went out of the city to Bethany, or to t...
And he taught daily in the temple,.... Every day till the passover came, and only in the day; for at night he went out of the city to Bethany, or to the Mount of Olives: some of his discourses in the temple, the parables he delivered, and his disputations with the doctors, are recorded in Mat 21:27,
but the chief priests, and the Scribes, and the chief of the people; or "the elders of the people", as the Syriac version renders it; that is, the whole sanhedrim:
sought to destroy him; met and consulted together how to get him into their hands, and what charges to bring against him, in order to put him to death.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Gill: Luk 19:48 - -- And could not find what they might do,.... The Vulgate Latin, Syriac, and Ethiopic versions, and so Beza's most ancient copy, add, "to him"; they coul...
And could not find what they might do,.... The Vulgate Latin, Syriac, and Ethiopic versions, and so Beza's most ancient copy, add, "to him"; they could not find an opportunity of seizing him, nor any advantage against him; they knew not what steps to take, nor how to bring about their wicked design of destroying him.
For all the people were very attentive to hear him; there were great crowds always about him, that hung upon him, as the word rendered "attentive" signifies; they heard him with great eagerness and diligence, and were ready to catch every word that dropped from his lips; and were exceedingly taken with him, having never heard any man speak like him: wherefore having so many followers, and being so high in the opinion and affection of the people, the sanhedrim were at a loss what method to make use of to gain their point; and they feared the people, should they seize him publicly, lest they should rise and rescue him, and cause a tumult and disturbance.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9a206/9a20678833a2d5f914528c6918ee079b308382c5" alt=""
expand allCommentary -- Verse Notes / Footnotes
NET Notes -> Luk 19:40; Luk 19:40; Luk 19:40; Luk 19:41; Luk 19:41; Luk 19:41; Luk 19:42; Luk 19:42; Luk 19:42; Luk 19:43; Luk 19:43; Luk 19:44; Luk 19:44; Luk 19:44; Luk 19:44; Luk 19:44; Luk 19:44; Luk 19:44; Luk 19:45; Luk 19:45; Luk 19:45; Luk 19:45; Luk 19:45; Luk 19:46; Luk 19:46; Luk 19:46; Luk 19:47; Luk 19:47; Luk 19:47; Luk 19:47; Luk 19:48; Luk 19:48; Luk 19:48
NET Notes: Luk 19:40 This statement amounts to a rebuke. The idiom of creation speaking means that even creation knows what is taking place, yet the Pharisees miss it. On ...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
NET Notes: Luk 19:41 When Jesus approached and saw the city. This is the last travel note in Luke’s account (the so-called Jerusalem journey), as Jesus approached an...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
NET Notes: Luk 19:42 But now they are hidden from your eyes. This becomes an oracle of doom in the classic OT sense; see Luke 13:31-35; 11:49-51; Jer 9:2; 13:7; 14:7. They...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
NET Notes: Luk 19:43 An embankment refers to either wooden barricades or earthworks, or a combination of the two.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
NET Notes: Luk 19:44 You did not recognize the time of your visitation refers to the time God came to visit them. They had missed the Messiah; see Luke 1:68-79.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
NET Notes: Luk 19:45 Matthew (21:12-27), Mark (11:15-19) and Luke (here, 19:45-46) record this incident of the temple cleansing at the end of Jesus’ ministry. John (...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
NET Notes: Luk 19:46 A quotation from Jer 7:11. The meaning of Jesus’ statement about making the temple courts a den of robbers probably operates here at two levels....
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
NET Notes: Luk 19:47 The action at the temple was the last straw. In their view, if Jesus could cause trouble in the holy place, then he must be stopped, so the leaders we...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
NET Notes: Luk 19:48 All the people hung on his words is an idiom for intent, eager listening. Jesus’ popularity and support made it unwise for the leadership to sei...
Geneva Bible: Luk 19:41 ( 9 ) And when he was come near, he beheld the city, and wept over it,
( 9 ) Christ is not delighted with destruction, no not even of the wicked.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Geneva Bible: Luk 19:42 ( g ) Saying, ( h ) If thou hadst known, even thou, ( i ) at least in this ( k ) thy day, the things [which belong] unto thy ( l ) peace! but now they...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Geneva Bible: Luk 19:44 And shall lay thee even with the ground, and thy children within thee; and they shall not leave in thee one stone upon another; because thou knewest n...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Geneva Bible: Luk 19:45 ( 10 ) And he went into the temple, and began to cast out them that sold therein, and them that bought;
( 10 ) Christ shows after his entry into Jeru...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/9a206/9a20678833a2d5f914528c6918ee079b308382c5" alt=""
expand allCommentary -- Verse Range Notes
TSK Synopsis -> Luk 19:1-48
TSK Synopsis: Luk 19:1-48 - --1 Of Zacchaeus a publican.11 The ten pieces of money.28 Christ rides into Jerusalem with triumph;41 weeps over it;45 drives the buyers and sellers out...
Maclaren -> Luk 19:37-48
Maclaren: Luk 19:37-48 - --A New Kind Of King
And when He was come nigh, even now at the descent of the mount of Olives, the whole multitude of the disciples began to rejoice a...
MHCC -> Luk 19:28-40; Luk 19:41-48
MHCC: Luk 19:28-40 - --Christ has dominion over all creatures, and may use them as he pleases. He has all men's hearts both under his eye and in his hand. Christ's triumphs,...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
MHCC: Luk 19:41-48 - --Who can behold the holy Jesus, looking forward to the miseries that awaited his murderers, weeping over the city where his precious blood was about to...
Matthew Henry -> Luk 19:28-40; Luk 19:41-48
Matthew Henry: Luk 19:28-40 - -- We have here the same account of Christ's riding in some sort of triumph (such as it was) into Jerusalem which we had before in Matthew and Mark; le...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Matthew Henry: Luk 19:41-48 - -- The great Ambassador from heaven is here making his public entry into Jerusalem, not to be respected there, but to be rejected; he knew what a n...
Barclay -> Luk 19:28-40; Luk 19:41-48
Barclay: Luk 19:28-40 - --From Jerusalem to Jericho was only seventeen miles, and now Jesus had almost reached his goal. Jerusalem, journey's end, lay just ahead. The prop...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Barclay: Luk 19:41-48 - --In this passage there are three separate incidents.
(i) There is Jesus' lament over Jerusalem. From the descent of the Mount of Olives there is a ma...
Constable: Luk 19:28--22:1 - --VI. Jesus' ministry in Jerusalem 19:28--21:38
Luke's account of Jesus' passion highlights Jesus' entry into Jeru...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Constable: Luk 19:28-40 - --A. The Triumphal Entry 19:28-40 (cf. Matt. 21:1-9; Mark 11:1-10; John 12:12-19)
Luke did not record Jesus' actual entrance into the city of Jerusalem....
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Constable: Luk 19:41-48 - --B. The beginning of Jesus' ministry in Jerusalem 19:41-48
This is a transitional section that bridges Je...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Constable: Luk 19:41-44 - --1. Jesus' sorrow over Jerusalem 19:41-44
This material occurs in no other Gospel. The destruction of Jerusalem that Jesus predicted here was an import...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Constable: Luk 19:45-46 - --2. Jesus' cleansing of the temple 19:45-46 (cf. Matt. 21:12-13; Mark 11:15-17)
Judgment began wh...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""
Constable: Luk 19:47-48 - --3. A synopsis of Jesus' teaching in the temple 19:47-48 (cf. Mark 11:18)
Luke stressed the rejec...
College -> Luk 19:1-48
College: Luk 19:1-48 - --LUKE 19
9. Zacchaeus the Tax Collector (19:1-10)
1 Jesus entered Jericho and was passing through. 2 A man was there by the name of Zacchaeus; he was...
McGarvey -> Luk 19:29-44; Luk 19:45-48
McGarvey: Luk 19:29-44 - --
CV.
JESUS' TRIUMPHAL ENTRY INTO JERUSALEM.
(From Bethany to Jerusalem and back, Sunday, April 2, A. D. 30.)
aMATT. XXI. 1-12, 14-17; bMARK XI. 1-11; ...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/387e7/387e7193a893fc1cc00ed34c01c74f8d36840b0a" alt=""